WO2001031136A2 - Reinforced concrete systems - Google Patents

Reinforced concrete systems Download PDF

Info

Publication number
WO2001031136A2
WO2001031136A2 PCT/US2000/041485 US0041485W WO0131136A2 WO 2001031136 A2 WO2001031136 A2 WO 2001031136A2 US 0041485 W US0041485 W US 0041485W WO 0131136 A2 WO0131136 A2 WO 0131136A2
Authority
WO
WIPO (PCT)
Prior art keywords
layer
steel reinforcement
steel
cement
concrete
Prior art date
Application number
PCT/US2000/041485
Other languages
French (fr)
Other versions
WO2001031136A3 (en
Inventor
James J. Myrick
Original Assignee
Concrete Sciences Corporation
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by Concrete Sciences Corporation filed Critical Concrete Sciences Corporation
Priority to AU29174/01A priority Critical patent/AU2917401A/en
Publication of WO2001031136A2 publication Critical patent/WO2001031136A2/en
Publication of WO2001031136A3 publication Critical patent/WO2001031136A3/en
Priority to US10/125,969 priority patent/US6929865B2/en

Links

Classifications

    • CCHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
    • C23COATING METALLIC MATERIAL; COATING MATERIAL WITH METALLIC MATERIAL; CHEMICAL SURFACE TREATMENT; DIFFUSION TREATMENT OF METALLIC MATERIAL; COATING BY VACUUM EVAPORATION, BY SPUTTERING, BY ION IMPLANTATION OR BY CHEMICAL VAPOUR DEPOSITION, IN GENERAL; INHIBITING CORROSION OF METALLIC MATERIAL OR INCRUSTATION IN GENERAL
    • C23FNON-MECHANICAL REMOVAL OF METALLIC MATERIAL FROM SURFACE; INHIBITING CORROSION OF METALLIC MATERIAL OR INCRUSTATION IN GENERAL; MULTI-STEP PROCESSES FOR SURFACE TREATMENT OF METALLIC MATERIAL INVOLVING AT LEAST ONE PROCESS PROVIDED FOR IN CLASS C23 AND AT LEAST ONE PROCESS COVERED BY SUBCLASS C21D OR C22F OR CLASS C25
    • C23F11/00Inhibiting corrosion of metallic material by applying inhibitors to the surface in danger of corrosion or adding them to the corrosive agent
    • CCHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
    • C04CEMENTS; CONCRETE; ARTIFICIAL STONE; CERAMICS; REFRACTORIES
    • C04BLIME, MAGNESIA; SLAG; CEMENTS; COMPOSITIONS THEREOF, e.g. MORTARS, CONCRETE OR LIKE BUILDING MATERIALS; ARTIFICIAL STONE; CERAMICS; REFRACTORIES; TREATMENT OF NATURAL STONE
    • C04B28/00Compositions of mortars, concrete or artificial stone, containing inorganic binders or the reaction product of an inorganic and an organic binder, e.g. polycarboxylate cements
    • C04B28/02Compositions of mortars, concrete or artificial stone, containing inorganic binders or the reaction product of an inorganic and an organic binder, e.g. polycarboxylate cements containing hydraulic cements other than calcium sulfates
    • EFIXED CONSTRUCTIONS
    • E04BUILDING
    • E04CSTRUCTURAL ELEMENTS; BUILDING MATERIALS
    • E04C5/00Reinforcing elements, e.g. for concrete; Auxiliary elements therefor
    • E04C5/01Reinforcing elements of metal, e.g. with non-structural coatings
    • E04C5/015Anti-corrosion coatings or treating compositions, e.g. containing waterglass or based on another metal
    • E04C5/017Anti-corrosion coatings or treating compositions containing cement
    • CCHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
    • C04CEMENTS; CONCRETE; ARTIFICIAL STONE; CERAMICS; REFRACTORIES
    • C04BLIME, MAGNESIA; SLAG; CEMENTS; COMPOSITIONS THEREOF, e.g. MORTARS, CONCRETE OR LIKE BUILDING MATERIALS; ARTIFICIAL STONE; CERAMICS; REFRACTORIES; TREATMENT OF NATURAL STONE
    • C04B2111/00Mortars, concrete or artificial stone or mixtures to prepare them, characterised by specific function, property or use
    • C04B2111/20Resistance against chemical, physical or biological attack
    • C04B2111/26Corrosion of reinforcement resistance

