FÉDÉRATION INTERNATIONALE D´ÉDUCATION PHYSIQUE ET SPORTIVE
Physical Education and Physical Activities
of Children, Youth and Adults and
Healthy Active Living
Researches – Best Practices – Situation
Branislav Antala
Jana Labudová
Adriana Kaplánová
John van Heel
Dario Novak
Xueshuang Wang
Editors
Bratislava 2022
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active
Living: Researches - Best Practices - Situation
Editors:
Branislav ANTALA (Comenius University in Bratislava, Slovakia)
Jana LABUDOVÁ (Comenius University in Bratislava, Slovakia)
Adriana KAPLÁNOVÁ (Comenius University in Bratislava, Slovakia)
John van HEEL (New Health Foundation, Netherlands)
Dario NOVAK (University of Zagreb, Croatia)
Xueshuang WANG (Beijing Sport University, China)
Reviewers:
Jelena PETROVIČ (Serbia): jelenailicpetrovic@gmail.com
Pavel ŠMELA (Slovakia): pavel.smela@uniba.sk
Monika POPLUHÁROVÁ (Slovakia): monika.popluharova@uniba.sk
Dario NOVAK (Croatia): dario.novak@kif.hr
Tibor BALGA (Slovakia): tibor.balga@uniba.sk
Klaudia KUKUROVÁ (Slovakia): klaudia.kukurova@uniba.sk
Gheorghe BALINT (Romania): gyuri68@hotmail.com
Jarka ARGAJOVÁ ml. (Slovakia): j.argajova@gmail.com
Eva RÝZKOVÁ(Slovakia): eva.ryzkova@uniba.sk
Imen BEN AMAR (Tunisia): imenbenamar03@gmail.com
František SEMAN (Slovakia:) frantisek.seman@uniba.sk
Publisher:
Slovak Scientific Society for Physical Education and Sport
Printed by:
DOLIS GOEN, s.r.o., Stará Vajnorská 11, 831 04 Bratislava, Slovakia
Book – Jacket:
Anton LEDNICKÝ (Slovakia): anton.lednicky@uniba.sk
Circulation:
622 pages, 100 copies, 1st edition
ISBN
978-80-8251-012-9
Supported:
by ERASMUS + project 613045-EPP-1-2019-1-NL-SPO-SCP “New Health”
Note:
No part of this publication may be reproduced without the prior permission of the authors
Table of Contents
__________________________________________________________________________________
Table of Contents
9
Introduction
NEW HEALTH
New Health EU Project - For a Healthier Future!
John van Heel
13
Exercise as a Medicine – Selected Findings from Literature Review in Slovakia
Jana Labudová - Ľubomíra Benčuriková - Ľuboš Grznár - Matúš Putala - Eva Rýzková Martin Belás - Adriana Kaplánová
29
Exercise as a Medicine – Selected Findings from Worldwide Literature Review
Manel Valcarce-Torrente - Francisco Gómez-Almeida - Carla Chicau Borrego –
Susana Franco - Eric Vandenabeele - Gert van Reckem - Adriana Kaplánová
39
Food as a Medicine – Selected Findings from Literature Review in Slovakia
Stanislav Kraček - Gabriela Kotyrová Štefániková - Adriana Kaplánová - Branislav Antala
51
Food as a Medicine – Selected Findings from Worldwide Literature Review
Susana Franco - Manel Valcarce-Torrente - Francisco Gómez-Almeida - Carla Chicau Borrego Eric Vandenabeele - Gert van Reckem - Stanislav Kraček - Gabriela Kotyrová Štefániková Adriana Kaplánová
61
Brain as a Medicine – Selected Findings from Literature Review in Slovakia
Adriana Kaplánová - Petra Pačesová
75
Brain as a Medicine – Selected Findings from Worldwide Literature Review
John van Heel - Manel Valcarce-Torrente - Francisco Gómez-Almeida - Carla Chicau Borrego Susana Franco - Eric Vandenabeele - Gert van Reckem - Adriana Kaplánová
87
Summary from Literature Reviews Focused on Exercise as a Medicine, Food as
a Medicine, and Brain as a Medicine
John van Heel – Adriana Kaplánová – Branislav Antala
97
RESEARCHES
Physical Activity and Exercise Enjoyment in a Sample of Metropolitan College
Students
Eng Hoe Wee - Wei Fong Cheng - Hui Yin Ler - Ngien Siong Chin
103
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
The Effects of Innovative Tools Implemented in Singapore during Physical
Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults
Govindasamy Balasekaran - Ng Yew Cheo - Peggy Boey
119
The Relationship Between Attitudes and Participation Motivation Among
Undergraduate Students Towards Extra-Curricular Activities During the Pandemic
Ngien-Siong Chin - Eng-Hoe Wee - Boon-Sian Teo - Arthur Ling Wei - Dana Raja A/L
Narayanasamy - Matheus Chin Yan Yu
131
University Students' Lifestyle and Physical Activity during the COVID-19 Pandemic
Jasna Kudek Mirošević
141
The Application of Transtheoretical Model (TTM) of Behavioural Change Among
Malaysian Undergraduate Trainee Teachers towards Physical Activity
Pei-Yi Ting - Ngien-Siong Chin - Garry Kuan - Yee-Cheng Kueh - Boon-Sian Teo –
Ting-Len Lim
151
The Role of Recreation in the System of Physical Education of Young People with
a Sedentary Lifestyle
Sergii Ivashchenko - Nataliya Kovalchuk
163
Effects of Peer Motivation on Sport Participation among College Students
Eng Hoe Wee - Liang Wei Wong - Wei Fong Cheng - Hui Yin Ler - Ngien Siong Chin
171
Functional Disorders of the Musculoskeletal System in Younger School-age Pupils
Elena Bendíková
183
Demographic Factors towards Online Learning Readiness of Physical Education
and Sports Science Undergraduate Students during the COVID-19 Pandemic
Ngien-Siong Chin - Kie-Yin Teng - How-Yew Lee
195
Characteristics of Morphofunctional Features of Men Engaged in Power Martial Arts on Example of Arm Wrestling
Nikulin Igor Nikolaevich - Posokhov Alexey Viktorovich - Sobyanin Fedor Ivanovich –
Beketov Oleg Vladimirovich -Bogacheva Elizabeth Alekseevna
205
Longitudinal Design of Measuring Physical Activity in Children: In Relation to
Their Motor Abilities and Anthropometric Measurements
Badriya K. Al-Hadabi
215
The HEPAS Model: A Healthy and Physically Active School Model Promoting
Physical Activity and Healthy Lifestyles in School Settings
Richard Bailey - Manolis Adamakis – Zoltan Boronyai - Jana Vašíčková - Petr Vlček –
Andreu Raya Demidoff – Rose-Marie Repond - Sandra Heck - Claude Scheuer
229
Table of Contents
__________________________________________________________________________________
Behavioral Disorders in Children Owing to Confinement by the COVID-19
Pandemic - Proposal of Daily Goals to Restart Physical Activity for Mental Health
Giovanni Hernández - Ricardo Ortiz Pulido - Rubén Ortiz Pulido
239
BEST PRACTICES
“Creix amb Dansa”: Healthy Active Living Project for Children and Youth, based
on a Leisure Education initiative and NeuroEF principles through Dance and
Physical Education
Agustí Castillo Cañiz - Nàdia Pesarrodona Rovira
251
Creating a Global Index Measuring Countries’ Levels of Fitness:
The “World’s Fittest Countries Ranking”
Nadim Nassif - Kaissar Keyrouz
265
Coaches Help Czech and Slovak Teachers in Primary Schools
Jan Macháček - Branislav Antala - Diana Kosová - Martin Dovičák
277
Instructional Effectiveness in Physical Education: Factors for Attaining Motor
Skill Equity
Ulana Lysniak - Eve Bernstein
289
eL CaMiNo De piEFcitos: United for a Healthy and Sustainable Physical Education
Carlos Chamorro Durán
301
Innovation in Physical Activity to Health Lifestyles through the Mile´s Schools
Program: A Mexican Experience
Antonio Eugenio Rivera-Cisneros - Néstor Rangel Jantes - Manuel Guerrero-Zainos Gabriela Murguía-Cánovas - Yesenia Lara-Mayorga - Jorge Manuel Sánchez GonzálezJuan Antonio Rivera-Ríos - Gloria Vargas-Sánchez - Ricardo Félix-Inguanzo –
Felipe Horacio Gómez-Ballesteros - Marco Antonio Ojeda Macías
309
An International Review of the Contributions of School-based Physical Activity,
Physical Education, and School Sport to the Promotion of Health-enhancing
Physical Activity
Richard Bailey - Manolis Adamakis - Jana Vašíčková - Petr Vlček - Andreu Raya Demidoff Uwe Pühse - Sandra Heck - Claude Scheuer
315
The Use of Speed Agility Training Aids for Developing Physical Fitness
Candrawati Ibrahim - Garry Kuan - Chin Ngien Siong - Ismail Dikoh - Nurlyn Syifaa’
Jacklyna Aban - Muhd. Dzulfikrie Hipni - Ratna Kertinie Hipni - Malisa Haziqah
Mohammad Haffizie
327
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
SITUATION
Exploring the Efficacy of an International Immersion Program towards Building
Cultural Competence for Health and Physical Education Teachers: Australia
and Samoa
Matthew Winslade - Lana McCarthy - Suzie Schuster
339
The Professional Identity of the Physical Education Teacher
Hector Manuel Icaza Campa
355
Motor Education in Primary Schools in Italy, the Role of the Teacher of Motor
Science in State Law
Francesco Perrotta
365
Issues of Outdoor Physical Education in Bibliographic Databases
Agnieszka Pasek - Barbara Griffin - Marcin Pasek
375
Students with Special Educational Needs Care within Physical Education Classes
while Covid-19 Lockdown in the North of Mexico
Mayra Judith Jurado Neri - Ramón Alfonso González Rivas - Oscar Nuñez Enriquez –
Javier Bernabé González Bustos - Ma. de los Ángeles Bibiano Mejía Felipe Valenzuela Jurado
385
The Health Benefits of Physical Activity in People with Alzheimer's Disease A Short Review
Italo Sannicandro - Rosa Anna Rosa - Giusi Antonia Toto
395
Physical Literacy as a Health Option for Children: Overweight and Obesity a Rising
Problem
Liliana Aracely Enríquez del Castillo - Oscar Núñez Enríquez - Luis Alberto Flores Olivares 405
The Development and Evolution of School Sports Policies since China's Reform and
Opening up
Qianyi Wang - Lin Li - Xin Liu
413
Importance of Physical Education in the Early Stages of the Life Cycle, for a Healthy
Life
Jose Francisco Mora Núñez - Manuel Guerrero Zainos
427
Physical Activity at School of Children in Poland during the First Three Years of
Primary Education
Aleksandra Lodzińska - Magdalena Lelonek
441
Table of Contents
__________________________________________________________________________________
Percentiles of Physical Qualities in Men and Women of Primary Schools, in San Luis
Potosí Mexico
Manuel Guerrero Zainos - Antonio Eugenio Rivera Cisneros - Ricardo Félix Inguanzo –
Juan Sandoval Barajas
449
Effect of Exercises on Elderly to Prevent Fall: A Narrative Review
Wan Zhen Lee - Kueh Yee Cheng - Muhammad Hafiz Hanafi – Garry Kuan
461
Criticality in New Zealand Physical Education: Disrupting the Orthodoxy, Creating
a New Imagery
Susannah Stevens - Ian Culpan
471
Physical Activity on Children and Youth – The importance for a Healthy Lifestyle
Liliana Ramos - Susana Franco - Carla Chicau Borrego
483
Obstacle Course Race in Physical Education Lessons: A Way to Contrast the Covid-19
Restrictions
Viviana Zito - Nicola Lovecchio
497
Physical Education and Physical Activities Attitude in the Preservice Physical
Education Teacher in Primary School for Healthy Active Living Research
Stefania Cazzoli - Federico Abate Daga
505
ARTICLES IN FRENCH
Articles en français
Influencée de l´angle cuisse-tronc sur la mobilité de la chaine posturale
Djiby Guissé Diakhate - Mohamed Mansourou Lawani - Gratien Houeto - Djibril Seck
517
Les activités physiques et sportives au Maroc: constats, contraintes et voies
d’amélioration
Abderrazak El Akari
529
Realités infrastructurelles, activités de loisir et perspectives d´attraction au parc
urbain Bangr-Weoogo de Ouagadougou
Gouriyamba Ouedraogo - Augustin Pale - Antoine Hounga
547
Détermination des normes de la valeur physique liée à la santé en milieu scolaire
en Algérie - 13 – 19 ans catégorie garçons
Nacer Abdelkader - Sebbane Mohammed - Belkadi Adel - Remaoun Mohamed
559
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Le boom du fitness au Sénégal : le développement de l’activité physique pour tous
à partir d’initiatives privées
Fall Ibrahima
567
La lutte de KÃGOR-YÕ du peuple "SAN" de Nayala au Burkina Faso: une pratique
saine des enfants a sauvegarder
Boukaré Ouedraogo - Augustin Pale - Sakré Pakode
581
Contribution de l’Education Physique et du Sport (EPS) à la résilience communautaire
par l’animation socio-éducative, sanitaire, culturelle et économique (ASCE) face à
l’épidémie de la Covid-19 au Sénégal
Seck Djibril - Sèye Amadou - Ndongo Mohamed - Ndiouck Amadou - Diompy Patrick Diouf Thierno
591
Gestion de l’enseignement l’Education Physique et du Sport Scolaire dans le contexte
de la Covid-19 au Maroc
Abdesselam Mili
601
Attitudes des élèves vis-à-vis du cours d’éducation physique et sportive, perception
des compétences durant la période de propagation de la Covid-19 au Gabon
Doumbeneny Jean Derlish Désiré - Tsamba Nzedy Rosamour Gassien Aymar –
Boulamba Mounanga Sandra
611
Introduction
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
You are holding a book that is one of the intellectual outcomes of the ERASMUS + project
613045-EPP-1-2019-1-NL-SPO-SCP “New Health”. This project, addressed in 2019 - 2022, is
focused on supporting healthy active living of young and adults in EU. Project coordinator is New
Health Foundation from the Netherlands. Full partners are Sport Sciences School of Rio Maior
(ESDRM) in Portugal, Europe Active in Belgium, Lithuanian Association of Health and Fitness
Clubs in Lithuania, Fitness federation in Belgium, Association Europea Deporte, Ejercicio Y Salud
(AEDESA) in Spain and Comenius University in Bratislava in Slovakia. Expert panel is
representing by European Network of Sport Education (ENSE) in Austria, Movisie, Knowledge
Center Sports Netherlands (KCSportNL), NL Active and Jan Middelkamp in the Netherlands
The book is also part of the 4th Physical Education Worldwide Survey on Quality Physical
Education, which is carried out by UNESCO in cooperation with FIEPS and its partners. The
publication is part of one of its lines, focusing on mapping the basic characteristics of physical
education and physical activities of children and youth in the world at individual levels of schools,
from pre-school education to universities. Book is focused on selected topics related health of
youth, adults, and elderly persons.
In 2017 the book "Physical Education in Primary School: Researches - Best Practices - Situation",
edited by D. Collela, B. Antala and S. Epifani, was published by Pensa Multimedia in Italy and has
502 pages. 102 authors from 27 countries and 5 continents participated. In 2018, it was followed
by a publication "Physical Education in Secondary School: Researches - Best Practices - Situation",
published by the University of Montenegro in cooperation with the Montenegrin Sport Academy.
The editors were S.Popovič, B.Antala, D.Bjelica and J.Gardaševič. It had 343 pages and was
prepared by 84 authors from 24 countries and 5 continents. The publication "Physical Education
in Early Childhood Education and Care: Researches - Best Practices -Situation" was published in
Slovakia by the Slovak Scientific Society for Physical Education and Sport in 2019. Its editors were
B. Antala, G. Demirhan, A. Carraro, C. Oktar, H. Oz and A. Kaplánová. It had 464 pages. 120
authors from 32 countries from 5 continents participated. In 2020 a book “Physical Education in
Universities: Researches - Best Practices -Situation” was prepared. Its editors were M. Bobrík, B.
Antala and R. Pělucha. 136 authors from 28 countries and 5 continents participated in the book.
In 2021 was published 5th book in the series “Physical Education and Sport for Children and Youth
with Special Needs: Researches – Best Practices – Situation”. 178 authors from 32 countries and 5
continents participated in the book, editors of book were G. Balint, B. Antala, C. Carty, J.M.
Aleokol Mabiémé, I. Ben Amar and A. Kaplánová and book was published in Slovakia by the
Slovak Scientific Society for Physical Education and Sport.
A series of these 4th Physical Education Worldwide Survey publications is closed in 2022 by this
publication “Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy
Active Living: Researches - Best Practices - Situation".
9
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
The book is divided into 5 parts. In the first part of "New Health” we bring the results of the
scientific part of the project focused on literature reviews in participating countries of the project.
In the second part of the publication called "Researches", we bring the latest research findings
aimed at exploring the physical education and physical activities of children, youth and adults and
healthy active living. The third part, the “Best Practices” brings examples of good practice from
different countries of the world and fourth part “Situation” is focused on presenting knowledge
related to the characteristics of the state of the issue in various countries of the world. Last, fifth
part of the book is focused on French language write articles. Due the agreement between FIEPS
and CONFEJES, the book was open for articles write in French language also. Nine articles,
especially from African countries, are situated in this last part of the book.
155 authors from 32 countries and five continents participated in the book, of which 15 were
European countries (Belgium, Croatia, Czech Republic, Greece, Hungary, Italy, Luxembourg,
Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Russia, Slovakia, Spain, Switzerland, Ukraine) 3 countries from
America (Colombia, Mexico, USA), 5 countries from Asia (China, Lebanon, Malaysia, Oman,
Singapore), 6 countries from Africa (Algeria, Benin, Burkina Faso, Gabon, Morocco, Senegal)
and 3 countries from Oceania (Australia, New Zealand, Samoa). Therefore, the publication brings
a broad international perspective on the issue of pre-school physical education and physical
activities in pre-school facilities.
A thank you goes also to the reviewers who, through their comments and advice, helped the
authors improve the quality of their contributions.
Branislav Antala
Jana Labudová
Adriana Kaplánová
John van Heel
Dario Novak
Xueshuang Wang
Editors
10
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
New Health
11
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
12
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
New Health EU Project - For a Healthier Future!
John van Heel
New Health Foundation, Netherlands
e-mail: info@new-health.eu
Abstract
The ERASMUS + project 613045-EPP-1-2019-1-NL-SPO-SCP “New Health”, addressed in 2019
- 2022, is focused on supporting healthy active living of young and adults in EU. Project
coordinator is New Health Foundation from the Netherlands. Full partners are Sport Sciences
School of Rio Maior (ESDRM) in Portugal, Europe Active in Belgium, Lithuanian Association of
Health and Fitness Clubs in Lithuania, Fitness federation in Belgium, Association Europea
Deporte, Ejercicio Y Salud (AEDESA) in Spain and Comenius University in Bratislava in Slovakia.
Expert panel is representing by European Network of Sport Education (ENSE) in Austria,
Movisie, Knowledge Center Sports Netherlands (KCSportNL), NL Active and Jan Middelkamp
in the Netherlands. Project combined information about the new active living guidelines, the antidoping code for professionals and consumers. The innovative character of the New Health Project
is focused on: the Lifestyle is Medicine coach course that contains the new active living guidelines,
the anti-doping code and a part of coaching health behaviour change including behaviour change
models and theories and practical application tools, the creation of a European Healthy Lifestyle
promotors network (network of professionals and volunteers that support family, friends,
neighbours, colleagues in their lifestyle), recognition of the New Health Healthy Lifestyle
promotor education on EQF level 2 by Europe Active Positive Health.
Key words: Healthy lifestyle promotor, Exercise as a medicine, Brain as a medicine, Food a
medicine
13
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
The WHO and the Health Council developed guidelines for healthy active living and improvement
of the quality of life. Unfortunately, most adults and the elderly of today, as well as professionals
in education, care, welfare and sports, have never learned these new healthy living guidelines.
Socially, too, there is still insufficient movement in the direction of people learning to organize and
manage their health in a preventive way. Unfortunately, the youth of today also do not receive
these essential insights, with the result that many will follow the same path of health care to come,
at one point, to the conclusion that one must change something in the lifestyle. And even then, for
many it is still often a search for the right information. In this project the most important essential
insights for a healthy life, body and mindset are summarized in short, enjoyable to watch mini
documentaries, intended for everyone who wants to live healthier and all professionals who want
to help and inspire people to a healthier lifestyle.
If people have the knowledge about the at this moment available healthy living guidelines, and what
they can bring to health and quality of life if applying, but also what harm they bring if not, people
would take steps and make choices to start a healthier life.
The aim of this project is:
1. to educate professionals, volunteers, and
2. via the professionals and volunteers educate the consumer, especially the low SES, and when
necessary, guide and coach them to a lifelong healthier live.
Within the project we use a New Health platform for online learning and communicate New
Health lifestyle is medicine educational and inspirational material. The project will be developed
within 36 months, and we are working with partner organisations in 6 EU countries; The
Netherlands, Spain, Portugal, Lithuania, Slovakia and Belgium.
Goals of the New Health project:
•
•
•
•
•
Improve the participation of sport and active living, especially among low SES and younger
adults
Improve a healthy lifestyle, consisting of physical activity, healthy food, a health mindset and
social interaction between people
Increase the knowledge about a healthy lifestyle, of professionals, volunteers and consumers,
especially among low SES and younger adults
Strengthened cooperation between institutes, foundations and (educational) organisation
Sharing best practices between institutes and organisation in the field of sports and
active/healthy living
14
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
New Health essential education
The ‘New Health’ program is informing and educating consumers
and professionals/volunteers in sports and fitness about four
guidelines.
1. The WHO ‘Global Guidelines of Physical Activity and
sedentary behaviour’
2. The Health Council ‘guidelines of good food 2015’
3. Up to date knowledge about developing a growth mindset
4. Positive Health Model
5. World anti-doping code, keeping doping away from recreational sports
Together these guidelines and this knowledge form an ideal health & prevention
approach. Working on one of these theme’s results in health gain, working on
more than one themes, results in more health gain.
According to the WHO and Health council, applying the 15 lifestyle themes of the guidelines can
lower the risk of chronic diseases with 50 to 80%. A second educational focus for professionals
and volunteers is health behaviour guidance and coaching, learning about the most effective ways
to help people to change their behaviour.
Essential healthy lifestyle knowledge for every human being!
New Health is developing a digital lifestyle & prevention education platform, with the essential
knowledge, that every human being should have.
15
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
This programme is presented in 7 languages: Dutch, English, Spanish, Portuguese, France,
Lithuanian and Slovaks.
New Health – Healthy Lifestyle documentary
Part one is the healthy lifestyle course and documentary. Consumers and professionals can join and
walk true the following chapters:
Introduction: The turning point of the Homo Sapiens
o Chapter 1 - OUR HEALTH! - The current situation
o Chapter 2 - OUR EVOLUTION - 60.000.000 years
o Chapter 3 - OUR HABITS - How did we use our body and how did we eat
o Chapter 4 - OUR HISTORY OF SPORTS - Further evolution of our physical activity
o Chapter 5 - OUR INDUSTRIAL REVOLUTIONS - How machines made us less active!
o Chapter 6 - OUR FOOD INDUSTRY - Where did we lose control?
o Chapter 7 - OUR FUTURE - And the future of our children
Part 2: Exercise as medicine
o Chapter 1 – The inactive Homo Sapiens
o Chapter 2 – The effect of our inactive lifestyle
o Chapter 3 – Healthy active living recipe
o Chapter 4 – Exercise as medicine, how do we do that?
o Chapter 5 – The Homo Sapiens… back into active living
Part 3: Food as medicine
o Chapter 1: The history of our food
o Chapter 2: Programmed unhealthy
o Chapter 3: How do we eat now?
o Chapter 4: The healthy eating ‘recipe’
o Chapter 5: Making the food switch
Part 4: The brain as medicine
o Chapter 1: The history of our brain
o Chapter 2: Phases of behavior change
o Chapter 3: Our levels of consciousness
o Chapter 4: Food for our sub-consciousness
o Chapter 5: The strength of our 3 brains
o Chapter 6: Essential conditions for change
o Chapter 7: Neuroplasticity, placebo and mindset
o Chapter 8: Developing more control over our mind
o Chapter 9: Mind(re)set strategy
o Chapter 10: Lifestyle and mindset
16
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
A New Health lifestyle scan and library for everyone!
The second part is the online health library, lifestyle scan and SWITCH program, where trainers,
coaches, health care workers, volunteers etc. can together with consumers, do a lifestyle scan with
themes of The World Health Organisation ‘Global Guidelines of Physical Activity and sedentary
behaviour’ and the ‘Health Council ‘guidelines of good food 2015’.
Filling in this lifestyle scan, consumers receive a clear overview on what parts of their lifestyle harm
their health significantly. Alone or together with a coach, users use a SWITCH choice to work on
in the upcoming month. The program helps the user with the health library, that gives insight about
the what, why and how of every lifestyle aspect in the scan.
Participants who work with the New Health program get
access to the New Health personal online portal and library,
where they can;
1. find background information (a factsheet) per theme
2. use the New Health lifestyle coach App
3. download and use inspirational posters per lifestyle
theme.
The inspirational posters and Factsheet can be used by
professionals and companies who want to use New Health
for their employees.
Company’s use this poster (to hang up in the employee room, at the coffee machine) to get the
conversation going within the company about that specific health theme and to invite employees
to start the coach tip program in their own portal.
Sports organisations together with educational organisations
In this project we connect sport and fitness organisations with educational organisations. The
educational organisations educate the volunteers and professionals about the four guidelines and
about a coach strategy to educate and coach the consumers about the health enhancement lifestyle
SWITCH.
The volunteers and professionals will get insight about the healthy living guidelines and about the
most effective way to help people mentally to overcome their personal barriers. With this extra
mindset knowledge, it is possible to help people to a sustainably healthier lifestyle.
17
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Innovative parts of the New Health 2022 project
What is the innovative character of the New Health Project?
•
•
•
•
•
Combined information about the new active living guidelines, the anti-doping code for
professionals and consumers
The Healthy Lifestyle promotor course that contains the new active living guidelines, the antidoping code and a part of coaching health behaviour change including behaviour change
models and theories and practical application tools.
The creation of a European Healthy Lifestyle promotors network (network of professionals
and volunteers that support family, friends, neighbours, colleagues in their lifestyle).
Recognition of the New Health Healthy Lifestyle promotor education on EQF level 2 by
Europe Active
Positive Health (see below)
Positive Health!
Positive Health is a new look at health and prevention. Physician and researcher Machteld Huber
developed the Positive Healthy Spider Web based on the vision that health is ‘the ability to adapt
and take control in the light of the physical, emotional and social challenges of life’.
This model, including tools and working methods, will be added to the New Health toolbox for
professionals.
18
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
Healthy Lifestyle Promotor
In collaboration with Europe Active and the New
Health 2022 partners, a competency profile has
been developed at level EQF 2. Level 2 has been
deliberately chosen so that consumers can easily
join in and so that it can be used as a 'Lifelong
learning' training program for professionals.
This is the first EQF competency profile in which
substantive knowledge is immediately provided to
participants, in e-learning/documentary form, free
of charge for all participants.
Professionals can also choose to take a short
Healthy Lifestyle Promotor course by any of the
project partners and to take the recognized exam
and obtain the official 'Healthy Lifestyle promoter'
certificate.
Spreading the word!
The main challenge is, nationally and internationally, that governments don’t have any money (or
don’t spend it on prevention) to make these guidelines known among the public and professionals,
they leave that to the market. In the Netherlands, within one-year, New Health build a network of
almost 400 professionals and volunteers, that receive the health enhancement inspirational material
every two month to spread it to their own network.
New Health combines lifestyle issues like active living, healthy food, mental wellness, healthy aging
and positive health for consumers and reaches professionals the tools to educate and coach people
on these topics to create a change for live.
Project coordinator, partners, and expert panel
Project coordinator
•
New Health Foundation: The Netherlands
Full partners
•
•
Sport Sciences School of Rio Maior (ESDRM): Portugal
Europe Active: Belgium
19
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
•
•
•
•
Lithuanian Association of Health and Fitness Clubs: Lithuania
Fitness federation: Belgium
Association Europea Deporte, Ejercicio Y Salud (AEDESA): Spain
Comenius University in Bratislava (Faculty of Physical Education and Sports): Slovakia
Expert panel
•
•
•
•
•
European Network of Sport Education (ENSE): Austria
Movisie: The Netherlands
Knowledge Center Sports Netherlands (KCSportNL): The Netherlands
NL Active: The Netherlands
Jan Middelkamp: The Netherlands
This program is supported by the Erasmus+ programma of the European Union.
Project information: https://ec.europa.eu/programmes/erasmus-plus
20
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
New Health mission for the future!
With the development of the New Health program, we try to bridge the gap between the essential
healthy living guidelines of the WHO and the Health Council and the citizens who need this
essential knowledge. Awareness about these essential insights is the foundation of making healthy
choices. Because the guidelines are only fairly recent, generations of people have not been learning
them on a structural basis and unfortunately most people have unwittingly started living so
unhealthy that this takes a heavy toll on people's health and health care. Millions of citizens can be
reached with the information of the New Health program through a European network of
professionals in care, education, welfare and sport and through volunteers. Professionals and
volunteers also gain insight into the basic insights of behavioral change guidance and developing a
healthy mindset, but consumers can also go through this matter, so that they can take more control
over their own lifestyle.
1000 professionals and 100,000 citizens!
An objective in a follow-up project of New Health is to train 1000 volunteers and professionals to
become a Healthy Lifestyle promoter. These 1000 Healthy Lifestyle promoters each provide at
least 100 people with the New Health documentary and have them go through the Lifestyle Scan.
Snowball effect!
Because the program is presented Dutch, English, Spanish, Portuguese, France, Lithuanian and
Slovaks, we hope that we, together with the partners, will train thousands of Healthy Lifestyle
promotors more in the upcoming years, and that the documentary will reach millions of people.
Lifestyle education in primary education
A long-term goal of the New Health foundation is getting the Healthy Lifestyle education
integrated in primary education. When we don’t teach our youth about the foundation and
guidelines of healthy living, how than will they ever be able to make healthy choices. We should
not let our health and lifestyle dependent on coincidence but should take responsibility for the
health of the growing generations. Because we currently must assume that today's parents have also
not received this essential knowledge, the implementation in primary education is a crucial step to
effectively organize primary prevention for a healthier future. To realize this, we will have to
translate the essential insights of a healthy lifestyle and healthy mindset into the perception of
young people. A considerable project, which requires manpower, specialism, and budget, but where
there is a perspective and mission, there will come solutions. For anyone who would like to
contribute to the realization of this mission, feel free to contact us via info@new-health.eu
New Health Foundation, Houtstraat 14, 6001 SJ Weert (Netherlands), www.new-health.eu
info@new-health.eu
21
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Partners Presentation
Asociación Europea Deporte, Ejercicio y Salud - AEDESA
Asociación Europea Deporte, Ejercicio y Salud
(AEDESA) is an Association that aims to offer
knowledge of sport and physical activity through the
promotion, giving information and organizing sport
events. Our mission as physical exercise professional is to believe in physical activity for the integral
development of the humans. Promotion, conscience and educate in the importance of physical
movement as felicity and good wellness. AEDESA aims to maintain relationships with all kinds of
public and private organizations and entities within Spain, Europe and the rest of the world in
defence of their interests. We develop informative and training actions through our entity, and we
have qualified professionals for this purpose. In addition, AEDESA has various collaborations
with various companies and entities in the sector, to promote the complementary training of
professionals. Our actions are aimed at professionals in the physical activity and sports sector;
students, monitors, sports technicians, etc; coordinators, directors or managers of facilities or
companies in the sports or fitness sector.
The New Health project is very important for AEDESA because Spain needs to increase the rates
of practice of physical and sports activity of its population to reach the levels of the most developed
European countries and, consequently, reduce the rates of sedentary lifestyle, obesity and
overweight that have such a negative impact on health and the economy of citizens, especially boys,
girls and adolescents. In this sense, the objective is to aspire to have the same level as other
countries with very low rates of sedentary lifestyle, where only 4% of its citizens do not perform
physical activity in a normal week, in addition to having an average weekly hour dedicated to
physical activity of 12.8 hours, according to the Ipsos Report “Global views on exercise and team
sports” (2021).
Participating in this project is both for the organization and on a personal level, an opportunity to
collaborate in the promotion of healthy habits and the practice of physical exercise in the European
population. A way of offering quality, safety and qualified supervision of all those professionals
who provide services to improve people's health and physical condition.
Within the New Health project, AEDESA collaborates with the other European partners in the
development of tools and courses for disseminating scientific and quality information to improve
physical activity, healthy eating, mental health, positive health and a healthy lifestyle. Those tools
include the free consumer lifestyle platform, courses for those who promote health and healthy
lifestyle; e-learning (electronic learning) and the creation of the figure of the promoter of a healthy
lifestyle.
22
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
EuropeActive
EuropeActive is the leading not-for-profit organisation
representing the European fitness and physical activity
sector. According to the Deloitte Market Report in
April 2020 (pre- COVID-19 pandemic) the sector
serves nearly 62 million consumers, it generates 27.2 billion Euro in revenues, employs over
750,000 people, and consists of 62,000 facilities, and was growing at 3-4% a year compounded.
Fitness is the largest participation sport (Special Eurobarometer, 2014 & 2018) and alongside its
significant economic contribution, the sector has a major role to play in making a more active and
healthier Europe, and in promoting the importance of healthy lifestyles for all. EuropeActive
currently represents approximately 30,000 facilities it has 23 National Associations and a
membership spread across 30 countries in Europe, which includes operators, suppliers, National
Associations, training providers, higher education, and accreditation institutions.
EuropeActive can trace its origin to 1995 with the establishment of the European Network of
Fitness Associations, and from 2001-2015 as the European Health and Fitness Association (EHFA),
and then into EuropeActive. EuropeActive was one of the first members of the Advisory Board for
the European Week of Sport and remains one of its most active partners. For several years
EuropeActive has been represented on High Level Groups and in EU Expert Groups, including
being an observer in the former EU Expert Group on Health Enhancing Physical Activity1 and the
EU Expert Group on Skills and Human Resources Development (2020)2. Through the close
involvement with these Expert Groups and other EU initiatives, EuropeActive has been proactive
in informing and supporting its members in a number of key policy areas. Between 2015-2017,
EuropeActive successfully ran the Erasmus+ projects Promoting Active and Healthy Ageing
(PAHA) and Active Learning for Children in Schools (ALCIS 1 and 2) encouraging 28,000 +
Europeans into adopting physical activity at a level that is beneficial to their health. These projects
were targeting school children (aged 8 to 12) and older inactive adults (aged 55 to 65) across 16 EU
Member States.
Between 2018-2020, EuropeActive has run the Let’s #BEACTIVE project to promote physical
activity (PA) and to encourage citizens to lead healthy lifestyles and as recommended in the EU
and World Health Organisation Physical Activity Guidelines. From 2017, EuropeActive organised
the #LetsBEACTIVE campaign together with its members, partners, fitness clubs, and our
national fitness associations. The event represented the European fitness sector contribution to the
European Week of Sport.
EuropeActive is currently running two E+ projects to promote HEPA. The first is through the
highly successful National Fitness Days to promote the European Week of Sport in 4 non-EU
1 European Commission: Expert Groups (EU Work Plan for sport 2014-2017), Brussels 2017.
2 https://op.europa.eu/en/publication-detail/-/publication/8f28e3a0-6f11-11ea-b735-01aa75ed71a1
23
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
countries through effective campaigns which are based on the success experiences from Ukactive
and Ireland Active, and the second called Active Ageing Communities which is an intergenerational
approach to encourage older adults to become more active and to adopt healthy lifestyles.
In 2020 EuropeActive launched a new strategy in a Sectoral manifesto comprised of 4 pillars –
Health, Digital, Community and Standards. Under the community pillar EuropeActive promotes
the concept of active citizenship and is working to align our businesses and organisations with
specific UN Sustainable Development Goals, including environmental protection and Co2
reductions, and to have an inclusive approach to citizens and consumers.
EuropeActive had no hesitation in becoming a partner in the New Health Project, targeted as it is
on promoting healthy, active lifestyles across Europe. EuropeActive’s role in the project has been
essentially twofold, that is to produce a set of educational standards that would support the ongoing training of healthy lifestyle promoters across Europe and to oversee a comprehensive
communication plan to effectively disseminate the objectives and activities of the New Health
Project, in order to maximise its scope and implementation. This dissemination plan includes the
running of multiplier events in partner countries as well as a final conference in Amsterdam to
promote the healthy lifestyle assessment tools, supporting information and Healthy Lifestyle
Promoter role.
In its development of educational standards to support a Healthy Lifestyle Promoter role,
EuropeActive’s Professional Standards Committee formed a Technical Expert Group (TEG) made
up of educational experts from across the fitness and physical activity sector. These experts over
the course of a number of TEG meetings developed the first draft of an EQF Level 2 Healthy
Lifestyle Promoter Lifelong Learning Qualification. The job purpose of this Healthy Lifestyle
Promoter was identified as ‘To promote healthy lifestyle information to communities and individuals using
available tools and educational materials.’ Within this job purpose, units of learning outcomes were
developed focusing on organisational, legal and ethical issues associated with the role; the
promotion of healthy lifestyles; lifestyles assessment tools and sources of healthy lifestyle
information. These draft Standards were then put out to external consultation across the European
fitness and physical activity sector before being established on EuropeActive’s Sector
Qualifications Framework. It is hope they will be the basis for the training of an army of Healthy
Lifestyle Promoters across Europe who will positively impact on the health and vitality of
European citizens for many years to come.
FITNESS.BE
Fitness.be is the working name of the Belgian
Fitness Organisation, which provides social and
economic support to the fitness sector. It does so
via the not-for-profit professional association
24
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
BBF&W (Belgian professional association for fitness and wellness companies), and by providing
training courses and continuing education via the Fitness.be Faculty. Their main objectives are
to represent interests, provide services and issue communications related to the structured
promotion of a professional and high-quality fitness sector. Fitness.be aims to position the fitness
sector as a fully-fledged economic entity within the preventive healthcare sector.
Vision: Fitness, group fitness and personal training provide an ideal solution to the increasing
sedentary nature prevalent in society. This safe, efficient, pleasant type of exercise, suitable for
everyone, can help us all strive towards a healthier society.
Mission: To use the fitness and group fitness offering to raise awareness of healthy physical
exercise, without the use of performance- and image-enhancing drugs. To convince fitness
professionals, partners, the government and its officials to work together to achieve this goal, based
on the quality of exercise on offer.
The role of Fitness.be in the New Health Project
As a project partner, our task is to provide feedback, translations and dissemination. We will also
be rolling out the project in Belgium, where we have already made major advances in terms of
getting out the word with respect to the lifestyle scan – over 10,000 people in Belgium have already
completed the scan, making them aware of their strengths and, more importantly, their points for
attention. The scan has also shown them how they can turn certain weaknesses into strengths.
The New Health Project can have a major impact when it comes to awareness on the part of all
participants. Health statistics in Belgium are not heading in the right direction, with cases of obesity,
diabetes and cardiovascular disease rising each year. Furthermore, these diseases of affluence are
afflicting people at an increasingly younger age.
Our mission is to make as many people as possible aware of their unhealthy lifestyle and to provide
solutions, which is why we will train as many people as we can to become healthy lifestyle
promoters so that they in turn can help others to make the move to a healthier and more active
lifestyle
The Sport Sciences School of Rio Maior - ESDRM
The Sport Sciences School of Rio Maior (ESDRM) is a
Portuguese public higher education school integrated in the
Polytechnic Institute of Santarém (IPSantarém)
(https://siesdrm.ipsantarem.pt/esdrm/si_main). ESDRM
was establish in 1997, in the city of Rio Maior (near to the
capital – Lisbon), as known by “City of Sport” (https://www.desmor.pt/).
25
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Actually, ESDRM has 5 bachelor’s degrees: Physical Activity and Lifestyle (European bachelor);
Sport Coach; Fitness & Health; Outdoor Activities and Sport Tourism; Sport Management); and 3
master’s degrees: Sport Coach; Physical Activity and Health; Sport and Recreation; and also 1
professional programmes (EQF-level 5) in Surfing.
ESDRM is integrated in the consortium of 3 research centre’s: Research Centre in Sport, Health &
Human Development (CIDESD) (https://cidesd.utad.pt/); Research Centre for Quality of Life
(CIEQV) (https://www.cieqv.pt/pt/inicio/); and Centre for Tourism, Research, Development
and Innovation (CiTUR) (http://citur-tourismresearch.com/pt/), all of them supported by the
National Foundation for Science & Technology (FCT).
ESDRM Key activities are Training/education; Research; Consultation and community projects;
Development of the technical, scientific, and cultural exchange with national and international,
private and public institutions, which have similar goals; Participation in national and international
cooperation I&D projects. ESDRM has: 135 staff members (42 teachers full-time; 73 teachers parttime; 20 staff workers); 1019 students (887 bachelor; 95 masters; 37 EQF-level 5 programmes).
Susana Franco and Carla Borrego are Associate Professors of ESDRM, and Vera Simões is
Assistant Professor of ESDRM, and work in New Health 2022 project. Their activities in the
project are: Participate in development of EuropeActive occupational standards for Healthy
Lifestyle Promoter; Translation the course and voiceover into Portuguese; Support researcher in
coach program, portal, app; Educating Healthy Lifestyle Promoter; Evaluation report.
Particularly in Portugal, more than half of the population are obese or overweight, and more than
2/3 of the population never engage in exercise or play sport. Also, Portuguese eating habits have
been getting worse, and levels of depression and anxiety are increasing. It’s urgent to educate
Portuguese population for them to improve their healthy lifestyle. The Portuguese have worse and
worse lifestyles, with the consequent quality of life, diseases and financial burden for governments
to treat. It’s necessary to invest more on health prevention. That’s why New Health 2022 project
it’s so important to contribute to this objective.
LSKA – Lietuvos sveikatingumo klubų asociacija
Lithuanian Association of Health and Fitness
Clubs (www.lska.lt) was established on April
4th, 2013 m. The members of LSKA are the
biggest chains of H&F clubs in Lithuania
(“Impuls”, “Lemon Gym”, “Gym+”, “Apelsinas”), also other sports clubs, studios, exercise
professionals. Since 2014, LSKA is a member of Europe Active. The mission of LSKA is to engage
more Lithuanian population to fitness and physical activity for better health and quality of life. The
main aims of LSKA are:
26
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
To promote the active lifestyle and sports activities of the Lithuanian people and initiate
projects for health promotion and physical literacy
To increase attendance at sports and health clubs
To improve the country's legal and tax framework governing the activities of fitness clubs
To introduce classification indicators for fitness clubs
To introduce qualification requirements in the work of employees of fitness clubs, and to
contribute to the development of educational programs
To publicize the positive image of health and fitness activities and conduct research on the
Lithuanian fitness market
To collaborate with sports, health and educational institutions to achieve interrelated goals.
LSKA is a mediator between H&F clubs and universities, training providers, annually provides
conferences, educational lectures, webinars for fitness professionals and general population.
EuropeActive on 2015 signed the Memorandum of Understanding and Trust with the LSKA.
LSKA started to be recognized as the approved body of EREPS (European Register of Exercise
Professionals) in the country, ensuring that fitness professionals hold the required European level of
qualification. Being a part of EuropeActive, EREPS and participating in various European H&F
events, LSKA shares with the newest worldwide fitness trends, training principles and methods,
and ensures the highest competency level for exercise professionals and employers. LSKA
successfully participated in the international projects:
•
•
•
Erasmus+ Sport programme supported by EC Project – ALCIS - Promoting Action
Learning for Children in School (2015) and ALCIS 2 (2016)
International project supported by EASE, UNI Europa Sport and EC - Supporting the test
phase of the European Sectoral Social Dialogue Committee for sport and active leisure
(2016-2017).
Erasmus+ Sport programme supported by EC Project – Let’s #BEACTIVE (2018-2021).
LSKA is actively involved in many processes related to the increasing impact of community-based
interventions in healthy ageing through a more active society. The proportion of physical inactivity
of citizens in the EU and Lithuania remains unacceptably high. Around half of Lithuania citizens
do not exercise or play sport at all. In addition, Lithuania faces with low level of health literacy,
which is associated with less healthy choices, riskier health behaviors, poorer health, higher costs,
and misuse of health services. This might indicate that the message about the importance of sport
and physical activity for an individual's health and wellbeing has still not got through to significant
segments of the population. It is also notable that participation levels are much lower among those
who have lower levels of education, and among those in a more difficult financial situation.
New Health Programme 'Lifestyle is medicine' is to provide sports- and lifestyle organizations,
professionals, volunteers, and consumers with easy to obtain and to understand knowledge and
27
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
tools to improve physical activity and healthy lifestyle. Increasing health and physical literacy
provides citizens with more opportunities to develop personal and collective knowledge and skills,
to create a health-enhancing environment, and health policies. People gain more self-confidence
by making positive decisions about their health, changing their lifestyle and living conditions.
Health literates are more active in economic prosperity, have higher incomes and employment, are
better educated and informed, contribute more to community activities and enjoy better health and
well-being. Therefore, participating in the project for health promotion and physical literacy is
important target for LSKA.
PhD Simona Pajaujiene and PhD Aurimas Maciukas are persons who drive this project In
Lithuania. Simona and Aurimas believe, that with this project Lithuanian inactive part of population
will become more active due to impact of promoters for healthy lifestyle.
Comenius University in Bratislava
Faculty of Physical Education and Sports
Faculty of Physical Education and Sports is a public state-funded academic,
educational and research institution within the oldest Slovak university –
Comenius University in Bratislava. The faculty is a leading institution in
Slovakia within the field of sport sciences and education of sport
professionals cooperating with other key organizations, for instance Slovak
Ministry of Education, Science, Research and Sport of SR, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Slovak
Olympic and Sport Committee and National Sport Centre. Besides education, the research focus
of the faculty with the longest history lies within functional assessment of physical performance
ranging from school children to top athletes, followed by prescription of exercise programs for
various populations. Another main area of scientific activities represents studying the aspects of
physical activity as a preventive and treatment modality. Aging and Lifestyle Diseases Research
Centre has been created in 2013 and in 2020 was open Centre for Active Aging (CAA).
Key activities: all university level education of sports and PE professionals (coaches, P.E. teachers),
research in majority of sport sciences fields (exercise physiology, sport humanities, antidoping,
health oriented exercise programs), promotion of physical activity for health, collaboration at
national and international level with universities and other sport related bodies (e.g. Slovak
Olympics Committee, Slovak Anti-doping Agency, FIEPS, sports associations and federations),
development of national guidelines for physical activity (e.g. children, elderly population)
Affiliations: Slovak Anti-doping Agency, National Sport Centre, Slovak Olympic and Sport
Committee, 32 Erasmus+ university bilateral agreements, FIEPS, ICSSPE, Slovak Ice Hockey
Federation, Slovak Canoe Association, Slovak Weightlifting Association, Slovak Basketball
Association, Slovak Volleyball Federation, Slovak Swimming Federation, etc.
28
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
Exercise as a Medicine – Selected Findings from Literature
Review in Slovakia
Jana Labudová - Ľubomíra Benčuriková - Ľuboš Grznár - Matúš Putala Eva Rýzková - Martin Belás – Adriana Kaplánová
Comenius University in Bratislava, Faculty of Physical Education and Sports, Slovakia
e-mail: jana.labudova@uniba.sk
Abstract
The “Exercise as a medicine” section deals with the positive effects of exercise on the health of
people of different ages or people who have been diagnosed with different types of the disease.
Properly selected types of exercise programs of moderate intensity of continuous physical activity
or high-intensity interval physical exercise with a longer duration of the training unit seem to
demonstrably improve somatic indicators, contribute to better physical and functional performance
of people and eliminate harmful effects of long-term sedentary work or unhealthy lifestyle. Longterm inactivity can result in a number of health complications and cause cardiovascular as well as
respiratory problems. It can also reduce the elasticity of muscles and their atrophies, inflammatory
processes in the body or osteoporosis.
Key words: Exercise, health, lifestyle, medicine
29
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
In article which is focus on active older adults Kováčiková et al. (2020) constate that limited
physical functional performance as a consequence of aging is considered as a possible contributor
to falls in older adults, even in physically active ones. Purpose: This study determines which clinical
and laboratory tests simulating activities of daily living could distinguish age-related differences in
functional performance of physically active older adults. Material and Methods: In this study, 30
participants aged 60–69 years (23 females and 7 males; age 65.5 ± 1.9 years; height 168.0 ± 10.4
cm; weight 74.7 ± 13.0 kg) and 20 participants aged 70–79 years (14 females and 6 males; age 74.9
± 5.0 years; height 166.7 ± 10.5 cm; weight 70.2 ± 12.7 kg) underwent battery of clinical and
laboratory tests. Time to complete the five-repetition sit-to-stand test (5RSTS), maximal reaching
distance in the frontal and sagittal plane and centre of pressure (CoP) sway in the anteroposterior
(AP) and mediolateral (ML) directions during bipedal stance were evaluated. In addition, CoP sway
and its AP and ML components during stair descent (CoPAP and CoPML) and in the first 5 s of
re-stabilization (CoPAP-5 and CoPML-5) were evaluated. Results: Older adults over 70 years
of age achieved significantly longer time in the 5RSTS test (12.3%, P = .035, d =.632) and had
significantly higher values of CoP sway in the first 5 s of re-stabilization (CoPAP-5 19.4%, P =
.003, d = .889; CoPML-5 15.7%, P = .044, d = .593) compared to those aged 60–69 years.
Conclusions: Differences in balance control attributable to ageing were more readily seen under
more challenging conditions. Only the 5RSTS test and stair descent from one step onto a
compliant surface test were able to reflect differences in functional performance between two
groups of physically active older adults.
Aim of Oreská et al. (2020) research focused on physical performance in the elderly was to identify
the effect of the multimodal strength-endurance and aerobic-coordination training on the
parameters of physical performance in the elderly, such as maximal walking speed and 5x sit-tostand test. Volunteers were distributed into two groups. 1) training group took part in the 12-week
multimodal strength-endurance and aerobic-coordination training programme, and the 2) control
group participated in the stretching exercises. According to the effect of the training programme,
the training group improved in the 10m maximal walking speed test and 5x sit-to-stand test. The
study may have a beneficial impact on the commercial area, for coaches and medical practitioners,
who work with the elderly population.
Sedentary behaviour of older people was topic of research of Pechová et al. (2019). Older adults
are considered the most sedentary and the most fragile group in our society. Understanding how
seasonal and meteorological factors impact the sedentary behaviour (SB) is important for
developing of strategies to improve their health. Therefore, the purposes of the present study were
to examine: (1) potential spring-autumn variation in SB patterns among older adults from Central
Europe, and (2) possible interactions between weather conditions and SB patterns. Methods: 83
participants aged 55+ were repeatedly measured by accelerometers for one year – in spring and
autumn months. Data about SB, physical activity (PA) and meteorological factors (daylight length,
average precipitation and temperature) have been collected during both seasons. SB intervals
(bouts) with a duration of 1–4, 5–9, 10–19, 20–29, 30–39, 40–59, and 60+ minutes were extracted
to observe the spring-autumn differences. Results: In older adults, total sedentary time was 412min
and 435min in spring and autumn, respectively (p<0.001). In both seasons, approximately 85% of
30
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
daily bout frequency comprised bouts ≤10 minutes long. Regarding to sedentary bout duration,
about 45% of the daily sedentary time was accumulated in bouts ≤10 minutes long. No significant
differences between spring and autumn about the duration of sedentary bouts (p>0.05) and
frequency of sedentary bouts lasting ≥20 minutes were found. Looking at weather conditions, SB
was significantly lower when the temperature was above 10°C in the autumn (p<0.01). Daylight
length and average precipitation were significantly associated with total sedentary time; however,
the associations differed in seasons. Conclusions: Although total sedentary time was slightly higher
in autumn compared to spring, SB patterns did not differ significantly between spring and autumn.
Overall, weather conditions appear to be important factors related to SB in elderly. Both, total
sedentary time and SB patterns in relation to weather conditions should be considered when
targeting older adults’ SB and PA interventions in different seasons.
Agility performance in middle-aged and older subjects was topic of study of Horníková, Doležajová
and Zemková (2018). Both reaction time and agility times increase with advancing age. However,
it is not whether and to what extent regular practise of sport such as table tennis contributes to
faster decision-making and movement speed in middle-aged and older adults. The aim of this study
was to compare agility time in table tennis players and sedentary subjects of different ages and
also to investigate the relationship between agility time and age in these groups. Forty-four young,
early middle-aged, late middle-aged and older table tennis players and forty-eight sedentary subjects
of matched age performed the agility test consisting of movement reactions to visual stimuli.
ANCOVA revealed a significant difference in agility time between table tennis players and
sedentary subjects when the effect of age was controlled (F(1, 89) = 46.1, p < .001). Agility time
was significantly shorter in early middle-aged (435.8 ± 35.6 ms and 483.8 ± 36.5 ms, respectively;
p = .006), late middle-aged (481.0 ± 36.8 ms and 530.7 ± 31.8 ms, respectively; p = .004) and older
(500.9 ± 24.4 ms and 564.5 ± 44.9 ms, respectively; p = .007) table tennis players than sedentary
subjects. In addition, there was a significant relationship between agility time and age in sedentary
subjects (rp = .73, p < .001) and table tennis players (rp = .53, p < .001). Agility time is shorter in
early middle-aged, late middle-aged and older (≥ 60 years) table tennis players compared to agematched sedentary subjects (9.9%, 9.4%, and 11.3%, respectively).
Nemček, Labudová and Kraček (2012) were focused in their research on quality of life. Life
satisfaction of a man is closely related to the assessment of quality of life, but it also reflects
the lifestyle, which should include the regular participation in physical activity. Therefore, this
research contributes to knowledge of the life satisfaction of the population in relation to sport. The
largest percentage of our group (n = 452) consisted of recreational athletes (59.5 %), 25.7 % of all
respondents were elite athletes and 14.8 %, sedentary people. To collect an empirical data we used
a standardized questionnaire SWLS. We evaluated the significance of differences between the level
of life satisfaction and groups of respondents, by the Chi – square. The results showed notable
differences in levels of life satisfaction in terms of sports, where a significantly higher satisfaction
with life, showed the group of people regularly performing sport activity (elite and recreational
levels) compared to the population favouring a sedentary lifestyle. Sport and active lifestyles are
important resources that contribute to increase life satisfaction of citizens.
31
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Evaluation of the effect of aerobic exercise was topic of research of Lipková and Kyselovičová
(2011). The aim of the study was to evaluate the effect of aerobic exercise on blood (BP) and
intraocular pressure (IOP). A group of six female patients, mean age 54 + 3,4 years, with
pharmacologically treated open angle glaucoma were enrolled in 3-months aerobic exercise
program (formed by aerobics and fit ball exercises) with frequency of sessions 2-times per week.
The values of intraocular pressure varied before intervention in the normal range. After the
program IOP was reduced more, with exception of one slight increase, but the value does not
exceed the standard. There were no differences in blood pressure between input and output values.
No significant pressure variation during the day, neither hypotension was found out. In patients
with borderline low blood pressure a slight increase in systolic and diastolic pressure was recorded
after the intervention. Regarding the impact of acute exercise on blood pressure the unambiguous
assessment cannot be done. However, in some cases the pressure was increased immediately after
the exercise, and a reduction in systolic and diastolic pressure was recorded as well. The results of
our study suggest a positive impact of aerobic program on retention the risk factors of glaucoma
under the control.
Vandáková, Péliová and Kyselovičová (2018) was focused in their study on physical activity of
women. In the study theiy determined the influence of a special, 3 months training program on
selected somatic and metabolic parameters of two different age groups in adult women. Based on
an invitation offered in the “Mrs.Sporty” fitness centre in Senec, 180 women volunteered in the
research. Volunteers were divided in two groups based on age: the “A” group comprised of 90
women aged 25-45, while the “B” group consisted of 90 women aged 46-65. For the period of
three months, all women regularly participated in a special aerobic circuit training three times a
week. By comparing the input and the output data, we monitored changes in observed somatic
characteristics (body weight, BMI, visceral fat level, total fat level, active muscular tissue, WHR)
and metabolic characteristics (basal metabolic rate, metabolic age). In both groups, the results for
somatic parameters confirmed a statistically significant decrease of values (p≤0.01) in favour of the
output data. In case of most parameters, comparing differences between groups proved statistically
insignificant. Significant differences (p≤0.01) in favour of older women were detected in case of
the WHR. In both groups, the results for metabolic parameters of the showed an insignificant
increase of basal metabolic rate values, along with a statistically significant decrease of metabolic
age (p≤0.01). Discovered differences in metabolic parameters between the groups proved to be
statistically insignificant. Based on the result we conclude that regular aerobic activities combined
with targeted exercise, particularly the “Mrs.Sporty” training program, have a demonstrably
positive effect on changes in selected somatic and metabolic parameters in the adult healthy
women.
Physical activity of women was topic also of study of Rýzková and Labudová (2019). Aquafitness is
a vertical position physical exercise in the water. It is still growing in popularity because of a positive
influence on the physical fitness and health of various population groups. The aim of work was to
investigate the effects of aquafitness programs in shallow water with moderate intensity continuous
and high intensity interval physical loading on the selected biological and motor parameters of
postmenopausal women, and thereby contribute to widen this field of knowledge. Thirty
32
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
postmenopausal women participated. The groups were continuous exercise (n = 10), interval
exercise (n = 10), and control (n = 10). Exercise groups completed a 12-week aquafitness programs
with continuous or interval physical loading and a frequency of sessions three times per week. The
control group with sedentary behaviour did not participate in any organized physical activity. We
examined selected parameters using the methods of measurement and testing. Lipid profile
included total cholesterol, HDL-cholesterol, triglycerides (all measured by Reflotron Plus), LDLcholesterol (Friedewald equation) and the ratio of total cholesterol to HDL cholesterol. The level
of physical fitness was measured by the PWC150 test and the motor tests. After 12 weeks
of aquafitness programs, both continuous exercise and interval exercise, showed a significant
decrease in waist circumference (p > 0,01), hip circumference (p > 0,05), body fat (p > 0,01),
triglycerides (p > 0,05 for continuous exercise group, p > 0,01 for interval exercise group),
cholesterol ratio (p > 0,01 for continuous exercise group, p > 0,05 for interval exercise group).
Both exercise groups significantly improved dynamic balance, flexibility of the hamstrings and
lumbar spine and strength endurance of the lower extremities (p > 0,05). Only continuous exercise
group significantly decreased their body weight, BMI, total cholesterol and significantly increased
their HDL-cholesterol (p > 0,05). Only interval exercise group significantly increased their aerobic
power (p > 0,01). Based on our findings and in coherence with authors researching similar
problematic, we can recommend implementation of moderate intensity continuous physical
loading with longer duration of training unit as well as high intensity interval physical loading
(Tabata) with shorter duration of training unit into aquafitness programs for women after
menopause.
Rýzková, Labudová, Grznár and Šmída (2018) were focused in their study on physical activity of
college students. The aim of the study was to investigate the effect of a 10week aquafitness program with the inclusion of high intensity interval training on selected
biological and motor parameters of female college students. Sixteen volunteers (age: 21.1± 3.2
years, body height: 171.0 ± 5.6 cm and body mass: 60.62 ± 5.5 kg) were randomly divided into two
groups. A control group (CG, n=8) continued with their regular daily activities without
involvement in any physical exercise program. An experimental group (EG, n=8) completed a 10week shallow water training program with a frequency of 50-minute sessions twice per week. Three
blocks of HIIT (Tabata format) were included into the continuous aerobic training unit. The
physical activity intensity level was measured by the heart rate monitor (Polar RS400). EG showed
a significant decrease in waist circumference, body fat percentage, waist to hip ratio, resting heart
rate, an improvement of static balance, flexibility of the hamstrings and lumbar spine (p ˂ 0.05)
and dynamic balance (p ˂ 0.001). Aquafitness with inclusion of HIIT can offer significant benefits
in physical fitness of female college students.
Physical activity of male college students was topic of research of Tibenská, Nagyová and Ludvig
(2019). The research was focused on the changes in some anthropometric characteristics of
students of the Faculty of Pharmacy, Comenius University in Bratislava. The investigated set
consisted of 35 male students in a 1st year of study, who’s mean (average) age was 19.05 ± 0.82.
After successful passing four semesters of the "Physical Education and Sport" course, decrease in
thickness of skin fold Biceps and Supraspinal was investigated, respectively. There was found
33
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
increase in thickness of skin fold Triceps, Subscapular and index of centrality value as well. None
of the changes observed was considered statistically significant.
Pělucha a Hančák (2019) were in their research focused on physical activity of college students.
The aim of their work was to find out the developmental trends of aerobic performance in the
seven-year period of 1st year students of FCHPT STU in Bratislava and to find out the differences
between men and women. The research sample consisted of 3330 students of FCHPT STU (967
men and 2363 women). The aerobic performance was calculated based on endurance Beep test (20
m sections per signal) (Moravec et. al. 2002). The developmental tendencies of aerobic performance
are similar in men and women. Both show a variable character, with a decreasing trend. When
determining the effect of a seven-year period on aerobic performance, we found out significant
relationships in both men and women (χ2 = 39.59; p <0.05; χ2 = 86.9; p <0.01). When looking for
the relationship between the levels of aerobic performance in the seven-year period, we found out
a significant relationship in both men and women (χ2 = 39.59; p <0.05; χ2 = 86.9; p <0,01). Looking
for differences in aerobic performance between men and women, we found out statistically
significant differences in all categories (p <0,01).
Physical activity of college female students was topic of the study of Harmadyová, Scíranka and
Pavlíková (2019). The aim of study was to extend findings about free time activities of the female
students of selected faculties of Comenius University. 200 female students of Faculty of Natural
Sciences and Faculty of Arts of Comenius University in Bratislava participated. To obtain empirical
data, we used a non-standardized questionnaire. To process data the Chi-quadrate (χ 2) was used.
Based on the results, we found out that the most frequent leisure activities include reading books,
hang out with friends and listening to music, and sports was chosen for the fourth place. The most
important aspect of sport was the health aspect. We found a statistically significant.
Research focus on physical fitness was made by Šmída, Macejková and Rýzková (2018). Aim of
this study was to investigate changes in blood sugar level after aerobic workout on rowing
ergometer. Tested group consisted of Slovak rowers (n: 6, average age: 22.2±4.9 years, average
height: 183.5±4.0 cm, average weight: 79.5±6.0 kg). Group undertook 4 tests: lactate
curve, glycaemic profile, rowing exercise at intensity of anaerobic threshold (IANT) and rowing
exercise at intensity of aerobic threshold (IAT). Blood sugar level was measured during 120 min.
intervals before workout and after workout with Accu-Chek Active unit. We used nonparametric
Wilcoxon signed-rank test (p<0.05) for dependent files for evaluation of the results. Results have
shown that the difference between average fluctuation of blood sugar during 120 minutes postand pre-workout is not significant. Difference of glycaemia (by 2.2 mmol.l-1, 46% resp.)
immediately before and after the IANT test was significant (p<0.05). Difference of glycaemia (by
0.4 mmol.l-1, 7% resp.) immediately before the IAT test and after the test was not significant.
Research on physical fitness was presented by Baran (2015). The aim of his work was to assess the
most common injuries, which occur during training and competition in diving, to analyse their
causes and propose a model for strength training for divers, which would have contributed
to minimise the risk of these injuries.
34
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
The same topic has study of Ferenc (2017). Today people are giving hight importance to stretching
in sport or physiotherapy sphere. At the end of the training, most athletes do not like to do
stretching exercise or they don´t have a time for it. Likewise, in some sports is stretching on
secondary place despite of it is prevention of the damage and activity for improving performance in
sport. From a physiological aspect is confirmed, that doing stretching immediately after the end of
training, can help to faster regeneration and relaxation of the muscles. In many cases, it has been
shown, that the well-chosen type of stretching before to starting of training has a positive effect
on the performance in sport. In his contribution it was strive to importance and irreplaceability of
stretching exercises performed before or immediately after the end of any type of sport, whether
winter or summer.
Physical fitness was also topic of the research of Belás and Rýzková (2018). The aim of the research
was to assess the impact of a long-term training program built from conventional cycling on the
development of the current population. Trainer's effectiveness indicators were general exercise
performance tests. The experimental set achieved statistically significant gains in general exercise
performance tests after completing the training program when compared to a control group that
did not complete the training program.
Physical activity and bone metabolism was topic of research of Kovárová and Hamar (2015). The
susceptibility of bones to external mechanical stress represents the possibility of influencing bone
tissue even without pharmacological preparations. The paper describes the structure of bone tissue
and the nature of the mechanical stress that elicits an osteogenic response in the body. Synthesizes
knowledge about the influence of age and regular physical activity on bone density. Finally, it offers
partial results of research monitoring the acute response of bone metabolism to the strength
training.
Dobay, Bánhidi and Šimonek (2018) were focus in their study on health habits of adults. The
purpose of the research was to present results of an international study are presented regarding the
traveling habits of adults who participated in outdoor education programs during their childhood.
Materials and methods: in the survey, 2965 Slovak and 2404 Hungarian adults were studied to
determine if there is any correlation between school experience and travel behaviour. In both
countries, there are serious discussions as to why school education should offer and support school
camps, which teach children sport skills while they are away from home. The data were processed
using the Statistica program. Results: In both countries, one out of every five individuals (21.6%
SK; 22.2% HU) participating in the study take a vacation in the summer months. As children, many
(84.5% SK, 92% HU) of the participants took part in school water sport camps. Of these
participants, 65.8% of the Slovaks and 60.2% of the Hungarians rated the time spent there as very
positive. Among the positive values, 44.2% indicated that the mountains were a favourite and
frequently a chosen travel destination. Twenty-five percent of the respondents spend more than
four hours hiking during their vacation. Conclusions: Based on the results of our survey we can
conclude that the camps in the mountains can be considered as a useful outdoor program (5-7
days), where the students can experience traveling, living together and having fun.
35
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
References
BARAN, I. (2015). Injury when jumping into the water and minimizing their specialized training.
In: Technika a metodika zimných a letných športov v prírode 2015 [Technique and methodology of winter
and
summer
sports
in
nature
2015]
©
Fakulta telesnej výchovy a športu,
Univerzita Komenského v Bratislave, [Faculty of Physical Education and Sports Commenius
University in Bratisalva], 2015. ISBN 978-80-223-3986-5
BELÁS, M. & RÝZKOVÁ, E (2018). Development of conditional skills of adolescents through
conditional cycling and cycloturism. In: Technika a metodika zimných a letných športov v prírode
2018 [Technique and methodology of winter and summer sports in nature 2018] ©
Fakulta telesnej výchovy a športu, Univerzita Komenského v Bratislave, [Faculty of Physical
Education and Sports Commenius University in Bratisalva 2018, ISBN 978-80-223-4643-6
DOBAY, B., BÁNHIDI, M. & ŠIMONEK, J. (2018). Effects of outdoor education on traveling
habits of adults in Slovakia and Hungary. In: Journal of Physical Education and Sport®
(JPES), 18(2), Art 107, pp. 731 - 738, 2018 online ISSN: 2247 - 806X; p-ISSN: 2247 – 8051;
ISSN - L = 2247 - 8051 © JPES
HARMADYOVÁ, B., SCIRANKA, J. & PAVLÍKOVÁ, A. (2019). Športovanie ako súčasť
voľnočasových aktivít študentiek vybraných fakúlt Univerzity Komenského. [ Sport as a part
of free-time activities of the students of selected faculties of Comenius University] In: Telesná
výchova a šport [Physical education and sport], Bratislava: Slovenská vedecká spoločnosť pre TV
a šport [Slovak Scientific Society for PE and Sport], Volume XXIX, No. 2/2019, p. 25-28,
ISSN 1335-2245.
HORNÍKOVÁ, H., DOLEŽAJOVÁ, L. & ZEMKOVÁ, E. (2018). Playing table tennis
contributes to better agility performance in middle-aged and older subjects. Acta Gymnica,
48(1), 15-20.
FERENC, I. (2017). Stretching as prevention of the demage of during the winter and summer
sporting. In: Technika a metodika zimných a letných športov v prírode 2017 [Technique and methodology
of winter and summer sports in nature 2017]
© Fakulta telesnej výchovy a športu,
Univerzita Komenského v Bratislave, [Faculty of Physical Education and Sports Commenius
University in Bratisalva], 2017, ISBN 978-80-223-4467-8
KOVÁČIKOVÁ, Z., JANURA, M., SARVESTAN, J., ZEMKOVÁ, E. & PECHO, J. (2020).
Tests revealing age-related changes in the functional performance of physically active older
adults. In: Journal of Physical Education and Sport® (JPES), Vol.20 (3), Art 209, pp. 1522 1528, 2020 online ISSN: 2247 - 806X; p-ISSN: 2247 – 8051; ISSN - L = 2247 - 8051 © JPES
KOVÁROVÁ, J. & HAMAR, D. (2015). Vplyv pohybovej aktivity na kosti [Influence of physical
activity on bones] In: Telesná výchova a šport [Physical education and sport], Bratislava: Slovenská
vedecká spoločnosť pre TV a šport [Slovak Scientific Society for PE and Sport], Volume
XXV, No. 1/2015, p. 23 - 26, ISSN 1335-2245.
LIPKOVÁ, J. & KYSELOVIČVÁ, O. (2011). The effect of physical activity on blood and
intraocular pressures in patients with glaucoma. In:
Acta Facultatis Educationis Physicae Universitatis Comenianae. Bratislava, 2011, p. 511. ISBN 978-80-223-3109-8
36
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
NEMČEK, D., LABUDOVÁ, J. & KRAČEK, S. (2012). Life satisfaction of sedentary and
physically active population. In: Acta Facultatis Educationis Physicae Universitatis
Comenianae. Bratislava, 2012, p. 61-71. ISBN 978-80-223-3229-3.
ORESKÁ, L., VAJDA, M., SLOBODOVÁ, L., TIRPÁKOVÁ, V., CVEČKA, J., UKROPCOVÁ,
B., UKROPEC, J. & SEDLIAK, M. (2020). Vplyv 12-týždňového multimodálneho tréningu
na motorické parametre pohybovej výkonnosti ľudí vo vyššom veku. [Influence of 12-week
multimodal training on motor parameters of physical performance of elderly people] In:
Telesná výchova a šport [Physical education and sport], Bratislava: Slovenská vedecká spoločnosť
pre TV a šport [Slovak Scientific Society for PE and Sport], Volume XXX, No. 1/2020, p. 814, ISSN 1335-2245.
PECHOVÁ, J., PELCLOVÁ, J., DYGRÝN, J., ZAJĄC-GAWLAK, I. & TLUČÁKOVÁ, L.
(2019). Sedentary behavior patterns and spring-autumn seasonality in older Central
European adults. Journal of Physical Education and Sport® (JPES), Vol.19 (issue 2), Art
158, pp. 1092 – 1098, 2019 online ISSN: 2247 - 806X; p-ISSN: 2247 – 8051; ISSN - L =
2247 - 8051 © JPES
PĚLUCHA, R. & HANČÁK, J. (2019). Vývojové tendencie úrovne aeróbnej výkonnosti
v sedemročnom období študentov FCHPT STU v Bratislave. [ Developmental trends in the level
of aerobic performance in the seven-year period of students FCHPT STU in Bratislava] In: Telesná výchova
a šport [Physical education and sport], Bratislava: Slovenská vedecká spoločnosť pre TV a šport
[Slovak Scientific Society for PE and Sport], Volume XXIX, No. 2/2019, p. 29-32, ISSN
1335-2245.
RÝZKOVÁ, E., LABUDOVÁ, J., GRZNÁR, Ľ. & ŠMÍDA, M. (2018). Effects of aquafitness with
high intensity interval training on physical fitness. In: Journal of Physical Education and
Sport® (JPES), 18 Supplement issue 1, Art 51, pp. 373 - 381, 2017 online ISSN: 2247 - 806X;
p-ISSN: 2247 – 8051; ISSN - L = 2247 - 8051 © JPES
RÝZKOVÁ, E. & LABUDOVÁ, J. (2019). Vplyv pohybových programov vo vodnom prostredí
na biologické a motorické ukazovatele žien v strednom veku [Effect of aquafitnes on the
selected biologic and motoric parameters of middleaged female]
[Monography], Bratislava: Slovenská vedecká spoločnosť pre TV a šport [Slovak Scientific
Society for PE and Sport], pp. 94. ISBN 978-80-89075-80-5.
ŠMÍDA, M., MACEJKOVÁ, Y. & RÝZKOVÁ, E. (2018). Aerobic workout on a rowing
ergometer and blood sugar level. In: Journal of Physical Education and Sport® (JPES), 18
Supplement issue 1, Art 54, pp.392 - 396, 2018online ISSN: 2247 - 806X; p-ISSN: 2247 –
8051; ISSN - L = 2247 - 8051 © JPES
TIBENSKÁ, M., NAGYOVÁ, L. & LUDVIG, D. (2019). Dvojročné zmeny vybraných
somatických ukazovateľov študentov Farmaceutickej fakulty Univerzity Komenského
v Bratislave [Two-Year Changes of Selected Anthropometric Parameters of Students of the
Faculty of Pharmacy, Comenius University in Bratislava] In: Telesná výchova a šport [Physical
education and sport], Bratislava: Slovenská vedecká spoločnosť pre TV a šport [Slovak Scientific
Society for PE and Sport], Volume XXIX, No. 4/2019, p. 40-44, ISSN 1335-2245.
