New York Send-Off | The Unicorn Next Door

DESCRIPTIONMarcus Yam/The New York Times Medieval treasures are to be found around every corner at the Cloisters, thanks to the ingenuity and bank accounts of some enterprising Americans.

Jan Benzel is an editor at The Times who is being reassigned to Paris. Before she leaves, she is attempting to do all the things in the city that every New Yorker should do at least once.

Go for the unicorn, but be sure to give yourself plenty of time to poke around and see the many marvels of the Cloisters, that medieval chapel on the hill built and stocked at the turn of the 20th century by some enterprising Americans with a passion for art and plenty of money. I won’t go into the history of the Cloisters here; you can read all about it on its Web site, or in a handsome book published by the Metropolitan Museum of Art (the Cloisters is a branch of the Met) and Yale University Press. And I won’t describe the actual cloisters, the walkways that would have been in the center of a monastery, open to the sky, letting nature in, but private, protected from the hubbub of the world. Go. See them for yourself.

I’d been to the Cloisters to see the famous unicorn tapestries once, several years ago, when as a Mother’s Day offering, my family let me choose the plan for the day. We went, loved the unicorns and the cloister gardens, but our girls were small then, so I didn’t linger. And so many readers suggested the Cloisters as an unmissable New York experience that I decided I had to go back.

For me, the Metropolitan Museum of Art is a quick walk across Central Park. To get to the Cloisters, I took the A Train. My companions on this adventure were the ones with the quick walks. Marcus Yam, a photographer who has been an intern at The Times this summer and who has been shooting photographs for Send-Off posts, and his wife, Jenny, popped over, and my friend Holland Cotter, an art critic for The Times who dwells in the Cloisters every chance he gets, strolled down from Inwood.

Marcus is from Malaysia, Jenny from a small village in China, Holland from Boston. The treasures in the Cloisters are from all over Europe: France, Spain, Germany, Austria. Large fragments of medieval cloisters were installed on the hilltop, and inspired the design of the current structure. (Charles Collens, who designed Riverside Church, another unmissable New York sight, was the architect.)

We wandered from one intricately sculptured marvel, or beautifully painted Madonna, or fabulously arched chapel, or illuminated manuscript, or reliquary, to the next. “Look at this!” we each kept enthusing as we came upon yet another surprise, tiny or giant. There was plenty of Islamic imagery side by side with Christian symbology. “Wow,” Holland said, upon examining a 10th-century pyx, with birds, lions and gazelles. “This is the real Islamic McCoy.” (Let’s pause here for a commercial: Read Holland’s own eloquent tour of the Cloisters.)

Holland and Marcus put their heads together over some 9th- and 10th-century treasures from Spain, deciphering the stew of religious symbols they bore.

“Spain! Now that was truly a melting pot,” Holland said. There were Muslims, Christians, Jews, all living side by side.”

Likewise, it’s the mix of artifacts that makes the Cloisters special, he said. “In French museums, you get French art. In Spain, Spanish art. Here, you get this thing that’s so American, really, putting all these things together.”

Jenny moved to New York when she was 7; Marcus, who is 22, has just moved here, to be with her. He, like my young French friend Diane, is seeing the city for the first time. He’s seen quite a bit of it already on assignments and through the lens of his camera.

What do you like best about New York so far? I asked him after Holland had peeled off to go home, and Marcus and Jenny and I were strolling in the growing dusk through gardens along the Hudson.

“I like everything,” he said. “ I like it that the whole world is here.”

Comments are no longer being accepted.

Nowadays, acquiring an overseas monastery, dismantling and shipping it to NYC and re-erecting it almost a “spoils of war” trophy would be so un-PC as to be unthinkable.

But attitudes were vastly different a 100+ years ago when the moneyed-set of the day were competing with each other to acquire and show-off artistic and archeological prizes from throughout the world (e.g. Cleopatra’s Needle in CP).

Having The Cloisters here in NYC today is unique because such an acquisition/re-location would never now occur. And thanks for pointing out there is much more to see than just the unicorn tapestry. Albeit mention of that Islamic imagery may now cause a bunch up in the underwear of the Tea Party types.

The Cloisters is such a gem. And such a commitment to visit — truly a destination (as opposed to the Whitney or MoMA or anything on Museum Mile, which can be reached easily).

George,

I agree but remember that The Cloisters actually restored and preserved many of the treasures found at its museum, including pieces of monasteries and churches that had been left crumbling and unattended in their original locations.

It is one of my top places in New York to go, and I find myself gravitating to it often. It’s also not much of a trek; only those who confine themselves to Midtown really believe that. Remember Manhattan island is very small and it’s worth the short trip!

As for Islamic artifacts side-by-side with Christian, it’s a wonderful reminder that our history is made up of many stories and backgrounds, and no one part of it should be dismissed or disregarded.

Two favorite seasons to visit: the Christmas holidays when the halls are resplendent with della robbia wreaths and mid-winter on a snowy day when the potted lemon and orange trees that have been brought in for the winter bloom. The cloister walkways are fragant with the scent of orange blossoms.

The M2 goes to the Cloisters as well

I lived a 10-minute walk from the Cloisters (and five minutes from the lovely Ft. Tryon Park) for 17 years, and know the Museum like the back of my hand. Visiting that area was always like traveling to another country (AND another time). It’s one of the truly affordable and transportive experiences in Manhattan.

Whenever a friend asks me for a “hidden gem” in NYC, the Cloisters is always the first thing off my tongue. It amazes me how few tourists — and even longtime residents — are more than vaguely aware of it.

Walking up to the museum from the end of the A train is a treat in and of itself… as the land rises and the trees wrap behind you, you feel like you’re passing some magic portal out of the city and into some distant, older world. Then, as you turn and look out over the Hudson, the GWB and the apartment towers of Fort Lee come into view, but now somehow more distant, and shrunk to a human scale.

It’s truly one of the great gifts of this city. My only worry in talking it up to friends and visitors is that it might become as popular as some of our other museums, and all opportunity for peace, reflection, and leisurely appreciation of art will vanish!

Readers may also want to dip into the never-before-told story of The Cloisters in Rogues’ Gallery: The Secret History of the Lust, Lies, Greed and Betrayals That Made the Metropolitan Museum of Art. It has all the blood, sweat, and philanthropic and artistic tears that is missing from the various official versions. Thomas Hoving, longtime curator of the Cloisters, said he learned a great deal he’d never before known about the institution he ran from the book (published by Random House/Broadway Books and available everywhere–except the Metropolitan Museum).

I fell in love with The Cloisters on a school trip when I was 12 years old. It became the litmus test for potential boyfriends. If they “got” why I loved it here so much, they were worth the trouble of knowing better. As a result, I have great romantic memories of one of NY’s most glorious museums.

You might be interested in this book my dad made about New York City. He photographed every street in Manhattan. Here is the link:

//www.blurb.com/bookstore/detail/1551295

Enjoy!