Updates From This Business
IT FEELS LIKE SUMMER ☀️
Enjoy dinner & drinks in our outdoor area! And of… read more
The Happiest Hour
Monday - Friday… read more
Celebrate St. Patrick's Day with us!
Enjoy a delicious pint of Guinness with Traditional… read more
Menu
Popular dishes
What's the vibe?
See all 18
Inside
18 photos
See all 7
Outside
7 photos
See all 59
All photos
59 photos
Highlights from the Business
Outdoor seating
Large group friendly
Catering service
Sports on TV
Private events
Happy hour specials
People also searched for
Location & Hours
Amenities and More
About the Business
Bottomless Brunch 7 days a week
Ask the Community
Got a question about The Crooked Knife? Ask the Yelp community!
Recommended Reviews
Overall rating
36 reviews
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
- Nov 3, 2023
Great local spot! Lots of bar and table seating. Great relaxed atmosphere. Friendly staff and fast service. The burger and the seafood pasta are the standouts of the menu. Great value for the price! They also have lots of beers on tap.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0 - Dec 1, 2022
Dropped in for lunch on a Friday. We reserved a table for a large group, the table was set and ready when we got there. Has a nicer interior than I expected- sort of an old school feel.
We ordered an assortment of different main dishes. I opted for the burger. It wasn't bad, but similar to a burger you can get at most bars. My friend ordered a chicken parm that was undercooked and another friend didnt receive their meal until right before we left which was unfortunate.
The service was good but I think they were a bit overwhelmed with the amount of orders that went in at the same time.Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Ginette P.New York, NY733181912555Mar 13, 2023
In the area for an appointed, we came here after since we wanted something to eat.
Drinks , water & coke not bad.
On the food I had a Avocado chicken sandwich , sandwich was very good nice taste comes with fries they were nice & fresh, decent fries.
Hubby had a Steak sandwich also w fries, good sandwich as well.
Small place, comfy seating we had a good lunch.Helpful 4Thanks 2Love this 5Oh no 0 - Dec 10, 2022
We hit this place up on a Thursday evening, light crowd. Loud music, typical for a bar... but hard to talk or hear in there.
We were ordering dinner and beer after our long flight into the city. There fish & chips sounded like a winner, and I was not disappointed. Killer crispy skins on fries. Perfect! Fish super crispy outside, flaky and moist on this inside... done just right. Couldn't finish it all, it's a hearty plate of food. My husband's burger also looked quite substantial and since there was nothing left I'd presume it was just as delicious. Close to my cousin's so that also made it a no brainer for us to walker over too. Definitely if you're in the vicinity it's worth a spot in and check. Nice/friendly server too.Helpful 2Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0 - 48414699Dec 7, 2022
Great location that opened relatively recently. Went for brunch and the food was good and the vibes were solid. Prices were fair. Place seems to be crowded frequently so looks like they're doing a great job at a location that has a lot of opportunity. 3.5 round up to 4
Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0 - Albert K.New York, NY654119922844Jan 29, 2023
Really kind staff - fun, social, and extremely accommodating. Excellent bar and beer selection.
Breakfast was good. I thought that the bacon was a bit thin/dry (would have loved to see them thick and juicier) and that the toast was just one slice of toast. Would have been great to have 2 slices, some butter (didn't include butter), and an option of white or wheat. Sausages were a bit spicy and crunchy, and the eggs were cooked well.
Their cocktails are delicious, so definitely worth coming here for the bar/drinks/beer selection.
With slight tweaks to the breakfast, this would be an excellent brunch spot. Will come again.Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Jan 17, 2023
We grabbed a quick drink here before a movie at the AMC Theater next door. I was immediately (and happily) taken aback by the fact that a cocktail is only $11, but there was a premium charge for Maker's in the old fashioned so it ended up being closer to $16 (the bartender asked if I wanted it with Maker's, not mentioning the surcharge). I wonder what kind of bourbon they would have used in the base cocktail since Maker's isn't exactly top shelf. I would have been fine with the price except that it didn't really taste like an old fashioned at all (read: was not very good). But service was quick and friendly.
Helpful 16Thanks 0Love this 10Oh no 0 - Sulema E.Manhattan, NY093Nov 25, 2023
Fantastic Irish pub. On Thanksgiving, our meal there was exceptionally good. They got everything right. The traditional turkey dinner was so good as was the salmon, for the non turkey eaters, Very good pumpkin pie--Excellent value on bottle of wine.
Loved being there.Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Eric P.San Francisco, CA08Feb 4, 2024
It's a fun place. Loud music & lively patrons. Good experiences at other locations, but the dishes at 2nd Avenue place were below par. Red Hot omelette came with no jalapeños. CK breakfast with overcooked eggs & dry sausage. They serve something they call a mimosa, but not really. French toast was great. Excellent service overall.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Noel K.Manhattan, NY53271Aug 30, 2023
Beer on draft is usually flat. Nice staff. Foods ok. Mixed drinks might be good. Don't know
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0