37
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
VANDÁKOVÁ, L., PÉLIOVÁ, K. & KYSELOVIČOVÁ, O. (2018). Vplyv špeciálneho
pohybového programu na vybrané somatické a metabolické ukazovatele žien [The influence
of special training program on selected somatic and metabolic parameters of women]. In:
Telesná výchova a šport [Physical education and sport], Bratislava: Slovenská vedecká spoločnosť
pre TV a šport [Slovak Scientific Society for PE and Sport], Volume XXVIII, No. 2/2018,
p. 15 – 20. ISSN 1335-2245.
38
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
Exercise as a Medicine – Selected Findings from Worldwide
Literature Review
Manel Valcarce-Torrente - 5Francisco Gómez-Almeida - 2Carla Chicau
Borrego - 2Susana Franco - 3Eric Vandenabeele - 3Gert van Reckem 4
Adriana Kaplánová
1
1
Valencian International University, Valencia, Spain
Sport Sciences School of Rio Maior, Polytechnic Institute of Santarém; Life Quality Research Center, Portugal
3
Fitness- BE Wellness & Health, Belgium
4
Comenius University in Bratislava, Faculty of Physical Education and Sports, Slovakia
5
Valgo Sports Consulting, Madrid, Spain
2
Abstract
Research by many experts suggests that the promotion of physical activity, for example, reduces
the risk of sarcopenia, which is characterized by loss of muscle mass, strength and function.
Resistance exercises with load control performed under the supervision of experienced trainers or
physiotherapists have demonstrably eliminated problems caused by the physiological process of
aging or a number of chronic diseases. In addition, research into the susceptibility of bones to
external mechanical stress provides much stimulating information for the development of exercise
programs aimed at injury prevention through special strength training. In addition, physical activity
has been shown to be beneficial for patients with diabetes mellitus. Not only was there a reduction
in the use of drugs or their discontinuation in some patients, but positive findings were also
recorded in somatic parameters and their levels of triglycerides and HDL, “good cholesterol”.
Controlled weight reduction in overweight women has also been shown to be very significant, as
rapid weight loss has been positively correlated with the risk of ring cancer due to estrogen
overproduction.
Key words: Exercise, Medicine, Physical activity
39
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Thomson (2007) wrote that Sarcopenia is the loss of skeletal muscle mass resulting in a reduction
of physical strength and ability to perform activities of daily living. This loss of skeletal muscle leads
to diminished quality of life, loss of independence, and mortality. This loss of independence
represents a high economic healthcare burden and area of high medical need. 33% of people 65+
years are put into long-term healthcare facilities due to their physical frailty and their inability to
maintain prerequisite activities of daily living, with most frail elderly facing > years of self-care
disability at the end of life. If people don’t work their muscles before sarcopenia becomes higher,
it won’t matter the therapy you do because there are no therapy that can restore the muscle in those
conditions. Even though growth hormone replacement to subjects with growth hormone
deficiency has been shown to improve muscle mass, it is less clear if growth hormone replacement
is efficacious in elderly sarcopenic subjects. Nowadays there are no therapies that can help you to
stop sarcopenia when it is already advanced. However, what we can do is do a little bit of physical
activity each day to prevent it from the beginning.
Lurati (2018) constates that nowadays, there are many jobs that involve many hours of sitting
without any physical activity, which leads to a huge amount of health issues and long-term
consequences. These may include cardiovascular and respiratory problems, cell aging, less muscle
elasticity and atrophy, inflammation, osteoporosis, decreased level of hormones and growth
factors, and even psychological outcomes. Due to all these problems, employees need to be
provided with an educational program so they can reduce risks and combine those sedentary
activities with physical guidelines.
Breathing literally completes exercise; with a good breathing technique it proper’s posture, shortens
recovery periods, and helps oxygen to reach muscle cells. The good breathing technique involves
breathing from your stomach, deepen your breath, breath fundamentally through your mouth,
never hold the breath, and don’t believe that groaning or grunting are good signs of quality
breathing (Steven T. Devor, 2010)
Jamie S. McPhee et al. (2016) wrote that evidence shows that regular physical activity improves
physical and mental functions, and reduces the risk of chronic diseases, in a way that also helps
older people to stay active and independent. Despite this, a large majority of older people in the
UK do not get enough physical activity, increasing the risk of bad health, cardiovascular disease,
obesity, falls, cognitive impairment and muscle weakness. In this study, the authors encourage the
authorities to promote physical activity in the elderly, as well as doctors, family and friends, who
can be influential. You can practice different activities, keeping costs low, facilitating enjoyment
and group activities.
Much is known about the benefits of exercise for people with cardiovascular disease. However, it
is known less about the effectiveness of combined aerobic and resistance training. Therefore, this
study compared the results of applying resistance training, aerobic training, and a combined training
of both, in terms of cardiovascular risk factors (Schroeder at al. 2019). The study showed that a
combined aerobic and resistance training, of as little as 8 weeks, can provide more complete
40
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
benefits in terms of cardiovascular risk reduction than exclusively aerobic or exclusively resistance
training.
In recent decades, there has been a progressive increase in the proportion of older people in the
population, leading to an increase in patients with non-communicable diseases. (Nomura at al.
2018). This article focuses on sarcopenia, which is the decrease in muscle mass in the lower
extremities. Furthermore, diabetes has been shown to enhance sarcopenia. Therefore, in this study
it is considered necessary to promote the use of physical activity to reduce the risk of suffering
from both sarcopenia and diabetes, through resistance exercises, always under the supervision of
exercise professionals and physiotherapists, controlling loads to avoid greater risks or possible
injuries. Finally, they conclude that one of the main problems is the motivation of patients to carry
out physical activity, which is why it is one of the most important challenges.
Due Goh et al. (2019) exercise is an effective treatment for osteoarthritis, although its effects may
vary depending on each patient. The objective of this study was to carry out a bibliographic review
of clinical trials to evaluate the efficacy of exercise in terms of pain, functionality, performance and
quality of life in patients with knee and hip osteoarthritis. It was concluded that exercise
significantly reduces pain and improves functionality, performance and quality of life for people
with knee and hip osteoarthritis, after an 8-week program. These effects continue to strengthen
after 2 months, although they slowly diminish. However, treatment continues to work as a
preventive method against the effects of osteoarthritis. Furthermore, it has been observed that
younger subjects benefit more from physical activity therapy.
In review study of Cornelissen & Smart (2013) the effects of endurance, dynamic endurance,
combination training, and isometric training on blood pressure were examined. In this way, the
objectives were to compare and quantify the changes in blood pressure for each type of training.
For this, clinical trials were studied that applied these types of workouts and that lasted more than
4 weeks, in healthy adults. It was concluded that conventional resistance training, dynamic
resistance training and isometric resistance training reduce both systolic blood pressure and
diastolic blood pressure. The combined training only lowered diastolic blood pressure.
Additionally, other studies suggest that isometric resistance training has the potential to achieve the
greatest reductions in systolic blood pressure.
Lack of physical activity is one of the main causes of obesity and functional disability in the elderly.
A study by Marcos-Pardo, Martínez-Rodríguez, and Gil-Arias (2018) examined the impact of a 12week motivational resistance training program on adherence and body composition in the elderly.
The experimental group significantly reduced its percentage of fat mass and increased muscle mass
compared to the control group. The motivational resistance training program for older people has
led to positive significant changes at the physical, psychological and social levels.
Martins at al. (2020) show that physical activity (PA) and sedentary behaviors (SB) influence health.
Since most people engage in different combinations of both behaviors every day, understanding
the socio-demographic characteristics of adults with distinct PA and sitting time (ST) patterns is
41
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
important to contribute to evidence-based planning of public health strategies. Data from a
national survey on diet and activity behaviours (IAN-AF, 2015/16) including 1724 adults (50.5%
women, 18–64 years) from a representative sample of Portuguese adults was used in this study.
Participants were interviewed face-to-face, and the International Physical Activity Questionnaire
(IPAQ) was used. Logistic regression examined the associations between socio-demographic
factors each of the four-low/high PA-ST groups. PA low/high categories were defined as in IPAQ,
while ST low/high categories were defined according to ST tertiles (≤180 min/day, ≥360
min/day). A ‘higher risk’ behaviour pattern (low PA/high ST) was present in 37.3% of the adults
and was likely associated with a middle household income, and with having 12 or more years of
education. The ‘lower risk’ (high PA/low ST) represented 26.6% of the sample and was likely
associated with middle-aged adults and with having a lower educational level. Being male, young
and highly educated was related to being physically active and spending large amounts of time in
ST. Besides adding to the body of mixed evidence on this theme, the identification of the sociodemographic factors associated with each PA/ST pattern will permit national public health
authorities to define policies and tailored actions to promote PA and reduce ST.
Study of Teixeira at al. (2020) describes levels of self-reported physical activity, frequency of
selected opportunistic nonsedentary behaviors, and preferences of leisure-time activities in a
representative sample of Portuguese adults, using data from a national survey on diet and activity
behaviors (National Food, Nutrition and Physical Activity Survey, IAN-AF, 2015–2016). Methods:
Participants were 3873 Portuguese adults (1827 men). They were interviewed face to face, and the
short version of the International Physical Activity Questionnaire was used. Regular leisure-time
programmed activities, and 6 additional items, forming the activity choice index questionnaire, were
used to assess 6 discrete nonsedentary behaviors. Using the International Physical Activity
Questionnaire categories, 42.3% of the sample were classified as low active, 30.6% as moderately
active, and 27.1% as highly active. Walking, health/fitness activities, running, group gymnastics
classes, swimming/pool activities, football/futsal, and cycling were the most popular leisure-time
activities. Between 15% (parking further away from destinations) and 48% (using the stairs instead
of elevators) of participants reported that they frequently adopted commonly recommended
nonsedentary activities. This study updates self-reported physical activity prevalence for Portugal
adults, including older adults. In addition, it uniquely describes leisure-time activity preferences in
the population and also the relative frequency of several nonsedentary activities of daily living
Ageing is associated with a progressive decline in cognitive function, which occurs according to
heterogeneous trajectories, dependent on multiple physiological and environmental components
(pereira at al. 2019). To tackle this major chal-lenge, we designed a project to test the effect of a
tailored physical exercise intervention program in the cog-nitive function of a Portuguese elderly
cohort, included in the AGA@4life project. The exercise program included aerobic and strength
components, prescribed in a personalized approach according to the AGA@4life model,
andimplemented under direct control of two experienced professionals. The 33 included elderly
participants were divided into two groups (intervention group–IG–and control group–CG)
according to their willingness to participate in the physical training program. Cognitive function
was evaluated with the Cambridge Neuropsychological Test Automated Battery (CANTAB)
42
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
platform at baseline ant three-months after the inter-vention period in all the participants. The
groups had similar clinical and demographic characteristics atbaseline. After the intervention
program, significant improvements in cognitive function were observed in theIG, but not in the
CG. Particularly, a significant improvement in motor control, spatial working memory
andvisuospatial associate learning were depicted in the IG, which revealed an overall better
cognitive performanceas compared with the CG after the follow-up period. The results clearly
identify physical exercise as an effectivenon-pharmacological tool to positively modulate agerelated decline in cognitive function in older adults, par-ticularly when prescribed in a personalized
approach with a multicomponent structure as foreseen in the in-novative AGA@4life model
Study of Silva at al. (2020) aims to assess cardiovascular and metabolic risk factors in Portuguese
middle-aged adults according to gender and level of PA. Equipment and methods This crosssectional study evaluated cardiovascular and metabolic risk factors in 275 Portuguese adults (33.0
± 7.3 years old) according to gender and level of physical activity. Subjects’ body weight, height,
waist circumference, blood pressure and fasting blood glucose were assessed. Body mass index was
subsequently calculated and body fat was assessed by bioelectrical impedance. Results The majority
of inactive men was obese (69.7%) and 21.7% was overweight; 71.2% of the inactive women were
obese (33.3 ± 4.2 kg/m²) and 28.8% was overweight. There were no inactive women presenting
normal BMI. Although there were no significantly differences in age (P ≥ 0.05) between active and
inactive participants, there were significant differences (P < 0.05) among other cardiovascular and
metabolic risk factors. In inactive participants of both sexes, high levels of body fat, waist
circumference and fasting blood glucose, and hypertension were risk factors for developing
cardiovascular and metabolic diseases, with the fasting blood glucose ≥ 100 mg/dl being the most
significant (OR = 4.21). Inactive women were more likely to be at greater cardiovascular and
metabolic risk than inactive men, which emphasizes the need for greater awareness about primary
prevention of cardio-metabolic diseases in early ages, especially in women.
To establish the effect of three types of treatment – multicomponent exercise (MEX); the oral
hypoglycaemic drug metformin (MET); combined therapy comprising exercise plus metformin
(MEXMET) – on cardiovascular risk in older adults with type 2 diabetes (T2D) and with
comorbidities in an early stage of the disease (HbA1c < 7.5%). A sample of 284 participants was
evaluated for multifactorial cardiovascular risk at baseline and at 24-month intervention according
to anthropometric and hemodynamic components, lipid profile, glycaemia and cardiorespiratory
fitness (CRF). Participants underwent one of three conditions: MEX (n = 59), training in three
sessions per week; MET (n = 30), using metformin 850 mg twice daily; MEXMET (n = 195),
combining exercise and metformin. After the 24-month intervention MEX and MEXMET showed
more positive results than MET therapy. MEX decreased body mass (BM; 4%), waist
circumference (WC; 4%), body mass index (BMI; 3%), systolic blood pressure (SBP; 11%), diastolic
blood pressure (DBP; 11%), triglycerides (21%), and glycaemia (12%), and increased
cardiorespiratory fitness (CRF; 18%). Conversely, the MET group showed increased WC (2%),
waist-to-hip ratio (WHR) (3%), and SBP (5%). Differences between MEX and MET groups
presented large effect sizes for BM, WC, WHR, SBP, DBP and CRF, and moderate effect sizes for
BMI and glycaemia. MEX was the most effective therapy in decreasing cardiovascular risk in the
43
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
early stage of T2D in older adults with multimorbidity and attenuated the adverse effects of
pharmacological therapy in MEXMET treatment (Baptista et al. 2018)
Study of Oliveira et al (2018) includes, for the first time, estimates of general and abdominal obesity
prevalence for all ages of the Portuguese population, using common standardized methodologies.
Results are compared by sex, age groups, educational level and geographical regions. Participants
were a representative sample of the Portuguese population aged between 3 months and 84 years
of age (n= 6553), enrolled in the National Food, Nutrition and Physical Activity Survey, 2015–
2016. Objective anthropometric measurements included length/height, weight and body
circumferences, performed according to standard procedures. Body mass index (BMI) was
classified according to the World Health Organization (WHO) growth charts for children and
adolescents, and WHO criteria for adults. Abdominal obesity was defined in adults as waist-hip
ratio≥0.85 in women or≥0.90 in men. Prevalence estimates and 95% confidence intervals (95%CI)
were weighted according to a complex sampling design, considering stratification by seven
geographical regions and cluster effect for the selected Primary Health Care Unit. The national
prevalence of obesity is 22.3% (95%CI: 20.5–24.0), significantly higher in women. Obesity
prevalence is much higher in the elderly (39.2%, 95%CI. 34.2–44.2), while children and adolescents
have the lowest prevalence around8–9%. In a regression model, three knot points denoting an
inflection of obesity prevalence across the life span were observed around 5, 15 and 75 years. The
prevalence of pre-obesity at national level is 34.8% (95%CI: 32.9–36.7), higher in men, and almost
18% of children and 24% of adolescents have pre-obesity. The sex- and age-standardized
prevalence of obesity ranged from 38.3% (95%CI: 34.6–42.1) to 13.1% (95%CI: 10.3–15.9)for the
less and the most educated individuals, respectively. Although some geographical region disparities,
obesity prevalence did not significantly differ across regions (p=0.094). The national prevalence of
abdominal obesity in adults is 50.5% (95%CI: 47.9–53.1), particularly high in the elderly (80.2%).
Almost 60% of the general Portuguese population is obese or pre-obese. Women, elderly and less
educated individuals present the highest obesity prevalence. Abdominal obesity, in particular,
seems to be a relevant public health problem among the elderly men.
Physical activity and self-rated wellbeing have important benefits to health. However, scientific
knowledge regarding their relationship among older adults is scarce (Peralta at al 2018). Thus, the
aim of this study was to examine the associations between physical activity frequency and several
dimensions of self-rated wellbeing, in a representative sample of European older adults from 28
countries. Methods: This study is based on the European Social Survey round 6, 2012. It had a
total sample size of 12,341 older adults (5100 men, 7241 women) with mean age 73.8 ± 6.6 years.
Information was collected through a questionnaire, filled-in during an hour-long face-to-face
interview. Physical activity was accessed using the question “On how many of the last 7 days you
were physically active continuously for 20 minutes or longer?” and six dimensions of self-rated
wellbeing were used. Results: Physical activity in the last 7 days was linearly related with all
dimensions of the self-rated wellbeing and with wellbeing total score for both sexes (men, β = 0.09,
95% CI: 0.07 to 0.10, p < .001; women, β = 0.10, 95% CI: 0.09 to 0.11, p < .001). Conclusions:
Physical activity promotion should be stressed as a meaningful strategy to improve people's
wellbeing overall. This strategy has special importance when considering the older adult population.
44
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
Physical activity (PA) is a keystone of diabetes management, but although self-exercise is beneficial,
supervised exercise (SE), adapted to individual characteristics, and is more effective. Objectives
(Esteves at al. 2019). The main research goal is to compare SE patterns among diabetic and nondiabetic Portuguese adults. Methods. A total of 484 participants (85 diabetics, 399 non-diabetics),
aged 41-90 years old (mean=58.9; SD=11.9) were interviewed. PA level was assessed using short
form of the International Physical Activity Questionnaire. Attendance in different SE programs
was evaluated across three kinds of PA programs providers: gym/health-clubs; swimming pools
and other club/ sports facilities. Itens like Barriers to Exercise; Intention to participate; Importance
of the structure and PA information sources were also evaluated. Independent t-tests were used to
examine the difference between the group means, and Levene’s test was used to check the
homokedasticity of the groups’ variances. Results. PA level of diabetics (32% low; 25% moderate;
44% high) and non-diabetics (29% low; 33% moderate; 39% high) display no differences. 90% of
diabetics do not attend SE. The main barrier for diabetics’ non-participation is the perception that
the exercise is not adequate to their health. Doctors are the preferred information source for
diabetics, and they rely less on information provided by the Internet, with may impair on-line
campaigns. Conclusion. Promoting exercise in diabetics should shift the focus from "promoting
physical activity" to "promoting SE".
Study of Marques et al. (2014) aims to assess awareness of physical activity levels among adults and
to investigate the variables associated with different types of awareness. The participants were 1042
men and 1316 women aged 31–60 years old (43.3 ± 6.1). Data were collected on physical activity
behaviour, physical activity awareness, perceptions and psychological factors. Awareness was
assessed by comparing self-rated physical activity with achieving physical activity guidelines. Chisquare and logistic regression analyses were applied to the results. About 32.4% were considered
active. Moreover, 61% accurately reported their physical activity (38.3% realistic inactive and 22.7%
realistic active), 29.2% overestimated their physical activity (overestimators) and 9.7% incorrectly
described themselves as inactive (underestimators). Perception of an excellent health status (odds
ratio, OR = 4.07, 95% confidence interval, CI: 2.07–8.00, p < 0.001) was the strongest positive
association with being realistic active, followed by having a high socio-economic status (SES) (OR
= 1.53, 95% CI: 1.10–2.12, p < 0.05). Overestimator participants were more likely to have an
excellent perception of health (OR = 2.58, 95% CI: 1.47–4.52, p < 0.01) and had a good experience
in physical education (OR = 1.46, 95% CI:1.03–2.08, p < 0.05). Almost half of these participants
erroneously perceived themselves as physically active. Gender, body mass index (BMI) and the
quality of physical education at school were associated with those who misperceived their physical
activity.
The situation in Belgium according to the results of the 2018 health survey is presented in article
of Drieskens, Charafeddine and Gisle (2018). The fact that nearly half (49.3%) of the adult
population aged 18 years and older is overweight and 15.9% is obese, prevalence that have been
observed since the first health survey in 1997 (41.3% and 10.8%, respectively). %) have only
continued to increase, makes this a major public health problem. Overweight and obesity are more
common in men, in the 35-74 age group and the less educated, making them important target
groups in terms of prevention. In addition, the situation is worst in the Walloon Region (51.8%
45
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
and 18.0% respectively, percentages significantly higher than in the Flemish and Brussels Regions).
One in five (19.0%) young people aged 2 to 5 17 years of age are overweight and 5.8% are obese.
The problem is greatest among toddlers aged 2-4 years (24.4% respectively, so almost one in four,
and 11.7%). The situation among young people is more favorable, in the sense that this prevalence
have remained constant compared to the previous survey years (except 1997). Here too, attention
should be paid to young people from households with a low educational level, because two out of
five (40.5%) of these young people are already overweight and 14.0% are obese. As far as young
people are concerned, the situation is only in the Brussels Region (27.3% and 10.5% respectively,
percentages significantly higher than the Flemish Region, but not the Walloon Region).
In the study of Pot et al. (2020) researchers examined the effect of this treatment method in an
initial 438 participants. Ultimately, they were able to include data from 234 participants in the
analyzes. The program consists of an intensive coaching program of 6 months followed by a
follow-up program of 18 months. It is intended for patients with diabetes who are already on
medication. During the treatment the focus is on nutrition, exercise, sleep and relaxation. The
guidance is provided by a dietician, exercise coach and nurse. The patient's GP is also closely
involved in the treatment. We work with a combination of individual and group sessions,
supplemented with online support. Some results:
• After 2 years, 67% of the participants used less sugar-lowering drugs, and 28% were even able to
stop using this medication completely.
• Of the 66 participants who received insulin at baseline, 71% were no longer using insulin after 2
years.
• The participants weighed an average of 7 kg less after the study and had a smaller waist
circumference (average -8.2 cm). Their triglycerides (blood fats) and HDL ("good" cholesterol)
levels were also improved.
• Mean HemoglobinA1c (HbA1c) levels, on the other hand, did not change much in the
participants. Hemoglobin is a protein that can bind sugar in the blood. The value of this
"saccharified" hemoglobin or HbA1c gives a good picture of the average blood sugar level. The
proportion of "normal" HbA1c levels increased in the participants from 45% at the start of the
lifestyle program to 53% after 2 years.
• The program had a positive effect on the participants' quality of life: they were less tired and felt
healthy.
Researchers Teras at al. (2019) and Drieskens at al. (2018) examined whether women who lose
weight had a lower risk of developing breast cancer. Previous research has shown that the risk of
breast cancer is higher in overweight or obese women. This could be because they produce more
estrogens than healthy weight women. Those estrogens can cause breast cells to grow, which can
lead to breast cancer if that growth is out of control. To find an answer to the research question,
the researchers collected data from ten large cohort studies with women over 50 years old. During
the follow-up, the women had to declare their weight at least three times and recorded breast cancer
incidence. In total there were 180,885 women and 6,930 breast cancers. The researchers divided
the women into different groups according to the evolution of body weight during the follow-up.
46
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
The researchers also took into account possible disturbing factors such as physical activity and the
use of hormonal preparations. Compared to women who maintained a stable weight, the risk of
breast cancer decreased by 13% when they lost 2 to 4.5 kg. With a weight loss of 4.5 to 9 kg that
was 16% and when they lost more than 9 kg, it even decreased by 26%. The reduction in breast
cancer risk was particularly evident in women who were overweight or obese at the start of the
study. The researchers conclude that weight loss can be an important measure to reduce the risk
of breast cancer.
Overweight or obesity is very often associated with high blood pressure, abnormal blood sugar and
excess cholesterol (Lasalle 2020) Yet there are many people with a BMI over 25 (which the World
Health Organization classifies as "overweight") and even over 30 ("obese") for whom these clinical
indicators are absent. Despite their excess body fat, they have a fairly normal blood pressure and
cholesterol, which makes them considered healthy by many doctors, especially at the level of the
metabolism. Fat but healthy, if you like.This is unjustified, according to a long and comprehensive
study in which thousands of people in more than ten European countries were followed for years.
The British medics who coordinated the study looked for links between obesity on the one hand
and heart disease on the other. They classified the study participants according to medical indicators
such as blood pressure, cholesterol level, blood sugar and BMI. If people met three or more of the
criteria, they were classified as "unhealthy". People with a (much too) high BMI escaped that. "In
the overweight group, the risk of heart complaints was almost 30 percent higher than in the healthy
participants with a healthy BMI (between 18.5 and 25)" But the analysis found that in the end, they
didn't escape the effects of their excess body fat - statistically, that is. For example, the risk of
ischemic heart complaints - in which the heart receives too little blood due to blocked coronary
arteries and a heart attack - was almost 30 percent higher than in the healthy participants with a
healthy BMI (between 18.5 and 25). In the unhealthy participants the risk of the same type of heart
complaints was preferably twice as high as in the healthy group.
The positive relationship between physical movement and brain volume in middle-aged people has
already been demonstrated, but this now appears to be the case for children as well (EstebanCornejo 2017; Ortega at al. 2014; Ronan at al. 2016). Moreover, more active children show an
increase in gray matter volume, which in turn is associated with better school performance. The
findings of this large-scale study (as part of the “ActiveBrains” project) were reported by Spanish
researchers in the specialist journal Neurolmage. Previous studies have already shown the positive
effect of sports on cognition, brain function and academic performance. People who exercise less
during their lifetime run a higher risk of developing neurodegenerative disorders and cognitive
problems. In addition, body weight also plays a determining factor in this: overweight people show
accelerated aging of the brain, which means that their gray matter corresponds to people who are
10 years older than themselves. In addition, the higher the body mass index (BMI), the less gray
matter volume. What's more, overweight children perform worse at school than normal weight
children. All this demonstrates the importance of a scientific study of the potential benefits of
physical exercise on the brain in overweight children and its impact on school performance. More
specifically, 110 overweight children aged between 8 and 11 years were included in the study. Their
physical fitness was tested using an extensive battery test, looking at a number of cardiorespiratory
47
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
factors, as well as "speed-agility" (including movement speed, dexterity and coordination) and
muscle strength. All children also underwent a brain scan and their academic profile was mapped.
By looking at those factors together, the researchers were able to see which aspects were associated
with greater brain volume. The study therefore showed that cardiorespiratory factors and "speedagility" are related to higher brain volume, as shown in the figure. The green brain regions are
positively associated with physical movement (panel A for cardiorespiratory factors, panel B for
"speed-agility"). Moreover, a positive relationship with better academic performance has also been
shown for some of these brain regions. However, no association between brain volume and muscle
strength was found.
These results thus demonstrate the positive effect of physical movement on the brain and can thus
counteract the negative influence of obesity. Increasing physical activity in children (with or without
overweight) is therefore very important. Moreover, this can have direct implications for education,
among other things.
The purpose of the study of Oja et al. (2011) was to update the evidence on the health benefits of
cycling. Cross-sectional and longitudinal studies showed a clear positive relationship between
cycling and cardiorespiratory fitness in youths. Prospective observational studies demonstrated a
strong inverse relationship between commuter cycling and all-cause mortality, cancer mortality, and
cancer morbidity among middle-aged to elderly subjects. Intervention studies among working-age
adults indicated consistent improvements in cardiovascular fitness and some improvements in
cardiovascular risk factors due to commuting cycling. Six studies showed a consistent positive doseresponse gradient between the amount of cycling and the health benefits. The existing evidence
reinforces the current efforts to promote cycling as an important contributor to better population
health.
References
Baptista LC, Machado-Rodrigues AM & Martins RA (2018). Back to basics with active lifestyles:
exercise is more effective than metformin to reduce cardiovascular risk in older adults with
type 2 diabetes. Biol Sport. Dec;35(4):363-372. doi: 10.5114/biolsport.2018.78057. Epub
2018 Aug 31. PMID: 30765922; PMCID: PMC6358532.
Cornelissen, V., & Smart, N. (2013). Exercise training for blood pressure: a systematic review and
meta-analysis. Journal of the American Heart Association. 2(1). Recovered from
https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/JAHA.112.004473
Drieskens, S., Charafeddine, R. & Gisle, L. (2018). Gezondheidsenquête 2018. (The situation in
Belgium according to the results of the 2018 health survey). https://his.wivisp.be/nl/Gedeelde%20%20documenten/NS_NL_2018.pdf
Drieskens S, Charafeddine R & Gisle L. Gezondheidsenquête (2018): Voedingsstatus. Brussel,
België: Sciensano; Rapportnummer: D/2019/14.440/53.
48
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
Esteves M, Gouveia A, Rodrigues R, Pinheiro P, Bras R, O'Hara K et al .(2019). Supervised
Exercise Patterns among Diabetic and Non-diabetic Portuguese Adults. Ann Appl Sport Sci.;
7 (3) :49-56 URL: http://aassjournal.com/article-1-757-en.html
Esteban-Cornejo I, Cadenas-Sanchez C, Contreras-Rodriguez O et al. (2017). A whole brain
volumetric approach in overweight/obese children: Examining the association with different
physical fitness components and academic performance. The ActiveBrains project.
NeuroImage. Epub ahead of print.
Goh, S.L., Persson, M., Stocks, J., Hou, Y., Lin, J., Hall, M., Doherty, M., & Zhang, W. (2019).
Efficacy and potential determinants of exercise therapy in knee and hip osteoarthritis: A
systematic review and meta-analysis. Annals of Physical Rehabilitation Medicine. 62(5), 356-365.
doi: 10.1016/j.rehab.2019.04.006
Lasalle, C. (2020:. University College London, VK in European Heart Journal
Lurati, A.R. (2018). Health Issues and Injury Risks Associated with Prolonged Sitting and Sedentary
Lifestyles. Workplace Health & Safety, 66(6), 285-290. doi: 10.1177/2165079917737558
Marcos-Pardo, P.J., Martínez-Rodríguez, A. & Gil-Arias, A. (2018). Impact of a motivational
resistance-training programme on adherence and body composition in the elderly. Sci Rep 8:
1370 doi: 10.1038/s41598-018-19764-6 Recovered from:
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5778069/
Martins J., Adilson Marques, Pedro J. Teixeira, Jorge Mota, Carla Lopes & Paulo J. Nicola (2020)
Socio-demographic factors associated with physical activity and sitting time patterns in
adults: An analysis based on the Portuguese Food, Nutrition and Physical Activity Survey,
European Journal of Sport Science, DOI: 10.1080/17461391.2020.1736643
Marques A., João Martins, Madalena Ramos, Flávia Yazigi & Francisco Carreiro da Costa (2014)
Perception and reality – Portuguese adults' awareness of active lifestyle, European Journal of
Sport Science, 14:5, 468-474, DOI: 10.1080/17461391.2013.837512
McPhee J.S., French, D., Jackson, D., Nazroo, J., Pendleton, N., & Degens, H. (2016). Physical
activity in older age: perspectives for healthy ageing and frailty. Biogerontology, 17(3), 567-580.
doi:10.1007/s10522-016-9641-0
Nomura, T., Kawae, T., Kataoka, H., & Ikeda, H. (2018). Assessment of lower extremity muscle
mass, muscle strength, and exercise therapy in elderly patients with diabetes mellitus. Environ
Health and Preventive Medicine, 23(1), 20. doi:10.1186/s12199-018-0710-7
Nyberg J, Aberg MA, Schioler L et al. Cardiovascular and cognitive fitness at age 18 and risk of
early-onset dementia. Brain. 2014;137 (Pt 5), 1514–1523.
Oja, P., Titze, C.,Geus,B., Krenn, O., Reger-Nash, B. & Kohlberger, T. (2011) Health benefits of
cycling: A systematic review. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine and Science in Sports 21(4):
496-509. Doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0838.2011.01299.x Recovered from:
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/51054095_Health_benefits_of_cycling_A_syste
matic_review
Oliveira, A. et al (2018). Prevalence of general and abdominal obesity in Portugal: comprehensive
results from the National Food, nutrition and physical activity survey 2015–2016. BMC
Public Health, 18:614. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-018-5480-z
Ortega FB, Campos D, Cadenas-Sanchez C et al. (2017). Physical fitness and shape of subcortical
brain structures in children. British Journal of Nutrition. 1–10, Epub ahead of print.
49
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Peralta M., Martins J., Gómez Chávez F., Cortés Almanzar, P. & Marques, A. (2018) Self-rated
wellbeing and physical activity associations in European older adults, European Journal of Sport
Science, 18:7, 1038-1044, DOI: 10.1080/17461391.2018.1469672
Pereira, T., Cipriano, I., Costa, T., Saraiva, M., & Martins, A. (2019). Exercise, ageing and cognitive
function - Effects of a personalized physical exercise program in the cognitive function of
older adults. Physiology & Behavior, 202, 8-13.
https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physbeh.2019.01.018
Pot, G. K., Battjes-Fries, M. C., Patijn, O. N. et al. (2020). Lifestyle medicine for type 2 diabetes:
practice-based evidence for long-term efficacy of amulticomponent lifestyle intervention
(Reverse Diabetes2 Now). BMJ Nutrition, Prevention & Health, bmjnph-2020.
Ronan L, Alexander-Bloch AF, Wagstyl K et al. Obesity associated with increased brain-age from
mid-life. Neurobiology of Aging. 2016;47, 63–70.
Schroeder, E., Franke, W., Sharp, R., y Lee, D-C (2019). Comparative effectiveness of aerobic,
resistance, and combined training on cardiovascular disease risk factors: A randomized
controlled trial. PLOS ONE, 14(1). doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0210292
Silva, M. R. G., Silva, H. H., Capkauskiene, S., Rosado-Marques, V., Machado-Rodrigues, A. M.,
Nogueira, H., & Padez, C. (2020). Cardiovascular and metabolic risk factors in physically
active and inactive Portuguese middle-aged adults: A cross-sectional study. Science & Sports,
35(4), e91-e98.
https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scispo.2019.06.009
Steven T. Devor (2010) & FACSM. (s.f.). Proper Breathing During Exercise: Importance for Safety
and Performance. Recovered from
https://www.copcp.com/Media/9b5954b7-dce3-43b5-b1a9-2a8913d7cae7.pdf
Thompson, D., (2007). Aging and Sarcopenia. JMNI: Journal Musculoskeletal Neuronal
Interactions, 7(4),344-345. Recovered from
http://www.ismni.org/jmni/pdf/30/29THOMPSON.pdf
Texeira, P.J., Marques, A., Lopes, C., Sardinha, L.B., & Mota, J. A. (n.d.). Prevalence and
Preferences of Self-Reported Physical Activity and Nonsedentary Behaviors in Portuguese
Adults, Journal of Physical Activity and Health, 16(4), 251-258. Retrieved Oct 30, 2020, from
https://journals.humankinetics.com/view/journals/jpah/16/4/article-p251.xml
Teras LR, Patel AV, Wang M, et al. (2019). Sustained weight loss and risk of breast cancer in women
≥50 years: a pooled analysis of prospective data. J Natl Cancer Inst. Dec 13.
50
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
Food as a Medicine – Selected Findings from Literature Review in
Slovakia
Stanislav Kraček – Gabriela Kotyrová Štefániková - Adriana Kaplánová –
Branislav Antala
Comenius University in Bratislava, Faculty of Physical Education and Sports, Slovakia
e-mail: stanislav.kracek@uniba.sk
Abstract
The section entitled "Food as a medicine" was created to bring the latest knowledge on the impact
of food on human health. Researchers have long been studying the synergistic effect of foods that
cause chronic health problems, as well as their therapeutic and defensive properties, which play a
key role in promoting health. At present, much research points to an increasing trend of obesity in
children and adolescents, which is mainly caused by a sedentary lifestyle combined with poor eating
habits, excessive consumption of sweetened beverages, or low nutritional foods. Expert findings
suggest that obesity has broad effects on human health, increases the risk of cardiovascular disease,
and also contributes to the increased incidence of diabetes mellitus in children and adolescents.
Key words: Food as a medicine, physical activity
51
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Tláskal (2019) summarizes the data to different nutritional factors that affect the formation of
adipose tissue. Not only excessive energy intake, but also differences of essential nutrients have
their importance. The individual components of the nutrients is variously involved in metabolic
processes. The formation of adipose tissue activates more diet with a higher content of sugars than
other carbohydrates, diet with a higher content of saturated and monoenoic unsaturated fatty acids
than polyunsaturated omega 3 fatty acids. In the context of the age is changing not only the way of
nutrition, but also habits of the individual. In the diet is so the five time periods that are individually
specific to activate the development of excessive accumulation of fat tissue. To prevent childhood
obesity is necessary to pay attention to the child´s diet systematically and differentially.
Zlatohlávková (2016) presents concept of Developmental Origins of Health and Disease presumes
that early human development programmes health and the risk of adult diseases through the
processes of developmental plasticity which can create different fenotypes stemming from a single
genotype in response to environmental signals. Early nutrition is a significant programming factor.
Individual long-term health can be affected by inadequate intrauterine and postnatal nutrition. In
order to reduce susceptibility to noncommunicable diseases preventive measures are most effective
in the time of the highest plasticity – during the human reproductive cycle which includes both
pregnancy and breastfeeding. Exclusive breastfeeding for up to 6 months of age followed by the
introduction of complementary foods with adequate protein intake and energy together with
continued breastfeeding is a basic preventive measure. Breastfeeding lowers the risk of being
overweight or obese in infancy, childhood, adolescence, and adulthood. It also reduces the
probability that a future mother will become overweight or obese before conception and during
pregnancy and thereby lowers the risk of fetal overnutrition with all the consequences for the
child’s health.
Kazda and Broulík (2017) in his article constate that the significance of protein income for bone
health and the significantly positive influence of proteins on decreased frequency of frailty
fractures. The influence of diets on acid-base status with respect to metabolism of the bone was
assessed. The types of obesity in relation to bone mass. Chronic inflammation of low degree,
accompanying the obesity and more of other chronic diseases in advanced age and its relation to
osteoporosis and to frailty fractures. The elevation of proinflammatory cytokines like the metabolic
dysregulation influenced the loss of bone. Clinical studies aimed to the amelioration of chronic
inflammation by proper diet. To this theme belongs knowledge about the positive influence of
dairy proteins on proinflammatory markers as well as studies of the influence of polyunsaturated
fatty acids omega-3 on these markers. The text is dedicated to keeping bone health among
vegetarians. The relations between the bone metabolism and the consumption of fruits, legumes,
drinking of alcoholic and non-alcoholic beverages are mentioned. Finally, the detrimental influence
of hyponatremia on metabolism of bone is presented.
Psoriasis vulgaris is one of the most common skin, chronic, immune-related diseases. It affects
about 0.5–11% of the adult population. The treatment integrates local and systemic therapy, in
cases of moderate to severe psoriasis, biologic therapy is used. The modification of eating habits
or using nutritional supplements in patients with psoriasis or psoriatic arthritis has been an
52
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
observed area for several decades. Patients with this skin disease, especially after their initial
diagnosis, want to know whether changing diets can contribute to improving their health problems.
The article of Mrosková and Konečná (2018) briefly summarizes the most recent findings on the
impact of selected nutrition areas – gluten-free diet, hypocaloric diet, nutritional supplements,
alcohol – on the incidence of psoriasis, the severity of skin changes or the quality of life. Changing
diet in certain groups of patients with psoriasis has beneficial effects, but nutritional interventions
should always be seen as an additional form of treatment along with the standardized treatment of
psoriasis.
Both in Europe and in Slovakia, cardiovascular morbidity and mortality dominates, with
cardiovascular mortality in our country represent ing 53% of al l cause mortality. Murín (2016)
described the pathophysiology of the process of atherosclerosis and atherothrombosis, which
is in the background of most cardiovascular diseases. He focused on the place of platelets
in atherothrombotic processes. In the second part he presents data concern in antithrombotic
(anti aggregational) effects of natural substances in food, mostly in tomato extract. This
extract also inhibits the ACE (angiotensin converting enzyme) which further enhances its
cardiovascular benefit. This extract has shown an antithrombotic influence in clinical studies and
it was safe for use.
Kajaba at al. (2020 presented a review of knowledge about the development of the microbiome
from birth with regard to its genetic predisposition to 2 basic factors - the way of birth and nutrition
of the newborn. The close relationship of microbial development to the intestinal immune system
is shown. Attention is drawn to the importance of eumicrobiosis and its preventive function in the
course of metabolic processes and the prevalence of non-contagiouse diseases. A particularly
serious risk of dysmicrobiosis, which is currently considered to be one of the major elements in the
etiopathogenesis of many so-called civilizations linked diseases, is underlined. The importance of
modulation is therefore justified, mainly by probiotics according to the classical works of
Mechnikov's lactic acid milk products containing lactic - acid milk bacteria. Recently, it is also the
application of "faecal microbial therapy", so far mainly in non-specific intestinal inflammations and
with the prospect of its application in several metabolic, cardiovascular, neurodegenerative,
autoimmune diseases, even in some mental disorders.
Article of Minárik and Mlkvý (2016) is focused on the role of Calcium in the prevention of
colorectal cancer. Calcium is an important nutrient for bone and dental health, and milk together
with dairy products are in the European region the main source of calcium. Colorectal cancer
(CRC) is the world's third most common cancer. In recent years sufficient evidence has been
accumulated that calcium together with vitamin D has in colon cancer antineoplastic effects.
Consistent evidence from existing studies suggests that both calcium and milk probably protect
against the CRC. Calcium supplementation probably protects against CRC as well. On the other
hand, limited evidence currently suggests that cheese on the contrary increases the risk of CRC.
Existing evidence also suggests that diet rich in calcium is likely to increase the risk of prostate
cancer. Therefore, currently there is no general recommendation to take calcium supplements as a
means to reduce the risk of CRC. Dietary supplements containing calcium are indicated as an
53
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
alternative source of calcium for people who for any reason are unable to receive enough calcium
from normal diet (for example, lactose intolerant persons, or strict vegan individuals). Milk and
low-fat dairy products if consumed in reasonable quantities and within a varied diet are considered
part of a healthy diet in those populations and regions of the world where dairy products are
traditional part of the diet. Most medical professional societies recommend on average to consume
3 servings of milk or dairy products daily. Oncology and cardiology societies recommend preferring
low-fat milk and low-fat dairy products. Vitamin D has a major role to ensure homeostasis of
calcium and phosphate and, like calcium. It is an important nutrient for bone and dental health. In
recent years there have been published a number of observational and epidemiological studies that
have confirmed that vitamin D plays an active protective role in the development of colorectal
cancer, as well as cancers of prostate, breast, ovary, and skin. Most of the evidence on the
preventive effect of vitamin D is at CRC. The best expression of the vitamin D status in the body
is the serum 25(OH)D vitamin level. Despite the strength of the evidence that oral intake and the
synthesis of vitamin D reduce the risk of CRC incidence and mortality, particularly when associated
with adequate calcium intake, the health professionals at present do not recommend
supplementation with vitamin D as a general measure for the prevention of malignancies, including
CRC. For more detailed information on causation, the mutual interaction of vitamin D with other
protective nutrients, as well as other aspects of the preventive effects of vitamin D at CRC, and
also other tumors, there is need for further prospective studies.
Currently, there is a pandemic of common obesity (Marinov and Střítecká 2017). In the last 25
years, there has been a tremendous increase in overweight, and common obesity has become the
most serious health problem of mankind today. In the surgeries of general paediatricians for
children and adolescents, common paediatric obesity is the second largest group of chronic diseases
with long-term metabolic changes, second only to allergic conditions. In the Czech Republic,
approximately 10 % of children aged up to 16 years old have obesity, including 2/3 children with
complex metabolic changes and 1/4 with extreme obesity. Cardiometabolic sequelae are
triggered and preserved by maladaptation processes based on malnutrition behaviour: on the one
hand, developed at an early age following the stage of imprinting during the period of neophobia
and negation and, on the other hand, based on national nutritional habits. The pressure of
obesogenic environment affects the nature of hyperalimentation and results in the development of
specific nutritional deficiencies that are discussed in the present article.
Pochop (2020) describes nutrition as an integral part of comprehensive patient care. Diet intake is
associated with vitality and the possibility of continuing cancer therapy. It should be noted that
with advanced cancer, the body's ability to use energy changes. Weight loss and anorexia can have
various causes. In many cases, these causes can be influenced by appropriate medication adjustment
as well as by dietary measures. Adequate education of caregivers leads to less urge for "healthy
nutrition" and the associated effort to find a miracle pill. The goal is proper nutrition at the right
time, thus providing appropriate comfort to palliative patients.
Aim of the study of Vitáriušová et al. (2010): In 2006–2008 a survey analyzing food patterns, intake
of main food items and leisure time activities of 5,410 schoolchildren was carried out. Methods:
54
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
The study was performed in 13 randomly selected regions of Slovakia. 5,410 elementary school
children (2,848 girls and 2,562 boys) aged from 6.3 to 15.9 years, mean age was 11±2.6 years, were
included. The data collected by questionnaire concerned nutrition and leisure time activities.
Results: Noteworthy results are that only 63% of participants eat breakfast regularly. Almost all of
the children eat lunch during workdays regularly and 60.9% prefer a cooked (hot) dish for supper.
Although dairy products are a substantial part of child nutrition, in general their consumption in
our sample was low. Only 50.1% of children consume these daily and 62% of children drink milk
daily, more often boys than girls. A striking observation is that only 65.5% of interviewed pupils
eat fruit every day and 30.9% of them eat vegetables daily. The frequency of consumption of
poultry and pork in our sample was almost the same, however, the analysis showed that only 14%
of children consume fish once per week. Moreover, only 12.6% of subjects prefer wholegrain
bread. In our sample 56.8% of children eat sweets daily, 32% prefer a salty snack almost 2 times
per week. Within the group of pupils 35.8% do not attend physical trainings even once a week.
Almost every child is used to watch TV and 64% of them play PC games daily. While both girls
and boys watched TV on average over 2 hours, boys spend more time on PC per day than girls
(girls 0.72 hours per day vs. boys 1.13 hours per day, p<0.001). The food patterns and leisure time
activities of children older than 11 years and rural pupils were less favourable. Conclusions:
According to results of our analysis we recommend to increase the consumption of dairy products,
fresh fruits and vegetables in Slovak schoolchildren and spare no effort in making children to take
breakfast regularly. It is necessary to promote daily moderate physical activity. Nutritional and
lifestyle education should begin already in childhood.
The study of Bašková, Baška and Holubčíková (2016) analysed the consumption of sweetened soft
drinks and energy drinks as well as attitudes towards their consumption. Design: Health Behaviour
in School-aged Children (HBSC) is a cross-sectional school-based study focused on the target
group of 11-, 13- and 15-year-old adolescents. It employs a universal, internationally standardized
questionnaire. Methods: The study analyses results of the HBSC survey carried out in Slovakia in
2014. A total of 10,179 schoolchildren from grades 5 through 9 participated (a response rate of
78.8%). Gender and age differences were analysed in 11-, 13- and 15- year-old respondents. Results:
The consumption of soft drinks varied from 16.9% (11-year-old girls) to 29.0% (15-year-old boys).
More than 8 in 10 respondents accepted the consumption of soft drinks. As much as 34.4% of
boys and 18.8% of girls aged 15 years reported the use of energy drinks at least weekly, with boys
showing higher rates than girls in all age groups and the rates increasing with age. Conclusion: In
Slovakia, consumption of sweetened soft drinks and energy drinks is widely popular and socially
accepted among adolescents. There is a need for more effective interventions including adoption
of appropriate legislative norms. Paediatric nursing plays an important role through outpatient
primary as well as hospital care.
Lifestyle of our population with the advent of science and new technologies adversely changes,
reduces physical activity and develops negative eating habits. Shift from malnutrition and infectious
diseases to chronic diseases (cardio metabolic diseases, cancer, diabetes mellitus) is typical for
current epidemiological situation. Obesity leads to a worse quality of life and shorter life
expectancy. Mortality of cardio metabolic diseases is 2.5 times higher than the average in European
55
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
countries. This current epidemiological situation in overweight and obesity is alarming.
Compulsory school physical education is the only place for physical activity for a lot of children.
And the number of these children is increasing. The research of Bernátová et al. (2016) is based on
project “Respect for Health”. They analysed the relationship between participation in compulsory
PE and cardio metabolic risk factors (blood pressure, weight and body mass index). The project
“Respect for Health” is monitoring the situation in the cardiovascular health of secondary school
students. Assessment of cardiovascular risk factors and physical activity (compulsory physical
education (PE) and extra-curriculum sport activities) in secondary school children is followed by
education in effective lifestyle measures.
The purpose of the paper of Šedík, Pocol and Horská (2019) is to investigate different profiles of
honey consumers in Slovakia and Romania by using a segmentation approach, thus supporting
honey producers from both countries and promoting the consumption of honey for both food and
health benefits. Based on the data, the authors identified similar segments in Slovakia and Romania,
in terms of frequency and annual consumption (“maniacs” or “loyal consumers”, “regular
consumers”, “occasional consumers” or “sporadic consumers” and “irregular consumers”), but, at
the same time, those segments are different in terms of the way in which honey is consumed
(multipurpose or direct consumption, spreads, beverages and ingredients for cooking).
The purpose of study of Lopašovský et al (2016) was to evaluate the microbiological quality of
Ready-To-Eat (RTE) foods produced in Slovakia. A total amount of 144 samples of RTE food
were tested during one-year period from January to December, 2014 and the microbiological
quality of kebabs (n=30), gyros (n=10), hamburgers (n=54), cheeseburgers (n=5), hot-dogs (n=31),
roasts (n=14) was analyzed. The samples were examined for the presence of: coliform bacteria,
sulfite-reducing clostridia, yeast, microscopic filamentous fungi and coagulase positive
staphylococci according to the ISO standards requirements. In kebab samples the counts of
coliforms were from < 10 to 1.6x10³ cfu.g-1 and incompliance was found in 12/ 30 (40%) of
samples. Maximum counts of coliforms and yeasts were exceeded in two and one sample of gyros
and isolation range was from 10 to 1.5x10³ cfu.g-1 3.2x10² cfu.g-1 and from 10 to 1.4x10² cfu.g-1
. Also 2/5 (40%) of samples of cheeseburger yielded unsatisfactory coliform counts and the
isolation rates were from less than 10 to 1.5x10³ cfu.g1 . In hot-dogs, counts of coliforms, yeasts
and coagulase positive staphylococci ranged from less than 10 to 1.4x103 , < 10 to 2.1x10³ cfu.g-1
and number of unsatisfactory samples were 3/31(10), 1/31(3) and 1/31 (3), respectively. In roast,
the counts of coliforms, yeasts and microscopic filamentous fungi were from less than 10 to 2.1x10²
cfu.g-1 , less than 10 to 1.4x10² cfu.g-1 and less than 10 to 3.2x10² cfu.g-1 , respectively and the
safety criteria were not met for 1/14 (7) samples for each of the bacteria group mentioned. Overall,
the microbiological criteria set for RTE foods in Slovak Republic were violated in 36/ 144 (25) of
samples tested. Results of the present study show that RTE foods might pose public health
concerns in Slovakia and more attention on the hygienic practices should no paid.
In the study of Krajčovičová-Kudláčková (2000) values of homocysteine and lipid parameters were
measured in groups of adults consuming alternative nutrition (vegetarians/lactoovo/, vegans) and
compared with a group consuming traditional diet (omnivores, general population). Frequency of
56
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
hyperhomocysteinemia was 53% in the vegans’ group, 28% in vegetarians vs. 5% in omnivores. In
conditions of lower methionine intake (reduced content in plant proteins), the remethylation
pathway of homocysteine metabolism prevails and it is vitamin B12 and folate-dependent. The
intake of vitamin B12 is equal to zero in vegans; vegetarians consume 124% of the RDA vs. 383%
in omnivores. Serum vitamin levels are significantly lower in subjects consuming alternative
nutrition with deficiency observed in 24% of vegetarians, 78% of vegans vs. 0% in omnivores.
Serum folate levels are within the reference range in all groups. Mild hyperhomocysteinemia in the
groups consuming alternative diet is a consequence of vitamin B12 deficiency. Vegetarians and
vegans meet the RDA for energy and fat, and have a favourable proportion of saturated, monoand polyunsaturated fatty acids on total energy intake; the ratio of linoleic/alpha-linolenic acid in
their diet corresponds with the recommendations. They have low cholesterol consumption and
higher vitamin E and C intake. Optimal fat intake of correct composition is reflected in lower
values of atherosclerosis risk factors (cholesterol, LDL-cholesterol, atherogenic index, saturated
fatty acids, triacylglycerols), and significantly higher levels of protective substances (linoleic acid,
alpha-linolenic acid, HDL-cholesterol, vitamin E, vitamin E/cholesterol, vitamin C). Low lipid risk
factors but higher findings of mild hyperhomocysteinemia in vegetarians mean a diminished
protective effect of alternative nutrition in cardiovascular disease prevention.
Damage of molecules as a consequence of oxidative stress has been implicated in the pathogenesis
of chronic diseases related to aging. Diet is a key environmental factor affecting the incidence of
many chronic diseases. Antioxidant substances in diet enhance the DNA, lipid and protein
protection by increasing the scavenging of free radicals. In the study of Krajčovičová-Kudláčková
(2008) products of oxidative damage of DNA (DNA strand breaks with oxidized purines or
oxidized pyrimidines), lipids (conjugated dienes of fatty acids) and proteins (carbonyls) in relation
to nutrition (vegetarian diet vs. non-vegetarian, traditional mixed diet) were measured in young
women aged 20-30 years (46 vegetarians, 48 non-vegetarians) vs. older women aged 60-70 years
(33 vegetarians, 34 non-vegetarians). In young subjects, no differences in values of oxidative
damage as well as plasma values of antioxidative vitamins (C,beta-carotene) were observed between
vegetarian and non-vegetarian groups. In older vegetarian group significantly reduced values of
DNA breaks with oxidized purines, DNA breaks with oxidized pyrimidines and lipid peroxidation
and on the other hand, significantly increased plasma values of vitamin C and beta-carotene were
found compared to the respective non-vegetarian group. Significant age dependences of measured
parameters (increase in all oxidative damage products and decrease in plasma vitamin
concentrations in older women) were noted only in non-vegetarians. Vegetarian values of older
women vs. young women were similar or non-significantly changed. The results suggest that
increase of oxidative damage in aging may be prevented by vegetarian nutrition.
The aim of the paper of Siváková et al. (2007) is to evaluate dietary habits and behavioural factors
related to atherosclerosis in Slovak Romany, the large minority, characterized by high
cardiovascular morbidity. The study involved 150 Romany volunteers (68 males, mean age 42.1
+/- 13.9 y and 82 females, mean age 40.9 +/- 13.7 y). Dietary data were obtained by a validated
food-requency questionnaire and a single 24-hour dietary recall. The nutrient intake and health
behaviour of the Romany population is not consistent with current guidelines for atherosclerosis
57
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
prevention. The mean intake of fat is higher than the recommended dietary allowance (RDA),
especially in males (155.3 % of RDA). In females the intake of alpha-linolenic acid is low, in males
the cholesterol content of the food exceeds the acceptable value. The mean intake of protein is
higher than the recommendation (males 153% of RDA, females 122.2%), with a high proportion
of animal protein. In both sexes the mean intake of vitamins is below the RDA. In comparison to
the general population the diet of the Romany males contains significantly more animal protein (p
< 0.05), less plant protein (p < 0.05) and folate (p < 0.01). In the diet of the Romany females a
significantly lower intake of plant protein (p < 0.05) and vitamin E (p < 0.05) was observed, as well
as a lower intake of linoleic acid and iron in both sexes. The cumulation of ten selected
cardiovascular risk factors showed that particularly the Romany males could be considered as
having more atherogenic profile.
In the study of Krajčovičová-Kudláčková (1993) Lipid parameters (cholesterol CH, HDL-, LDLcholesterol, triacylglycerols TG, atherogenic index AI) were estimated in four age groups of
vegetarians, 82 males and 80 females, aged 15 to 60 years. The period of consumption of vegetarian
food was 1.4 to 1.9 years for adolescents (15-18 years old) or 2.4 to 5.4 years for adults (age groups
19-29 years, 30-39 years and 40-60 years). Lacto-vegetarians constituted one half of females and
one third of males. Vitamin C content, lipid peroxidation levels (conjugated dienes, CD) and the
activities of catalase (CAT) and glutathione peroxidase (GSH-Px) were estimated in the oldest age
group of males and females. Low levels of TG and glutathione peroxidase (GSH-Px) were
estimated in the oldest age group of males and females. Low levels of TG and CH (in the lower
half of the reference range), low calculated values of LDL-CH and AI, as well as values of HDLCH in the upper region of the standard risk zone or over 1.4 mmol/l (reduced risk level) in males
and females of all age groups are the positive factors of vegetarian nutrition in prevention of
atherosclerosis. High levels of vitamin C in blood, absence of obesity and low blood pressure
should be mentioned here as additional positive factors as well. When considered as a single isolated
factor, the nearly significantly elevated values of CD (linked to increased intake of unsaturated fatty
acids) could be a negative factor of vegetarian nutrition.
In the research of Béderová et al. (1993) 410 children aged 11-14 years and 311 adolescents aged
15-18 years were examined in the region Orava. This region was selected for the survey because of
high unemployment rates. The survey was focused on changes in nutritional indices in children
and adolescents, as a consequence of changed food consumption patterns, caused by increased
food prices and global socio-economic regression. Biochemical markers showed negative trends in
serum lipid levels, especially a high prevalence of hypercholesterolaemia as well as that of vitamin
C hyposaturation. This finding is related to impaired structure of consumed food, intake of food
items of lower nutritional value, low intakes of fruit and vegetables, as shown by the analysis of
dietary data.
Krajčovičová-Kudláčková, Šimončič and Béderová (1997) summarize the health risks and
advantages of alternative nutrition-lactovegetarian, lactoovovegetarian and vegan. These dietary
patterns involve risk in particular during pregnancy, lactation and for the growing organism.
Veganism excluding all foods of animal origin involves the greatest risk. General nutritional
58
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
principles for the prevention of cardiovascular diseases, oncological diseases and diabetes are fully
met by the vegetarian diet. Vegetarians and vegans have low risk factors of atherosclerosis and
conversely higher levels of antisclerotic substances. Overthreshold values of essential antioxidants
in vegetarians imply a protective action against reactive metabolic oxygen products and toxic
products of lipid peroxidation and may reduce the incidence of free radical diseases. The authors
also draw attention to some still open problems of vegetarianism (higher n-3 fatty acids, taurine,
carnitine). In the conclusion semivegetarianism is evaluated.
References
BAŠKOVÁ, M., T. BAŠKA & J. HOLUBČÍKOVÁ, (2016) Consumption of sweetened drinks
and energy drinks in adolescent s in Slovakia: implications for paediatric nursing, Central
European
Journals
Nursing
and
Midwifery
2016;7(1):390–395
doi:
10.15452/CEJNM.2016.07.0005,
BÉDEROVÁ A, BABINSKÁ K, MÁGALOVÁ T & BRTKOVÁ A. (1993) Aktuálny zdavotnenutricný stav detskej populácie v oravskom regióne [The present health and nutritional status
of the pediatric population in the area of Orava]. Cesk Pediatr. 1993;48(6):328-331.
BERNÁTOVÁ, S., Z. HEGEDUSOVÁ, K. DOSTÁLOVÁ, S. WIMMEROVÁ, Z. GEROVÁ,
E. HORVÁTHOVÁ & Š. MÓRICOVÁ (2016), Trend of obesity, sport and nutrition,
Macedonian pharmaceutical bulletin, 62 (suppl) 263 - 264 (2016) ISSN 1409 - 8695 UDC:
613.25:613.71/.73(437.6)
KAJABA I, et al. (2020). Development of the intestinal microbiome - importance for prevention
and therapy. In: Hygiena. 65(1):22-26. DOI: 10.21101/hygiena.a1735
KAZDA A. & P. BROULÍK (2017). Výživa a kostní metabolismus. [Nutrition and bone
metabolism]. In: Klinická biochemie a metabolismus. 25 (46), No. 1, p. 4–12.
KRAJCOVICOVÁ-KUDLÁCKOVÁ M, SIMONCIC R, BABINSKÁ K & BÉDEROVÁ, K.
(1993). Lipid parameters in blood of vegetarians. Cor Vasa. 1993;35(6):224-229.
KRAJCOVICOVÁ-KUDLÁCKOVÁ M, SIMONCIC R & BÉDEROVÁ A. (1997). Riziká a
prednosti vegetariánskej výzivy [Risks and advantages of the vegetarian diet]. Cas Lek Cesk.
1997;136(23):715-719.
KRAJČOVIČOVÁ-KUDLÁČKOVÁ, M., P. BLAŽÍČEK, K. BABINSKÁ, J. KOPČOVÁ, J.
KLVANOVÁ, A. BÉDEROVÁ & T. MAGÁLOVÁ (2000) Traditional and alternative
nutrition - levels of homocysteine and lipid parameters in adults, Scandinavian Journal of
Clinical and Laboratory Investigation, 60:8, 657-664, DOI: 10.1080/00365510050216385
KRAJCOVICOVÁ- KUDLÁCKOVÁ, M., M. VALACHOVICOVÁ, V. PAUKOVÁ & M.
DUSINSKÁ (2008) Effects of diet and age on oxidative damage products in healthy subjects,
Physiol Res, 2008;57(4):647-51. Epub 2007 Jul 26.
LOPAŠOVSKÝ, L., M. TERENTJEVA, S. KUNOVÁ, L. ZELEŇÁKOVÁ & M. KAČÁNIOVÁ
(2016), Microbiological quality of ready-to-eat foods produced in Slovakia, Journal of
Microbiology an Biotechnololgy and Food sciences doi: 10.15414/jmbfs.2016.5.special1.3135
59
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
MARINOV, Z. & H. STŘÍTECKÁ. (2017). Malnutrition in obese children. In: Pediatrie pro praxi.
18(2): 94–99
MINÁRIK, P. & P. MLKVÝ. (2016). The role of calcium and vitamin D in the prevention of
colorectal cancer. In: Gastroenterologie a hepatologie. No (2)
MROSKOVÁ, S. & V., KONEČNÁ (2018). Výživa ako doplnková forma liečby psoriázy.
[Nutrition as an adjunct form of psoriasis treatment]. In: General Practitioner / Prakticky Lekar
. 98 (5), p214-216.
MURÍN, J. (2016). Prevencia kardiovaskulárnych ochorení – čo dokáže diéta? [Cardiovascular
prevention – what can we expect from our diet?]. In: Súčasná klinická. Prax. 1, pp 34-38.
POCHOP, L. (2020). How to approach anorexia and nutrition in palliative patients? In:
Onkologie.14(Suppl.C): 35-38. DOI: 10.36290/xon.2020.054
SIVÁKOVÁ, D., K. BABINSKÁ, Z. BASISTOVÁ, M. ZACHAROVÁ, L. WSÓLOVÁ & A.
BÉDEROVÁ, (2007) Dietary patterns and lifestyle in a sample of a Slovak Romany
community Anthropol Anz. 2007 Mar;65(1):25-35.
ŠEDÍK, P., C., B. POCOL & E. HORSKÁ (2019) Honey: food or medicine? A comparative study
between Slovakia and Romania, Mariantonietta Fiore British Food Journal, SSN: 0007-070X,
Publication date: 20 June 2019
TLÁSKAL, P. (2019). Vliv výživy na rozvoj obezity v různých obdobích vývoje dítěte [The
influence of nutrition on the development of obesity in different periods of child
development]. In: Czecho-Slovak Pediatrics / Cesko-Slovenska Pediatrie. 74, (2), p88-92.
VITÁRIUŠOVÁ, BABINSKÁ, KOŠŤÁLOVÁ, ROSINSKÝ, HLAVATÁ, PRIBILINCOVÁ,
BABINSKÁ & KOVÁCS, (2010), Food intake, leisure time activities and the prevalence of
obesity in schoolchildren in Slovakia, Cent Eur J Public Health 2010; 18 (4): 192–197
ZLATOHLÁVKOVÁ, B. (2016). Časná výživa a dlouhodobé zdraví. [Early nutrition and lifelong
health]. In: Pediatrie v praxi. 17(5): 286–290.
60
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
Food as a Medicine – Selected Findings from Worldwide
Literature Review
Susana Franco - 1Manel Valcarce-Torrente - 5Francisco Gómez-Almeida 2
Carla Chicau Borrego - 3Eric Vandenabeele - 3Gert van Reckem 4
Stanislav Kraček - 4Gabriela Kotyrová Štefániková - 4Adriana Kaplánová
2
1
Valencian International University, Valencia, Spain
Sport Sciences School of Rio Maior, Polytechnic Institute of Santarém; Life Quality Research Center, Portugal
3
Fitness- BE Wellness & Health, Belgium
4
Comenius University in Bratislava, Faculty of Physical Education and Sports, Slovakia
5
Valgo Sports Consulting, Madrid, Spain
e-mail: adriana.kaplanova@uniba.sk
2
Abstract
Expert studies have confirmed that nutritious food is a suitable preventive form of oncological
diseases (especially breast, prostate, colon and rectal cancers), as well as a suitable adjunctive
treatment for immune-mediated skin disease - Psoriasis Vulgaris. Clinical studies that have
alleviated chronic inflammation with a proper diet have even shown a positive effect of milk
proteins on anti-inflammatory markers, as well as a positive effect of omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty
acids on these markers. According to experts, the alternative diet nutrition-lactovegetarian,
lactoovovegetarian and vegan reduces the risk of atherosclerosis. Excessive levels of essential
antioxidants in vegetarians provide protective action against reactive metabolic oxygen products
and toxic lipid peroxidation products and can reduce the incidence of free radical disease.
Key words: Food as medicine, Physical activity
61
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
The aim of narrative review of Poti et al. (2017) was to summarize and critique recent evidence
evaluating the association between ultra-processed food intake and obesity. Overall, evidence
suggests that consumption of ultra-processed foods may be associated with increased risk of
obesity as well as metabolic syndrome prevalence, increases in total and LDL cholesterol, and risk
of hypertension. However, the limited number of prospective studies and the limited number of
studies investigating each outcome preclude any strong conclusions about the impact of ultraprocessed food consumption on obesity and related cardiometabolic outcomes. There is a clear
need for further studies, particularly those using longitudinal designs and with sufficient control
for confounding by lifestyle factors, to examine the association between ultra-processed food
consumption and obesity. If confirmed using stronger study designs and in diverse populations
and settings, these associations between ultra-processed food consumption and adverse health
outcomes can provide critical insight into the etiology of obesity and can help inform development
of targeted public health programs and policies to control and treat obesity among children and
adults worldwide.
The global challenges of diet-related obesity, diabetes mellitus, and CVD present enormous health
and economic burdens and emphasize the imperative of prioritizing nutrition in clinical care,
advocacy, research, and policy (Mozaffarian 2016). Scientific advances provide a wealth of new
evidence to identify several key dietary priorities for cardiometabolic health. These include foodbased priorities for more fruits, nonstarchy vegetables, nuts, legumes, fish, vegetable oils, yogurt,
and whole grains; and fewer processed (sodium-preserved) meats and foods higher in refined
carbohydrates and salt. Red meats shouldbe minimized to prevent diabetes mellitus; butter used
occasionally but not emphasized; and other foods (eg, unprocessed poultry, eggs) consumed in
moderation according to personal preference. Coffee and tea can be enjoyed, with possible (but
notyet confirmed) benefits; and alcohol, if consumed, should be moderate (up to 1 drink/d for
women and 2 drinks/d for men). Harmful additives, in particular sodium, transfat, and added sugar,
will generally be lower in such diets and must be further minimized through strong policy actions.
There is growing evidence and consensus for such food-based dietary patterns as the best means
to reduce CVD, obesity and weight gain, and diabetes mellitus,replacing outdated emphases on
total fat, other isolated nutrients, and calorie counting. Clinical behavior-change efforts, health
system changes, novel technologies, and robust policy strategies must complement and facilitate
these individual food choices, which together will reduce cardiometabolic disease and economic
burdens across the population.
That sarcopenic obesity is a highly multi-factorial condition, which requires a multi-targeted
approach. Review of Trouwborst et al. (2018) provides the latest overview of both exercise and
nutrition interventions targeting both the body composition and physical functioning in sarcopenic
obese individuals. In line with this aim, this review shows that a combination of a moderate weight
loss diet, with concurrent exercise and a high protein intake (≥1.2 g/kg/day), which is relatively
high in animal protein and spread throughout the day, has the highest potential in improving
different parameters of sarcopenic obesity. However, further research is needed to better
understand the optimal rate of weight loss, the type, intensity, and frequency of the exercise, the
combined effects of the different individual strategies (exercise and nutritional) on body
62
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
composition and physical functioning parameters in sarcopenic obese older adults. Finally, as new
interventional technics and bariatric surgery are spreading out for the treatment of obesity in adults,
we may have to consider the longterm impact of bariatric surgery on muscle preservation after
surgery, and the optimal strategy to maintain mobility in these aging patients in the future.
Review of Toro-Martin et al. (2017) was an attempt to stress the most important challenges and
issues that nutritional science has to overcome in order to successfully translate basic and clinical
knowledge into an effective precision nutrition care. Up to date, the PREDIMED study and the
Food4Me project could be considered as state-of-the-art trials in the field of precision nutrition,
and two of the most stimulating wide-scale approaches in this field, that will hopefully provide
guidance about how precision nutrition could be used to successfully prevent and manage
cardiometabolic disorders. As already mentioned, such integrated approaches have the potential to
improve dietary behaviors in an individualized or in a group-based manner, and to generate new
and innovative tools, methods and procedures.
In conclusion, Kim et al. (2019) found that fast food consumption was not directly associated with
obesity, whereas the “Meat and alcohol” pattern had independent associations with
overweight/obesity and central obesity independent of fast food. Even if fast food is high in
calories, the unhealthy dietary pattern has a stronger correlation with overweight/obesity and
central obesity than fast food consumption on its own. Our results indicate that more attention
should be paid to dietary patterns to prevent and manage overweight/obesity and central obesity
among adults in South Korea.
The obesity epidemic is an image of complexity, displaying a risk profile with biological and social
susceptibilities across population groups, environments, and life courses that could be present even
in early life . The concept of early metabolic programming gave us the possibility to look at the
literature, in order to see what causes could influence the first 1000 days of life, which is the most
important and critical period for development. The ten good practices developed have been shown
to influence growth and function of different tissues in the human body. We found that excessive
adipose tissue expansion may promote infant adipogenesis and infant rapid growth, both early
markers of risk associated with childhood obesity (Pietrobelli 2017).
Casas et al. (2018) have shown the intimate relationship between nutrition and CVD. Thus, the
challenge is in promoting healthy dietary habits as well as an active lifestyle as early as possible in
children and young adults. The evidence favors consumption of healthy dietary patterns, such as
the Mediterranean diet or DASH diet, against other unhealthy dietary patterns, such as the Western
diet, based on a high consumption of salt, added sugars, and saturated and trans-fats. Despite the
fact that strong evidence shows the potential health benefits of a great number of foods, nutrients,
bioactive compounds, and dietary antioxidants, such as polyphenols, may exert on CV risk factors
or directly on CVD development, it is necessary to conduct more interventional studies with a
higher number of cases and longer follow up. To date, a lot of results obtained have produced few
conclusions and sometimes, even contradictions. Therefore, due to a lack of information about
63
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
possible mechanisms implicated in the cardioprotective effect of diet, foods, nutrients, or bioactive
compounds, this needs to be more investigated.
With our population rapidly aging, nutritional strategies for preventing or reversing arterial aging
and reducing CVD risk will continue to be an important area of research (Larocca et al. 2017).
There is already strong clinical/translational evidence in support of several broad dietary patterns,
energy restriction approaches, and nutraceutical compounds for healthy arterial aging. However,
many important questions remain. It will be particularly important to further establish which
specific diets and foods improve vs. impair function, and which alternative strategies (e.g.,
intermittent fasting paradigms, select nutracueticals) have the potential to enhance arterial health
in older adults for whom healthy diet alone is not enough.
Nutrition therapies for diabetes have been described and reviewed. Evidence-based clinical practice
is a dynamic process. Clinicians create an individualized treatment plan based not only on
accumulated evidence but also on patient preference and original lifestyle. In this process, patientcentered communication skills are essential. I believe that such shared decision making is essential
for successful clinical practice and supports patient longevity and quality of life (Yamada 2017).
The main store of glycogen in the body. Sugar is a great supplement, supplying both glucose and
fructose (Peinado at al. 2013). A diet with a high amount of carbohydrates is recommended in
endurance and high endurance sports. In long-term submaximal efforts, the longer the physical
activity lasts, the greater the use of muscle glycogen and the less energy obtained from lipids. When
the effort is high but the duration is not so long, the phosphagen system, glucose and glycogen
constitute the main source of energy. Depending on the exercise load that is daily carried out, it is
recommended to take one amount of carbohydrates or another. In people who perform light
activities, 3-5 g / kg per day is recommended and in athletes with a high intensity exercise program
(4-5 h per day) 8-12 g / kg * day is recommended. The decrease in glycogen is a limiting factor in
performance. It is necessary to take into account not only the quantities but also the moment of
intake.