Definitions

  • the present invention is directed to reinforced concrete systems, and more particularly, is directed to steel reinforced concrete having improved corrosion and/or mechanical performance.
  • Steel-reinforced concrete is a remarkably versatile and ubiquitous material. It is easily formed from a cement-based slurry which hydrates with water, without extensive volume change, to form solid, compressively strong structures of virtually unlimited size and shape.
  • the structural weakness of concrete in tension is compensated by relatively inexpensive steel reinforcement, which fortuitously approximates the thermal expansion of concrete over a broad temperature range.
  • steel reinforcement is subject to corrosion (rusting), even when embedded in the high-pH, passivating environment of the hydrated cement paste.
  • the pressure from the increased volume of the confined iron oxide corrosion product spalls and cracks the concrete, destroying its functional integrity long before the end of its potential design life.
  • Estimates of the repair cost for existing highway bridges in the U.S. have been put at over $50 billion, and $1 to $3 trillion for all concrete structures M. Fickleburn, "Editorial", Materials and Structures Journal, RILEM, Vol. 23, No. 137, p. 317 (1990).
  • steel-reinforced concrete has many desirable attributes which have made it a dominant "Infrastructure" material for roads, bridges, buildings and dams throughout the world.
  • An enormous design, manufacturing and construction industry has developed which is efficient and skilled in its use and application. In the absence of corrosion, its behavior is relatively predictable and reliable.
  • Conventional steel reinforcement is relatively inexpensive, particularly in comparison to inherently expensive alternatives such as Fiber Reinforced Plastic (FRP) and stainless steel.
  • FRP Fiber Reinforced Plastic
  • Corrosion of steel reinforcement is greatly accelerated in the presence of chloride ions, which catalyze iron oxidation. Even if not present in the original concrete, chlorides can penetrate throughout the pore structure of the concrete when the external surfaces of the concrete are exposed to deicing salts or marine environments [J.A. Gonzalez, et al., "Some Considerations On The Effect Of Chloride Ions On The Corrosion Of Steel Reinforcements Embedded In Concrete Structures", Magazine Of Concrete Research, Vol. 50, pp. 189-199 (1998)].
  • a wide variety of approaches has been attempted to overcome the problem of corrosion in reinforced concrete. For example, steel reinforcement with a relatively expensive epoxy coating is commonly used in bridges and highways. However, the soft epoxy coating is easily damaged during transportation and placement.
  • the epoxy coating also prevents bonding of the rebar with the cement matrix, and itself tends to debond from the steel surface because its bond can be thermodynamically unstable in the alkaline cement environment.
  • the epoxy layer When debonded from the steel surface, the epoxy layer may be associated with underfilm and crevice corrosion.
  • Another expensive approach has been the use of reinforcing materials which do not corrode.
  • Stainless steel reinforcing bars meeting appropriate specifications ASASTM A955 and BS 6744
  • have been used in selected applications [F.N. Smith, et al., "Stainless Steel Reinforcing Bars", Proc.
  • FRP Fiber-reinforced plastic
  • FRP reinforcements typically comprise carbon, aramid and/or glass fibers embedded in a resin matrix, to provide a high tensile strength-to-weight ratio [O. Chaallal, et al., "Physical and Mechanical Performance of an innovative Glass-Fiber Reinforced Plastic Rod for Concrete and Grouted Anchorages, " Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering, V. 20, No. 2,1993, pp. 254-268.].
  • radial force transmission among adjacent fibers may be poor, and failure in fiber reinforced plastic composites may occur at relatively low strains (about 1-3 percent).
  • FIGURE I is a schematic illustration of a conventional, freshly-poured, aqueous cement slurry at a steel reinforcement surface
  • FIGURE 2 is a schematic illustration of a conventional, fully-reacted cement paste, at the steel reinforcement surface of FIGURE 1 ;
  • FIGURE 3 is a schematic illustration of a fully percolated conventional concrete showing a chloride percolation path to, and along, the steel reinforcement surface;
  • FIGURE 4 is a schematic illustration of a thermal spray system for integrally applying corrosion resistant and hydraulically reactive layers on hot reinforcing bar stock
  • FIGURE 5 is a schematic cross sectional view of a steel reinforcing bar having an integrally bonded, thermally sprayed layer of silicon or ferrosilicon alloy on the steel surface, and an integrally bonded, thermally sprayed layer of hydraulically reactive cementitious material such as blast furnace slag integrally adherently bonded to the silicon or ferrosilicon layer;
  • FIGURE 6 is a schematic cross-sectional view of a steel reinforcing bar having a thermally sprayed, dense adherent layer of hydraulically reactive cementitious material such as blast furnace slag integrally adherently bonded directly on the exterior steel surface;
  • FIGURE 7 is a schematic illustration of a freshly-poured aqueous cement slurry at a layered, adherent, reactive steel reinforcement surface prepared in accordance with the embodiment of FIGURE 5; and
  • FIGURE 8 is a schematic illustration of a cured cement layer at the non-corroding steel reinforcement surface of the embodiment of FIGURE 5, which has a relatively strong interface and which is protected from corrosion;
  • FIGURE 9 is a photomicrograph of an undeformed steel reinforcing bar which has been plasma sprayed with an adherent integrally thermally bonded coating of blast furnace slag which is hydraulically reactive in a high-pH cement paste environment
  • FIGURE 10 is a photomicrograph of a steel reinforcing bar which has been plasma sprayed with an adherent silicon coating and an adherent, integral blast furnace slag coating which is hydraulically reactive in a high-pH cement paste environment.
  • the present disclosure is directed to corrosion-prevention and property-enhancing technology for steel-reinforced concrete, to facilitate the continued use of conventional, relatively inexpensive carbon steel in highways, buildings, bridges and tunnels.
  • the present invention is directed to steel reinforcement for concrete which has the capability of forming an adherent bond with a cement matrix, and/or to methods for providing functionally graded, strongly adherent interfaces between steel reinforcement and a bulk cement matrix.
  • the present invention is also directed to corrosion-resistant steel reinforced concrete, and to methods for manufacturing corrosion-resistant concrete having an interface between the bulk cement matrix and the steel reinforcement which is at least as strong as the cement paste of the bulk cement, and preferably stronger.
  • the present invention is also directed to corrosion-resistant steel reinforcement.
  • the interfaces may be provided by thermally spraying very thin, adherently bonded integrally functional layer(s) on the steel surface.
  • the outer layer will at least partially react with the hydrating cement to produce a dense, adherent interface.
  • Thermal spray application of a variety of functionally graduated interface materials on steel reinforcement bar surfaces may be utilized to more finely control the interface reaction in cement, as will be discussed in more detail.
  • the purpose of the thermal spraying is to produce relatively dense, strongly adherent layers which are integrally and durably attached to, and protect, the steel surface.
  • Various thermal spray systems such as plasma spray, HVOF (high velocity oxygen flame), and other combustion spray systems may be utilized.
  • a key feature of the present disclosure is the thermal bonding of a calcium silicate or other cementreactive layer to the steel surface, or corrosion-passivated steel surface, to provide a strongly adherent interface.
  • Suitable reactive coating materials might also include thermally sprayed cohesive layers of alumina, calcium aluminate(s), calcium phosphate/apatite, ferrotitanates, and other materials which can react with hydraulic cement.
  • Dicalcium silicate e.g., from inexpensive pulverized fly ash or ground slag such as blast furnace slag, or pulverized burned oil shale
  • Dicalcium silicate is a particularly preferred material, because of its relatively low cost and its ability to react in the high alkalinity environment of the cement mix, while being relatively inert under more neutral conditions of transport and storage.
  • integrally adherent layers may be provided which are relatively inert and unreactive in storage and under construction site environmental conditions, but which are hydraulically reactive in the highly alkaline cement paste environment of an aqueous concrete mix.
  • the thermally sprayed layers may also include strong fiber materials which strengthen the interface zone.
  • the layers bond strongly with and protect the steel, and also may partially react with and become part of an enhanced, relatively dense interface with the bulk cement. It is important in the practicalities of the constructions sites and construction practices that the thermally sprayed reinforcing steel can be made so it is relatively durable for transport and handling prior to use. It is relatively inexpensive to apply the coating(s) to the reinforcing steel, which is also an important consideration for providing commercially effective reinforcement products.
  • an adhesion promotion layer may be selected to improve the adherence between the steel reinforcement surface and the thermally sprayed cement-reactive layer.
  • Adhesion promoting materials include boron, silicon, chromium, titanium, nickel and their lower oxides, which can form a chemical bond with, or from within, the iron surface, and with a calcium silicate, aluminate and/or phosphate thermally sprayed layer.
  • the adhesion promotion layer may be very thin, for example, 10-2000 Angstroms, so that the amount of material applied is very small in proportion to the steel reinforcement.
  • An optional metallic corrosion-resistant layer which is desirably integrally alloyed with or diffused in the steel reinforcement surface, may also be interposed between the steel and the cementitious hydraulically reactive bonding layer.
  • This corrosion-resistant layer may also be relatively thin (e.g., 1000 Angstroms to 25 microns) and comprise or be combined with the adhesion promoting layer.
  • the corrosion-resistant layer may be an integral silicon, boron, titanium or chromium diffusion or alloy which resists chloride catalyzed oxidation of iron.
  • the present disclosure is directed to corrosion-prevention and property-enhancing technology for steel-reinforced concrete, to facilitate the continued use of conventional, relatively inexpensive carbon steel in highways, buildings, bridges and tunnels.
  • Various aspects of the disclosure are directed to steel reinforcement for concrete which has the capability of forming an adherent bond with a cement matrix, and/or to methods for providing functionally graded, strongly adherent interfaces between steel reinforcement and a bulk cement matrix.
  • the present disclosure is also directed to corrosion-resistant steel reinforced concrete, and to methods for manufacturing corrosion-resistant concrete having an interface between the bulk cement matrix and the steel reinforcement which is at least as strong as the cement paste of the bulk cement, and preferably stronger.
  • the present invention is also directed to corrosion- resistant steel reinforcement.
  • the interfaces may be provided by thermally spraying one or more very thin, functional layer(s) on the steel surface.
  • the outer layer will at least partially react with the hydrating cement to produce a dense, adherent interface.
  • Thermal spray application of a variety of functionally graduated interface materials on steel reinforcement bar surfaces may be utilized to more finely control the interface reaction in cement, as will be discussed in more detail.
  • the purpose of the thermal spraying is to produce relatively dense, strongly adherent layers which are integrally and durably attached to, and protect, the steel surface.
  • Various thermal spray systems such as plasma spray, HVOF (high velocity oxygen flame), and combustion spray systems may be utilized.
  • a key feature of the present disclosure is the thermal bonding of a calcium silicate or other cement-reactive layer to the steel surface, to provide a strongly adherent interface.
  • Suitable reactive coating materials might also include thermally sprayed cohesive layers of alumina, calcium aluminate(s), calcium phosphate/apatite, and other materials which can react with hydraulic cement.
  • Dicalcium silicate e.g., from inexpensive pulverized fuel ash or ground slag such as blast furnace slag, burned oil shale
  • integrally adherent layers may be provided which are relatively inert and unreactive in storage and under potentially difficult construction site environmental conditions, but which are hydraulically reactive in the highly alkaline cement paste environment of an aqueous concrete mix.
  • the layers bond strongly with and protect the steel, and also may partially react with and become part of an enhanced, relatively dense interface with the bulk cement. It is important in the practicalities of construction sites and construction practices that the thermally sprayed reinforcing steel can be made so it is relatively durable for transport and handling prior to use. It is relatively inexpensive to apply the coatings to the reinforcing steel, which is also an important consideration for providing commercially effective reinforcement products.
  • Methods for manufacturing steel reinforcement for concrete structures can comprise the steps of providing a steel reinforcement element for a concrete structure, thermally applying an adherent layer of hydraulically reactive alkaline earth oxide, aluminate, silicate or phosphate or silica to the external surface of the steel reinforcing element, to form a cohesive layer having a thickness of preferably from about 5 to about 500 microns.
  • This layer is adherently bonded to the steel surface, either directly, or indirectly through an adherently bonded corrosion passivating layer such as a silicon or ferrosilicon layer.
  • interfacial zones can be relatively porous compared to the bulk of the cement matrix, and may therefor be a "weak link" in reinforced concrete [Z. Li, et al., “Enhancement Of Re-Bar (Smooth Surface)-Concrete Bond Properties By Matrix Modification And Surface Coatings", Magazine Of Concrete Research, Vol. 50, pp. 4957 (1998)].
  • the relatively porous interfacial zones typically can have a thickness of about 20-50 microns.
  • the porosity of the "weak link" zone adjacent a steel reinforcing bar may actually increase during the curing of the cement, as interfacial void content or microcracking increase at the interface when the cement cures.