A low fat and a carbohydrates diet, in people with overweight and metabolic syndrome, could offer
weight loss. Due Gomez at al. (2013) there are studies that do not blame sugar for the increase of
chronic disease. In Australia there was a substantial decrease in sugar intake and during that same
period obesity had experienced a significant increase. In conclusion we can see that sugar doesn’t
seem to limit obesity incidence. Another relevant factor that can help questioning sugarcardiovascular disease relation is sedentarism. There is some indicator that clearly shows that
sedentarism is more common in our society. One of the main reasons that can justify the increase
of cardiovascular diseases is that the main determinants for the population to modify their eating
habits and increase physical activity are not educational, but environmental. In other words, there
is a socio-economic and also a cultural background, which are determining factors in the different
types of impact of preventive interventions. Also, the lack of areas for practicing physical exercise
and the high prizes of vegetables and fruit, are considered to be some limiting factors. The current
64
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
is accompanied by a clear decrease of physical exercise, with stress as pivotal pathogenic elements
and a more unbalanced diet.
Article of Bray and Popkin (2013) found out that about 75% of all foods and beverages contain
added sugar in a large array of forms. Consumption of soft drinks has increased fivefold since 1950.
This consumption of soft drinks is related to the risk of diabetes, the metabolic syndrome, and
cardiovascular disease. In 1776- at the time of the American Revolution- Americans consumed
about 4 lbs of sugar per person each year. By 1850, this had risen to 20 lbs, and by 1994, to 120
lbs. High Fructose Corn Syrup and the fructose that they both contain have dramatically increased
the health risks. In another survey of 75 countries, soft drink intake increased globally from 9.5
gallons per capita per year in 1997 to 11.4 gallons in 2010. A 1% rise in soft drink consumption
was associated with an additional 48 overweight adults per 100 people, 2.3 obese adults per 100,
and 0.3 adults with diabetes per 100. Many health problems are linked with this increase in fructose
intake but fatty liver disease is one which increase is noted in both the U.S. and Europe and certainly
is linked with excessive fructose intake. Some of the recommendations for the individual are: 1)
Chose water, unsweetened coffee, or tea in place of calorically sweetened beverages. 2) Chose and
eat fruit rather than drink fruit juice or fruit drinks.
Apparently, ketogenic diets (<30 carbohydrates per day) are growing its popularity because of its
potential benefits on weight loss, but there are some studies that can affirm this diet can have worse
metabolic consequences than others which nowadays can be considered totally unhealthy (Evans
2018).
Stretching is a fundamental part of what is known as physical activity but it is not as studied and
well-practiced as it ought to be. Due Mora, Pena and Machado (2005) experts think professional
athletes sometimes reject stretching, but it allows the maximum path of the joint in various
positions. Furthermore, it is as important to stretch in the first place, as to do it correctly. It must
be maintained, in order, and progressive. If done correctly, stretching has a lot of benefits regarding
life quality.
Regarding sports at the aim of an athlete to maximizing his performance, it’s important to have in
mind three fundamental moments: before, during and after the exercise (Pérez-Guisado 2009). In
the first place, it’s important to know what to eat, in what amount, and how long before the physical
activity, so it helps digestion. But actually, the moment after the exercise is the most important one
to facilitate muscle mass and strength development.
Diet takes part of a lot of chronic diseases in our century. That is why diet is the object of study of
many experts, and also how it has affected to human’s health along the years compared to our
ancestors’s diets have. It’s been proved that primates have had a much more plant-based diet that
we humans, at the present time, have. That descreases our micronutrients and fiber intake, and also
taking into account the low caloric density of wild foods and our processed (both plant and animal)
food, that is clearly reflected in our health (Milton 2000).
65
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Due Pérez-López et al. (2014) caloric reduction has been one of the most popular dietary strategies
for many years. Caloric reduction is a successful strategy for a short-term goal (e.g. if you are a
judoka and you need to slim down for a tournament). However, for a long-term is not very effective
because of the jojo effect. The key to lose weight is to reduce the nutrients intake and also to do
physical activity. Harvard analysed the results of an investigation where they compare the effectivity
for two strategies: on the first hand, a diet, on the second hand we have the combination of a diet
and physical activity program. In the system with the diet they could see that the benefits disappear
as time passed by. Only 3% of the patients could maintain the weight lost for like a year (or five
years in extreme cases). With the other system we do not lose as much weight as we do with the
other strategy, but we increase our muscular mass. Besides we do not recover our lost mass.
Mediterranean Sea, and is generally characterised by frequent consumption of fruit, vegetables,
complex carbohydrates, pulses and fish; low consumption of meat and cheese; low-to-moderate
amount of wine intake during meals; and use of olive oil for seasoning (Turati et al. 2015). High
intake of fruit and vegetables have been related to a reduced risk of cancer at several sites. The high
intake of vegetables reduced the cancer appearance. The vegetables effect on our health is stronger
than the high fruit intake. In Italy 20%-60% of digestive tract cancers in Italy could be attributable
to low consumption of vegetables and fruit. Micronutrients (vitamins and minerals) could also act
against cancer through their antioxidant activities, fee radical-trapping capacity, modulation of
detoxification. However, despite the promising results of several dietary vitamins and food
component on cancer risk from epidemiological studies, trials usually failed to show a protective
effect of vitamin supplementation on cancer risk.
Weight loss is a key factor in preventing the risk of various diseases, including diabetes. In this
clinical trial, a group of individuals at high risk of suffering from diabetes was selected as a sample,
and a Diabetes Prevention Program (DPP) was applied, which included a diet high in carbohydrates
and low in fat, as well as physical activity. The objective was to evaluate the associations between
diet and the prevention of diabetes. The results showed that a dietary shift toward higher
carbohydrate intake, higher intake of dietary fibber, fruits, and vegetables, and lower fat intake,
promotes weight loss in people at high risk of developing type 2 diabetes (Sylvetsky et al. 2017).
Many studies have observed associations between saturated fat in the diet and the risk of coronary
heart disease, but few have compared saturated fats with unsaturated fats and carbohydrate sources
in relation to the risk of coronary heart disease, this being the goal of This studio. To do this, a
sample of 84,628 women and 42,908 men were analysed, all without previous illnesses. With the
results obtained, it has been observed that unsaturated fats and high-quality carbohydrates,
especially whole grains, can be used to replace saturated fats, and thus reduce the risk of coronary
heart disease (Li at al. 2015).
The importance of protein is known for maintaining a balanced diet, but its beneficial effects vary
depending on the type of protein it is, whether of animal or plant origin. Study of Song et al. (2016)
aims to compare the associations of animal protein and plant protein intake with the risk of
mortality. To do this, it has analysed the protein components of the diets of 131,342 participants,
66
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
for 32 years. In this study, it has been concluded that a high intake of animal protein was associated
with higher cardiovascular mortality, and a high intake of vegetable protein was inversely associated
with mortality, that is, it reduced the risk of death, especially in people at risk of health. Therefore,
they conclude that it would be important to replace red meat, especially processed meat, with
sources of vegetable protein.
Study of Mujcic and Oswald (2016) aims to analyse the psychological improvements produced after
a high consumption of fruits and vegetables in the diet, in a group of 385 adults. In this study it
has been observed that with an increase in the consumption of fruits and vegetables, there is an
increase in happiness, satisfaction with life and well-being. These improvements occurred in 24
months. People's motivation to eat healthy foods is weakened by the fact that the effects can take
a long time to appear. However, an increase in the consumption of fruits and vegetables allows to
observe positive effects in less time. Therefore, the authors conclude that, at a political level,
citizens can be shown improvements in increased happiness through a healthy diet rich in fruits
and vegetables, being able to feel its effects quickly.
Jensen (2006) makes an analysis on whether nutrition supplementation is actually important for the
recovery of inflammation, especially in highly proinflammatory states. Inflammation depends on
the genes and the lifestyle that someone has, but in illnesses it can become quite problematic. From
a nutrition point of view, it involves the destruction of muscle mass and joints and hyperglycaemia.
The author maintains that nutrition supplementation alone has no value towards the recovery of
inflammation, but he proves that combining good nutrition with other factors can solve
inflammation. Following this line of thought, the author states that including and combining antiinflammatory diets, glycemic control, physical activity, appetite stimulants, anabolic agents, antiinflammatory agents, anticytokines, and probiotics can really modulate inflammation altogether,
and therefore improve our health and recovery of illnesses and injuries.
Pinon et al. (2019) conducted a study, in a rural community in central Nebraska with under a
thousand inhabitants, about how many sugar-sweetened beverages (SSBs) they consumed every
day, with the purpose of studying if there is a high consumption of SSBs in areas with higher risk
of health disparities and risk of disease. To conduct the study, they used a survey designed so
everyone that has passed at least fourth grade of primary school could understand it and complete
it. They found out that there is a correlation between higher SSBs consumption and higher Body
Mass Index (BMI), especially in people who suffered overweight or obesity. These results are
important since a lot of studies point out that especially people that do not live in urban areas and
people with lower incomes, and thus, lower access to healthier food, are the ones with a greater
risk of suffering obesity and heart diseases. Therefore, this study proved that the last statistics are
the same for SSBs consumption, as in this community the average consumption was higher than
the average in an urban area in Nebraska, than the average in the whole state of Nebraska, and the
average of 23 states. In conclusion, the authors state that this field must be further studied and
addressed in primary attention clinics, as well as reducing access to SSBs, by increasing their taxes,
for instance, since this is a public health issue.
67
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
A review by Gómez et al. (2020) describes the effects of processing and preservation technologies
on the sensory and nutritional quality of meat products. Physical methods such as dry aging, dry
curing, high pressure discussion (HPP), conventional cooking, sous-vide cooking and 3D printing.
Chemical and biochemical methods such as fermentation, smoking, drying, marinating and
reformulation are discussed. are also re-evaluated. Their technical limitations, due to the loss of
sensory quality when the nutritional values of these products are improved, are presented and
discussed. There are several studies focused on either the nutritional or sensory quality of processed
meat products, but more studies are needed to integrate these two aspects. The combination of
different processing and preservation methods leads to better sensory quality results; thus, further
research into combinations of different factors is needed to ensure that the nutritional value of the
meat is not compromised.
Obesity is characterized by resistance to appetite-regulating hormones, which leads to a
misalignment between physiological signals and the perceived hunger / satiety signal. Interrupting
the rhythm of the synthesis may explain this situation. The aim of the study by Morante et al. (2020)
were to evaluate the effect of diet-induced weight loss on the daily rhythms of leptin and ghrelin
and its effect on daily doses of the variability of appetite sensations in obese patients. Weight loss
reduced leptin synthesis (pauc <0.001), but not rhythmic characteristics, except mean value of
variability (pmesor = 0.020). On the contrary, the average level of ghrelin increased after weight
loss. Rhythmic characteristics were also adjusted until the rhythm was similar to that achieved in
normal weight subjects. The degree of variability of leptin and ghrelin correlated with the
effectiveness of the dietary intervention (p <0.020 and p <0.001, respectively). Weight loss partially
restores the daily rhythms of leptin and adjusts the rhythms of ghrelin, but appetite is hardly
controlled, confirming that these hormones cannot perform their physiological functions properly.
Due Martins et al. (2020) physical activity (PA) and sedentary behaviors (SB) influence health. Since
most people engage in different combinations of both behaviors every day, understanding the
socio-demographic characteristics of adults with distinct PA and sitting time (ST) patterns is
important to contribute to evidence-based planning of public health strategies. Data from a
national survey on diet and activity behaviors (IAN-AF, 2015/16) including 1724 adults (50.5%
women, 18–64 years) from a representative sample of Portuguese adults was used in this study.
Participants were interviewed face-to-face, and the International Physical Activity Questionnaire
(IPAQ) was used. Logistic regression examined the associations between socio-demographic
factors each of the four-low/high PA-ST groups. PA low/high categories were defined as in IPAQ,
while ST low/high categories were defined according to ST tertiles (≤180 min/day, ≥360
min/day). A ‘higher risk’ behavior pattern (low PA/high ST) was present in 37.3% of the adults
and was likely associated with a middle household income, and with having 12 or more years of
education. The ‘lower risk’ (high PA/low ST) represented 26.6% of the sample and was likely
associated with middle-aged adults and with having a lower educational level. Being male, young
and highly educated was related to being physically active and spending large amounts of time in
ST. Besides adding to the body of mixed evidence on this theme, the identification of the sociodemographic factors associated with each PA/ST pattern will permit national public health
authorities to define policies and tailored actions to promote PA and reduce ST.
68
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
Study of Oliveira et al. (2018) includes, for the first time, estimates of general and abdominal obesity
prevalence for all ages of the Portuguese population, using common standardized methodologies.
Results are compared by sex, age groups, educational level and geographical regions. Participants
were a representative sample of the Portuguese population aged between 3 months and 84 years
of age (n= 6553), enrolled in the National Food, Nutrition and Physical Activity Survey, 2015–
2016. Objective anthropometric measurements included length/height, weight and body
circumferences, performed according to standard procedures. Abdominal obesity was defined in
adults as waist-hip ratio≥0.85 in women or≥0.90 in men. Prevalence estimates and 95% confidence
intervals (95%CI) were weighted according to a complex sampling design, considering stratification
by seven geographical regions and cluster effect for the selected Primary Health Care Unit. The
national prevalence of obesity is 22.3% (95%CI: 20.5–24.0), significantly higher in women. Obesity
prevalence is much higher in the elderly (39.2%, 95%CI. 34.2–44.2), while children and adolescents
have the lowest prevalence around8–9%. In a regression model, three knot points denoting an
inflection of obesity prevalence across the life span were observed around 5, 15 and 75 years. The
prevalence of pre-obesity at national level is 34.8% (95%CI: 32.9–36.7), higher in men, and almost
18% of children and 24% of adolescents have pre-obesity. The sex- and age-standardized
prevalence of obesity ranged from 38.3% (95%CI: 34.6–42.1) to 13.1% (95%CI: 10.3–15.9)for the
less and the most educated individuals, respectively. Although some geographical region disparities,
obesity prevalence did not significantly differ across regions (p=0.094). The national prevalence of
abdominal obesity in adults is 50.5% (95%CI: 47.9–53.1), particularly high in the elderly (80.2%).
Almost 60% of the general Portuguese population is obese or pre-obese. Women, elderly and less
educated individuals present the highest obesity prevalence. Abdominal obesity, in particular,
seems to be a relevant public health problem among the elderly men.
The fact that nearly half (49.3%) of the adult population aged 18 years and older is overweight and
15.9% is obese, prevalence that have been observed since the first health survey in 1997 (41.3%
and 10.8%, respectively). %) have only continued to increase, makes this a major public health
problem (Drieskens et al. 2018). Overweight and obesity are more common in men, in the 35-74
age group and the less educated, making them important target groups in terms of prevention. In
addition, the situation is worst in the Walloon Region (51.8% and 18.0% respectively, percentages
significantly higher than in the Flemish and Brussels Regions). One in five (19.0%) young people
aged 2 to 5 17 years of age are overweight and 5.8% are obese. The problem is greatest among
toddlers aged 2-4 years (24.4% respectively, so almost one in four, and 11.7%). The situation among
young people is more favorable, in the sense that this prevalence has remained constant compared
to the previous survey years (except 1997). Here too, attention should be paid to young people
from households with a low educational level, because two out of five (40.5%) of these young
people are already overweight and 14.0% are obese. As far as young people are concerned, the
situation is only in the Brussels Region (27.3% and 10.5% respectively, percentages significantly
higher than the Flemish Region, but not the Walloon Region).
This Belgian food consumption survey was conducted by the Scientific Institute of Public Health
(WIV). Food intake data was collected between February 2014 and May 2015 from nearly 3,200
Belgians aged between 3 and 64 years. This also provided for the first time more insight into the
69
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
nutrition of children between 3 and 15 years old. The previous food consumption survey dates
from 2004 and only concerned Belgians from the age of 15 (De Ridder et al. 2016). Belgians still
eat too many energy-rich and nutrient-poor foods and too few nutrient-rich foods. As a result, they
consume too much fat and sugar and show deficiencies in important vitamins and minerals. In
order for Belgians to better comply with the general dietary guidelines, the IPH argues for the
consumption of nutrient-rich basic foods such as vegetables, fruit, potatoes, whole grain products,
fish and milk products to be promoted more and to make it more available as an obvious choice.
Although there are arguments for limiting meat consumption, the IPH points out that meat is an
important source of essential nutrients. It is not necessary to completely remove meat from the
menu.
Where are the bottlenecks?
• drinks too little water: 797 ml instead of at least 1 liter; eat too little bread and substitute products:
141 g instead of 150-360 g; eat too few potatoes and substitute products: 138 g instead of 210 to
350 g; he eats a third less potatoes than ten years ago and is replacing potatoes more often with
refined and therefore less fiber-rich products such as white rice and pasta; takes too few vegetables:
145 g instead of 300 g; eat too little fruit: 1 piece instead of 2 to 3 pieces; uses too little milk products
and calcium-fortified soy products: 160 ml instead of the recommended 450 to 600 ml; he eats
enough cheese; because milk and dairy products are our main source of calcium, such underconsumption also has repercussions on the average calcium intake below the recommended
amount; consumes too many extras such as sugary and alcohol-containing drinks, sweets and
snacks that do not contribute to a healthy diet. These extras are good for more than 650 kcal or
about a third of the average energy intake. That is almost three times the maximum allowable
amount. Such extras are also responsible for about a third of the daily fat and saturated fat intake,
they contribute to an excessive intake of mono- and disaccharides and little or no intake of vitamins
and minerals
Previous studies have shown that there is a relationship between the composition of the intestinal
flora and, for example, obesity or all kinds of conditions such as intestinal inflammation and
diabetes. Such results naturally make you dream about the possibility of remedying ailments or
alleviating their symptoms through interventions on the intestinal flora. Substances produced by
microorganisms in our gut can affect the brain. In doing so, they also guide our behavior and our
feelings. Microbiologist Jeroen Raes (VIB - KU Leuven) discovered this after researching more
than a thousand test subjects. Until now, researchers have mainly investigated the link between
stomach and brain in laboratory animals. Raes (2019) and his team aimed at people. They mapped
the bacteria present in their test subjects' intestines. In that intestinal flora, they discovered specific
bacterial groups that are related to mental health. Two of these, Coprococcus and Dialister, were
not found in people with depression. Similar results were found in subjects in a Dutch research
project and in a group of depression patients at UZ Leuven. Raes also previously discovered that
certain bacterial communities are more common in Crohn's disease patients. It appears that the
bacteria associated with intestinal inflammation also negatively impacts mental health. This
investigation is currently ongoing.
70
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
In the study of Pot et al. (2020) researchers examined the effect of this treatment method in an
initial 438 participants. Ultimately, they were able to include data from 234 participants in the
analyzes. The program consists of an intensive coaching program of 6 months followed by a
follow-up program of 18 months. It is intended for patients with diabetes who are already on
medication. During the treatment the focus is on nutrition, exercise, sleep and relaxation. The
guidance is provided by a dietician, exercise coach and nurse. The patient's GP is also closely
involved in the treatment. We work with a combination of individual and group sessions,
supplemented with online support. Some results:
• After 2 years, 67% of the participants used less sugar-lowering drugs, and 28% were even able to
stop using this medication completely.
• Of the 66 participants who received insulin at baseline, 71% were no longer using insulin after 2
years.
• The participants weighed an average of 7 kg less after the study and had a smaller waist
circumference (average -8.2 cm). Their triglycerides (blood fats) and HDL ("good" cholesterol)
levels were also improved.
• Mean HemoglobinA1c (HbA1c) levels, on the other hand, did not change much in the
participants. Hemoglobin is a protein that can bind sugar in the blood. The value of this
"saccharified" hemoglobin or HbA1c gives a good picture of the average blood sugar level. The
proportion of "normal" HbA1c levels increased in the participants from 45% at the start of the
lifestyle program to 53% after 2 years.
Teras at al. (2019) and Drieskens at al. (2018) examined whether women who lose weight had a
lower risk of developing breast cancer. Those estrogens can cause breast cells to grow, which can
lead to breast cancer if that growth is out of control. To find an answer to the research question,
the researchers collected data from ten large cohort studies with women over 50 years old. During
the follow-up, the women had to declare their weight at least three times and recorded breast cancer
incidence. In total there were 180,885 women and 6,930 breast cancers. The researchers divided
the women into different groups according to the evolution of body weight during the follow-up.
The researchers also took into account possible disturbing factors such as physical activity and the
use of hormonal preparations. Compared to women who maintained a stable weight, the risk of
breast cancer decreased by 13% when they lost 2 to 4.5 kg. With a weight loss of 4.5 to 9 kg that
was 16% and when they lost more than 9 kg, it even decreased by 26%. The reduction in breast
cancer risk was particularly evident in women who were overweight or obese at the start of the
study. The researchers conclude that weight loss can be an important measure to reduce the risk
of breast cancer.
Overweight or obesity is very often associated with high blood pressure, abnormal blood sugar and
excess cholesterol (Lasalle 2018). Yet there are many people with a BMI over 25 (which the World
Health Organization classifies as "overweight") and even over 30 ("obese") for whom these clinical
indicators are absent. Despite their excess body fat, they have a fairly normal blood pressure and
cholesterol, which makes them considered healthy by many doctors, especially at the level of the
metabolism. Fat but healthy, if you like. This is unjustified, according to a long and comprehensive
study in which thousands of people in more than ten European countries were followed for years.
71
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
The British medics who coordinated the study looked for links between obesity on the one hand
and heart disease on the other. They classified the study participants according to medical indicators
such as blood pressure, cholesterol level, blood sugar and BMI. If people met three or more of the
criteria, they were classified as "unhealthy". People with a (much too) high BMI escaped that. "In
the overweight group, the risk of heart complaints was almost 30 percent higher than in the healthy
participants with a healthy BMI (between 18.5 and 25)". But the analysis found that in the end,
they didn't escape the effects of their excess body fat - statistically, that is. For example, the risk of
ischemic heart complaints - in which the heart receives too little blood due to blocked coronary
arteries and a heart attack - was almost 30 percent higher than in the healthy participants with a
healthy BMI (between 18.5 and 25). In the unhealthy participants the risk of the same type of heart
complaints was preferably twice as high as in the healthy group.
Dietary fiber (DF) contains a wide range of naturally occurring and modified materials with
significant changes in physical and chemical properties and potential physiological effects.
Although nutritional studies that test the effects of DF usually provide extensive details of
physiological responses, many still fail to adequately state the type and properties of DF itself. This
weakens the ability to directly replicate and compare studies and create structural-functional
relationships. The study by Poutanen et al (2018) outlines the factors that affect DF function and
provides 4 general recommendations for the characterization and reporting of DF preparations
and DF-containing foods in nutritional research. They relate to 1) the implementation of
characterization methods that reflect the study hypothesis; 2) adequate reporting of the source of
DF, quantity and composition; 3) measurement of rheological properties of DF; a4) estimation of
the rate and extent of DF fermentation. It is important to consider the food matrix of the tested
products, as this may affect the functionality of the DF and thus the apparent effectiveness of the
DF for health outcomes.
References
Bray, G. & Popkin, B. (2014). Dietary sugar and body weight: have we reached a crisis in the
epidemic 950-956. doi: 10.2337/dc13-2085
Casas, R., et al. (2018). Nutrition and Cardiovascular Health. In: International journal of molecular
sciences, 19(12), 3988. DOI: 10.3390/ijms19123988
De Ridder K, Bel S, Brocatus L, Lebacq T, Moyersoen I, Ost C & Teppers E. (2016). De
consumptie van voedings-middelen en de inname van voedingsstoffen. In: Bel S, Tafforeau
J (ed.). Voedselconsumptiepeiling 2014-2015. Rapport 4. WIV-ISP, Brussel.
Drieskens, S., Charafeddine, R. & Gisle, L. (2018). Gezondheidsenquête 2018. (The situation in
Belgium according to the results of the 2018 health survey). https://his.wivisp.be/nl/Gedeelde%20%20documenten/NS_NL_2018.pdf
Evans, M. (2018). Keto diets: good, bad or ugly? The journal of Physiology. 19, 4561. doi:
10.1113/JP276703
Gómez, I., Janardhanan, R., Ibañez., F.C. & Beriain, M.J. (2020). The effect of processing and
preservation technologies on meat quality: Sensory and nutritional aspects. Foods 2020, 9(10),
1416; https://doi.org/10.3390/foods9101416
72
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
Gómez, L., Romero, LM., & García, J. (2013). Azúcar y enfermedades cardiovasculares. Nutrición
Hospitalaria, 28(4), 48-56. ISSN: 1699-5198
Jensen, G. L. (2006). Inflammation as the Key Interface of the Medical and Nutrition Universes:
A Provocative Examination of the Future of Clinical Nutrition and Medicine. Journal of
Parenteral and Enteral Nutrition, 30(5), 453-463. doi:10.1177/0148607106030005453
Larocca, T. J., et al. (2017). Nutrition and other lifestyle influences on arterial aging. In: Ageing
research reviews, 39, 106–119. DOI: 10.1016/j.arr.2016.09.002
Kim D. Y., et al. (2019). Dietary Patterns Independent of Fast Food Are Associated with Obesity
among Korean Adults: Korea National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey 20102014. In: Nutrients, 11(11), 2740. DOI: 10.3390/nu11112740
Lasalle, C. (2018). University College London, VK in European Heart Journal
Li, Y., Hruby, A., Bernstein, A., Ley, S., Wang, D., Chiuve, S.E., Sampson, L., Rexrode, K., Rimm,
E.B., Willett, W.C., & Hu, F. (2015). Saturated fats compared with unsaturated fats and
sources of carbohydrates in relation to risk of coronary heart disease. Journal of the American
College of Cardiology, 66(14), 1538-1548. doi: 10.1016/j.jacc.2015.07.055
Martins, J., Adilson Marques, Pedro J. Teixeira, Jorge Mota, Carla Lopes & Paulo J. Nicola (2020)
Socio-demographic factors associated with physical activity and sitting time patterns in
adults: An analysis based on the Portuguese Food, Nutrition and Physical Activity Survey,
European Journal of Sport Science, DOI: 10.1080/17461391.2020.1736643
Milton, K. (2000). Back to Basics: Why Foods of Wild Primates Have Relevance for Modern Huma
Health. Department of Enviromental Science, Policy and Management, 16(7/8). Recovered from
https://nature.berkeley.edu/miltonlab/pdfs/backbasics.pdf
Mora, C., Peña, G., & Machado, E. (2005). Estiramiento muscular: su importancia en las actividades
físicas. Medicentro, 9(4). Recovered from:
http://medicentro.sld.cu/index.php/medicentro/article/viewFile/1153/1160
Morante, H., J.J., Soler, I.D., Muñoz, J.S.G., Sánchez, H.P., Ortega, C.B., Martínez, C.M. & Ruiz.,
J.M.M. (2020). Moderate weight loss modifies leptin and ghrelin synthesis rhythms but not
the subjective sensations of appetite in obesity patients. Nutrients 2020, 12(4), 916;
https://doi.org/10.3390/nu12040916
Mozaffarian, D. (2016). Dietary and Policy Priorities for Cardiovascular Disease, Diabetes, and
Obesity: A Comprehensive Review.In: Circulation, 133(2), 187–225.
DOI: 10.1161/CIRCULATIONAHA.115.018585
Mujcic, R., & Oswald, A.J. (2016). Evolution of well-being and happiness after increases in
consumption of fruit and vegetables. The American Journal of Public Health, 106(8), 1504-1510.
doi:10.2105/AJPH.2016.303260
Oliveira, A. et al. (2018). Prevalence of general and abdominal obesity in Portugal: comprehensive
results from the National Food, nutrition and physical activity survey 2015–2016. BMC
Public Health, 18:614. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-018-5480-z
Peinado, A., Rojo-Tirado, M., & Benito, P. (2013). Sugar and physical exercise; the importance of
sugar for athtletes. Nutrición Hospitalaria, 28(4), 48-56. ISSN: 1699-5198
Pérez-Guisado, J. (2009). The importance of the moment on the nutrients intake. Revista
Internacional de Medicina y Ciencias de la Actividad Física y del Deporte. 9(33), 14-24. ISSN: 15770354
73
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Pérez-López, A., Valadés, D., & García, N. (2014). ¿Por qué el músculo es tan importante para
evita el “efecto yoyo”? Facultad de Medicina y Ciencias de la Salud. Recovered from
https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Alberto_PerezLopez/publication/265553225_Por_
que_el_musculo_es_tan_importante_para_evitar_el_efecto_yoyo/links/5412c3740cf2bb73
47db06d4/Por-que-el-musculo-es-tan-importante-para-evitar-el-efecto-yoyo.pdf
Pietrobelli, A., (2017). Nutrition in the First 1000 Days: Ten Practices to Minimize Obesity
Emerging from Published Science. In: International journal of environmental research and public
health, 14(12), 1491. DOI: 10.3390/ijerph14121491
Pinon, L., Khandalavala, B., & Geske, J. (2019). Sugar-Sweetened Beverage Intake in a Rural Family
Medicine Clinic. Journal of the American Board of Family Medicine, 32(4), 601-606. DOI:
10.3122/jabfm.2019.04.180170
Pot, G. K., Battjes-Fries, M. C., Patijn, O. N. et al. (2020). Lifestyle medicine for type 2 diabetes:
practice-based evidence for long-term efficacy of amulticomponent lifestyle intervention
(Reverse Diabetes2 Now). BMJ Nutrition, Prevention & Health, bmjnph-2020.
Poti, J.M. et al. (2017) Ultra-processed Food Intake and Obesity: What Really Matters for Health—
Processing or Nutrient Content?. In: Curr Obes Rep 6, 420–431.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s13679-017-0285-4
Poutanen, K., Fiszman S., Marsaux, C., Vanhatalo, S., Steinert, R.E., & Mela, D.J. (2018).
Recommendations for characterization and reporting of dietary fibers in nutrition research.
American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 108(3). Doi: 10.1093/ajcn/nqy095
Raes, J. (2019). Vlaams darmfloraproject (VIB, Vlaams levenswetenschappelijk Instituut).
https://www.eoswetenschap.eu/gezondheid/onze-buik-beinvloedt-ons-brein
Song, M., Fung, T.T., Hu, F.B., Willett, W.C., Longo, Valter D., Chan, A.T., & Giovannucci, E.L.
(2016). Association of animal and plant protein intake with all-cause and cause-specific
mortality. JAMA Internal Medicine, 176(10), 1453-1463.
doi:10.1001/jamainternmed.2016.4182
Sylvetsky, Allison., Edelstein, S., Walford, G., Boyko, E., Horton, E., Ibeuogu., Knowler, W.,
Montez, M., Temprosa, M., Hoskin, M., Rother, K., Delahanty, L., Diabetes Preventio
Program Research Group. (2017). A High-Carbohydrate, High-Fiber, Low-Fat diet results
in weight loss among adults at high risk of type 2 Diabetes. The Journal of Nutrition, 147(11).
doi:10.3945/jn.117.252395
Teras L.R., Patel AV, Wang M, et al. (2019). Sustained weight loss and risk of breast cancer in
women ≥50 years: a pooled analysis of prospective data. J Natl Cancer Inst. Dec 13.
Toro-Martin, J. et al. (2017). Precision Nutrition: A Review of Personalized Nutritional Approaches
for the Prevention and Management of Metabolic Syndrome. In: Nutrients, 9(8). DOI:
10.3390/nu9080913
Trouwborst, I. et al. (2018). Exercise and Nutrition Strategies to Counteract Sarcopenic Obesity.
In: Nutrients, 10(5), 605. DOI: 10.3390/nu10050605
Turati, F., Rossi, M., Pelucchi, C., Levi, F., & La Vecchia, C. (2015). Fruit and vegetables and cancer
risk: a review of southern European studies. British Journal of Nutrition, 113, S102-S110. doi:
10.1017/S0007114515000148
Yamada, S. (2017). Paradigm Shifts in Nutrition Therapy for Type 2 Diabetes. In: The Keio journal
of medicine, 66(3), 33–43. DOI: 10.2302/kjm.2016-0016-IR
74
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
Brain as a Medicine – Selected Findings from Literature Review in
Slovakia
Adriana Kaplánová - Petra Pačesová
Comenius University in Bratislava, Faculty of Physical Education and Sports, Slovakia
e-mail: adriana.kaplanova@uniba.sk
Abstract
"Brain as a medicine" is a section that presents the knowledge of several experts in order to improve
the physical and mental health of people. Research findings suggest that mindfulness, yoga and
meditation have a positive effect on physiological and immunological indicators of stress and
inflammation. Its beneficial effects were monitored mainly in connection with the gray matter of
the brain, in which there were also impairments of sensory perception, memory, learning and
regulation of emotions. Repeated or chronic exposure to stressors is associated with changes in
neuroendocrine responses that are affected by the type, intensity, number, and frequency of stress
exposure. Stress tests focused on psychosocial stress revealed a more intense physiological
response of the participants compared to cognitive stress.
Key words: Stress management, Self-esteem, Psychological training, Health, Prevention,
Autogenic training, Anxiety, Blood pressure, Heart rate, Achievement motivation
75
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Psychological insight
Athlete's personality and stress management
According to Kaplánová (2020), financial awards can be an important factor influencing the
football players ‘anxiety and coping skills. The results of the study (age study sample: 18-32 years
(23.98 ± 3.01)) suggest that the financial awards increase the coping skills of football players but
also increase their cognitive component of anxiety which is manifested by worries and fear of
failure. Financial awards increase football players' motivation to better prepare for sports
performance, as evidenced by better performance goal setting, more carefully following coaches´
instruction as well as better mental preparation compared to unawarded football players. Alarming
is the increase in the cognitive component of anxiety awarded football players, which is associated
with fears of poor performance and also associated with loss of mental relaxation, the disintegration
of movement stereotypes, deautomatization of gaming automation, movement discoordination or
general discontinuity of football players and thus a reduction in sports performance. For this
reason, we encourage sports organizations to focus more on the mental preparation of football
players. It is important to provide football players the opportunity to graduate from short- or longterm mental training conducted by a trained sports psychologist not only at the time of the athlete’s
failure but also as a preventive measure against increasing cognitive anxiety. We recommend sports
organizations to train coaches in the field of mental training, preferably through annual short
training sessions with a sports psychologist, to influence the development of desirable athletes’
coping skills.
According to Kaplánová (2019a) sweating, increased heart rate, fidgeting, worrying thoughts and
fear of failure are typical symptoms of an inability to manage stress in an important moment of the
match. Thus, there is a well-founded need for psychological training that can help ice hockey
players to control their emotions in stressful situations. Research (age study sample: 20-28 years
(21.67 ± 1.94)) has shown that the cognitive component of hockey players' anxiety is closely linked
to coping with adversity, coachability, concentration, peaking under pressure and freedom from
worry, which is also manifested somatically. Research has also shown that higher self-esteem
suggests better coping with adversity, concentration and freedom from worry, pointing to the need
to orient psychological training towards increasing self-esteem of ice hockey players. Our research
has shown that the level of stress management strategies varies depending on the level of selfesteem and anxiety. It seems that reduced anxiety and increased self-esteem can lead to better stress
management and optimal competition performance.
Kaplánová (2019b) examined coping skills of gymnasts from the perspective of a five-factor model
of personality (age study sample: 15-26 years (19.34 ± 3.15)). The personality of gymnasts seems
to be one of the factors that influences why some gymnasts perform well in training and not in
competition. The results of the research show that stress management is related to the personality
structure of gymnasts, specifically to emotional lability/stability, extroversion/introversion and
openness to experience. Coping with adversity and freedom from worry have been closely linked
to the emotional lability of gymnasts. A higher level of introversion has proven to be beneficial for
76
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
self-confidence and achievement motivation, coachability and coping with adversity in this
individual sport. Higher openness to experience indicates better concentration and better
performance under pressure. A better understanding of personality traits and stress management
strategies can help coaches and sports psychologists develop effective interventions and help
gymnasts achieve optimal performance in competition.
Currently, there is a lack of research in the field of mental training and preparation of football
players for competitive conditions. The Kaplánová study (2019c) deals with stress management
strategies and the search for an association with the anxiety of football players (age study sample:
19-25years (21.30 ± 1.60)). Anxiety is a typical response to a situation where an athlete's skills are
being assessed. It consists of disturbing thoughts and concerns that declare a cognitive component
of anxiety and a degree of physical activation (sweating, muscle stiffness) that declares a somatic
component of anxiety. Our research has shown that psychological resilience of football players and
their ability to manage stress depends on their level of anxiety. The football players with a low level
of anxiety are able to quickly bounce back from mistakes or setbacks, they are mentally strong
enough, value their efforts and compete with enthusiasm compared to football players with a high
level of anxiety. It seems that reducing anxiety can improve the psychological skills of football
players and increase their sports performance in important moments of the match.
Psychological intervention for stress management
The aim of the paper Kaplánová and Gregor (2019) is to point out the possibility of using reframing
as a psychological technique to improve the mental preparedness of an athlete for competition.
Reframing can help athletes who find it difficult to think negatively to achieve set performance
goals. In addition to brief instructions for framing negative thinking into its more positive
perspectives, we also provide information on the development of negative thoughts, sources of
pessimism, and the athlete's tendency to create negative scenarios in his mind. The use of reframing
in the psychological training of athletes can contribute to improving their physical and mental
health.
Overall health, including physical, social, and mental health, is one of the highest values of human
life. Despite the continuous effort of the majority of the people who try to protect this value, there
are still many external as well as internal factors such as psychical burden or frustration that can
disrupt the smooth functioning of human beings and their social, private, or public life. The article
Šagát and Kaplánová (2019) deals primarily with one of the most serious contemporary civilization
problems, which is stress. It contains a basic definition of the stress concept as well as the other
closely related terms (psychical burden and frustration) and points out both negative and positive
aspects of stress concerning the human organism. The authors summarize the possibilities of
reaction to stress in relation to human personality characteristics. They are also focused on the
options of prevention and solution of negative aspects of stress. Further, the article identifies the
three ways how to eliminate those aspects, such as proper diet, sports activities, and active rest. In
the last part, the authors also describe individual approaches in detail, present the basic principles
77
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
of their operation in the fight against stress, and provide examples of the practical application of
anti-stress measures.
The study of Chovanec and Gropel (2020) tested the effect of 8-week endurance and resistance
training programs on cardiovascular stress responses, life stress, and coping. The participants (age
study sample: Mage = 21.02 ±1.65) were randomized to one of the three study groups: endurance
training group, a resistance training group and a waitlist control group. Both endurance and
resistance training programs caused physiological adaptation in terms of increased VO2max after
the intervention. For stress and coping parameters, participants in the training groups improved
cardiovascular recovery from stress and reported having less stress in their everyday life after the
intervention than participants in the control group. We did not find any significant differences in
heart rate reactivity and coping strategies between the study groups. These results partly support
that exercise training has stress-reducing benefits regardless of the type of exercise. Both endurance
and resistance exercise activities may be effectively used to improve stress regulation competence
while having less impact on changing specific coping strategies.
Bratská (2009) examinates counterfactual thinking and changes in the personality dimensions of
university students before and after participating in a socio-psychological training course that
focused on constructive solutions and coping with real load situations. After the sociopsychological training statistically lower neuroticism, significantly higher extraversion, and a
statistically significant difference in sub-dimension happiness in meaningfulness were shown. After
completing the training, participants usually understand problems as a challenge, enjoy possibilities
and their own initiative more, appreciate a creative problem solving, see a possibility to influence
the course of action, and want to create mutual cooperation. SPT revealed the functionality and
correctness of counterfactual thinking.
A case study of Hašto (2013), was illustrated the use of Eye Movement Desensitisation and
Reprocessing and Autogenic Training in Post-traumatic stress disorder treatment. Eye Movement
Desensitisation and Reprocessing was used to manage the acute symptoms, while Autogenic
Training was used to enhance the resilience in persisting stress. Using the biopsychosocial model
of mental illness, we discuss the socio-political and socio-psychological aspects of this case that has
put a burden on the relationship of two neighbouring nations (Slovakia and Hungary) as well as on
the relationship of the national majority and a minority within our country (Slovakia).
Biological insight
Stress, heart rate variability and anxious people
According to Soláriková et al. (2018) heart rate variability (HRV) represents one of the most used
biomarkers of cardiovascular health that offers insight into the autonomic nervous system
activation. The results of the study (age study sample: Mage = 22.3 ±3.10) suggest the stress tasks
which featured a social component (Psychosocial stress a Psychosocial stress group test) triggered
a more intensive physiological response in comparison to cognitive stress or with natural conditions
78
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
measurements. Allergic subjects showed a tendency towards decreased heart rate frequency (HR)
and increased overall HRV in all tests. Besides, the functioning of the ANS showed also gender
differences represented by an increased HR and a decreased HRV in women. The data support the
prior findings of sympathetic withdrawal or parasympathetic hyperactivation in individuals
suffering from allergy, which could be one form of the dysregulation of the autonomic nervous
system.
The study of Rajčáni, Soláriková and Brezina (2018) suggests that heart rate variability (HRV)
changes in allergic as well as high trait anxious people, and associations between allergic
inflammation and trait anxiety. This study investigated HRV of 20 low anxious allergic, 19 healthy
high traits anxious, and 18 healthy low anxious in a naturalistic setting. On arranged research days,
subjects performed measurements using portable ECG device and subjective self-assessment of
perceived stress. Five repeated measurements data from each subject have shown increases in
overall HRV, as well as HRV on respiratory frequencies in both allergy and high trait anxiety.
Subject’s sex was an important factor because HRV increases in allergy were only apparent in
women. Data from self-assessment show no differences in experienced stress attributable to allergy,
only to trait anxiety.
The results of the study Ježová et al. (2016) suggest that repeated or chronic exposure to stressors
is associated with changes in neuroendocrine responses depending on the type, intensity, number
and frequency of stress exposure as well as previous stress experience. Evidence of this is the results
of a study that compared salivary cortisol and cardiovascular responses to real-life psychosocial
stressors related to public performance can cross-adapt with responses to psychosocial stress
induced by public speech under laboratory setting. The sample consisted of 22 healthy male
volunteers, who were actors. The stress task consisted of 15 min anticipatory preparation phase
and 15 min of public speech on an emotionally charged topic. The actors, who were accustomed
to public speaking, responded with a rise in salivary cortisol as well as blood pressure to laboratory
public speech. The values of salivary cortisol, systolic blood pressure and state anxiety were lower
in actors compared to non-actors. Unlike non-actors, subjects with experience in public speaking
did not show a stress-induced rise in the heart rate. Evaluation of personality traits revealed that
actors scored significantly higher in extraversion than the subjects in the non-actor group.
The aim of the study Sabo, Rajčáni and Ritomský (2018) was to establish a methodology for
creating a database of speech under real stress, which may be used in future experiments
investigating speech under stress (age study sample: 25 – 56 years). To induce stress-related speech
changes, speakers took part in a virtual reality simulation of a roller coaster ride. Heart rate and
skin resistance were monitored as bodily reference indicators, while subjective experience was
monitored via stress and arousal checklist. In the recorded data, was founded slight increases in
pitch and intensity of speech during the simulation. However, these effects were not statistically
significant. In bodily indicators, we found a significant increase in HR and a decrease in skin
resistance during the simulation which shows increased arousal.
79
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
The study of Regecová et al. (2019) investigated the effect of an administration of dark or milk
chocolate on blood pressure, heart rate, and double product in young healthy women at rest and
during acute mental stress. All subjects underwent two tests of mental arithmetic one before
chocolate administration and the second one 2 hours after chocolate (1 mg/g of body weight)
ingestion. Two hours after ingestion at rest, dark chocolate administration resulted in a significant
increase in relative values of systolic blood pressure and double product by 5.1% ± 1.4% and 13.7%
± 3.2%, respectively, compared to the responses in the milk chocolate group (−2.4% ± 1.6% and
0.6% ± 3.4%, respectively, p < 0.04 for both comparisons) without changes in diastolic blood
pressure, heart rate, and mean arterial blood pressure. During mental arithmetic-induced acute
stress, the relative magnitude of the reactivity of diastolic blood pressure, heart rate, mean arterial
blood pressure, and double product decreased by about 10, 16, 8, and 23 percentage points,
respectively, 2 hours after ingestion of dark chocolate compared to the relative reactivity
determined before dark chocolate ingestion. Milk chocolate failed to affect any of the abovementioned parameters at rest or during stress. Thus, dark chocolate might have a beneficial effect
during acute stress due to its ability to buffer cardiovascular reactivity in young healthy women.
The aim of the study Janšáková et al. (2020) was to assess whether stimulation of salivation affects
the physiological flow of cortisol during a stressing day as compared to an ordinary day and show
how the normalizing factor affects the outcome of the study. Stimulated saliva was taken from 42
children at 8:00 a.m. and 12:00 a.m. on two separate days one month apart. During the first day,
the children were exposed to the stress situation, while the second day was considered a control
day. The concentration of cortisol was analysed using ELISA. The highest level of cortisol was
observed in the morning of the stress day (p 0.99). Based on our results, the examination of the
cortisol diurnal rhythm is not reliable in stimulated saliva. Moreover, the effect of saliva stimulation
has to be taken into account for every marker individually.
The aim of the study Ježová et al. (2013) was to evaluate the contribution of an acute increase in
state anxiety to neuroendocrine activation under stress conditions. We have decided to take
advantage of the effects of listening to music on anxiety and to apply a new methodological
approach. A group of fourteen healthy volunteers participated in a counterbalanced crossover
design study. Stress procedure consisted of mental (Stroop test, mental arithmetic) and physical
(handgrip exercise) tasks were combined with listening to music played forward (pleasant) or
backward (unpleasant). The results showed that the condition with listening to unpleasant music
was anxiogenic, while the other was not. In the case of increased state anxiety, the rise in ACTH
concentrations in response to mental challenge and the increase in systolic blood pressure induced
by handgrip exercise was reduced compared to the situation with unchanged anxiety.
Concentrations of testosterone, oxytocin, vasopressin and aldosterone were slightly increased in
response to the stress paradigm accompanied by increased anxiety. The present data demonstrate
that an acute increase in state anxiety contributes to neuroendocrine activation under stress
conditions. Listening to music may both positively and negatively influence the perception of stress
and the level of anxiety which might have functional consequences.
80
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
Ježová et al. (2015) performed a series of studies in healthy humans and patients to clarify the
relationship between anxiety and cardiovascular activation under stress conditions. In a group of
healthy volunteers with high trait anxiety, they have observed an exaggerated heart rate response
during psychosocial stress compared to non-anxious individuals. However, in contrast to general
expectations, plasma epinephrine and norepinephrine responses were lower in anxious subjects.
Treatment of anxious subjects with a mixture of aminoacids lysine and arginine (10 days) was able
to normalize stress-induced catecholamine responses. Anxious women in the follicular phase of
the menstrual cycle exhibited a greater stress-induced rise in systolic blood pressure compared to
anxious women in the luteal phase and to non-anxious women in both phases. Accordingly, we
have brought evidence for a reduced neuroendocrine response to stressors in patients with an
anxiety disorder or with immune dysfunction accompanied by anxiety.
Physical activity, mental health and achievement motivation
Stress is an integral part of our lives, and each of us has strategies in place to manage them. Interest
in this issue was also supported by the fact that for effective human functioning in all spheres of
life, it is desirable that stress management strategies be as effective as possible. Uncontrolled stress
can negatively affect human behaviour and experience. One of the ways to fight stress can be a
sports activity. It has several benefits (not only for physical but also mental health), contributes to
a healthier lifestyle, helps reduce stress, offers a form of self-realization and helps to develop selfdiscipline and discipline. The paper of Pačesová (2018) offers a theoretical overview of the issue as
well as some research studies in this area.
Pačesová (2019a) dealt with the level of achievement motivation and the level of anxiety trait of
male and female (n = 225, 21,59 ± 1,97 year). To obtain data, standardized DMV questionnaire
and standardized STAI questionnaire were used in this research. The analysis of the results revealed
the finding that athletes, regardless of gender differences, show a higher level of some aspects of
achievement motivation compared to non-athletes. These are, in particular, the level of
achievement motive and the level of achievement -promoting anxiety. On the contrary, within the
anxiety inhibiting achievement, a higher rate was found in non-athletic men and women. There was
no statistically significant difference in the anxiety of men who exercise regularly and men who do
not exercise at all. There was a statistically significant difference between women in terms of regular
sports activity in terms of lower levels of anxiety in women sports.
Šmela et al. (2019) dealt with the differences in achievement motivation of the physical education
teachers, divided by gender. The research sample was comprised of 52 physical education teachers
(male: n=22; 41.59±9.95 years old, female: n=30; 39.33±10.67 years old) from Slovakia. A
standardized LMI questionnaire consisting of 170 items was used as the research tool. Male physical
education teachers have significantly higher (p=0.043) achievement motivation compared to
female physical education teachers. A comparison of dimensions of achievement motivation of
male physical education teachers showed that they achieved significantly higher scores in the
dimensions of persistence, fearlessness, and competitiveness. Comparing them with national
standards, the achievement motivation of male teachers of physical education corresponds with
81
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
the 58th percentile (stanine value 5) and of female teachers of physical education with 46th
percentile (stanine value 5). The outcomes of this study characterize PE teachers as an elementary
component in the teaching process from the aspect of achievement motivation and its dimensions
and also indicate the status of PE teachers in society. This study is designated for PE teachers as
well as for the general public striving to improve the quality of the teaching process in sports.
The level of achievement motivation is focused generally, so the results can be generalized to the
demands of everyday life, it does not apply just to the motives for doing sports. The position of
achievement motivation in the work area is quite important and irreplaceable today. The demands
of the society on human performance are constantly increasing and they are “forcing” individuals
to pushing their goals and performance higher constantly. Human resources are currently highly
valued, and not only for young people is the emphasis primarily on ambition and strategies for
success, and not on strategies to avoid failure. Research of Pačesová (2019b) suggests that young
people engaged in sport activity have a higher level of achievement motivation. However, the area
of achievement motivation and the sphere of sport are so unique, that they deserve a thorough
examination of aspects that may play a role in them.
Pačesová et al. (2018) dealt with the level of women’s wellbeing regarding their sport activity, and
also designation the relationship between the individual dimensions of wellbeing and the level of
state anxiety and trait anxiety. The research group consists of 107 women (20.03±1.47 years),
divided into groups based on their sport activity (active 62, inactive 45). The standardized BDP
questionnaire the standardized STAI questionnaire were used. The higher level of personal wellbeing in the sample of women actively participating in sport activities was found. In both the
samples, an indirect relation between positive dimensions of personal well-being and state anxiety
(in the case of the sample of women not participating in any sport activity even with trait anxiety)
was found. A direct relation between the negative dimensions of wellbeing and the level of state as
well as trait anxiety was recorded only in the sample of women not participating in any sport
activity. These findings indicate that sport activity can be a suitable instrument to increase women´s
personal well-being.
Pačesová and Šmela (2020) dealt with the level of the dimension of aggression and anxiety trait
between nonathletes and contact and noncontact sport athletes and assessing the relationship
between dimensions of aggression and the level of anxiety trait across the groups. The research
group consisted of 153 males aged 22.07 ± 2.49 years: 47 contact sport athletes, 51 noncontact
sport athletes and 55 nonathletes. Dimensions of aggression were evaluated by the Buss-Perry
Aggression Questionnaire, anxiety trait was evaluated by the State-Trait Anxiety Inventory Authors
found that nonathletes were more physically aggressive than contact sport athletes and they also
displayed a higher level of anger and hostility. Moreover, nonathletes were more hostile, physical
and verbally aggressive than noncontact sport athletes. Nonathletes also had a higher level of
anxiety trait than athletes. There was no difference between athletes in any dimension of aggression
and anxiety trait level. Besides that, a significant relationship between anxiety trait level and physical
aggression across the groups was found. These findings suggest that sports activity can be beneficial
for personality in both contact and noncontact athletes. Sport activity may be one of the factors
82
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
which increase the possibility of releasing of aggression, while “contactless” of the sport does not
play any major role in the aggression of athletes.
Pačesová et al. (2018) dealt with the level of cognitive functions in context of sport. The aim of
this study was to assess differences in cognitive functions between tennis players and non-athletic
adolescents. The research sample consisted of 98 subjects: 44 tennis players (age 18.11 ± 1.35 years)
and 54 nonathletic adolescents (age 18.04 ± 1.33 years). The level of cognitive functions was
investigated using the standardized neuropsychological cognitive Stroop test. The tennis players
had higher cognitive function scores compared to the non-athletes in two of the three segments of
the Stroop test. There was no significant difference between the groups in the simplest segment of
the Stroop test (segment T). However, a significant difference (p = .028; d= 0.45) was found
between the tennis players and non-athletes in segment S of the Stroop test and in segment B, the
most difficult segment of the test, the difference between research groups was also significant (p
= .002; d = 0.63). There a difference between athletes and non-athletes in cognitive functions such
as cognition inhibitory control, concentration of attention, conscious and selective attention.
However, the differences have only been demonstrated in moderate difficulty and most difficulty
segment, in the simplest segment we have not found difference between athletes and non-athletes.
Šmela at al. (2018) dealt with differences in achievement motivation among college students in
terms of sports activities. The research sample was comprised of 248 college students (men: n=141,
22.40±1.62 years of age; women: n=107, 21.78±1.49 years of age) from Bratislava. The
respondents were divided into 3 groups according to frequency of sports activities: college students
who didn’t engage in any sports activities (non-active respondents), college students who engaged
in sports activities 1 to 2 times a week (moderately active respondents), and those who engaged in
sports activities 3 or more times a week (highly active respondents). A standardized DMV
questionnaire consisting of 52 items was used as the research tool. The results revealed significant
(p≤0.001) differences in all three performance motivation dimensions. The performance
motivation of the highly active respondents was significantly higher compared to that of the
moderately active respondents. Also, when compared with the non-active respondents, the level of
performance motivation was significantly higher among the highly active respondents.
Performance motivation and performance-supporting anxiety increases with the frequency of
sports activities; on the contrary, performance-hindering anxiety decreases with the frequency of
sports activities. Hence, these results testify to the fact that sport activity is one of the determinants
for increased performance motivation.
Pačesová, Šmela and Nemček (2020) dealt with the cognitive functions usable in the sports
performance (e. g. an ability to anticipate, perception and speed of movement reactions, decisionmaking ability or attention). These abilities or functions apply differently to different sports. It
means that open skill sports such as team sports, require the coordination of complex bodily
movements and adaptation to continually changing task demands. The aim of this study is to
identify differences in the level of female's cognitive functions regarding the chosen open skill
sports and closed skill sport disciplines. The research group consisted of 84 women aged
22.70±1.71 years. Women were divided into three groups in terms of sport discipline into: female
83
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
engaged in closed skill sport disciplines (n=26), in open skill sport disciplines (n=19) and not
engaged in any sport activity (n=39). Standardized S-test to determine the level of cognitive
functions was used. It is a test of spatial orientation and concentration of attention with accentuated
demands on the pace of activity. The results showed that female engaged in open skill sport
disciplines showed higher level of cognitive functions than female engaged in closed skill sport
disciplines (p=0.04) and also as nonathletes (p=0.02). There was no difference in cognitive function
between female engaged in closed skill sport disciplines and nonathletes. These results confirm the
theory of different involvement of cognitive functions from the point of view of different types of
sport disciplines.
References
BRATSKÁ, M. (2018). Changes in personality dimensions and counterfactual thinking of female
university students in the context of coping with load situations. Studia Psychologica 51(2),
251-258.
HAŠTO, J., & H. VOJTOVÁ. (2013). posttraumatic stress disorder, bio-psycho-social aspects, eye
movement desensitization and reprocessing and autogenic training in persistent stress: case
study. Europaen Journal of Mental Health 8 (2), 232-264. DOI: 10.5708/EJMH.8.2013.2.4
CHOVANEC. L., & P. GROPEL (2020). Effect of 8-week endurance and resistance training
programmes on cardiovascular stress response, life stress and coping. Journal of Sports Sciences
doi: 10.1080/02640414.2020.1756672.
JANŠAKOVÁ, K., KYSELICOVÁ, K., CELUŠÁKOVÁ, H., REPISKÁ G., & D.
OSTATNÍKOVÁ. (2020). The effect of saliva stimulation on the secretion of cortisol during
stress and physiological conditions. Bratislava Medical Journal 121(6), 428-430.
JEŽOVÁ, D., HLAVÁČOVÁ, N., DUNCKO, R., SOLÁRIKOVÁ., P., MARKO, M., & I.
BREZINA. (2015). Cardiovascular responses to threatful challenges in persons with high trait anxiety.
Annual scientist sessions; world congress on Heart disease [20th] - Vancouver, 25.-27.7.2015.
JEZOVÁ, D., HLAVÁČOVÁ, N., DICKO, I., SOLÁRIKOVÁ, P., & I. BREZINA. (2016).
Psychosocial stress based on public speech in humans: is there a real life/laboratory setting
cross-adaptation? Stress 19(4), 1-5 doi: 10.1080/10253890.2016.1203416
JEŽOVÁ, D., HLAVÁČOVÁ, N., MAKATSORI, A., DUNCKO, R., LODER., I. & H.
HINGHOFER. (2013). Increased anxiety induced by listening to unpleasant music during
stress exposure is associated with reduced blood pressure and ACTH responses in healthy
men. Neuroendocrinology 98(2), DOI: 10.1159/000354202
KAPLÁNOVÁ, A. (2019a). Self-esteem, anxiety and coping strategies to manage stress in ice
hockey. Acta Gymnica 49(1), 10-15, doi: 10.5507/ag.2018.026
KAPLÁNOVÁ, A. (2019b). Personality of gymnasts and coping strategies to manage stress. Science
of Gymnastics Journal 11(2), 255-265.
KAPLÁNOVÁ, A. (2019c). Anxiety of football players and their coping strategies to manage stress. Sport,
physical education and performing arts as tools of social transformation [electronic
document] : abstract book. : 1. ed. ISBN 978-84-9729-385-3. - Barcelona, 2019. - p. 279-280.
84
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
KAPLÁNOVÁ, A. (2020). Financial awards and their effect on football players´anxiety and coping
skills. Frontiers in Psychology 11: 1148. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2020.01148
KAPLÁNOVÁ, A., & T. GREGOR. (2019). Využitie kognitívnej techniky reframing
v psychologickej príprave športovcov. [Utilization of cognitive technique reframing in
psychological training of athletes]. Telesná výchova a šport 21(2), 12-15. ISSN 1335-2245.
PAČESOVÁ, P. (2018). Copingové stratégie a športová aktivita – pomáha nám športovanie
efektívnejšie zvládať stres? [Coping strategies and sport activity – Does sport make coping
with stress more effective?] E-mental, 2018, 6(1), p. 27-37. ISSN 1339-4614.
PAČESOVÁ, P., ŠMELA, P., KRAČEK, S. & PLEVKOVÁ, L. (2018). Women’s Well-Being,
State and Trait Anxiety Regarding their Sport Activity. Sport Mont 2018, 16(2), p. 33-38.
ISSN 2337-0351
PAČESOVÁ, P., ŠMELA, P., KRAČEK, S., KUKUROVÁ, K. & PLEVKOVÁ, L. (2018)
Cognitive function of young male tennis players and non-athletes. Acta Gymnica, 48(2), p.
56–61. ISSN 1213-8312.
PAČESOVÁ, P. (2019a). Motivácia výkonu a miera úzkostlivosti mužov a žien z hľadiska
športovej aktivity [Achievement motivation and anxiety trait level of men and women in
terms of sports activity]. Bratislava: Slovenská vedecká spoločnosť pre telesnú výchovu
a šport, 100 p. ISBN 978-80-89075-79-9
PAČESOVÁ, P. (2019b). Výkonová motivácia v kontexte športovania [Achievement motivation
in the context of sport]. E-mental, 2019, 7(1), p. 6-13. ISSN 1339-4614.
PAČESOVÁ, P. & ŠMELA, P. (2020). Aggression and anxiety trait level of young male contact
and noncontact athletes, Acta Gymnica, 2020, 50(1), 2020, p. 9–15. ISSN 1213-8312.
PAČESOVÁ, P., ŠMELA, P. & NEMČEK, D. (2020). Cognitive functions of female open skill
sport athletes, closed skill sport athletes and nonathletes. Physical Activity Review, 2020,
8(2), p. 23-29.
RAJČÁNI, J., SOLÁRIKOVÁ, P. & I. BREZINA. (2018). Allergy and high trait anxiety are related
to increases in heart rate variability: Results of naturalistic long-term design study. European
Annals of Allergy and Clinical Immunology 50(1), 19-27.doi: 10.23822/EurAnnACI.1764-1489.33
REGECOVÁ, V., JURKOVIČOVÁ, J., BABJAKOVÁ, J., & I. BERNÁTOVÁ. (2019). The effect
of single dose of dark chocolate on cardiovascular parameters and their reactivity to mental
stress. Journal of the American College of Nutrition 39(3), 1-8, DOI:
10.1080/07315724.2019.1662341
SABO, R., RAJČANI, J., & M. RITOMSKÝ. (2018). Designing database of speech under stress
using a simulation in virtual reality. DISA 2018 [electronic document] : IEEE World
Symposium on Digital Intelligence for Systems and Machines. - : 1. ed. ISBN 978-1-53865102-5. - Danver : Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, p. 321-325.
SOLÁRIKOVÁ, P., BREZINA, I., TUROŇOVÁ, D., RAJČÁNI, J., & S. MLYNČEKOVÁ.
(2018). Long-term monitoring of heart rate variability and state anxiety in allergic patients:
Comparison of four stress protocols. Československá psychologie 62(3), 258-271.
85
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
ŠAGÁT, P., & A. KAPLÁNOVÁ. (2019). Physical burden, frustration, stress and its influence on human
health. 12th international conference on kinanthropology „Sport and quality of life“
[electronic document] : book of abstracts : Vol. 12. - : 1. ed. ISBN 978-80-210-9429-1. - Brno
: Masaryk university, 2019. - p. 54
ŠMELA, P., PAČESOVÁ, P., KRAČEK, S., KUKUROVÁ, K. & HALAČOVÁ, N. (2018).
Achievement Motivation of Undergraduates Divided by Sport Activity. Sport Mont 2018,
16(2), p. 55-60.
ŠMELA, P., PAČESOVÁ, P., ANTALA, B., ČEKANOVÁ, I. & FUČÍK, H. (2019). Achievement
Motivation of Physical Education Teachers. Sport Mont 2019, 17(3), p. 67-71. ISSN 23370351.
86
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
Brain as a Medicine – Selected Findings from Worldwide
Literature Review
John van Heel - 1Manel Valcarce-Torrente - 5Francisco Gómez-Almeida 2
Carla Chicau Borrego - 2Susana Franco - 3Eric Vandenabeele 3
Gert van Reckem - 4Adriana Kaplánová
6
1
Valencian International University, Valencia, Spain
Sport Sciences School of Rio Maior, Polytechnic Institute of Santarém; Life Quality Research Center, Portugal
3
Fitness- BE Wellness & Health, Belgium
4
Comenius University in Bratislava, Faculty of Physical Education and Sports, Slovakia
5
Valgo Sports Consulting, Madrid, Spain
6
New Health, Netherlands
e-mail: adriana.kaplanova@uniba.sk
2
Abstract
The human brain is composed of several billion neurons secured by thousands of connections,
making it one of the most important and complicated human organs. Significant positive results
were also achieved by patients who regularly performed techniques focused on deep breathing,
mindfulness and meditation. In the treatment of post-traumatic stress disorder, patients have again
seen improvements after autogenous training, eye movement desensitization and reprocessing.
From the above, it is clear that there are many effective ways to enhance a person's subjective wellbeing and quality of life.
Key words: Brain as a medicine, physical activity
87
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
The health effects of resistance exercise training are proven, but less is known about the mental
health benefits. Specifically, this study aims to perform a quantitative synthesis of the effects of
resistance exercises on anxiety. For this, a resistance exercise program was applied to a sample of
31 individuals, and other similar clinical trials were analyzed. In this study of Gordon et al. (2017),
it is concluded that the development of a resistance exercise program significantly improves anxiety
symptoms both in healthy participants and in participants suffering from a physical or mental
illness.
Separating ourselves from an unpleasant memory doesn’t seem easy. This asymmetric in mind
control in common reason for discomfort and motivation that leads many people to psychological
consultations (Barraca 2011). A recent study by Killingsworth and Gilbert (2010), with a large
sample of 2250 participants, has found that most people spend 46,9% of waking hours on thoughts
that have nothing to do with what they are doing. There is a possibility that these intrusive thoughts
make normal functioning impossible. To achieve this emotions control, the patient must be helped
to establish relations between their cognition, their emotions and their behaviours, to identify the
most irrational thoughts, or their or their most maladaptive cognitive processes, modify these
cognitions through different methods, either through a cognitive or a behavioral path. Many
professionals seem to find in acceptance and mindfulness those techniques they couldn’t count
with to help patient control certain negative thoughts. Although people still struggling to separate
their selves from a particular thought, sensation or emotion has been the goal of a behavior therapy,
it has not always worked in all cases, and the usefulness of acceptance different thoughts and staying
active has been understood.
Due Barraca and Barrios (2012) people act from this structure (reptilian brain) in response to their
vital needs. This part of the brain is made up of the basal ganglia, the brain stem, and the reticular
system. This part of the brain is responsible for automatic or programmed behaviors (preservation
of the species or physiological changes necessary for survival). IT is denominated reptilian because
it is usual in reptiles and has an important role in controlling instinctive. This includes animal
behaviors like nesting or mating. The behavior of the animal is largely controlled by this area of
the brain. It is a programmed behavior and resistant to change. It is survival impulse (eat, drink,
mating…). It processes the functions that have to do with doing and acting (routines, habits,
territoriality, living space ...). According to Chirinos (2007), the reptilian brain controls respiration,
heart rate, blood pressure and even collaborates in the continuous expansion-contraction of
muscles. It allows human being to adapts to an environment through elemental answers little
complicated emotional and intellectually. To sum up, this part of the brain is a kind of programmed
and powerful instinctual behaviour and is therefore highly resistant to change.
Oxytocin and vasopressin are neuropeptides that have a relevant role in most of our social
interactions. Meyer-Lindenberg et al. (2011) studied how can these neuropeptides be involved in
mental health, as an effective treatment for the mental disorder, or even as its cause. They used
recent studies on Autism Spectrum Disorder, anxiety in patients with depression and schizophrenia
to develop a new study on how can they be used in order to reverse or reduce the impact of these
88
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
disorders on the patients, by administrating them intranasal oxytocin, proving that this treatment
reduces behavioural and endocrine responses to social stress, mediates stress-protective effects of
social support (‘social buffering’), attenuates amygdala reactivity to social stimuli, and improves
social cognition, emotion recognition, secure attachment and empathy in humans.
Recent studies show that self-control in humans (as the ability to adapt our behaviour to live in a
society and accomplish our goals) depends on a limited power source, as the effort humans make
to self-control is greater in following attempts to do it, affecting human behaviour and how humans
respond to different stimuli (controlling emotions, attention and impulses). Gailliot and Baumeister
(2007) link this source of willpower to the glucose levels in blood, as glucose is the main fuel for
brain functions. They studied how more glucose is used in effortful and self-controlled interactions.
Also, they linked the lack of self-control in humans under the effects of alcohol to the fact that
alcohol reduces the metabolism of glucose in brain and body. In conclusion, the authors stated that
humans are more capable of achieving hard goals that require willpower when acquiring the right
amount of glucose for the proper functioning of their brains.
Metcalfe and Mischel (1999) analyse how our brain functions in order to obtain gratification, and
therefore how it works to commit to a long-term objective. They start presenting the delay of
gratification paradigm, being the object of lots of studies. This paradigm studies when is a human
controlled by their emotions to obtain the gratification, or when are they driven by reason (for
example, when a greater gratification could be obtained). All of this leads to the real development
of willpower. The authors theorized a two-system framework, where the cool system responds to
reason and the hot system responds to emotions. These two systems normally work as a whole,
but sometimes they differ, becoming of interest which of them prevails. If the hot system prevails,
we could say that the subject is “yielding” to temptation, having no willpower. To avoid this,
humans use some strategies to diminish the influence of the hot system and accomplish their longterm goals, being better at them as they grow and become adults, when they have automated this
self-control. There is a problem when adults are under stress or other chronic difficulties, under
which the willpower will be diminished constantly.
Seifert et al. (2012) study the relationship intrinsic and extrinsic motivation, and they apply it to
health promotion and wellness. On the first hand, extrinsic motivation, or the motivation that
functions by obtaining “rewards”, has been proven to not work in all cases as recent studies show,
as it can lead to better performances in mechanical skills, but quite the opposite in cognitive skills.
This means that for cognitive skills (where health and wellness are included), the extrinsic
motivation must be followed by a meaningful result, that creates an intrinsic motivation. This
happens when the subject has sufficient knowledge to want to change their behaviour, which can
be given by extrinsic motivation. The authors state eight strategies to help create intrinsic
motivation for health promotion and wellness, including identifying one’s intentions, provide
“how-to” knowledge, through belonging and recognition and making the change “fun”, among
others. The authors conclude that extrinsic motivation is just the first step, being necessary to create
intrinsic motivation through different strategies to accomplish the wanted health promotion.
89
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
This research of Brinol et al. (2004) shows that the confidence produced by the affirmation of
oneself can increase or decrease persuasion depending on the quality of the arguments presented.
When a message is made up of weak arguments, asserting yourself increases persuasion. In the
other hand, when the message is made up of strong arguments, persuasion decreases. The fact that
self-affirmation decreases persuasion increases resistance to strongly convincing messages and
supports an interpretation based on motivation to process information. The confidence, that is
possibly reduced as a result of the self-affirmation, can affect the number of thoughts when it is
induced before the message is elaborated, but it could also affect how you think about your own
thoughts if it is induced after the message has already been processed. Therefore, it is important to
accept yourself with your flaws and your virtues. Even so, affirming a person's identity can take on
at least two different roles in the context of persuasion, thus influencing the number of thoughts
or the confidence associated with them.
The study by Monteos-Aparicio and Rodriguez-Moreno (2019) dealt with synaptic plasticity and
how it is modified in specific time windows of development. A better understanding of how
synaptic adjustments take place during learning and memory and / or development can help shape
and improve the effectiveness of current protocols in the early stages of academic learning. The
ability to manipulate specific neural pathways and synapses has really important implications for
therapeutic and clinical interventions that will improve our health. Promising therapies have proven
to be deep brain stimulation, non-invasive brain stimulation, neuropharmacology, exercise,
cognitive training, or real-time functional magnetic resonance feedback, based on our current
understanding of brain plasticity and the subject of intensive research in various pathologies. A
better understanding of the mechanisms governing neuroplasticity following brain injury or nerve
lesions would help improve the patient's quality of life and save costs for national health systems
around the world.
The aim of study of Wemelinger et al. (2018) is to evaluate the relationship between resilience and
mental health in older adults and how physical activity influences that relationship. A crosssectional study was carried out with 312 older adults (179 active and 133 sedentary classifieds by
IPAQ). Considering the whole sample, an inverse relationship was found for resilience (Wagnild–
Young’s Resilience Scale) with depression and stress (DASS-21). Among the sedentary, in spite of
there not being an association between total resilience and mental health, there was an inverse
relationship for the “meaning of life” component of the resilience and depression scale. For the
active group, there was a relationship between total resilience and its components with depression
and stress, but not for the “meaning of life” component of the resilience scale. Physical activity
played an important role in the relationship between resilience and depression, showing that active
and sedentary people use different components of resilience
Ageing is associated with a progressive decline in cognitive function, which occurs according to
heterogeneoustrajectories, dependent on multiple physiological and environmental components
(Periera et al. (2019). To tackle this major chal-lenge, we designed a project to test the effect of a
tailored physical exercise intervention program in the cog-nitive function of a Portuguese elderly
90
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
cohort, included in the AGA@4life project. The exercise program includedaerobic and strength
components, prescribed in a personalized approach according to the AGA@4life model,
andimplemented under direct control of two experienced professionals. The 33 included elderly
participants weredivided into two groups (intervention group–IG–and control group–CG)
according to their willingness toparticipate in the physical training program. Cognitive function was
evaluated with the CambridgeNeuropsychological Test Automated Battery (CANTAB) platform
at baseline ant three-months after the inter-vention period in all the participants. The groups had
similar clinical and demographic characteristics atbaseline. After the intervention program,
significant improvements in cognitive function were observed in theIG, but not in the CG.
Particularly, a significant improvement in motor control, spatial working memory andvisuospatial
associate learning were depicted in the IG, which revealed an overall better cognitive
performanceas compared with the CG after the follow-up period. The results clearly identify
physical exercise as an effectivenon-pharmacological tool to positively modulate age-related decline
in cognitive function in older adults, par-ticularly when prescribed in a personalized approach with
a multicomponent structure as foreseen in the in-novative AGA@4life model
Physical activity and self-rated wellbeing have important benefits to health. However, scientific
knowledge regarding their relationship among older adults is scarce. Thus, the aim of study of
Peralta et al. (2018) was to examine the associations between physical activity frequency and several
dimensions of self-rated wellbeing, in a representative sample of European older adults from 28
countries. Methods: This study is based on the European Social Survey round 6, 2012. It had a
total sample size of 12,341 older adults (5100 men, 7241 women) with mean age 73.8 ± 6.6 years.
Information was collected through a questionnaire, filled-in during an hour-long face-to-face
interview. Physical activity was accessed using the question “On how many of the last 7 days you
were physically active continuously for 20 minutes or longer?” and six dimensions of self-rated
wellbeing were used. Results: Physical activity in the last 7 days was linearly related with all
dimension of the self-rated wellbeing and with wellbeing total score for both sexes (men, β = 0.09,
95% CI: 0.07 to 0.10, p < .001; women, β = 0.10, 95% CI: 0.09 to 0.11, p < .001). Conclusions:
Physical activity promotion should be stressed as a meaningful strategy to improve people's
wellbeing overall. This strategy has special importance when considering the older adult population.