  • X. Fu, et al. "Effects of Water-Cement Ratio, Curing Age, Silica Fume, Polymer Admixtures, Steel Surface Treatments, and Corrosion on Bond Between Concrete and Steel Reinforcing Bars", A CI Materials Journal, November-December, 1998, pp. 725-733.
  • FIGURE I schematically illustrated in FIGURE I is a magnified view of a conventional, freshly-poured aqueous cement slurry at a steel reinforcement surface.
  • the aqueous cement slurry comprises a plurality of unreacted cement particles 12 surrounded by water 14, which is adjacent the steel reinforcement surface 16.
  • the unreacted cement particles are typically 20-60 microns in length, and accordingly are shown in schematically magnified view in FIGURE 1.
  • the cement particles immediately adjacent the steel reinforcement surface 16, the cement particles may pack less efficiently than in the bulk cement packing zone.
  • the unreacted cement particles may pack relatively more efficiently and uniformly to provide a bulk cement packing zone 20.
  • FIGURE 2 Schematically illustrated in FIGURE 2 is a conventional fully-reacted cement paste at a steel reinforcement surface like that of FIGURE 1.
  • the cement particles 12 of the bulk of the cement paste react with water to provide various hard, hydrated cement paste products to provide a bulk density cement paste zone 22.
  • the hydrated cement paste is not uniform at a microscopic level, in that it contains pores and may contain partially unreacted cement grains which are not fully hydrated at their cores, this cement paste zone is illustrated as a relatively dense, uniform zone in FIGURE I for purposes of this discussion.
  • the fully reacted cement paste in the bulk density zone 22 may be relatively dense, the reacted cement paste immediately adjacent the steel reinforcement surface 16 has reduced density, for reasons previously discussed.
  • the reduced density zone may be, for example, 20-50 microns in thickness and may form a relatively porous zone 24 immediately adjacent the steel reinforcement surface 16.
  • the tensile strength of the steel reinforcement is relatively high in comparison to the tensile strength 28 of the bulk density cement paste.
  • cement and concrete have a tensile strength which is significantly lower than its compressive strength, and significantly lower than that of the steel reinforcement. In fact, this is the principal reason for providing steel or other reinforcement in concrete.
  • the tensile strength of the relatively porous interface between the bulk density cement paste and the steel reinforcement surface is even lower in tensile strength than the fully reacted bulk cement paste 22.
  • This relatively weak, porous interface zone 24 is accordingly a "weak link" between the cured concrete mass and the steel reinforcement.
  • the porosity of the interface promotes corrosion by permitting contact with corrosioninducing chloride ions and oxidizing agents, and adversely affects the environmental durability of the concrete, causing accelerated deterioration.
  • the porous interface zones around each of the inclusions, including the steel reinforcement and the aggregate particles form an interconnected network which can foster the percolation of chloride ions through the concrete cover to the steel reinforcement [Y.F. Houst, et al., "Influence of aggregate concentration on the diffusion of C02 and 02", Interfaces in Cementitious Composites, ed. by J. Maso (E and FN Spon, London, 1992), 279-288].
  • interfacial zone weakness and porosity adjacent the steel reinforcement can be exacerbated by inhomogeneities which occur during pouring of the reinforced concrete, such as caused by component settling in the concrete mix or structure before hardening.
  • relatively heavy aggregate and cement particles can settle in freshly poured concrete, to displace free water upwardly where it is trapped at the undersurfaces of aggregate and reinforcement [K.H. Khayat, "Use Of Viscosity-Modifying Admixture To Reduce
  • FIGURE 3 schematically illustrated in FIGURE 3 is a fully permeated conventional concrete mass illustrating a chloride percolation path to, and along, the steel reinforcement surface of an embedded reinforcing bar 30.
  • the scale of FIGURE 3 is substantially less than that of FIGURES 1 and 2.
  • the inclusions such as aggregate pieces 32 and sand particles (not shown) generally all have relatively porous interfacial zones, and because at relatively high loadings of sand and aggregate in conventional concrete, the surfaces of the sand and aggregate particles are closely spaced together.
  • porous interfacial zones of each of the aggregate particles tend to become connected, thereby forming a pathway through the concrete which includes the porous interfacial zone 34 at the steel reinforcement surface. Accordingly, chloride ions and other materials can permeate through the concrete at a rate much faster than the permeation rate through bulk cement paste.
  • a corrosion-resistant layer or alloy is provided at the steel reinforcement surface, between the steel and the cement-reactive layer, to further protect the steel from corrosion.
  • a passivating, corrosion-resisting layer such as an iron suicide surface layer may be readily applied to steel reinforcement such as "rebar", beams, wire or mesh, by reaction with silicon at elevated temperatures in the presence of chlorides ("Ihrigizing").
  • Other materials such as chromium, boron/borides, nickel, stainless steel, titanium, aluminum, etc. may also be vapor-reacted and/or thermally sprayed onto the steel reinforcement to serve as a very thin, hard, adherent protective layer which is inexpensively applied by plasma, HVOF or combustion thermal spraying onto the surface of the steel reinforcement.
  • the corrosion-resistant layer such as an iron suicide, iron-titanium, or ferrochrome layer, may be relatively thin, on the order of 0.1 to 100 microns. Silicon, chromium and titanium readily alloy with iron, with Gibbs Free Energy release, so that the iron suicide or other alloy layer is integral with the steel reinforcement, and mechanically much stronger than the bulk cement paste.
  • the ferrosilicon or other intermetallic alloy or silicon coating is thermodynamically less reactive than the untreated steel surface to oxidation in the high pH cement paste environment of the concrete, and/or relatively more passivated with respect to catalytic oxidation in the presence of chloride ion.
  • the corrosion-passivating layer may be very thin, but should be capable of strong chemical (not just mechanical) bonding to a cement- reactive layer, as will be further described. It is desirable to provide a continuous layer of the alloyed diffused or otherwise chemically passivated surface layer over the steel reinforcing member.
  • the surface may be useful to subject the surface to vapor-phase chemical reaction and diffusion, such as by treatment with SiCl 4 , BC1 3 , silanes, boron hydrides, titanium chloride (in a reducing environment) or mixtures thereof, at an elevated temperature (e.g., about 400-1300° C. see, e.g., U.S. Patent Nos. 5,064,691 and 5,089,061), to insure surface reaction.
  • the diffused or alloyed surface layer containing B, Si, Ti, Cr or mixtures thereof may be very thin, e.g., 0.5 + 15 microns, but should best be continuous.
  • the corrosion passivating layer may be applied during forging or as the steel reinforcement is exiting the rolling mill where it is manufactured, while it is still heated to a rolling/forging temperature of 800-1200° C.
  • Conventional plasma spraying particularly if applied to a heated reinforcing steel surface, may produce a dense, thin surface zone which at least partially interdiffuses with the steel surface.
  • Fine silicon, boron, titanium, chromium or nickel powders or compounds can be heated to vaporization temperature in a plasma gun system and applied to a hot steel reinforcing bar so that these materials diffuse at the steel surface to form a passivated integral surface layer.
  • High temperature electric arc plasma spraying can also provide high velocity particles and may also heat the steel surface momentarily to cause binding and interdiffusion.
  • High velocity oxygen flame (HVOF) plasma spraying of passivating materials such as silicon or ferrosilicon may also produce a dense surface layer, particularly in view of the ultrahigh velocity of the sprayed particles, which melt and interact upon impacting of the particles at the surface, where the kinetic energy is converted to thermal energy in a relatively instantaneous manner.
  • a reducing atmosphere, and particularly a sputtering of the hot steel surface is best for chemical bonding and diffusion.
  • a particularly useful method for applying a passivating alloy surface which is continuous, even on a microscopic basis, is by partially transferred arc and/or rf/plasma arc plasma coating.
  • the electric heating arc is transferred internally to the accelerating gun nozzle.
  • the steel surface to be coated with the alloy and/or passivating material is biased with a negative voltage in respect to a positive current source at the interior of the nozzle of the plasma spray device.
  • the positive electrode may be the regular cathode of the plasma spray gun, or may be a separate electrode located slightly downstream of the plasma gun.
  • a plasma column is provided between the plasma gun and the steel surface which is being coated, which conducts current between the reinforcing steel surface and the plasma gun cathode.
  • Steel reinforcement may form a native oxide surface (e.g., FeO) during its manufacture in a rolling mill, which is removed by the
  • sputtering effect of a transferred arc or rf plasma.
  • the plasma functions to ionize and clean oxides and other electronegative components on the surface of the steel, so that they are removed, and to attract ionized metals or silicon or positively charged silicon particles or other passivating materials, which become metallurgically bonded to the cleaned steel surface to form an impervious passivating layer.
  • the plasma is a reducing plasma (e.g., contains hydrogen), this may also aid in the formation of a metallurgical bond.
  • a radio frequency plasma can be provided to assist maintenance of the arc between the plasma gun and the steel substrate to be coated and alloyed with a passivating material.
  • an outer layer of an inorganic ceramic or glass such as an alkaline earth silicate, (e.g., calcium silicate), aluminate, a phosphate, and/or a silica or alumina layer, which is also integrally bonded to the iron suicide layer, and which is reactive with the hydraulic cement paste. It is also stronger than the bulk cement paste, and has a relatively strong bond to the steel reinforcement such that the steel-ceramic composite is itself stronger than the bulk cement paste.
  • thermal spraying is conventionally used for applying strongly bonded ceramic and metal layers for mechanically demanding applications such as turbine blades, so the strength and bonding capabilities of thermal spray systems are more than adequate for reinforced concrete bonding needs.
  • the composition of the inorganic ceramic or glass layer may be primarily in the mono- to di-silicate range (e.g., powdered blast furnace or other slag, fly ash, burned shale ash or other such material, which is compatible with and participates in and participates in cement hydration reactions and makes an inexpensive raw material source), so that it remains stable in unhydrated form for storage of the reinforcing bars prior to use.
  • powdered silica and/or alumina may also be used as a reactive interface material.
  • the calcium silicate layer may also be relatively thin, but should desirably be sufficiently thick that it does not become fully hydrated throughout its thickness during the hydration of concrete.
  • a thickness of 50-100 microns of a less reactive lower calcium silicate layer should be more than adequate.
  • a vitreous or ceramic layer may also be quite mechanically strong compared to the cement paste, and is integrally bonded to the iron suicide, iron titanide or other iron-passivating layer.
  • the calcium silicate layer may also be applied by relatively inexpensive high-temperature plasma, HVOF or combustion thermal spraying.
  • the thin, refractory, adherent, unitary, inorganic layers may readily be applied during steel rebar manufacture. There are some adhesion and efficiency advantages in high-speed application of the layers in the rolling mill before the steel reinforcement bars have completely cooled.
  • the outer surface of the calcium silicate layer may preferably be applied with a somewhat greater degree of open porosity (e.g., 5-20%) than the interior layer (e.g., 015% porosity) to further assist the formation of a functionally graded interface with the bulk cement matrix. Because of the relatively low thermal spray temperatures required for calcium silicate application, the low cost of the materials (e.g., fly ash or blast furnace slag) and the thinness of the layers, the cost of application is relatively low. As indicated earlier, an adhesion-promoting layer may be utilized to promote chemical bonding of the metallic steel or steel alloy surface with the ceramic vitreous coating.
  • An extremely thin layer of boron or silicon oxide groups may be formed at the surface of the iron suicide and/or boride layer formed at the surface of the reinforcing steel, which can chemically bond with the thermally applied glass or ceramic layer.
  • a very thin layer of chromium, titanium or nickel oxide may form an adhesion-promoting layer, particularly if in a partially-oxidized metallic, or lower oxidation state.
  • FIGURE 4 illustrates a thermal spray system 40 for applying corrosion resistant and hydraulically reactive layers on steel reinforcing bar stock as produced by a conventional rolling mill.
  • a finished steel reinforcing bar 42 from a rolling mill 44 is continuously transported through a thermal spray station 46.
  • the reinforcing bar (or "rebar") stock may still be at elevated temperature such as 500- 1200° C. from its manufacture.
  • the thermal spray station 46 comprises a thermal spray station 48 for applying a passivating corrosion-resistant layer such as a silicon or ferrosilicon layer 49, and thermal spray station 50 for applying a hydraulically reactive ceramic material layer 51 on the corrosion-resistant layer 49.
  • the thermal spray station 48 desirably comprises at least three thermal spray guns spaced radially around the reinforcing bar, so that the entire surface of the bar is coated on a continuous basis as it is conducted through the thermal spray station. Because the steel bar may form a native oxide (such as FeO) on its surface during its manufacture in the rolling mill, the thermal spray may also desirably be operated with a reducing atmosphere. Preferably, the thermal spray guns function to "sputter-clean" the reinforcing bar surface as the corrosion-resistant layer 49 and/or diffusion is applied.
  • a relatively fine silicon or ferrosilicon powders are preferably used, with relatively high plasma operating temperatures, so that at least a portion of the silicon or ferrosilicon is vaporized, for subsequent condensation on this heated steel reinforcing bar surface, to provide a continuous layer.
  • the silicon/fe ⁇ o silicon will quickly diffuse/alloy with the steel rebar at its elevated temperature.