Keywords: Physical exercise, epidemiology, active life styles, public health
Due Raes (2019) previous studies have shown that there is a relationship between the composition
of the intestinal flora and, for example, obesity or all kinds of conditions such as intestinal
inflammation and diabetes. Such results naturally make you dream about the possibility of
remedying ailments or alleviating their symptoms through interventions on the intestinal flora.
With this Gut Flora project we hope to take steps to unravel the relationship between an individual
and his or her intestinal flora. Substances produced by microorganisms in our gut can affect the
brain. In doing so, they also guide our behavior and our feelings. Microbiologist Jeroen Raes (VIB
- KU Leuven) discovered this after researching more than a thousand test subjects. Until now,
researchers have mainly investigated the link between stomach and brain in laboratory animals.
Raes and his team aimed at people. They mapped the bacteria present in their test subjects'
91
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
intestines. In that intestinal flora, they discovered specific bacterial groups that are related to mental
health. Two of these, Coprococcus and Dialister, were not found in people with depression. Similar
results were found in subjects in a Dutch research project and in a group of depression patients at
UZ Leuven. Raes also previously discovered that certain bacterial communities are more common
in Crohn's disease patients. It appears that the bacteria associated with intestinal inflammation also
negatively impacts mental health. This investigation is currently ongoing.
It is not clear how intensive sweeteners that do not supply energy can have a negative effect on our
body weight. Several hypotheses are circulating, but need further investigation. For example, some
think that sweeteners would increase the urge for sweetness, which ultimately leads to more eating.
Others think that sweeteners change the composition of our intestinal flora and thus have a
negative effect on our body weight. Other research has shown that the use of light products leads
to a higher consumption because of the psychological effect (brain as a medicine): people feel less
guilty when using light products and therefore tend to eat more of them. This completely cancels
out any positive effect. Finally, it is also quite possible that diet sodas are a marker of unhealthy
eating habits. It is not diet sodas, but unhealthy dietary habits that are the cause of obesity and
lifestyle diseases (Azad et al. 2017; Rogers 2015; Miller and Perez 2014).
Cahn et al. (2017) in an article published in the journal Frontiers in Human Neuroscience
investigated the effects of yoga and meditation on humans by looking at physiological and
immunological markers of stress and inflammation. Researchers studied people who participated
in an intensive three-month retreat. They found that exercise had a positive effect on physiological
and immunological markers of stress and inflammation. They also improved subjective well-being.
Practitioners view "meditation" or mental training as a process of becoming familiar with one's
mental life that leads to long-term changes in cognition and emotion. Little is known about this
process and its effect on the brain. Here, experts Lutz et al. (2004) investigate how long-term
Buddhist practitioners themselves induce sustained high-amplitude gamma-band
electroencephalographic oscillations and phase synchronization during meditation. These
electroencephalogram patterns differ from those of controls, particularly at lateral frontoparietal
electrodes. Furthermore, the ratio of gamma band activity (25-42 Hz) to slow oscillatory activity
(4-13 Hz) is initially higher at resting baseline for meditating practitioners than controls at medial
frontoparietal electrodes. This difference increases significantly during meditation at most scalp
electrodes and remains higher than the initial baseline in the post-meditation baseline. These data
suggest that mental training involves temporal integration mechanisms and can produce short- and
long-term neural changes.
The effect of mindfulness meditation training on biological acute stress responses to anxiety
disorder, by Georgetown University, USA. One of the main things sciences says about meditation
is that it helps to reduce and prevent stress. A study by Hoge et al. (2017), published in January
2017, found that meditation reduced hormonal inflammatory responses to stress, specifically after
92
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
practicing mindfulness. This rigorously designed clinical study found objective physiological
evidence that conscious meditation fights anxiety.
Mindfulness exercises lead to an increase in the density of gray matter in the brain. A 2011 study
conducted by researchers at Massachusetts General Hospital in the US, published in the journal
Psychiatry Research: Neuroimaging, revealed that meditation, specifical mindfulness, can cause
measurable changes in the brain areas associated with memory, consciousness, empathy, and stress.
This study by Hölzel et al. (2011) first showed what changes meditation can cause over time in the
gray matter in the brain. Analysis of the MRI images showed a greater density of gray matter in the
hippocampus. This is important for learning ability and memory. This density has also been found
in structures associated with self-awareness and introspection. The reduction in stress is also
correlated with the decrease in the density of gray matter in the amygdala. The amygdala is known
to play an important role in anxiety and stress.
Ravesteijn et al. (2014) a recently randomized controlled trial provided preliminary evidence for the
effectiveness of mindfulness-based cognitive therapy (MBCT) for the top 10% frequent primary
care visitors with persistent medically unexplained symptoms (MUS). The aim of this qualitative
study is to investigate the mechanisms of action and potential barriers of MBCT in this population.
A total of 35 qualitative interviews were conducted. MBCT has initiated a process of change,
starting with the awareness of the present moment, the associated sensory experiences, thoughts
and emotions, and accepting them instead of resisting them. Participants began to recognize and
change their own behavioral patterns, improving self-care. Self-compassion seemed to result from
and facilitate this process. The main barriers were simultaneous social problems and the inability
or unwillingness to accept symptoms. MBCT can initiate a change process in patients with
persistent MUS. Awareness and acceptance of painful symptoms and emotions are key factors in
this process. Changes in unhelpful behavioral patterns and increased self-care and self-compassion
may result from this process.
Yackle (2017) et al. states that slow, controlled breathing has been used for centuries to promote
mental relaxation and is used clinically to suppress excessive arousal such as panic attacks.
However, the physiological and neural basis of the relationship between breathing and higher brain
activity is unknown. We found a neuronal subpopulation in the mouse preBötzinger complex
(preBötC), the primary generator of the respiratory rhythm that regulates the balance between calm
and excited behavior. Conditional bilateral genetic ablation of ∼175 Cdh9/Dbx1 double-positive
preBötC neurons in adult mice left breathing intact but increased quiet behavior and reduced time
in excited states. These neurons project to, synchronize, and regulate positive noradrenergic
neurons in the locus coeruleus, a brain center involved in attention, arousal, and panic that projects
through the brain.
Breathing is one of the eternal rhythms that are often taken for granted, the apparent simplicity
belies the complex neural machinery involved. According to Sheikhbahaei and Smith (2017) this
behavior is more complicated than just generating inspiration because breathing is integrated with
93
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
many other motor functions such as vocalization, orofacial motor behavior, emotional expression
(laughing and crying), and motor skills. In addition, cognition can strongly influence breathing.
Mindful breathing during yoga, meditation, or psychotherapy can modulate emotion, arousal, or
stress. Therefore, it is of great importance to understand the connections between respiratory
behavior, the arousal state of the brain, and higher-order brain activity.
There are many reasons why normal breathing can be negatively affected, including biochemical,
biomechanical, or psychological disorders. According to Ristiniemi et al. (2013) conscious or
unconscious changes in breathing can affect both our feelings and thoughts and emotions and
feelings of anger, fear and anxiety can strengthen our breathing. Biomechanical aspects of
respiration affect its functionality and patients with unexplained respiratory symptoms, such as
dyspnoea, often exhibit abnormalities in the respiratory pattern. Changes in the performance of
the respiratory muscles can decrease the effectiveness of ventilation. People with hyperventilation
syndrome often display a predominant chest breathing pattern at rest. It has been proposed that
the abdominal afferent proprioceptive input associated with such respiration can directly lead to
the perception of respiratory symptoms. Unpleasant sensations may appear in the intercostals and
other respiratory muscles as a result of prolonged chest breathing, and the sensations may worsen
when the patient is stressed. So it is not surprising that patients with exhaustion syndrome and
elevated anxiety levels show higher levels of hyperventilation compared to healthy controls.
References
Azad, Meghan B., et al. "Nonnutritive sweeteners and cardiometabolic health: a systematic review
and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials and prospective cohort studies." Canadian
Medical Association Journal 189.28 (2017): E929-E939.
Barraca, J. & Barrios, L. (2012). ¿Aceptación o control mental? Terapias de aceptación y
mindfulness frente a las técnicas cognitivo-conductuales para la eliminación de pensamientos
intrusos. Revista Praxis, 8, 147-165. ISSN: 1657-4915
Barraca, J. (2011). Aceptación o control mental? Terapias de aceptación y mindfulness frente a las
técnicas cognitivo-conductuales para la eliminación de pensamientos intrusos. Análisis y
Modificación de Conducta, 37(155-156), 43-63. Recover from:
http://repositorio.ucjc.edu/bitstream/handle/20.500.12020/446/Aceptaci%c3%b3n%20o
%20control%20mental%20Terapias%20de%20aceptaci%c3%b3n%20y.pdf?sequence=1&i
sAllowed=y
Briñol, P., Gallardo, I., Horcajo, J., de la Corte, L., Valle, C., & Díaz, D. (2004). Afirmación,
confianza y persuasión. Psicothema, 16, 27-31. ISSN: 0214 – 9915
Cahn BR, Goodman MS, Peterson CT, Maturi R & Mills PJ (2017) Yoga, Meditation and MindBody Health: Increased BDNF, Cortisol Awakening Response, and Altered Inflammatory
Marker Expression after a 3-Month Yoga and Meditation Retreat. Front. Hum. Neurosci.
11:315. doi: 10.3389/fnhum.2017.00315
94
New Health
__________________________________________________________________________________
Gailliot, M. T., & Baumeister, R.F. (2007). The Physiology of Willpower: Linking Blood Glucose
to Self-Control. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 11, 303-327.
doi: 10.1177/1088868307303030
Gordon, B.R., McDowell, C.P., Lyons, M., & Herring, M. (2017). The Effects of Resistance
Exercise Training on Anxiety: A Meta-Analysis and Meta-Regression Analysis of
Randomized Controlled Trials. Sports Medicine 47(12), 2521–2532. doi:10.1007/s40279-0170769-0
Hoge EA, Bui E, Palitz SA, Schwarz NR, Owens ME, Johnston JM, Pollack MH & Simon NM
(2018). The effect of mindfulness meditation training on biological acute stress responses in
generalized anxiety disorder. Psychiatry Res. Apr;262:328-332.
doi: 10.1016/j.psychres.2017.01.006. Epub 2017 Jan 26. PMID: 28131433; PMCID:
PMC5526744.
Holzel B.K., Carmody J., Vangel M., Congleton C., Yerramsetti S.M., Gard T. & Lazar S.W.
(2011) Psychiatry Research - Neuroimaging, 191 (1) , pp. 36-43.
Lutz, A., Greischar, L.L., Rawlings, N.B., Ricard, M., & Davidson, R.J., (2004). Long-term
meditators self-induce high-amplitude gamma synchrony during mental practice. PNAS,
101(46). https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0407401101
Mateos-Aparicio, P., & Rodriguez-Moreno, A. (2019). The impact of studying brain plasticity.
Front. Cell. Neurosci. 13:66 doi.org/10.3389/fncel.2019.00066
Metcalfe, J., & Mischel, W. (1999). A Hot/Cool-System Analysis of Delay of Gratification:
Dynamics of Willpower. Psychological Review, 106(1), 3-19. doi: 10.1037/0033-295X.106.1.3
Meyer-Lindenberg, A., Domes, G., Kirsch, P., y Heinrichs, M. (2011). Oxytocin and vasopressin
in the human brain: social neuropeptides for translational medicine. Nature Reviews
Neuroscience, 12, 524-538. Recovered from
https://www.nature.com/articles/nrn3044
Miller, Paige E., & Vanessa Perez. "Low-calorie sweeteners and body weight and composition: a
meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials and prospective cohort studies." The American
journal of clinical nutrition 100.3 (2014): 765-777
Peralta, M., João Martins, Francisco Gómez Chávez, Paola Cortés Almanzar & Adilson Marques
(2018) Self-rated wellbeing and physical activity associations in European older adults,
European Journal of Sport Science, 18:7, 1038-1044, DOI: 10.1080/17461391.2018.1469672
Pereira, T., Cipriano, I., Costa, T., Saraiva, M., & Martins, A. (2019). Exercise, ageing and cognitive
function - Effects of a personalized physical exercise program in the cognitive function of
older adults. Physiology & Behavior, 202, 8-13.
https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physbeh.2019.01.018
RAES, J. (2019). Vlaams darmfloraproject (VIB, Vlaams levenswetenschappelijk Instituut).
https://www.eoswetenschap.eu/gezondheid/onze-buik-beinvloedt-ons-brein
Ravesteijn HJ, Suijkerbuijk YB, Langbroek JA, Muskens E, Lucassen PL, van Weel C, Wester F, &
Speckens AE (2014). Mindfulness-based cognitive therapy (MBCT) for patients with
medically unexplained symptoms: process of change. J Psychosom Res. Jul;77(1):27-33. doi:
10.1016/j.jpsychores.2014.04.010. Epub 2014 May 5. PMID: 24913338.
95
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Ristiniemi, H., Perski, A., Lyskov, E., & Emptner, M., (2014). Hyperventilation and exhaustion
syndrome. Scand J Caring Sci; 2014; 28; 657–664, https://doi.org/10.1111/scs.12090
Rogers, Peter J., et al. Does low-energy sweetener consumption affect energy intake and body
weight? A systematic review, including meta-analyses, of the evidence from human and
animal studies. International Journal of Obesity, 2015.
Seifert, C.M., Champan, L.S., Hart, J.K., & Perez, P. (2012). Enhancing Intrinsic Motivation in
Health Promotion and Wellness. American Journal of Health Promotion and Wellness, 26, 1-12.
DOI: 10.4278/ajhp.26.3.tahp
Sheikhbahaei, S., & Smith, J.C. (2017) Breathing to inspire and arouse. Science 355(6332), pp.13701371. DOI: 10.1126/science.aan146
Wermelinger Ávila, M., Corrêa, J., Lucchetti, A., & Lucchetti, G. (2018 ). The Role of Physical
Activity in the Association Between Resilience and Mental Health in Older Adults, Journal
of Aging and Physical Activity, 26(2), 248-253.https://doi.org/10.1123/japa.2016-0332
Yackle, K., Schwarz, L.A., Kam, K., Sorokin J.M., Hugenard, J.R., Feldman, J.L., Luo, L., &
Krasnow, M.A., (2017). Breathing control center neurons that promote arousal in mice
Science 355 (6332), pp. 1411-1415, DOI: 10.1126/science.aai7984
96
New Health
_________________________________________________________________________________
Summary from Literature Reviews Focused on Exercise as a
Medicine, Food as a Medicine, and Brain as a Medicine
John van Heel – 2Adriana Kaplánová – 2Branislav Antala
1
1
New Health Foundation, Netherlands
2Comenius
University in Bratislava, Faculty of Physical Education and Sports, Slovakia
e-mail: info@new-health.eu
Abstract
The “Exercise as a medicine” section deals with the positive effects of exercise on the health of
people of different ages or people who have been diagnosed with different types of the disease.
The section entitled "Food as a medicine" was created to bring the latest knowledge on the impact
of food on human health. "Brain as a medicine" is a section that presents the knowledge of several
experts and research in order to improve the physical and mental health and to raise the awareness
that breathing, mindfulness and meditation have a positive effect on physiological and
immunological indicators of stress and inflammation.
Key words: Exercise as a Medicine, Food as a Medicine, and Brain as a Medicine
97
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
_________________________________________________________________________________
Exercise as a Medicine
The “Exercise as a medicine” section deals with the positive effects of exercise on the health of
people of different ages or people who have been diagnosed with different types of the disease.
Properly selected types of exercise programs of moderate intensity of continuous physical activity
or high-intensity interval physical exercise with a longer duration of the training unit seem to
demonstrably improve somatic indicators, contribute to better physical and functional
performance of people and eliminate harmful effects of long-term sedentary work or unhealthy
lifestyle. Long-term inactivity can result in several health complications and cause cardiovascular
as well as respiratory problems. It can also reduce the elasticity of muscles and their atrophies,
inflammatory processes in the body or osteoporosis.
Research by many experts suggests that the promotion of physical activity, for example, reduces
the risk of sarcopenia, which is characterized by loss of muscle mass, strength, and function.
Resistance exercises with load control performed under the supervision of experienced trainers
or physiotherapists have demonstrably eliminated problems caused by the physiological process
of aging or several chronic diseases. In addition, research into the susceptibility of bones to
external mechanical stress provides much stimulating information for the development of
exercise programs aimed at injury prevention through special strength training. In addition,
physical activity has been shown to be beneficial for patients with diabetes mellitus. Not only was
there a reduction in the use of drugs or their discontinuation in some patients, but positive
findings were also recorded in somatic parameters and their levels of triglycerides and HDL,
“good cholesterol”. Controlled weight reduction in overweight women has also been shown to
be very significant, as rapid weight loss has been positively correlated with the risk of ring cancer
due to estrogen overproduction.
The researchers concluded that physical activity can be considered as one of the effective ways
to prevent the health problems of the elderly or chronically ill. Experts point to the importance
of developing health literacy related to healthy exercise, as ignorance limits people's motivation
to start training, walk or cycle more often. A 10-minute walk or a 1-minute plank can significantly
improve the health of children, adults or the elderly. Raising awareness of exercise as a medicine
supports the inner motivation to live more actively and healthily. Awareness and understanding
of the importance of exercise is therefore an important condition for a sustainable active lifestyle.
Food as a Medicine
The section entitled "Food as a medicine" was created to bring the latest knowledge on the impact
of food on human health. Researchers have long been studying the synergistic effect of foods
that cause chronic health problems, as well as their therapeutic and defensive properties, which
play a key role in promoting health. At present, much research points to an increasing trend of
obesity in children and adolescents, which is mainly caused by a sedentary lifestyle combined with
98
New Health
_________________________________________________________________________________
poor eating habits, excessive consumption of sweetened beverages, or low nutritional foods.
Expert findings suggest that obesity has broad effects on human health, increases the risk of
cardiovascular disease, and also contributes to the increased incidence of diabetes mellitus in
children and adolescents. Many diseases can be prevented by proper eating habits.
Expert studies have confirmed that nutritious food is a suitable preventive form of oncological
diseases (especially breast, prostate, colon and rectal cancers), as well as a suitable adjunctive
treatment for immune-mediated skin disease - Psoriasis Vulgaris. Clinical studies that have
alleviated chronic inflammation with a proper diet have even shown a positive effect of milk
proteins on anti-inflammatory markers, as well as a positive effect of omega-3 polyunsaturated
fatty acids on these markers. According to experts, the alternative diet nutrition-lactovegetarian,
lactoovovegetarian and vegan reduces the risk of atherosclerosis. Excessive levels of essential
antioxidants in vegetarians provide protective action against reactive metabolic oxygen products
and toxic lipid peroxidation products and can reduce the incidence of free radical disease.
However, in addition to the benefits, these types of diets bring certain health risks, so it is
necessary to know all the context of the chosen diets. Increasing knowledge about the importance
of plant-based and fiber-rich foods has been shown to increase people's motivation to adapt their
eating habits to good health. Sufficient information about the disadvantages of excessive sugar
consumption or about the risks that the development of canned foods and preservatives has
brought with it has a positive effect on the development of healthy eating habits. Low-calorie
diets reduce metabolism, leptin synthesis and contribute to the yo-yo effect, ie the re-increase in
human body weight. From the above, by creating the right eating habit rich in vitamins and
minerals, it is possible to prevent many types of diseases or even improve human health, so the
right choice of food is also considered a medicine.
Brain as a Medicine
"Brain as a medicine" is a section that presents the knowledge of several experts in order to
improve the physical and mental health of people. Research findings suggest that mindfulness,
yoga and meditation have a positive effect on physiological and immunological indicators of stress
and inflammation. Its beneficial effects were monitored mainly in connection with the gray matter
of the brain, in which there were also impairments of sensory perception, memory, learning and
regulation of emotions. Repeated or chronic exposure to stressors is associated with changes in
neuroendocrine responses that are affected by the type, intensity, number, and frequency of stress
exposure. Stress tests focused on psychosocial stress revealed a more intense physiological
response of the participants compared to cognitive stress. Financial evaluation for sports
performance also proved to be a significant stressor increasing the cognitive component of
football players' anxiety, which was accompanied by a loss of mental relaxation, the breakdown
of movement stereotypes, discoordination of movements and a reduction in sports performance.
99
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
_________________________________________________________________________________
During acute stress induced by mental arithmetic, the magnitude of the reactivity of diastolic
blood pressure, heart rhythm, as well as average arterial blood pressure changes.
In the treatment of post-traumatic stress disorder, patients have again seen improvements after
autogenous training, eye movement desensitization and reprocessing. Positive results were also
achieved by patients who regularly performed techniques focused on deep breathing. The human
brain is composed of several billion neurons secured by thousands of connections, making it one
of the most important and complicated human organs. From the above, it is clear that there are
many effective ways to enhance a person's subjective well-being and quality of life.
In addition, knowledge of a strong and growth-based way of thinking and how the brain works
provide greater flexibility in changing behavior and strengthens the inner motivation to live
healthier. Our will can help control our thoughts and give our lives further direction.
100
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Researches
101
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
102
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Physical Activity and Exercise Enjoyment in a Sample of
Metropolitan College Students
Eng Hoe Wee¹ - Wei Fong Cheng2 - Hui Yin Ler3 - Ngien Siong Chin4
1,2,3
5
Tunku Abdul Rahman University College, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
Institute of Teacher Education Batu Lintang Campus, Kuching, Sarawak, Malaysia
E-mail: weeeh@tarc.edu.my
Abstract
This research examines physical activity (PA) participation and exercise enjoyment of students at
a metropolitan private university college. Participants were 358 bachelor program students
(Male=265, Female=93; Age = 20.4±1.5) from four faculties. They were surveyed using a
convenient sampling method. The most popular physical activities were exercise activities (70
percent participation), individual sport and team sport. Males participated more than females in all
the three activities. However, significant differences were found for individual and team sport
participation with males ranking the two exercises higher than females. PA level was determined
using PA Index (PAI). Male students were more active in PA as compared to that of females.
Enjoyment of exercise was evaluated with 18-item PA Enjoyment Scale (PACES). Only about
24% of the sample showed a high enjoyment level while 61% had a low enjoyment score. Male
had higher enjoyment in physical activity participation. The 20-21 years old group (14%) had
higher enjoyment in physical activity participation as compared to other groups (18-19 years old,
and 22 and above). No significance was found for the influence of gender and age for enjoyment
of PA. However, PA enjoyment differed according to PAI category. Implications are drawn
concerning the role of educational institutions to provide appropriate types of physical activity and
conducive environments that are supportive of promoting commitment to health-supporting
physical activity behaviour among college students.
Key words: Physical Activity Index, Enjoyment, Health supporting behaviour
103
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
Even though physical activity improves overall well-being, one in four adults in the world failed
to comply with the proposed global PA levels (World Health Organization [WHO], 2020). WHO
(2020) also revealed that despite the fact that up to 5 million deaths a year could be averted if the
world population could be active, more than 80% of adolescents are not sufficiently active
engaging in physical activities.
Physical inactivity (PI) is recognized as the fourth leading mortality and mortality risk factor
globally (Rajappan, Selvaganapathy & Liew, 2015), and it has been accepted as a major health issue
of undergraduates in Southeast Asian institutions of higher education. Peltzer and Pengpid (2018)
examined PI in Cambodia, Indonesia, Laos, Malaysia, Myanmar, Philippines, Singapore, Thailand,
and Vietnam, and reported that university students in the region do not get enough PA (39.0%
men; 53.0% women). Specifically, Indonesia reported between 49% (Sumardiyanto et al., 2019)
and 64% (Sudikno et al., 2019) university students were inactive. Similarly, numerous studies on
PI have been reported in Malaysia. Rajappan, Selvaganapathy and Liew (2015) revealed 43.7%
Malaysian college students were physically inactive, and for those who were active, only 43.5% (22
- 25 years old) reported participating at high physical activity level. Other Malaysian studies
reported between 55% (Bakar et al., 2019) and 66% (Yusoff et al., 2018) university students were
sedentary with only 5% physically active (Yusoff et al., 2018). However, the Malaysian National
Institute of Health [MNIH] (2020) revealed that a quarter of adult population was physically
inactive.
Various reasons may explain physical inactivity among adults and they are varied and specific to
individuals. Barriers to physical activity participation have been reported by many researchers. Wee
(2012) examined 511 college students and reported three main physical inactivity barriers as injury
phobia, unskillfulness and inter-personal effects. Other researchers concur that barriers to physical
activity are time constraints (Cerin et al., 2010; Gomez-Lopez et al., 2010) and financial constraints,
physical travelling constraints, facility scarcity (Jackson, 1993), influence of significant others, and
peers (Coakley & White, 1999), unknowledgeable, insufficient amenity, reachability, indifference,
without companions, cultural beliefs, financial constraints, physical limitations and unsafe
neighbourhood (Alexandris & Caroll, 1997; Crawford, Jackson & Godbey 1991; Goodale & Witt,
1989; Jackson & Rucks, 1993; Raymore et al., 1993; Shawn, Bonen, & McCabe, 1991; Wuest &
Fisette, 2012). While other researchers reported that individual barriers to physical activity may
include prioritising study over physical activity (Gomez-Lopez et al., 2010), and making choices
and decisions based on previous and present PA experiences. (Laker, 2002).
On the contrary, individuals participate in physical activity due to numerous motives. Enjoyment
motivates individuals to involve in PA. Previous research had revealed many grounds such as
bonding, pleasure, health, capability, and contest for involvement in physical activity (Weiss &
Petlichkoff, 1989). While others cited happiness and satisfaction as the reason why people continue
in physical activity and found experience enjoyable (Kimiecik, 2002; Titze, Stronegger, & Owen,
2005). However, Williams et al. (2006) revealed that individualized PA program provided greater
104
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
enjoyment in individuals. Other researchers reported that enjoyment, intention and adherence are
interrelated in sport participation (Nielsen et al., 2014; Granero-Gallegos et al., 2017; Teixeira et
al., 2019), exercise (Chen et al., 2020; Klos et al., 2020; Rodrigues et al., 2020), and recreation
(Gardner, Magee, & Vella, 2017). Research has also shown that greater enjoyment affected
individual’s intention to exercise and these could explain why individuals were more committed
and persistent in pursuing exercise. (Rodrigues et al., 2020).
Enjoyment indicates feelings of happiness, passion, and contentment in physical activity
participation, and is associated with intrinsic motivation in PA involvement. (Moore et al., 2009;
Nielsen et al., 2014). According to Craike, Hibbins, and Cuskelly (2010) enjoyment of LTPA is a
multidimensional construct which is conceptualised to include three dimensions: activity
enjoyment (good feeling due to leisure physical activity pursuit); physical and environmental
enjoyment (enjoy the location and environment where LTPA occur); and inter-personal
interactions. Previous research conducted to examine the relationships between enjoyment and
sport related physical activities reported feeling of pleasure or fun during sport participation.
Moreover, it was reported that enjoyment has encouraged youths to participate in PA and sport
(Fenton, Duda, Appleton, & Barrett, 2017; Karatrantou et al., 2020; Lagestad & Sørensen, 2018),
in organized sport (DiFiori et al., 2018; Fenton et al., 2017; Karatrantou et al., 2019), specifically
in basketball (DiFiori et al., 2018). Other researchers examined the meaning of enjoyment among
youths (Cheon, Reeve, Lee, & Lee, 2015; Duda & Appleton, 2016; Harwood, Barker, & Anderson,
2015) reported that avoidance of social comparison, promotion of personal improvement,
reduction of sport-related anxiety, creation of empowering climate, and feeling of autonomy in
physical activity participation have played positive roles in promoting enjoyment among youths.
Furthermore, other researchers cited that performing novelty physical activities (Dalle Grave et
al., 2011) could improve physical participation, and enjoyment and interest could be increased
when individuals perform new and challenging exercises and when new skills are acquired
(González-Cutre et al., 2019; Lakicevic et al., 2020). On the contrary, lesser enjoyment increased
dropout rate in sport (Crane & Temple, 2015).
Similarly, numerous other factors such as self-efficacy (SE) was cited as a predictor of PA
enjoyment. According to Bandura (1999), individuals with high SE would be more interested and
committed in their PA involvement. Earlier Fairclough (2003) reported that optimistic physical
competency promotes enjoyment in exercise.
Similarly, if exercise participants have required physical competency and self-confident, fun would
prevail (Eime & Harvey, 2018). When individuals enjoy their PA, they would establish inclination
for it and enhance their participation (Craike et al., 2010). Furthermore, if physical activities match
an individual’s skill levels, it will heighten enjoyment in physical activity involvement and could
promote greater exercise adherence (Westerbeek & Eime, 2021).
Previous research has shown that enjoyment is essence to participation in LTPA, and maintenance
of an active involvement in physical exercise (Henderson, Glancy, & Little, 1999; Salmon, Owen,
Crawford, Bauman, & Sallis, 2003). According to Dacey, Baltzell, and Zaichkowsky (2008),
105
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
enjoyment is an important forecaster of exercise involvement and is a variable in health promotion
theories and models. However, there are scarcity of research that investigates enjoyment in the
context of types of physical activity involvement and physical activity index. Thus, our
comprehension of the role of enjoyment in LTPA participation is limited.
Methods
Participants
In the present study 358 participants (male = 265 [74%], female = 93 [26%]; Mage = 20.4 years;
SD = 1.5) enrolled in four bachelor programs at a private educational institution located in Kuala
Lumpur, Malaysia. More than half of the students were in the 20-21 years old group (59%) and
thus could be viewed as still experiencing initial transition into adulthood.
Instrumentation
Physical Activity Index [PAI] (Griffin, 2006)
The PAI provides a single measure of the level of physical experience by an individual in their
college’s life, by incorporating estimates of the intensity, frequency and duration of their selfreported physical activity. These individual factors are reported on a 5-point scale (1 = lowest
score, 5 = highest score). These scores are then multiplied to produce a PAI rating with a range of
scores between 1 and 125.
Exercise Enjoyment Scale
Exercise enjoyment was appraised with PACES (Kendzierski & DeCarlo, 1991) that evaluated the
proportion of enjoyment of physical activity participant at a particular occasion. Kendzierski and
DeCarlo (1991), and Motl et al. (2002) have confirmed the construct validity of PACES as a
measure of enjoyment in PA participation. Participants expressed their PA enjoyment on a 7-point
scale for 18 items. Higher scores reflect greater enjoyment. This instrument was verified in
Malaysia with a reliability score of .895 using Cronbach's Alpha method. (Victor Kung, 2017).
Procedure
The Ethical Committee of the Educational Institution has approved this research prior to data
collection. Questionnaires were distributed through emails and WhatsApp to the potential
participants in four faculties at a metropolitan private university college, Kuala Lumpur Main
Campus. Participants provided their response to the questionnaire from Section A (Demographic
data), Section B (Type of physical activity involvement), Section C (Physical Activity Index), and
Section D (Enjoyment inventory) in sequence. The participants were contacted via the course or
class representatives of every course or class.
106
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Data collection and analysis
Researcher explained the objectives and desired outcomes of the study to the participants prior to
obtaining a written consent. An information sheet was furnished together with the consent form,
emphasising voluntary participation, data confidentiality, and they could withdraw from
participating in the survey at any moment without providing any reasons. The information of the
main researcher was published to allow participants wishing to seek further explanations.
Frequency and percentages were used to describe the demographic data (gender, age category, BMI
category, PA type, and PAI category. For enjoyment inventory, total score for the 18-item were
reported and categorized into ‘low enjoyment’ (score <72), ’neutral’ (score of 72), and ‘high
enjoyment’ (score >72). PAI total score was calculated via multiplication of intensity-durationfrequency variables. PAI was rated as ‘Excellent’ (PAI score = 100 or more), ‘Good; (PAI score =
60-99), ‘Average’ (PAI score = 40-59), ‘Fair’ (PAI score =20-39), and ‘Need improvement (PAI
score = < 20).
T-test, and analysis of variance (ANOVA) were used to compare the mean scores of exercise
enjoyment according to gender, age category, BMI category, and PAI category. Where F-test in
ANOVA was significant, a post-hoc Tukey multiple comparison test was applied. All research data
were analysed with SPSS ver. 23.
Assessment of Exercise Enjoyment
PACES was used to determined exercise enjoyment. Subjects’ perceived enjoyment was rated on
a 7-point Likert scale for 18 items. The total score from the sum of 18 items demonstrated the
perceived enjoyment of the physical activity. A minimum score of 18 denotes lowest level of
enjoyment level, and a maximum score of 126 reflects highest level of enjoyment. Score below 72
points is considered to have a low level of exercise enjoyment, a score of above 72 shows high
enjoyment level, and a score of 72 is neutral.
Results
Results in Table 1 showed 74% of the respondents were male (74%), and majority of them (58.7%)
were in the 20-21 years age group. In terms of BMI, a majority of the respondents was in the
normal weight group (66%) with 12.9% overweight. As for the Physical Activity Index (PAI),
about one third of the respondents were in the good category with 15.4% of respondents needing
improvement in their physical fitness levels.
The analysis of physical activity in Figure 1 was based on participants’ activities in the last three
months. Majority of the respondents (70.3%) participated in exercise activity, about 54% in
individual sport, and 51% in team sport. Further analysis of the three activities according to gender
revealed that males were more involved in all the three activities; ‘exercise activities’ (male: 74.6%,
107
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
female: 25.4%), ‘individual sports’ (male: 82.4%, female: 17.6%), and ‘team sports’ (male: 84.9%,
female:15.1%).
Table 1 Profiles of the Respondents (N = 358)
Socio-demographic characteristics
Gender
Male
Female
Total
Age Category (years)
18-19
20-21
22 & above
Total
BMI
< 18.5
Underweight
18.5 – 24.9
Normal weight
25.0 – 29.9
Overweight
Total
PAI Score & Rating
<20
Need improvement
20-39
Fair
40-59
Average
60-99
Good
100 or >
Excellent
Total
Frequency (n)
Percent (%)
265
93
358
74.0
26.0
100
94
210
54
358
26.3
58.7
15.1
100
75
235
46
356
21.1
66.0
12.9
100
55
93
85
111
14
358
15.4
26.0
23.7
31.0
3.9
100
Overall, only about 24% of the participants showed a high enjoyment level while 61% had a low
enjoyment score. For the high enjoyment category, males (73%) enjoyed their physical activity
participation more than female participants (27%). The participants aged between 20 and 21 years
old (58%) enjoyed their physical activities more than the younger (18-19 years) group and older
group (22 years and above). In terms of PAI category, the ‘good’ category group participants (33%)
enjoyed physical activities the most as compared to other group participants. The normal weight
participants (61%) appeared to enjoy their activities as compared to other groups.
In Table 3, the percentage of enjoyment is calculated based on enjoyment frequencu as compared
to the sum total of participants in each activity. Almost 26% of the participants had high enjoyment
when they were involved in outdoor leisure, followed by 22.2% in team sport, 21.4% in exercise
activity, 19.7% in individual sport, and 13.6% in outdoor challenge.
108
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Figure 1 Physical activity participation according to gender (percentage)
Table 2 Enjoyment level according to gender, age, PAI category, and BMI category
Enjoyment Frequency
Characteristics
Total
Low
Neutral 72
High
(Percentage)
Enjoyment
Enjoyment >72
<72
Gender
Male
167
36
62
265 (74.0)
Female
50
20
23
93 (26.0)
Total
217
56
85
358 (100.0)
Age
18 – 19 years
62
11
21
94 (26.3)
20 – 21 years
125
36
49
210 (58.6)
22 years & above
30
9
15
54 (15.1)
Total
217
56
85
358 (100.0)
PAI Category
<20 needs improvements
24
10
21
55 (15.4)
20-39 fair
56
22
15
93 (30.0
40-59 average
52
12
21
85 (23.7)
60-99 good
72
11
28
111 (31.0)
100 or more excellent
13
1
0
14 (3.9)
Total
217
56
85
358 (100.0)
BMI Category
<18.5 Underweight
39
17
19
75 (21.1)
18.5 - 24.99 Normal
153
30
52
235 (66.0)
weight
25 - 29.99 Overweight
25
7
14
46 (12.9)
217
54
85
356 (100.0)
109
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Table 3 Enjoyment level according to type of physical activities
Characteristics
Exercise activities
No
Yes
Total
Individual sport
No
Yes
Total
Team sport
No
Yes
Total
Outdoor leisure
No
Yes
Total
Outdoor challenge
No
Yes
Total
Enjoyment Frequency
Low
Neutral 72
High
Enjoyment <72
Enjoyment >7
2
Total
(Percentage)
61
156
217
14
42
56
31
54
85
106 (29.6)
252 (70.4)
358 (100.0)
92
125
217
26
30
56
47
38
85
165 (46.1)
193 (53.9)
358 (100.0)
99
118
217
30
26
56
44
41
85
173 (48.3)
185 (51.7)
358 (100.0)
197
20
217
50
6
56
76
9
85
323 (90.2)
35 (9.8)
358 (100.0)
200
17
217
54
2
56
82
3
85
336 (93.9)
22 (6.1)
358 (100.0)
Enjoyment of physical activity participation according to gender, age, BMI, and PAI.
An analysis of enjoyment by gender for the students showed no significant difference in enjoyment
(t= -1.270, p>0.05). Similarly, insignificant differences in enjoyment were observed according to
age group (F (2, 355)=1.191, p>0.05), and BMI group (F(2, 353)=0.591, p>0.05). However, PAI
group analysis showed significant results for enjoyment (F(4, 353)=4.041, p<0.05). A multiple
comparison test showed the mean enjoyment score of ‘excellent’ group (mean=60.93) differed
from that of other four groups. There were no differences among the ‘fair’ group (mean = 68.32),
‘good’ group (mean = 68.65), ‘average’ group (mean = 69.29), and ‘need improvement’ group
(mean = 71.18).
Discussion
Physical activity index of participants
This study reported about 4% of the participants were in the ‘excellent’ category, 31% in the ‘good’
category with 15.4% of respondents in the ‘need improvement’ category. Our findings revealed
110
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
lower physical fitness level among participants as compared to that reported by Wee et al. (2013).
Wee and colleagues (2013) examined physical activities of undergraduates and revealed that 11.3%,
37%, 11% of them are in the excellent, good, and need improvement category respectively.
Similarly, current findings (35% in excellent and good category) differed from another research
findings of Wee and other researchers (2012) where it was reported that about 40% of
undergraduates had good and excellent physical fitness levels. However, current findings showed
the participants’ physical fitness levels are better than that of a study on sport science
undergraduates; 8% very good, 28% good, and 20% in the poor level (Elijah & Eric, 2012).
The mean PAI score for the sample was 44.9 which may be considered as entering into the ‘average’
PAI classification. According to Le Rossignol, Boertien, and Wee (2016), when the PAI
classifications is compared to the WHO physical activity guidelines, it suggests that a PAI score of
40 to 60 (average) could be considered as meeting the international recommendations for moderate
PA (150 minutes/week) or vigorous PA (75 minutes/week).
In this sample the male students had a significantly higher PAI (t= 4.217, p=0.001) than their
female counterparts. The male mean score placed them in the average category (Mean=47.95,
SD±23.79) whereas the mean for the female students was in the fair band (Mean=36.10,
SD±21,92), indicating that a significant proportion of the female students were failing to fulfil the
international recommendation of minimal PA involvement. On the contrary, Elijah and Eric (2012)
examined physical activity of undergraduates and found insignificant difference in the perceived
physical health status according to gender.
As for age category, there was a significant difference (F[1,731]=0.558, p=.455) observed between
younger students 18-19 years group (Mean=50.27, SD±24.82) and older students (20-21 years old,
Mean=42.30, SD±23.56). Younger students were physically active in this sample and this situation
could be explained by Wee et al. (2013) that older students in Kuala Lumpur college indicated that
they lacked skill to participate. However, Wee et al. (2013) also reported that college students in
Melbourne, younger students perceived inadequate time as their greater obstacle to being physically
active. These findings concur with the previous finding that age affected physical activity
participation significantly (Torkildsen, 2000). Torkildsen also observed that older students have
considerably more time at their disposal than the younger student group.
Physical activity of the participants
The study revealed that participants were engaged in three main physical activities (exercise activity,
70.3%; individual sport, 54%, team sport, 51%) with male participants 3-6 times more active in
those activities than female participants. Exercise activity of this sample is indistinguishable from
that reported in a comparative-research between Kuala Lumpur and Melbourne undergraduates
(Wee, Aumand, Ler and Chan, 2013). However, individual sport (29.3%), and team sport (27.2%)
were much lower in Wee et al. (2013) study as compared to the findings of this research. In addition,
another research (Michael et al., 2016) reported that males boys engaged in more activities, and
enjoyed PA more, as compared to females.
111
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Enjoyment and type of physical activity
This research sample experienced a high enjoyment level when they participated in outdoor leisure
(26%), followed by team sport (22.2%), and exercise activity (21.4%). Increasing PA among
adolescents has been linked to opportunities to be involved in and enjoy a variety of PA (Michael,
Coffield, Lee, & Fulton, 2016). Leisure activity such as walking and team sport are associated with
increased PA (Agans & Geldhof, 2012; Taverno Ross, Dowda, Beets, & Pat, 2013). In fact,
adolescent enjoyed their PA more if they engaged in activities that they preferred (Liu, Sun, Beets,
& Probst, 2013), and regular participation in sport could increase their PA levels (Hebert, Møller,
Andersen, & Wedderkopp, 2015; Kokko et al., 2019). Enjoyment has encouraged almost 72% of
young basketball players (71.5%) to participate in MVPA between 6 and 7 days per week
(Krommidas, 2016).
In examining the relationship between PA type and enjoyment, Michael et al. (2016) reported
enjoyment was positively correlated to PA involvement in boys. PA enjoyment played a mediating
role in PA and team sports participation. In girls, team sports and weightlifting have positive
relationships with PA participation and individual sport was predictor of PA enjoyment. In
addition, PA participation and individual sports are mediated by the sense of enjoyment.
Outdoor leisure structure could affect participants' enjoyment as well. In identifying the youth
involvement in outdoor activities in city neighbourhood recreational area (soccer field, futsal court
and jogging track), Omara, Omara, Othman, and Yusoff (2016) reported that youth were pleased
with the facilities with males dominating in the usage of soccer field (M: 64.4%, F:46.6%), futsal
court (72.4% versus 56.8) and jogging track (57.1% versus 53.7%). Similarly, Bowers, Larson, and
Sandoval (2019) interviewed youths who participated in outdoor adventure camp and revealed that
they enjoyed spending time outdoors and meeting new people in a natural setting. The outdoor
experience has connected youths to the natural world, promoting a sense of oneness with the
natural setting and enhanced enjoyment (Cheng & Monroe, 2012). The novel settings for
recreation experiences among youths and allowing them a sustained time in nature (Garst et al.,
2011) has generated enjoyment in them.
Enjoyment of physical activity participation according to gender, age, and BMI
Bai et al. (2018) revealed significant interaction effects of gender and enjoyment; Boys and girls
who had high-level enjoyment in PA had statistically significant higher PA. However, insignificant
result was reported according to gender. In another study of elementary school students, Burford,
Zhang and Bartholomew (2021) found girls had enjoyed lower intensity activities more while boys
reported more joyful with high intensity activities and activities that require strength. According
to other research (Kann et al., 2014; Ortega et al., 2013) PA among girls decrease sharply as
compared to boys. The decline might be due to decrease in enjoyment among adolescent girls as
compared to boys (Cairney et al., 2012).
112
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Bai et al. (2018) found younger students had higher enjoyment scores and higher PA as compared
to older students; elementary school students had the highest level of enjoyment and PA as
compared to middle school students and high school students respectively. Accordingly, previous
research (Cooper et al., 2015; Ortega et al., 2013) is in agreement that PA declines with age and
consequently there is an increase in sedentary behaviour.
With regard to the effects of body weight, and enjoyment of PA, Bevan et al. (2021) surveyed 579
undergraduate’s behaviour in physical activities and reported that weight stigma (teasing, and
negative comments), appearance evaluation (beliefs about one's appearance), and weight bias
internalisation (self-blame) were related to lower enjoyment of PA and sport. In addition, Baven
also revealed that due to the above, undergraduates with body weight issues tend to avoid physical
activity. According to Pearl and Puhl (2016) self-blame was highly associated with lower PA
enjoyment and incline to turn away from PA and sport.
Conclusion
This research reported that enjoyment in physical activity is associated with many variables such
as demographic (gender, age, PAI, body weight, type of PA). Taken collectively, the findings of
this research indicate that it might be imperative to observe the effects of enjoyment on PA and
not the activity itself. These research findings also support the belief that enjoyment is linked to
PA behaviours. Since enjoyment is changeable, College co-curriculum program provider should
aim at increasing enjoyment in students PA. However, as the results of this study are based on
student self-respond, the results may be prejudiced. Thus, the findings should be viewed within
the limitation.
References
Alexandris, K., & Carroll, B. (1997). An Analysis of Leisure Constraints based on Different
Recreational Sport Participation Levels: Results from a study in Greece. Leisure Science, 19,
1-15.
Agans, J.P., & Geldhof, J. (2012). Trajectories of participation in athletics and positive youth
development: influence of sport type. Appl Dev Sci., 16(3), 151–165.
Bai, Y., Allums-Featherston, K., Saint-Maurice, P.F., Welk, G.J., & Candelaria, N. (2018).
Evaluation of Youth Enjoyment Toward Physical Activity and Sedentary Behaviour. Pediatr
Exerc Sci., 30(2), 273-280. doi: 10.1123/pes.2017-0101.
Bakar, Z.A., Ibrahim, H., & Ashaari, Z.M. (2019). Physical Activity Among Malaysian University
Students: The Motives. Indian Journal of Public Health Research & Development, 10(6), 1305-1308.
DOI: 10.5958/0976-5506.2019.01476.1
Bandura, A. (1999). Self-Efficacy in Changing Societies. NY: Cambridge University Press.
Bevan, N., O’Brien, K.S., Lin, C.Y., Latner, J.D., Vandenberg, B., Jeanes, R., …Georgia Rush, G.
(2021). The Relationship between Weight Stigma, Physical Appearance Concerns, and
Enjoyment and Tendency to Avoid Physical Activity and Sport. International journal of
environmental research and public health, 18(19), 9957. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph18199957
113
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Bowers, E.P., Larson, L.R., & Sandoval, A.M. (2019). Urban Youth Perspectives on the Benefits
and Challenges of Outdoor Adventure Camp. Journal of Youth Development, 14(4), 122-143.
DOI 10.5195/jyd.2019.809
Burford, K., Zhang, Y., & Bartholomew, J. (2021). Gender differences in enjoyment for types of
physical activity in children: Mini-Oral Presentation C1.6. The Health & Fitness Journal of
Canada, 14(3). https://doi.org/10.14288/hfjc.v14i3.742
Cairney J, Kwan MY, Velduizen S, et al. (2012). Gender, perceived competence and the enjoyment
of physical education in children: a longitudinal examination. Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act.; 9:26.
Cerin, E., Leslie, E., Sugiyama, T. & Owen, N. (2010). Perceived barriers to leisure-time physical
activity in adults: An ecological perspective. Journal of Physical Activity and Health, 7, 451-459.
Chen, C., Finne, E., Kopp, A., and Jekauc, D. (2020). Can positive affective variables mediate
intervention effects on physical activity? A systematic review and meta-analysis. Front.
Psychol. 11:587757. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2020.587757
Cheng, J. C. H., & Monroe, M. C. (2012). Connection to nature: Children’s affective attitude
toward nature. Environment and Behavior, 44(1), 31-49. 10.1177/0013916510385082
Cheon, S. H., Reeve, J., Lee, J., & Lee, Y. (2015). Giving and receiving autonomy support in a
high-stakes sport context: A field-based experiment during the 2012 London Paralympic
Games. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 19, 59–
69. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.psychsport.2015.02.007
Craike, M. J., Hibbins, R., and Cuskelly, G. (2010). The influence of various aspects of enjoyment
on participation in leisure time physical activity. World Leis. J. 52, 20–33. doi:
10.1080/04419057.2010.9674619
Crane, J., & Temple, V. (2015). A systematic review of dropout from organized sport among
children and youth. European Physical Education Review, 21(1), 114-131. DOI:
10.1177/1356336X14555294
Crawford, D. W., Jackson, E.L, Godbey, G. (1991). A hierarchical model of leisure constraints.
Leisure Sciences, 13, 309-320.
Coakley, J., & White, A (1999). Experience and identity. In J. Coakley and P. Donelly (Eds.), Inside
Sports. London: Routledge.
Cooper, A.R., Goodman, A., Page, A.S., Sherar, L.B., Esliger, D.W., van Sluijs, E.M.F., Ekelund,
U. (2015). Objectively measured physical activity and sedentary time in youth: the
international children’s accelerometry database (ICAD). Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act., 12:113.
PubMed doi:10.1186/s12966-015-0274-5
Dacey, M., Baltzell, A., & Zaichkowsky, L. (2008). Older adults ‘intrinsic and extrinsic motivation
toward physical activity. American Journal of Health Behavior, 32, 570-582.
Dalle Grave, R., Calugi, S., Centis, E., El Ghoch, M., and Marchesini, G. (2011). Cognitivebehavioral strategies to increase the adherence to exercise in the management of obesity. J.
Obes. 2011:348293. doi: 10.1155/2011/348293
DiFiori, J. P., Güllich, A., Brenner, J. S., Cote, J., Hainline, B., Ryan, E., & Malina, R. M. (2018).
The NBA and youth basketball: Recommendations for promoting a healthy and positive
experience. Sports Medicine, 48, 2053-2065. DOI: 10.1007/s40279-018- 0950-0
114
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Duda, J. L., & Appleton, P. R. (2016). Empowering and disempowering coaching climates:
Conceptualization, measurement considerations, and intervention implications. In M. Raab,
P. Wylleman, R. Seiler, A.-M. Elbe, & A. Hatzigeorgiadis (Eds.), Sport and exercise psychology
research:
From
theory
to
practice (pp.
373–388).
Elsevier
Academic
Press. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-803634-1.00017-0
Eime, R., & Harvey, J. (2018). Sport participation across the lifespan: Australian trends and policy
implications, In R. Dionigi and M. Gard (Eds.), Sport and Physical Activity Across the Lifespan
(23-43). London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Elijah, G. R., & Eric, D.K.N. (2012). Motivational gender differences in sport and exercise
participation among university sport science students. Journal of Physical Education and Sport,
12(2), 180 – 187.
Fairclough, S. (2003). Physical activity, perceived competence and enjoyment during secondary
school physical education. European Journal of Physical Education, 8, 5-18.
Fenton, S. A. M., Duda, J. L., Appleton, P. R., & Barrett, T. G. (2017). Empowering youth sport
environments: Implications for daily moderate-to-vigorous physical activity and adiposity.
Journal of Sport and Health Science, 6, 423-433. DOI:10.1016/j.jshs.2016.03.006
Gardner, L., Magee, C.A., & Vella, S.A. (2017). Enjoyment and behavioural intention predict organized
youth sport participation and dropout. Faculty of Social Sciences - Papers. 3376.
https://ro.uow.edu.au/sspapers/3376
Garst, B. A., Browne, L. A., & Bialeschki, M. D. (2011). Youth development and the camp
experience. New Directions for Youth Development, 130, 73-87. doi:10.1002/yd.398
Griffin, J.C. (2006). Client-centred exercise prescription (2nd ed.). Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics.
Gomez-Lopez, M., Granero Gallegos, A., & Baena Extremera, A. (2010). Perceived barriers by
university students in the practice of physical activities. Journal of Sports Science and Medicine, 9,
372-381.
González-Cutre, D., Romero-Elías, M., Jiménez-Loaisa, A., Beltrán-Carrillo, V. J., & Hagger, M.
S. (2019). Testing the need for novelty as a candidate need in basic psychological needs
theory. Motiv. Emot. 44, 295–314. doi: 10.1007/s11031-019-09812-7
Goodale, L., & Witt, A. (1989). Recreation non-participation and barriers to leisure. In E. L.
Jackson & T. L. Burton (Eds.), Understanding leisure and recreation: Mapping the past, charting the
future (pp.421-49). State College, PA: Venture.
Granero-Gallegos, A., Gomez-Lopez, M., Rodriguez-Suarez, N., Abraldes, J., Alesi, M., & Bianco,
A. (2017). Importance of the motivational climate in goal, enjoyment, and the causes of
success in handball players. Front. Psychol. 8:2081. 10.3389/fpsyg.2017.02081
Hebert, J. J., Møller, N. C., Andersen, L. B., & Wedderkopp, N. (2015). Organized sport
participation is associated with higher levels of overall health-related physical activity in
children (CHAMPS Study-DK). PLoS ONE, 10(8), e0134621. DOI: 10.1371/journal.
pone.0134621
Henderson, K.A., Glancy, M., & Little, S. (1999). Putting the fun into physical activity. Journal of
Physical Education, Recreation & Dance, 70, 43-45.
Jackson, E., & Rucks, V. (1993). Reasons for ceasing participation and barriers to participation:
Further examination of constrained leisure as an internally homogeneous concept. Leisure
Sciences, 15, 217-230.
115
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Kann, L., Kinchen, S., Shanklin, S.L., Flint, K.H., Kawkins, J., Harris, W.A.,…Zaza, S. (2014).
Youth Risk Behavior Surveillance: United States, 2013. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report
Surveillance Summaries, 63(4), 1–168.
Karatrantou, K., Stavrou, V., Hasioti, P., Varveri, D., Krommidas, C., & Gerodimos, V. (2020).
An enjoyable school‐based swimming training programme improves students’
aquaticity. Acta Paediatrica, 109(1), 166–174. https://doi.org/10.1111/apa.14920
Karatrantou, K., Gerodimos, V., Voutselas, V., Manouras, N., Famisis, K., & Ioakimidis, P. (2019).
Can sport-specific training affect vertical jumping ability during puberty? Biol Sport. 36(3),
217–224. doi: 10.5114/biolsport.2019.85455
Kendzierski, D., & DeCarlo, K.J. (1991). Physical Activity Enjoyment Scale: Two Validation
Studies. Journal of Sport & Exercise Psychology, 13(1), 50-64. DOI: 10.1123/jsep.13.1.50
Kimiecik, J. (2002). Discovering the joy of exercise. NY: Houghton Mifflin Company.
Klos, L., Feil, K., Eberhardt, T., & Jekauc, D. (2020). Interventions to promote positive affect and
physical activity in children, adolescents and young adults—a systematic review. Sports 8:26.
10.3390/sports8020026
Kokko, S., Martin, L., Geidne, S., Van Hoye, A., Lane, A., Meganck, J., … Koski, P. (2019). Does
sports club participation contribute to physical activity among children and adolescents? A
comparison across six European countries. Scandinavian Journal of Public Health, 47(8), 851858. DOI: 10.1177/1403494818786110
Krommidas, C., Perkos, S., Syrmpas, I., Gorozidis, G.S. , Vlahos, O., Brisimis, E. , & Loules, G.
(2020). Self-reported physical activity, enjoyment and well-being of greek youth basketball
players. European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science, 6(3), 127-143.
Krommidas, C., Galanis, E., Papaioannou, A., Tzioumakis, G., Zourbanos, N., Keramidas, P., &
Digelidis, N. (2016). The relationship of Empowering and Disempowering coaching climate
with enjoyment and quality of life variables in Greek youth soccer. Inquiries in Sport &
Physical Education, 14(2), 19-35.
Lagestad, P. A. & Sørensen, A. (2018). Longitudinal changes in sports enjoyment among
adolescents.
Journal
of
Physical
Education
and
Sport,
18(1):11,
89-97.
doi: 10.7752/jpes.2018.01011
Lakicevic, N., Gentile, A., Mehrabi, S., Cassar, S., Parker, K., Roklicer, R.,…Drid, P. (2020).
Make Fitness Fun: Could Novelty Be the Key Determinant for Physical Activity
Adherence? Front. Psychol., 11: 577522. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2020.577522
Laker, A. (Eds.). (2002). The sociology of sport and physical education. London: Routledge.
Le Rossignol, P. & Boertien, M. & Wee, E.H. (2016). Health related physical activity behaviour
of first year university students. International Sports Studies, 38(1), 25-35.
Liu, J., Sun, H., Beets, M., & Probst, J, C. (2013). Assessing natural groupings of common leisuretime physical activities and its correlates among U.S. adolescents. J Phys Act Health, 10,
470–479.
Malaysian National Institutes of Health (MNIH)(2020). National Health and Morbidity Survey
2019 (Non-communicable diseases, healthcare demand, and health literacy): Key Findings.
Setia Alam, Selangor, Malaysia: Ministry of Health Malaysia. Retrieve from:
http://iptk.moh.gov.my/images/technical_report/2020/4_Infographic_Booklet_NHMS_
2019_-_English.pdf
116
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Michael, S.L., Coffield, E., Lee, S.M., Fulton, J.E. (2016). Variety, Enjoyment, and Physical
Activity Participation Among High School Students J Phys Act Health, 13(2): 223–230.
doi:10.1123/jpah.2014-0551.
Moore, J., Yin, Z., Hanes, J., Duda, J., Gutin, B., & Barbeau, P. (2009). Measuring enjoyment of
physical activity in children: validation of the physical activity enjoyment scale. J. Appl. Sport
Psychol. 21, 116–129. 10.1080/10413200802593612
Motl, R. W., Dishman, R. K., Saunders, R. P., Dowda, M., Felton, G., Ward, D. S., & Pate, R. R.
(2002). Examining social-cognitive determinants of intention and physical activity among
Black and White adolescent girls using structural equation modeling. Health Psychology, 21(5),
459–467. https://doi.org/10.1037/0278-6133.21.5.459
Nielsen, G., Wilman, J. M., Jensen, C. J., Schmidt, J. F., Gliemann, L., & Andersen, T. R. (2014).
Health promotion: the impact of beliefs of health benefits, social relations and enjoyment
on exercise continuation. Scand. J. Med. Sci. Sports 24, 66–75. doi: 10.1111/sms.12275
Omara, K.A., Omara, D., , Othman, S., & Yusoff, Z.M. (2016). The relationship between youth
activities and outdoor features in urban neighbourhood space. Procedia - Social and Behavioral
Sciences 234 ( 2016 ) 271 - 279.
Ortega, F.B., Konstabel, K., Pasquali, E., Ruiz, J.R., Hurtig-Wennlöf, A., …, Sjostrom, M. (2013).
Objectively measured physical activity and sedentary time during childhood, adolescence
and young adulthood: a cohort study. PLoS ONE, 8(4):e60871. doi:10.
1371/journal.pone.0060871
Pearl, R.L., & Puhl, R.M. (2016). The distinct effects of internalizing weight bias: An experimental
study. Body Image, 17, 38–42
Peltzer, K. & Pengpid, S. (2018). Prevalence, risk awareness and health beliefs of behavioural risk
factors for cardiovascular disease among university students in nine ASEAN countries. BMC
Public Health (2018) 18:237 https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-018-5142-1
Rajappan, R., Selvaganapathy, K., Liew. L. (2015). Physical activity level among university students:
a cross sectional survey. Int J Physiother Res 3(6), 1336-1343. DOI: 10.16965/ijpr.2015.202
Raymore, L, Godbey, g., Crawford, D., & von Eye, A. (1993). Nature and process of leisure
constraints: An empirical test. Leisure Sciences, 15, 99-113.
Rodrigues, F., Teixeira, D. S., Neiva, H. P., Cid, L., and Monteiro, D. (2020). The bright and dark
sides of motivation as predictors of enjoyment, intention, and exercise persistence. Scand. J.
Med. Sci. Sports 30, 787–800. doi: 10.1111/sms.13617
Salmon, J., Owen, N., Crawford, D., Bauman, A. & Sallis, J. (2003). Physical activity and sedentary
behaviour: A population-based study of barriers, enjoyment and preference. Health Psychology,
22(2), 178-188.
Shawn, S., Bonen, A., & McCabe, J. (1991). Do more constraints mean less leisure? Examining the
relationship between constraints and participation. Journal of Leisure Research, 23, 286-300.
Sudikno, Elisa, D.J., Yunita, D.S., & Yurista, P.S. (2019). The Relationship of Physical Activities
on Obesity in Adults in Indonesia. Advances in Health Sciences Research, 22, 96-100. Retrieved
from:https://www.atlantis-press.com/proceedings/ishr-19/sessions/3238
Sumardiyanto, S. Jajat, J., Risma, R., Kuston, S., & Cep Ubad, A. (28 – 30 November 2019).
Physical Activity Level of University Students.Paper presented at the 4th International
117
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Conference on Sports Science, Health and Physical Education, Bali, Indonesia. Retrieved
from: http://toc.proceedings.com/53421webtoc.pdf
Taverno Ross, S.E., Dowda, M., Beets, M.W., & Pat, R.R. (2013). Physical activity behavior and
related characteristics of highly active eighth-grade girls. J Adolesc Health, 52(6), 745–751.
Teixeira, D. S., Pelletier, L., Monteiro, D., Rodrigues, F., Moutão, J., Marinho, D., & Cid, L. (2019).
Motivational patterns in persistent swimmers: a serial mediation analysis. Eur. J. Sport Sci.,
20, 660–669. 10.1080/17461391.2019.1675768
Titze, S., Stronegger, W.J., & Owen, N. (2005). Prospective study of individual, social, and
environmental predictors of physical activity: Women's leisure running. Psychology of Sport and
Exercise, 6(3), 363-376.
Torkildsen, G. (2000). Leisure and recreation management. (5th ed.). NY: E & FN Spon.
Victor Kung C. W. (2017). Relationship between exercise enjoyment and Exercise adherence
among college students (Research Project). Tunku Abdul Rahman University College, Faculty
of Applied Sciences, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
Wee, E.H., Ler, H.Y., Chan, K.Q., Saunders, J. & Aumand, E. (2012). Comparing barriers to being
physically active between TAR College and Australian Catholic University students
(Research Project). Tunku Abdul Rahman University College, Faculty of Applied Sciences,
Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
Wee Eng Hoe, Aumand, E., Ler Hui Yin & Chan Kai Quin (2013). Physical activity participation
and its barriers: A comparative study of college students in Malaysia and Australia.
International Sports Studies, 35(1), 49-57.
Weiss, M.R., & Petlichkoff, L.M. (1989). Children’s motiavation for paticipation in and withdrawal
from sport: Identifying the missing links. Pediatric Exercise Science, 1, 195-211.
Westerbeek, H. & Eime, R. (2021). The Physical Activity and Sport Participation Framework—A
Policy Model Toward Being Physically Active Across the Lifespan. Front. Sports Act. Living,
3, 1-11. https://doi.org/10.3389/fspor.2021.60859
Williams, D. M., Papandonatos, G. D., Napolitano, M. A., Lewis, B. A., Whiteley, J. A., & Marcus,
B. H. (2006). Perceived enjoyment moderates the efficacy of an individually tailored physical
activity intervention. Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 28, 300–309
World Health Organization [WHO] (2020). Physical activity.
https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/physical-activity.
Wuest, D.A. & Fisette, J.L. (2012). Foundations of physical education, exercise science and Sport
(17th ed.). NY: McGraw-Hill.
Yusoff, N.A.M., Ganeson, S., Ismail, K.F., Juahir, H., Shahril, M.R., Lin, L.P., … Rajikan, R.
(2018). Physical activity level among undergraduate students in Terengganu, Malaysia using
pedometer. J. Fundam. Appl. Sci., 10(1S), 512-522.
doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.4314/jfas.v10i1s.36
118
Researches
_________________________________________________________________________________
The Effects of Innovative Tools Implemented in Singapore
during Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children,
Youth and Adults
Govindasamy Balasekaran - Ng Yew Cheo - Peggy Boey
Nanyang Technological University, Singapore
e-mail: govindasamy.b@nie.edu.sg
Abstract
Purpose: This chapter investigated 2 studies that implemented innovative tools for children,
youth and adults to utilize during physical education (PE) and physical activities (PA). 1) The use
of Brain Breaks® videos and its effects on Singaporean students’ attitudes towards PA. 2) The
use of the adult OMNI Rate of Perceived Exertion (RPE) scale on soccer players during
laboratory and field testing. Methods: 1) A total of 113 clinically healthy students (boys: 47, girls:
66) (age: 9.68 0.95 years, height: 1.38 8.27 m, weight: 35.21 10.21 kg, body mass index
(BMI): 18.19 2.86 kg•m-2) participated in this study and were randomly assigned to experimental
Brain Breaks® group (BB, 48 students) and control group (CG, 65 students). BB underwent
Brain Breaks® video intervention consisting of 3-5 minutes of Brain Breaks® video exercises for
10 weeks, 5 days per week during academic lessons. CG continued academic lessons without
video intervention. A self-reported Attitudes toward Physical Activity Scale (APAS) questionnaire
was administered pre- and post-intervention for all students. 2) Ten healthy female participants
volunteered for this study (age: 23.20 1.49 years, height: 161.10 7.50 cm, weight: 49.01 3.90
kg, body fat percent: 22.20 3.89 %). Participants underwent 3 sessions trials that consisted of
laboratory session 1 (S1), field sessions 2 and 3 (S2 & S3). In S1, participants completed a
discontinuous submaximal exercise treadmill run protocol with 4 minutes run, 4 minutes rest.
OMNI RPE, oxygen consumption (VO2) and HR were recorded during the last minute of each
exercise stage. During S2 and S3, participants completed warm-up, 5v5 possession soccer game,
followed by cool down. After each exercise segment, participants recorded their RPE and HR on
a data recording sheet. Results: 1) There were significant main effects between groups for
importance (p = 0.012), learning (p = 0.000), self-efficacy (p = 0.000), fun (p = 0.034) and fitness
(p = 0.022). 2) Results indicated significant positive correlation between HR during field (field
HR) and HR during treadmill (treadmill HR) at Vpt (field HR: 161.94 ± 12.80 beats•min-1 vs.
treadmill HR: 156.0.6 ± 12.25 beats•min-1, r = 0.79, p = 0.032); field HR and OMNI RPE during
treadmill (treadmill OMNI RPE) (field HR: 161.94 ± 12.80 beats•min-1 vs. treadmill OMNI RPE:
4.89 ± 0.93, r = 0.726, p = 0.027). Conclusion: 1) 3-5 minutes daily of Brain Breaks® video is
sufficient to improve students’ perception toward PA and this will subsequently lead students to
increase the duration of PA. 2) Recreational and elite athletes from soccer and other similar team
sports can use OMNI RPE 4-6 to self-regulate their exercise intensity to allow them to train
optimally and achieve significant improvement in performance.
Key words: Innovative tools, Singapore, Physical education
119
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
_________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
Research on physical activity (PA) has shown to contribute to various health benefits (e.g.,
prevention of weight gain, regulation of blood pressure, management of good mental health etc.).
The American College of Sports Medicine (ACSM, 2014) recommends 150 minutes of moderateto-vigorous intensity of exercise weekly for healthy adults and 60 minutes of PA for children
daily. In Singapore, physical educators, coaches, and sports trainers are constantly finding
different methods to actively engage students and athletes in PA, exercise, and training in the
most fun, effective, and safe way to meet the PA requirements. Singapore educators are also
incorporating technology into lessons or co-curricular activities (CCA), especially during the
recent pandemic when the country was under lockdown. The current generation of students are
better known to be “tech-savvy” and are interested in technology (Balasekaran et al., 2021).
Therefore, it is suggested that technology and digital platforms can encourage students to increase
their PA levels (Boone et al., 2015; Lewallen et al., 2015). Hence, this chapter investigated two
studies (1) and (2) that implemented innovative tools for children, youth and adults during
physical education (PE) and PA in Singapore.
Exercise videos found on YouTube, HOPSports, JumpJam etc. are becoming increasingly
popular with students and adults. This study utilized the exercise videos from HOPSports Brain
Breaks® as this platform is aligned to the Whole School, Whole Community, and Whole Child
(WSCC) Guidelines (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2020, Shields & Behrman,
2000) and the United Nations 17 Sustainable Development Goals (UNSDG) (Balasekaran et al.,
2021). Furthermore, Singapore is committed to the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development
(Ministry of Education, 2020) and these values are also aligned to Singapore’s Ministry of
Education (MOE) Desired Outcomes of Education and 21st Century Competencies (Ministry of
Foreign Affairs, 2018). The HOPSports Brain Breaks® videos are between 3-5 minutes in
duration with easy-to-follow video instructions in completing aerobic/movement exercises. 1)
The first study investigated the use of Brain Breaks® videos and its effects on Singaporean
students’ attitudes towards PA and the possibility of increasing PA participation during its
intervention conducted amid school curricula.
While PA and exercise are imperative, exercising at an optimal intensity is also essential to prevent
or reduce the risk of sustaining injuries. Children, youths, and adults should enjoy exercise and
simultaneously reap cardiovascular benefits. Hence, they would participate in PA regularly. One
way to measure optimal exercise intensity is by utilizing Ratings of Perceived Exertion (RPE),
which is commonly used during exercise to perceptually estimate effort. There have been studies
done locally using OMNI RPE scale for children and youths as a self-regulatory tool for weight
loss and Physical Education (PE) lessons (Balasekaran, Loh, Govindaswamy & Robertson, 2012;
Balasekaran, Loh, Govindaswamy & Cai, 2014). Additionally, the OMNI RPE scale has been
validated across various target groups to allow these individuals identify a safe training zone
during their PA or exercise. 2) The second study investigated the use of the adult OMNI RPE
scale on soccer players during laboratory and field testing. It aimed to examine whether adult
120
Researches
_________________________________________________________________________________
soccer players in Singapore could self-regulate exercise intensity using the OMNI RPE scale
during their soccer training sessions.
Methods
1) A total of 113 clinically healthy students (boys: 47, girls: 66) (age: 9.68 0.95 years, height: 1.38
8.27 m, weight: 35.21 10.21 kg, body mass index (BMI): 18.19 2.86 kg•m-2) participated in
this study (Table 1). The students in their respective classes were randomly assigned according to
experimental Brain Breaks® group (BB: 6 classes of 48 students) and control group (CG: 6 classes
of 65 students). BB underwent Brain Breaks® video intervention consisting of 3-5 minutes of
Brain Breaks® video exercises for 10 weeks, 5 days per week during academic lessons. The
students in BB followed the Brain Breaks® videos that featured physical movement activities
alongside song, dance, and exercise movements. Students could also select their choice of Brain
Breaks® videos and a variety of videos were streamed online during the intervention via the
official website https://brain-breaks.com (Rizal et al., 2019; Kuan et al., 2019). CG continued
their academic lessons as usual without video intervention. A self-reported Attitudes toward
Physical Activity Scale (APAS) questionnaire was administered pre- and post-intervention for
both groups of students. This study obtained approval from the Institutional Review Board from
Nanyang Technological University (NTU-IRB Reference Number: 2019-01-025), together with
a school initiative. Parents and students also gave consent by submitting informed consent forms.
The APAS designed by Mok et al. (2015) is a self-reported questionnaire used to measure beliefs,
attitudes and self-efficacy towards PA, which is comprised of 7 sections using Likert-type scales:
F1 ‘promoting holistic health’, F2 ‘importance of exercise habit’, F3 ‘self-efficacy in learning with
video exercises’, F4 ‘self-efficacy in selecting video exercises for themselves’, F5 ‘exercise
motivation and enjoyment’, F6 ‘self-confidence on physical fitness’ and F7 ‘trying to do my
personal best’. This questionnaire also required participants to complete basic demographics (e.g.,
age, gender, school grade level, height, and weight). It also included a four-point Likert-type
response category, ‘strongly disagree’, ‘disagree’, ‘agree’ and ‘strongly agree’. In addition, the
Cronbach’s Alpha reliability coefficients for this study ranged from 0.81 to 0.92 (Table 2).
Table 1. Participants’ Descriptive Statistics (n = 113)
Variables
Age (years)
Height (m)
Weight (kg)
Body Mass Index (kg•m-2)
Total (n = 113)
Mean ± SD
9.68 ± 0.95
1.38 ± 8.27
35.21 ± 10.21
18.19 ± 2.86
BB (n = 48)
Mean ± SD
9.71 ± 0.99
1.37 ± 0.09
34.91 ± 10.97
18.24 ± 4.18
CG (n = 65)
Mean ± SD
9.66 ± 0.94
1.39 ± 0.09
35.43 ± 10.55
18.16 ± 3.67
Note: Values are in mean ± SD. BB (Brain Breaks® Group); CG (Control Group); age (years); height (meters,
m); weight (kilograms, kg); body mass index (kilograms per square meter, kg•m-2).
121
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
_________________________________________________________________________________
Table 2 Cronbach’s Alpha Reliability Coefficients for Attitudes toward Physical Activity Scale
(APAS)
Scale
Number of Items
Promoting Holistic Health (F1)
Importance of Exercise Habit (F2)
Self-efficacy in Learning with Video Exercises (F3)
Self-efficacy in Selecting Video Exercises (F4)
Exercise Motivation and Enjoyment (F5)
Self-confidence on Physical Fitness (F6)
Trying to do Personal Best (F7)
10
5
11
4
14
8
5
Cronbach’s
alpha
0.84
0.81
0.93
0.90
0.87
0.92
0.82
Note: Cronbach’s Alpha: 0.9 > 𝛼 ≥ 0.8: Good; 𝛼 ≥ 0.9: Excellent
2) A total of 10 healthy female participants volunteered for this study (age: 23.20 1.49 years,
height: 161.10 7.50 cm, weight: 49.01 3.90 kg, body fat percent: 22.20 3.89 %) (Table 3).