  • An adhesion-promoting layer may be applied between the silicon/ferrosilicon layer.
  • a fine aqueous spray of a chromium, nickel or titanium oxide-based solution or slurry may be directly applied to the hot steel surface, which will promote fusion and bonding at the elevated processing temperatures (e.g., 400- 1200° C.) with the subsequently applied ceramic or vitreous layer.
  • the thermal spray station for the ceramic layer application may also desirably be a low-cost combustion system or HVOF system.
  • FIGURE 7 is a schematic illustration of a freshly poured aqueous cement slurry at the surface of a thermally sprayed steel reinforcing bar embedded in the cement slurry.
  • the steel reinforcing bar 72 has an adherent, thin, thermally sprayed ferrosilicon or silicon layer 74 at its surface, which is substantially more passive with respect to both rusting, and chloride ioncatalyzed oxidation, than the bulk steel of the reinforcing bar 72.
  • Silicon can be used to produce a surface which is relatively inert to oxidation catalyzed by the chloride ion.
  • the silicon readily alloys with and diffuses into iron at moderately elevated temperatures, which are present immediately after manufacture of the rebar in a steel rolling mill, and/or which can be briefly applied to the surface of the reinforcing bar without damaging the internal metallo graphic structure, to form a variety of ferrosilicon compounds or solid solutions.
  • a passivating silicon alloy layer can be provided by exposure to silicon-containing gases such as SiC14 at elevated temperatures (see, e.g., U.S. Patents 3,433,253 and 5,200,145). Pure silicon powder can also be thermally sprayed to produce a relatively inert layer of silicon and/or ferrosilicon alloy.
  • ferrosilicon can also be used to provide a surface which is relatively passivated with respect to oxidation under chloridecatalyzed conditions.
  • Fe ⁇ osilicon can be produced at very low expense, and provided in powdered form for thermal spray volitalization and/or application to the surface of the steel reinforcement to produce an intimately bonded, alloyed layer at the surface.
  • boride materials may be provided and plasma-vaporized at lower expense than boron hydride materials.
  • the corrosion-resistant fe ⁇ osilicon layer 72 has an intimately adherent cementitious layer 74, which is thermally sprayed thereon and bonded thereto.
  • the illustrated cementitious layer may be an industrial-grade calcium silicate, such as the primarily dicalcium silicate materials of blast furnace slag waste products.
  • the thermally-applied cementitious layer may desirably be graded, either continuously, or discreetly, so that it is more dense and/or more unreactive in the high pH environment of a cement mix, immediately adjacent the fe ⁇ osilicon layer 74.
  • the layer 76 may be more porous and/or more hydraulically reactive at the exterior surface 78 facing the aqueous cement mix.
  • a calcium silicate powder which crystallizes to form a relatively inert material such as wollastonite may be applied using HVOF thermal spraying to produce a very dense, relatively crystalline layer which strongly adheres to the fe ⁇ osilicon or silicon surface 74.
  • An external layer of predominantly dicalcium. silicate, such as fly ash or blast furnace slag, may be applied over the calcium silicate layer, using a lower velocity HVOF or plasma spray gun, to produce and external layer which is relatively more hydraulically reactive in the aqueous high pH environment of the cement mix.
  • the amount of reaction may be precisely controlled, to ensure that an adherent, dense, protective inorganic oxide layer remains adjacent the steel surface to contribute to the protection of the underlying steel reinforcement.
  • An extremely thin adhesion-promoting layer (not shown), for example of chromium oxide, titanium dioxide or lower oxide, or nickel oxide may be present between the fe ⁇ osilicon surface of the steel bar, and the cementitious calcium silicate layer 76.
  • the external surface 78 of the thermally sprayed reactive layer 76 need not to be completely smooth, and may also have some degree of porosity, which may permit a denser aggregation of cement particles adjacent the surface.
  • the physical density of the calcium silicate layer 76 at the external surface should best be at least 75 percent solid (less than 25% porosity), as compared to a lower concentration of cement particles in the cement mix, and accordingly, the unreacted cement particles 82 of the freshly poured aqueous cement slurry may form a relatively dense surface reaction zone 80 together with the thermally sprayed reactive layer 76.
  • the unreacted cement particles in the water matrix 84 away from the immediate surface of the zone 80 may be in a zone 86 having the conventional bulk cement packing density.
  • the thermal spray guns may also apply relatively inert fibers, such as alumina fibers or zirconiabased high-pH-stable cement fibers with the cementitious layers. These fibers may be relatively small in diameter (e.g., 2-25 microns) and length (e.g., 25-200 microns), but can considerably strengthen the hydrated cement layer which is formed around the steel reinforcement.
  • the volume of reinforcing fibers may desirably be in the range of 2-25 percent of the volume of the cementitious thermally sprayed layer 76.
  • the ceramic external layer 76 of the treated steel reinforcement presents a reactive surface which partially hydrates with the bulk cement paste. It preferably does not completely hydrate, however, because it is thicker and less reactive than the cement particles, which themselves may not fully hydrate.
  • a strongly adherent, unhydrated layer of the calcium silicate is accordingly retained on the steel surface.
  • the high density, unhydrated calcium silicate at the steel surface, and the graded participation of the surface in the cement hydration reaction inhibits the formation of a porous weak interface zone. Co ⁇ osion-causing chloride percolation along the steel surface is therefor restricted, because there is no weak, porous zone adjacent the steel surface.
  • the net result is a dense interface, adherently chemically bonded to the steel surface, which is thereby protected from corrosion, and which transmits mechanical forces between the steel reinforcement and the bulk cement matrix.
  • the interface is desirably stronger than the bulk cement paste.
  • the interface is not porous, and does not promote the percolation of water or corrosioninducing chloride ions through the cured concrete or along the surface of the steel reinforcement. Because the interface integrally bonds the steel reinforcement to the bulk cement matrix with an adhesion strength desirably at least equal to the strength of the cement matrix, the mechanical properties of the reinforced concrete are maximized, rather than minimized by a porous interface zone.
  • the reactive calcium silicate layer 76 interacts with the cement particles to prevent the formation of a relatively porous and weak interfacial zone between the steel reinforcement and the bulk cement paste.
  • schematically illustrated in Figure 8 is a cured, adherent cement layer at a dense, non co ⁇ oding steel reinforcement surface.
  • the steel reinforcement 72 upon curing or partial curing of the cement particles in the cement mix, the steel reinforcement 72 still retains its adherent fe ⁇ osilicon layer 74 which passivates the iron against chloride-catalyzed oxidation, and a portion of the calcium silicate layer 76, which is itself strongly adherent to the fe ⁇ osilicon layer 74 by virtue of the thermal spray processing of its application.
  • the presence of silicon, titanium or other similar strong matrix oxide forming elements in the co ⁇ osion-passivating layer facilitates the formation of a strong, adherent chemical bond therebetween.
  • the exterior surface of the calcium silicate layer 76 has reacted by hydration with the cement mix to form a relatively dense, strong adherent surface reaction zone 88 which may be denser and stronger than the fully hardened cement paste 90 which is formed at the bulk density of the original cement mix.
  • the tensile strength of the composite structure is schematically shown in the graph below the structure illustrated in Figure 8, and in registration therewith.
  • the tensile strength of the steel reinforcement is relatively high, and the ferrosilicon, ferrochrome or ferrotitanium layer 74 is generally relatively lower in view of its increased brittleness.
  • the tensile strength of the unreacted calcium silicate layer 76 is relatively lower than that of the silicon, fe ⁇ otitanium, fe ⁇ ochrome or fe ⁇ osilicon layer 74, but still substantially higher than the bulk density cement paste.
  • the surface reaction zone (like the zones immediately su ⁇ ounding the individual cement particles) is denser and stronger in the direction of the hydration reaction adjacent the unreacted surface zone, and tapers toward the tensile strength of the bulk density cement paste.
  • the composite structure of Figure 8 does not produce a "weak link" of porosity adjacent the steel reinforcement. Rather, a functionally graded interface is produced which has a gradient of properties which gradually transitions to that of the bulk density cement paste 90.
  • the fe ⁇ osilicon layer 74 and the partially unreacted calcium silicate layer 76 physically limit the access of chloride ion and oxygen to the iron surface, thereby restricting oxidation.
  • the functional layers may be applied by thermal spraying, which is an economical technology for applying thin, adherent layers of refractory materials.
  • thermal spraying very small molten particles (e.g., 10-50 microns) and vaporized portions of the material to be applied are accelerated by combustion gases or an electric arc plasma, followed by deposition or impacting onto the steel reinforcement surface.
  • the steel surface may be heated so that the passivating components can diffuse into the steel surface to form an integrally-passivated layer.
  • solidification typically occurs at very rapid rates, so that the as-sprayed deposit is ultra-fine grained. This fast cooling should stabilize calcium silicates in the high-density gamma crystalline form desirable for use in hydraulic cements.
  • Thermal spray application of the functional layers is a relatively inexpensive and efficient method for integrally applying the functional layers to the reinforcing steel.
  • a wide range of materials has been successfully plasma-sprayed for a variety of applications, including gas turbine components having complex geometries [M.R. Jackson, et al, "Production of Metallurgical Structures by Rapid Solidification Plasma Deposition", J Metals, 33, Nov. 1981, 23-27; S. Sampath and H.Herman, J. Metals, 45(7) (1993) 42; R. Tiwari, et al., "Plasma Spray Consolidation of High Temperature Composites", Mat. Sci. and Eng. A144 (1991) 127-131; M. Moss, Acta Met., 16 (1968) 321 ; V.
  • the temperature of a plasma may be as high as 15,000° C. for a typical dc plasma torch, but the application of calcium silicate does not require such high temperatures.
  • Other thermal spray processes such as High Velocity Oxy-Fuel Spraying (HVOF), in which a high temperature oxygen-fuel flame undergoes free-expansion from the torch nozzle, to accelerate the particles to a high velocity (e.g., over Mach 3) may be used to produce dense, adherent coatings.
  • HVOF High Velocity Oxy-Fuel Spraying
  • Porosity should desirably be controlled in the application of the calcium silicate layers, for example in the range of from about 2-25 percent porosity (95-98 percent solid calcium silicate or calcium silicate plus reinforcing fibers).
  • porosity decreases.
  • the smaller the particle size the lower the porosity for typical thermal spray systems
  • Example I Three steel reinforcing bars (or dowels) without ribs or surface deformations, nominally 1/2 inch in diameter and 2 feet long, are cleaned of rust and surface oxidation by sand blasting. All bars receive the same sand blasting treatment.
  • One of the bars is placed on a rotating mandrel and coated with a very thin layer of silicon using a high temperature helium plasma Praxair/Miller Thermal SG-100 Plasma Spray System, so that substantially the entire surface of the bar is coated with the silicon layer.
  • the SG- 100 plasma spray gun uses a non-transfe ⁇ ed dc plasma torch configuration with powers up to 100 kW (here, about 40 kW).
  • the basic design of the plasma gun consists of two electrodes: a cone-shaped cathode inside a cylindrical anode, which forms a nozzle.
  • Gases e.g. argon, hydrogen, helium
  • the primary gas is argon (100 scfh) and the secondary gas is helium (60 scfh).
  • the powder carrier gas is typically argon (15 scfh).
  • a four hole gas ring is utilized to induce vortex flow in the electrode.
  • Powders injected into the plasma are accelerated and melted by its high temperature.
  • the molten droplets i.e. splats
  • the molten droplets are propelled onto the substrate where they solidify and accumulate to form a well-bonded coating.
  • the first bar (Bar 1) was placed on a rotating mandrel, and silicon was applied by plasma spray along its outer surface. Silicon was applied to the second bar (Bar 2) by plasma spray along a longitudinal strip along the bar length, without mandrel rotation. The silicon is applied at a low feed rate, in order to heat the bar and provide an opportunity for some diffusion of the silicon into the surface of the bars. The bars are not preheated, so diffusion was limited, and the silicon formed a surface layer. All three bards were subsequently coated with ground blast furnace slag using the same helium plasma gun. The third bar (Bar 3) was accordingly directly coated by plasma spray of ground blast furnace slag to the sand blasted surface of the steel reinforcing bar, without an intermediate silicon layer.
  • the ground granulated blast furnace slag (GGBFS) used was a product commercially available under the tradename GranCem from Holnam, Inc., 6211 Ann Arbor Road, Dundee, Michigan 48131. It was thermally sprayed using the plasma spray gun operated at about 40 kW.
  • the GGBFS had the following specifications:
  • the GGBFS is intended for use in admixture with portland cement and is accordingly compatible therewith.
  • the GranCem cement is made to meet the requirements of ASTM C 989 (equivalent AASHTO specification is M 302), which lists three grades of GGBF slag: Grade 80, Grade 100 and Grade 120. Grade 100 was utilized in the present example.
  • the sample used has the following characteristics according to the Chicago Grinding Facility of Holnam, Inc.: SLAG ACTIVITY INDEX SPECIFICATIONS MININUM
  • FIGURE 9 is a photomicrograph of Bar 3, showing an abraded surface of the steel about 3 min wide, and the surface texture of the applied GGBFS.
  • FIGURE 10 is similarly a photomicrograph of Bar 1, showing the abraded steel about 3 min wide, and the surface texture of the GGBFS layer.
  • the intermediate silicon layer can also be seen In FIGURE 10.
  • Bars 1, 2 and 3 and an uncoated steel reinforcing bar were cast in (Sakrete brand) mortar mix, which appear to be "lean” in cement. The bars will be examined after the mortar mix cures.