Anthropometric measurements were taken for participants, which also included body
composition assessment using Body Impedance Analysis (BIA). Participants were also required
to complete a PAR-Q+ medical questionnaire to declare their current health status. Participants
underwent 3 sessions trials that consisted of laboratory session 1 (S1), field sessions 2 and 3 (S2
& S3). In S1, participants completed a discontinuous submaximal exercise treadmill run protocol
which is a series of treadmill runs with each stage lasting 4 minutes, followed by 4 minutes
recovery rest (Balasekaran, Govindaswamy, Lim, Boey & Ng, 2021). Treadmill speed will increase
with each stage by 0.5 km•h-1, ranging between 6 km•h-1 to 14 km•h-1 depending on the
participant’s fitness level. At each stage, participant will rate their OMNI RPE with the 10-point
OMNI RPE scale (Figure 1). RPE, oxygen consumption (VO2) and HR were measured during
the last minute of each exercise stage. The test ceased when participant had achieved 85% of their
maximal heart rate (HR), which is within the range where ventilatory breakpoint (Vpt) occurs.
During S2 and S3, participants completed warm-up, 5v5 possession soccer game, followed by
cool down. After each exercise segment, participants rated their RPE and recorded their HR on
a data recording sheet. Participants were told to keep their OMNI RPE between 1 and 3 during
warm-up and cool down, OMNI RPE between 4 and 6 during 5v5 possession soccer game. In
the final week, participants repeated the same exercises. This study obtained approval from the
Institutional Review Board from Nanyang Technological University (NTU-IRB Reference
Number: 2019-01-008). Participants gave consent by submitting informed consent forms prior
to commencement of study.
122
Researches
_________________________________________________________________________________
Figure 1 Adult OMNI-Walk/Run Scale of Perceived Exertion (Robertson 2004)
Table 3 Participants’ Descriptive Statistics (n = 10)
Variables
Age (Years)
Height (cm)
Weight (kg)
Body Fat (%)
Results (Females, n=10)
Mean ± SD
23.30 ± 1.49
161.10 ± 7.50
49.01 ± 3.90
22.20 ± 3.89
Variables at Final stage of Treadmill protocol
VO2 (L•min-1)
VO2 (mL•kg-1•min-1)
HR (beats•min-1)
30.37 ± 4.60
1.48 ± 0.22
167.90 ± 1.79
Note: Values are in mean ± SD. Age (years); height (centimeters, cm); weight (kilograms, kg); Body Fat
(percentage, %); absolute oxygen consumption at final stage of treadmill protocol (VO2; L•min-1); relative oxygen
consumption at final stage of treadmill protocol (VO2, mL•kg-1•min-1); heart rate (HR, beats•min-1).
Data Analysis
1) Sample size for the Brain Breaks® videos intervention was calculated using G-Power Version
3.1, repeated measures ANOVA with two research conditions (BB & CG) x 2 points (baseline,
and post). Using a power of 0.80, an 𝛼 of 0.05, and an effect size of 0.25, it was determined that
a minimum of 98 participants were required to test both main and interaction effects (Balasekaran
et al., 2021). Distribution of data for variables was assessed for normality (Skewness and Kurtosis
values were close to 0 and z-values that ranged between -1.96 to 1.96.).
2) Using a power of 0.80 and α level of 0.05 with an effect size of > 1.1, the sample size of the
second study determined that 10 participants were needed as adopted from Robertson et al.
(2001). Therefore, active, and healthy participants were randomly recruited from the university.
123
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
_________________________________________________________________________________
Results
1) There were significant main effects between groups for importance (p = 0.012), learning (p =
0.000), self-efficacy (p = 0.000), fun (p = 0.034) and fitness (p = 0.022) (Table 4). Effect sizes for
Group main effect were relatively small (η2 < 0.12) for all scales except Learning (η2 =0.23).
Time*Group interaction effects were significant for all APAS scales (p<0.05). Results also
indicated that female students had higher self-efficacy scores than male students in learning
curriculum subjects through video exercises (BB males: 3.76 ± 0.28 vs EG females: 3.54 ± 0.39,
p = 0.04) (Figure 2).
2) Participants were able to self-regulate their exercise intensity between OMNI RPE 4 and 6
during the 5v5 possession soccer game (Table 5). Results indicated significant positive correlation
between HR during field (field HR) and HR during treadmill (treadmill HR) at V pt (field HR:
161.94 ± 12.80 beats•min-1 vs. treadmill HR: 156.0.6 ± 12.25 beats•min-1, r = 0.79, p = 0.032);
field HR and OMNI RPE during treadmill (treadmill OMNI RPE) (field HR: 161.94 ± 12.80
beats•min-1 vs. treadmill OMNI RPE: 4.89 ± 0.93, r = 0.726, p = 0.027) (Tables 6 & 7). There
was also no significant difference between field HR and treadmill HR (field HR: 161.94 ± 12.80
beats•min-1 vs. treadmill HR: 156.0.6 ± 12.25 beats•min-1, p = 0.102). Their average HR is at
82.49% of their maximum HR (HRmax) at OMNI RPE 5 (S1) and 83.10% of their HRmax at OMNI
RPE 5 (S2), which also correlates to their Vpt.
Table 4. Descriptive Statistics and ANOVA Pre- and Post-test Results for Brain Breaks® Group
(BB; n = 48) and Control Group (CG; n = 65).
Variables
on
Group
physical activity
Benefits (F1)
Importance (F2)
Learning
(F3)
Self-efficacy (F4)
Fun (F5)
Fitness (F6)
Personal Best (F7)
CG
BB
CG
BB
CG
BB
CG
BB
CG
BB
CG
BB
CG
BB
Pre-test
Post-test
Time
Group
Time*Group
Mean ± SD
Mean ± SD
F
p
2
F
p
2
F
p
2
3.19 ± 0.55
3.06 ± 0.51
3.28 ± 0.61
3.29 ± 0.52
2.77 ± 0.78
2.65 ± 0.67
3.10 ± 0.60
3.02 ± 0.62
3.18 ± 0.58
3.17 ± 0.48
3.05 ± 0.73
2.97 ± 0.73
3.29 ± 0.65
3.20 ± 0.61
3.13 ± 0.64
3.61 ± 0.37
3.32 ± 0.60
3.74 ± 0.31
2.32 ± 0.88
3.64 ± 0.36
2.82 ± 0.74
3.62 ± 0.51
3.19 ± 0.66
3.58 ± 0.38
3.07 ± 0.69
3.65 ± 0.39
3.32 ± 0.63
3.66 ± 0.43
18.87
<0.001
0.15
3.86
0.052
0.03
29.29
<0.001
0.21
17.89
<0.001
0.14
6.49
0.012
0.06
12.57
0.001
0.10
9.35
0.003
0.08
32.55
<0.001
0.23
66.08
<0.001
0.37
4.38
0.039
0.04
14.89
<0.001
0.12
33.45
<0.001
0.23
13.70
<0.001
0.11
4.59
0.034
0.04
13.27
<0.001
0.11
25.92
<0.001
0.19
5.42
0.022
0.05
22.89
<0.001
0.17
11.59
<0.001
0.10
2.08
0.153
0.02
9.36
0.003
0.08
Note: Values are in mean ± SD. Brain Breaks® Group (BB); Control Group (CG). Significance set at
p<0.05.
124
Researches
_________________________________________________________________________________
Figure 2. Post-Self-efficacy Scores in Learning Curriculum Subjects through Video
Exercises of the Experimental Group for Both Genders.
Table 5 Heart Rate (HR) and OMNI Rate of Perceived Exertion (RPE) Results
for Field Sessions 1 and 2
Variables
Warm-Up
HR
RPE
Field Session 1 129.40
±2.30
11.24
0.68
Field Session 2 125.10 ± 7.402.10
0.57
Game
HR
RPE
±162.50
±4.90
14.69
0.99
±163.70 ± 8.925.00
0.47
Cool down
HR
RPE
±108.10
±1.40 ± 0.52
17.98
±108.20
±1.50 ± 0.52
11.56
Note: Values are in mean ± SD. Heart rate (HR, beats•min-1); rate of perceived exertion (RPE).
Table 6 Variables at Ventilatory Breakpoint (Vpt) during Treadmill Protocol
Variables at Ventilatory Breakpoint (Vpt) during Treadmill Protocol
VO2 (L•min-1)
1.39 ± 0.10
Speed (km•hr-1)
8.24 ± 0.90
RPE
4.89 ± 0.93
Note: Values are in mean ± SD for oxygen uptake (L•min-1); Speed (km•h-1); OMNI Rate of Perceived
Exertion (RPE)
125
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
_________________________________________________________________________________
Table 7 Significant Correlations between Heart Rate (HR) at Field, on Treadmill and OMNI
Rate of Perceived Exertion (RPE) on Treadmill at Ventilatory Breakpoint (Vpt)
HR Field Vpt
HR Treadmill Vpt
RPE Treadmill Vpt
HR Field Vpt
r = 0.709*
p = 0.032
r = 0.726*
p = 0.027
HR Treadmill Vpt
r = 0.709*
p = 0.032
r = 0.924*
p = 0.000
RPE Treadmill Vpt
r = 0.726*
p = 0.027
r = 0.924*
p = 0.000
-
* Indicates significant difference p<0.05.
Discussion
1) Evidence from this study supports the positive effect of Brain Breaks® videos with 3-5
minutes daily, 5 times a week for 10 consecutive weeks. Hence, students’ attitude towards PA has
significantly improved. These results coincide with other studies’ findings that investigated the
impact of Brain Breaks® videos conducted in other countries (Zhou et al., 2021; Bonnema,
Coetzee, Lennox, 2020; Hajar et al., 2019; Dinc, Uzunoz, Mok & Chin, 2019; Popeska et al., 2018;
Uzunoz, Chin, Mok, Edginton & Podnar, 2018; Glapa et al., 2018). These previous studies have
reported that short duration of PA or exercise carried out in the classroom were correlated to
improvement in students’ on-task behaviour and PA, while participating in Brain Breaks®
activities.
Utilising this online platform could assist students and teachers during long periods of continuous
lessons, which may lead to mental fatigue that could possibly reduce attention-span and focus
among students. These short PA breaks not only assist to increase students’ PA duration, it also
would help students and teachers to refocus for the next lesson or continue with the lesson.
2) In general, RPE is a non-invasive and easy tool to monitor and regulate as compared to
measuring VO2 and HR or taking blood lactate during exercise (Stoudemire et al., 1996). No
gender differences were discovered in RPE and physiological responses (Robertson, 2000).
Moreover, RPE increases as intensity increases and there is a high correlation between
physiological variables (percentage of HR (%HR) vs. percentage of maximal VO2 (%VO2max),
RPE vs. %VO2max, RPE vs. %HRmax)) (Robertson, 2000).
From study 2, results also revealed that there were no significant differences for HR between
field and laboratory settings with significant positive correlation for OMNI RPE between field
and laboratory settings (Table 7). Participants from study 2 were able to self-regulate their exercise
intensity of an average of OMNI RPE 5 during the games (Table 5). They were also able to self-
126
Researches
_________________________________________________________________________________
regulate their exercise intensity at OMNI RPE 1-3 during their warm-up and cool down with
lower HR (Table 5). This study also coincides with other studies using the range of OMNI RPE
4-6 for children and OMNI RPE 5-7 for adults to self-regulate their exercise intensity to exercise
within a safe training zone (Balasekaran et al., 2019; Roberston et al., 2001).
Conclusion
1) This study, along with previous studies, revealed that investing with just 3-5 minutes daily is
sufficient to improve students’ perception toward PA and this will subsequently lead students to
increase the duration of PA to meet the standard requirements. Hence, implementing this
interactive technology tool during the Singapore school system curriculum is easy to implement
and is readily accessible. This will benefit students in enhancing their holistic health both
physically and mentally.
2) Other studies, including study 2 have shown that exercising at Vpt improves performance and
reaps cardiovascular benefits. Vpt calculated from the treadmill run protocol is significantly
correlated to OMNI 4-6 on field settings as well. Recreational and elite athletes from soccer and
other similar team sports (e.g., hockey, netball, ultimate frisbee, basketball etc.) can use OMNI
RPE 4-6 to self-regulate their exercise intensity to allow them to train optimally and achieve
significant improvement in performance. Simultaneously, this will also help to reduce the risk of
sustaining injuries and prolong their involvement in PA and exercise. Furthermore, maintaining
exercise at such optimal intensities will lead to positive cardiovascular and peripheral adaptations
and through consistency, it will eventually lead to weight loss as well.
Overall, both studies have shown that technology can be a fun and effective way to incorporate
among children and youths to bring about health benefits. In addition, children, youths, and
adults can self-regulate their exercise at optimal intensity to prolong their exercise or PA routine.
This can help children, youths, and adults to enjoy exercise, promote exercise adherence and help
them to lead an active and healthy lifestyle.
References
American College of Sports Medicine (ACSM). (2014). American College of Sports Medicine
guidelines for exercise testing and prescription.
Balasekaran, G., Thor, D., Ng, Y. C., & Boey, P. (2022). A normalized rate of perceived exertion
at ventilatory breakpoint for different exercise modalities and production of exercise
intensity with self-regulation for Singapore children. The Journal of sports medicine and
physical fitness. (Preprint DOI: 10.23736/S0022-4707.22.13411-0)
Balaskearan, G., Govindaswamy, V.V., Lim J.Z., Boey, P., Ng, Y.C. (2021). Applied Physiology
Exercise Laboratory Manual. World Scientific.
127
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
_________________________________________________________________________________
Balasekaran, G.; Ibrahim, A.A.B.; Cheo, N.Y.;Wang, P.K.; Kuan, G.; Popeska, B.; Chin, M.-K.;
Mok, M.M.C.; Edginton, C.R.; Culpan, I.; Durstine J. L. (2021). Using Brain-Breaks® as a
Technology Tool to Increase Attitude towards Physical Activity among Students in
Singapore. Brain Sci. 11, 784.
Balasekaran, G., Govindaswamy, V. V., Loh, R. M. K., Ng, Y. C., Thor, D., Boey, P., & Lim, J.
(2019). Curricular Guide to Health-Fitness Applications in Physical Education Using the OMNI
Perceived Exertion Scale. Pearson Education South Asia Pte Ltd.
Balasekaran, G., Loh, M.K., Govindaswamy, V.V., & Robertson, R. J. (2012). OMNI Scale of
Perceived Exertion: mixed gender and race validation for Singapore children during cycle
exercise. European Journal of applied physiology, 112(10), 3533-3546
Balasekaran, G., Loh, M.K., Govindaswamy, V.V., & Cai, S. J. (2014). Omni Scale Perceived
Exertion responses in obese and normal weight male adolescents during cycle exercise. The
journal of sports medicine and physical fitness, 54(2), 186-196.
Bonnema, J.; Coetzee, D.; Lennox, A. (2020). Effect of a three-month HOPSports Brain Breaks®
intervention programme on the attitudes of Grade 6 learners towards physical activities
and fitness in South Africa. J. Physic. Educ. Sport, 20(1), 196-205.
Boone, J.E., Gordon-Larsen, P., Adair, L.S., Popkin, B.M. (2007). Screen time and physical
activity during adolescence: longitudinal effects on obesity in young adulthood. Int. J.
Behav. Nutr. Phys. Act. 4, 26.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Whole School, Whole Community, Whole Child
(WSCC). 2020. https://www.cdc.gov/healthyschools/wscc/index.htm (accessed on 12
January 2021)
Dinc, S.C.; Uzunoz, F.S.; Mok, M.M.; Chin, M.-K. (2019). Adaptation of the attitudes toward
physical activity scale for higher education students in Turkey. J. Educ. Learn. 8(3), 95-101.
Glapa, A.; Grzesiak, J.; Laudanska-Krzeminska, I.; Chin, M.K.; Edginton, C.R.; Mok, M.M.;
Bronikowski, M. (2018). The impact of brain breaks classroom-based physical activities on
attitudes toward physical activity in Polish school children in third to fifth grade. Int. J.
Environ. Res. Public. Health, 15(2), 368
Hajar, M.S.; Rizal, H.; Kueh, Y.C.; Muhamad, A.S.; Kuan, G. (2019). The effects of brain-breaks
on motives of participation in physical activity among primary school children in Malaysia.
Int. J. Environ. Res. Public. Health, 16, 2331.
Kuan, G.; Rizal, H.; Hajar, M.S.; Chin, M.K.; Mok, M.M.C. (2019). Bright sports, physical activity
investments that work: implement-ing brain breaks in Malaysia primary schools. Br. J.
Sports Med. 1-2.
Lewallen, T.C., Hunt, H., Potts‐Datema, W., Zaza, S., Giles, W. (2015). The whole school, whole
community, whole child model: A new approach for improving educational attainment and
healthy development for students. J. School Health. 85(11), 729-39.
Ministry of Education (MOE), Singapore. 2020. https://beta.moe.gov.sg/education-in-SG/
(accessed 12 January 2021)
Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MFA). Towards a Sustainable and Resilient Singapore. 2018.
https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/19439Singapores_Voluntar
y_National_Review_Report_v2.pdf. (Accessed on 2 November 2020).
128
Researches
_________________________________________________________________________________
Mok, M.M.C.; Chin, M.K.; Emeljanovas, A.; Mieziene, B.; Bronikowski, M.; LaudanskaKrzeminska, I.; et al. (2015). Psychometric properties of the attitudes towards physical
activity scale: a Rasch analysis based on data from five location. J. Appl. Meas. 16(4), 379400.
Popeska, B.; Jovanova-Mitkovska, S.; Chin, M.K.; Edginton, C.R.; Mok, M.M.C.; Gontarev, S.
(2018). Implementation of brain breaks® in the classroom and effects on attitudes toward
physical activity in a Macedonian school setting. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health. 15(6),
1127.
Rizal, H.; Hajar, M.S.; Muhamad, A.S.; Kueh, Y.C.; Kuan, G. (2019). The effect of brain breaks®
on physical activity behavior among primary school children: a transtheoretical perspective.
Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health, 16(21), 4283.
Robertson, R.J., Goss, F.L., Boer, N., Gallagher, J.D., Thompkins, T., Bufalino, K., Balasekaran,
G., Meckes, C., Pintar, J., Williams, A. (2001). OMNI scale perceived exertion at ventilatory
breakpoint in children: response normalized. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 33(11):1946-1952.
Robertson, R. J., Moyna, N. M., Sward, K. L., Millich, N. B., Goss, F. L., & Thompson, P. D.
(2000). Gender comparison of RPE at absolute and relative physiological criteria. Medicine
and science in sports and exercise, 32(12), 2120-2129.
Shields, M.K.; Behrman, R.E. (2000). Children and computer technology: analysis and
recommendations. Future Child. 10(2), 4-30.
Stoudemire, N.M., Wideman, L., Pass, K.A., McGinnes, C.L., Gaesser, G.A., Weltman, A. (1996).
The validity of regulating blood lactate concentration during running by ratings of
perceived exertion. Med Sci Sports Exerc 28:490–495
Uzunoz, F.S.; Chin, M.K.; Mok, M.M.; Edginton, C.R.; Podnar, H. (2018). The effects of
technology supported brain breaks on physical activity in school children. In: Dumon D,
Hofmann AR, Diketmuller R, Koenen K, Bailey R, Zinkler C, (Eds.). Passionately Inclusive:
Towards Participation and Friendship in Sport: Festschrift für Gudrun Doll-Tepper. Münster,
NY, USA: Waxmann Verlag GmbH, pp. 87–104.
Zhou, K.; He, S.; Zhou, Y.; Popeska, B.; Kuan, G., Chen, L.; et al. (2021). Implementation of
brain breaks in the classroom and its effects on attitude towards physical activity in Chinese
school setting. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public. Health, 18, 272.
129
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
_________________________________________________________________________________
130
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
The Relationship Between Attitudes and Participation Motivation
Among Undergraduate Students Towards Extra-Curricular
Activities During the Pandemic
Ngien-Siong Chin1 - Eng-Hoe Wee2 - Boon-Sian Teo1 - Arthur Ling Wei1 Dana Raja A/L Narayanasamy1 - Matheus Chin Yan Yu3
1
Institute of Teacher Education Batu Lintang Campus, Kuching, Sarawak, Malaysia
2
Tunku Abdul Rahman University College, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
3
SMK Sungai Maong, Kuching, Sarawak, Malaysia
e-mail: ngiensiong@gmail.com
Abstract
Attitudes and motivation have traditionally been the most influential factors in determining
physical activity (PA) involvement in physical education, sports, and extracurricular activities that
contribute to health and well-being. The study analyzed the attitudes and participation motivation
of 540 university students (17 to 23 years old) on extracurricular activities. Students' attitudes and
motivation were measured using the Attitude towards Physical Activity Scale (M-APAS: Chin &
Jeswenny, 2021) and Participation Activity and Leisure Motivation Scale-M (Kueh, Kuan, &
Morris, 2019). The research utilized Pearson's product-moment and multiple regression analysis.
The Pearson correlation between attitudes and participation motivation revealed a weak to strong
positive connection. In contrast, the regression analysis found that learning, competition,
appearance, affiliation, and physical health were the most significant predictors of BMI. The
findings revealed that both extrinsic and intrinsic forms of self-determination motivation have a
higher impact on the psychological elements of students' participation in extra-curricular activities.
Key words: Attitudes, Participation motivation, Undergraduate students, extra-curricular activities
131
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
The current pandemic has created a great deal of uncertainty regarding participation in physical
activities that are required for extra-curricular activities in schools and universities (Matias et al.,
2020; Finnerty et al., 2021). Physical activity (PA) and other extracurricular activities help to
establish self-regulation mechanisms that boost psychological and social elements of wellness,
health, and mental health (Guilmette et al., 2019). Sandford (2020) indicated that an estimated 4
billion people were socially isolated, which dramatically altered the PA patterns of people.
Although the World Health Organization (2019) advocated 150 minutes of moderate physical
activity per week for persons aged 18 to 64 to improve their mental and physical health, nearly
one-third of the population did not participate in sports to achieve these recommendations. This
also covers Malaysia, where 36.3% of individuals curtailed their physical activity and 30.7% gained
weight due to COVID-19 pandemic lockdowns (Chin et al., 2022). This is similar with Ali et al.
(2021) study, which concluded that approximately 95% of the participants’ time were spent on inhome obligatory and maintenance tasks, which negatively impacted their physical and social wellbeing. Prior to the pandemic, the physical activity level of students in higher education institutions
were low due to a heavy workload, assignments, exams, social and family obligations (Anuar et al.,
2021; Fagaras et al., 2015). Conversely, undergraduate students reported a low to moderate level
of physical activity (Balle et al., 2020; Galle et al., 2020) within the two years following the
pandemic.
Among the approaches that have demonstrated improvement in online learning is the
incorporation of online physical activity classes into school lessons, utilising digital platforms that
can increase students' physical activity. Due to the extraordinary problems posed by the COVID19 pandemic, the Malaysian education system has established a number of digital platforms, such
as the Digital Educational Learning Initiative Malaysia, in order to keep up with the worldwide
industry advances. Students in Malaysian schools and Institutions of Higher Education now have
access to interactive learning tools and resources that promote successful teaching and learning.
Consequently, the teaching of physical activity through various digital platforms and tools has
become a unique method as a feasible mechanism for achieving physical activity equity among
students (Webster et al., 2021). These digital technologies were intended to empower individuals
to engage in physical activity or exercise with greater initiative. During the unprecedented COVID19 pandemic, physical exercise is one of the major variables that can increase physical and mental
health (stress, anxiety, depression), reduce cardiovascular disease, and strengthen the control of the
immune system against infectious diseases (Pedersen & Saltin, 2015). Despite the fact that a
number of studies have demonstrated that psychological needs and attitudes are related with higher
levels of PA motivation and behaviour, the aftermath of COVID-19 tends to vary among
population groups with different demographic variables and characteristics. As the world has
nearly recovered from COVID-19, people, such as university students, will likely be motivated to
return to their typical levels of physical exercise. Comprehending the behaviour of students
towards PA after COVID-19 necessitates examining the limitations of understanding the
motivation and attitudes of university students towards PA after recovery from COVID-19. This
132
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
study examines to evaluate the relationship between undergraduate students' views and
involvement motivation during the pandemic.
Method
Participants
The participants were comprised of 540 undergraduates from the Institution of Higher Learning
in Sarawak, Malaysia. The participants consisted of 377 (69.8%) females and 163 (30.2%) males
between the ages of 17 to 19 years old (296) 54.8% and 20 to 23 (244) 45.2%. Before conducting
the research, permission and consent were sought from the Institute of Teacher Education Batu
Lintang Campus Ethics Committee and the participants. Participation in the study was anonymous
and voluntary, and participants' anonymity and confidentiality were guaranteed.
Measures
The Attitudes toward Physical Activity Scale in Malay version (M-APAS) (Chin & Jeswenny, 2021)
was used to assess an individual's attitudes, beliefs, and perceptions of self-efficacy towards physical
activity participation. The M-APAS was modified by Mok et al. from the Attitudes towards Physical
Activity Scale (2015). The M-APAS consisted of 35 items that are comprised of the following seven
factors: Benefits (6 items; e.g., Being physically active helps to relax me), importance (3 items; e.g.,
It is importance to spend time to be physically active), learning (4 items; e.g., I learned about
language through video exercise), self-efficacy (3 items; e.g., I know which is my favourite physical
activity in video exercise), fun (7 items; e.g., I feel stronger after physical activity), fitness (7 items;
e.g., I am confident with my flexibility), and personal best (5 items; e.g., I just do my personal best
in physical activity). The items were assessed on a 7-point scale ranging from 1 (Strongly Disagree)
to 7 (Strongly Agree). The subscales' internal consistency ranged from 0.71 to 0.92, and their total
reliability was 0.96, supporting the findings of Chin and Jeswenny's (2021) study on Malaysian
primary school pupils.
The Physical Activity and Leisure Motivation Scale in Malay version (PALMS-M: Kueh, Kuan, &
Morris, 2019) was utilised to assess the student's physical activity involvement motives. The
PALMS comprised of forty items, eight subscales with five items each, which are competition/ego
(e.g., Because I perform better than others), appearance (e.g., To lose weight, look better), others’
expectations (e.g., To manage medical condition), affiliation (e.g., Because I enjoy spending time
with others), physical condition (e.g., Because it keeps me healthy), psychological condition (e.g.,
Because it helps me relax), mastery (e.g., To improve existing skills), and enjoyment (e.g., Because
it’s fun). Items are assessed on a 5-point Likert scale, with 1 (strongly disagree) to 5 (strongly agree).
The internal consistency of the subscales ranged from 0.69 to 0.92, with an overall reliability of
0.95.
133
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Results
Table 1 Socio-Demographic Characteristics of the 540 Participants
Characteristics
Frequency
(N)
Percentage
(%)
163
377
30.2
69.8
296
244
54.8
45.2
338
202
62.6
37.4
91
357
73
16.9
66.1
13.5
19
3.5
406
134
75.2
24.8
248
223
27
42
45.9
41.3
5.0
7.8
Gender
Male
Female
Age group
17 – 19
20 – 23
Ethnicity
Malay
Non-Malay
Body Mass Index (BMI)
Underweight (≤ 18.49)
Normal (18.5 – 24.9)
Overweight (25.0 –
29.9)
Obese (30.0 – 34.9)
Frequency of Exercise Per
Week
1 – 3 times
4 – 6 times
Minutes Exercise
0 – 30 minutes
31 – 60 minutes
61 – 90 minutes
91 – 120 minutes
The demographic characteristics of the participants are shown in Table 1. 540 participants were
involved in the study, comprising of 163 (30.2%) males and 377 (69.8%) females. The age groups
categories showed that 296 (54.8%) of the participants were aged 17 – 19 years old while 244
(45.2%) were aged 20 – 23 years old. In terms of ethnicity, Malay accounted for 62.6% of the
population, followed by non-Malay accounted for 37.4%. According to Body Mass Index, 357
(66.1%) of the participants were in the normal weight category, followed by underweight category
with 91 (16.9%), overweight category with 73 (13.5%) and obese category with 19 (3.5%). Whereas,
in terms of the frequency of exercise, the majority of participants (75.2%) exercised 1 to 3 times
per week for 0 to 30 minutes on average (45.9%).
134
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Table 2 Mean, Standard Deviation and Reliability of M-APAS and PALMS-M
Variables
M-APAS
M
SD
Benefits
Importance
Personal Best
Fun
Fitness
Self-efficacy
Learning
PALMS-M
Physical Condition
Enjoyment
Psychological Condition
Mastery
Appearance
Affiliation
Competition/Ego
Others’ Expectations
4.39
4.23
4.23
4.18
3.89
3.85
3.48
0.54
0.59
0.65
0.64
0.73
0.72
0.87
4.54
4.35
4.32
4.31
4.07
4.04
3.55
2.78
0.57
0.65
0.63
0.66
0.82
0.76
0.84
0.79
α
.96
.87
.71
.89
.90
.92
.74
.89
.95
.92
.90
.89
.90
.86
.85
.80
.69
The mean, standard deviation and reliability of M-APAS and PALMS-M are shown in Table 2. For
M-APAS, the most crucial construct influencing students’ participation in physical activity was
benefits (4.39 ± 0.54), followed by importance (4.23 ± 0.59), personal best (4.23 ± 0.65), fun (4.18
± 0.64), fitness (3.89 ± 0.73), self-efficacy (3.85 ± 0.72) and learning (3.48 ± 0.87). The M-APAS
showed high consistency of 0.96, whereas the subscales’ alpha values for fitness, fun, personal best,
learning, benefits, self-efficacy and importance demonstrated high reliability of 0.92, 0.90, 0.89,
0.89, 0.87, 0.74, and 0.71, respectively. Whereas, for PALMS-M, physical condition (4.54 ± 0.57)
was the most crucial construct that influenced the students’ engagement in physical activity,
followed by enjoyment (4.35 ± 0.65), psychological condition (4.32 ± 0.63), mastery (4.31 ± 0.66),
appearance (4.07 ± 0.82), affiliation (4.04 ± 0.76), competition/ego (3.55 ± 0.84) and others’
expectations (2.78 ± 0.79). The internal consistency of the PALM-M was 0.95, with alpha
coefficients of 0.92, 0.90, 0.90, 0.89, 0.86, 0.85, 0.80, and 0.69 for physical condition, enjoyment,
mastery, psychological condition, appearance, affiliation, competition-ego, and others'
expectations, respectively.
135
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
The relationship between benefits, importance, learning, self-efficacy, fun, fitness, personal best,
competition-ego, appearance, others’ expectations, affiliation, physical condition, psychological
condition, mastery and enjoyment are shown in Table 3.
Table 3 Correlation between variables for M-APAS and PALMS-M
Variable BN
s
F
BNF
IMP
LRN
SE
F
FIT
PB
CE
APP
OE
AFF
PHYC
PSYC
MAS
ENJ
IMP LRN SE
F
.69** .44** .54** .74**
.45** .57** .77**
.48** .51**
.67**
-
FIT
.56**
.59**
.47**
.65**
.68**
-
PB
.64**
.68**
.43**
.62**
.75**
.69**
-
CE
.36**
.44**
.40**
.41**
.53**
.53**
.46**
-
APP
.39**
.39**
.30**
.37**
.46**
.42**
.49**
.61**
-
OE
.14**
.20**
.30**
.23**
.24**
.29**
.20**
.61**
.39**
-
AFF
.52**
.45**
.40**
.44**
.59
.50**
.53**
.58**
.43**
.34**
-
PHY
C
.64**
.64**
.33**
.56**
.66
.52**
.72**
.40**
.54**
.14**
.52**
-
PSY
C
.74**
.66**
.45**
.56**
.71**
.54**
.70**
.44**
.48**
.22**
.60**
.80**
-
MAS
.69**
.65**
.42**
.58**
.74**
.62**
.76**
.58**
.57**
.26**
.64**
.82**
.80**
-
ENJ
.74**
.70**
.42**
.60**
.78**
.63**
.76**
.50**
.50**
.18**
.64**
.81**
.85**
.87**
-
BNF = Benefits, IMP = Importance, LRN = Learning, SE = Self Efficacy, F = Fun, FIT = Fitness,
PE = Personal Best, CE = Competition-Ego, APP = Appearance, OE = Others’ Expectations,
AFF = Affiliation, PHYC = Physical Condition, PSYC = Psychological Condition, MAS =
Mastery, ENJ = Enjoyment
Note**. Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed)
Benefits was highly correlated with enjoyment (r =.74), fun (r = .74), and psychological condition
(r = .74) but moderately correlated with importance (r = .69), self-efficacy (r = .54), fitness (r =
.56), personal best (r = .64), affiliation (r = .52), physical condition (r = .64) and mastery (r = .69).
Benefits was weakly correlated with learning (r = .44), competition/ego (r = .36), appearance (r =
.39) and others’ expectations (r = .14). Importance was highly correlated with fun (r =.77) and
enjoyment (r = .70), yet moderately correlated with self-efficacy (r = .57), fitness (r = .59), personal
best (r = .68), mastery (r = .61), physical condition (r = .64), psychological condition (r = .66) and
mastery (r = .65). Importance was weakly correlated with learning (r = .45), competition/ego (r =
.44), appearance (r = .39), others’ expectations (r = .20), and affiliation (r = .45). Learning was
moderately correlated with fun (r = .51), whereas weakly correlated with self-efficacy (r = .48),
fitness (r = .47), personal best (r = .43), competition-ego (r = .40), appearance (r = .30), others’
expectations (r = .30), affiliation (r =.40), physical condition (r = .33), psychological condition (r =
.45), mastery (r =.42), and enjoyment (r = .42). Self-efficacy was moderately correlated with fun (r
= .67), fitness (r = .65), personal best (r = .62), physical condition (r = .56), psychological condition
(r = .56), mastery (r =.58), and enjoyment (r = .60), yet weakly correlated with competition-ego (r
= .41), appearance (r = .37), others’ expectations (r = .23) and affiliation (r = .44). Fun was highly
correlated with fitness (r = .68), personal best (r = .75), psychological condition (r = .71), mastery
136
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
(r = .74) and enjoyment (r = .78), but moderately correlated with competition –ego (r = .53),
affiliation (r =.59) and physical condition (r = .66). Fun was also weakly correlated with appearance
(r = .46) and others’ expectations (r = .24). Fitness was moderately correlated with personal best
(r = .69), competition-ego (r = .53), affiliation (r =.50), physical condition (r = .52), psychological
condition (r = .54), mastery (r = .62) and enjoyment (r = .63), yet weakly correlated with appearance
(r = .42) and others’ expectations (r = .29). Personal best was highly correlated with affiliation (r =
.53), physical condition (r = .72), psychological condition (r = .70), mastery (r =.76) and enjoyment
(r = .76) but weakly correlated with competition-ego (r = .46), appearance (r = .49), others’
expectations (r = .20). Competition-ego was moderately correlated with appearance (r = .61),
others’ expectations (r = .61), affiliation (r = .58), mastery (r = .58) and enjoyment (r = .50), whereas
weakly correlated with physical condition (r = .40) and psychological condition (r = .44).
Appearance was moderately correlated with physical condition (r = .54), mastery (r = .57) and
enjoyment (r = .50), yet weakly correlated with others’ expectations (r = .39), affiliation (r = .43)
and psychological condition (r = .48). Others’ expectations were weakly correlated with affiliation
(r = .34), physical condition (r = .14) psychological condition (r = .22), mastery (r = .26) and
enjoyment (r = .18). Affiliation was moderately correlated with physical condition (r = .52),
psychological condition (r = .60), mastery (r = .64) and enjoyment (r = .64). Physical condition was
highly correlated with psychological condition (r = .80), mastery (r = .82) and enjoyment (r = .81).
Psychological condition was highly correlated with mastery (r = .80) and enjoyment (r = .85).
Enjoyment was highly correlated with enjoyment (r = .87).
Table 4 Hierarchical Regression Analysis showed gender, age groups, benefits, importance,
learning, self-efficacy, fun, fitness, personal best, competition/ego, appearance, others’
expectations, affiliation, physical condition, psychological condition, mastery and enjoyment as
predictors of levels of BMI
β
t
p
Gender
Age Groups
-.03
-.04
-0.58
-0.85
.57
.39
Benefits
Importance
Personal Best
Fun
Fitness
Self-efficacy
Learning
Physical Condition
Enjoyment
Psychological Condition
Mastery
Appearance
Affiliation
Competition/Ego
Others’ Expectations
-.04
.07
-.06
-.06
-.06
-.003
.14
-.20
.04
-.08
.10
.38
-.12
.-.18
-.01
-0.53
1.02
-0.80
-0.63
-0.92
-0.05
2.67
-2.24
0.40
-0.82
1.00
6.64
-2.06
-2.44
-0.19
.60
.31
.43
.53
.36
.96
.008*
.026*
.69
.41
.32
< .001*
.04*
.015*
.85
Variables
Step 1
Step 2
* p < .05
137
R
.07
Adj. R2
.004
Δ Adj. R2
< .001
.35
.12
.09
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Table 4 shows the hierarchical multiple regression which assess the ability of fifteen control
measures (benefits, importance, learning, self-efficacy, fun, fitness and personal best,
competition/ego, appearance, others’ expectations, affiliation, physical condition, psychological
condition, mastery and enjoyment) to predict levels of BMI, after controlling for the influence of
gender and age groups. Preliminary analyses were evaluated to ensure no violation of the
assumptions of normality, linearity, multicollinearity, and homoscedasticity. Gender and age
groups were entered at Step 1, explaining 0.4%, F(2, 537) = 1.13, p = .33 of the variances in
perceived SEGAK. After entry of the benefits, importance, personal best, fun, fitness, self-efficacy,
learning, and physical condition, enjoyment, psychological condition, mastery, appearance,
affiliation, competition/ego, others’ expectations, and at Step 2 the total variance explained by the
model as a whole was 11.9 %, F(17, 522) = 4.15, p < .001. The two control measures explained
an additional 11.5% of the variance in BMI, after controlling for gender and age groups, R squared
change = .115, F change (15, 522) = 4.54, p < .001. In the final model, only five control measures,
learning (β = .14, p = .008, competition/ego (β = -.18, p = .015), appearance (β = .38, p < .001),
affiliation (β = -.12, p = .04), and physical condition (β = -.20, p = .026) were found statistically
significant predictor with BMI.
Discussion
During the pandemic period, the aim of this study was to investigate the relationship between
participation motivation and attitudes of university students toward extracurricular activities.
Positive factors of attitudes were found to be associated with self-determined participation
motivation that allow participants to be more aware of the positive impacts of extracurricular
activities in the form of PA and workouts on health and mental wellness. As fun was found to be
highly correlated with fitness, psychological condition, personal best, mastery, and enjoyment, it
suggests that a positive attitude toward fun will motivate students to engage in PA regardless of
the extrinsic value of PA.
The gratification in terms of fun and interest from the novelty of challenging PA and exercises
through digital platforms may have stimulated and increased their interest, enjoyment, and
adherence toward better health and PA programmes in the universities. The usage of digital
platforms for directing and aiding students to adapt their involvement and engagement in PA can
indirectly reduce the impact of restrictions during a pandemic. Rogers et al. (2008)'s study
supported the current findings whereby attitude factors, such as benefits, importance, personal
best, and fun, and physical condition, enjoyment, psychological condition, and mastery in
participation motivation were interconnected and related to motivating students to participate in
extracurricular activities. According to literature, students' BMI was mostly influenced by their
intrinsic learning attitude and extrinsic motivations for competition, beauty, affiliation, and physical
condition. These findings further indicates that both intrinsic and extrinsic elements are required
for extracurricular activity engagement by students.
138
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Conflicts of interest
The authors acknowledge that there were no financial and commercial benefits that can contribute
to any form of conflict of interest in the study.
References
Ali, M., de Azevedo, A. R.G., Marvila, M. T., Khan, M. I., Memon, A. M., Masood, F., Almahbashi,
N. M. Y., Shad, M.
K., Khan, M. A., Fediuk, R., Timokhin, R., Borovkov, A., & Haq,
I. U. (2021). The influence of COVID-19induced daily activities on health
parameters – A case study in Malaysia. Sustainability, 13(13), 7465.
https://doi.org/10.3390/su13137465
Anuar, A., Hussin, N. Z. M. H. @, Maon, S. N., Hassan, N. M., Abdullah, M. Z., Mohd, I. H., &
Sahudin, Z. (2021).
Physical inactivity among university students. International Journal of
Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences, 11(5), 356–366.
Balle, C., Konstantinus, I. N., Jaumdally, S. Z., Havyarimana, E., Lennard, K., Esra, R., Barnabas,
S. L., Happel, A., Moodie, Z., Gill, K., Pidwell, T., Karaoz, U., Brodie, E., Maseko, V.,
Gamieldien, H., Bosinger, S. E., Myer, L., Bekker, L., Passmore, J. S., & Jaspan, H. B. (2020).
Hormonal contraception alters vaginal microbiota and cytokines in South African
adolescents in a randomized trial. Nature Communications, 11(1), 1-16.
https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-020-19382-9
Chin, N. S., & Jeswenny, F. J. (2021). Goal content and attitudes toward physical activity among
primary school students during COVID-19 conditional movement control order. Asian
Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 1, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajsep.2021.09.005
Chin, Y. S., Woon, F. C., & Chan, Y. M. (2022). The impact of Movement Control Order during
the COVID-19 pandemic on lifestyle behaviours and body weight changes: Findings from
the MyNutriLifeCOVID-19 online survey. PLoS ONE, 17(1), e0262332.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal. pone.0262332 com/2020/04/02/coronavirus-ineurope-spain-com/2020/04/02/coronavirus-in-europe-spain-deaths-in-24-hou
(accessed 14 April 2020). deaths-in-24-hou (accessed 14 April 2020).
Fagaras, S.P., Radu, L.E., & Vanvu, G. (2015). The level of physical activity of university students.
Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences, (197), 1454–1457.Available at:
https://www.euronews.finement. Available at: https://www.euronews.
Finnerty, R., Marshall, S. A., Imbault, C., & Trainor, L. J. (2021). Extra-curricular activities and
well-being: Results from a survey of undergraduate university students during covid-19
lockdown restrictions. Frontiers of Psychology. 12, 1-14.
https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2021.647402
Galle, F., Sabella, E. A., Ferracuti, S., De Giglio, O., Caggiano, G., Protano, C., Valeriani, F., Parisi,
E. A., Valerio, G., Liguori, G., Montagna, M. T., Spica, V. R., Da Molin, G., Orsi, G. B., &
Napoli, C. (2020). Sedentary behaviors and physical activity of Italian undergraduate
students during lockdown at the time of COVID-19 pandemic. International Journal of
Environmental Research and Public Health, 17(17), 61-71.
139
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Guilmette, M., Mulvihill, K., Villemaire-Krajden, R., & Barker, E. T. (2019). Past and present
participation in extracurricular activities is associated with adaptive self-regulation of goals,
academic success, and emotional wellbeing among university students. Learning and Individual
Differences, 73, 8-15. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.lindif.2019.04.006
Kueh, Y. C., Kuan, G., & Morris, T. (2019). The Physical Activity and Leisure Motivation Scale: A
confirmatory study of the Malay language version. International Journal of Sport and Exercise
Psychology, 17(3), 250-265. https://doi.org/10.1080/1612197X.2017.1321029
Matias, T., Dominsji, F. H., & Marks, D. F. (2020). Human needs in COVID-19 isolation. Journal
of Health Psychology, 25(7), 871-882. https://doi.org/10.1177%2F1359105320925149
Mok, M. M. C., Chin, M. K., Chen, S., Emeljanovas, A., Mieziene, B., Bronikowski, M., & Phua,
K. W. (2015). Psychometric properties of the attitudes toward physical activity scale: A
Rasch analysis based on data from five locations. Journal of Applied Measurement, 16(4), 379400. now on lockdown as 90 countries call for con-now on lockdown as 90 countries call
for conPedersen, B. K., & Saltin, B. (2015). Exercise as medicine – Evidence for prescribing exercise as
therapy in 26 different chronic diseases. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports,
25(Suppl. 3), 1–72. https://doi.org/10.1111/sms.12581
Rogers, H., Morris, T., & Moore, M. (2008). A qualitative study of the achievement goals of
recreational exercise participants. The Qualitative Report, 13(4), 706-734.
Sandford, A. (2020). Coronavirus: Half of humanity now on lockdown as 90 countries call for
confinement.
https://www.researchgate.net/deref/https%3A%2F%2Fwww.euronews.com%2F2020%2
F04%2F02%2Fcorona virus-in-europe-spain-s-death-toll-hits-10-000-after-record-950new-deaths-in-24-hous-death-toll-hits-10-000-after-record-950-new-s-death-toll-hits-10000-after-record-950-newWebster, C. A., D’Agostino, E., Urtel, M., McMullen, J., Culp, B., Loiacono, C. A. E., & Killian,
C. (2021). Physical education in the COVID era: Considerations for online program delivery
using the comprehensive school physical activity program framework. Journal of Teaching in
Physical Education, 40(2), 327-336.
World Health Organization (WHO). (2019). Physical activity. https://www.who.int/newsroom/fact-sheets/detail/physical-activity
140
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
University Students' Lifestyle and Physical Activity during the
COVID-19 Pandemic
Jasna Kudek Mirošević
Faculty of Teacher Education, University of Zagreb, Croatia
e-mail: jasna.kudek@ufzg.hr
Abstract
The altered lifestyle and insufficient physical activity of students in the Republic of Croatian
studying under circumstances of the COVID-19 pandemic can have a negative effect on their
academic and health experiences. The overall low mood and health problems can be consequences
of the effects of isolation during the pandemic. Therefore, it is necessary to place greater focus not
only on psychological and mental consequences of the pandemic but on physical and kinesiology
activities and habits of young people as well, particularly owing to reduced socialization. The aim
of this research, within the framework of promoting mental health and a healthy lifestyle, is to
examine the degree of students’ agreement with the offered statements of their general mood and
lifestyle under the circumstances of the COVID-19 pandemic with particular emphasis on their
physical and kinesiology activity. For this purpose, a Questionnaire for students on coping with
emergency situations and circumstances brought upon the COVID-19 pandemic was prepared.
The questionnaire was distributed online to 153 students of the Faculty of Teacher Education in
Zagreb. Through quantitative analysis of frequencies, the questionnaire statements were
interpreted and grouped. The results show that students’ mood during the COVID-19 pandemic
was mostly negatively affected. They also indicate a presence of student awareness and expressed
need for physical activity in order to avoid increased negative moods. After online classes, students
do not have sufficient energy for physical activities in their free time. They assess conditions for
kinesiology activities as much worse during the pandemic, although students who were not
involved in kinesiology activities in the pre-pandemic time actually wanted to become involved in
some type of kinesiology activity. The results indicate that, in time leading to the post-pandemic
period, higher education institutions should provide possibilities for increased physical and
kinesiology activities along with making available effective counselling and guidance in order to
find adequate solutions for academic, health and career challenges caused by the COVID-19
pandemic.
Key words: COVID-19 pandemic, Mental health, Mood, Physical and kinesiology activities,
Students
141
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
The period during the COVID-19 pandemic has had a significant influence on all aspects of society,
including mental and physical health among the older population but also among children and
youth. Around the world, Croatia included, government pleas were manifested in form of demands
that people stay safe, i.e. stay at home, As a result measures of social distancing, which limited daily
activities, were introduced. For the working population, pupils, and students that meant that the
majority of their time (if not all) was to be spent without their ordinary, daily activities which take
place outside of their homes. Research conducted over the last two years indicate concern that the
measure of social distancing and quarantine can have implications on people’s behavior with
respect to physical activity (Papaioannou, Schinke, Chang, Kim, & Duda, 2020; Sallis, Adlakha,
Oyeyemi, & Salvo, 2020; Hall, Laddu, Phillips, Lavie, & Arena, 2021).
The World Health Organisation (WHO) (2020) defines physical activity as any physical movement
which is produced by muscles in the body and which requires energy consumption. Newell (1990),
and Hoffman (2005), according to Jurko, Čular, Badrić, and Sporiš, (2015), define physical activity
as intentional, voluntary movement directed towards reaching an identified goal. Kinesiology
activities are important for the exercise processes which aim to improve health and maintain body
characteristic, abilities and motor knowledge at a high level for as long as possible. From the point
of view of kinesiology, Prskalo (2007) emphasizes the importance of creating habits among children
and youth of proper use of free time dedicated to exercise and movement which should become
the primary task of education. In that sense, the same author points to the possibility of developing
a positive relationship towards physical exercise without which leading a healthy lifestyle in presentday, or in the future, is inconceivable. Moreover, it is well known that physical activity is useful for
people’s mental health in general. It enhances perception, self-confidence and self-respect (Fox,
1999). Piercy et al. (2018) state that regular physical activity has health benefits for every person
regardless of age, sex, race or ethnicity, and is recommended for children, adolescents, the elderly,
and for persons with chronic diseases and persons with disabilities. The WHO recommends,
among others, that children and youth with disabilities between the ages of 5 and 17 also need to
accumulate at least 150 minutes of physical activity of moderate to strong intensity per week
whenever that is possible. This can be also be recognized in the context of offering social support
to persons with disabilities. Wellbeing is also manifested in the reduced feeling of anxiety, lower
blood pressure, better sleep, better cognitive functions as well as in improved cardiorespiratory
condition, muscle strength and fewer symptoms of depression. Therefore, knowledge of efficient,
individualized ways of coping in such situations is of special significance (Folkman & Moskowitz,
2004; Folkman, 2011). What is more, studies have shown that physical condition in childhood can
later affect health and that adult persons as they grow old must maintain their condition at a certain
level. According to Piercy et al. (2018) it is recommended that children and youth work on muscle
and bone strength and do physical activities three or more days per week as physical activity can
improve not only their cardiorespiratory and muscle condition, cardio-metabolic health, bone
health, weight and cognition, but also lower the risk of depression. The benefit of regular physical
activity for youth, in addition to overall health and physical condition, is in lowering the risk of
142
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
developing numerous illnesses, mental difficulties and conditions. Therefore, physical activity,
health and quality of life are very closely linked. In that sense, it is important to maintain, on a daily
basis, physical activity as an important life habit.
In the context of altered conditions for physical activity, newest research suggest that people of all
age groups have significantly lowered their level of physical activity during the COVID-19
pandemic in comparison to the pre-pandemic time (Hossain, Sultana, & Purohit, 2020; Maugeri et
al., 2020; Theis, Campbell, De Leeuw, Owen, & Schenke, 2021), which, as a consequence, had a
negative effect on their mental health and wellbeing (Ammar, Trabelsi, & Brach, 2020). In that
context, measures of social distancing meant that young persons had fewer opportunities for being
physically active, especially if their activities were limited, such as going to the gym, group gettogethers, and other. Among the population, youth in particular, this changed way of life led to
changes in behavior, sleep regime and quality of life affecting mental health and reaction to stress
which, in the end, leads to insufficient social recourses which are important factors for young
persons’ resilience towards mental and health difficulties (Sehmi, Maughan, Matthews, &
Arseneault, 2019). For example, children and youth in risk groups, such as those with physical
disabilities and/or intellectual difficulties, are particularly susceptible to the effects of limitations
brought upon the COVID-19 pandemic. According to Fitzgerald, Stride, & Drury (2020) the
effects of reduced possibilities for kinesiology activities and directives regarding possibilities for
regular physical activity will, for those groups, most likely deeply affect their physical activity and
mental health in general. The Republic of Croatia observes trends which are similar to those in
developed countries such as decrease in activity with an increase in age and greater frequency of
eating disorders, therefore, it is important to observe trends and developments among young
persons (Bjelajac, Relja, & Stanić, 2010).
According to Piercy et al. (2018), Fröberg (2020) states that physical activity is of particular
importance for the wellbeing and mental health of children and youth. Yet, if public gyms, fitness
centers and public sports fields are closed due to forbidden public gatherings, young persons have
limited access to indoor and outdoor environments in which they used to be physically active (Lim
& Pranata, 2020). In line with this concern, one research showed that physical activity on a global
scale was reduced for more than 25% within 30 days of declaring the COVID-19 pandemic (Tison
et al., 2020 according to Fröberg, 2020). Along with the mentioned, research has shown numerous
psychological, social and neuroscientific effects of the COVID-19 pandemic and relating to that
direct and indirect psychological and social consequences which could affect mental health of
people, particularly children and youth, now and in the future. Some of the negative psychological
effects can be manifested as confusion, anger and posttraumatic stress symptoms (Brooks et al.,
2020). Holmes et al. (2020) place the COVID-19 pandemic in the context of increased prevalence
of mental health and the multidisciplinary approach and accordingly the need for cooperation
between different disciplines. According to the results of the SIDERAL Project – Social and
International Dimension of Education and Recognition of Acquired Learning (2021), during their academic
activities, students mostly felt frustrated, anxious, and bored. It may indicate that student wellbeing
with respect to the general situation during the COVID-19 pandemic could worsen. But, on the
143
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
other hand, it is positive that the results also showed that the frequency of happiness was average
and the frequency of undesired emotions such as hopelessness and shame was assessed as relatively
low.
Aim and research questions
The standpoints of the above-mentioned recent research along with research to date, indicate that
the benefits of physical and kinesiology activity for young people prior to and during the COVID19 pandemic were widely recognized and advocated in the promotion of healthy lifestyles such as
the importance of physical activity for improvement of mental health, better spirits and reduced
symptoms of depression, cognitive (mental) function and self-respect. Along that line of thought
and within the framework of promoting mental health and a healthy lifestyle, the aim of this
research is to examine the degree of students’ agreement with the offered statements of their
general mood and lifestyle under the circumstances of the COVID-19 pandemic with particular
emphasis on their physical and kinesiology activity.
The research poses two research questions:
• To what extent do students agree with the offered statements about their mood and lifestyle
during their study under circumstances of the COVID-19 pandemic?
• To what extent do students agree with the offered statements about their involvement in
physical and kinesiology activities under circumstances of the COVID-19 pandemic?
Methodology
Participants
The sample comprised 153 students of teacher education from the Faculty of Teacher Education,
University of Zagreb (M= 3.3%, F=96.7%) enrolled in the third (37.9%), fourth (39.2%) and fifth
(22.9%) year of study. Following ethical standards for conducting research, students participated
in the research by providing their informed consent. Students were informed and assured that the
research questionnaire which included questions regarding their general demographic data (sex and
year of study) were anonymous and that their personal data would not be sought. Furthermore, by
pursuing to complete the questionnaire they confirmed being informed regarding the research and
accepted participation.
Instrument and data collection procedure
For the purpose of this research the Questionnaire for students on coping with emergency situations and
circumstances brought upon the COVID-19 pandemic (further in text Questionnaire) was devised. The
research was carried out in the 2020/2021 academic year in an online environment. Upon creating
the online Questionnaire through Google forms, the participants received a link via study groups.
As the research was conducted in accordance with all ethical aspects of the research, the
144
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
participants were informed of the purpose and aim of the research, and they were guaranteed
anonymity and secrecy of their data, as well as the possibility to opt out of participation at any time.
They were asked to provide their opinions in the most spontaneous and honest manner. If they
did not want to share their opinions on some statements they were not obliged to do so.
The Questionnaire comprised two parts. The first part referred to participants’ socio-demographic
data (sex and year of study). The second part of the questionnaire comprised 30 statements for
which students express a certain degree of agreement with statements of their general mood and
lifestyle while studying under extraordinary situations and circumstances caused by the COVID-19
pandemic. For the purpose of this paper, 16 statements were extracted, i.e., variables which refer
to the degree of students’ agreement with statements of their mood and their lifestyle under
circumstances of the COVID-19 pandemic and their involvement in physical and kinesiology
activity during the COVID-19 pandemic. The degree of agreement with each statement was
marked on a four-degree Likert-type scale (1 – I entirely disagree, 2- I partly disagree, 3- I agree, 4I entirely agree).
Grouped items from the questionnaire were interpreted and argued by quantitative analysis of
frequencies in the following manner: The first group of items (Table 1) refers to the degree of
students’ agreement with statements of their mood and lifestyle while studying under circumstances
of COVID-19 pandemic; The second group of items (Table 2) refers to the degree of students’
agreement with statement regarding the extent to which they assess their involvement in physical
and kinesiology activities under circumstances caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. Based on the
grouped items from the Questionnaire on coping in emergency situations and circumstances caused by the
COVID-19 pandemic, along with their involvement in physical and kinesiology activities, the
distribution of frequencies was used. Data were calculated in percentages and presented in tables.
Results and discussion
Considering the applied quantitative methodology and the analysis of frequencies, Table 1 shows
the distribution of frequencies of results according to the degree of students’ agreement with the
offered statement of their lifestyle mood during their studies in pandemic conditions is shown.
The distribution of the frequencies of results according to the degree of students’ agreement with
the offered variables on their lifestyle mood during their studies in pandemic conditions (Table 1)
shows that students, considering both assessments I agree and I entirely agree, felt very tired and
exhausted prior to doing work for their studies (80.4%) and that they felt exhausted and tired after
online classes (62.5%). Over 50% of the participants entirely took steps and activities in line with
the examples provided to resolve the situation that led to their negative mood. Furthermore,
considering both opinions, I agree and I entirely agree, 53.9% of students needed more time to
entirely relax and feel better after online classes.
145
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Table 1 Distribution of frequencies of results – Mood and lifestyle during the (%) (N=153)
Variables
Some days I feel tired and exhausted before I start doing work for my
studies.
After online classes I need more time than I previously needed in
order to relax and feel better.
After online classes I usually feel exhausted and tired.
I feel energized while doing my assignments.
I usually quickly overcome difficult periods and stressful events.
I have a difficult time recuperating when something bad happens.
I’ve taken steps and activities in order to solve a situation which led
to my negative mood (e.g. I’ve planned how to avoid such a situation
in the future, tried to solve the problem through exercise).
I haven’t done anything in particular, nor did I exercise in order to
improve my mood.
1
4.6
2
3
4
15.0 30.1 50.3
20.4 25.7 27.6 26.3
11.8
17.1
11.8
27.0
13.7
25.7
44.7
34.2
42.8
30.7
31.6
28.3
34.9
19.1
27.5
30.9
9.9
19.1
11.1
28.1
47.8 29.4 16.3
6.5
Less than 40% of students felt energized while doing their assignments and 6.5% of students did
nothing in particular, nor did they exercise in order to improve their mood. In addition, taking into
account that another 16.3% of students agreed with this statement, a somewhat relatively worrying
number of students who do, in fact, nothing to improve their mood is get (22,8%). Opposite, from
the data mentioned, 47.8% students disagreed and partly disagreed 29,4% with the statement. It
can be assumed that those students were aware of their concern for themselves and their lifestyle
under such conditions and did not allow for total relaxation i.e. they try to find activities in order
to overcome the difficult periods and stressful events and they did something and exercise in order
to improve their mood.
Based on these findings, it can be also assumed that there is a presence of awareness among
students for seeking physical activity in order to prevent falling into greater negative moods. This
is supported by the statement in which students agreed that they usually quickly overcome difficult
periods and stressful events (a total of 54% of students both agree and entirely agree). Generally,
the mentioned may accounts for students' understanding that with the help of physical activity they
can achieve health and social aims. In this way they could avoid potentially engage in risky behavior
such as smoking, consumption of drugs, alcohol or irresponsible sexual behavior.
On the other hand, almost a third of the students (30.2%) agreed that they had a difficult time
recuperating when something bad happened.
Table 2 shows the distribution of frequencies of results according to students’ agreement with
statements of physical and kinesiology activities during the pandemic.
146
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Table 2 Distribution of frequencies of results – Physical and kinesiology activities of students
during the pandemic (%) (N=153)
Variables
After online classes I have enough energy for physical activities in my
free time.
I usually feel filled with energy when doing some form of physical
activity after classes.
I’ve participated in physical activities in order to improve my moods.
During the pandemic, my kinesiology activities were reduced.
Conditions for kinesiology activities are much worse than they were
before.
Kinesiology activities help me overcome this state.
I do kinesiology activities more than before as I have more time.
I don’t have possibilities for joining a sports activity due to the
COVID-19 pandemic.
1
2
3
4
18.3 37.9 28.8 15.0
7.2
20.3 32.0 40.5
10.5 27.4 32.0 30.1
24.2 24.2 23.5 28.1
17.1 27.0 27.6 28.3
11.1 28.8 30.0 30.1
27.3 29.4 27.0 16.3
37.3 32.6 18.3 11.8
The distribution of frequencies of results in Table 2 shows that only 37.3% of students entirely had
opportunities to participate in a sports activity during the pandemic i.e. they entirely disagreed with
statement I don’t have possibilities for joining a sports activity due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
On this occasion, no information was obtained whether they used those opportunities. The
remaining 32.6% of students partly agreed that they had those possibilities, while 30.1% students
did not have such possibilities.
More than 70% of students agreed that they usually feel filled with energy when engaging in
physical activities after classes, however only 15% of students entirely agreed that after online
classes they have sufficient energy for physical activity in their free time. Badrić and Prskalo (2011)
state that young people today are generally more prone to selecting activities which do not exert
any physical effort and owing to technological advancements they mostly spend their time passively
and using passive content. As the results presented in Table 1 show that students sought ways for
engaging in physical activity, more than 60% of students (Table 2) agreed that participated in
physical activities in order to improve their mood during the pandemic and more than 60% of
students agreed that kinesiology activities helped them overcome the pandemic situation.
Therefore, somewhat more than 43% of students engaged in kinesiology activities more than
before as they had more time. Furthermore, 56% of students agreed that the conditions for
kinesiology activities were much worse during the pandemic than they were in pre-pandemic times.
According to the results of the research conducted by Bjelajac, Relja and Stanić (2010) prior to the
pandemic, two thirds of the students participated in some form of sport or recreational activity
during their free time. This was mostly the case for men and those studying at technical, natural
science and biomedical faculties and the main reasons for engaging in recreational activity were
most frequently of individual nature (improving health, becoming fit, and improving looks), while
147
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
those of social nature (socializing and gaining new friendships) were less represented. Similar results
were observed in the estimation of benefits as the majority of students stated personal benefits and
a significantly lower number of students reported social benefits. However, these results indicate
that more than 50% of students agreed that their kinesiology activities were reduced during the
pandemic period.
Conclusion
Although the COVID-19 pandemic significantly disrupted continuity in education, particularly
how students study, and expanded inequalities, at the same time it pointed out new ways of teaching
and learning, new ways of communicating, and new roles with the aim of improving concern for
oneself and reflecting on possibilities for engaging in physical activities. With the research questions
which were directed to students’ opinions, the aim of this research was to examine the degree of
students’ agreement with the offered statements of their general mood and lifestyle under
circumstances caused by the COVID-19 pandemic with emphasis on their physical and kinesiology
activity. The research was devised within the framework of promoting mental health and a healthy
lifestyle. The results point to a pronounced concern and awareness students have about their
deteriorating mood and general wellbeing and on the altered way of life. However, although
generally having a low mood, being exhausted and tired from online classes, the results show that
students gained valuable experiences and a will for engaging in physical activity in order to improve
the general mood and this can be valuable in process of planning kinesiology programs and
activities during their course of study. What is more, the results show that students sought ways
and were motivated for doing physical activity and because of that the opportunity for action
should not be wasted. That calls for planning processes which continuously assess the situation,
plan for solving inequalities, encourage participation in physical and kinesiology activities and assess
and evaluate practice in order to be more successful and in order to maintain and pursue those
practices which proved successful for the mental health of young people. Furthermore, that
assumes that student organizations should also reach out to their members and contribute to
strengthening social relationships between colleagues, particularly during times of crisis (Doolan et
al., 2021). In that context it is necessary to develop institutional resilience in higher education and
pay attention to the mental health of students, with special focus on observing the effects on
students of vulnerable health or those in vulnerable groups.
Finally, it is important to emphasize that the interpretation of the results requires caution in
concluding. The limitation is mainly represented in. double-barreled statements (positive and
negative) which can lead to misinterpretation by the participants.
References
Ammar A., Trabelsi K., & Brach M. (2020). Effects of home confinement on mental health and
lifestyle behaviours during the COVID-19 outbreak: Insight from the ECLB-COVID19
multi center study. Biology of Sport, 38(1), 9-21.Retrieved on 26.2.2022. from
148
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/343473575_Effects_of_home_confinement_on
_mental_health_and_lifestyle_behaviours_during_the_COVID19_outbreak_Insight_from_the_ECLB-COVID19_multicenter_study
Badrić, M., & Prskalo, I. (2011). Participiranje tjelesne aktivnosti u slobodnom vremenu djece i
mladih. Napredak, 152(3-4), 479-494.
Bjelajac, S., Relja, R., & Stanić, S. (2010). Tjelesna aktivnost i zdrav način života kod studenata. In:
Plenković, M. (Ed.), Društvo i tehnologija (p. 150-160). Zagreb: Hrvatsko komunikološko
društvo i Nonacom.
Brooks, S. K., Webster, R. K., Smith, L. E., Woodland, L., Wessely, S., Greenberg, N., & Rubin,
G. J. (2020). The Psychological Impact of Quarantine and How to Reduce It: Rapid Review
of the Evidence. The Lancet, 395, 912-920. Retrieved on 26.2.2022. from
https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(20)30460-8/fulltext
Doolan, K. et al. (2021). Student life during the COVID-19 pandemic lockdown:
Europe-wide insights. Brussels: European Students’ Union. Retrieved on 26.2.2022. from
https://www.esu-online.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/0010-ESUSIderalCovid19_WEB.pdf
Fitzgerald, H., Stride, A., & Drury, S. (2020). COVID-19, lockdown and (disability) sport. Managing
Sport and Leisure, 1-8. Retrieved on 25.2.2022. from
https://doi.org/10.1080/23750472.2020.1776950
Folkman S. (2011). Stress, health, and coping: synthesis, commentary, and future directions. In:
Folkman, S., (Ed.), The Oxford Handbook of stress, health, and coping. Oxford: Oxford University
Press.
Folkman, S., & Moskowitz, J. T. (2004). Coping: Pitfalls and Promise. The Annual Review of Psychology,
55, 745-774.
Fox, K. R. (1999). The influence of physical activity on mental well-being. Public Health Nutrition,
2, 411–418.
Fröberg, A. (2020). How children and young people can stay physically active during the novel
coronavirus pandemic while take into account safety measures and precautions. Health
promotion perspectives, 10(4), 295–299. Retrieved on 26.2.2022. from
https://doi.org/10.34172/hpp.2020.47
Hall, G., Laddu, D. R., Phillips, S. A., Lavie, C. J., & Arena, R. (2021). A tale of two pandemics:
How will COVID-19 and global trends in physical inactivity and sedentary behavior affect
one another? Progress in Cardiovascular Diseases, 64, 108-110. Retrieved on 26.2.2022. from
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32277997/
Holmes, E. A., O'Connor, R. C., Perry, V. H., Tracey, I., Wessely, S., Arseneault, L., Ballard, C.,
Christensen, H., Cohen Silver, R., Everall, I., Ford, T., John, A., Kabir, T., King, K., Madan,
I., Michie, S., Przybylski, A. K., Shafran, R., Sweeney, A., Worthman, C. M., …& Bullmore,
E. (2020). Multidisciplinary research priorities for the COVID-19 pandemic: A call for action
for mental health science. The Lancet Psychiatry, 7(6), 547–560. Retrieved on 16.2.2022. from
https://doi.org/10.1016/S2215-0366(20)30168-1
Hossain, M. M., Sultana, A., & Purohit, N. (2020). Mental health outcomes of quarantine and
isolation for infection prevention: a systematic umbrella review of the global evidence.
149
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Epidemiology
and
Health,
42.
Retrieved
on
26.2.2022.
from
https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Mental-health-outcomes-of-quarantine-andisolation-Hossain-Sultana/11ec48d23451f072a34eeead153a19a5663a0247
Jurko, D., Čular, D., Badrić, M., & Sporiš, G. (2015). Osnove kineziologije. Split: Sportska knjiga,
Gopal d.o.o.
Maugeri, G., Castrogiovanni, P., Battaglia, G., Pippi, R., D'Agata, V., Palma, A., Di Rosa, M., &
Musumeci, G. (2020). The impact of physical activity on psychological health during
COVID-19 pandemic in Italy. Heliyon, 6(6), e04315.
Lim, M. A., & Pranata, R. (2020). Sports activities during any pandemic lockdown. Irish Journal of
Medical Science, 1-5.
Papaioannou, A. G., Schinke, R. J., Chang, Y. K., Kim, Y. H., & Duda, J. L. (2020). Physical activity,
health and well-being in an imposed social distanced world. Journal of Sport and Exercise
Psychology, 18(4), 414-419.
Piercy, K. L., Troiano, R. P., Ballard, R. M., Carlson, S. A., Fulton, J. E., Galuska, D. A., George,
S. M., & Olson, R. D. (2018). The physical activity guidelines for Americans. JAMA, 320(19),
2020-2028. Retrieved on 26.2.2022. from https://yellowbrickprogram.com/wpcontent/uploads/2021/07/The-Physical-Activity-Guidelines-for-Americans.pdf
Prskalo, I. (2007). Kineziološki sadržaji i slobodno vrijeme učenica i učenika mlađe školske dobi.
Odgojne
znanosti,
9(2
(14)),
161-173.
Retrieved
on
24.2.2022.
from
https://hrcak.srce.hr/23551
Sallis, J. F., Adlakha, D., Oyeyemi, A., & Salvo, D. (2020). An international physical activity and
public health research agenda to inform coronavirus disease-2019 policies and practices.
Journal of Sport and Health Science, 9(4), 328-334. Retrieved on 27.2.2022. from
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32450160/
Sehmi, R., Maughan, B., Matthews, T., & Arseneault, L. (2020). No man is an island: Social
resources, stress and mental health at mid-life. The British Journal of Psychiatry, 217(5), 638-644.
doi:10.1192/bjp.2019.25
Theis, N., Campbell, N., De Leeuw, J., Owen, M., & Schenke, K. C. (2021). The effects of COVID19 restrictions on physical activity and mental health of children and young adults with
physical and/or intellectual disabilities. Disability and health journal, 14(3), 101064. Advance
online publication. Retrieved on 10.2.2022. from
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dhjo.2021.101064
Tison, G. H., Avram, R., Kuhar, P., Abreau, S., Marcus, G. M., Pletcher, M. J., & Olgin, J. E. (2020).
Worldwide Effect of COVID-19 on Physical Activity: A Descriptive Study. Annals of internal
medicine, 173(9), 767-770. Retrieved on 27.2.2022. from https://doi.org/10.7326/M20-2665
World Health Organisation (2020). Physical Activity and Young People. Geneva: World Health
Organisation. Retrieved on 2.2.2022. from
https://www.who.int/dietphysicalactivity/factsheet_young_people/
150
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
The Application of Transtheoretical Model (TTM) of Behavioural
Change Among Malaysian Undergraduate Trainee Teachers
towards Physical Activity
Pei-Yi Ting1 - Ngien-Siong Chin2 - Garry Kuan1 - Yee-Cheng Kueh3 - BoonSian Teo2 - Ting-Len Lim1
1
School of Health Sciences, Universiti Sains Malaysia, Kubang Kerian, Kelantan, Malaysia
2
Institute of Teacher Education Batu Lintang Campus, Sarawak, Malaysia
3
School of Medical Sciences, Universiti Sains Malaysia, Kubang Kerian, Kelantan, Malaysia
e-mail: ngiensiong@gmail.com
Abstract
The study investigated the transtheoretical model among Malaysian undergraduate trainee teachers.
The questionnaires for decisional balance (Plotnikoff et al.,2001); self-efficacy scale (Rizal et
al.,2019) and processes of change (Rizal et al.,2019) were completed by 450 participants including
132 males (29.3%) and 318 females (70.7%) aged between 17 – 22 years old. The results revealed
a significant difference in pros and cons for decisional balance; situational and competing demands
for self-efficacy; consciousness-raising, counterconditioning and stimulus control for processes of
change among gender. Based on the age groups, the results revealed significant difference in
reinforcement management, self-reevaluation, social liberation, consciousness-raising and in
processes of change among age groups. Finally, no statistically significant difference was found
between ethnicities for decisional balance, self-efficacy, and processes of change. The trainee
teachers need to lead as societal leaders in PA as exemplars of a healthy lifestyle to advocate and
articulate the values of PA among the school students to adhere and maintain a healthy lifestyle in
the long run.
Key words: Transtheoretical model, Trainee teachers, Physical activity
151
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
The increase in obesity prevalence among the Malaysian population is a reflection of the fall in
physical inactivity which is one of the commonly known non-communicable diseases. The
Malaysian National Health and Morbidity Surveys (NHMSs) showed that obesity and overweight
prevalence among adults ranged from 29.4% (2011) to 30% (2015) and 15.1% (2011) to 17.7%
(2015), respectively. In contrast, 15.2% and 13.35% of secondary school students aged 13 to 17
were overweight and obese respectively. Malaysia has the highest overweight and obesity rate
among adults in Asia with the second-highest child obesity prevalence among children between 5
to 9 years old and 7.1% of kids under the age of 5 were overweight. This shows that the Malaysian
government’s efforts to tackle the obesity and overweight epidemic have not been successful. The
drop-in physical activity is most pronounced between youth (15-19 years) and young adulthood
(20-25 years), placing students in a high-risk group (Han et al., 2017; Jahan et al., 2017; Liu et al.,
2018; Wallace et al., 2000). As a result, there is a need to educate children and adolescents in
schools about good food and physical activity as these youngsters may face a variety of noncommunicable diseases (diabetes, heart disease) as adults in the future.
Inculcating trainee teachers to engage in physical activities amongst themselves is a crucial aspect
of the Institute of Teacher Education Campuses in Malaysia. PE in schools did not significantly
contribute to health and wellness outcomes, as evidenced by Malaysia's obesity and overweight
prevalence over the years. It implied the seriousness in considering alternatives to physical
education because PE is not as effective at encouraging kids to engage in physical activities as part
of a healthy lifestyle. The low adherence of teachers and school administrators to implement daily
20 of continuous, moderate-intensity exercise, as well as the poor quality of physical education
(PE) programmes, have been a problem (Allison et al., 2016; Bremer et al., 2018; Donnelly et al.,
2017; Olstad et al., 2015). According to the teachers’ health and physical activity review, RosalesRicardo et al. (2017) discovered that the majority of university professors exhibited sedentary
behaviours that led to their obesity and overweight status. Kee (2013) discovered that more than
a third of trainee teachers were actively involved in PA, while more than half were mildly involved
in PA. The identification of PA behaviours among trainee teachers can facilitate the design of
more effective health education programmes in the Institute of Teacher Education Campuses.
The transtheoretical model (TTM) is one of the integrated theories utilised in evaluating PA and
health related behaviour studies. The TTM approach examines people's preparedness to change
their behaviour and develops treatments to help them change via five phases of motivational
readiness, resulting in the desired behaviour change (Han et al., 2017; Prochaska & DiClemente,
1983). The stages of change (SOC), self-efficacy, decisional balance (DC), and change processes
make up the TTM (POC). The main construct is the stage of change, which includes
precontemplation, contemplation, preparation, action, and maintenance. Individuals begin by
intending to adopt the behaviour criteria in the precontemplation, contemplation, and preparation
stages before eventually adopting and maintaining the desired acquired behaviour in the action and
maintenance stages (Prochaska & Velicer, 1997; Romain et al., 2018). As they progress through
the stages, people might employ a variety of methods to enhance or adapt their behaviour.
Processes of change (POC), decisional balance (DB), and self-efficacy are the other three
152
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
intervening constructs (SC). The ten POC are linked in promoting movement between lower
stages (1-3) involving cognitive and affective processes and upper stages (4-5) focusing on
behavioural processes, although DC (evaluating the benefits and drawbacks of altering) and SE
have an influence on the process (Laranjo, 2016). The DC's goal was to enhance participation in
PA, sports, and exercise by balancing the benefits and drawbacks of changing or adopting the
targeted behaviour. Individuals in any of the stages of change may have a different DC, with the
benefits of embracing change outweighing the disadvantages in the stages of action and
maintenance. Self-efficacy is known as one’s level of confidence, which is reflected in one’s selfbeliefs as one move through the phases (Marcus et al., 1992). The TTM demonstrated that lower
levels of self-efficacy were linked to lower stages of change, in which the disadvantages outweigh
the benefits (Dziedzic & Hammond, 2010). On the contrary, self-efficacy levels were correlated
with behaviour performance levels whereby the benefits exceed the disadvantages.
Studies had shown that sedentary students lack the necessary psychological factor to motivate
them to change their behaviour through physical activities, sports, and exercise in order to maintain
an active lifestyle. Several studies on PA and physical activities demonstrated the applicability of
the TTM Model (Cengiz, 2007; Kee et al., 2010). Higher education students would be able to
increase their knowledge of PA processes of change if they had a deeper understanding of TTM
studies. Kee et al. (2010) discovered that 22.8% of Malaysian secondary school students engaged
in physical activity at the action or maintenance stage, whereas only 63.2% engaged in physical
activity occasionally. In terms of gender, previous research (Cengiz, 2007; Spencer et al., 2006)
determined that a greater proportion of male students were in the action and maintenance stage
than female students, whereas a greater proportion of female students were in the precontemplation, contemplation, and preparation stages. This was supported by Ebem (2007), who
found that a slightly greater proportion of male students than female students were in the action
and maintenance stage, despite the fact that the majority of students were in the pre-contemplation,
contemplation, preparation, action and maintenance stages. However, Ebem's (2007) study also
revealed that a large proportion of males and females were in the pre-contemplation,
contemplation, and preparation stages. In addition, the majority of college students tend to be in
the pre-contemplation, contemplation, and preparation stages, possibly as a result of their
demanding schedules and workloads (Cengiz, 2007; Kocak, 2005; Spencer et al., 2006). The
application of the TTM among undergraduate trainee teachers is essential for institutions to
identify which stages of health and mental well-being the trainee teachers may be in as they
transition from secondary education to the Institute of Teacher Education due to their demanding
workload, academic assignments, and schedules. These TTM mechanisms enable interventions to
support their mental health and well-being through participation in physical activities and exercises
during leisure time.
There are limited studies utilising the TTM on trainee teachers in PA in which TTM studies need
to undertake to better understand the behavioural change of trainee teachers when modifying their
health behaviour to maintain an active lifestyle as they enter the Institute of Teacher Campuses.
Thus, this study examined the first-year trainee teachers’ physical activity decisional balance, selfefficacy and process of change.
153
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Method
Participants
A total of 450 first-year undergraduate trainee teachers from one Institute of Teacher Education
campus in Sarawak, Malaysia involved in the study. The participants comprised 450 first-year
undergraduate trainee teachers from one Institute of Teacher Education Campus in Sarawak,
Malaysia. There were 132 males (29.3%) and 318 females (70.7%) among the participants, with
nearly half (48.4%) of them being between the ages of 17 and 22 years (1.72 ± 0.78). In terms of
ethnicity, a higher proportion of participants were Malay (63.1%) as compared to the Non-Malay
(36.9%). Whereas, the BMI classifications revealed that 65.6% of the participants have a normal
BMI, 16.4% underweight, 14.0% overweight, and 4.0% obese. The participants' average weekly
exercise frequency was 1.72 (SD=0.78) minutes, with each session lasting between 0 and 30
minutes.
Measures
The Malay version of TTM questionnaires (Rizal, Hajar, Kueh, Muhamad & Kuan, 2019) was
utilised which measures constructs of processes of change (stages of change, processes of change,
decisional balance and self-efficacy). Rizal et al. (2019) suggested that the TTM questionnaires be
administered to a broader population in order to generalise the validated Malay version of the
questionnaires.
Decisional balance questionnaire
The decisional balance questionnaire (Plotnikoff et al., 2001) was used to assess the positive (pros)
and negative (cons) elements of the perceived significance of altering physical activity. The 10-item
questionnaire was scored on a 5-point Likert scale from 1 (not at all) to 5 (extremely). Participants
were asked to rate the significance of each statement in relation to their decision to be physically
active or inactive during their leisure time (Kee, 2013; Rizal et al., 2019). The scales of pros and
cons were independently analysed to indicate the positive and negative aspects of behavioural
change in individuals. The mean scores of the five pro items and the five con items were computed
by adding the responses of the participants to the ten pro items and the six con items separately
and dividing by the number of items.
Self-efficacy questionnaire
The self-efficacy questionnaire (Bandura, 1997; Kim, 2007; Rizal et al., 2019) was a three-factor,
13-item scale that measured participants' situational confidence in the certainty of performing their
exercise routine consistently and regularly (three times per week), i.e. internal feeling (5 items),
competing demand (4 items), and situational confidence (4 items). Participants responded on a 5point Likert scale ranging from 1 (not at all confident) to 5 (completely confident) for each of 18
items corresponding to a given statement. Internal reliability for conflicting demands was 0.60,
internal feeling it was 0.74, and situational was 0.80. (Liu et al., 2018).
154
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Processes of change questionnaire
The processes of change questionnaire (Rizal et al., 2019; Nigg et al., 1999) was used to examine
the cognitive (covert) and behavioural (overt) actions that individuals employ as they proceed
through the many stages of change. The 30-item questionnaire, scored on a 5-point Likert scale
ranging from 1 (not at all) to 5 (extremely), represented ten processes with the most empirical
support, including the five main factors of cognitive processes (consciousness raising, dramatic
relief, environmental re-evaluation, self-re-evaluation, social liberation, and stimulus control) and
the five main factors of behavioural processes (counter-conditioning, helping relationships,
reinforcement management, self-liberation and stimulus control). There were a minimum of three
statements for each process, with the participant selecting the relevant column to indicate the
degree of response. The ten processes of change were assessed independently, and the mean scores
for each process of change were computed by adding the responses to each process of change
separately and dividing by the number of questions (Kee, 2013). Cognitive processes had an
internal reliability of 0.84, while behavioural processes had an internal reliability of 0.87, indicating
strong internal consistency.
Ethics
The Universiti Sains Malaysia Human Research Ethics Committee (USM/JEPeM/21050369)
approved the study in conformity with the International Declaration of Helsinki. All participants
were informed of the study's goal, voluntariness, anonymity, and confidentiality, and their consents
were acquired. The study was undertaken when schools reopened in January 2022 in accordance
with the regular operating protocols of the Malaysian Ministries of Health and Education.
Data analysis
The data was analysed using version 27.0 of the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS).
The gender and age categories of the TTM variables were examined using descriptive statistics,
independent sample t-tests, and one-way analysis of variance.
Results
Table 1 shows the demographic characteristics of the participants. A total of 450 participants were
involved in this study, 132 (29.3%) males and 318 (70.7%) females. The age groups categories
showed that 218 (48.4%) of the participants were 17 – 18 years old, 139 (30.9%) were 19 – 20
years old, and 93 (20.7%) were 21 – 22 years old. In terms of ethnicity, Malay formed the largest
percentage with 63.1%, followed by Non-Malay who comprised of 36.9%. Based on the Body
Mass Index (BMI), the majority of the participants were in normal weight category with a total of
295 (65.6%), followed by underweight category with 74 (16.4%), overweight category with 63
(14.0%) and obese category with 18 (4.0%). Whereas, in terms of the frequency of exercise, a high
percentage of the participants exercise 1 to 2 times (48.9%) a week averaging between 0 to 30
minutes (47.8%).
155
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Table 1 Demographic Characteristics of the 450 Participants
Characteristics
Frequency
(N)
Percentage
(%)
Gender
Male
Female
Age group
17 – 18
19 – 20
21 – 22
Ethnicity
Malay
Non-Malay
Body Mass Index (BMI)
Underweight
(≤
18.49)
Normal (18.5 – 24.9)
Overweight (25.0 –
29.9)
Obese (30.0 – 34.9)
Frequency of exercise per
week
1 – 2 times
3 – 4 times
5 – 6 times
7 times
Minutes per session
0 – 30 minutes
31 – 60 minutes
61 – 90 minutes
91 – 120 minutes
Mean (SD)
1.71 (0.46)
132
318
29.3
70.7
1.72 (0.78)
218
139
93
48.4
30.9
20.7
1.37 (0.48)
284
166
63.1
36.9
1.56 (0.88)
74
16.4
295
63
65.6
14.0
18
4.0
1.68 (0.78)
220
165
54
11
48.9
36.7
12.0
2.4
1.73 (0.89)
215
177
21
37
47.8
39.3
4.7
8.2
Table 2 shows the independent sample t-test of decisional balance scale, self-efficacy scale and
processes of change scale based on gender. The results revealed statistically significant difference
for decisional balance scale in pros scores whereby the males (3.86 ± 0.58) rated 0.13 point higher
than the females (3.73 ± 0.52), p = .019. Besides, cons were significant difference between gender
whereby the males (3.32 ± 0.81) rated 0.25 point higher than the females (3.07 ± 0.68), p = .002.
Whereas, for self-efficacy scale, the results revealed no statistically significant difference in internal
feelings scores between gender, p = .07. Conversely, competing demands was significant difference
between gender whereby the males (3.26 ± 0.77) rated 0.23 point higher than the females (3.03 ±
0.71), p = .002. Moreover, situational was significant difference between gender whereby the males
(3.13 ± 0.77) rated 0.16 point higher than the females (2.97 ± 0.81), p = .049.
156
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Table 2 Independent T-Test of Decisional Balance Scale, Self-Efficacy Scale and Processes
of Change Scale based on Gender
Variables
Decisional Balance Scale
(DBS)
Pros
Cons
Self-Efficacy Scale
Internal feelings
Competing demands
Situational
Processes of Change Scale
Consciousness Raising
Dramatic Relief
Environmental Reevaluation
Self-Reevaluation
Social Liberation
Counterconditioning
Helping Relationships
Reinforcement Management
Self-Liberation
Stimulus Control
Male
M
SD
Female
M
SD
t-test
t
p
3.86
3.32
0.58
0.81
3.73
3.07
0.52
0.68
2.35
3.17
.019*
.002*
3.23
3.26
3.13
0.67
0.77
0.77
3.10
3.03
2.97
0.70
0.71
0.81
1.82
3.05
1.98
.07
.002*
.049*
3.76
3.58
3.73
3.73
4.09
3.60
3.82
3.95
3.98
3.44
0.76
0.80
0.84
0.84
0.73
0.69
0.86
0.75
0.73
0.89
3.41
3.53
3.81
3.81
4.11
3.31
3.86
3.99
3.86
3.03
0.90
0.77
0.77
0.77
0.72
0.90
0.94
0.77
0.76
0.99
4.19
0.69
-0.97
-0.28
0.32
4.99
-0.45
-0.49
1.51
4.04
< .001*
.49
.33
.78
.75
< .001*
.65
.63
.13
< .001*
In addition, for processes of change Scale, an independent-samples t-test was conducted to
compare the cognitive processes (consciousness raising, dramatic relief, environmental
reevaluation, self-reevaluation, social liberation), and behavioral processes (counterconditioning,
helping relationships, reinforcement management, self-liberation and stimulus control) scores for
males and females. Results revealed statistically significant difference in consciousness raising
scores between gender whereby the males (3.76 ± 0.76) rated 0.35 point higher than the females
(3.41 ± 0.90), p < .001. However, there was no significant difference between gender for dramatic
relief between gender, p = .49, environmental reevaluation, p = .33, self-reevaluation, p = .78., and
social liberation, p = .75. In contrast, counterconditioning was significant difference between
gender whereby the males (3.60 ± 0.69) rated 0.39 point higher than the females (3.21 ± 0.90), p
< .001. Besides, there was no significant difference between gender for helping relationships, p
= .65. , reinforcement management, p = .63, and . self-liberation, p = .13. Lastly, stimulus control
was significant difference between gender whereby the males (3.44 ± 0.89) rated 0.40 point higher
than the females (3.03 ± 0.99), p < .001.
157
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Table 3 One-Way ANOVA of Decisional Balance Scale, Self-Efficacy Scale and Processes of
Change Scale based on Age Groups
Variables
Decisional Balance Scale
(DBS)
Pros
Cons
Self-Efficacy Scale
Internal feelings
Competing demands
Situational
Processes of Change Scale
Consciousness Raising
Dramatic Relief
Environmental Reevaluation
Self-Reevaluation
Social Liberation
Counterconditioning
Helping Relationships
Reinforcement Management
Self-Liberation
Stimulus Control
* p < .05
Age Groups
17 – 18
19 – 20
21 – 22
F
p
3.74 (0.53) 3.77 (0.56) 3.84 (0.54) 1.08
3.09 (0.68) 3.16 (0.72) 3.23 (0.84) 1.33
.34
.27
3.15 (0.64) 3.17 (0.74) 3.08 (0.72) 0.47
3.11 (0.71) 3.09 (0.77) 3.08 (0.75) 0.06
3.03 (0.77) 3.03 (0.84) 2.95 (0.82) 0.36
.62
.94
.70
3.28 (0.90)
3.46 (0.73)
3.74 (0.78)
4.03 (0.72)
3.87 (0.73)
3.26 (0.84)
3.81 (0.93)
3.87 (0.79)
3.83 (0.76)
3.11 (0.93)
< .001*
.09
.42
.028*
.003*
.07
.72
.01*
.09
.18
3.61 (0.80)
3.65 (0.81)
3.83 (0.82)
4.12 (0.73)
4.09 (0.74)
3.31 (0.85)
3.88 (0.91)
4.03 (0.74)
3.89 (0.74)
3.10 (1.02)
3.89 (0.77)
3.57 (0.84)
3.85 (0.78)
4.27 (0.71)
4.14 (0.76)
3.51 (0.91)
3.88 (0.89)
4.14 (0.71)
4.04 (0.73)
3.32 (1.02)
18.50
2.47
0.86
3.61
6.05
2.73
0.33
4.62
2.46
1.72
Table 3 shows the one-way ANOVA of decisional balance scale, self-efficacy scale and processes
of change scale based on age groups. For decisional balance scale, the results revealed that there
was no statistically significant difference between the three age groups for pros, p = .34, and cons,
p = .27. For self-efficacy scale, the results revealed no significant difference between the three age
groups for internal feelings, p = .62, competing demands, p = .94, and situational, p = .70. Whereas,
for processes of change scale, the results revealed that there was significant difference between the
three age groups for consciousness raising, p < .001. Post-hoc Tukey HSD adjusted comparisons
for consciousness raising indicated that the mean score for age group of 21 – 22 (3.89 ± 0.77) was
significantly higher than age group of 17 – 18 (3.28 ± 0.90), µ = 0.61, p < .001, 95% CI [0.36, 0.86],
and age group of 19 – 20 (3.61 ± 0.80), µ = 0.28, p = .037, 95% CI [0.01, 0.54]. Age group of 17
– 18 (3.28 ± 0.90) was significantly lower than age group of 19 – 20 (3.61 ± 0.80), µ = -0.33, p
= .001, 95% CI [-0.55, -0.12]. Besides, there was no significant difference between the three age
groups for dramatic relief, p = .09, and environmental reevaluation, p = .42. However, there was
significant difference between the three age groups for self-reevaluation, p = .028. Post-hoc Tukey
HSD adjusted comparisons for self-reevaluation indicated that the mean score for age group of 21
– 22 (4.27 ± 0.71) was significantly higher than age group of 17 – 18 (4.03 ± 0.72), µ = 0.24, p
= .021, 95% CI [0.03, 0.45]. Moreover, there was significant difference between the three age
158
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
groups for social liberation, p = .003. Post-hoc Tukey HSD adjusted comparisons for social
liberation indicated that the mean score for age group of 17 – 18 (3.88 ± 0.73) was significantly
lower than age group of 19 – 20 (4.09 ± 0.74), µ = -0.22, p = .017, 95% CI [-0.41, -0.03], and age
group of 21 – 22 (4.14 ± 0.76), µ = -0.27, p = .009, 95% CI [-0.48, -0.05]. Conversely, there were
no significant difference between the three age groups for counterconditioning, p = .07, and
helping relationships, p = .72. In addition, there was significant difference between the three age
groups for reinforcement management, p = .01. Post-hoc Tukey HSD adjusted comparisons for
reinforcement management indicated that the mean score for age group of 17 – 18 (3.87 ± 0.79)
was significantly lower than age group of 21 – 22 (4.14 ± 0.71), µ = -0.27, p = .012, 95% CI [-0.49,
-0.05]. In contrast, there were no significant difference between the three age groups for selfliberation, p = .09, and stimulus control, p = .18.
Table 4 Independent T-Test of Decisional Balance Scale, Self-Efficacy Scale and Processes of
Change Scale based on Ethnicity
Variables
Decisional Balance Scale
(DBS)
Pros
Cons
Self-Efficacy Scale
Internal feelings
Competing demands
Situational
Processes of Change Scale
Consciousness Raising
Dramatic Relief
Environmental Reevaluation
Self-Reevaluation
Social Liberation
Counterconditioning
Helping Relationships
Reinforcement Management
Self-Liberation
Stimulus Control
Malay
M
SD
Non-Malay
M
SD
t-test
t
p
3.77
3.14
0.53
0.72
3.77
3.13
0.56
0.74
0.16
0.13
.87
.90
3.12
3.07
3.02
0.68
0.72
0.80
3.17
3.14
3.00
0.70
0.76
0.80
-0.70
-1.07
0.21
.48
.29
.83
3.47
3.57
3.79
4.10
4.00
3.30
3.80
3.95
3.86
3.10
0.89
0.79
0.79
0.68
0.74
0.84
0.89
0.75
0.74
0.97
3.59
3.50
3.78
4.13
3.97
3.36
3.93
4.03
3.95
3.23
0.86
0.77
0.80
0.79
0.75
0.91
0.95
0.78
0.77
1.00
-1.43
0.91
0.16
-0.40
0.49
-0.66
-1.41
-1.04
-1.25
-1.38
.15
.37
.87
.68
.63
.51
.52
.30
.21
.17
Table 4 shows the independent sample t-test of decisional balance scale, self-efficacy scale and
processes of change scale based on ethnicity. For decisional balance scale, the results revealed no
statistically significant difference between ethnicity for pros, p = .87, and cons, p = .90. For selfefficacy scale, the results revealed no statistically significant difference between ethnicity for
internal feelings, p = .48., competing demands, p = .29and situational, p = .83. For Processes of
Change Scale, the results revealed no statistically significant difference between ethnicity for
159
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
consciousness raising, p = .15. , dramatic relief , p = .37. environmental reevaluation, p = .87, selfreevaluation, p = 69, social liberation, p = .63, counterconditioning, p = .51, helping relationships,
p = .16, reinforcement management, p = .30, self-liberation, p = .21, and stimulus control, p = .17.
Discussion
The study extended further review on the TTM among Malaysian undergraduate trainee teachers.
The results revealed a significant gender difference in self-efficacy, indicating that males were more
confident in their ability to engage in physical activity than females as they were more likely to be
encouraged to engage in masculine activities. With such a high level of self-assurance, men are
more likely to engage in and undertake more demanding and intense forms of public service. Males
had higher positive perceived benefits of exercise and lower perceived costs than females,
indicating that due to gender stereotypes, males have a substantial advantage in engaging in physical
activity and performing physical tasks better than females. On the other hand, the non-significant
difference between the age groups indicated that the trainee teachers had nearly equivalent selfefficacy for PA, revealing that they were able to schedule their time for PA. In terms of ethnicity
and self-efficacy, both Malay and non-Malay participants perceived that engaging in PA could
improve their health and prevent and manage non-communicable diseases. In addition, they were
aware that PA facilitates socialisation and reduced stress and anxiety associated with their academic
workloads and schedules as they progressed through the programme.
For decisional balance, the age groups, Malay and Non-Malay had similar positive perceptions of
PA in that they deemed regular PA as a beneficial health measure that can positively contribute to
a healthy lifestyle and meet the daily demands. From the process of change among gender, the
male used more cognitive and behavioural processes of change than the female. Regarding age
groups, there was no significant difference in decisional balance and self-efficacy, but there was a
significant difference in consciousness raising, self-re-evaluation, self-liberation, and reinforcement
management processes of change, with the older age group employing more cognitive and
behavioural processes than the two younger age groups.
As schools are the main setting to nurture positive behaviours in the health and well-being of the
students, the future trainee teachers need to lead as societal leaders in PA through lessons,
intramural sports and sports programs that can cater for the interests and needs of all students
(Kee et al., 2010). In order to be exemplars of a healthy lifestyle, the trainee teachers would need
to be responsible and take charge of their own habitual PA and health to guide the school children
to practice lifelong engagement in PA.
Conflicts of interest
The authors declare that the study was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial
relationships that could be constructed as a potential conflict of interest.
160
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
References
Allison, K. R., Vu-Nguyen, K., Ng, B., Schoueri-Mychasiw, N., Dwyer, J. J. M., Manson, H., Hobin,
E., Manske, S., & Robertson, J. (2016) Evaluation of daily physical activity (DPA) policy
implementation in Ontario: surveys of elementary school administrators and teachers. BMC
Public Health, 16(1), 1-16. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-016-3423-0
Bandura, A. (1997). Self-efficacy: The exercise of control. Worth Publishers.
https://doi.org/10.5860/choice.35-1826
Bremer, E., Graham, J. D., Veldhuizen, S., & Cairney, J. (2018). A program evaluation of an inschool daily
physical activity initiative for children and youth. BMC Public Health, 18(1),
1-10. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-018-5943-2
Cengiz, C. (2007). Physical activity and exercise stages of change levels of middle east technical university
students. [Master’s thesis, Middle East Technical University].
Donnelly, J. E., Hillman, C. H., Greene, J. L., Hansen, D. M., Gibson, C. A., Sullivan, D. K.,
Poggio, J., Mayo, M. S., Lambourne, K., Szabo-Reed, A. N., Herrmann, S. D., Honas, J. J.,
Scudder, M. R., Betts, J. L., Henley, K., Hunt, S. L., & Washburn, R. A. (2017). Physical
activity and academic achievement across the curriculum: Results from a 3-year clusterrandomized trial. Preventive Medicine, 99, 140-145.
Dziedzic, K., & Hammond, A. (2010). Rheumatology e-book: Evidence-based practice for physiotherapists
and occupational therapists. Elsevier Health Sciences.
Ebem, Z. (2007). Health promoting behaviors and exercise stages of change levels of students at transition to
university. [Master’s thesis]. Middle East Technical University.
Han, H., Pettee, Gabriel, K., & Kohl III, H. W. (2017). Application of the transtheoretical model
to sedentary behaviors and its association with physical activity status. PLoS ONE, 12(4),
e0176330. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal. pone.0176330
Institute for Public Health. (2011). National Health and Morbidity Survey 2011 (NHMS 2011).
Vol. II: Non-Communicable Diseases. Ministry of Health Malaysia.
Institute for Public Health. (2015). National Health and Morbidity Survey 2015 (NHMS 2015).
Vol. II: Non-Communicable Diseases, Risk Factors & Other Health Problems. Ministry of
Health Malaysia, 2, 185-186.
Jahan, H. R., Shokravi, F. A., & Sanaeinasab, H. (2017). Relationship between regular physical
activity and transtheoretical model components among members of municipality councils in
selected districts of Tehran. Asian Journal of Sports Medicine, 8(2), 1-6.
https://doi.org/10.5812/asjsm.13736
Kee, K. M. (2013). Exercise behaviour among Malaysian teacher trainees. [Unpublished PhD thesis].
University of Malaya.
Kee, K. M., Ong, T. F., & Wee, E. H. (2010). Exercise behavior of Malaysian secondary school
students: A Transtheoretical Model approach. International Conference on Science and Social
Research, 596-601. https://doi.org/10.1109/CSSR.2010.5773851
Kim, Y. H. (2007). Application of the transtheoretical model to identify psychological constructs
influencing exercise behaviour: A questionnaire survey. International Journal of Nursing
Studies, 44(6), 936-944.
161
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Kocak, S. (2005). Perceived barriers to exercise among university members. International Council for
Health, Physical Education, Recreation, Sport and Dance, XLI (1), 34-36.
Laranjo, L. (2016). Social media and health behavior change. In S. Syed-Abdul, E. Gabarron, & A.
Y.
S.
Lau (Eds.), Participatory health
through
social
media (pp.
83-111).
Elsevier. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-809269-9.00006-2
Liu, K. T., Kueh, Y. C., Arifin, W. N., Kim, Y. & Kuan, G. (2018). Application of transtheoretical
model on behavioral changes, and amount of physical activity among university’s students.
Frontiers in Psychology, 9, 2402. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2018.02402
Marcus, B. H., Selby, V. C., Niaura, R. S., & Rossi, J. S. (1992). Self-efficacy and the stages of
exercise behavior change. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport, 63(1), 60–66.
https://doi.org/10.1080/02701367.1992.10607557
Nigg, C. R., Norman, G. J., Rossi, J. S., & Benisovich, S. V. (1999). Processes of exercise behavior
change: Redeveloping the scale. Annals of Behavioral Medicine, 21, S79.
Olstad, D. L., Campbell, E. J., Raine, K. D., & Nykiforuk, C. I. (2015). A multiple case history and
systematic review of adoption, diffusion, implementation and impact of provincial daily
physical activity policies in Canadian schools. BMC Public Health,15(1), 1-25.
https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-015-1669-6
Plotnikoff, R. C., Blanchard, C., Hotz, S. B., & Rhodes, R. (2001). Validation of the decisional
balance scales in the exercise domain from the transtheoretical model: A longitudinal
test. Measurement in Physical Education and Exercise Science, 5(4), 191-206.
Prochaska, J. O., & DiClemente, C. C. (1983). Stages and processes of self-change of smoking:
Toward an integrative model of change. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 51(3), 390395.
Prochaska, J. O., & Velicer, W. F. (1997). The transtheoretical model of health behavior change.
American Journal of Health Promotion, 12(1), 38–48. https://doi.org/10.4278/0890-117112.1.38
Rizal, H., Hajar, M. S., Kueh, Y. C., Muhamad, A. S., & Kuan, G. (2019). Confirmatory factor
analysis of the Malay-language transtheoretical model of physical activity among
Malaysian primary school children. Malaysian Journal of Medical Sciences, 26(2), 99-113.
https://doi.org/10.21315/mjms2019.26.2.11
Romain, A. J., Caudroit, J., Hokayem, M., & Bernard, P. (2018). Is there something beyond stages
of change in the transtheoretical model? The state of art for physical activity. Canadian Journal
of Behavioural Science, 50(1), 42–53. https://doi.org/10.1037/cbs0000093
Rosales-Ricardo, Y., Orozco, D.R., Yaulema, L., Parreño, Á., Caiza, V., Barragán, V., Rios, A., &
Peralta, L. (2017). Physical activities and health in teachers: A review. Apunts Sports Medicine,
52(196), 159-166.
Spencer, L., Adams, T. B., Malone, S., Roy, L., & Yost, E. (2006). Applying the transtheoretical
model to exercise: A systematic and comprehensive review of the literature. Health Promotion
Practice, 7(4), 428–443. https://doi.org/10.1177/1524839905278900
Wallace, L. S., Buckworth, J., Kirby, T. E., & Sherman, W. M. (2000). Characteristics of exercise
behavior among college students: Application of social cognitive theory to predicting stage
of change. Preventive Medicine,31(5), 494-505. https://doi.org/10.1006/pmed.2000.0736
162
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
The Role of Recreation in the System of Physical Education of
Young People with a Sedentary Lifestyle
Sergii Ivashchenko - Nataliya Kovalchuk
Kyiv Borys Grinchenko University, Kyiv, Ukraine
e-mail: algis6274@hotmail.com
Abstract
One of the important elements of the system of recreational activities aimed at maintaining
people's health is the optimization of their physical activity. Myofascial massage is an important
component of the complex of measures to stimulate the motor activity of people. This is a
specific massage technique used by qualified specialists, and is aimed mainly at the fascial
structures that form the connective tissue membranes of individual muscles and muscle groups in
order to optimize their tone. A decrease in the level of physical activity of people against the
background of the Coronavirus pandemic contributes to the development of adverse changes in
the state of the fascial sheaths of their muscles. This study was conducted to determine the effect
of recreational techniques with elements of myofascial massage on the well-being and functional
state of the muscular apparatus of young people. The study involved 136 people (58 men and 78
women) aged 20 to 35 with a low level of physical activity. The study period lasted from
September 2020 to November 2021. The study participants were divided into the main and
control groups according to the principle of similarity of the main parameters (age, gender,
anthropometric indicators). We took the results of carpal dynamometry as an indicator of the
state of the respondent's muscular system. During the entire period of observation, the
participants of the main group used complexes of recreational activities using the techniques of
myofascial massage, and the participants in the control group did not use such complexes. At the
end of the observation period, the dynamometry was repeated and compared with the original
data. The results showed that the use of myofascial massage techniques turned out to be an
effective means of optimizing the condition of people with a low level of physical activity.
Key words: Motor activity level, Myofascial massage, Health programs, Carpal dynamometry
method
163
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
Over the past decades, in many countries of the world there has been a trend towards an increase
in the number of people leading a sedentary lifestyle. A sedentary lifestyle, or physical inactivity, is
an insufficient amount of moderate and/or vigorous physical activity relative to the
recommended level (13). One of the reasons for this trend is a high level of computerization of
life processes, as well as a change in the style of people's daily activities due to a change in the
nature of professional activity (2, 11). Finally, the third most important cause of this
phenomenon can be considered the restrictions on motor activity associated with the Covid-19
pandemic.
Thus, a huge number of people, especially those of the first mature age, are influenced by these
factors. As a result of prolonged exposure to this state, most people experience adverse changes
in physical and mental health (6). Can these people be helped to avoid the adverse effects of this
condition? This question is a serious scientific problem, the search for a solution of which
requires the concentration of efforts of many scientists. An analysis of the scientific literature
indicates that many scientists are working productively on the problem of studying the adaptive
reserves of a person with a sedentary lifestyle (7). Of great interest are those scientific works that
are devoted to studying the effect of cardiorespiratory load on the condition of young people (1,
8).
Valuable results have been obtained in the study of the impact on the physical and mental health
of young people leading a sedentary lifestyle, activities such as aerobics and meditation (10).
Particular attention should be paid to studies devoted to the problems of optimizing the use of
the resources of the human body in the process of its adaptation to the use of special motor
programs and technologies (5). Also important are the results of studying the role of inclusive
education in the prevention of a sedentary lifestyle for different categories of the population, in
particular students of higher educational institutions (4).
An important aspect of scientific research in this direction can rightfully be considered the study
of the influence of socio-economic factors and the level of sensory abilities of an individual on
the nature of motor activity in the process of daily activities (9). Of course, the results of research
by scientists who have devoted their efforts to studying the historical aspect in search of ways to
solve this problem deserve special attention (14). One of the important areas of scientific activity
was the study of changes in mental health indicators of persons with a reduced level of motor
activity (2).
In addition, the results of studies aimed at studying the features of recreational and social
rehabilitation of people leading a sedentary lifestyle deserve special attention (12). However,
despite significant progress in the study of these problems, the issue of the relevance of the use
of recreational programs based on myofascial massage to restore the physical and mental health
of people leading a sedentary lifestyle remains insufficiently studied in our time. The research
work carried out by our team was devoted to the study of this important issue.
164
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
In the course of fulfilling the objectives of this study, we also studied the condition of persons
whose movement restriction was associated exclusively with the Covid-19 pandemic.
Methods
In the course of this study, the following scientific methods were applied. The method of
studying medical records was used to form equivalent groups of respondents in terms of age,
gender and anthropometric data.
To obtain reliable information about the characteristic complaints of respondents during the
study period, the methods of questioning, interviews and pedagogical observation were used. At
the final stage of the study, modern methods of statistical processing of the results obtained were
used. The age range of participants was 20 - 35 years old, they were residents of the city of Kyiv
and its environs. All of them gave written consent to participate in the study. Of the total number
of participants, two equivalent groups were formed (main and control). At the same time, during
the entire period of observation, the indicators of well-being and the results of carpal
dynamometry were monitored for all participants in the study.
The results of carpal dynamometry were regarded as an indicator of the tone of the muscular
system as a whole. For all participants in the main group, special health programs were used,
which were based on sessions of myofascial massage. For the participants of the control group,
such programs were not used, so they were engaged in physical culture on their own.
To control the indicators of the respondents' well-being, self-observation logs were kept, in
which the respondents noted typical complaints of deterioration in well-being, as well as the
degree of their severity. To generalize the results of the study and determine the level of their
reliability, statistical methods used in the field of biomedical research were used.
Results
In recent years, in many countries of the world there has been a trend towards an increase in the
number of people leading a sedentary lifestyle. This is due to the Covid-19 pandemic and the
introduction of restrictions on the movement of citizens, their contacts and certain activities.
One of the important tasks of scientists working in the field of healthcare, physical culture and
sports was to find a way convenient for the general population to minimize the negative
consequences of forced physical inactivity in order to preserve the physical and mental health of
people. In the course of our study, the condition of people with a sedentary lifestyle living in
Kyiv and its environs was studied. Of the 136 selected respondents, two groups were formed
(main and control) according to the principle of matching age, gender and anthropometric
indicators. Each of these groups included 68 people.
165
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
To assess the level of physical health of each of the respondents, we chose the index of hand
dynamometry as the most accessible and convenient in terms of dynamic control. For the
respondents of the first (main) group, throughout the entire observation period, special training
programs were used using myofascial massage.
For respondents of the second (control) group, such programs were not used. They were
engaged in physical training on their own at home. In the course of the study, we adopted the
classical method of carpal dynamometry using hand dynamometers certified in our country.
Dynamometry is a technique for measuring the strength of an individual muscle or group of
muscles using special instruments - dynamometers. Carpal dynamometry is a measurement of the
strength of the flexor muscles of the fingers. This procedure looks like a one-time maximum
impact on the device of the muscles of the hand. With the forearm extended, the subject
squeezes the carpal dynamometer with one hand. The study is carried out for both limbs, after
which the data obtained are compared.
After measuring the strength of the muscles of the right and left hands of each subject, we
calculated the average value of these data and entered it into the study protocol. The results that
we obtained during this study are presented in the following table.
Table1 Carpal dynamometry parameters in persons with a sedentary lifestyle (kg)
Research
phase
Main group
Control group
Male persons
Female persons
Male persons
Female persons
Start of study
46,8 ± 3,1
32,4 ± 2,6
46,7 ± 3,1
32,4 ± 2,6
End of study
50,6 ± 3,8
35,5 ± 2,9
48,3 ± 3,3
32,6 ± 2,7
From this table, we see that the indicators of carpal dynamometry at the beginning of the study
were almost the same in both the representatives of the main group and the participants in the
control group. However, in the male representatives of the main group, the indicators of carpal
dynamometry during the study period increased from 46.8±3.1 kg to 50.6±3.8 kg, while in the
female representatives of the main group they increased to a lesser extent (from 32, 4 ± 2.6 kg to
35.5 ± 2.9 kg).
At the same time, in the participants of the control group (both men and women), the indicators
of carpal dynamometry at the beginning of the study and at the end of it remained almost the
166
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
same (their changes were within the permissible measurement error). To assess the mental health
of the respondents, we assessed the indicators of their well-being.
For this we have developed a special control system. We suggested that each of the study
participants keep a personal diary of self-observation and assessment of their well-being. In the
process of keeping such a diary, the respondents daily noted the state of their health and
recorded complaints about its deterioration.
At the same time, they evaluated each case of deterioration in well-being in points, depending on
the extent to which this deterioration affected their ability to perform daily activities. If the
deterioration in well-being practically did not affect the performance of daily functions, 1 point
was put in the diary of self-observation. If the impact of a case associated with a deterioration in
well-being had a slight negative impact on the process of performing vital functions, such a
condition was assessed as 2 points. A score of 3 points was given in the case when the
deterioration in well-being skill fully limited the ability to perform the usual life functions. 4
points were given in cases where, as a result of a violation of self-esteem, the limitation of the
ability to perform vital functions was significant. Finally, 5 points were awarded when the
deterioration of the respondent's health was so severe that he was practically unable to perform
daily life functions.
We summed up the points scored by the respondents during the observation period, and on the
basis of this we judged the state of health characteristic of each participant. The most frequent
complaints were increased irritability, the presence of pain syndrome of various localization and
sleep disturbance in the form of insomnia. The remaining types of complaints were not
numerous, so we grouped them into the category of other signs.
The analysis of the obtained data made it possible to determine the trends in the change in the
indicators of the well-being of the respondents, depending on whether special health programs
were applied to them. Information on the assessment of the well-being of the respondents of
both groups is presented in Table. 2.
As can be seen from the data presented in Table. 2, the number of points received by the
respondents of the main group at the beginning and at the end of the study remained practically
unchanged. At the same time, the respondents of the control group showed a significant increase
in the frequency of complaints of deterioration in well-being during the second year of
observation compared with the first year. At the same time, this pattern was observed in relation
to all types of complaints, regardless of their nature.
Taking into account the fact that special health programs based on the use of myofascial massage
were used for the participants of the main group during the entire observation period, it can be
concluded that this was the condition for maintaining the physical and mental health of the study
participants at a stable level.
167
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Table2. Indicators of well-being among the people with a sedentary lifestyle (in points)
Symptoms frequency
Sequence
number
The nature of the
disorder
Main group
2020
2021
1
Nervous
excitement
66,4 ± 4,2
67,1 ± 4,3
66,3 ± 4,2
71,2 ± 4,5
2
Pain syndrome
83,5 ± 5,9
84,3 ± 6,0
82,7 ± 5,9
87,1 ± 6,5
3
Insomnia
42,5 ± 2,9
42,6 ± 3,0
42,4 ± 2,9
46,4 ± 3,2
4
Other signs
75,4 ± 3,1
76,2 ± 3,2
75,3 ± 3,1
79,4 ± 3,5
Control group
2020
2021
Discussion
There is no doubt that in our time for many people living in different countries of the world, the
so-called sedentary lifestyle is typical. And that, unfortunately, the number of people suffering
from this syndrome continues to gradually increase. The reason for such an adverse impact is the
combined impact of a number of circumstances that characterize the life of a modern person.
This is a high level of computerization of many life processes, and the widespread use of modern
technical means that replace the physical actions of a person when performing many types of
work in production and at home.
And, of course, those quarantine restrictions that many people are forced to comply with in order
to protect their health and the health of others, in connection with the Covid-19 pandemic. But
does the restriction of physical activity of people contain a potential danger in relation to their
state of health? The opinion of many reputable scientists studying this problem agrees that, of
course, an insufficient level of physical activity of a person in most cases leads to a violation of
both his physical and mental health. Stagnation resulting from prolonged physical inactivity leads
to disruption of the normal functioning of many organs of the human body.
But how can you help those people who, for various reasons, are forced to lead a so-called
sedentary lifestyle for a long time? This important question worried many scientists and a large
number of studies have been carried out on this topic.
168
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
This work was devoted to evaluating the effectiveness of one of these methods, with the help of
which the effect of improving the well-being of people and supporting their physical and mental
health is achieved. One of the main features of this study was that the contingent of respondents
included precisely those young people who, in accordance with the international age
classification, belong to the first period of adulthood, since they are the main productive force in
any state and are the force that determines the development strategy of society.
With regard to the gender approach, the trends identified in our study were characteristic of both
men and women, although the degree of their manifestation was not the same in all cases.
Summarizing the above, we can conclude that the use of special recreational programs using the
techniques of myofascial massage can help maintain both the physical and mental health of
people who lead a sedentary lifestyle. It would be logical to assume that one of the important
directions for further scientific research on this problem could be the development of methods
for improving the physical and mental health of people with a sedentary lifestyle belonging to
other age categories.
The search for ways to solve this problem is an extremely complex process and requires the
combined efforts of the best specialists working in the field of health, physical culture and sports.
Conclusion
Based on the analysis of the results of this study, the following conclusions can be drawn:
1. Due to the presence of total movement restrictions associated with the quarantine measures
of the Covid-19 pandemic, many categories of people, especially in the first period of
adulthood, have a significant decrease in the level of motor activity, which can be called a
sedentary lifestyle. As a result, indicators of their physical and mental health deteriorate.
2. One of the effective means, the use of which leads to an increase in the physical health of
people who lead a sedentary lifestyle, is the systematic use of special health programs based
on the principle of using myofascial massage. This, first of all, has a positive effect on muscle
tone and strength indicators of the main muscle groups of a person, especially the muscles of
his upper limbs, which is extremely important for human production activities.
3. Special health programs with the use of myofascial massage also contribute to the
improvement of the mental health of the respondents, as evidenced by the decrease in the
frequency of various types of disturbances in their well-being. Thus, the use of health
programs with myofascial massage is advisable for people leading a sedentary lifestyle.
References
Boterberg, S., & Warreyn, P. (2016). Making sense of it all: The impact of sensory processing
sensitivity on daily functioning of children. Personality and Individual Differences, 92, 80 –
86.
169
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Castroa, O., Benniea, J., Vergeera, I., Bosselutb, G., & Biddlea, S. (2018). Correlates of sedentary
behaviour in university students: A systematic review. Preventive Medicine, 116, 194 – 202.
Choi, J., Lee, M., Kang, D., & Choi, J.-Y. (2017). Correlates associated with participation in
physical activity among adults: a systematic review of reviews and update. BMC Public
Health, 17 (1). doi: 10.1186 / s12889-017-4255-2.
Gaintza, Z., Castro, V. (2020). Physical education sessions in secondary school: attitudes towards
the inclusion of students with disabilities. Journal of Physical Education and Sport, 20 (1),
214 – 221. doi: 10.7752/jpes. 2020.01028.
Goldan, J., Schwab, S. (2020). Measuring student’s perceptions of resources in inclusive
education-validation of a newly developed instrument. International Journal of Inclusive
Education, 24 (12), 1326 – 1339. doi: 10.1080 / 13603116.2018.1515270.
Han, H., Gabriel, K., & Kohl, W. (2017). Application of the transtheoretical model to sedentary
behaviours and its association with physical activity status. PLUs, ONE, 12 (4), e0176330.
Kiraly, A., Kay, M., Kalbli, K. (2019). Overview of the Adaptation Process of the Hungarian
National Student. Fitness Test to Students. PALAESTRA, 33 (1). 20 – 27.
Lang J.J., Tremblay, M.S., Tomkinson, G.R. (2019). Review of criterion-referenced standards for
cardio-respiratory fitness. British journal of sports medicine, 53 (15), 953 – 958.
Lee, J., Kim, U. (2017). Application of the social ecological constructs to explain physical activity
in middle aged adults. International Journal of Sport Psychology, 48 (2), 99 – 110.
Mir, I., Xin, C., & Jabbar, M.A. (2019). Effectiveness of aerobic exercise and meditation on shortterm memory and attention in young university students with depression: a randomized
control. Journal of Physical Therapy. 9, 295. doi: 10.4172 / 2157 – 7595.
Pruzek, M., Cihova, I., Novak, D., Wang, X., Vasickova, J., Tomanek, L., & Antala, B. (2020).
Inclusion in physical education on the basis of opinions of high school female students
from Slovakia, Czech Republic and Croatia. Journal of Physical Education and Sport, 20 (3),
1538 – 1542. doi: 10.7752 / jpes. 2020.03211.
Rahappan, R., Selvaganapathy, K. & Liew, L. (2015). Physical activity level among university
students: a cross sectional survey. International Journal of Physiotherapy and Research, 3
(6): 1336 – 1343.
Stamatakis, E., Ekelund, U., Hamer, M., & Lee, I.M. (2019). Is the time right for quantitative
public health guidelines on sitting? A narrative review of sedentary behaviour research
paradigms and findings. British Journal of Sport Medicine, 53, 377 – 382.
Zivanovic, Nenad; Antala, Branislav; Pantelic-Babic, Kristina (2015): The History of Physical
Education in Europe, Book 1-2, FIEP Europe – History of Physical Education and Sport
Section, Faculty of Physical Education and Sport, Leposavic, Serbia.
170
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Effects of Peer Motivation on Sport Participation among College
Students
Eng Hoe Wee¹ - Liang Wei Wong2 - Wei Fong Cheng3 - Hui Yin Ler4 Ngien Siong Chin5
1,2,3,4
5
Tunku Abdul Rahman University College, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
Institute of Teacher Education Batu Lintang Campus, Kuching, Sarawak, Malaysia
e-mail: weeeh@tarc.edu.my
Abstract
This study examined the effects of peer motivation on sport participation of college students. A
sample of 278 team sport co-curriculum programme participants (19.7+1.5 years) from six team
sports were surveyed using a purposive sampling method. Participants completed a 21-item Peer
Motivational Climate in Youth Sport Questionnaire (PeerMCYSQ; Ntoumanis & Vazou, 2005).
The items of the inventory were weighted on a 7-point Likert-scale from strongly disagree (1) to
strongly agree (7). Descriptive and inferential statistics were used to analyse the data collected.
Inferential statistics such as t-test and one-way ANOVA were used to determine whether
differences existed in peer motivation mean scores according to gender, and age category. All data
analysis was carried out using SPSS (IBM, ver.23). All tests of significance were at the 0.05 level.
For the one-way ANOVA, where F-tests were significant, a Tukey-HSD post-hoc test was
employed. Descriptive statistics showed that the whole sample had favourable peer motivation
climate mean scores for all the five subscales. In addition, female participants were found to favour
all the five subscales more than male participants. Independent sample t-test according to gender
revealed a significant result only on ‘intra-team conflict’ sub-scale (t(276) = -2.879, p=.004) with
female participants scored significantly higher than male participants, showing that they have less
conflicts with teammates as compared to the male participants. Similarly, significant results were
also obtained in the intra-team conflict according to age (p=0.006), with younger students (18-19
years old) scoring significantly higher than the older student group (20-21 years old). For future
research, it is recommended that the examination of peer motivation should also include individual
sport and mixed sport participants.
Key words: Physical activity, Peer motivation, Task-orientation, Ego-orientation, Intramural sport
programme
171
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
In the college sport context, participation in sport has provided numerous positive benefits; college
students learned to balance between sports participation and academic pursuit. And this has helped
them to develop good time management skills and also helped them reduce stress. Numerous
researchers (Eime et al., 2015; Khan et al., 2012) have reported that the opportunity to take part
in physical activity has led to a healthy lifestyle among individuals. In addition, sport participation
has helped individuals develop and improve physically, mentally, and socially (Eime et al., 2013;
Janssen & LeBlanc, 2010). Similarly, organised sport programmes that offer participation
opportunities for college students, are contexts in which young people can acquire not only
important skills and competencies but also enhance psychological well-being. These can contribute
to positive youth development. In addition, organised sport such as team sport helps participants
reduce social anxiety, promote social acceptance, and promote health over time in youth as
compared to those who participate in an individual sport programme (Eime et al., 2013).
Previous studies on sport participation motivation have reported that peers are important
contributors in creating a motivational climate in sport settings (Cervello et al., 2007; Ntoumanis
& Vazou, 2005; Ullrich-French & Smith, 2006; Vazou, Ntoumanis, & Duda, 2006). Motivational
climate in which the peers were supportive and emphasized personal improvement, cooperation,
and effort could influence positive affective responses to sport among participants (Murcia et al.,
2008). This could be mediated through variables such as the satisfaction of individual needs for
autonomy, competence, and relatedness, as well as self-determined motivation. However, Murcia
et al. (2008) could not confirm how autonomy, competence, and relatedness mediate the
relationships between peer motivational climate and athletes’ motivation and persistence
behaviour in sport.
The effects of social support from peers on sport participation were inconclusive. For example,
Shafer (2012) reported that there were no significant correlations between physical activity and
self-efficacy, motivation and social support from friends among male college students. However,
Wee et al. (2012) revealed that the majority of the college students preferred friends as their partner
when doing physical activity. And female students had higher social support than male students.
Even though peers are important to adult motivational climate towards sports (Joesaar, Hein, &
Hagger, 2011; Ntoumanis, Taylor, & Thøgersen-Ntoumani, 2012; Ullrich-French & Smith, 2009),
peers also act as source of stress and anxiety by creating conflict and negative evaluation (FraserThomas & Cote, 2009).
Peers play an influential role in various levels of competitive or recreational sport and physical
activity participation. Peers could lead individuals to a higher level of enjoyment in exercise even
in exercise groups (Murcia, 2008). In fact, peer motivation has a greater influence on enjoyment in
sport compared to coach created motivation climate (Vazou et al., 2006). Peers could create a more
mastery climate which have positive impact on other athletes which are similar to that created by
coaches (Keegan et al., 2014; Ntoumanis et al., 2007; Vazou et al., 2006). According to Ntoumanis
et al. (2007), a mastery climate created by peers correlates with the feeling of self-esteem,
172
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
enjoyment, greater chance of sport participation in the future and lower anxiety of competitive
traits. In addition, Keegan et al. (2014) found that peers promote the feeling of belonging in a
group.
Even though much research has been conducted to examine peer motivation, and goal orientation,
apparently there is no study examining the peer motivation among students in the compulsory cocurriculum sport programme. In light of this, the aim of this research is to investigate the effects
of peer motivation on sport participation of college students.
Methods
Participants
The sample consisted of 278 students who have enrolled in a compulsory college co-curriculum
programme. The participants were selected based on six team sports which were made available
to students by the College Student Affairs Department. The sample consisted of 60.8% (n = 169)
male and 39.2% (n = 109) female. In terms of age, 41.4% of the respondents were under 20 years
old, 48.2% was in the 20-21 years old category and the 10.4% was in the 22 and above years old
category. As for the sport involvement, 19.1% of the participants were involved each in basketball,
and volleyball, while 18.7% of them were involved each in futsal, and netball. Almost 15% of the
participants were in the softball team while about 10% in the soccer team.
Instrumentation
Peer motivation on sport participation was measured using the “Peer Motivational Climate in
Youth Sport Questionnaire” (PeerMCYSQ) (Ntoumanis & Vazou, 2005). The 21-item
PeerMCYSQ inventory comprised of 5 subscales which are improvement (4 items, α = .88),
relatedness support (3 items, α = .52), effort (5 items, α = .92), intra-team competition and ability
(5 items, α = .54) and intra-team conflict (4 items, α =.87). Participants were asked to respond to
what extent they agreed or disagreed to the items using a 7-point Likert Scale anchored on 1
(strongly disagree) to 7 (strongly agree). The reliability for the ‘intra-team competition and ability’
(α =. 54), and ‘relatedness support (α = .52), were less than satisfactory and any data related to
these factors would be treated with caution as suggested by Joesaar, Hein, and Hagger (2011).
These two scales were excluded in the inferential statistical analyses. However, overall reliability
was 0.84 which is considered adequate for it to be used.
PeerMCYSQ was developed by Ntoumanis and Vazou (2005). The ‘improvement’ dimension is
defined as “encouraging and providing feedback to help teammates progress and develop”. ‘Effort’
dimension refers to “the degree to which peers emphasize to their teammates that they should
perform to their best ability” while ‘relatedness support’ is defined as “fostering a strong sense of
belonging and created a friendly team atmosphere”. Intra-team Competition is “the promotion of
competition within peer group members”. Lastly, Intra-team Conflict means “negative and
unsupportive behaviours toward other team members”.
173
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Procedure
This survey was available only to the undergraduates who enrolled in the compulsory team sport
co-curriculum programme. All the team sport co-curriculum programme registered participants
were invited to participate in this study through their programme instructors. Data was collected
once at each co-curriculum programme, thus the participants had only one opportunity to
complete the inventory. All participants gave informed consent before completing their survey.
Research ethics clearance was granted by the Research Ethics Committee of the institution where
this study was conducted.
Data Collection and Analysis
The raw scores from the above-mentioned questionnaire were used for analysis. For PeerMCYSQ,
items were weighed on a priori weight method from Strongly Agree (7) to Strongly Disagree (1).
The ‘intra-team conflict’ subscale was reversed scored to demonstrate non-existence of conflict
among team members. The data collected was analysed using the Statistical Package for the Social
Sciences (SPSS) for Windows ver.23. Two types of statistical techniques were used to analyse the
data, namely, descriptive and inferential statistics. Descriptive statistics such as means, standard
deviations, unweighted mean, and rank were used to report the demographic data and data from
PeerMCYSQ inventory.
In the descriptive statistics, the unweighted means was used because PeerMCYSQ sub-scales
contain a different number of items. The unweighted means were calculated by dividing the means
by the number of items in the sub-scales. A mean of 3.50 is considered neutral; a mean above 3.50
is considered a favourable peer motivation climate and a mean below 3.50 is considered as having
unfavourable peer motivation climate.
Inferential statistics such as independent sample t-test was used to compare differences in
PeerMCYSQ according to gender. One-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was used to compare
differences in PeerMCYSQ according to age category, and years of study. All tests of significance
were set at the 0.05 level. For the one-way ANOVA, where F-tests were significant, a post-hoc
test using the Tukey-HSD test was employed.
Results
Descriptive statistics
In order to examine the peer motivation climate, the scores of the items were compounded as a
single mean score according to five PeerMCYSQ sub-scales as shown in the table below. Overall,
there was a favourable peer motivation climate as indicated by Peer Motivation score. The
unweighted mean showed that the ‘intra-team conflict’ was ranked first indicating that there was no
conflict among team members. The ‘effort’ sub-scale was ranked second showing that teammates
encourage each other to perform well in their sport activity while ‘relatedness support’ was ranked
third which demonstrated that students enjoyed their strong sense of belonging and the friendly
team atmosphere.
174
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Table 1 Descriptive statistics of PeerMCYSQ sub-scales
PeerMCYSQ sub-scales
Improvement
Relatedness Support
Effort
Intra-team Competition
ability
Intra-team Conflict
Peer Motivation
Mean
20.57
15.87
26.48
and 24.06
21.86
108.83
Standard
Deviation
Number
of items
Unweighte
d means
Rank
3.85
2.84
5.11
4
3
5
5
5.14
5.29
5.30
4.81
4
3
2
5
4
21
5.47
5.18
1
4.39
5.15
16.07
Figure 1 Peer Motivation Climate according to gender
Figure 1 showed that both male and female participants ranked ‘intra-team conflict’ first. Male
participants ranked ‘effort’, and ‘relatedness/ability’ as second and third. While female participants
ranked ‘effort’, and ‘relatedness/ability’ as second. Female scored higher than the male participants.
Overall, females demonstrated higher scores in all the five subscales of peer motivation.
Gender and age group difference analyses
Independent sample t-test with gender as the independent variable and PeerMCYSQ sub-scales
serving as dependent variables yielded a significant result only on ‘intra-team conflict’ sub-scale
(t(276) = -2.879, p=.004). Female participants (mean = 22.92) score significantly higher than male
participants (mean = 21.17) ‘intra-team conflict’ variable, showing that they have no conflicts with
teammates.
175
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Follow-up ANOVA reveals that there was a significant effect of age group on PeerMCYSQ subscales at the p<.05 level for the ‘intra-team conflict’ sub-scale [F(2, 275) = 5.23, p = .006]. The
result showed the 18-19 years old group (mean = 22.97) participants scored significantly higher
than the 20-21 years old group (mean = 20.88) on the ‘intra-team conflict’ peer climate variable.
Similarly, there was a significant effect of years of study on PeerMCYSQ sub-scales at the p<.05
level for the ‘intra-team conflict’ sub-scale [F(2, 275) = 3.585, p = .029]. The result revealed the
year one group (mean = 22.43) participants scored significantly higher than the year three group
(mean = 19.27) on the ‘intra-team conflict’ peer climate variable. There were no conflicts among
co-curriculum participants in younger participants as indicated by the analyses of age group and
years of study.
Discussion
Descriptive statistics in Table 1 revealed that all the unweighted mean scores exceeded 3.50 which
is considered favourable peer motivation climate in all the five subscales. The subscales were
discussed according to task-involving motivation climate (‘improvement’, ‘effort’, and ‘relatedness
support’), and ego-involving motivation climate (‘intra-team competition and ability’, ‘intra-team conflict’).
In both orientations, female participants scored higher than males in peer motivation.
Lawler, Heary, Shorter & Nixon (2021) in a study of the influence of peer and parental processes
on physical activity participation among adolescents reported that friend support helped girls to
participate in organised sport and unorganized physical activity. On the contrary, males who
engaged in team sport or mixed PA patterns experienced higher levels of peer acceptance. This
suggests that team sport participation might be more important in gaining social status among
males but not females. Similarly, Lawler et al. (2021) also reported low scores in ego orientation
and high scores in task orientation which is contrary to the findings of this research. Our research
findings also on the contrary to other research; Ruiz-Juan, Gómez, Pappous, Alacid and Allende
(2010) with young elite paddlers and Abraldes, Granero-Gallegos, Baena-Extremera, GómezLópez, and Rodríguez-Suárez (2016) with swimmers.
Gut, Schmid, and Conzelmann (2020) revealed that peers influence adolescent participation in
organised sports, and the participation level is higher than that of other types of sport especially
for females. In addition, Gut et al. (2020) reported that friend support was associated with team
sport rather than leisure active individual sport. The findings indicated that friend support is
positively related to physical activity of adolescents demonstrating differences according to gender;
friends support playing a more important role in females rather than males.
Our research revealed that male and female participants ranked ‘intra-team conflict’(ego-involving)
first, and ‘effort’ (task-involving) second. These results are contrary to that of Duda (1989) which
examined gender difference in goal perspectives between male and female high school athletes and
found that females were significantly higher in task orientation than males, and males were
significantly higher in ego orientation than females. Similarly, our findings are contrary to
176
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Chowdhury’s (2012) which found similar differences in motive for male and female. Males have
indicated higher motivation for affiliation and challenge than females.
Peer support in physical activity comprises of instrumental support (e.g., sharing resources,
participation in physical activity together as a group), and emotional and motivational support (e.g.,
providing encouragement or praise) (Fitzgerald et al., 2012; Lawler et al., 2021; Martins et al., 2020;
Mendonça et al., 2014). In addition, other previous research has emphasized that peers play
important role in physical activity participation in females (Weiss et al., 2013; Zook et al., 2014).
However, other research (Garn, 2016; Ullrich-French & Smith, 2009) reported higher perceptions
of peer acceptance are associated with team sport participation for both adolescent males and
females (Garn, 2016; Ullrich-French & Smith, 2009).
Inferential statistical analyses showed significant results for ‘intra-team conflict’ (ego orientation)
according to gender and age groups, and insignificant results for the ‘improvement’, and ‘effort’
sub-scales (task orientation) for both the above-mentioned independent variables. In addition, for
the ‘intra-team conflict’ variable, female participants scored significantly higher than male
participants, and younger students (18-19 years old) scored significantly higher than the older
student group (20-21 years old).
The findings of this research are supported by Ntoumanis, Vazou, and Duda (2007) where they
found females exhibited perceptions of a more ego-involving peer climate.
On the contrary to the findings of this research, in a study examining conflict in sport focused on
female intercollegiate athletes’ perceptions of the sources of teammate conflicts, Holt, Knight and
Zukiwski (2012) through a semi-structured interviews reported the presence of conflict relating to
performance (i.e. task) and relationships (i.e. social). Similarly, the above-mentioned research
results on gender differences (intra-team conflict - ego involving) differed from that of Vazou et
al. (2006). Vazou et al. (2006) found males scoring higher on perceptions of an ego-involving peer
climate which might be due to males being exposed to more ego-involving motivational practices
(Lewko & Greendorfer, 1988). The insignificant task-involving motivation climate (‘improvement’
and ‘effort’) also differed from findings by Vazou et al. (2006). However, Belli (2015) compared
goal orientation between males and females and found significant differences were observed in
favour of females in the sub-dimension of ego orientation. Other researchers (Zarauz-Sancho, &
Ruiz-Juan, 2016; Zarauz-Sancho, Ruiz-Juan, Flores-Allende, & García-Montes, 2017) investigated
gender and goal orientation but have not found significant differences according to gender.
Our research findings found younger students (18-19 years old) scored significantly higher than
the older student group (20-21 years old) in the intra-team conflict (ego-involving). Our findings were
supported by some previous research (Ogles, & Masters, 2000; Steinberg & Grieve, 2011; ZarauzSancho, & Ruiz-Juan, 2011) which examined the relationship between goal orientation and age;
the results revealed that the older the participant, the greater his or her task goal orientation, and
the younger the participant, the greater his or her ego orientation.
177
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
However, Ntoumanis, Vazou, and Duda (2007) revealed that athletes in the younger age group,
both males and females, reported similar levels of ego-involving peer climate. In examining the
link between goal orientation and the sources of enjoyment in Korean youth sport, Yoo and Kim
(2002) reported that athletes high on ego orientation more frequently identified social recognition
and rewards as their enjoyment sources. Thus, this might explain why there is less conflict for
athletes high on ego orientation.
Our research findings which indicated higher peer motivation scores in intra-team conflict (less
conflict) in younger participants is supported by the previous research (Vazou et al., 2006). Vazou
et al. (2006) found older athletes perceived more intra-team conflict than younger athletes.
Younger athletes perceived their peers to be more supportive, and perceived them to use more
normative referenced criteria for competence evaluation and to encourage intra-team competition.
In a study of junior tennis players, Weiss and Smith (2002) who had similar beliefs and interests,
companionship/pleasant play and conflict resolution with their best tennis friends found their
experiences more fun and pleasurable, thus less conflict among them. Similarly, our research
findings also concur with the findings of Belli (2015) where it was reported that younger age group
students had more ego orientation than students aged between 26 and 30 years old. This finding
may be due to the fact that the students’ with more or longer experience in sport have more
individually ego-orientation compared to inexperienced younger students. Further, young
individuals who join a new social group are more likely to move with a group (Belli, 2015), thus
creating less conflict with their teammates.
Conclusion
The present study extends prior research by demonstrating that peer processes are associated with
college students’ participation in organized sport. Our results showed a positive peer motivational
climate in male and female college students in compulsory team sport participation with female
students having higher peer motivation scores. Female students demonstrated higher mean peer
motivational climate scores as compared to male students in all the five PeerMCYSQ sub-scales.
In addition, younger college students are different as compared to older students in the ‘intra-team
conflict’. However, this research has its limitations as we did not examine peer motivation climate
among students who participated in individual sport, mixed sport and unstructured sport and
physical activity.
References
Abraldes, J., Granero-Gallegos, A., & Baena-Extremera (2016). A. Goal orientations, satisfaction,
beliefs in sport success and motivational climate in swimmers. Rev. Int. Med. Cienc. Act., 63,
583–599.
Belli, E. (2015). An Investigation of Task and Ego Oriented Goals of the Students Majoring at the
Faculty of Sport Sciences. Universal Journal of Educational Research, 3(12), 960-966. DOI:
10.13189/ujer.2015.031202
178
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Chowdhury, D. (2012). Examining reasons for participation in sport and exercise using the physical activity
and leisure motivation scale (PALMS). In: Doctoral dissertation. Victoria University: School of
Social Science and Psychology Faculty of Arts.
Cervello, E., Santos-Rosa, F.J., Garcia-Calvo, T., Jimenez, R. & Iglesias, D. (2007). Young Tennis
Players’ Competitive Task Involvement and Performance: The Role of Goal Orientations,
Contextual Motivational Climate, And Coach-Initiated Motivational Climate. Journal of
Applied Sport Psychology, 19(3), 304–321. https://doi.org/10.1080/10413200701329134
Duda, J. L. (1989). Goal perspectives, participation and persistence in sport, International Journal of
Sport Psychology, 20, 42-56.
Eime, R.M., Young, J.A., Harvey, J.T., Charity, M.J. and Payne, W.R. (2013). A systematic review
of the psychological and social benefits of participation in sport for children and adolescents:
informing development of a conceptual model of health through sport. International Journal
of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity, 10, 98. doi: 10.1186/1479-5868-10-98
Eime, R., Harvey, J., Charity, M., Casey, M., van Uffelen, J., & Payne, W. (2015). The contribution
of sport participation to overall health enhancing physical activity levels in Australia: a
population-based study. BMC Public Health, 15, 806. http://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-0152156-9
Fitzgerald, A., Fitzgerald, N., & Ahearne, C. (2012). Do peers matter? A review of peer and/or
friends’ influence on physical activity among American adolescents. Journal of
Adolescence, 35(4), 941–958. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.adolescence.2012.01.002
Fraser-Thomas, J. & Cote, J. (2009). Understanding adolescents’ positive and negative
developmental experiences in sport. The Sport Psychologist, 23, 3-23.
Garn, A. (2016). Perceived teammate acceptance and sport commitment in adolescent female
volleyball players. The Sport Psychologist, 30(1), 30–39. https://doi.org/10.1123/tsp.20150004
Gut, V., Schmid, J., & Conzelmann, A. (2020). The interaction of behavioural context and
motivational-volitional factors for exercise and sport in adolescence: Patterns matter. BMC
Public Health, 20(1), 570.
Holt, N.L., Knight, C.J., & Zukiwski, P. (2012). Female athletes’ perceptions of teammate conflict
in sport: Implications for sport psychology consultants. The Sport Psychologist, 26, 135–154.
Janssen, I. & LeBlanc, A.G. (2010). Systematic review of the health benefits of physical activity
and fitness in school-aged children and youth. International Journal of Behavioural Nutrition and
Physical Activity. 7, 1–16. doi: 10.1186/1479-5868-7-40
Joesaar, H., Hein, V., & Hagger, M.S. (2011). Peer influence on young athletes’ need satisfaction,
intrinsic motivation and persistence in sport: A 12-month prospective study. Psychology of
Sport and Exercise, 12 (2011), 500-508.
Keegan, R.J., Spray, C.M., Harwood, C., Lavallee, D. (2014). A qualitative investigation of the
motivational climate in elite sport. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 15(1), 97–107. DOI:
10.1016/j.psychsport.2013.10.006
Khan, K. M., Thompson, A. M., Blair, S. N., Sallis, J. F., Powell, K. E., Bull, F., & Bauman, A. E.
(2012). Sport and exercise as contributors to the health of nations. Lancet, 380, 59-64. DOI:
10.1016/S0140-6736(12)60865-4
179
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Lawler, M., Heary, C., Shorter, G., & Nixon, E. (2021). Peer and parental processes predict distinct
patterns of physical activity participation among adolescent girls and boys. International
Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 1-18. DOI: 10.1080/1612197X.2021.1891118
Lewko, J.H., & Greendorfer, S.L. (1988). Family influences in the sports socialization of children
and adolescents. In F.L. Smoll, R.A. Magill, & M.J. Ash (Eds.), Children in sport (3rd 8 ed.,
pp. 265-286). Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics.
Martins, J., Rodrigues, A., Marques, A., Cale, L.,
& da
Costa, F.
C. (2020). Adolescents’
experiences and perspectives on physical activity and friend influences over time. Research
Quarterly for Exercise and Sport, https://doi.org/10.1080/02701367.2020.173960
Mendonça, G., Cheng, L. Z., Mélo, E. N., & de Farias Júnior, J. C. (2014). Physical activity and
social support in adolescents: A systematic review. Health Education Research, 29(5), 822–839.
https://doi.org/10.1093/her/cyu017
Murcia, J.A.M., Román, M.L., Galindo, C.M., Alonso, N. & González-Cutre, D. (2008). Peers’
Influence on Exercise Enjoyment: A Self-Determination Theory Approach. J Sports Sci &
Med., 7(1), 23–31.
Ntoumanis, N., & Vazou, S. (2005). Peer motivational climate in youth sport: Measurement
development and validation. Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 27, 432-455.
Ntoumanis, N., Vazou, S., & Duda, J. L. (2007). Peer-Created Motivational Climate. In S. Jowette
& D. Lavallee (Eds.), Social Psychology in Sport (pp. 145–156). Human
Kinetics. https://doi.org/10.5040/9781492595878.ch-011
Ntoumanis, N., Taylor, I. M. & Thøgersen-Ntoumani, C. (2012). A longitudinal examination of
coach and peer motivational climates in youth sport: Implications for moral attitudes, wellbeing, and behavioural investment. Development Psychology, 48, 213- 223.
Ogles, B.M., & Masters, K.S. (2000). Older vs. younger adult male marathon runners: Participative
motives and training patterns. J. Sport Behav. 23, 130.
Ruiz-Juan, F., Gómez-López, M., Pappous, A., Cárceles, F.A., & Allende, G.F. (2010).
Dispositional Goal Orientation, Beliefs about the Causes of Success and Intrinsic
Satisfaction in Young Elite Paddlers. J. Hum. Kinet, 26, 123–136.
Shafer, A.B. (2012). Psychological determinants of physical activity in a sample of undergraduate
college students. Unpublished Doctor of philosophy in exercise physiology, University of
Pittsburgh, USA.
Steinberg, G., Grieve, F.G., & Glass, B. (2011). Achievement goals across the lifespan. J. Sport
Behav., 24, 298–306.
Ullrich-French, S., & Smith, A. L. (2009). Social and motivational predictors of continued youth
sport participation. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 10, 87-95.
Ullrich-French, S., & Smith, A.L. (2006). Perceptions of relationships with parents and peers in
youth sport: Independent and combined prediction of motivational outcomes. Psychology of
Sport and Exercise, 7, 193–214. doi:10.1016/j.psychsport.2005.08.006
Vazou, S., Ntoumanis, N., & Duda, J. L. (2006). Predicting Young Athletes Motivational Indices
as a Function of Their Perceptions of the Coach and Peers Created Motivational Climate.
Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 7, 215-233.
180
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Wee, E.H., Saunders, J., Aumand, E., Ler, H.Y. & Chan, K.Q. (2012). Comparing barriers to being
physically active between Tunku Abdul Rahman College and Australian Catholic University
Students. Unpublished Research Report, Tunku Abdul Rahman College.
Weiss, M. R., Stuntz, C. P., Bhalla, J. A., Bolter, N. D., & Price, M. S. (2013). ‘More than a game’:
Impact of The first Tee life skills programme on positive youth development: Project
introduction and year 1 findings. Qualitative Research in Sport, Exercise and Health, 5(2), 214–
244. https://doi.org/10.1080/2159676X.2012.712997
Weiss, M.R., & Smith, A.L. (2002). Friendship Quality in Youth Sport: Relationship to Age,
Gender, and Motivation Variables. Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 24(4), 420–437.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1123/jsep.24.4.420
Yoo, J., & Kim, B.J. (2002). Young Korean athletes' goal orientation and sources of enjoyment,
Perceptual and Motor Skills, 94, 1043-1049.
Zarauz-Sancho, A. & Ruiz-Juan, F. (2011). Commitment and negative addiction to training and
competition for marathoners. Rev. Int. Med. Cienc. Act., 11, 817–834.
Zarauz-Sancho, A. & Ruiz-Juan, F. (2016). Motivation, satisfaction, perception and beliefs about
the causes of success in Spanish master athletes. Ibero-Am. J. Exerc. Sports Psychol., 11, 37–46.
Zarauz-Sancho, A., Ruiz-Juan, F., Flores-Allende, G., García-Montes, M.E. (2017). Perception of
success in marathoners depending on their training habits. Retos, 32, 111–114.
Zook, K. R., Saksvig, B. I., Wu, T. T., & Young, D. R. (2014). Physical activity trajectories and
multilevel factors among adolescent girls. Journal of Adolescent Health, 54(1), 74–80.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jadohealth.2013.07.015
181
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
182
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Functional Disorders of the Musculoskeletal System in Younger
School-age Pupils
Elena Bendíková
Faculty of Education, Catholic University, Ružomberok, Slovakia
e-mail: elena.bendikova@ku.sk
Abstract
Body posture is a movement habit that is formed and changed throughout the lifespan of a person
and carries all the characteristics of the movement activity and mental state of the individual.