Abstract

Noncorroding reinforcing steel (16), and steel reinforced concrete (74), which has an adherent bond with hydrated concrete formed by a thermally sprayed hydraulically reactive layer (76) of a material such as blast furnace slag on the steel surface.

Description

REINFORCED CONCRETE SYSTEMS
Field of the Invention
The present invention is directed to reinforced concrete systems, and more particularly, is directed to steel reinforced concrete having improved corrosion and/or mechanical performance.
Background of the Invention Steel-reinforced concrete is a remarkably versatile and ubiquitous material. It is easily formed from a cement-based slurry which hydrates with water, without extensive volume change, to form solid, compressively strong structures of virtually unlimited size and shape. The structural weakness of concrete in tension is compensated by relatively inexpensive steel reinforcement, which fortuitously approximates the thermal expansion of concrete over a broad temperature range. Unfortunately, steel reinforcement is subject to corrosion (rusting), even when embedded in the high-pH, passivating environment of the hydrated cement paste. The pressure from the increased volume of the confined iron oxide corrosion product spalls and cracks the concrete, destroying its functional integrity long before the end of its potential design life. Estimates of the repair cost for existing highway bridges in the U.S. have been put at over $50 billion, and $1 to $3 trillion for all concrete structures M. Fickleburn, "Editorial", Materials and Structures Journal, RILEM, Vol. 23, No. 137, p. 317 (1990).
Except for its tendency to corrode, and its poor mechanical interface with the cement matrix, steel-reinforced concrete has many desirable attributes which have made it a dominant "Infrastructure" material for roads, bridges, buildings and dams throughout the world. An enormous design, manufacturing and construction industry has developed which is efficient and skilled in its use and application. In the absence of corrosion, its behavior is relatively predictable and reliable. Conventional steel reinforcement is relatively inexpensive, particularly in comparison to inherently expensive alternatives such as Fiber Reinforced Plastic (FRP) and stainless steel.
Corrosion of steel reinforcement is greatly accelerated in the presence of chloride ions, which catalyze iron oxidation. Even if not present in the original concrete, chlorides can penetrate throughout the pore structure of the concrete when the external surfaces of the concrete are exposed to deicing salts or marine environments [J.A. Gonzalez, et al., "Some Considerations On The Effect Of Chloride Ions On The Corrosion Of Steel Reinforcements Embedded In Concrete Structures", Magazine Of Concrete Research, Vol. 50, pp. 189-199 (1998)]. A wide variety of approaches has been attempted to overcome the problem of corrosion in reinforced concrete. For example, steel reinforcement with a relatively expensive epoxy coating is commonly used in bridges and highways. However, the soft epoxy coating is easily damaged during transportation and placement. The epoxy coating also prevents bonding of the rebar with the cement matrix, and itself tends to debond from the steel surface because its bond can be thermodynamically unstable in the alkaline cement environment. When debonded from the steel surface, the epoxy layer may be associated with underfilm and crevice corrosion. [Weyers, et al., "Estimating the Service Life of Epoxy-Coated Reinforcing Steel", AC1 Materials Journal, pp. 546557 (1998)]. Another expensive approach has been the use of reinforcing materials which do not corrode. Stainless steel reinforcing bars meeting appropriate specifications (ASTM A955 and BS 6744) have been used in selected applications [F.N. Smith, et al., "Stainless Steel Reinforcing Bars", Proc. Conf, Conference on Understanding Corrosion Mechanisms in Concrete, MIT, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 27-31 July 1997; F.N. Smith: "The Use Of Stainless Steel For Concrete Reinforcing Bars Is Gaining Momentum", Stainless Steel World, Vol.10, No.6, August 1998, p.52], but unfortunately are relatively expensive and difficult to work with, and consume strategic materials. Fiber-reinforced plastic (FRP) reinforcing materials, which are even more expensive, are being developed as inert, corrosion-resistant reinforcement for concrete in marine and highdeicing-salt environments. [R. Masmoudi et. al., "Flexural Behavior of Concrete Beams Reinforced with Deformed Fiber Reinforced Plastic Reinforcing Rods", V. 95, pp. 665-676 (1998); Neale, K. W., and Labossiere, P., eds. Advanced Composite Materials in Bridges and Structures, Proceedings, First International Conference on Advanced Composite Materials in Bridges and Structures, Sherbrooke, Canada, published by the Canadian Society for Civil Engineering, 1992, 700 pp.; A. Nanni, et al., eds., Fiber Reinforced Plastic Reinforcement for Concrete Structures, SP138, American Concrete Institute, Farmington Hills, Mich., 1993, 977 pp.; Saadatmanesh, H.. and Ehsani, M. R., eds., Composites in Infrastructure, Proceedings, First International Conference on Composites in Infrastructures, Tucson, Ariz., 1996, 600 pp.]. FRP reinforcements typically comprise carbon, aramid and/or glass fibers embedded in a resin matrix, to provide a high tensile strength-to-weight ratio [O. Chaallal, et al., "Physical and Mechanical Performance of an Innovative Glass-Fiber Reinforced Plastic Rod for Concrete and Grouted Anchorages, " Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering, V. 20, No. 2,1993, pp. 254-268.]. However, in spite of their potentially high strength based on the strength of the individual fibers, radial force transmission among adjacent fibers may be poor, and failure in fiber reinforced plastic composites may occur at relatively low strains (about 1-3 percent). Their tendency for sudden, brittle failure, particularly at high strain rates, may present safety problems under current reinforced concrete design criteria [Banthia, et al., "Impact Resistance of Concrete Plates Reinforced with a Fiber Reinforced Plastic Grid", ACI Materials Journal, pp. 11 - 18 (1998)]. Unlike steel, FRP reinforcement also has a significantly higher radial thermal expansion than concrete, posing compatibility problems, and inherently poor adhesion to the cement matrix.
Because of the poor corrosion characteristics of steel reinforced concrete, there is significant opportunity to improve the overall properties of steel reinforced concrete, if improved interfaces can be provided [X. Fu, et al., "Effects Of Water-Cement Ratio, Curing Age, Silica Fume, Polymer Admixtures, Steel Surface Treatments, And Corrosion On Bond Between Concrete And Steel Reinforcing Bars", ACI Materials Journal, pp. 725-734 (1998)]. It is an object of the present invention to improve the mechanical properties and/or the durability, of steel reinforced concrete could be improved if the low density, highly porous interface zones adjacent the steel reinforcement surfaces could be replaced by dense, strong, adherent layers. Accordingly, there is a need for improved concrete reinforcement, as well as functional cementsteel interfaces, which prevent corrosion of the steel reinforcement and resultant premature deterioration of steel reinforced concrete structures. There is also a need to improve anchoring and transmission of mechanical forces between the steel reinforcement and the cement matrix, in order to improve the performance and durability of the concrete. It would also be desirable to prevent percolation of corrosion-causing chloride salts along the surfaces of steel reinforcement in cured concrete structures. There is also a need for functional interfaces which maximize underlying microstructure and hydration transformations in concrete, to optimize durability and macro-mechanical properties.
Description of the Drawings FIGURE I is a schematic illustration of a conventional, freshly-poured, aqueous cement slurry at a steel reinforcement surface;
FIGURE 2 is a schematic illustration of a conventional, fully-reacted cement paste, at the steel reinforcement surface of FIGURE 1 ;
FIGURE 3 is a schematic illustration of a fully percolated conventional concrete showing a chloride percolation path to, and along, the steel reinforcement surface;
FIGURE 4 is a schematic illustration of a thermal spray system for integrally applying corrosion resistant and hydraulically reactive layers on hot reinforcing bar stock; FIGURE 5 is a schematic cross sectional view of a steel reinforcing bar having an integrally bonded, thermally sprayed layer of silicon or ferrosilicon alloy on the steel surface, and an integrally bonded, thermally sprayed layer of hydraulically reactive cementitious material such as blast furnace slag integrally adherently bonded to the silicon or ferrosilicon layer;
FIGURE 6 is a schematic cross-sectional view of a steel reinforcing bar having a thermally sprayed, dense adherent layer of hydraulically reactive cementitious material such as blast furnace slag integrally adherently bonded directly on the exterior steel surface;
FIGURE 7 is a schematic illustration of a freshly-poured aqueous cement slurry at a layered, adherent, reactive steel reinforcement surface prepared in accordance with the embodiment of FIGURE 5; and FIGURE 8 is a schematic illustration of a cured cement layer at the non-corroding steel reinforcement surface of the embodiment of FIGURE 5, which has a relatively strong interface and which is protected from corrosion;
FIGURE 9 is a photomicrograph of an undeformed steel reinforcing bar which has been plasma sprayed with an adherent integrally thermally bonded coating of blast furnace slag which is hydraulically reactive in a high-pH cement paste environment; and FIGURE 10 is a photomicrograph of a steel reinforcing bar which has been plasma sprayed with an adherent silicon coating and an adherent, integral blast furnace slag coating which is hydraulically reactive in a high-pH cement paste environment.
Summary of the Invention The present disclosure is directed to corrosion-prevention and property-enhancing technology for steel-reinforced concrete, to facilitate the continued use of conventional, relatively inexpensive carbon steel in highways, buildings, bridges and tunnels. Generally, the present invention is directed to steel reinforcement for concrete which has the capability of forming an adherent bond with a cement matrix, and/or to methods for providing functionally graded, strongly adherent interfaces between steel reinforcement and a bulk cement matrix. The present invention is also directed to corrosion-resistant steel reinforced concrete, and to methods for manufacturing corrosion-resistant concrete having an interface between the bulk cement matrix and the steel reinforcement which is at least as strong as the cement paste of the bulk cement, and preferably stronger. The present invention is also directed to corrosion-resistant steel reinforcement. The interfaces may be provided by thermally spraying very thin, adherently bonded integrally functional layer(s) on the steel surface. The outer layer will at least partially react with the hydrating cement to produce a dense, adherent interface. Thermal spray application of a variety of functionally graduated interface materials on steel reinforcement bar surfaces may be utilized to more finely control the interface reaction in cement, as will be discussed in more detail. The purpose of the thermal spraying is to produce relatively dense, strongly adherent layers which are integrally and durably attached to, and protect, the steel surface. Various thermal spray systems such as plasma spray, HVOF (high velocity oxygen flame), and other combustion spray systems may be utilized. A key feature of the present disclosure is the thermal bonding of a calcium silicate or other cementreactive layer to the steel surface, or corrosion-passivated steel surface, to provide a strongly adherent interface. Suitable reactive coating materials might also include thermally sprayed cohesive layers of alumina, calcium aluminate(s), calcium phosphate/apatite, ferrotitanates, and other materials which can react with hydraulic cement. Dicalcium silicate (e.g., from inexpensive pulverized fly ash or ground slag such as blast furnace slag, or pulverized burned oil shale) is a particularly preferred material, because of its relatively low cost and its ability to react in the high alkalinity environment of the cement mix, while being relatively inert under more neutral conditions of transport and storage. In this regard, integrally adherent layers may be provided which are relatively inert and unreactive in storage and under construction site environmental conditions, but which are hydraulically reactive in the highly alkaline cement paste environment of an aqueous concrete mix. The thermally sprayed layers may also include strong fiber materials which strengthen the interface zone. The layers bond strongly with and protect the steel, and also may partially react with and become part of an enhanced, relatively dense interface with the bulk cement. It is important in the practicalities of the constructions sites and construction practices that the thermally sprayed reinforcing steel can be made so it is relatively durable for transport and handling prior to use. It is relatively inexpensive to apply the coating(s) to the reinforcing steel, which is also an important consideration for providing commercially effective reinforcement products. Depending upon the nature of the materials chosen to be applied to the steel reinforcement, an adhesion promotion layer may be selected to improve the adherence between the steel reinforcement surface and the thermally sprayed cement-reactive layer. Adhesion promoting materials include boron, silicon, chromium, titanium, nickel and their lower oxides, which can form a chemical bond with, or from within, the iron surface, and with a calcium silicate, aluminate and/or phosphate thermally sprayed layer. The adhesion promotion layer may be very thin, for example, 10-2000 Angstroms, so that the amount of material applied is very small in proportion to the steel reinforcement. An optional metallic corrosion-resistant layer, which is desirably integrally alloyed with or diffused in the steel reinforcement surface, may also be interposed between the steel and the cementitious hydraulically reactive bonding layer. This corrosion-resistant layer may also be relatively thin (e.g., 1000 Angstroms to 25 microns) and comprise or be combined with the adhesion promoting layer. The corrosion-resistant layer may be an integral silicon, boron, titanium or chromium diffusion or alloy which resists chloride catalyzed oxidation of iron.
Detailed Description of the Invention As indicated, the present disclosure is directed to corrosion-prevention and property-enhancing technology for steel-reinforced concrete, to facilitate the continued use of conventional, relatively inexpensive carbon steel in highways, buildings, bridges and tunnels. Various aspects of the disclosure are directed to steel reinforcement for concrete which has the capability of forming an adherent bond with a cement matrix, and/or to methods for providing functionally graded, strongly adherent interfaces between steel reinforcement and a bulk cement matrix. The present disclosure is also directed to corrosion-resistant steel reinforced concrete, and to methods for manufacturing corrosion-resistant concrete having an interface between the bulk cement matrix and the steel reinforcement which is at least as strong as the cement paste of the bulk cement, and preferably stronger. The present invention is also directed to corrosion- resistant steel reinforcement. The interfaces may be provided by thermally spraying one or more very thin, functional layer(s) on the steel surface. The outer layer will at least partially react with the hydrating cement to produce a dense, adherent interface. Thermal spray application of a variety of functionally graduated interface materials on steel reinforcement bar surfaces may be utilized to more finely control the interface reaction in cement, as will be discussed in more detail. The purpose of the thermal spraying is to produce relatively dense, strongly adherent layers which are integrally and durably attached to, and protect, the steel surface. Various thermal spray systems such as plasma spray, HVOF (high velocity oxygen flame), and combustion spray systems may be utilized. A key feature of the present disclosure is the thermal bonding of a calcium silicate or other cement-reactive layer to the steel surface, to provide a strongly adherent interface. Suitable reactive coating materials might also include thermally sprayed cohesive layers of alumina, calcium aluminate(s), calcium phosphate/apatite, and other materials which can react with hydraulic cement. Dicalcium silicate (e.g., from inexpensive pulverized fuel ash or ground slag such as blast furnace slag, burned oil shale) is a particularly preferred material, because of its relatively low cost and its ability to react in the high alkalinity environment of the cement mix, while being relatively inert under more neutral conditions of transport and storage. In this regard, integrally adherent layers may be provided which are relatively inert and unreactive in storage and under potentially difficult construction site environmental conditions, but which are hydraulically reactive in the highly alkaline cement paste environment of an aqueous concrete mix. The layers bond strongly with and protect the steel, and also may partially react with and become part of an enhanced, relatively dense interface with the bulk cement. It is important in the practicalities of construction sites and construction practices that the thermally sprayed reinforcing steel can be made so it is relatively durable for transport and handling prior to use. It is relatively inexpensive to apply the coatings to the reinforcing steel, which is also an important consideration for providing commercially effective reinforcement products. An optional corrosion-resistant layer, which is desirably integrally alloyed with the steel reinforcement surface, may also be interposed between the steel and the cementitious hydraulically reactive bonding layer. Methods for manufacturing steel reinforcement for concrete structures can comprise the steps of providing a steel reinforcement element for a concrete structure, thermally applying an adherent layer of hydraulically reactive alkaline earth oxide, aluminate, silicate or phosphate or silica to the external surface of the steel reinforcing element, to form a cohesive layer having a thickness of preferably from about 5 to about 500 microns. This layer is adherently bonded to the steel surface, either directly, or indirectly through an adherently bonded corrosion passivating layer such as a silicon or ferrosilicon layer.
Because concrete is a composite material, its physical, mechanical and chemical properties depend in part on the properties of the interfaces between the cement matrix and inclusions such as reinforcing steel, stone or sand aggregate and/or reinforcing fibers. These interfacial zones can be relatively porous compared to the bulk of the cement matrix, and may therefor be a "weak link" in reinforced concrete [Z. Li, et al., "Enhancement Of Re-Bar (Smooth Surface)-Concrete Bond Properties By Matrix Modification And Surface Coatings", Magazine Of Concrete Research, Vol. 50, pp. 4957 (1998)]. The relatively porous interfacial zones typically can have a thickness of about 20-50 microns. A more complete discussion of the composite structure of concrete and the porous nature of the cement-aggregate interface, is given by E.J. Garboczi, et al., "Multi-Scale Picture of Concrete and its Transport Properties... ", National Institute Of Standards and Technology NIST 5900, pp. 1-46 (1996). The porous interfacial zones may be caused by surface effects from relatively inefficient packing of cement particles before the cement hardens. It has also been suggested that a "one-sided-growth" effect results from the hydrating reactant concentration coming only from the bulk cement side and not the inclusion surface [See Garboczi, et al., supra], to produce less dense, more porous, growth in the interfacial zone than in the bulk cement paste. The porosity of the "weak link" zone adjacent a steel reinforcing bar may actually increase during the curing of the cement, as interfacial void content or microcracking increase at the interface when the cement cures. X. Fu, et al., "Effects of Water-Cement Ratio, Curing Age, Silica Fume, Polymer Admixtures, Steel Surface Treatments, and Corrosion on Bond Between Concrete and Steel Reinforcing Bars", A CI Materials Journal, November-December, 1998, pp. 725-733. In this regard, schematically illustrated in FIGURE I is a magnified view of a conventional, freshly-poured aqueous cement slurry at a steel reinforcement surface. The aqueous cement slurry comprises a plurality of unreacted cement particles 12 surrounded by water 14, which is adjacent the steel reinforcement surface 16. The unreacted cement particles are typically 20-60 microns in length, and accordingly are shown in schematically magnified view in FIGURE 1. As shown in the figure, immediately adjacent the steel reinforcement surface 16, the cement particles may pack less efficiently than in the bulk cement packing zone. Accordingly, in freshly poured aqueous cement slurries there may be a relatively poor cement packing zone 18 immediately adjacent the steel reinforcement surface 16. In the bulk of the cement slurry (which may also contain other inclusions such as sand and gravel-not shown), the unreacted cement particles may pack relatively more efficiently and uniformly to provide a bulk cement packing zone 20.
A porous zone created upon hydration of the cement results in an undesirable gradient of physical properties. Because of this interfacial porosity, the mechanical properties at a conventional cementsteel interface may tend to be weakest where the strain is the highest. Cement paste/gel is inherently much weaker than the steel reinforcement, so its interface with the cement matrix is inherently a performance limiting zone, even if it is of uniform strength. Therefore, the formation of an even weaker zone with microporosity or microcracks immediately adjacent the steel reinforcement further exacerbates this "weak link", and further limits the performance of the concrete composite. Schematically illustrated in FIGURE 2 is a conventional fully-reacted cement paste at a steel reinforcement surface like that of FIGURE 1. As shown in FIGURE 2, the cement particles 12 of the bulk of the cement paste react with water to provide various hard, hydrated cement paste products to provide a bulk density cement paste zone 22. While the hydrated cement paste is not uniform at a microscopic level, in that it contains pores and may contain partially unreacted cement grains which are not fully hydrated at their cores, this cement paste zone is illustrated as a relatively dense, uniform zone in FIGURE I for purposes of this discussion. While the fully reacted cement paste in the bulk density zone 22 may be relatively dense, the reacted cement paste immediately adjacent the steel reinforcement surface 16 has reduced density, for reasons previously discussed. The reduced density zone may be, for example, 20-50 microns in thickness and may form a relatively porous zone 24 immediately adjacent the steel reinforcement surface 16. As schematically shown immediately below the steel reinforcement and cement paste illustration of FIGURE 2, and in registration and there with, is a graphical schematic illustration of the tensile strength of the materials present in the figure. As shown in FIGURE 2, the tensile strength of the steel reinforcement is relatively high in comparison to the tensile strength 28 of the bulk density cement paste. In general, cement and concrete have a tensile strength which is significantly lower than its compressive strength, and significantly lower than that of the steel reinforcement. In fact, this is the principal reason for providing steel or other reinforcement in concrete. However, the tensile strength of the relatively porous interface between the bulk density cement paste and the steel reinforcement surface is even lower in tensile strength than the fully reacted bulk cement paste 22. This relatively weak, porous interface zone 24 is accordingly a "weak link" between the cured concrete mass and the steel reinforcement.
In addition, the porosity of the interface promotes corrosion by permitting contact with corrosioninducing chloride ions and oxidizing agents, and adversely affects the environmental durability of the concrete, causing accelerated deterioration. In conventional concrete, the porous interface zones around each of the inclusions, including the steel reinforcement and the aggregate particles, form an interconnected network which can foster the percolation of chloride ions through the concrete cover to the steel reinforcement [Y.F. Houst, et al., "Influence of aggregate concentration on the diffusion of C02 and 02", Interfaces in Cementitious Composites, ed. by J. Maso (E and FN Spon, London, 1992), 279-288]. When the porous interface zones interconnect as a result of the proximity of the aggregate surfaces present in conventional concretes, the concrete is "fully percolated" and can have up to two orders of magnitude greater permeability than the bulk cement paste from which it is made [J.F. Young, "A Review of the Pore Structure of Cement Paste and Concrete and Its Influence on Permeability", ill Permeability of Concrete, ed. by D. Whiting and A. Walitt, ACI SP- 108 (American Concrete Institute, Detroit, 1988); C.L. Page and V.T. Ngala, in Proceedings of Conference on Chloride Diffusivity in Concrete, RILEM, France (1995), as well as reduced elastic modulus [R.W. Zimmerman, et al., Cem. Con. Res. 16, 239 (1986); A. Ulrik Nilsen and P. J.M. Monteiro, Concrete: A Three Phase Material, Cem. and Cone. Res. 23, 147-151 (1993); Cohen, et al., "The Role of Silica Fume in Mortar: Transition Zone Versus Bulk Paste Modification", Cem. and Cone. Res., 24, 95-98 (1994)]. This "fully percolated porosity" of the interconnected interfacial zones permits more rapid transport of chloride ions through the concrete, as well as directly along the entire surface of the steel reinforcement, which can cause accelerated corrosion. The interfacial zone weakness and porosity adjacent the steel reinforcement can be exacerbated by inhomogeneities which occur during pouring of the reinforced concrete, such as caused by component settling in the concrete mix or structure before hardening. In this regard, relatively heavy aggregate and cement particles can settle in freshly poured concrete, to displace free water upwardly where it is trapped at the undersurfaces of aggregate and reinforcement [K.H. Khayat, "Use Of Viscosity-Modifying Admixture To Reduce
TopBar Effect Of Anchored Bars Cast With Fluid Concrete", ACI Materials Journal, pp. 158-167 (1998)]. This further increases interface porosity, and can even cause a separation between the lower surfaces of the reinforcement and the concrete [S.P. Shah, et al., "Modeling Of Constitutive Relationship Of Steel Fiber-Concrete Interface", Mechanics Of Geomaterial Interfaces (eds. A. P. S. Selvadurai, et al.) Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 227-255].
In addition, the porous zones adjacent the steel surface and other inclusions in the concrete provide a pathway for chloride ions and other materials through the concrete composite. In this regard, schematically illustrated in FIGURE 3 is a fully permeated conventional concrete mass illustrating a chloride percolation path to, and along, the steel reinforcement surface of an embedded reinforcing bar 30. The scale of FIGURE 3 is substantially less than that of FIGURES 1 and 2. As shown in FIGURE 3, because the inclusions such as aggregate pieces 32 and sand particles (not shown) generally all have relatively porous interfacial zones, and because at relatively high loadings of sand and aggregate in conventional concrete, the surfaces of the sand and aggregate particles are closely spaced together. The porous interfacial zones of each of the aggregate particles tend to become connected, thereby forming a pathway through the concrete which includes the porous interfacial zone 34 at the steel reinforcement surface. Accordingly, chloride ions and other materials can permeate through the concrete at a rate much faster than the permeation rate through bulk cement paste. In one example of the proposed interfaces, a corrosion-resistant layer or alloy is provided at the steel reinforcement surface, between the steel and the cement-reactive layer, to further protect the steel from corrosion. A passivating, corrosion-resisting layer such as an iron suicide surface layer may be readily applied to steel reinforcement such as "rebar", beams, wire or mesh, by reaction with silicon at elevated temperatures in the presence of chlorides ("Ihrigizing"). Other materials, such as chromium, boron/borides, nickel, stainless steel, titanium, aluminum, etc. may also be vapor-reacted and/or thermally sprayed onto the steel reinforcement to serve as a very thin, hard, adherent protective layer which is inexpensively applied by plasma, HVOF or combustion thermal spraying onto the surface of the steel reinforcement. The corrosion-resistant layer, such as an iron suicide, iron-titanium, or ferrochrome layer, may be relatively thin, on the order of 0.1 to 100 microns. Silicon, chromium and titanium readily alloy with iron, with Gibbs Free Energy release, so that the iron suicide or other alloy layer is integral with the steel reinforcement, and mechanically much stronger than the bulk cement paste. The ferrosilicon or other intermetallic alloy or silicon coating is thermodynamically less reactive than the untreated steel surface to oxidation in the high pH cement paste environment of the concrete, and/or relatively more passivated with respect to catalytic oxidation in the presence of chloride ion. The corrosion-passivating layer may be very thin, but should be capable of strong chemical (not just mechanical) bonding to a cement- reactive layer, as will be further described. It is desirable to provide a continuous layer of the alloyed diffused or otherwise chemically passivated surface layer over the steel reinforcing member. In this regard, as indicated, it may be useful to subject the surface to vapor-phase chemical reaction and diffusion, such as by treatment with SiCl4, BC13, silanes, boron hydrides, titanium chloride (in a reducing environment) or mixtures thereof, at an elevated temperature (e.g., about 400-1300° C. see, e.g., U.S. Patent Nos. 5,064,691 and 5,089,061), to insure surface reaction. The diffused or alloyed surface layer containing B, Si, Ti, Cr or mixtures thereof may be very thin, e.g., 0.5 + 15 microns, but should best be continuous. The corrosion passivating layer may be applied during forging or as the steel reinforcement is exiting the rolling mill where it is manufactured, while it is still heated to a rolling/forging temperature of 800-1200° C. Conventional plasma spraying, particularly if applied to a heated reinforcing steel surface, may produce a dense, thin surface zone which at least partially interdiffuses with the steel surface. Fine silicon, boron, titanium, chromium or nickel powders or compounds can be heated to vaporization temperature in a plasma gun system and applied to a hot steel reinforcing bar so that these materials diffuse at the steel surface to form a passivated integral surface layer. High temperature electric arc plasma spraying can also provide high velocity particles and may also heat the steel surface momentarily to cause binding and interdiffusion. High velocity oxygen flame (HVOF) plasma spraying of passivating materials such as silicon or ferrosilicon may also produce a dense surface layer, particularly in view of the ultrahigh velocity of the sprayed particles, which melt and interact upon impacting of the particles at the surface, where the kinetic energy is converted to thermal energy in a relatively instantaneous manner. A reducing atmosphere, and particularly a sputtering of the hot steel surface is best for chemical bonding and diffusion. In this regard, a particularly useful method for applying a passivating alloy surface which is continuous, even on a microscopic basis, is by partially transferred arc and/or rf/plasma arc plasma coating. In conventional plasma spraying and other arc-based thermal sprayed processes, the electric heating arc is transferred internally to the accelerating gun nozzle. In partially transferred arc plasma spraying, the steel surface to be coated with the alloy and/or passivating material is biased with a negative voltage in respect to a positive current source at the interior of the nozzle of the plasma spray device. The positive electrode may be the regular cathode of the plasma spray gun, or may be a separate electrode located slightly downstream of the plasma gun. In addition to the heating current between the internal cathode and internally electrode of the plasma spray gun, a plasma column is provided between the plasma gun and the steel surface which is being coated, which conducts current between the reinforcing steel surface and the plasma gun cathode. Steel reinforcement may form a native oxide surface (e.g., FeO) during its manufacture in a rolling mill, which is removed by the
"sputtering" effect of a transferred arc or rf plasma. The plasma functions to ionize and clean oxides and other electronegative components on the surface of the steel, so that they are removed, and to attract ionized metals or silicon or positively charged silicon particles or other passivating materials, which become metallurgically bonded to the cleaned steel surface to form an impervious passivating layer. If, the plasma is a reducing plasma (e.g., contains hydrogen), this may also aid in the formation of a metallurgical bond. As described in U.S. Patent 4,902,870, a radio frequency plasma can be provided to assist maintenance of the arc between the plasma gun and the steel substrate to be coated and alloyed with a passivating material. Also applied to the steel reinforcement is an outer layer of an inorganic ceramic or glass, such as an alkaline earth silicate, (e.g., calcium silicate), aluminate, a phosphate, and/or a silica or alumina layer, which is also integrally bonded to the iron suicide layer, and which is reactive with the hydraulic cement paste. It is also stronger than the bulk cement paste, and has a relatively strong bond to the steel reinforcement such that the steel-ceramic composite is itself stronger than the bulk cement paste. In this regard, thermal spraying is conventionally used for applying strongly bonded ceramic and metal layers for mechanically demanding applications such as turbine blades, so the strength and bonding capabilities of thermal spray systems are more than adequate for reinforced concrete bonding needs. The composition of the inorganic ceramic or glass layer, such as a cementitious calcium silicate layer, may be primarily in the mono- to di-silicate range (e.g., powdered blast furnace or other slag, fly ash, burned shale ash or other such material, which is compatible with and participates in and participates in cement hydration reactions and makes an inexpensive raw material source), so that it remains stable in unhydrated form for storage of the reinforcing bars prior to use. As indicated, powdered silica and/or alumina may also be used as a reactive interface material. The calcium silicate layer may also be relatively thin, but should desirably be sufficiently thick that it does not become fully hydrated throughout its thickness during the hydration of concrete. Because the cores of conventional Portland cement particles over 50-100 microns in size may remain incompletely hydrated in conventional concrete after decades, a thickness of 50-100 microns of a less reactive lower calcium silicate layer should be more than adequate. Such a vitreous or ceramic layer may also be quite mechanically strong compared to the cement paste, and is integrally bonded to the iron suicide, iron titanide or other iron-passivating layer. The calcium silicate layer may also be applied by relatively inexpensive high-temperature plasma, HVOF or combustion thermal spraying. The thin, refractory, adherent, unitary, inorganic layers may readily be applied during steel rebar manufacture. There are some adhesion and efficiency advantages in high-speed application of the layers in the rolling mill before the steel reinforcement bars have completely cooled.
The outer surface of the calcium silicate layer may preferably be applied with a somewhat greater degree of open porosity (e.g., 5-20%) than the interior layer (e.g., 015% porosity) to further assist the formation of a functionally graded interface with the bulk cement matrix. Because of the relatively low thermal spray temperatures required for calcium silicate application, the low cost of the materials (e.g., fly ash or blast furnace slag) and the thinness of the layers, the cost of application is relatively low. As indicated earlier, an adhesion-promoting layer may be utilized to promote chemical bonding of the metallic steel or steel alloy surface with the ceramic vitreous coating. An extremely thin layer of boron or silicon oxide groups (such as a mono layer or surface silanol groups) may be formed at the surface of the iron suicide and/or boride layer formed at the surface of the reinforcing steel, which can chemically bond with the thermally applied glass or ceramic layer. Similarly, a very thin layer of chromium, titanium or nickel oxide may form an adhesion-promoting layer, particularly if in a partially-oxidized metallic, or lower oxidation state.
FIGURE 4 illustrates a thermal spray system 40 for applying corrosion resistant and hydraulically reactive layers on steel reinforcing bar stock as produced by a conventional rolling mill. As shown in FIGURE 4, a finished steel reinforcing bar 42 from a rolling mill 44 is continuously transported through a thermal spray station 46. The reinforcing bar (or "rebar") stock may still be at elevated temperature such as 500- 1200° C. from its manufacture. The thermal spray station 46 comprises a thermal spray station 48 for applying a passivating corrosion-resistant layer such as a silicon or ferrosilicon layer 49, and thermal spray station 50 for applying a hydraulically reactive ceramic material layer 51 on the corrosion-resistant layer 49. The thermal spray station 48 desirably comprises at least three thermal spray guns spaced radially around the reinforcing bar, so that the entire surface of the bar is coated on a continuous basis as it is conducted through the thermal spray station. Because the steel bar may form a native oxide (such as FeO) on its surface during its manufacture in the rolling mill, the thermal spray may also desirably be operated with a reducing atmosphere. Preferably, the thermal spray guns function to "sputter-clean" the reinforcing bar surface as the corrosion-resistant layer 49 and/or diffusion is applied. In applying the ferrosilicon layer, a relatively fine silicon or ferrosilicon powders are preferably used, with relatively high plasma operating temperatures, so that at least a portion of the silicon or ferrosilicon is vaporized, for subsequent condensation on this heated steel reinforcing bar surface, to provide a continuous layer. The silicon/feπo silicon will quickly diffuse/alloy with the steel rebar at its elevated temperature. An adhesion-promoting layer may be applied between the silicon/ferrosilicon layer. A fine aqueous spray of a chromium, nickel or titanium oxide-based solution or slurry may be directly applied to the hot steel surface, which will promote fusion and bonding at the elevated processing temperatures (e.g., 400- 1200° C.) with the subsequently applied ceramic or vitreous layer. The thermal spray station for the ceramic layer application may also desirably be a low-cost combustion system or HVOF system.