Posture is a basic prerequisite for good health, normal growth, and development of humans, which
is why it is very important that care for proper posture begins in preschools and continuing at
school. The aim of the research was to expand the knowledge, to find out and point out the level
of the musculoskeletal system with an emphasis on selected functions of the muscular system and
body posture in younger school-age pupils. The group consisted of 𝝨 288 younger school-age
pupils in the number of n = 150 girls (body height (x) 136.21 ± 4.8 cm, body weight (x) 34.5 ± 8.6
kg and n = 138 boys (body height (x) 137.65 ± 5.1 cm, body weight (x) 35.12 ± 8.1 kg from the
Central Slovakian region. In terms of data acquisition methods, we used standardized methods for
evaluating the functional state of the locomotor system for physical education practice. The results
significantly demonstrated the fact that in the period of younger school age, the kyphotic posture
predominates in pupils to the detriment of girls (χ2p < 0.01), accompanied already in this
developmental period by upper and lower cross syndrome. We also found significant differences
(χ2p < 0.05) in the overall posture, where the III. quality level dominated, to the detriment of the
girls. From the areas of individual posture segments, the forward head posture and the prominent
abdominal area had the highest proportion. The above partial findings show the need to increase
the attention of primary prevention by physical activity in the school and out of school
environment. The listed study is the part of research project VEGA "1/0427/22 Prevention of
pupils' postural health by physical activity".
Key words: Body posture, Functional disorders, Health, Locomotor system, Younger school-age
183
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
The issues of health, healthy and harmonious development of children and youth are currently the
focus of our entire society. In Slovakia, there has been an upward trend in diseases of civilization
and health disorders in the school population, in the last two decades (Bendíková, 2017; Olekšák
& Nemček, 2021).
One of the areas of health is also postural health, which is linked to the musculoskeletal system,
where posture has become a negative syndrome, or a disease of civilization today. Posture disorders
in children and adolescents are one of the most serious but underestimated health problems.
Decreased cardiorespiratory activity, decreased vital capacity of the lungs, pain in the
musculoskeletal system, as well as displacement of internal organs are just some of the
consequences of untreated body posture (Yu et al., 2002).
Posture defects may include incorrect posture of the head, shoulders, shoulder blades, pelvis, spine,
chest, or upper and lower limbs. Disorders in the position of specific parts of the body cause
instability and imbalance (Claus et al., 2007). All negative changes in body posture intensify during
periods defined as critical during the posturogenesis process. It is the beginning of younger school
age and the first phase of puberty (Lafond et al., 2007). The younger school age is the most
vulnerable to changes in body posture. No large or sudden weight gain or height is observed until
the age of 5 years. The pace of developmental phenomena is declining at that time compared to
childhood.
An upright body posture is the result of an individual postural function that ensures body posture
with respect to external conditions. Proper body posture is one of the basic prerequisites for
optimal involvement of individual muscle groups (Vařeka, 2002).
The functional musculoskeletal disorders are about the muscular coordination disorders due to
central control disorders. However, the question of the boundary of the norm is problematic
because movement stereotypes are to some extent individual and characteristic of each individual.
Ideally, movement stereotypes should allow the most economical movement as possible, which
would require a minimum of energy at a certain power (Lewit, 1996).
The movement stereotype is characterized as a complex human movement manifestation, which
is formed by a system of conditioned and unconditional reflexes. These reflexes result in a certain
movement, and by repeating these reflexes are fixed and changed during life in response to changes
in the external and internal environment. From a functional point of view, it is important how the
muscle is involved in the locomotor chain.
According to Vařeka (2002), postural stability is related to the issue of ensuring correct upright
posture. This means that in the analysis of postural function, Kolář et al. (2009) distinguish between
postural stability, postural stabilization, and postural reactibility. Postural stability is the body as a
184
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
whole in a static position and does not change its position in space. However, each static position
(upright position, seat) contains implicitly dynamic actions. When taking a fixed position, it is not
a static state, but rather a certain process or process that faces the natural lability of the locomotor
system, which is a prerequisite for movement.
Postural stabilization is the active holding of body segments against the action of external forces,
controlled by the central nervous system. It is a muscular activity that strengthens segments of the
body against the action of external forces (mainly gravity). Without coordinated muscle activity,
our skeleton would collapse.
With every movement that is demanding on the force, a contractile muscle force is always
generated, which is needed to overcome the resistance. They call this reaction stabilization function
postural reactibility. It follows that the external stimulus stereotype leads to the formation of an
internal stereotype of neural actions. Not only targeted movement (phase movement) is automated,
but above all its postural securing (movement stabilization). It can be assumed that the movement
stereotype (movement and its posture) facilitates the operation of the central system in more
complex and more recurring situations. Our normal movements are performed automatically and
unconsciously, which very often causes us to use certain muscles insufficiently and to overload
others all day long without realizing it (Vařeka & Dvořák 2001; Kolář, 2009).
The unfavourable situation in musculoskeletal system in the school population is pointed out by
research by several domestic and foreign authors with an intent on the occurrence of incorrect
body posture, muscle imbalance, or disorders in the field of movement stereotypes (Malátová &
Matějková, 2011; Lemos et al., 2012).
Hypokinesia, lifestyle change, weight gain, and low muscle fitness are among the primary causes of
musculoskeletal disorders today (Gray et al., 2015; Bendíková, 2016; Bendíková et al., 2020;
Nemček & Ladecká, 2020). The current lifestyle of the school population in Slovakia has acquired
a hypokinetic character over the last two decades (Bendíková, 2018), which was also reflected in
the upward trend in chronic diseases of civilization (Booth et al., 2012), which includes disorders
of the musculoskeletal system (Acasandrei & Macovei, 2014). Insufficient primary prevention in
the musculoskeletal system from childhood leads to the emergence of vertebrogenic diseases in
adulthood, the prevalence of which is up to 60-80 %. Vertebrogenic disorders are associated with
the occurrence of poor body posture and muscle imbalance.
Postural activity is a complex of factors that lead to optimal posture maintenance during each
movement. Postural activity is part of every movement and is controlled by the central nervous
system. Postural stability ensures an upright body posture and responds to changes in external and
internal forces to prevent an uncontrollable fall (Vařeka, 2002).
The deep stabilizing system is the punctum fixum, a form of support for performing normal
movement. This knowledge can be used to improve the implementation of individual movements
185
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
in various correct postural patterns. Muscles in the body core called "core - deep stabilizing system"
are aimed at improving lumbopelvic stability. The core area consists of the diaphragm at the top,
the abdominal and oblique abdominal muscles at the front and the side, the paraspinal and gluteal
muscles at the back and the pelvic floor muscles at the bottom. These muscles are needed to ensure
the dynamic stability of the spine and other body segments (Vařeka, 2002).
It is important to start and focus on prevention from childhood, even before the onset of the initial
symptoms. Within physical and sport education, intervention in the form of postural educational
programs with an emphasis on the correct movement habits of everyday life is important
(Bendíková, 2020).
The aim of the research was to expand the knowledge, to find out and point out the level of the
musculoskeletal system with an emphasis on selected functions of the muscular system and body
posture in younger school-age pupils.
Method
Participants
The group consisted of 𝝨 288 younger school-age pupils in the number of (n) 150 girls and (n) 138
boys from the Central Slovakian region. The average body height in girls was (x) = 136.21 ± 4.8
cm and in boys (x) = 137.65 ± 5.1 cm. The average body weight in girls was (x) = 34.5 ± 8.6 kg
and in boys (x) = 35.12 ± 8.1 kg. The mentioned pupils attended the second, third and fourth years
of the I. grade of primary school. At the same time, they were willing to cooperate in the research
with the cooperation of physical education and sport teachers as well as parents and legal guardians.
The primary characteristics of the group are presented in Table 1.
Table 1 The primary characteristics of groups (n = 288)
(n = 288)
Girls (n = 150)
Body height / cm
Factors
136.21 ± 4.8
Age/ years 8.6 ± 1.4
BMI
24.6 ± 1.5
Legend: BMI - Body mass index
Body weight / kg
34.5 ± 8.6
Boys (n = 138)
Body height / cm
137.65 ± 5.1
8.8 ± 1.3
24.9 ± 1.7
Body weight / kg
35.12 ± 8.1
Data collection
The partial aim of the research was pursued in the Covid period from January to March 2022, when
measures were relaxed, and students attended the school in person. This pandemic period was
challenging in terms of obtaining data, as it was difficult to predict the situation we had to deal with
in the project.
186
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
In terms of data acquisition methods, we used two standardized methods for physical education
practice.
a) Method for evaluating body posture according to Labudová, Thurzová (1992). It is he method
of visual evaluation according to Klein and Thomas, modified by Mayer. The evaluation of the
individual areas was expressed as the sum of points, each area being evaluated by points 1, 2, 3, 4
according to the current level of body posture. It was followed by classification into the qualitative
body posture levels. The evaluation was focused on: I. Head and neck posture, II. Chest (shape),
III. Abdomen and pelvic inclination, IV. Spine curvature, V. Frontal body posture (Evaluation of
shoulders - Shoulder blades / scapulas).
Evaluation of body postures:
I. Correct body posture ..........................................................................5 points
II. Good (almost correct) body posture ...............................................6 – 10 points
III. Bad body posture …........................................................................11 – 15 points
IV. Incorrect body posture ....................................................................16 – 20 points
b) The method of evaluating the quality of the locomotor system function according to Janíková
(1998) with an intention of involving muscle groups in the muscle chains.
In the area of the head and upper trunk, we observed the upper cross syndrome between the
following muscle groups:
type A - shortening of the upper part of m. trapezius and weakening of the lower blade fixators,
type B - shortening of mm. pectoralis and weakened interscapular muscles,
type C - imbalance between deep neck flexors and neck extensors.
In the area of the pelvis and lower trunk, we observed the lower cross syndrome, most often
represented by muscle imbalance between muscle groups:
type A - weakened mm. gluteus maximus and shortened hip flexors,
type B - weakened m. abdominal and shortened m. erector spinae lumbalis,
type C - weakened gluteus medius and shortened mm. tensor fasciate latae (a m. quadratus
lumborum).
Data analysis
In terms of data processing methods, the following were applied: percentage frequency analysis
(%), frequency (n), arithmetic mean (x), standard deviation (s), range of variation (Vrmax-min) and
Chi-square test of goodness (χ2 p < 0.01, p < 0.05). We also used methods of logical analysis and
synthesis using inductive and deductive methods, comparison, and generalization, compared with
187
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
the literature and presented in tables. The data were processed using the statistical program RProject.
Results and discussion
The presented results must be understood in the overall context as indicative and initial in relation
to the postural health of younger school-age pupils, as well as in the creation of the content of
physical and sport education. The analysis shows that younger school-age pupils have functional
disorders manifested by incorrect movement stereotypes, which also results in an increased degree
of functional disorders in body posture.
Among the most common body posture functional disorders in younger school-age pupils 𝝨 (n =
288), which is presented in Table 2, we found out the following. In both, boys (n = 54. 39 %) and
girls (n = 78. 52 %), the highest percentage is kyphotic posture with a significant difference (χ2 =
9.890
, p < 0.01) to the detriment of girls. Also, in order for both genders are scoliotic posture (boys
n = 37. 27 %, girls n = 38. 25 %), hyperlordotic posture (boys n = 34. 25 %, girls n = 24. 16 %)
and finally, hypolordotic posture (boys n = 13. 9 %, girls n = 38. 25 %).
Table 2 Functional body posture disorders in younger school-age pupils (n = 288)
Functional disorders Kyphotic
BP /gender
body posture
Hyperlordotic
body posture
Hypolordotic
body posture
Scoliotic body
posture
Boys (n = 138)
n = 54 (39 %)
n = 34 (25 %)
n = 13 (9 %)
n = 37 (27 %)
Girls (n = 150)
n = 78 (52 n = 24 (16 %)
%)**
n = 10 (7 %)
n = 38 (25 %)
Legend: Body posture
The overall evaluation of body posture in boys is presented in Table 3. In the initial evaluation, we
found out that from of the whole group of boys 𝝨 (n = 138), only 18.84 % (n = 26) had I. level,
that means the Correct body posture, where the total point value was equal to 5. II. level, that
means the good body posture, for which it was necessary to achieve the sum of points between 6
and 10, reached only 18.11 % (n = 25) boys. Up to 49.29 % (n = 68) of boys (without one pupil
almost 50% of the group) had the III. level of body posture (Bad body posture), whose total point
was between 10 and 15. Incorrect body posture, represented by the fourth degree (point total was
at the level of 16 - 20 points) we noticed in 13.76 % (n = 19) boys. The most common quality level
in the monitored group of boys was Bad body posture (level III).
The overall body posture evaluation for girls was similar 𝝨 (n = 150) (Table 3). I. level - Correct
body posture we noticed in 13 % (n = 20) girls, II. level - Good body posture in 25 % (n = 37),
III. level - Bad body posture in 52 % (n = 78) and IV. Level - Incorrect body posture in 10 % (n
= 15) girls. The most common quality level in the monitored group of girls was Bad body posture
(level III).
188
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
In terms of qualitative evaluation of the total body posture between the groups, we noticed
significant differences (χ2 = 6.931, p < 0.05) in III. quality level to the detriment of the girls. The
average point score was at (x) = 11 ± 2.12, with a VRmax-min of 10.
Table 3 Total body posture of younger school-age pupils (n = 288)
Factors/gender Correct
body Good
body Bad
body Incorrect
body
posture
posture
posture
posture
Boys (n = 138) n = 26 (18.84 %) n = 25 (18.11 %) n = 68 (49.29 n = 19 (13.76 %)
%)
Girls (n = 150) n = 20 (13.00 %) n = 37 (25.00 %) n = 78 (52.00 n = 15 (10.00 %)
%)*
In the area of the I. evaluation – posture of head and neck, we evaluated 20 % (n = 30) girls and 26 %
(n = 36) boys with mark 1, whose eyes were facing forward, the mandible was normal retracted.
Direct view, but the axis of the neck was slightly tilted forward about 10 degrees, we noticed in 21
% (n = 32) girls and 20 % (n = 28) boys. We found the highest percentage of both, boys (n = 58.
42 %) and girls (n = 66. 44 %) with a mark of 3. We evaluated 15 % (n = 22) of girls and 12 % (n
= 16) boys with mark 4.
In the area of the II. evaluation – posture of chest, we noticed a normal chest, that is symmetrical, its
axis is vertical, is well arched, the ribs form a 30-degree angle with the spine, they move
symmetrically when breathing, thoracic kyphosis is physiological, in 56 % (n = 84) girls and 59 %
(n = 81) boys. We found out small deviations from the normal in the axis of the chest, a slope of
about 10 degrees in girls in 39 % (n = 59) and in boys in 38 % (n = 53). With a 2% difference to
the detriment of the girls and in the stated percentage, we found the same in boys (n = 4.3 %) as
well as in girls (n = 7.5 %), which was evaluated with mark 3, which is characterized by a flat chest
and the thoracic spine is considerably bent, the plumb line lowered from the nape of the neck bent
over the enlarged thoracic kyphosis, the plumb line attached to the apex of the thoracic kyphosis
pointed out of the head. A severe deviation of the shape of the chest, which is flat, the thoracic
spine is strongly bent in a complete arch has not been detected.
By evaluating the area of III. - evaluation of the abdomen and pelvic inclination, we evaluated 21 % (n =
30) girls with mark 1, 29 % (n = 48) with mark 2, and 45 % (n = 65) with mark 3. In Boys, 25 %
(n = 35) were evaluated with mark 1, 32 % (n = 44) by mark 2, and 41 % (n = 56) were evaluated
by mark 3. We found out the evaluation at level of 4 in 2 % of girls as well as in boys (nG = 7; nB
= 3).
In area IV. - evaluation of the spine curvature, with a mark1, we evaluated 22 % (n = 33) girls, and 29
% (n = 40) boys. We found out small deviations from the normal in the sense of plus or minus in
38 % (n = 57) of girls and 36 % (n = 50) of boys. We found out the apparently curved but also flat
189
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
back in approximately the same way for boys (48 %, n = 35) and girls (40 %, n = 60). We did not
find out any severe deviations from the normal in the observed group.
Next evaluated area was V. - evaluation of frontal body posture. Complete symmetry, the same height
of the shoulders, shoulders relaxed, the shoulder blades do not protrude, their inner axes are
parallel, we found out in 26 % (n = 39) girls and in 29 % (n = 40) boys. We also found out a slight
deviation in one point in girls (39 %, n = 59) and in boys (40 %, n = 55). We found out one side
extension, asymmetry, one shoulder higher in 35 % (n = 52) girls and in 31 % (n = 43) boys. We
did not find out any significant protrusion of the shoulder blades, considerable extension of the
hips, asymmetry of the thoraco-abdominal triangles in our group.
From the above findings, in body posture, the incorrect posture in the thoracic area of the spine
was found, with an intention for forward head posture, which dominated in both genders.
Compensation for this was the position in the abdominal posture. The erroneous postural
stereotype of forward head posture was found in all pupils, which was in the highest percentage
affected by the observed A type, the development of functional disorders of muscle groups m.
trapezius pars descendens and m. levator scapule, with the contribution of local imbalance between
m. sternocleidomastoid and deep head and neck flexors. Upper cross syndrome, type C, showed a
declining percentage-frequency tendency in both genders in relation to age (older age improved
quality of deep neck flexors) (Table 4). At the same time, we also found out the upper type of
breathing in the monitored group. This means that the probands helped with their shoulders when
breathing, thus not using their entire vital lung capacity. This was due to the belly contracting, then
the breath was automatically transferred to the higher segments. This way of breathing overloads
the muscles of the neck and the abdominal cavity is unable to relax. It also affects the internal
organs and, finally, it causes back pain.
The way of breathing and the stabilization of the trunk are very closely related. Disruption of static
and dynamic muscle interaction creates tension and imbalance. The pelvis, with its position, most
often by moving to the spine, significantly affects the function of the diaphragm.
Table 4 Upper cross syndrome in younger school-age pupils (n = 288)
Upper cross syndrome/gender
type A - upper part of m. trapezius and lower blade fixators,
type B - m. pectoralis and interscapular muscles
type C - deep neck flexors and neck extensors
Boys (n = 138)
n = 54 (39 %)
n = 44 (32 %)
n = 40 (29 %)
Girls (n = 150)
n = 63 (42 %)
n = 47 (31 %)
n = 41 (27 %)
Lower cross syndrome causes shortening the hip flexors, spine straighteners in the area of passing
from the lumbar spine to sacrum, and weakening of the sciatic, abdominal muscles. Disturbed
movement patterns are abduction and extension of the hip joint or enlarged lumbar lordosis
(Table5).
190
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
In girls, the situation in area of the lower cross syndrome was as follows. With increasing age, we
noticed a higher percentage of type A with a weakening of mm. gluteus maximus and shortening
of the hip flexors. The above findings also show the relationship between the state of muscle
groups and movement stereotypes in the activation of individual muscles in the extension of the
lower limb in the lumbar joint. It turned out that the weakened m. gluteus maximus was substituted
by the torso straightener and ischiocrural muscles.
Taner (2009) states that the gluteus maximus, which is associated with the thoracolumbar fascia
and the femoral fascia, can affect the position of the knee. Therefore, understanding the
relationship between the positioning of individual body segments is crucial for those, who are
involved in preventing and correcting body posture.
Table 5 Lower cross syndrome in younger school-age pupils (n = 288)
Lower cross syndrome/gender
type A - m. gluteus maximus and hip flexors
type B - m. abdominal and m. erector spinae lumbalis
type C - m. gluteus medius and mm. tensor fasciae latae
Boys (n = 138)
n = 53 (39 %)
n = 57 (41 %)
n = 28 (20 %)
Girls (n = 150)
n = 55 (37%)
n = 69 (46 %)
n = 26 (17 %)
Quality level of m. rectus abdominis, as well as substitution movement stereotypes in the group of
girls aged eight years had a low-quality level of function. With age, we noticed an improvement in
the monitored muscle group.
A similar situation was also in the group of younger boys, where we noticed a significant weakening
of the above-mentioned muscle group and substitution movement stereotype. In lower age groups,
type B of muscle imbalance dominated. While in older age, the lower cross syndrome of type A,
had a downward trend compared to girls. The findings show that the functional condition of the
tested muscle group improves with age. From the above, we state that these changes correspond
to the trend of ontogenetic development of the child.
In addition to these findings, the increased curvature of the cervical and lumbar spine in pupils was
not caused by the primary functional state of muscles and muscle groups, but by an incorrect
postural stereotype, which is caused by insufficient control of motor functions with low
neuromuscular coordination, as well as other external and internal factors, which may include the
number of hours spent in one-sided, statically overloaded positions, in the ergonomic layout and
equipment of the workplace, as well as movement and postural habits, as we found out.
Hagner, Bak & Hagner-Derengowska (2011), who examined a group of children aged 6 to 10 years,
observed a tendency for deteriorating body posture with increasing age. The percentage of good
body posture in 10-year-old pupils has almost halved compared to 6-year-olds, from 42 % to 27
%. Significant changes were observed in the inclination of the arms in the sagittal plane, the position
191
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
of the scapula, the asymmetry of the back shape in the forward bend.
Systematic monitoring of body posture (established in children) should continue after a period of
stabilization of body posture (Dolphens et al., 2012). Factors that affect body posture impairment,
especially those that can be modulated, should also be identified. Examples of such factors are
overweight and sedentary lifestyles. Their adverse effect on body posture quality has been
demonstrated many times (Jung et al., 2016; Maciałczyk-Paprocka et al., 2017). The position of the
individual body segments relative to each other is also important.
Body posture according to Khosravi et al. (2016) undergoes significant changes during their
lifetime. It is a development during which any mistake can cause a reduction in normal functioning
in the future, which is why it is important to monitor body posture, as children, adolescents and
adolescents often experience poor body posture. According to Ludwig et al. (2018), Bendíková
(2016, 2020), by regular physical activity we can improve the quality of body posture during
adolescence, which will have a positive effect on the adult body in the future.
Conclusion
The pilot empirical research in question contributes to the expansion of knowledge about the state
of postural health of young school-age pupils in relation to the occurring functional disorders in
the field of body posture because of incorrect movement stereotypes realized in the normal
movement regime.
The head, shoulders, and abdominal areas, which manifested themselves in the non-physiological
curvature of the spine and in the position of the observed body segments, are considered to be the
segments with the most frequent deviation from correct body posture in younger school-age pupils.
In terms of functional disorders, we found out disorders in body posture area, muscle imbalance
as a manifestation of movement stereotypes.
In connection with the issues addressed, the active school and physical and sport education lessons
are gaining in importance as a space for primary prevention and early intervention in terms of
supporting the postural health of pupils in the school environment (Bendíková, 2018).
Acknowledgements
The listed study is the part of research project VEGA “1/0427/22 Prevention of pupils' postural
health by physical activity “.
192
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
References
Acasandrei, L. & Macovei, S. (2014). The body posture and its imbalances in children and
adolescents. Science, Movement and Health, 14(2), 354-359.
Balkó, Š., Balkó, I. , Valter, L. & Jelínek, M. (2017). Influence of physical activities on the posture
in 10-11 year old schoolchildren. Journal of Physical Education and Sport, 17,S(1), 101-106.
DOI:10.7752/jpes.2017.s1016
Bendíková, E. (2017). Theory of health, movement and lifestyle of human beings. Debrecen: University of
Debrecen.
Bendíková, E. (2018). Health-Oriented Education in Slovakia Related to Physical and Sport
Education. Hungarian Educational Research Journal, 8(2), 39-49.
Bendíková, E. (2020). Diversification of the physical and sport education syllabi and its effects on
the musculoskeletal system in young female students. Trends in Sport Science, 27(3), 149-155.
doi: 10.23829/TSS.2020.27.3-5
Bendíková, E., Novotná, B., Rozim, R., Tomková, Š., Fyodorov, A. & Palaščáková Špringrová, I.
(2020). Analysis od physical activity status and functional posture in Slovakia's young schoolaged children with different body weight = [Analýza stavu pohybovej aktivity a funkčného
stavu držania tela u detí mladšieho školského veku rôznou telesnou hmotnosťou na
Slovensku]. Zdravotnícke listy, 8(2), 71-81.
Booth, F. W., Roberts, C. H. K., Laye, M. J. (2012). Lack of exercise is a major cause of chronic
diseases. Compr. Physiol., 2(2), 1143-1211. doi: 10.1002/cphy.c110025
Claus, A., Hides, J. A., Moseley, G. L. & Hodges, P. (2007). Different ways to balance the spine:
subtle changes in sagittal spinal curves affect regional muscle activity. Spine, 34(6), 208-214.
Dolphens, M., Cagnie, B., Vleeming, A., Vanderstraeten, G., Coorevits, P. & Danneels, L. (2012).
A clinical postural model of sagittal alignment in young adolescents before age at peak height
velocity. Eur Spine J., 5, 21(11), 2188–97. doi: 10.1007/s00586-012-2416-7
Gray, C. et al. (2015). What is the relationship between outdoor time and physical activity, sedentary
behaviour, and physical fitness in children? A systematical review. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public
Health. 12(6), 6455-6474. doi:10.3390/ijerph120606455.
Hagner, W., Bak, D., & Hagner-Derengowska, M. (2011). Changes in body posture in children
between the 10th and 13th years of age. Polish Annals of Medicine, 18(1), 76–81.
doi: 10.1016/S1230-8013(11)70025-X.
Janíková, D. (1998). Fyzioterapia funkčná diagnostika lokomočného systému. Martin: Osveta.
Jung, S. I, Lee, N. K, Kang, K. W., Kim, K. & Lee, D. Y. (2016). The effect of smartphone usage
time on posture and respiratory function. J. Phys. Ther. Sci., 28(1), 186–189.
Kellmann, M., Bertollo, M., Bosquet, L., Brink, M., Coutts, A. J., Duffield, R., Erlacher, D., Halson,
S. L., Hecksteden, A., Heidari, J., Kallus, K.W., Meeusen, R., Mujika, I., Robazza, C., Skorski,
S., Venter, R. & Beckmann J. (2018). Recovery and performance in sport: consensus
statement. International journal of sports physiology and performance, 13(2), 240-245.
Kolář, P. et al. (2009). Rehabilitace v klinické praxi. Praha: Galén.
Labudová, J. & Thurzová, E. (1992). Teória a didaktika zdravotnej telesnej výchovy [Theory and didactics
of health physical education]. Bratislava: FTVŠ UK.
193
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Lafond, D., Descarreaux, M., Normand, M. C. & Harrison, D. E. (2007). Postural development in
school children: a cross sectional study. Chiropractic & Osteopathy, 15(1), 1-11.
doi: 10.1186/1746-1340-15-1.
Lemos, A. T., Santos, F. R. & Gaya, A. C. A. (2012). Lumbar hyperlordosis in children and
adolescents at a privative school in southern Brazil: occurrence and associated factors.
Cadernos De Saúde Pública, 28(4), 781–788.
Maciałczyk-Paprocka, K., Stawińska-Witoszyńska, B., Kotwicki, T., Sowińska, A., Krzyżaniak, A.,
Walkowiak, J. et al. (2017). Prevalence of incorrect body posture in children and adolescents
with overweight and obesity. Eur J Pediatr., 176(5), 563–72. doi:10.1007/s00431-017-2873-4
Modrzejewska, J. & Malec, Z. (2017). Faulty body posture amongst pupils in primary education.
News and Research Reports, 63(3), 85–94.
Nemček, D. & Ladecká, P. (2020). Úroveň osobnej pohody stredoškolákov s poruchami
muskuloskeletálneho systému = [The level of subjective well-being of high school students
with musculoskeletal disorders]. Zdravotnícke listy, 8(2), 16-21.
Olekšák, O. & Nemček, D. (2021). Gender differences in subjective well-being of high school
students with self-reported health disorders participating in sport leisure activities. Studia
Scientifica Facultatis Paedagogicae, 20(5), 15-27.
Siedentop, D. L., Hastie, P. & Van der Mars, H. (2019). Complete guide to sport education. Human
Kinetics.
Smith, B. & McGannon, K. R. (2018). Developing rigor in qualitative research: Problems and
opportunities within sport and exercise psychology. International review of sport and exercise
psychology, 11(1), 101-121.
Yu, C. W., Sung, R. Y., So, R., Lam, K., Nelson, E. A, Li, A. M., Yuan, Y. & Lam, P. K. (2002).
Energy expenditure and physical activity of obese children: cross-sectional study. Hong Kong
medical journal = Xianggang yi xue za zhi / Hong Kong Academy of Medicine, 8, 313–317.
Tanner J. M. (2009). Growth and Maturation during Adolescence. Nutr. Rev., 39, 43–55.
Vařeka, I. & Dvořák, R. (2001). Posturální model řetězení poruch funkce pohybového systému.
Rehabilitace a fyzikální lékatství, 8(1), 33-37.
Vařeka, I. (2002). Posturální stabilita. Terminologie a biomechanické principy. Rehabilitace a fyzikální
lékařství, 4, 115–121.
Winnick, J. & Porretta, D. L. (2018). Adapted physical education and sport. Human Kinetics.
WHO. (2018). Global action plan on physical activity 2018-2030: more active people for a healthier world.
Ženeva: WHO, 2018, 101 p. ISBN 978-92-4-151418-7
194
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Demographic Factors towards Online Learning Readiness of
Physical Education and Sports Science Undergraduate Students
during the COVID-19 Pandemic
Ngien-Siong Chin1 - Kie-Yin Teng2 - How-Yew Lee2
1
Institute of Teacher Education Batu Lintang Campus, Sarawak, Malaysia
Institute of Teacher Education Tun Abdul Razak Campus, Sarawak, Malaysia
e-mail: ngiensiong@gmail.com
2
Abstract
The unprecedented pandemic has adopted digital technology by shifting traditional teaching
pedagogy to online learning which has emerged as the main methodology and continuity of
education globally. This study aimed to examine the effect of demographic factors towards online
learning readiness among physical education and sports science undergraduate students. The
respondents comprised of (108 male and 102 female) aged between 18 to 23 years of age.
Descriptive statistics, independent t-test and one-way ANOVA was utilised. The results revealed
no significant difference in the students’ readiness for online learning based on their gender and
age groups. The Institution of Higher Learning needs to be more inclined towards creating
academics and student-centric instructional and learning environment that can facilitate new online
teaching and learning pedagogical approaches that can complement students’ equity and diversity
at tertiary-level.
Key words: Online learning readiness, Physical education, Sports science, Gender, Age groups
195
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
The unprecedented pandemic global crisis has resulted in varying degrees of sustainable restriction
by 186 countries to prevent, control and slow the transmission. The era of the pandemic has
resulted in the world been evolved with technological advancements since 2019 that has reshaped,
connect and embrace global societies at astonishing speed. These challenges have forced the global
educational system to quickly adopt and integrate the usage of digital technologies as alternative
to replace the traditional educational methodology of face-to-face teaching and learning in schools,
colleges, institutes and universities (Valverde-Berrocoso, 2021). This option has led to major
interruptions in teacher teaching and student learning having to adjust to online learning which
have also led to numerous challenges such as internet accessibilities, lack of infrastructure and
resources, insufficient training, developing and educating the teachers and students in their
teaching and learning competencies through digital technologies. Studies had shown the
importance of collaborative approaches in teaching and learning through different social practice
strategies in order to facilitate the process of teaching and learning (Valverde-Berrrocoso, 2021).
The complex process of integrating various practice-oriented and modelling strategies to improve
the teaching and learning on the pedagogical utilisation of digital technologies need to apply,
sustain and harness the potential of online-learning.
Among the disciplines which have disrupted are physical education and sports science which
tended to be emphasised in term of education reform as compare to other majors in the institutions
of higher learning. In these both disciplines require appropriate venues, instruments, equipment’s,
learning through movement, physical activities and exercises integrating with thinking activities
which are the challenges faced through online learning (Zheng et al. 2021). With online learning
through various digital resources and learning models to enrich the PE and sports science content,
the PE educators and students have to adopt, adapt and apply technology in teaching and learning
to satisfy the needs of modern education which play a crucial role in teaching methodologies and
learning effectiveness. Therefore, the application of online learning environment in terms of its
success would lies upon the students’ readiness towards online learning. Bloom (1995) stated that
readiness plays an imperative role in the education process in terms of inputs within the teaching
and learning system. The readiness of the students’ based on their level, ability and competence
before the online learning started is crucial in their gradual progress in the learning effectiveness.
Thus, online learning readiness (OLR) is the state of being motivated either physically and mentally
for both teachers and students through the use of digital technologies towards digital learning (Nor
Aniza & Chua, 2015). Studies had emphasised the importance and benefits of online learning
through learning technologies such as synchronous and asynchronous and multimedia
technologies towards learning stressing the essentiality to place digital learning competence with
innovative online education models (Colarado & Eberle, 2021). Since future PE teachers are the
emplemary role model in digital technologies within their disciplines, they would need to integrate
technical training, reflective knowledge and skills in their pedagogical teaching and learning
methodologies within the technological platform into online learning (Zheng et al., 2021). These
196
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
will lead to individual’s readiness to learn online which would are crucial to the success of the
performance academically (Engin, 2017).
There are five dimensions in OLR which comprised of self-directed learning, motivation for
learning, internet self-efficacy, online communication self-efficacy and learner control which
played a fundamental role in the online learning process. Studies had shown that university
students have higher self-regulated learning such as elaboration, thinking critically and selfregulated in their online learning as well as ready in adapting and engaging online learning (Adams
et al., 2021; Chung, Subramaniam & Dass, 2020). Herguner et al. (2021) study showed that sports
science students had positive attitudes toward OLR in which online learning attitude of the
students correlated positively with OLR.
Though studies have examined OLR of students but has not examined its readiness towards the
disciplines of physical education and sports science (Chung et al., 2020; Kamaruzaman et al. 2021;
Siti Norazian Miskam et al., 2020). Thus, this study sought to examine the OLR of physical
education and sports science students in institutions of higher learning in terms of their level of
OLR and relationship between the students’ demographics and OLR.
Methods
Participants
The respondents comprised of undergraduate physical education and sports science students from
several Institution of Higher Learning during the second semester of 2021. This is cross-sectional
online survey design via Google Form which was the feasible way to facilitate data collection. The
students participated in the study voluntarily with their consent and have the right to withdraw at
any time.
Ethics
The study was approved by the Institute of Teacher Education Batu Lintang Campus Research
Committee in accordance with the International Declaration of Helsinki guidelines. All
respondents were briefed on the study in terms of the purpose, voluntary, confidentiality and
anonymity and their consents were obtained.
Data analysis
The Statistical Package for the Social Science (SPSS) 24.0 was utilised to analyse the data. The
descriptive statistics, independent sample t-tests and one-way Anova was used to examine the
gender and age groups of the OLR variables.
Measures
The Online Learning Readiness Scale (OLRS: Hung et al., 2020) was utilised to measure the
readiness of physical education and sports science students on online learning. The OLRS consists
of 18 items that encompassed of 5 dimensions which include computer and internet self-efficacy,
197
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
self-directed learning, learner control, motivation for learning and online communication selfefficacy. The OLRS is measured on a 5-point Likert scale ranging from 1 (strongly agree) to 5
(strongly agree). The internal consistency for computer and internet self-efficacy (.94), self-directed
learning (.92), learner control (.93), motivational for learning (.92), online communication skills
efficacy (.93) and overall OLR (.90) demonstrating high consistency.
Findings and Discussion
Demographic Profile of Respondents
A total of 210 responses collected from all the respondents. Table 1 shows the respondents' general
background information. It is noticeable that the respondents were at the age of 18 to 23 years old
of which consisting of Malay (45.2%), Chinese (26.2%), Bumiputera Sarawak and Sabah (28.5%).
There were 58.1% of them took up Physical Education while 41.9% of them took up Sports
Science. Most of them (58.1%) came from IPGK Batu Lintang, Ilmu Khas and Kent. Whereas,
the remaining (41.9%) studied in UiTM.
Table 1 Demographic Profile of Respondents
Variables
Gender
Age
Ethicity
Education
IPG / University
Group
male
female
18-19
20-21
22-23
Malay
Chinese
Bumiputera Sarawak
Bumiputera Sabah
Physical Education
Sports Science
IPGK Batu Lintang
IPGK Ilmu Khas
IPGK Kent
UiTM
Frequency
108
102
76
64
70
95
55
36
24
122
88
73
36
13
88
Valid %
51.4
48.6
36.2
30.5
33.3
45.2
26.2
17.1
11.4
58.1
41.9
34.8
17.1
6.2
41.9
Data Normality Test
In order to identify the relationship of demographic factors on the level of OLR among
undergraduate students, t-test and anova was performed. The data normality assumption should
198
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
be fulfilled prior proceed with the t-test and anova. As mentioned in previous section, researchers
applied skewness and kurtosis test to determine the data distribution of the variables involved. Z
values for both skewness and kurtosis should be located in the acceptable region, -3.29 to 3.29
(Kim, 2013). From Table 2, the Z values for skewness was at -.226 whereas the values for kurtosis
was at -2.078. Thus, the normality assumption of the data was accepted in this analysis.
Table 2 Descriptive Statistics
Online
Learning
Readine
ss
Valid N
(listwise)
N
Statisti
c
Minimu
m
Statistic
Maximu
m
Statistic
Mean
Statisti
c
Std.
Deviatio
n
Statistic
210
2.31
5.00
3.901
.622
Skewness
Std.
Statisti
Erro
c
r
-.038
.168
Kurtosis
Std.
Statisti
Erro
c
r
-.694
.334
210
Interpretative scales for the study variables
For the purpose of interpretation in descriptive analysis, each of the study variables was
appropriately assigned an interpretative scale as according to the Mathematical formula
recommended by Gravetter and Wallnau (2015). In order to standardise the interpretation for
descriptive analysis on the overall level of the variables, researchers have set five value labels or
divisions for each of them as in Table 3. For instance, very low, low, moderate, high and very high
levels.
Table 3 Interpretative Scale for Online Learning Readiness Scale (OLRS)
Value
1.00 – 1.80
Value Level
Very low
1.81 – 2.60
2.61 – 3.40
Low
Moderate
3.41 – 4.20
4.21 – 5.00
High
Very high
Level on Online Learning Readiness
As shown in Table 4, descriptively, the overall OLR was at high level, 3.90 (SD=.043). The mean
199
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
score for all the dimensions: computer/internet self-efficacy, self-directed learning, learner control,
motivation for learning as well as online communication self-efficacy was at high level too, 4.00
(SD=.736); 3.86 (SD=.695); 3.72 (SD=.744); 4.07 (SD=.690) and 3.86 (SD=.790) respectively.
Table 4 Descriptive Statistics on Students’ Online Learning Readiness
Online Learning Readiness
Computer/internet self-efficacy
Self-directed learning
Learner control
Motivation for learning
Online communication selfefficacy
Valid N (listwise)
N
Minimum
Maximum
Mean
Std. Deviation
210
210
210
210
210
2.31
1.67
1.40
2.00
2.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
5.00
3.90
4.00
3.86
3.72
4.07
.043
.736
.695
.744
.690
210
1.33
5.00
3.86
.790
210
Effect Of Age Groups on Online Learning Readiness
A one-way between subjects ANOVA was performed to compare the effect of age groups on
OLR of undergraduate students towards Physical Education and Sports Science during the
COVID-19 pandemic. Table 5 indicated that there was no significant effect of age groups on
online learning readiness at the p>.05 level for the three conditions [F(2, 207) = .589, p >.05]. This
has shown that the age of the students does not have an effect on OLR. This may because of the
range of the respondents are small of which only different by five years old. Therefore, the age
groups did not influence much on their OLR. However, this finding was contradicted with Chung
et al. (2020), Elumalai et al. (2020) and Zulaikha Khairuddin et al. (2020) which found that the
students who were estimated different by five years old (Diploma to Bachelors; Bachelor’s 1st year
to Masters 2nd years) varied in their perceptions on e-learning. This is likely to occur because older
students are more likely to have a higher level of confidence than younger pupils because they
have had more online learning experience. As students in the upper levels of education are often
older, the situation is likely comparable to that of students at different educational levels.
Table 5 Tests of Between-Subjects Effects Online Learning Readiness across Students’ Age Groups
Between Groups
Within Groups
Total
Sum of Squares
.458
80.490
80.948
df
2
207
209
200
Mean Square
.229
.389
F
.589
Sig.
.556
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Differences In Gender Towards Online Learning Readiness
An independent-samples-t-test was conducted to compare OLR among male and female students.
From Table 6, there was a not significant difference in the scores for males (M=3.84, SD=.660)
and females (M=4.00, SD=.576); t (208)=-1.476, p=.141. This finding is consistent with Cole,
Shelly and Swartz (2014) which found that there was no significant difference in online learning
satisfaction between male and female. However, the results were contradicted to the previous
literature which has found that male and female students were different in terms of their quality
of e-learning, satisfaction, motivation, study habits, learning experience and learning strategies
(Chung et al., 2020; Cuadrado-García et al., 2010; Elumalai et al., 2020; Peixoto et al., 2012). These
could be due to both genders have adopted digital technology from a tender age as they were from
the Generation Z whose birth started from 1995 (Lau et al., 2021). Both genders could have equal
opportunities and chances to learn and access to digital technologies in the educational system
such as schools and Institutions of Higher Learning. In addition, with greater progress and support
from the Malaysian government towards gender equality, women empowerment and educational
opportunities have resulted in both genders being able to have similar equal competencies towards
OLR.
Table 6 One-Sample Statistics
Online Learning
Readiness
Demography
N
Mean
Std. Error Mean
3.839
Std.
Deviation
.660
male
108
female
102
3.966
.576
.057
.064
Table 7 One-Sample Test
Variables
t
df
Sig. (2-tailed)
Gender
-1.476
208
.141
Mean
Difference
-.126
Conclusion
Universities, faculties, and educators must be prepared to encounter more online learning in the
future. This is due to the students' readiness, with the majority agreeing that they are virtually ready
to participate in online learning in the future. This issue is also aided by the rapid advancement of
technology that occurs every year.
201
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Furthermore, students today are digital natives, meaning they are more comfortable with the usage
of technology in their daily lives, such as utilizing gadgets and accessing the internet. As a result,
educators must keep up with technological advancements in education and be more advanced than
their students. This is because, in the future, instructors will need to be more prepared when
creating lesson plans. As a result, additional training should be provided to both educators and
students in order to provide them with the knowledge required to conduct online learning. The
limitation of the study is that the respondents were mainly from Sarawak in which the findings
cannot be generalize to other populations in Malaysia. Thus, future research could examine online
learning readiness with students from other Institution of Higher Learning from Sabah and West
Malaysia and how online learning readiness and sociodemographic variables are associated with
emotional distress, mental health and well-being as relevant health outcomes
To summaries, lecturers cannot only deliver a better online learning approach, but also improve
their online experience and satisfaction by knowing OLR among their students and how
demographic factors affect this readiness. Based on the findings of this study, it is proposed that
other researchers perform a qualitative research study to gain a deeper understanding of students'
readiness to participate in online learning. This is where researchers may analyse more detailed
data in order to better serve students' requirements and stay current with educational technologies.
As a result, future investigations will be able to qualitatively support the findings of the current
study.
Conflicts of interest
The authors declare that the study was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial
relationships that could be constructed as a potential conflict of interest.
References
Adams, D., Chuah, K.M., Sumintono, B., & Mohamed, A. (2021). Students’ readiness for elearning during the COVID-19 pandemic in a South-East Asian university:a Rasch analysis.
Asian Education and Development Studies. https://doi.org/10.1108/AEDS-05-2020-0100
Chung, E., Subramaniam, G., & Dass, L. C. (2020). Online learning readiness among university
students in Malaysia amidst Covid-19. Asian Journal of University Education, 16 (2), 46- 58.
https://doi.org/10.24191/ajue.v16i2.10294
Cole, M.T., Shelley, D.J. & Swartz, L. B. (2014). Online instruction, e-learning, and student
satisfaction: a three-year study. The International Review of Research in Open and Distance Learning.
15(6), 111-131.
Colorado, J.T., & Eberle, J. (2010). Student demographics and success in online learning
environments. Emporia State Research Studies, 41(1), 4-10.
202
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Cuadrado-García, M., Ruiz-Molina, M. E., & Montoro-Pons, J. D. (2010). Are there gender
differences in e-learning use and assessment? Evidence from an interuniversity online
project in Europe. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 367–371.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sbspro.2010.03.027
Elumalai, K. V., Sankar, J. P., R, K., John, J. A., Menon, N., Alqahtani, M. S. N., & Abumelha. M.
A. (2020). Factors affecting the quality of e-learning during the COVID-19 pandemic from
the perspective of higher education students. Journal of Information Technology Education:
Research, 19, 731-753.
Gravetter, F., & Wallnau, L. (2015). Statistics for behavioral sciences (10th ed.). Cengage Learning, Inc.
Hung, M. L., Chou, C., Chen, C. H., & Own, Z. Y. (2010). Learner readiness for online learning:
Scale development and student perceptions. Computers & Education, 55(3), 1080-1090.
Hueguner, G., Yaman, C., CglakSari, S., Yaman, M.S., & Donmez, A. (2021). The effect of online
learning attitudes of sports sciences students on their online learning readiness to learn in
the era of the new coronavirus pandemic. The Turkish Online Journal of Educational, 20 (1), 6877.
Kamaruzaman, F. M., Sulaiman, N. A., & Shaid, N. A. N. (2021). A study on perception of
students’ readiness towards online learning during covid-19 pandemic. International Journal of
Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences, 11(7), 1536–1548.
http://dx.doi.org/10.6007/IJARBSS/v11-i7/10488
Kim, H. Y. (2013). Statistical notes for clinical researchers: assessing normal distribution (2)
using skewness and kurtosis. Restorative Dentistry & Endodontics, 38(1), 52-54.
Lau, Y. Y., Tang, Y.M., Chau, K.Y., Vyvas, L., Sandoval-Hernandez, A. & Wong, S. (2021). Covid19 crisis: exploring community of inquiry in online learning for sub-degree students. Frontier
in Psychology, 12. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2021.679197
Nor Aniza Ahmad & Chua, L.N. (2015). Technology and higher education: Using an E-learning
tutorial as a pedagogy for innovation and flexible learning, Malaysian Journal of Distance
Learning, 17(1), 21-31.
Peixoto, H. M., Peixoto, M. M., & Alves, E. D. (2012). Learning strategies used by undergraduate
and postgrad-uate students in hybrid courses in the area of health. Revista Latino-Americana
de Enfermagem, 20(3), 551–558. https://doi.org/10.1590/s0104-11692012000300017
Siti Norazian Miskam, Liaw, Y. H., & Zulfadhli Osman. (2020). Tahap kesediaan pembelajaran
atas talian pelajar Kolej Komuniti Beufort (KKBS). Proceedings of 4th National Research and
Innovation Conference, 293-298.
Valverde-Berrocoso, J., Fernández-Sánchez, M. R., Revuelta Dominguez, F. I., & Sosa-Díaz, M. J.
(2021). The educational integration of digital technologies preCovid-19: Lessons for teacher
education. PloS One, 16(8), e0256283. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0256283
Zheng, W., Ma, Y.-Y., & Lin, H.-L. (2021). Research on Blended Learning in Physical Education
During the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Case Study of Chinese Students. SAGE Open.
https://doi.org/10.1177/21582440211058196
Zulaikha Khairuddin, Nik Nur Athirah Nik Mohd Arif, & Zurina Khairuddin (2020). Students'
readiness on online distance learning (ODL). Universal Journal of Educational Research, 8(12),
7141 - 7150. https://doi.org/10.13189/ujer.2020.081281
203
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
204
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Characteristics of Morphofunctional Features of Men Engaged in
Power Martial Arts - on Example of Arm Wrestling
Nikulin Igor Nikolaevich1 - Posokhov Alexey Viktorovich1 Sobyanin Fedor Ivanovich1 - Beketov Oleg Vladimirovich1 Bogacheva Elizabeth Alekseevna2
1
2
Belgorod State National Research University, Belgorod, Russia
Belgorod Institute of Education Development, Belgorod, Russia
e-mail: sosnovi60@mail.ru
Abstract
The purpose of the study is a comparative analysis of morphofunctional features of arm wrestlers
of different skill levels and weight categories. The study involved 40 arm wrestlers of various
qualifications and training experience. The athletes were divided into two groups of 20 people
each: athletes of low skill level with 1-3 years of training experience; qualified athletes with
sporting achievements at the All-Russian and international level of competitions, with 4-10 years
of training experience. The methodology for studying the morphofunctional features of arm
wrestlers included the following indicators: standing height, body weight, chest circumference,
shoulder, forearm. Dynamometric measurements were made: brush and deadlift dynamometry.
The following indices were calculated: weight-height Quetelet index, Erisman's chest-height
index, life index, Pinier's physique strength index, power indices. The results obtained indicate
that qualified athletes have morphofunctional features that differ from athletes of a low level of
skill, probably due to which they achieve great success in arm wrestling. These features are the
best development of the girdle of the upper limbs: the muscles of the forearm and shoulder, as
well as the muscles of the back, which allows you to show great results in carpal and postural
dynamometry and in fights at competitions. As the weight category increases, a wave-like increase
in the average value of carpal dynamometry was revealed. With the growth of the weight
category, the indicators of the power index of the leading hand of qualified athletes decrease in
waves.
Key words: Arm wrestling, Morphofunctional features, Anthropometry, Beginners and qualified
athletes, Dynamometry, Power indices, Weight categories.
205
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
Arm wrestling is a sport that has received nationwide recognition for its accessibility and
entertainment. In 2020, a significant event for the development of this type of power martial arts
took place - by the decision of the International Federation of Physical Education (FISU), arm
wrestling was included in the program of the World Universiade. The growth in the popularity of
arm wrestling is still ahead of the process of scientific and methodological support for the
training and competitive activities of athletes.
Arm wrestling is a power sport, manifested in the form of martial arts, where the most important
success factor is the actual power, speed-strength qualities and strength endurance. Motor actions
in the process of performing various exercises, including power ones, differ in biomechanical
structure, duration of performance, intensity, and other features. These features are associated
with the mode of muscle work, which can be dynamic, static or statodynamic in nature (V.N.
Kurys, 2013).
One of the most promising areas in modern sports is the accounting of morphofunctional data,
since it allows to increase the success of athletes' performance by improving physical fitness,
improving technique, as well as preventing injuries and improving the level of health in general.
Currently, in many sports (sports games, weightlifting and athletics), anthropometric and
morphofunctional features of athletes are being actively studied, certain patterns of their changes
under the influence of training have been identified, and a methodology for assessing physical
development has been developed (E.M. Martirosov, 2010; D. B. Nikityuk, 2011; A.F. Zekrin,
2015, etc.). Comparative analysis of morphological and functional features is widely used in the
analysis of the state of athletes in martial arts.
Yagello V. and co-authors (2004), studied the relationship of anthropometric indicators in
relation to the level of sportsmanship of highly qualified judokas. The authors found the
interdependence of the width of the pelvis, shoulder, elbow and diameter of the forearm with the
improvement of sports skills.
V.V. Semenov V.V. (2013) analyzed the morphological features of sports talent in women's
freestyle wrestling. The author highlights the most informative indicators that differ depending
on the weight categories. These include longitudinal, transverse and girth indicators of the thigh,
lower leg, shoulder and forearm.
L.V. Porigalo and co-authors (2016) studying the representatives of percussion (karate, hand-tohand combat, taekwondo) and throwing martial arts (judo, Greco-Roman wrestling), found that
anthropometric indicators are characterized by the greatest contribution to the formation of a
functional system for the growth of sportsmanship: body length and weight, chest circumference,
carpal dynamometry, shoulder width.
206
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
R.E. Sirazetdinov and co-authors (2021), based on a factor analysis of body size with the
calculation of micro / macrosomia indicators, the features of body proportions in highly qualified
combat athletes (various types of wrestling) characteristic of Russian and Altai men were
revealed: a strong chest, broad shoulders, relatively short legs and elongated arms, minimal
development of fat deposition on the body and limbs.
In arm wrestling, such studies are still few in number (L.V. Podrigalo et al., 2013, 2016; A.V.
Posokhov et al., 2017; Akpinar S., 2013) and they cover a fairly narrow range of indicators. So, in
his work L.V. Podrigalo et al. (2010) cite some anthropometric and morphological indicators
confirming the superiority of athletes of the highest skill level over athletes of mass categories
and those without categories. Akpinar S., 2013 et al. we considered some anthropological
predictors that affect the effectiveness of arm wrestling competitions. At the same time, the
authors examined athletes of a number of weight categories, but not all of them provided for by
the Competition Rules. There are still not enough studies analyzing various morphofunctional
data of arm wrestlers, especially taking into account the weight category of athletes.
Therefore, the purpose of this study was a comparative analysis of morphofunctional features of
arm wrestlers of different skill levels and weight categories.
Materials and methods
A methodology for studying the morphofunctional features of arm wrestlers was developed,
which includes a number of anthropometric, morphological and dynamometric measurements, as
well as the calculation of several indices. When measuring the indicators of armwrestlers, we used
the recommendations of well-known specialists in this field (G.D. Aleksanyants, 2005; E.G.
Martirosov, 2006).
The methodology for studying the anthropometric and morphofunctional features of
armwrestlers included the following indicators: standing height, body weight, chest
circumference, shoulder, forearm.
Weight-height index Quetelet. It characterizes the ratio of body length to its mass. Calculated
𝑃
according to the formula: 𝐼 = , where P is the weight in grams, L is the length of the body in
𝐿
cm. The average values of the Quetelet index: men - 350-400 g/cm, women - 325-375 g/cm,
athletes - 400 g/cm and above.
Erisman's chest-height index. Allows you to evaluate the development of the chest. Calculated
according to the formula: 𝐼 = 𝑇 − 0,5х𝐿, Where T is the circumference of the chest at rest in
cm, L is the height in cm. For male athletes, it is on average 5.8 cm, for female athletes 3.8 cm. A
large value indicates a wide chest.
207
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
The life index characterizes the functionality of the respiratory apparatus. It is determined by
dividing the vital capacity of the lungs (in ml) by body weight (in kg), i.e., it calculates how much
lung volume falls on 1 kg of body weight. For example, the body weight of the subject is 70 kg,
and the vital capacity of the lungs is 5600 ml. Life index = 5600/70 = 80 ml/kg. For men, the
index should be at least 65–70 ml/kg, for women at least 55–60 ml/kg. For athletes and female
athletes, the index, as a rule, is higher than these figures.
Strength indices determine the development of the strength of individual muscle groups relative
to body weight. They are obtained by dividing strength by weight and are expressed as a
percentage. For example, the strength of the right hand of the subject is 60 kg, the dead strength
is 200 kg, and the body weight is 70 kg. Force index for the hand = 60/70100% =85%. Strength
index for backbone strength = 200/70100% = 285%.
The average values of hand strength in men are considered to be 70-75% of the weight (in
athletes 75-81%), in women 50-60% (in athletes 60-70%). For back strength, the average values
for men are 200–220% (for athletes 260–300%), for women 135–150% (for athletes 150–200%).
The indicator of body strength (according to Pignet) expresses the difference between standing
height and the sum of body weight and chest circumference:
Х = Р — (В+О),
where: X - index, P - height (cm), B - body weight (kg), O - chest circumference in the
exhalation phase (cm). The smaller the difference, the better the indicator (in the absence of
obesity).
A difference less than 10 is rated as a strong physique, from 10 to 20 - good, from 21 to 25 average, from 25 to 35 - weak, more than 36 - very weak. The material obtained during the study
was processed using the method of mathematical statistics using Student's t-test.
The study involved 40 arm wrestlers of various qualifications and experience. Athletes were
divided into two groups of 20 people each: athletes of low skill level with 1-3 years of training
experience; qualified athletes with sporting achievements at the All-Russian and international
level of competitions, with 4-10 years of experience.
Results
The results of the study of anthropometric and morphofunctional indicators of arm wrestlers are
presented in Table 1.
208
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Table 1 The results of the study of anthropomorphological indicators of arm wrestlers
of various skill levels
№
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
Indicators
Height, cm
Weight, kg
chest circumference, cm
Right shoulder circumference,
cm
Left shoulder circumference,
cm
Right forearm circumference,
cm
Left forearm circumference, cm
Wrist circumference, cm
Vital capacity of the lungs,l
Carpal dynamometry, right, kg
Carpal dynamometry, left, kg
Deadlift dynamometry, kg
Low level
athletes, М±σ
177,6±2,06
79,7±2,00
97,6±2,06
38,1±0,87
Qualified
Athletes, М±σ
177,6±2,06
87,0±4,11
102,0±1,73
40,5±0,87
Difference
t
p
0
7,3
4,4
2,4
0,0
1,6
1,6
1,9
>0,05
>0,05
>0,05
>0,05
37,8±0,76
40,4±0,97
2,6
2,1
<0,05
33,1±0,65
36,2±0,54
3,1
3,7
<0,05
32,6±0,65
17,4±0,27
5,2±0,24
52,7±2,38
53,5±3,03
140,8±8,12
35,4±0,70
19,0±0,22
5,8±0,17
73,3±3,35
66,8±4,33
180,7±11,9
2,8
1,6
0,6
20,6
13,3
39,9
2,9
4,5
2,0
5,0
2,5
2,8
<0,05
<0,05
>0,05
<0,05
<0,05
<0,05
Note: M is the average result for the group; σ is the standard deviation; t is the difference error; p
is the significance of differences according to Student's t-test.
Statistical processing of the results of the study revealed that the average value of such
anthropomorphological indicators as height, weight, chest circumference did not have significant
differences in arm wrestlers of a low level compared to qualified athletes. In such indicators as
the circumference of the right shoulder and the lung capacity difference is close to reliable in
favor of qualified athletes and Candidate to Master Sport, and it can be called a trend.
Attention is drawn to the reliability of differences in such indicators as the circumference of the
left shoulder (2.6 cm), the circumference of the right forearm (3.1 cm), the circumference of the
left forearm (2.8 cm), the circumference of the wrist (1.6 cm) in qualified athletes, compared with
athletes of mass categories. In indicators reflecting the strength of the hand and back, qualified
arm wrestlers also significantly outperform athletes of mass categories. Thus, the strength of the
right and left hand is significantly higher by 20.6 and 13.3 kg, respectively, and the strength of the
back muscles is by 39.9 kg (p<0.05).
After calculating and analyzing various anthropomorphological indices presented in Table 2, the
following conclusions can be drawn. According to the Quetelet weight-height index, all athletes
have more than 440 g/cm of height, there are no significant differences between the groups.
Significant differences were found in the Pignet index, which characterizes the strength of the
physique. Also significant is the difference in the Erisman index, which characterizes the
development of the chest.
209
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Table 2 Indices of anthropomorphological indicators of armwrestlers
№
п.п.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
Indicators
Quetelet index, g/cm
Pinier index
Erisman index, cm
Life index, ml/kg
Power index of the right
hand, %
Power index of the left
hand, %
Strength index of the
deadlift, %
Shoulder length to forearm
length, %
Circumference of the right
shoulder to the forearm, %
Circumference of the left
shoulder to the forearm, %
Low level
athletes, М±σ
448,7±9,71
0,4±4,00
8,8±2,44
65,6±2,46
66,3±3,13
Qualified Athletes,
М±σ
488,9±19,33
-14,7± 4,83
16,6±1,89
67,2±2,71
85,1±4,10
Difference
t
p
40,2
15,1
7,8
1,6
18,8
1,9
2,4
2,5
0,4
3,6
>0,05
<0,05
<0,05
>0,05
<0,05
67,3±3,60
77,3±4,50
10,0
1,7
>0,05
176,9±9,44
208,6±13,12
31,7
2,0
>0,05
133,1±3,50
133,9±1,45
0,8
0,2
>0,05
115,4±2,01
111,7±0,95
3,7
1,7
>0,05
116,0±1,44
114,2±1,26
1,8
1,0
>0,05
Table 2 shows that the power index of the right hand is higher in qualified athletes by 18.8%
(p<0.05). As a trend, we note a higher strength index of the left hand and back strength by 10
and 31.7%, respectively.
When analyzing the average anthropometric data of arm wrestlers, a regular increase in weight
and height indicators, as well as the circumferences of the links of the arm as the weight category
increases, was established. The average value of wrist dynamometry also increases naturally
(Fig.1). If the average gripping force of athletes in the 50 kg weight category is 59.7, then in the
110 kg weight category it is equal to 80 kg. The difference is 34%. Some exceptions to this trend
have been established. So, the average result of the weight category up to 70 kg is quite
significantly higher than the data obtained in the weight categories 80 and 85 and slightly exceeds
even 100 kg. The average result of the 75 kg weight category is approximately equal to the result
of the 90 kg category. However, the data obtained need further research involving a larger
number of subjects and comparing them with similar results. It was found that with the growth
of the weight category, the indicators of the power index of the leading hand in qualified athletes
decrease (Fig.2). At the same time, there is a greater result in the 75 kg weight category compared
to the previous categories, except for 55 kg.
Discussion
Studies to establish the specifics of the influence of anthropomorphological and
morphofunctional indicators on the skill level of arm wrestlers are carried out in two main ways.
The first is a comparative analysis of the data of athletes of various sports. The second is a
comparative analysis of experimental data of athletes of the same sport, but of different skill
levels.
210
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
90
85
80
80
75,7
75
70
75,2
69,4
68,7
65
60
64,8
59,7
59,4
58,8
55
55
50
45
40
55 kg
60 kg
65 kg
70 kg
75 kg
80 kg
85 kg
90 kg
100 kg 110 kg
Figure 1 Average carpal dynamometry indicators for qualified arm wrestlers of different weight
categories, kg.
120
110
108,4
100
99,3
93,3
90
101,7
92,2
84,3
82,5
80
71,1
70
73,5
75,1
60
55 kg
60 kg
65 kg
70 kg
75 kg
80 kg
85 kg
90 kg
100 kg 110 kg
Figure 2 Average indicators of the power index of the leading hand in qualified arm wrestlers of
different weight categories, %
The second method is more effective for identifying the features that allowed athletes to achieve
a higher level of skill.
211
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
The absence of significant differences between some indicators (height, weight, chest
circumference, vital capacity of the lungs) can be regarded as a reflection of the proximity of the
level of physical fitness of the participants and the result of specialized training in arm wrestling.
The correctness of this assumption is illustrated by the analysis of physical development. In such
indicators as the circumference of the right shoulder and the vital capacity of the lungs the
difference is close to reliable in favor of qualified athletes and Candidate for master of Sports and
it can be called a trend.
Indicators characterizing grip strength are the most important in arm wrestling. All participants
are characterized by high results of wrist dynamometry. Higher results from more qualified arm
wrestlers indicate the importance of this indicator for the effectiveness of competitive activity.
Similar data are given by Akpinar S., et al. (2013) and Podrihalo O.O. et al. (2020).
As the weight category increases, a wave-like increase in the average values of carpal
dynamometry was revealed. However, with the growth of the weight category, the indicators of
the power index of the leading hand of qualified athletes also decrease in waves.
The analysis of the left shoulder circumferences, right and left forearm circumferences, as well as
the wrist circumference confirms the importance of these criteria for improving athletic
performance. At the same time, Akpinar S., et al. (2013) found that the circumference of the
forearm is a significant predictor only for the left hand. According to the authors, the indicators
of the circumference of the forearm of the right hand did not reach a significant level in order to
be a predictor.
The results obtained indicate that qualified athletes have morphofunctional features that differ
from athletes of a low level of skill, probably due to which they achieve great success in arm
wrestling. These features are the best development of the girdle of the upper limbs: the muscles
of the forearm and shoulder, the muscles of the back, which allows you to show great results in
carpal and postural dynamometry and in fights at competitions.
Conclusions
Thus, the research has established morphofunctional features that distinguish athletes of high
skill levels in arm wrestling. These features are the better development of the girdle of the upper
limbs: the muscles of the forearm and shoulder, the muscles of the back, which allows to show
great results in strength tests and in competitive activity. As the weight category increases, a
wave-like increase in the average values of carpal dynamometry was revealed. However, with the
growth of the weight category, the indicators of the power index of the leading hand of qualified
athletes also decrease in waves. However, the data obtained need further research involving a
larger number of subjects and comparing them with similar results.
212
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
References
Aleksanyants, G.D. Sports morphology: manual for university students studying in the specialty
of 032100 and 032101б add. Federal Agency for Physical Education and Sports / G.D.
Aleksanyants, V.V. Abushkevich, D.B. Tlekhas et al. - M.: Soviet sport, 2005. - 91 p.
Zekrin, A.F. Anthropometric features of junior judoists of different weight groups / A.F.
Zekrin, F.H. Zekrin, V.V. Zebzeev // Theory and practice of physical culture. - 2015. No. 4. - pp. 11-13.
Kurys, V.N. Biomechanics. Cognition of bodily-motor exercise: textbook / V.N. Kurys. – M.:
Soviet sport, 2013. – 368 p.
Martirosov, E.G. Technologies and methods for determining the composition of the human
body / E.G. Martirosov, D.V. Nikolaev, S.G. Rudnev. — M.: Nauka, 2006. - 248 p.
Martirosov, E.G. Application of anthropological methods in sports, sports medicine and fitness:
manual for students of higher education studying in the specialties 032101, 032102 : rec. by
Educational and Methodical Association of Physical Education and Sports / Z.G.
Martirosov, S.G. Rudnev, D.V. Nikolaev. - M.: Phys. culture, 2010. - 119 p.
Nikityuk, D.B. Anthropometric status of athletes of different specialization and qualifications /
D.B. Nikityuk et al. // Scientific notes of St. Petersburg State Medical University named
after Academician I.P. Pavlov. - 2011. - Vol. 18, No. 2. - pp. 98-99.
Nikulin, I.N. Comparative characteristics of indicators of special strength training of arm
wrestlers of various weight categories and the level of sportsmanship / I. N. Nikulin, I. A.
Matyushenko, A.V. Antonov, A.V. Posokhov // Theory and practice of physical culture. –
2021. – No. 5. – pp. 9-11.
Podrigalo, L.V. Monitoring of the functional state of athletes in armsport: medical-hygienic and
sports-pedagogical aspects / L.V. Podrigalo, A.G. Istomin, A.I. Galashko, N.I. Galashko –
Kharkov: Kharkov National Medical University, 2010. – 149 p.
Podrigalo, L.V. Studying the interrelations of morphofunctional indicators in students engaged in
martial arts / L. V. Podrigalo, S. S. Ermakov, A. F. Alekseev, O. A. Rovnaya // Physical
education of students. – 2016. – No. 1. – pp. 64-70.
Posokhov, A.V. Analysis of anthropomorphological features of arm wrestlers of various levels of
training /A.V. Posokhov, I.N. Nikulin, A.V. Voronkov / Development of physical culture
and sports in the context of human self-realization in modern socio-economic conditions :
materials of the All-Russian Scientific and practical conference with International
participation, Lipetsk, November 23-24, 2017 / Lipetsk State Pedagogical University
named after P.P. Semenov-Tyan-Shansky; ed. by T.S. Frolov. – Lipetsk, 2017. – pp. 279282.
Posokhov, A.V. Analysis of anthropometric indicators of arm wrestlers of various weight
categories as a factor of success in performing at All-Russian competitions / A.V.
Posokhov, I. N. Nikulin, L. A. Kadutskaya, V. A. Malakhov // Theory and practice of
physical culture. – 2018. – No. 7. – pp. 69-71.
Semenov, V. V. Morphological predictors of sports talent in women's freestyle wrestling. VII
International Congress of integrative anthropology, October 17-18, 2013. Vinnytsia, 2013,
pp. 142-143.
213
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Sirazetdinov, R.E. Express assessment of the somatotype of martial artists using computer
technology / R.E. Sirazetdinov, E.Z. Godina, I.A. Khomyakova, M.A. Negasheva //
Theory and practice of physical culture. – 2021. – No. 2. – pp. 98-100.
Jagiello, V. The relationship of anthropometric indicators with the level of sportsmanship of
highly qualified judoists in Poland / V. Jagiello, V. Tkachuk, V. Blach. Physical education
of students of creative specialties: Collection of scientific collection papers ed. Ermakova
S.S. Kharkov: Kharkiv State Academy of Design and Fine Arts, 2004. No. 2. - pp.36-45
Akpinar, S., Zileli, R., Senyüzlü, E., Tunca, S.A. Anthropological and perceptual predictors
affecting the ranking in arm wrestling competition International Journal of Morphology,
2013, 31(3), рр. 832-838.
Podrigalo, L.V., Galashko M.N., Galashko N.I., Prusik Krzysztof, Cieslicka Miroslawa. Research
of hands' strength and endurance indications of arm sport athletes having different levels of
skills.
Physical
education
of
students,
2014,
vol.2,
pp.
37-40.
http://dx.doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.907140.
Podrihalo, O.O. The analysis of handgrip strength and somatotype features in arm wrestling
athletes with different skill levels (Анализ силы хвата и особенностей соматотипа
атлетов армреслинга разного уровня мастерства) / Podrihalo O.O., Podrigalo L.V.,
Bezkorovainyi D.О., Halashko O.I., Nikulin I.N., Kadutskaya L.A. / Physical education
of students, 2020;24(2):64–70. https://doi.org/10.15561/20755279.2020.0201
Podrihalo, O.O., Kiprych, S.V., Galashko, M.I., Marchenkov, M.K., Nasonkina, O.Y. The
comparative analysis of morphological and functional indicators of arm wrestling and street
workout athletes. Pedagogy of Physical Culture and Sports, 2021, 25(3), рр. 188-193.
214
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Longitudinal Design of Measuring Physical Activity in Children:
In Relation to Their Motor Abilities and Anthropometric
Measurements
Badriya K. Al-Hadabi
Physical Education & Sport Sciences Department, Sultan Qaboos University, Sultanate of Oman
e-mail: bhaddabi@squ.edu.om
Abstract
Objective: The study is aimed at a) observing the same group of children to identify the
development of MA, anthropometric measures, and PA levels over two years, b) to assess how well
changes in the anthropometric measurements will be able to predict the changes in each MA
component, and c) to assess whether changes in MA components and/or anthropometric
measurements over time were able to explain the changes in different PA levels. Methodology: A
total of 21 children (11 boys and 10 girls) were tracked over two-year groups: year 4 (age 9.3 ± 0.3
years), year 5 (age 10.3 ± 0.3 years) and year 6 (age 11.3 ± 0.3 years) volunteered to participate at
this study. Objective measurement of habitual PA was conducted by using an accelerometer for
four days: two weekdays and two weekend days. MA tests included the flamingo balance test (FBT),
eye-hand coordination (EHC), sit and reach (Sit-R), standing vertical jump (SVJ), hand grip (HG),
sit-up, 30m dash, and figure of 8 agility (F8A) and 20m shuttle run test (20m SRT). Results: All
MA improved with tracking year, with improvements in EHC and SVJ greater in males compared
to females. BF% was increased over two tracking years, with a greater percentage increase in
females than males over time. Height, body mass and BMI were found to be main predictive factors
of MA components. Longitudinal methods of tracking MA and anthropometrics over time nullified
the dominating nature of gender in predicting MA. Moreover, 8 to 12-year-old children tend to
spend significant time in a sedentary lifestyle and are insufficiently active, according to WHO.
Key words: Pediatric population, Accelerometer, Motor ability, Anthropometrics, Body
composition, Health
215
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
According to the World Health Organization (WHO, 2018) sedentary lifestyle is the fourth leading
risk factor for premature mortality, being responsible of 6% of deaths globally. Generally, studies
have reported that moderate and vigorous physical activity (MVPA) are associated with better
health benefits in adults such as cardiorespiratory fitness, better skeletal health, and controlled body
weight (Sallis, Patrick. 1994, Gunter, Nader. 2015) as well as in 3–18-year-old children and
adolescents. (Wu, 2017). During the last decade, the benefits of physical activity (PA) have been
extolled as an important component for a good quality of life and improved sense of well-being.
In this context, numerous studies in adults have shown that being physically active is positively
associated with the ability of an individual to perform daily tasks throughout their life due to the
observable benefits to the musculoskeletal, cardiovascular, and respiratory systems
(Blair et al., 2001; Riddoch & Boreham, 2000; Sirard & Pate, 2001; U.S. Department of Health and
Human Services, 1996).
In comparison with the adult population, the relationship between PA and health outcomes is not
yet clear in children. However, it is widely believed that being more physically active during
childhood is positively associated with remaining more physically active in adulthood (Fuentes et
al., 2003). Tracking studies have suggested that regular participation in PA during childhood plays
a significant role in the prevention of children's development of chronic disease (Blair & Connelly,
1996; Kohl & Hobbs, 1998; WHO, 2009), while physical inactivity is linked with increased risk of
hypertension, being overweight or obese, insulin resistance, and impaired lipid and lipoprotein
function (Katzmarzyk et al., 1999; Guillaume et al., 1997; WHO, 2009). According to the Chief
Medical Officer (2004), for general health benefits and to prevent obesity in young people; 60
minutes of moderate PA should be achieved every day and activities that improve bone health,
muscular strength, and endurance should be achieved twice a week (Department of Health, 2004).
It has since been suggested that this recommended level of PA be increased and instead children
and adolescents should participate in moderate PA for at least 90 minutes each day (Anderson et
al., 2006).
Numerous studies have illustrated that increasing sedentary activities, in particular watching TV
and using mass media technology (computer and internet use), has a significant relationship with
increased levels of being overweight and obese, and has been reported throughout the WHO
report, participating in a less active life style is one of the main risk factors causing a rise in
worldwide mortality rates (WHO, 2009).
There is an increasing recognition that children are usually mechanically active and coordinated in
basic motor performances by the time they are 5-7 years old (Gallahue, 1995; Malina et al., 2004).
As a child grows, the body undergoes a gradual progression from general to specific motor
performance (Katzmarzyk et al., 1997). Improvements in motor ability occur and may lead to
increases in physical activity performance. Consequently, researchers suggest that the development
of basic motor performance should play an important role in physical education programmes from
an early age (Oja and Jürimäe, 2002). However, it is still unclear which factors determine the level
216
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
of physical activity participation in children and adolescents. One essential influencing factor may
be the level of mastery of motor abilities which children and adolescents need in order to participate
in different physical activities (Okely et al., 2001).