The relative position of thermally applied layers is shown in cross-section in FIGURES 5 and 6.
FIGURE 7 is a schematic illustration of a freshly poured aqueous cement slurry at the surface of a thermally sprayed steel reinforcing bar embedded in the cement slurry. As illustrated in FIGURE 7, the steel reinforcing bar 72 has an adherent, thin, thermally sprayed ferrosilicon or silicon layer 74 at its surface, which is substantially more passive with respect to both rusting, and chloride ioncatalyzed oxidation, than the bulk steel of the reinforcing bar 72. Silicon can be used to produce a surface which is relatively inert to oxidation catalyzed by the chloride ion. The silicon readily alloys with and diffuses into iron at moderately elevated temperatures, which are present immediately after manufacture of the rebar in a steel rolling mill, and/or which can be briefly applied to the surface of the reinforcing bar without damaging the internal metallo graphic structure, to form a variety of ferrosilicon compounds or solid solutions. A passivating silicon alloy layer can be provided by exposure to silicon-containing gases such as SiC14 at elevated temperatures (see, e.g., U.S. Patents 3,433,253 and 5,200,145). Pure silicon powder can also be thermally sprayed to produce a relatively inert layer of silicon and/or ferrosilicon alloy. However, for economic reasons (because SIC 14 gas treatment and pure silicon powder is relatively expensive), industrial ferrosilicon can also be used to provide a surface which is relatively passivated with respect to oxidation under chloridecatalyzed conditions. Feπosilicon can be produced at very low expense, and provided in powdered form for thermal spray volitalization and/or application to the surface of the steel reinforcement to produce an intimately bonded, alloyed layer at the surface. Similarly, boride materials may be provided and plasma-vaporized at lower expense than boron hydride materials.
The corrosion-resistant feπosilicon layer 72 has an intimately adherent cementitious layer 74, which is thermally sprayed thereon and bonded thereto. The illustrated cementitious layer may be an industrial-grade calcium silicate, such as the primarily dicalcium silicate materials of blast furnace slag waste products. The thermally-applied cementitious layer may desirably be graded, either continuously, or discreetly, so that it is more dense and/or more unreactive in the high pH environment of a cement mix, immediately adjacent the feπosilicon layer 74. Conversely, the layer 76 may be more porous and/or more hydraulically reactive at the exterior surface 78 facing the aqueous cement mix. For example, a calcium silicate powder which crystallizes to form a relatively inert material such as wollastonite, may be applied using HVOF thermal spraying to produce a very dense, relatively crystalline layer which strongly adheres to the feπosilicon or silicon surface 74. An external layer of predominantly dicalcium. silicate, such as fly ash or blast furnace slag, may be applied over the calcium silicate layer, using a lower velocity HVOF or plasma spray gun, to produce and external layer which is relatively more hydraulically reactive in the aqueous high pH environment of the cement mix. By controlling the thickness of the external, more reactive layer, the amount of reaction may be precisely controlled, to ensure that an adherent, dense, protective inorganic oxide layer remains adjacent the steel surface to contribute to the protection of the underlying steel reinforcement. An extremely thin adhesion-promoting layer (not shown), for example of chromium oxide, titanium dioxide or lower oxide, or nickel oxide may be present between the feπosilicon surface of the steel bar, and the cementitious calcium silicate layer 76.
As indicated in FIGURE 7, the external surface 78 of the thermally sprayed reactive layer 76 need not to be completely smooth, and may also have some degree of porosity, which may permit a denser aggregation of cement particles adjacent the surface. In any event, the physical density of the calcium silicate layer 76 at the external surface should best be at least 75 percent solid (less than 25% porosity), as compared to a lower concentration of cement particles in the cement mix, and accordingly, the unreacted cement particles 82 of the freshly poured aqueous cement slurry may form a relatively dense surface reaction zone 80 together with the thermally sprayed reactive layer 76. The unreacted cement particles in the water matrix 84 away from the immediate surface of the zone 80 may be in a zone 86 having the conventional bulk cement packing density.
The thermal spray guns may also apply relatively inert fibers, such as alumina fibers or zirconiabased high-pH-stable cement fibers with the cementitious layers. These fibers may be relatively small in diameter (e.g., 2-25 microns) and length (e.g., 25-200 microns), but can considerably strengthen the hydrated cement layer which is formed around the steel reinforcement. The volume of reinforcing fibers may desirably be in the range of 2-25 percent of the volume of the cementitious thermally sprayed layer 76.
Upon hydration, the ceramic external layer 76 of the treated steel reinforcement presents a reactive surface which partially hydrates with the bulk cement paste. It preferably does not completely hydrate, however, because it is thicker and less reactive than the cement particles, which themselves may not fully hydrate. A strongly adherent, unhydrated layer of the calcium silicate is accordingly retained on the steel surface. The high density, unhydrated calcium silicate at the steel surface, and the graded participation of the surface in the cement hydration reaction, inhibits the formation of a porous weak interface zone. Coπosion-causing chloride percolation along the steel surface is therefor restricted, because there is no weak, porous zone adjacent the steel surface. Instead, a dense, relatively impermeable reaction zone is created which is bonded to the steel surface, and efficiently transmits mechanical forces without being a "weak link". The optional non-rusting ferrosilicon, ferrotitanium or other corrosion-passivated layer is retained as a further protection for the reinforcing steel:
The net result is a dense interface, adherently chemically bonded to the steel surface, which is thereby protected from corrosion, and which transmits mechanical forces between the steel reinforcement and the bulk cement matrix. The interface is desirably stronger than the bulk cement paste. The interface is not porous, and does not promote the percolation of water or corrosioninducing chloride ions through the cured concrete or along the surface of the steel reinforcement. Because the interface integrally bonds the steel reinforcement to the bulk cement matrix with an adhesion strength desirably at least equal to the strength of the cement matrix, the mechanical properties of the reinforced concrete are maximized, rather than minimized by a porous interface zone. Upon hydration or partial hydration, the reactive calcium silicate layer 76 interacts with the cement particles to prevent the formation of a relatively porous and weak interfacial zone between the steel reinforcement and the bulk cement paste. In this regard, schematically illustrated in Figure 8 is a cured, adherent cement layer at a dense, non coπoding steel reinforcement surface. As illustrated, upon curing or partial curing of the cement particles in the cement mix, the steel reinforcement 72 still retains its adherent feπosilicon layer 74 which passivates the iron against chloride-catalyzed oxidation, and a portion of the calcium silicate layer 76, which is itself strongly adherent to the feπosilicon layer 74 by virtue of the thermal spray processing of its application. The presence of silicon, titanium or other similar strong matrix oxide forming elements in the coπosion-passivating layer facilitates the formation of a strong, adherent chemical bond therebetween. However, the exterior surface of the calcium silicate layer 76 has reacted by hydration with the cement mix to form a relatively dense, strong adherent surface reaction zone 88 which may be denser and stronger than the fully hardened cement paste 90 which is formed at the bulk density of the original cement mix. The tensile strength of the composite structure is schematically shown in the graph below the structure illustrated in Figure 8, and in registration therewith. As indicated, the tensile strength of the steel reinforcement is relatively high, and the ferrosilicon, ferrochrome or ferrotitanium layer 74 is generally relatively lower in view of its increased brittleness. Similarly, the tensile strength of the unreacted calcium silicate layer 76 is relatively lower than that of the silicon, feπotitanium, feπochrome or feπosilicon layer 74, but still substantially higher than the bulk density cement paste. The surface reaction zone (like the zones immediately suπounding the individual cement particles) is denser and stronger in the direction of the hydration reaction adjacent the unreacted surface zone, and tapers toward the tensile strength of the bulk density cement paste. Accordingly, the composite structure of Figure 8 does not produce a "weak link" of porosity adjacent the steel reinforcement. Rather, a functionally graded interface is produced which has a gradient of properties which gradually transitions to that of the bulk density cement paste 90. In addition, it will be noted that the feπosilicon layer 74 and the partially unreacted calcium silicate layer 76 physically limit the access of chloride ion and oxygen to the iron surface, thereby restricting oxidation. Moreover, there is no porous zone immediately adjacent the steel reinforcement surface for the passage of coπoding environments along the reinforcement surface.
As indicated, the functional layers may be applied by thermal spraying, which is an economical technology for applying thin, adherent layers of refractory materials. In such thermal spraying, very small molten particles (e.g., 10-50 microns) and vaporized portions of the material to be applied are accelerated by combustion gases or an electric arc plasma, followed by deposition or impacting onto the steel reinforcement surface. For the metallic passivation layer, the steel surface may be heated so that the passivating components can diffuse into the steel surface to form an integrally-passivated layer. For the application of cementitiously-reactive ceramics, solidification typically occurs at very rapid rates, so that the as-sprayed deposit is ultra-fine grained. This fast cooling should stabilize calcium silicates in the high-density gamma crystalline form desirable for use in hydraulic cements.
Thermal spray application of the functional layers is a relatively inexpensive and efficient method for integrally applying the functional layers to the reinforcing steel. A wide range of materials has been successfully plasma-sprayed for a variety of applications, including gas turbine components having complex geometries [M.R. Jackson, et al, "Production of Metallurgical Structures by Rapid Solidification Plasma Deposition", J Metals, 33, Nov. 1981, 23-27; S. Sampath and H.Herman, J. Metals, 45(7) (1993) 42; R. Tiwari, et al., "Plasma Spray Consolidation of High Temperature Composites", Mat. Sci. and Eng. A144 (1991) 127-131; M. Moss, Acta Met., 16 (1968) 321 ; V. Wilms, Ph.D.Thesis, SUNY Stony Brook (1978); K.D. Krishnanand and R.W. Cahn, Rapidly Quenched Metals, Ed. N.J. Grant and B.C. Giessen, pp. 67-75, MIT Press, Cambridge, 1976; S. Sampath and S.F. Wayne, "Micro structure and Properties of Plasma Sprayed Mo-Mo2C Composites", J Thermal Spray Tech. Vol.3, No.3 (1994) 282; S. Sampath, R.A. Neiser, H. Herman, J.P. Kirkland and W.T. Elam, "A Structural Investigation of a Plasma Sprayed Ni-Cr based Alloy Coating", J Mater. Res., Vol.8,
No. 1,(1993), 78 as referenced in "Thermal Spray Coatings", H. Herman and S. Sampath, The Thermal Spray Laboratory, Department of Materials Science and Engineering, State University of New York, Stony Brook, NY 11794-2275] and medical implants. The temperature of a plasma may be as high as 15,000° C. for a typical dc plasma torch, but the application of calcium silicate does not require such high temperatures. Other thermal spray processes such as High Velocity Oxy-Fuel Spraying (HVOF), in which a high temperature oxygen-fuel flame undergoes free-expansion from the torch nozzle, to accelerate the particles to a high velocity (e.g., over Mach 3) may be used to produce dense, adherent coatings. In standard combustion spraying, which is by far the least expensive process, (which may be suitable for calcium silicate layers), a fuel-air flame is used. In plasma spray processes, which can be significantly hotter, an electric arc rather than combustion creates the extremely hot thermal zone. In all of the thermal spray processes, the calcium silicate feedstock or other metallic or ceramic powder is injected into either the rear of the torch or into the plasma or other heated high velocity stream, and the melted particles are accelerated toward the steel surface. Upon impact, the particles convert kinetic to thermal energy, and bond to the surface to produce a dense, strongly adherent coating. Deposition rates of, for example, 2-20 kg/hr per nozzle, with excellent adherence, may be provided onto steel reinforcement bars exiting a rolling mill at about 200-400° C. in the processing zone. Porosity should desirably be controlled in the application of the calcium silicate layers, for example in the range of from about 2-25 percent porosity (95-98 percent solid calcium silicate or calcium silicate plus reinforcing fibers). Generally, as particle velocity increases, the porosity decreases. Similarly, the smaller the particle size, the lower the porosity for typical thermal spray systems
Example I Three steel reinforcing bars (or dowels) without ribs or surface deformations, nominally 1/2 inch in diameter and 2 feet long, are cleaned of rust and surface oxidation by sand blasting. All bars receive the same sand blasting treatment. One of the bars is placed on a rotating mandrel and coated with a very thin layer of silicon using a high temperature helium plasma Praxair/Miller Thermal SG-100 Plasma Spray System, so that substantially the entire surface of the bar is coated with the silicon layer. The SG- 100 plasma spray gun uses a non-transfeπed dc plasma torch configuration with powers up to 100 kW (here, about 40 kW). The basic design of the plasma gun consists of two electrodes: a cone-shaped cathode inside a cylindrical anode, which forms a nozzle. Gases (e.g. argon, hydrogen, helium) can flow through the space between the electrodes, where they are ionized to form a plasma. Typically, the primary gas is argon (100 scfh) and the secondary gas is helium (60 scfh). The powder carrier gas is typically argon (15 scfh). A four hole gas ring is utilized to induce vortex flow in the electrode.
Powders injected into the plasma are accelerated and melted by its high temperature. The molten droplets (i.e. splats) are propelled onto the substrate where they solidify and accumulate to form a well-bonded coating.
The first bar (Bar 1) was placed on a rotating mandrel, and silicon was applied by plasma spray along its outer surface. Silicon was applied to the second bar (Bar 2) by plasma spray along a longitudinal strip along the bar length, without mandrel rotation. The silicon is applied at a low feed rate, in order to heat the bar and provide an opportunity for some diffusion of the silicon into the surface of the bars. The bars are not preheated, so diffusion was limited, and the silicon formed a surface layer. All three bards were subsequently coated with ground blast furnace slag using the same helium plasma gun. The third bar (Bar 3) was accordingly directly coated by plasma spray of ground blast furnace slag to the sand blasted surface of the steel reinforcing bar, without an intermediate silicon layer.
The ground granulated blast furnace slag (GGBFS) used was a product commercially available under the tradename GranCem from Holnam, Inc., 6211 Ann Arbor Road, Dundee, Michigan 48131. It was thermally sprayed using the plasma spray gun operated at about 40 kW. The GGBFS had the following specifications:
Figure imgf000024_0001
The GGBFS is intended for use in admixture with portland cement and is accordingly compatible therewith. The GranCem cement is made to meet the requirements of ASTM C 989 (equivalent AASHTO specification is M 302), which lists three grades of GGBF slag: Grade 80, Grade 100 and Grade 120. Grade 100 was utilized in the present example. The sample used has the following characteristics according to the Chicago Grinding Facility of Holnam, Inc.: SLAG ACTIVITY INDEX SPECIFICATIONS MININUM
Figure imgf000024_0002
SLAG ACTIVITY INDEX
Figure imgf000025_0001
SLAG-REFERENCE CEMENT MORTAR PERFORMANCE
Compressive Strength at 7d 26.31 MPa Compressive Strength at 28d 42.85 MPa
REFERENCE CEMENT MORTAR PERFORMANCE*
Compressive Strength at 7d 29.13 MPa
Compressive Strength at 28d 37.32 MPa
* Individual test [_] or Average of 5 tests [X] SLAG CHEMICAL DATA
Specifications
Sulfur content (S-2) 1.06 (ASTM C 114) 2.5% Max. Sulfate ion reported at S03 0.27 (ASTM C 114) 4.0% Max.
OTHER SLAG DATA
Specifications
Blaine Fineness (mΛ2/kg) 565 (ASTM C204 N/A
Retained on 325 mesh
(45 micron) 2.40% (ASTM C430) 20% Max
Air content of slag mortar 2.87% (ASTM C 185) 12% Max
Slag density (gm/cmΛ3) 2.74 (ASTM C 188) N/A
Reference Portland Cement Data (ASTM C 150)
Specifications
Blaine Fineness 380 (ASTM C204) 200 m2/kg min
Total Alkalies
(Na20 + 0.658 K2O) 0.8 (ASTM C 114) 0.6-0.9%
The adherence of the layers applied to Bars I and 2 was tested by a high speed abrasive wheel (Dremel at 30,000 rpm) and found to be hard and adherent. FIGURE 9 is a photomicrograph of Bar 3, showing an abraded surface of the steel about 3 min wide, and the surface texture of the applied GGBFS. FIGURE 10 is similarly a photomicrograph of Bar 1, showing the abraded steel about 3 min wide, and the surface texture of the GGBFS layer. The intermediate silicon layer can also be seen In FIGURE 10.
Bars 1, 2 and 3, and an uncoated steel reinforcing bar, were cast in (Sakrete brand) mortar mix, which appear to be "lean" in cement. The bars will be examined after the mortar mix cures.
While the present invention has been described with respect to particular embodiments of apparatus and methods, it will be appreciated that various modifications and adaptations may be made based on the present disclosure and are intended to be within the scope of the accompanying claims.

Claims

WHAT IS CLAIMED IS:
1. A steel reinforcement for concrete which has the capability of forming an adherent bond with a cement matrix, comprising a steel reinforcement substrate, and a thermally sprayed, adherent, cementitiously reactive layer adherently applied to said substrate.
2. A steel reinforcement in accordance with Claim I wherein the steel reinforcement has a corrosion-passivated metallic surface adherently bonded to said reactive layer.
3. A steel reinforcement in accordance with Claim I wherein the reactive layer is calcium aluminate, calcium phosphate/apatite, or calcium silicate which can react with hydraulic cement.
4. A steel reinforcement in accordance with Claim I further including an adherence-promoting layer to increase the adherence between the steel reinforcement surface and the thermally sprayed cement-reactive layer.
5. A steel reinforcement in accordance with Claim 4 wherein the adhesionpromoting layer comprises boron, silicon, chromium, titanium, nickel and/or their lower oxides.
6. A steel reinforcement in accordance with Claim 1 further including a metallic coπosion-resistant layer, which is integrally alloyed with or diffused in the steel reinforcement surface, and interposed and bonded between the steel and the cementitious hydraulically reactive bonding layer.
7. A steel reinforcement in accordance with Claim I wherein the metallic corrosion-reducing layer comprises the adhesion-promoting layer.
8. A method for manufacturing coπosion-resistant concrete having an interface between the bulk cement matrix and the steel reinforcement which is at least as strong as the cement paste of the bulk cement, comprising the steps of providing a steel reinforcement, then-nally applying a cementitious surface coating on the surface of said steel reinforcement, placing the coated steel reinforcement in an aqueous concrete slurry, and curing the concrete slurry in contact with the coating to provide a steel -reinforced concrete.
9. A method in accordance with Claim 4 wherein said layer comprises thermally sprayed blast furnace slag, fly ash and/or pulverized burned oil shale, and wherein a coπosion-passivated metallic layer is provided at the interface between the steel reinforcement and the cementitious surface coating.
PCT/US2000/041485 1999-10-27 2000-10-24 Reinforced concrete systems WO2001031136A2 (en)

Priority Applications (2)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
AU29174/01A AU2917401A (en) 1999-10-27 2000-10-24 Reinforced concrete systems
US10/125,969 US6929865B2 (en) 2000-10-24 2002-04-19 Steel reinforced concrete systems

Applications Claiming Priority (2)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
US16183899P 1999-10-27 1999-10-27
US60/161,838 1999-10-27

Publications (2)

Publication Number Publication Date
WO2001031136A2 true WO2001031136A2 (en) 2001-05-03
WO2001031136A3 WO2001031136A3 (en) 2002-01-24

Family

ID=22582969

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
PCT/US2000/041485 WO2001031136A2 (en) 1999-10-27 2000-10-24 Reinforced concrete systems

Country Status (2)

Country Link
AU (1) AU2917401A (en)
WO (1) WO2001031136A2 (en)

Cited By (2)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
US6929865B2 (en) * 2000-10-24 2005-08-16 James J. Myrick Steel reinforced concrete systems
CN109824312A (en) * 2019-03-21 2019-05-31 徐州工程学院 A kind of preparation method improving Marine Reinforced Concrete Structures corrosion resistance of chloride ion ability

Citations (3)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
US3954482A (en) * 1973-05-24 1976-05-04 High Performance Coatings, Inc. Corrosion resistant coating material and method
US4725491A (en) * 1986-07-09 1988-02-16 Solomon Goldfein Reinforced cement products with improved mechanical properties and creep resistance
US5100738A (en) * 1990-07-12 1992-03-31 Rebar Couplerbox, Inc. Reinforced concrete containing coated steel reinforcing member

Patent Citations (3)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
US3954482A (en) * 1973-05-24 1976-05-04 High Performance Coatings, Inc. Corrosion resistant coating material and method
US4725491A (en) * 1986-07-09 1988-02-16 Solomon Goldfein Reinforced cement products with improved mechanical properties and creep resistance
US5100738A (en) * 1990-07-12 1992-03-31 Rebar Couplerbox, Inc. Reinforced concrete containing coated steel reinforcing member

Cited By (3)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
US6929865B2 (en) * 2000-10-24 2005-08-16 James J. Myrick Steel reinforced concrete systems
CN109824312A (en) * 2019-03-21 2019-05-31 徐州工程学院 A kind of preparation method improving Marine Reinforced Concrete Structures corrosion resistance of chloride ion ability
CN109824312B (en) * 2019-03-21 2021-07-27 徐州工程学院 Preparation method for improving chlorine ion erosion resistance of marine reinforced concrete

Also Published As

Publication number Publication date
WO2001031136A3 (en) 2002-01-24
AU2917401A (en) 2001-05-08

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
US6929865B2 (en) Steel reinforced concrete systems
Nematollahi et al. Micromechanics-based investigation of a sustainable ambient temperature cured one-part strain hardening geopolymer composite
Yang et al. Characteristics and durability test of magnesium phosphate cement-based material for rapid repair of concrete
Ma et al. Review and outlook on durability of engineered cementitious composite (ECC)
Al-Osta Exploitation of ultrahigh-performance fibre-reinforced concrete for the strengthening of concrete structural members
Mathur et al. Influence of wollastonite on mechanical properties of concrete
Liu et al. Use of silica fume and GGBS to improve frost resistance of ECC with high-volume fly ash
Sharma et al. Micro fiber reinforced cement paste and mortar overlays-A review
Sharkawi et al. Efficiency of geopolymer vs. high-strength grout as repairing material for reinforced cementitious elements
Wang et al. Research progress on interfacial bonding between magnesium phosphate cement and steel: A review
Bartos Glassfibre reinforced concrete: a review
Yoo et al. Highly ductile ultra-rapid-hardening mortar containing oxidized polyethylene fibers
Ghazy et al. Durability performance of geopolymer ferrocement panels prepared by different alkaline activators
Wu et al. Trade-off between strength and ductility of random discontinuous fiber reinforced cementitious composites
WO2001031136A2 (en) Reinforced concrete systems
Akhnoukh Application of supplementary cementitious materials in precast concrete industry
Karthikeyan et al. High strength concrete using Ultra-fine TiO2 and Basalt fiber-A study on Mechanical and Durability characteristics
Mohammed Mechanical properties of ultra high strength fiber reinforced concrete
JP3721005B2 (en) Bridge with high-strength lightweight concrete slab
Cui et al. Bond strength of steel bar and plain or fibre reinforced geopolymer concrete
Rajendran Corrosion assessment of ferrocement element with nanogeopolymer for marine application
Raidyarto et al. Flowability of self-compacting concrete containing marine materials and steel fiber
Grünewald et al. Properties of fibre reinforced SCC
Soong et al. The potential of geopolymer in development of green coating materials: A review
Porkodi et al. Improvement of corrosion resistance of concrete element by using nanotechnology

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
AK Designated states

Kind code of ref document: A2

Designated state(s): AE AG AL AM AT AU AZ BA BB BG BR BY BZ CA CH CN CR CU CZ DE DK DM DZ EE ES FI GB GD GE GH GM HR HU ID IL IN IS JP KE KG KP KR KZ LC LK LR LS LT LU LV MA MD MG MK MN MW MX MZ NO NZ PL PT RO RU SD SE SG SI SK SL TJ TM TR TT TZ UA UG US UZ VN YU ZA ZW

AL Designated countries for regional patents

Kind code of ref document: A2

Designated state(s): GH GM KE LS MW MZ SD SL SZ TZ UG ZW AM AZ BY KG KZ MD RU TJ TM AT BE CH CY DE DK ES FI FR GB GR IE IT LU MC NL PT SE BF BJ CF CG CI CM GA GN GW ML MR NE SN TD TG

121 Ep: the epo has been informed by wipo that ep was designated in this application
DFPE Request for preliminary examination filed prior to expiration of 19th month from priority date (pct application filed before 20040101)
AK Designated states

Kind code of ref document: A3

Designated state(s): AE AG AL AM AT AU AZ BA BB BG BR BY BZ CA CH CN CR CU CZ DE DK DM DZ EE ES FI GB GD GE GH GM HR HU ID IL IN IS JP KE KG KP KR KZ LC LK LR LS LT LU LV MA MD MG MK MN MW MX MZ NO NZ PL PT RO RU SD SE SG SI SK SL TJ TM TR TT TZ UA UG US UZ VN YU ZA ZW

AL Designated countries for regional patents

Kind code of ref document: A3

Designated state(s): GH GM KE LS MW MZ SD SL SZ TZ UG ZW AM AZ BY KG KZ MD RU TJ TM AT BE CH CY DE DK ES FI FR GB GR IE IT LU MC NL PT SE BF BJ CF CG CI CM GA GN GW ML MR NE SN TD TG

WWE Wipo information: entry into national phase

Ref document number: 10125969

Country of ref document: US

REG Reference to national code

Ref country code: DE

Ref legal event code: 8642

122 Ep: pct application non-entry in european phase
NENP Non-entry into the national phase in:

Ref country code: JP