PA tracking studies attempt to quantify whether a child will preserve his or her PA position within
a cohort of children over a period of time (Kelly et al., 2007). It is also a constructive way to predict
children’s PA behaviour and health in the future according to their initial behaviours at a younger
age (Pate et al., 1996), as it has been accepted that PA is one of the important independent risk
factors for several chronic diseases (Boreham et al., 2004). Therefore, PA tracking in children can
be used as an approach to determine a suitable age to begin an intervention programme (Loucaides,
2002), as it is widely believed that children who have high risk behaviours tend to maintain the
same behaviours during their adulthood (Pate et al., 1996).
To summarize, since the tracking studies require longitudinal observation of the same individual at
not less than two points in time (Malina,1996), there are a relatively small number of studies that
have examined the tracking of PA behaviour during childhood and adolescence. Based on the
methods and findings from previous studies, there is a difference concerning the studies’
population, PA measurements, length of tracking, and analysis methods to assess PA tracking and
the findings from these studies. From the review of the literature, studies have reported a low to
moderate tendency of tracking PA behaviour during childhood to adolescence from different
backgrounds and with a wide range of age groups (Janz et al., 2005; Pate et al., 1996; Pate et al.,
1999; Raitakari et al., 1994; Sallis et al., 1995). According to Raitakari et al. (1994), the PA tracking
correlation coefficient declined as the interval time between the measurements increased therefore,
the majority of the previous studies used an average 3-year interval period to track PA behaviour
(Janz et al., 2005; Pate et al., 1996; Pate et al., 1999; Raitakari et al., 1994). However, other studies
have extended the tracking period to 5 years (Janz et al., 2005) or 6 years (Raitakari et al., 1994;
Sallis et al., 1995; Kelly et al., 2007) or have minimised the tracking period to just two years.
Therefore, the current study is aimed at a) observing the same group of children to identify the
development of MA, anthropometric measures and PA levels over time in 8–12-year-olds, b) to
assess how well changes in the anthropometric measurements will be able to predict the changes
in each MA component, and c) to assess whether changes in MA components and/or
anthropometric measurements over time were able to explain the changes in different PA levels.
Methodology
The total number of participants who managed to complete three phases of motor ability tests
from year 4 to year 6 was (n = 21). The total tracked number of participants from year 4 to year 5
was (n = 27), and that from year 5 to year 6 was (n = 26). More details of total participants tracked
from both genders is described in Table 1.
Participants were recruited from a local primary school. All participants and their parents or
guardians gave their written informed consent for the testing prior to the commencement of the
test for each year.
217
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Table 1 The number of participants involved in the motor ability, anthropometric and PA
measures in the longitudinal study
Tracking years
2 years
Year 4
Gender
M
F
13
14
Year 5
Gender
M
F
14
12
Year 6
Gender
M
F
18
12
Total number of
participants
tracked
21
Furthermore, all participants or guardians confirmed that their child was free from any medical
condition that would preclude the child from participating in the study. Ethical approval for the
study was obtained from the University Ethical Committee. All tests were administered in the
sports hall and school playground at the same time of day. There was adequate interval time
between each test.
Physical activity measurement
PA was monitored using a unidirectional accelerometer that measures acceleration in the vertical
plane (model ActiGraph GT1M, ActiGraph LLC, Fort Walton Beach, FL). The ActiGraph is a
uniaxial accelerometer (Figure 1) that measures body movement in terms of acceleration, which
can then be used to estimate physical activity intensity levels over time (Chen & Bassett 2005,
Troiano, 2005).
Motor ability tests & Body composition
To determine body fat percentage, the median of the triplicate measurements at each site (triceps
and calf) were used. Then, equations provided by Slaughter (1988). The participant’s motor ability
components were assessed by using eight different tests, included general balance, coordination,
flexibility, explosive strength, static strength, running speed, abdominal and trunk strength, and
agility as well as 20m SRT.
Results
Anthropometric characteristics over two tracking years
For the analysis group, data of a total number of 21 participants were tracked over two years, and
a summary of the participants’ characteristics over two tracking years are shown in table 2. A
significant within tracking year effect was found in height, body mass, BMI, and BF% (all P <
0.05). Gender had an effect on BF% which was higher in females in year 4 and year 5 (P < 0.05),
but not year 6 (P > 0.05). Looking at gender specifics (males), year 6 shows a significantly higher
BF% from year 4 and year 5 (P < 0.05), whereas year 4 females showed a significantly lower BF%
from year 5 and year 6 (P < 0.05).
218
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Table 2 Mean ± SD participant descriptive characteristics tests of (n= 10 male) and (n= 11 female)
in years 4 to 6 who were tracked over a two-year period (n=21). († indicates significantly different
from year 4, * indicates significantly
Table 2 difference between genders at the same year, a indicates gender specific (male)
significant difference from year 6, a indicate gender specific (female)
significant difference from year 4 (P < 0.05)
Male
Female
Mean ±SD Mean ±SD
9.36±0.20
9.24±0.035
Age
(yr)
Height 1.36±0.05
(m)
Body
31.32±4.05
mass
(kg)
BMI
17.03±1.87
BF%
Male
Female
Mean ±SD Mean ±SD
10.41±0.20† 10.33±0.35†
Male
Female
Mean ±SD Mean ±SD
11.33±0.18† 11.25±0.32†
1.36±0.003
1.40±0.06†
1.45±0.07†
33.56±4.30
33.25±5.53† 36.59±5.00†
39.18±5.69† 41.65±6.36†
18.13±2.00
16.90±2.39† 17.95±1.96†
18.52±2.24† 18.60±2.14†
1.43±0.04†
1.49±0.04†
16.04±5.27a 22.51±3.65* 17.06±5.76† 24.91±4.80†*b 22.24±6.84† 24.74±4.54†
a
b
The longitudinal impact on motor ability over two tracking years by gender
A main effect for gender was found for EHC and SVJ (P < 0.05). For EHC, significant gender
differences were found at year 5 and year 6 (P < 0.05); but not year 4 (P > 0.05). Males showed an
improvement over the two years and significantly outperformed females in all year groups (P <
0.05), whereas females’ significant improvement was found between year 4 and year 5 and between
year 5 and year 6 (P < 0.05). In (SVJ), no significant differences have been reported between
genders during each of the tracking years (P < 0.05). However, both genders improved significantly
from the pre-testing to post-testing phase (P < 0.05).
Interrelationship between changes in MA score and anthropometric measurements over
two tracking years
Differences in year explained 17.6% (p < 0.01) of the variance of changes in EHC. However, the
inclusion of differences in height increased the variance of changes to 28.1% (p < 0.001). Whilst
the changes in EHC increased if the differences in year increased, the opposite interrelation was
seen with differences in height. The final multiple regression model was:
Δ EHC = 1.221+ 6.130 × Δ Year – 124.877 × Δ Height
Where Year is coded as first tracking year = 1 and second tracking year = 2.
219
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
The differences in Year also explained 42.3 % (p < 0.01) of the variance of changes in Sit and
Reach, which could be increased to 53.3% (p < 0.001) by additional inclusion of differences in
BF%, meaning that the increases of differences in Year together with the decrease in differences
of BF% led to a better flexibility performance. The final multiple regression model was:
Δ Sit-Reach = -9.716 + 7.715 × Δ Year -0.452 × Δ FB%
Differences in Year also explained 21.3% (p < 0.01) of the variance of changes in SVJ, meaning
that being in a higher school-year improved the changes in the development of participants’
explosive strength. The final multiple regression model was:
Δ SVJ = -6.448 + 5.924 × Δ Year
The Differences in age explained 9.9% (p < 0.01) of the variance of changes in EHC. However,
the inclusion of differences in body mass increased the variance of changes to 19.8% (p < 0.001),
while the changes in HG increased if the differences in both age and body mass increased. The
final multiple regression model was:
Δ HG = -83.032+101.967 × Δ Age +2.583 × Δ Body mass
Differences in year explained 85.1% (p < 0.01) of the variance of changes in F8A, which indicates
that a higher difference in year led to a better agility performance. The final multiple regression
model was:
Δ F8A = 9.112 – 8.801 × Δ Year
Table 3 Mean ± SD for each motor ability tests in male and female of years 4 to 5 and 5 to 6 who
were tracked over a two-year period (n=21). († indicates significant difference from year 4, *
indicates significantly different between genders within the same year, a indicates gender specific
Year 4
Year 5
Year 6
MA tests
FBT(number of step downs)
EHC (number of catches of ball)
Male
Mean
±SD
3.8±2.30
12.1±4.99
Female
Mean
±SD
5.7±2.76
10.3±4.22
Male
Mean
±SD
3.9±2.47†
17.4±7.78†a
Female
Mean
±SD
4.6±3.75†
6.1±3.70†*
Male
Mean
±SD
5.5±3.60†
21.5±5.28†
Female
Mean ±SD
a
b
19.1±7.53
20.6±4.72
16.5±7.78†
17.6±5.39†
21.1±8.89†
22.4±5.66†
26.1±4.53
23.0±4.07
26.8±4.96†
21.4±7.13†
30.9±6.15†
27.4±4.92†
a
b
a
b
12.5±3.26
5.4±0.39
16.9±3.73
35.3±2.71
11.5±1.99
5.6±0.26
14.3±5.73
36.4±1.29
15.5±3.45†
5.2±0.34†
20.0±3.16†
35.7±2.55†
14.8±2.14†
5.4±0.37†
17.6±4.57†
36.7±1.21†
18.4±3.54†
5.1±0.40†
23.7±3.40†
26.3±2.21†
17.0±3.48†
5.2±0.29†
19.5±5.09†
28.2±2.04†
4.4±4.03†
13.8±3.97†*b
SitR (cm)
SVJ (cm)
HG (kg)
30m dash (s)
Sit-ups (number of performances)
F8A (s)
(male) significant difference at the same test, b indicates gender specific (female) significant
difference at the same test (P < 0.05).
The longitudinal impact on PA levels over two tracking years
Six participants who met the criteria for PA monitoring were found to have significant differences
from the main group (n=21) in EHC, HG, SVJ, sit-reach, and FBT (P < 0.05) using independent
sample t-test.
220
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Table 4 Mean ± SD participants’ time (minutes) spent in different physical activity levels PAL at
years 4 to 5 and 5 to 6 who were tracked over a 2-year period (n=6).
Table 4 shows the Mean ± SD of participants’ physical activity levels (PAL) over the
tracking years (years 4 to 6). No significant main effect within school years was found at
year 4
year 5
year 6
PA levels
SPA
LPA
MPA
Mean ± SD
579.4±35.77
140.3±23.29
2.0±4.73
Mean ± SD
565.6±98.65
156.7±89.93
1.2±1.41
Mean ± SD
594.4±64.23
152.6±60.02
3.8±4.80
VPA
MVPA
2.0±4.74
4.1±9.48
1.3±1.60
2.5±3.00
0.2±0.28
4.1±4.84
any physical activity level
Interrelationship between changes in MA score and anthropometric measurements over
two tracking years
Differences in year explained 74.0% (p < 0.01) of the variance of changes in EHC. The changes in
EHC tend to be greater with the increasing differences of year and gender. The final multiple
regression model was:
Δ EHC = -68.833+29.000 * Δ Year
*
Where gender is coded as male = 1 and female = 2.
The differences in year explained 43.8% (p < 0.01) of the variance of changes in sit-reach, where
the equation shows that increasing the differences in year lead to an increased change in sit-reach
performance. The final multiple regression model was:
Δ Sit-Reach = -8.667 + 5.167 × Δ Year
Differences in body mass explained 39.5% (p < 0.01) of the variance of changes in HG, which
means that increased differences in body mass led to a better HG performance. The final multiple
regression model was:
Δ HG = 16.915 + 4.114 × Δ Body mass
The differences in BMI explained 36.2% (p < 0.01) of the variance of changes in sit-up. The
equation shows that having less difference in the BMI means a better sit-up performance. The final
multiple regression model was:
Δ Sit-up = 5.611 – 1.940 × Δ BMI
Differences in year explained 88.3% (p < 0.01) of the variance of changes in F8A, where having a
high difference in year means a better agility performance. The final multiple regression model was:
Δ F8A = 10.808 – 10.063 × Δ Year
221
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Interrelationship between changes in PA levels and MA and/or anthropometric
measurements over two tracking years
The differences in FBT explained 49.1% (p < 0.01) of the variance of changes in SPA, and 45.4%
(p < 0.01) of the variance of changes of LPA. These mean that having less difference in FBT results
in higher changes in SPA, whereas higher differences in FBT result in higher changes in LPA. The
final multiple regression models were:
Δ SPA = 6.188 - 16.107 × Δ FBT
Δ LPA = 7.697 + 18.510 × Δ FBT
Differences in BF% explained 29.1% (p < 0.01) of the variance of the changes in MPA, meaning
that high differences in FB% lead to a higher change in MPA. The final multiple regression model
was:
Δ MPA = -2.800 + 1.022 × Δ BF%
Discussion
The current longitudinal study focused on tracking the level of MA, anthropometric measures, and
monitoring of PA level over a period two tracking years in 8 to 12-year-old children. The main
finding from the current study demonstrated that all MA components significantly improved over
two years of tracking, which is unsurprising. Furthermore, although both males and females
showed an improvement over the tracking period, gender only appeared to have an effect on
improvements in EHC and SVJ tests, with males improving to a much greater extent than females.
When MA components and anthropometric measures were tracked over a period of two years,
improvements of MA components were observed, apart from FBT, which did not change
significantly over the two years. gender appeared only to affect improvements in EHC and SVJ
tests. Interestingly, improvements in EHC (i.e. change from pre- to post) were not significantly
greater in males than females for year 4 but males increased their EHC scores to a significantly
greater level between year 5 and 6 than females. SVJ was found to be significantly improved when
looking at a specific gender over time, but no significant difference was found between genders
within one school year. Over two years of tracking, increases of height, body mass, BMI, and BF%
(all P < 0.05) were found. In addition, two tracking years showed an increase in females’ BF% from
year 4 to year 5 compared to males, but not from year 5 to year 6.
The current study showed that all MA components measured improved with time. This is likely
due to maturity, growth and increased skill levels that come with increasing age. Gender differences
in improvements occurred only in EHC and SVJ, with males improving their performance of EHC
ability over the tracking year to a greater extent than females. The EHC test that was used in this
study has not previously been defined as a gender-specific task. However, it may be that this greater
improvement in males is due to males participating in more eye-hand coordination activities than
females, particularly in their free play. The majority of activities in which males participate at this
age involve balls, whereas for females, this involvement is greatly reduced. Alternative EHC tests
which could have been used generally involve ball skills or are less specific to EHC, for example
222
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
ladder gross body agility tests, and thus tend to look at general motor co-ordination. Interestingly,
in a preliminary study conducted, the researcher observed that in this ladder stepping task, females
outperformed males in all years. However, Thomas & Marzke (1992) suggested that the gender
differences in throwing skills are not only because males have a greater amount of practice than
females. At a young age it was noted that even males as young as 3-4 years old were three times
better than females. This suggests the skill is developed very early on (maybe by different types of
play) or is an innate ability. However, throwing is only a small part of EHC ability and therefore
links between the current study and the throwing study should be made with caution.
The growth of the muscles and body mass may affect the improvements in SVJ of both genders.
However, the superior performance of males is likely to be as a result of males having greater
increases in muscle strength in their lower limbs than females as the SVJ measures lower body
explosive power. Furthermore, females tended to have a high BF% which will result in increased
fat mass relative to muscle mass (Malina et al., 1995; Raudsepp and Pääsuke, 1995).
The current study showed that tracking PA levels over two years does not illustrate any differences
for either the main effect of gender or school year. Both genders tend to spend about 8 to 9 h.day1 at SPA, and about 2 to 3 h.day-1 at LPA over both one and two tracking years. The current study
also illustrated that participants tend to spend only a few minutes per day participating at MPA,
VPA, and MVPA levels which means that children are insufficiently active, according to current
government guidelines on healthy PA levels. (Department of Health (DH), UK, 2011). The UK
Department of Health recommended that children from 5 to 18 years old should be engaged in at
least 60 minutes of MVPA including strengthening muscles and bone activities about 3 times a
week. The guidelines also recommended that children should minimise the amount of time spent
being sedentary and less active. On the other hand, the current study result of PA levels was not
different to the current literature (Riddoch, 2007), where 11-year-old UK children tend to
participate in about 7.5 h.day-1 at SPA, 5.5 h.day-1 at LPA, 13 min.day-1 at MPA and 2 min.day-1
at VPA levels (Riddoch. 2007). This study also confirmed that a large majority of children are
insufficiently active, according to current recommended health levels.
Effect of anthropometric factors on selected MA components
To explore how well changes in the anthropometric measurements were able to predict the changes
in each MA component over a period of one tracking year, stepwise multi-regression analysis was
used. It illustrated that height, body mass, and BMI were the dominant factors affecting the changes
in balance, hand and abdominal strength, and agility.
The positive changes in height were found to be negatively associated with change in balancing.
Balance is in part determined by centre of gravity and increases in height and mass may affect
centre of gravity, resulting in attenuated balance development. According to Rival et al. (2005), the
processes underlying balance ability are mature by 6 years of age, but obviously as height continues
to increase the body will have to adapt to the new centre of gravity which will then attenuate an
increase in balance performance.
223
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Change in body mass was found to positively affect the changes in hand static strength, but
negatively affect abdominal strength. This is likely to be due to increases in upper body mass
making it more difficult to undertake the sit-up task, as the upper trunk has to move a considerable
distance against gravity. However, hand-grip is a more static strength test which isolates muscle
strength from the change in body mass.
Agility improved with increased height and BMI. As this is a more complex task involving different
aspects of MA function, this may be due to maturity. However, the improvement in agility with
increases in BMI is surprising, as agility requires a quick change in body direction, with a good level
of both speed and dynamic balance which may be expected to be lower with increases in BMI.
Furthermore, change in balancing ability showed improvement with a reduced change in height.
Anthropometric measures showed that changes in sit-up could be predicted only through changing
body mass, although none of the other anthropometric measures could predict any other MA
components. To summarize the results from this group, some of these changes in MA are likely
due to general maturity leading to increased growth, although this is not the case with balance tasks
and height. By tracking MA and anthropometric measures over two years, tracking year could also
be added as a variable in the regression equation to explore whether the first or second tracking
year could predict any of the MA components. The results illustrated that changes in tracking year
were the dominant factor in interaction with EHC, sit-up, SVJ, and F8A tests, meaning that the
second tracking year showed greater improvements in MA.
The data from two tracking years confirmed that the HG test improved with both increasing
change of age and body mass which has been explained earlier through the one-year tracking group.
Two years of tracking has also shown an interaction between the sit-up test and BF%. The increase
of BF% plays a role in decreasing abdominal strength.
Effects of anthropometric measures and MA components on PA levels
Results from the six participants tracked over two years showed that balancing ability could explain
some of the SPA and LPA but in two different directions: negatively with increasing SPA and
positively with LPA. This means that children who are deficient in balancing ability tend to spend
a great amount of time being inactive, whereas having a better balancing performance relates to
increased participation at a light physical activity level. BF%, on the other hand, was shown to be
a good predictor of MPA. The findings from the current study showed some relationships between
anthropometric measures and MA components and how they could be a good predictor of change
in PA level. However, the sample is very small and therefore, interpretations of the results should
be made with caution.
In conclusion, the main findings of this study were that all MA improved with tracking year, with
improvements in EHC and SVJ greater in males compared to females. BF% was increased over
two tracking years, with a greater percentage increase in females than males over time. Height, body
mass, and BMI were found to be main prediction factors of MA components. Longitudinal
methods of tracking MA and anthropometrics over time nullified the dominating nature of gender
224
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
in predicting MA. Moreover, 8 to 12-year-old children tend to spend much time in a sedentary
lifestyle and are insufficiently active, according to current UK Department of Health and WHO
recommended levels.
References
Andersen, L. B., Harro, M., Sardinha, L. B., Froberg, K., Ekelund, U., Brage, S., et al. (2006).
Physical activity and clustered cardiovascular risk in children: a cross-sectional study (The
European Youth Heart Study). The Lancet, 368(9532), 299-304.
Blair, S. N., & Connelly, J. C. (1996). How much physical activity should we do? The case for
moderate amounts and intensities of physical activity. Research Quarterly for Exercise and
Sport, 67(2), 193-205.
Blair, S. N., Cheng, Y., & Scott Holder, J. (2001). Is physical activity or physical fitness more
important in defining health benefits? Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 33(6), S379.
Boreham, C., Robson, P. J., Gallagher, A. M., Cran, G. W., Savage, J. M., & Murray, L. J. (2004).
Tracking of physical activity, fitness, body composition and diet from adolescence to young
adulthood: The Young Hearts Project, Northern Ireland. Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act, 1(1),
14.
Chen, K. Y., & Bassett Jr, D. R. (2005). The technology of accelerometry-based activity monitors:
current and future. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 37(11), S490.
Fuentes, R. M., Notkola, I. L., Shemeikka, S., Tuomilehto, J., & Nissinen, A. (2003). Tracking of
body mass index during childhood: a 15-year prospective population-based family study in
eastern Finland. International journal of obesity, 27(6), 716-721.
Gallahue, D., & Ozmun, J. (1995). Understanding motor development: An overview.
Understanding motor development: infants, children, adolescents, 2, 3-23.
Guillaume, M., Lapidus, L., Björntorp, P., & Lambert, A. (1997). Physical activity, obesity, and
cardiovascular risk factors in children. The Belgian Luxembourg Child Study II. Obesity
research, 5(6), 549.
Gunter, K.B.; Nader, P.A.; John, D.H. (2015). Physical activity levels and obesity status of Oregon
Rural Elementary School children. Prev. Med. Rep., 2, 478–482.
Janz, K. F., Burns, T. L., & Levy, S. M. (2005). Tracking of activity and sedentary behaviors in
childhood: the Iowa Bone Development Study. Am J Prev Med, 29(3), 171-178.
Katzmarzyk, P., Malina, R., & Beunen, G. (1997). The contribution of biological maturation to the
strength and motor fitness of children. Annals of human biology, 24(6), 493-505.
Katzmarzyk, P., Malina, R., & Beunen, G. (1997). The contribution of biological maturation to the
strength and motor fitness of children. Annals of human biology, 24(6), 493-505.
Kelly, L. A., Reilly, J. J., Jackson, D. M., Montgomery, C., Grant, S., & Paton, J. (2007). Tracking
physical activity and sedentary behavior in young children. Pediatric Exercise Science, 19(1),
51.
Kohl, H. W., & Hobbs, K. E. (1998). Development of physical activity behaviors among children
and adolescents. Pediatrics, 101(Supplement 2), 549.
225
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Loucaides, C. A. (2002). The physical activity levels of Cypriot children and correlates of their
activity. School of sport sciences. Exeter, University of Exeter, PhD thesis, Pp 31-34.
Malina, R. (1996). Tracking of physical fitness and performance during growth (pp. 1-10): Stuttgart:
Ferdinand Enke Verlag.
Malina, R. M., Bouchard, C., & Bar-Or, O. (2004). Growth, maturation, and physical activity:
Human Kinetics Publishers
Malina, R., Beunen, G., Classens, A., Lefevre, J., Vanden, E. B. V., Renson, R., et al. (1995). Fatness
and physical fitness of girls 7 to 17 years. Obesity research, 3(3), 221-231.
Oja, L. J., T. (2001). Tracking of motor Abilities, Physical Activity, and Elementary Motor Skills
During Transition from Preschool To School. Kinesoiologiae Universitatis Tartuensis, 6, 9010.
Oja, L., & Jorimae, T. (2002). Physical activity, motor ability, and school readiness of 6-yr.-old
children. Perceptual and Motor skills, 95(2), 407-415.
Pate, R. R., Baranowski, T., Dowda, M., & Trost, S. G. (1996). Tracking of physical activity in
young children. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 28(1), 92.
Pate, R. R., Baranowski, T., Dowda, M., & Trost, S. G. (1996). Tracking of physical activity in
young children. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 28(1), 92.
Pate, R., Trost, S., Dowda, M., Ott, A., Ward, D., Saunders, R., et al. (1999). Tracking of physical
activity, physical inactivity, and health-related physical fitness in rural youth. Pediatric
Exercise Science, 11, 364-376.
Raitakari, O. T., Porkka, K. V., Taimela, S., Telama, R., Rasanen, L., & Viikari, J. S. (1994). Effects
of persistent physical activity and inactivity on coronary risk factors in children and young
adults. The Cardiovascular Risk in Young Finns Study. Am J Epidemiol, 140(3), 195-205
Raudsepp, L. P., M. (1995). Gender differences in fundamental movement patterns, motor
performances, and strength measurements of prepubertal children. Pediatric Exercise
Science, 7, 294-304.
Riddoch, C., & Boreham, C. (2000). Physical activity, physical fitness and children’s health: current
concepts. Paediatric exercise science and medicine, 243-252.
Riddoch, C.J.; Leary, S.D.; Ness, A.R.; Blair, S.N.; Deere, K.; Mattocks, C.; Gri_ths, A.; Davey
Smith, G.; (2009). Prospective associations between objective measures of physical activity
and fat mass in 12–14-year-old children: The Avon Longitudinal Study of Parents and
Children (ALSPAC) BMJ. 2009;339: b4544
Rival, C., Ceyte, H, Olivier, I. (2005). Developmental changes of static standing balance in children.
Neurosci Lett, 376(2), 133-113.
Sallis, J. F., Berry, C. C., Broyles, S. L., & McKENZIE, T. L. (1995). Variability and tracking of
physical activity over 2 yrs in young children. -700 M. Medicine & Science in Sports &
Exercise., 27(7), 1042–1049.
Sallis, J.F.; Patrick, K.J. (1994). Physical activity guidelines for adolescents: Consensus statement.
Pediatr. Exerc. Sci., 6, 302–314.
Sirard, J. R., & Pate, R. R. (2001). Physical activity assessment in children and adolescents. Sports
Medicine, 31(6), 439-454.
226
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Thomas, J. R. M., D. Gallagher, J. D. (1994). Effects of Training on gender differences in overhand
throwing, A brief quantitative literature analysis. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport,
65(1), 67-71.
Tilling, K. (2009). Prospective associations between objective measures of physical activity and fat
mass in 12-14-year-old children: The Avon Longitudinal Study of Parents and Children
(ALSPAC). BMJ, 339.
Troiano, R. P. (2005). A timely meeting: objective measurement of physical activity. Medicine &
Science in Sports & Exercise, 37(11), S487.
WHO. (2009). Global health risks: mortality and burden of disease attributable to selected major
risks. Geneva. World Health Organization Press, 1-70.
World Health Organization (WHO). Global Recommendations on Physical Activity for Health.
online:https://www.who.int/dietphysicalactivity/factsheet_recommendations/en/(accesse
d on 20 March 2022).
Wu, X.Y.; Han, L.H.; Zhang, J.H.; Luo, S.; Hu, J.W.; Sun, K. (2017), The influence of physical
activity, sedentary behavioron health-related quality of life among the general population of
children and adolescents: A systematic review. 9;12(11).
227
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
228
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________________
The HEPAS Model: A Healthy and Physically Active School
Model Promoting Physical Activity and Healthy Lifestyles in
School Settings
Richard Bailey1 - Manolis Adamakis2 – Zoltan Boronyai3 - Jana Vašíčková4 Petr Vlček4 - Andreu Raya Demidoff5 – Rose-Marie Repond4 - Sandra Heck2
- Claude Scheuer2
1
University of Nottingham Malaysia, Malaysia
2
University of Luxembourg, Luxembourg
3
Hungarian School Sport Federation, Hungary
4
European Physical Education Association, Luxembourg
5
Deporte para la Educacion y la Salud, Spain
e-mail: claude.scheuer@uni.lu
Abstract
The Healthy and Physically Active Schools project aimed at building up the capacity of schoolrelated stakeholders (e.g., teachers, educators, school headmasters) when it comes to the
improvement of school-based physical activity (PA) for children and adolescents, as well as their
healthy lifestyles in general. (HEPAS; https://www.movingschoolsaward.com/hepas). One of the
most important outcomes of the HEPAS project included the development of a complex
theoretical model, which is the main focus of this paper. The HEPAS model includes the
dimensions and layers that represent the functions and environment of a school from the PA
promotion perspective. These dimensions are: 1. Physical Activity; 2. Physical Education; 3. School
Sport; 4. Healthy Lifestyles; and 5. Transversal Dimension (i.e., Inclusion and Diversity,
Professional Development, Facilities, Equipment & Resources, Community Partnerships, Events,
Project Weeks, and Camps). The dimensions are both surrounded and influenced by the social
climate and the physical environment. Finally, the model includes an overarching aim of
supporting students’ physical activity/health behaviours and important considerations are also
discussed.
Key words: Active school, Physical activity, Physical education, School sport, Healthy lifestyles
229
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
Schools have frequently been suggested as valuable settings for interventions to promote physical
activity (PA) and wellbeing, and public health entities throughout the world have advocated an
increase in PA opportunities for children and young people through comprehensive whole-school
approaches (Böcker, 2014; Pavelka, Sigmund, & Sigmundová, 2014; Volkmann, 2015). There are
several characteristics of schools that make them well-suited as settings for the promotion of
health-enhancing PA:
• Schools can reach almost all children regardless of social background, and have long-term,
in-depth contact with them (Bailey, Agans, Côté, Côté, Daly-Smith, & Tomporowski, 2021);
• This contact happens during a crucial period of development, during which many healthrelated behaviours and interests are formed that can be carried forward into later life (Karnik
& Kanekar, 2011);
• Schools present a unique setting for integrating PA with other health-related messages
(Böcker, 2010);
• Schools can create easily accessible physical environments in which children regularly engage
in PA (Ip et al., 2017);
• Schools, especially primary schools, often act as a hub of community activities, creating a
focal point for PA opportunities, both directly [e.g., by organising school-based PA and
Physical Education (PE)], and indirectly (e.g., by encouraging PA at home, in the
neighbourhood, and during commuting to and from school) (Guinhouya, 2010);
• School lessons and other supervised periods are the only formal opportunities for the
promotion of knowledge, skills, attitudes, and values that underpin regular PA (Cale, 2020).
It is crucial to highlight that PA can be intentionally used before and after the school day (i.e., in
the frame of leisure time and active homework), during the school day (i.e., in the frame of preschool and after-school clubs and activities as well as physical activity-related school events) and
during classes (i.e., in the frame of PE but also as active-dynamic sitting, active breaks, active
classroom learning, relaxation phases and cross-curricular classes) as well.
In general, low levels of PA, and negative attitudes toward sports and PA can be significant issues
at the school level. Low levels of competence and confidence may result in children avoiding PA
settings, thereby removing themselves from the context that is most needed. One way of
envisaging the evidence that relates to this situation is the virtuous cycle presented in Figure 1.
The Healthy and Physically Active Schools (HEPAS) Model
The HEPAS model (Figure 2, below) attempts to represent some of the key features of an Active
School. The label ‘model’ is deliberately chosen. In the words of Keeves (1988, p. 559), “the model,
like the hypotheses, which are contained within it, can be built from accumulated evidence,
intuition by analogy, or derived from theory”. This model describes a framework for investigating
the realisation of a school environment in which PA is fully integrated and promoted.
230
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________________
Figure 1 The virtuous cycle of interactions between movement skill development and
psycho-social development (adapted from Bailey, Doherty, & Pickup, 2007)
From the perspective of the Active Schools concept, it is important to understand the range of
forces directing educational practice. It is also important to understand how those forces can be
directed towards or away from PA promotion. Numerous authors discussed in this document have
suggested that whole school activity promotion requires an “activity leader” who can coordinate
the various elements and activities, but, importantly, act as a central advocate for the growth of
the Active School.
Within the school, several key stakeholders for PA can be identified. An activity leader is obviously
going to play a pivotal role, and will usually be either a PE specialist or someone who has
experienced considerable professional development. Most teachers, it is known, have not received
significant preparation to promote PA, and the need to ensure continuous professional
development is a theme that repeatedly emerged from the literature reviews. Parents and the wider
community need to be engaged, as a central concept of the Active School is the abandonment of
the traditional division between in-school and out of school activities. Active Transport and Active
Homework are good examples of this new approach; they would be impossible without the full
support of parents and within an activity-friendly local environment. And with the growth of
public and private partnerships in developing new facilities, there is likely to be a growing
expectation across Europe that schools explore ways of co-funding, co-managing, and co-using
facilities.
The most important people within the school are, of course, the students. The realisation of the
WHO goals will not happen if it is left solely in the hands of teachers and parents. Daily PA
231
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
assumes a great deal of cooperation and decision-making by children and young people, and several
studies examined in the HEPAS project have highlighted the importance of early engagement of
students in change towards a more active school environment. The word ‘active’ is interesting
within this context, as it has two distinct meanings within the educational literature. The first,
which will be familiar to readers of this paper, relates to PA and exercise, and its opposite, ‘passive’,
indicates sedentariness. The second sense of ‘active’ within educational theory indicates proactivity, enthusiastic, and dynamic. The opposite idea is ‘passive’ as docile, apathetic, and
uninvolved. Perhaps both senses of the term ‘active’ should be applied to the concept of the Active
School?
The different elements of the HEPAS framework are discussed later in this paper. It is important
to remember that these are not the only settings for the promotion of PA in schools, nor are they
the most effective. Some of these elements are under-researched, and so it is difficult to make an
informed judgement about their use. Active Homework is, perhaps, the best example of this. Of
course, other settings and approaches could be added to this list. For example, standing desks,
bike-desks, walking buses, outside clubs for PE lessons, morning exercises, and many other
activities might be considered and added to the list of settings.
To avoid the danger of repetition or redundancy, there is the necessity of some sort of coordinator,
such as an activity leader, to ensure that the different elements work synergistically. So, the
movement skills developed in PE lessons could be applied and practised in Homework. They
could also be practised during Recess and sports clubs, especially they are planned collaboratively.
Likewise, professional development will probably be needed to support Active Breaks and Active
Learning, which could easily connect with PE lessons and Active Recess. In other words, wholeschool PA requires whole-school planning.
Another aspect of the model relates to the context in which PA takes place. The importance of
facilities and equipment has been discussed earlier. Despite a lack of research in this area, it seems
reasonable to suggest that the absence of adequate space and play equipment will limit PA. Indeed,
there is some evidence that the amount of available space (playgrounds, fields, gymnasiums)
positively relates to the amount of PA taking place (Pawlowski, Tjørnhøj-Thomsen, Schipperijn,
et al, 2014). There was also persuasive evidence that perceptions of the physical environment are
more important than the environment itself. Dark, untidy, or badly maintained equipment or play
areas reduce the likelihood of activity. Bright, colourful playgrounds are known to promote active
play. Social climate refers to the non-physical aspects of PA within the school. Friendly, supportive
and inclusive environments are much more likely to promote PA, especially those who are
traditionally marginalised, such as girls and the overweight. Teachers and other school staff are
vitally important in creating this climate, by promoting and enforcing relevant rules and norms,
promoting positive peer relationships, and celebrating diversity.
232
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________________
Figure 2 The HEPAS Model of an Active School
The project team used the following definitions to describe the different elements of the HEPAS
model:
1. School Values, Aims & Policies often discuss aims and values regarding physical activity
and health promotion, as well as more general goals. In addition to these explicitly presented
aims and values, schools called implicit aims and values that are not discussed but reflect
assumptions and priorities.
2. External Information might include information from scientific research, traditional and
social media, and consultants and advisers.
3. International, National & Local Expectations range from international guidance, such as
the WHO Physical Activity targets, to national curriculum, and municipal and local policy
statements.
4. Leaders, such as school headteachers/principals, school governing bodies, and other
leadership bodies, are known to be crucial mediators between policy and practice.\
5. Teachers / Staff and other significant adults are responsible for the promotion of physically
and healthy lifestyles of learners. In addition to teachers, this might include sports coaches,
teaching assistants, and volunteers.
6. Students’ voices in planning, delivery, and evaluation are vital elements in supporting
sustainable health-related initiatives.
7. Parents and families influence learners’ engagement with healthy lifestyles, both in and outside
of school.
8. Community refers to members of the local area, relevant service providers (such as school
neighbours, sports club owners, municipal leisure stakeholders).
233
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
9. Physical Activity, according to the HEPAS Project, includes Active Homework, Active
Learning (active lessons), Active Recess, and Active Transport (to and from school).
10. Physical Education, according to the HEPAS Project, includes school PE lessons and
physical teacher education.
11. School Sport, according to the HEPAS Project, includes competitive and non-competitive
activities taking place outside of the normal school day.
12. Healthy Lifestyles, in this context, refers to the findings of the consensus study on the most
effective elements of learning and health support systems influencing school students’ healthy
lifestyles education.
13. Social Climate refers to characteristics of the psycho-social environment and includes
interpersonal relationships, staff-teacher relationships, peer relationships, staff beliefs and
behaviours, staff communication styles, lesson and activity management and group processes.
14. The Physical Environment is made up of the real and perceived characteristics of the
physical context in which children spend their time (e.g., home, neighbourhood, school)
including aspects of urban design (e.g., presence and structure of sidewalks), traffic density and
speed, distance to and design of venues for physical activity (e.g., playgrounds, parks and
school fields), crime and safety.
15. Inclusion and Diversity refers to policies and practices that promote the participation and
engagement of all learners, irrespective of dis/abilities, gender, or other socio-economic
factors.
16. Professional Development refers to the formal, informal, and non-formal professional
training opportunities for qualified teachers and other school staff.
17. Facilities, Equipment & Resources refer to any school capital structures and spaces
associated with the promotion of health and physical activity, including gymnasia, play
equipment, fields associated with the school, and sports equipment.
18. Community Partnerships include any formal or informal understandings between the school
and members of the local neighbourhood. This might include, for example, sports groups,
religious and community associations, and shop owners.
19. Events, Project Weeks, Camps are examples of extra-curricular activities that support the
promotion of physical activity and healthy lifestyles, but usually take place outside of school
hours and away from school premises.
20. Students’ Physical Activity / Health Behaviours, in-, after-, and out-of-school, are the
intended outcomes of Active Schools.
The Five Dimensions of an Active School – Definitions and Categories
Physical Activity
Physical activity (PA) is behaviour that involves human movement, resulting in physiological
attributes including increased energy expenditure and improved physical fitness. It includes the
following categories:
234
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________________
Active Breaks
A short bout of PA performed as a break from academic instruction to increase or decrease
students’ activation.
Active Homework
Assigned physically active homework tasks that students can do on their own or with family
members.
Active Learning
The use of PA lessons in which curriculum topics are delivered through movement.
Active Recess
The dedicated break time for school-based children to engage in spontaneous play (self-organised)
or in structured play (active), but out of the formal subject-content curriculum.
Active Transport
Travel that incorporates all modes of transport relying on human power for propulsion.
Physical Education
Physical Education (PE) is supervised, structured PA experiences that are part of an explicit
curriculum domain, taking place during the school day. It includes the following categories:
Curriculum PE Lessons
Curriculum PE lessons are written, articulated plans for how standards and education outcomes
in PE will be attained. Curriculum PE can be viewed as the content of the lesson that is taught and
also as the result of how children can include PA into healthy lifestyles later.
Teacher Education Workforce
Physical Education Teacher Education (PETE) and workforce training are an essential part of
quality PE. PE teachers may be the only members of school staff professionally trained to work
with students in PA settings and thus promote a Healthy and Physically Active School concept.
School Sport
School sports are organised sporting activities within the school with the primary goal of enhancing
pupils’ knowledge, skills, and competencies in a selected sport. It can be competitive or noncompetitive. It includes the following categories:
Competitive School Sport
Result and performance-oriented individual or team sporting activities with comparable
competitiveness, in local, regional and/or national championships systems, such as Student
Olympics and Inter-School competitions.
Non-Competitive School Sport
Regular, non-result-oriented individual or team sporting activities for educational, health,
recreational, fun, or social reasons, such as school running, movement, dance clubs etc.
235
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Healthy Lifestyles
Healthy lifestyles
The collection of decisions by individuals which affect their health, and over which they have some
degree of control. The deployment of a healthy lifestyle education programme in a school setting
is shown to be more effective through the empowerment of key stakeholders to develop the basic
components of the practices that will develop the strategy and policies. It includes the following
categories:
Healthy School Policies
Healthy school policies are part of the strategy of the school and define those elements that are
most effective for promoting healthy lifestyles, both in a general plan that will contemplate health
promotion programmes for staff, family & community engagement, and healthy eating, as well as
on a more specific level with concrete actions in promoting physically active lifestyles or social,
emotional, and sex education.
Family & Community Engagement
Six types of family and community engagement have been identified as especially relevant:
parenting, communicating, volunteering, learning at home, decision making, and collaborating
with the community. By observing active behaviours and lifestyles in their families and
communities, students can internalise healthy habits, especially if health messages are shared
among the triad of school-family-community.
Healthy Eating
Healthy eating means eating a variety of foods from each of the major food groups, in the amounts
recommended, so that diet contributions positively to overall health. Healthy eating could be
developed through specific programmes, school-based interventions combining easier access to
fruit and vegetables within classroom lessons and even using engaged students as change agents.
Social & Emotional Education
Social and emotional education is the process through which students acquire and apply the
knowledge, attitudes, and skills necessary to understand and manage emotions, set and achieve
positive goals, feel and show empathy for others, establish and maintain positive relationships, and
make responsible decisions.
Health Promotion Programmes for Staff
Health promotion programmes involve deliberately training in specific topics such as school
policies, physical environment, social environment, community links, and health-sector
partnerships.
Sex Education
Sex education involves teaching and learning about a variety of topics related to sex, sexuality, and
relationships, exploring values and beliefs about those topics, and gaining the skills that are needed
to navigate relationships and manage one’s sexual health.
236
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________________
Transversal Dimension
Transversal dimensions are the themes that cut across the settings and elements that provide the
HEPAS framework. These themes feed into and are relevant to each of the settings. What follows
are summaries of these categories as they relate to the reviews above, with specific examples from
the literature to highlight their application within HEPAS. It includes the following categories:
Inclusion and Diversity
These themes deliberately address and respond to the diversity of needs of all learners through
increasing participation in learning, cultures, and communities, and reducing exclusion within and
from education. It involves changes and modifications in content, approaches, structures, and
strategies, with a common vision that covers all children of the appropriate age range and a
conviction that it is the responsibility of the regular system to educate all children.
Continuous Professional Development
Continuing professional development is the intentional maintenance and development of the
knowledge, skills, attitudes, and values needed to perform in educational contexts. It can include
formal training, collaborative practice, coaching, mentoring, peer review, reflective practice,
enquiring practice, action research, etc.
Facilities, Equipment, and Resources
These represent the physical sites and materials necessary for participating in curriculum activities.
Community Partnerships
These partnerships allow schools and community members to work together to identify a
common issue or problem and develop a plan of action to address it.
School Events, Project Weeks, and Camps
School events are events that take place either in the school itself or by the school community in
other settings. Within the context of the Active School concept, school events give a special focus
on students’ physical activity experiences. Project weeks are extended educational activities that
give students the opportunity to exp0lore different aspects of a specific theme. Examples of
project week topics might focus on physical activity, health, sport, or the local environment. Camps
enable students to explore, extend and enrich their learning and development in a non-school
setting. Camps typically involve activities requiring at least one night’s accommodation away from
home. Physically active camps may have sports, health, or cultural emphasis and can be important
aspects of the educational experiences offered by schools.
Conclusion
The Active School concept is a practical solution to the challenge of promoting PA among schoolaged children and young people. By expanding, extending, and enhancing settings and
opportunities for PA, it offers a manageable methodology for achieving the international target of
at least one hour per day, including periods of moderate-to-vigorous PA and vigorous PA.
Evidence suggests that the Active School concept is popular with students and teachers, causes no
harm to academic achievement (and can enhance it), and can significantly increase the quantity
and quality of PA experiences. Of course, not all students benefit from PA opportunities equally,
237
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
and schools and teachers must work to ensure that the PA settings do not merely result in more
opportunities for those who are already active. Strategies need to be put in place to support the
needs and interests of girls, overweight/obese students, and other groups who have been
marginalised or excluded from PA in traditional school settings.
References
Bailey, R. P., Agans, J. Côté, J., & Tomporowski, P. (2021). Sport and physical activity during the first
ten years. London, UK: Routledge.
Bailey, R., Doherty, J., & Pickup, I. (2007). Physical development and physical education. In J.
Riley (Ed.), Learning in the Early Years 3-7 (pp. 167-200). London, UK: SAGE Publications
Ltd.
Böcker, P. (2010). In Projekten lernen – Bewegte Zeit in der Ganztagsschule. In P. Frei & S.
Körner (Eds.), Ungewissheit: Sportpädagogische Felder im Wandel; Jahrestagung der dvs-Sektion
Sportpädagogik vom 11.-13. Juni 2009 in Hildesheim (pp. 151-158). Hamburg, GE: Deutsche
Vereinigung für Sportwissenschaft/Sektion Sportpädagogik.
Böcker, P. (2014). Projektwoche - bewegte Zeit in der Ganztagsschule. In R. HildebrandtStramann, R. Laging & J. Teubner (Eds.), Bewegung und Sport in der Ganztagsschule - StuBSS:
Ergebnisse der qualitativen Studie: Studie zur Entwicklung von Bewegung, Spiel und Sport in der
Ganztagsschule (StuBSS) (pp. 533-562). Baltmannsweiler: Schneider-Verlag Hohengehren.
Cale, L. (2020). Physical education’s journey on the road to health. Sport, Education and Society, 26(5),
486-499.
Guinhouya, B. C. (2010). Activité physique de l’enfant scolarisé en France. Le paradoxe d’une
priorité de santé publique! Revue d'épidémiologie et de santé publique, 58(4), 255-267.
Ip, P., Ho, F. K. W., Louie, L. H. T., Chung, T. W. H., Cheung, Y. F., Lee, S. L., ... & Jiang, F.
(2017). Childhood obesity and physical activity-friendly school environments. Journal of
Pediatrics, 191, 110-116.
Karnik, S., & Kanekar, A. S. (2011). Childhood obesity: a global public health crisis. International
Journal of Preventive Medicine, 3(1), 1-7.
Keeves, J. P. (1988). Models and model building, in J. P. Keeves (Ed.), Educational research,
methodology and measurement: an international handbook. Oxford: Pergamon.
Pawlowski, C. S., Tjørnhøj-Thomsen, T., Schipperijn, J., & Troelsen, J. (2014). Barriers for recess
physical activity: a gender specific qualitative focus group exploration. BMC Public
Health, 14(1), p. 639.
Pavelka, J., Sigmund, E., & Sigmundová, D. (2014). Analýza organizačních a materiálních
podmínek pro pohybovou aktivitu a tělesnou výchovu na školách v České republice. Tělesná
kultura, 37(1), 9-22.
Volkmann, V. (2015). Gesundheit fördern: Bestandsaufnahme und Perspektiven für den
Schulsport. Sportpädagogik, 39(1), 2-5
238
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Behavioral Disorders in Children Owing to Confinement by the
COVID-19 Pandemic - Proposal of Daily Goals to Restart Physical
Activity for Mental Health
Giovanni Hernández - Ricardo Ortiz Pulido - Rubén Ortiz Pulido
Veracruzana University, Mexico
e-mail: giotubarao@gmail.com
Abstract
There is increasing scientific evidence that continuous physical exercise offers significant positive
effects for improving mental health. Health restrictions show how children react to these events
(pandemic confinement), in the results of the tests applied, we can see how children are emotionally
affected and we must think about how we are going to compensate for these deficiencies, from
parents, family, neighborhood and society. There are notorious eating disorders, not only mental
ones, it is not a lost generation, they are just fragile, they are affected and they are cautious with the
way in which assistance and safe return to social activities are gradually normalized.
Key words: Confinement, Physical activity, Quarantine restrictions, Mental Health, Pandemic,
COVID-19
239
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Context
On March 11, 2020, in a statement given by Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesu, Director of the World
Health Organization, thus declaring Covid-19 a pandemic, in this way the world leaders took
sanitary measures to bring down or at least try to mitigate the effects of the virus in their countries,
borders were closed, the population was confined to their homes, declaring a quarantine that
expanded to 2 years of confinement, there were businesses closed, and people lost their jobs for
the same reason, life as we knew, radically changed, the work has been done remotely and only at
the beginning of 2022 has it returned to face-to-face classes. (Caballero, 2021:15)
The confinement practically led children from all over the world to a period of 2 years of inactivity
and if we add to this the serious problems of sedentary lifestyle that the Mexican population already
had, which in addition to poor eating habits, 6 of each 10 Mexican children have obesity,
overweight or even some type of chronic degenerative disease derived from these same health
conditions according to the 2020 National Health and Nutrition Survey on Covid-19 National
Results, applied in the year 2020 and published in the year 2021 by part of the Ministry of Health
of Mexico.
Having this context, we will be able to give an analysis of the severe problem that comes as an act
of repercussion in the form of a whiplash in children that will increase their symptoms in the long
run, that is why this type of proposal They seek to generate changes in the physical and mental
plane to be able to have health in both directions.
The effects of exercise on psychological health in children and adolescents specifically on children
and adolescents, reviews have been carried out on the topic we are dealing with. Among the most
recent, we can first highlight that of Biddle (1993), who states as a summary that the study of the
benefits of exercise on psychological health requires an expansion in pediatric research. Given the
fact that physical exercise can have positive emotional effects and whose children suffer from
emotional problems, the rational arguments for the preventive and therapeutic effects of exercise
that are used from the biological perspective can also be applied from the biological point of view
psychological. In this sense, one of the key issues facing educators at the moment is the
development of self-esteem in children.
Consequently, the potential beneficial effects of physical exercise on this subject are an important
issue to consider, both from the point of view of health and from the educational point of view.
Calfas and Taylor (1994) analyzed the existing literature on this subject in the ages between 11 and
21 years, as a result they concluded that the most consistent effect about the improvement of
psychological health is the increase in self-esteem. In addition, they also found a relationship
between the practice of physical exercise and a decrease in anxiety among the practicing subjects.
(Tejada, J. & Nuviala. 2016:18)
240
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
From behavioral problems to behavioral disorders
At first, it is important to define when children's attitudes are a relevant problem and when it is
just one more step in their normal self-development, that is, not all the behaviors observed in this
pandemic are the result of confinement, many of the Behaviors are now carefully viewed due to
the global health situation, but not all of them are caused by COVID-19.
From this consideration, the importance of evaluating behavioral problems is observed, to see if
they are at risk or not; in this sense to adhere to a possible diagnosis and subsequent physical and
mental treatment since without a doubt one cannot exist without going hand in hand with the
other. On the other hand, behavioral disorders are characterized by repetitive patterns of dissocial,
provocative or aggressive behavior in children between 8 and 11 years of age according to ICD11, which is the International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems
(WHO) in its last update 2019 and replicated for Latin America, through PAHO (Pan American
Health Organization).
When we evaluate behaviors in a child, it is important to take into account the age, the level of
socioeconomic development, among many other traits, since many behaviors that can be called
normal at certain ages or situations are not, however we must remember that the origins of our
behaviors are of a multifactorial, environmental order and it is important to detect any physical,
psychological or mental situation at an early age in a timely manner and more so when talking about
what happened in this pandemic that paralyzed the world, since any mental disorder can evolve in
future adults with a type of disorder or with a problem at some stage of their future life which
could lead to mental consequences due to confinement and all its social remnants, which is already
beginning to be called the second pandemic, the mental pandemic of COVID- 19.
Although we cannot confirm at this early stage of the pandemic's progress with such certainty
whether or not children and young people could develop a mental disorder or some type of
disorder associated with the pandemic, what we can confirm by reviewing the history of the planet,
are the social experiences where there was also confinement due to the war, for example, in them
we can observe that isolated people, replicated some personality disorder or even chronic mental
disorder at some point in their lives and that they present some unwanted personality traits that
were directly negatively affected by this situation, that is why we must be guided by past experiences
to project and see that they somehow left knowledge, experiences and thus on this occasion to be
able to diagnose promptly and act promptly to be able to counter by giving a range of healthy
physical activity options for health so that children (body and mind) can better integrate into society
after two years of confinement, where at this point in the year it already appears to be the final part
of the COVID-19 pandemic.
The research methodology used in this chapter is mixed, supported by the collection of data
supported by the survey tool of a single edition for parents and interviews with children. In order
not to start from assumptions, but from tangible realities, it is necessary to mention that a battery
241
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
of psychological evaluation was used, the ESPERI test for parents of children aged 8-11 years
(questionnaire for the detection of behavioral disorders in children and adolescents, answered by
the parents of the children) with linear scale interpretation, on this occasion it is very difficult to
have a control group, since everyone suffered from the pandemic so it would be very difficult to
find people who have not been confined.
Results
In order to interpret the questionnaires applied to a population in the first instance, the ESPERI
Test, a questionnaire for the detection of behavioral disorders in children and adolescents, created
by the O Belén Madrid foundation, was used. The Purpose is the early detection of behavioral
problems to carry out an early and precise intervention. It must be remembered that this test is not
for a conclusive diagnosis, but rather indicators of the probability that you suffer from a behavioral
disorder are sought.
On this occasion there was the participation of 87 parents of children between 7 and 11 years old
who were male and female, the conclusions and results of the study highlight all its manifestations,
with differences between males and females, the latter have higher score in impulsivity and
hyperactivity in males. The score and interpretation ranges are applied as normal, mild, moderate
and severe, the risk cases are subjects who are above the 600th percentile in the various factors, if
it is less than 600 they do not present a disorder in that trait, the three factors to analyze are
Attention-impulsivity-hyperactivity (IIH), the second is Oppositional Defiant (OD) and the last is
Predisocial and Dissocial (PDDI). The first two show a high rank and the third is below the middle
percentile, the results of the analysis of the answers of the questionnaires are shown in detail and
in this way to elaborate the profiles, everything is based on the criteria of the DSM-V and the ICD11 of the World Health Organization.
In this sense, it is necessary to briefly comment on what these three criteria that it evaluates refer
to in order to have a clearer result divided as factors:
Table 1 Observation factors ESPERI Test with brief description
Factor 1 A.I.H.
Attention-ImpulsivityHyperactivity
Factor 2 D. O.
Defiant Opposition
Factor 3 P.D.D.I.
Predisocial and dissocial
It is based on different predictive components of ADHD
(Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder)
It is a pattern of disobedient, hostile and defiant behavior
towards authority figures.
Children with Conduct Disorder are selfish and insensitive
to the feelings of others and may bully, damage property,
lie, or steal without feeling guilty.
242
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
The cause of oppositional defiant disorder isn't exactly known, but it may involve a combination
of genetic and environmental factors. Symptoms usually appear before the age of eight. They
include irritability, combative and defiant behavior, aggressiveness, and revengefulness that last
more than six months and cause significant problems at home or school. The symptoms of conduct
disorder, usually, in children with conduct disorder have the following characteristics: they are
selfish, they do not relate well to others, they lack an appropriate sense of guilt, they are insensitive
to feelings and welfare of others, they tend to misinterpret the behavior of other people as a threat
and react aggressively, undertake intimidating actions, threats, frequent fights, may be cruel to
animals, may damage property, lie or steal.
Conduct disorder affects boys and girls differently. Girls are less likely to be physically aggressive.
Instead, they often run away or lie. Children tend to get into fights, steal or vandalize. They often
seriously violate the rules, including running away from home and frequently being absent from
school. These children are prone to drug use and abuse and have difficulties in school. They may
have suicidal thoughts and should be seriously considered. Children with conduct disorder may
have other disorders, such as depression, attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder, or a learning
disorder. About two-thirds of children outgrow inappropriate behavior by the time they reach
adulthood. The earlier Conduct Disorder appears, the more likely it is to persist into adult life. If
the behavior continues into adult life, it often leads to legal problems, pervasive violation of the
rights of others, and frequently a diagnosis of antisocial personality disorder. Some of these adults
develop mood disorders, anxiety, or other mental disorders.
ESPERI TEST APPLIED TO BOYS AND GIRLS FROM 7 TO 11
YEARS OLD
1100
MAXIMUM
542
P.D.D.I.
D. O.
862
A. I. H.
917
0
Severity percentile
200
400
Predisocial and dissocial
600
Defiant Opposition
800
1200
Attention-Impulsivity-Hyperactivity
Picture 1 Resultados del Test ESPERI 2022
243
1000
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Target
Develop a social policy that promotes attention to the main demands of society for physical activity
for health after the COVID-19 pandemic from the perspective of physical activity for all, that is,
from a holistic perspective to contribute to the global development of children in the State of
Veracruz, Mexico, through strategic planning with real impact over time motor commitment and
controlled aerobic activities improving health conditions, inclusion, transparency, opportunities
and thus expand the scope of action of the municipalities serving all sectors of society in a state of
vulnerability.
The concept of health, according to the world health organization is the complete state of physical,
mental and social well-being, here two of the topics addressed in this research are included.
“Among the behaviors that are considered favorable for health, and that consequently should be
part of a healthy lifestyle, three types of habits are fundamentally identified: correct nutrition,
adequate and regular practice of physical activity, and rest patterns. regular and of appropriate
duration. ( (Tejada, 2016:15))
Project scope (target audience)
Develop healthy lifestyle habits through physical activity and sports for all in children and
adolescents, as well as with people with and without disabilities. Correct use of free time, creative
and recreational physical activities, creating permanent healthy lifestyles after the COVID-19
Pandemic in the State of Veracruz, Mexico.
To achieve our objective, we propose 4 core programs:
1.
2.
3.
4.
Sports Promotion.
Sports Material Support, with municipal management.
Creation and Rehabilitation of Sports Spaces.
Education and Training of Trainers and Sports Promoters.
Action Plan and Strategies
•
•
•
•
•
•
Planning and Quality in the services provided.
Suitable and trained Human Resources to develop the activities.
Acquisitions and quality services.
Healthy Finances.
Infrastructure.
Comprehensive communication and social closeness plan
244
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
Permanent campaign of physical activation for health. “Sport for all”
Supporting physical activity, along with an approach (educational and informative), This
comprehensive action plan identifies four strategic objectives:
1. Inform all the fathers and mothers of the children to raise awareness towards an active
society.
2. Educate physically through various activities, creating active environments.
3. The action lines of permanent physical activation.
4. Evaluate the results, through monitoring and reporting, can be achieved through 13
benchmarks that apply to all residents, obviously graduating depending on age, whether or
not they have a disability, health status, clinical history, among other factors. , recognizing
that Mexico and especially the State of Veracruz is going through some stage of obesity and
that we show sincere efforts to reduce the levels and habits of lazy sedentary lifestyle:
Actions
1. Communication campaigns on optimal practices of physical activity for health, thus sensitize
parents with the knowledge, understanding and appreciation of healthy lifestyles and their
visible long-term impact on the body, the family, the neighborhood, the community and the
State.
2. Organize regular mass activities in public spaces hand in hand with the municipal sports
committees, such as yoga classes, Zumba and night activities by bicycle, where the
community participates, with easy access and free of charge.
3. Training of professionals who provide the service before and during this series of events,
especially in recreational activities, leisure and recreation, social sports and physical training
in community groups based on the person's biotype, age and health status.
4. Converse with the powers of government to integrate urban planning policies, reinstatement
of abandoned or neglected sports areas, among others.
5. The use of the bike lane in the city to generate the habit of traveling to work places by bicycle
and thus cover the demand for transportation, reduce pollution, as well as traffic in the city
and therefore physical activity that generates active lifestyles and healthy.
6. Improve access to open public spaces and green areas, green networks and recreational
spaces, as well as parks to make the most of them and make them safe areas where people
can walk, carry out some specific physical activity or of a recreational nature adapted the
activities to people with disabilities and older people reducing inequality gaps.
7. Real massive physical activations in schools, as well as in public institutions to activate
workers who lead sedentary lives and generate good movement habits in them.
8. Start up an evaluation and follow-up system for people with sedentary behavior from the
State Health Secretariat and in this way refer them to where they can carry out physical
activity according to their current physical situation, that they be gradually activated and
provide a tracing. (this is where physical and sports educators are in charge of prescribing
physical activity)
245
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
9. Encourage people who have the opportunity to promote an active state of health, supporting
companies with subsidies or even vouchers that serve to be exchanged in committed and
sponsoring companies that generate active lifestyles with repercussions on social support.
10. Physical activity for the elderly for a healthy and active ageing.
11. Strengthening of active community environments in marginal areas or areas of difficult
access where someone is trained and can be a physical activating agent.
12. Strengthening and creation of school leagues, not only as seedbeds for future athletes, but
also for people who from a young age can have the experience of physical activity through
sports to generate healthy lifestyles, the earlier the age is better and will be lasting to generate
healthy and active lifestyles. With various sports with the support of state sports associations
and specialists in physical activity.
13. Development of programs for vulnerable groups, to offer these sectors ignored by the
government physical activity for health in a systematic way to generate healthy lifestyles in
this part so neglected by society and provide them with the opportunity of movement and
lifestyles assets, away from vices and delinquency.
Conclusions
The restrictions against social interaction, without a doubt, are the ones that brought the most
negative effects in terms of the well-being and behavior of all children, the decision made by the
World Health Organization to confine ourselves in the face of the serious pandemic and even the
organisms Health officials from each country who, depending on the incidences, mortality rates
and despite the risks caused by the contagion and the symptoms of covid-19, locked us up, where
it can be mentioned that there is a brief risk as a side effect of damaging the sense of smell and
children's taste in the long run and there are even studies that indicate a prevalence of persistent
Covid-19 contagion and even an increase in childhood diabetes, really although we have this
information, the truth is that definitive conclusions cannot yet be given, because we are still in a
very primary phase to be able to establish forceful criteria of the effects of this pandemic on a
physical and therefore mental level.
Director of the Psychiatric Center for Children and Adolescents of the Medical University of
Innsbruck in Austria, Dr. Kathrin Sevecke, investigates the repercussions of the pandemic on
children and adolescents, aged between 3 to 13 years, she confirms that in children allied in their
research, the feeling of negative emotional charge has increased, persisting the feeling of threat,
uncertainty, worsening of mood, emotional deprivation, feelings of fear and this without a doubt
has greatly reduced the quality of life in children which has decreased, some children express
loneliness, and a notorious difficulty to carry normally all the festivities and social activities to which
they were accustomed in their daily life, burdened with worries from adults since there were layoffs
and the uncertainty of the parents and their concerns permeate the mental health of children, they
learned so many things as adults that in other circumstances they would not know They would also
comment that there is a brief difference between the sexes, since it was noted that boys express
246
Researches
__________________________________________________________________________________
themselves more quickly, showing aggressiveness, while girls are more cautious in these
circumstances, although it really shows that both are equally overwhelmed and mentally exhausted.
The rates of domestic violence also cause repercussions, and although all this is multifactorial, as
well as seeing friends again, resuming classes, we really think of mixed solutions where we gradually
move from virtuality to the present, it is important to observe little by little Little how the behavior
of children and young people develops to be able to give attention to any trait that implies some
kind of mental disorder in them.
Physical activity has important benefits for the health of the heart, body and mind, physical activity
helps prevent and manage non-communicable diseases such as cardiovascular diseases, cancer and
diabetes, physical activity reduces symptoms of depression and anxiety, Physical activity improves
thinking, learning, and judgment skills Physical activity ensures healthy growth and development
in young people Physical activity improves overall well-being Globally, 1 in 4 adults fall short of
physical activity levels recommended globally, up to 5 million deaths a year could be prevented if
the world population were more active, people who are insufficiently active have a 20% to 30%
increased risk of death compared to people who are sufficiently active, more than 80% of the
world's adolescent population does not have enough physical activity, according to the Pan
American Organization Of the health.
References
Barbero, J. (2005). La escolarización del cuerpo: reflexiones en torno a la levedad de los valores del capital «cuerpo»
en Educación Física. Revista iberoamericana de educación, 39, 25-51.
Blázquez, D. (2011). Diez Competencias docentes para ser mejor profesor de Educación Física. España: Inde.
Caballero, F. (2021) La pandemia de COVID-19 y los cambios en las condiciones de Vida. Colombia: Fondo
Editorial Universidad Cooperativa de Colombia.
Cruz, E., Moreno, M., Pino, J., y Martínez, R. (2011). Actividad física durante el tiempo libre y su relación
con algunos indicadores de salud mental en España. España: Salud mental, 34(1), 45-52. Recuperado
en 25 de marzo de 2022, de
http://www.scielo.org.mx/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S018533252011000100006&lng=es&tlng=es.
Devís, J. (2000). Actividad física, deporte y salud. España: INDE.
Devís, J. y Beltrán, V. (2007). La educación física escolar y la promoción de la actividad física y la salud. En
D.P. Cevallos y N.C. Molina (Eds.), Educación corporal y salud: gestación, infancia y
adolescencia (pp. 29-43). Colombia: Funámbulos.
Fernández, A. (2008). El tiempo en la clase de educación física, la competencia tiempo docente. Deporte y actividad
física deporte para todos., 4, 102-120. Recuperado de
http://digibug.ugr.es/handle/10481/29529
García, F. (2001). Psicología de las emociones en el deporte. Buenos Aires: Jorge A. Socin Ediciones.
Generelo, E. (1996). Una aproximación al estudio del compromiso fisiológico en la educación física y deporte
educativo. En CSD, n°10, pp. 53-88. España: CSD.
247
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Guerrero M. (2017). Physical Education in Primary School. Italia: Prensa multimedia.
González, A. y Ramírez, A. (2020). Análisis y reflexiones sobre el COVID-19 Pandemia y Postpandemia.
España: Bosch Editor
Guillén, F. y Márquez S. (2016). Directorio de Psicología de la Actividad Física y del Deporte. España:
Wanceulen Editorial Deportiva, S. L.
López, V., Pérez, D., Manrique, J.C., & Monjas, R. (2016). Los retos de la Educación Física en el siglo
XXI. Retos. Nuevas Tendencias en Educación Física, Deporte y Recreación. 29, 182-187
Physical activity and stress resilience: Considering those At-Risk for developing mental health
problems, Mental Health and Physical Activity, 8, 1-7. doi: 10.1016/j.mhpa.2014.10.001.
Quindimil, D. (2021) Mundo Post COVID, la psicología del trabajo tras la pandemia. Argentina: Ediciones
Granica
Ramírez, A. (2021) Manual para actuar frente a la covid-19. España: Marge Books.
Rodríguez, C., Medrano, O. y Hernandez, A. (2021) Salud mental de los mexicanos durante la pandemia
de COVID-19. México: Gaceta Médica. vol.157, n.3, pp.228-233. ISSN 2696-1288.
Rodríguez, G., Barriopedro, M., & Alonso, P. y Garrido, M. (2015). Relaciones entre Actividad Física y
Salud Mental en la Población Adulta de Madrid. España: Revista de Psicología del Deporte, 24
(2),233-239.[fecha de Consulta 25 de Marzo de 2022]. ISSN: 1132-239X. Disponible en:
https://www.redalyc.org/articulo.oa?id=235141413005
Secchi, N., Nikos, C. y Anda, J.C. (2021). SARS-CoV-2: Abordaje multidisciplinario. México: Editorial
Alfil S.A. de C. V.
Secretaría de Salud Gobierno Federal México. (2021) Encuesta Nacional de Salud y Nutrición 2020 sobre
Covid-19 Resultados Nacionales.
Tejeda, J. y Nuviala, A. (2016) Actividad Física y Salud. Español: Universidad de Huelva
Warburton, D. E., Nicol, C. W., Bredin, S. (2006). Health benefits of physical activity: the evidence.
Canadian Medical Association Journal, 174, 801-809.
doi: https://doi.org/10.1503/cmaj.051351
William, L. (2001). Assessing the Influence of Physical Activity on Health and Fitness. American
Journal of Human Biology, 13, 159-161. doi: 10.2196/mhealth.6239 Wilner, N.J., Tone, E.B.
(2014).
World Health Organization. (2019) International Statistical Classification of Diseases an Related Health
Problems ICD-11
248
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
Best Practices
249
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
250
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
“Creix amb Dansa”: Healthy Active Living Project for Children
and Youth, based on a Leisure Education initiative and NeuroEF
principles through Dance and Physical Education
Agustí Castillo Cañiz1 - Nàdia Pesarrodona Rovira2
Ramón Llull University- FPCEE Blanquerna, Spain
2
INEFC- Universitat de Barcelona, Spain
e-mail: fiepcatalunya@gmail.com
1
Abstract
This article draws from a specific Healthy Active Living intervention within leisure education
scheme, carried out from 2015 in rural accommodations in Catalonia. The project has been
implementing over 7 years as part of a summer camp unique curriculum intervention for students
aged 8 to 16 years old. The main objective of the initiative is to provide a quality educational setting
based on student’s social interaction and critical thinking as well as acknowledging Dance and
Physical Education as tools for improving health quality standards and Social Transformation
values within the participants. The initiative is promoted by education professionals and taking the
shape of a joint project between Creix amb Dansa and Inncredu organisations. A multi-method
intervention and pedagogical strategies such as peer-feedbak and project-based learning have been
adopted over the years to promote specific encounters among students, and to reinforce the
importance of health in several areas. According to neuroscience findings related to physical
education known as NeuroEF (Pellicer, 2015), the project has wanted to highlight the importance
of understanding health as a wider spectrum of “healths” (Physical Health, Mental Health, Emotional
Health, Inner Health and Social Health) and deploying a number of activities to cover them. Over the
years, participants have been benefiting as the intervention have met general Dance and Physical
Education objectives and competencies, as well as improving emotional intelligence, personal and
social values.
Key words: Quality Physical Education (QPE), Leisure Education (LE), Dance, Neuroscience,
NeuroEF, Health, peer-feedback, project-based learning, Social Emotional Learning, Personal &
Social Values, Social Transformation.
251
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
Creix amb Dansa was created by a group of enthusiastic professionals planning to deliver leisure
education activities based on neuroscience findings about the impact of motor movement into
several human body systems and the learning process of the brain. The initiative was originated,
putting into practice years of leisure education knowledge, aiming to generate a unique educational
proposal with a renovated vision and generating a fulfilling educational option for families.
Although leisure education has been improving their summer time proposals, back in 2015 there
were still large number of proposals in the market based on a sequence of activities with a lack of
educational objectives, or made as a part of a massified proposal produced in order to gain large
sums of income during a short period of time.
On one hand, there were sporting initiatives, covering a wide range of sports during a period of
time with a certain technical input, depending on the age and aims of the group of participants. In
this group we could also find a large number of mountaineering-related activities led by scout
organisations, a very popular activity across the Catalonia region. On the other hand, a number of
mixed initiatives presenting a wide range of activities from different disciplines, but with a lack of
intentional educational input and generated to solve a particular family organisation management
during summer time. Both proposals, as well as many specific others such as technology campus,
arts and crafts or more specialised options, were created with the aim of entertaining rather than
generate a place for alternative education.
Literature review
For the realisation of this project, over the years, relevant literature has been reviewed in order to
obtained documentation to reinforce the professional praxis. We have looked at the importance
of the brain in improving general health thanks to the motor movement of the body and the
NeuroEF impulse as a way to implement Neuroscience findings; as well as Dance as an educational
tool, Quality Physical Education principles and Social Transformation as a critical pedagogy for
education.
General aspects of neuroscience
Since the beginning of the century, neuroscience has proved the close relationship between
movement and brain health in order to delay its ageing process. In fact, doing regular exercise can
be seen as one of the crucial aspects to help in improving the cognitive functioning. Back in 2008,
John Ratey stated that exercise help in enlighten the brain, thanks to the improvement of the
prefrontal cortex as a responsible of many executive tasks: planification, organisation, evaluation,
learning, keeping attention, etc. (Ratey, 2008). According to the author, this is possible thanks to
the deployment of BDNF (Brain-Derived Neurotrophic Factor) during exercise. Increasing BDNF
helps in improving learning factors, attentional skills, motivation and the lasting effects of the
memory (Ratey, 2008).
252
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
In more recent years, other scientists have proved that doing exercise produces an increase of blood
flow that helps in having more cerebral activity and generating substances responsible for
increasing synaptic plasticity and neurogenesis (Morgado, 2014). It has been also proved that doing
physical exercise creates new blood vessels into the brain helping in the learning process. Finally,
some scientists have suggested that without regular physical activity the brain perceives that its
neurones are not as important as other neurones across the body and tends to cut them off,
seriously impacting in brain’s capacity to solve mathematic problems and producing reflexive
writings. (Sousa, 2014).
NeuroEF (a neuroscience Physical Education perspective)
NeuroEF is a theoretical proposal of Irene Pellicer (2015) put into practice thanks to its delivery
during PE sessions. Within the theory, health is broken up into 5 dimensions (Physical Health,
Mental Health, Emotional Health, Inner Health and Social Health) that help in building a
general integrative Health of human beings. The idea is to create a path, starting with
understanding, protecting and working with our body as the basic element for the generation of
movement and the Physical Health. After providing movement into the body the second steps
lead us to the Mental Health as a result of increasing exercise and in relation to neuroscience
findings of benefits directly related to the brain.
The third level impacts on Emotional Health. Incorporating the treatment of this health into the
educational process helps in treating emotions as a fundamental part of children and youth
curriculum. Provide learning tools for a better listening, knowledge, expression and management
of emotions that have a direct relationship with our physical body (Pellicer, 2015). Dealing with
emotions helps in having a better understanding of our inner body related to Inner Health as a
fourth level of this process. Helping students in taking time to look and work with their inner
health will result in a better self-understanding and therefore, in a better relationship with their
outer world in terms of harmony and sustainability (Pellicer, 2015).
The last stop of the health journey ends up with the Social Health as a way to connect everyone’s
inner world with the rest of the people and their own personal perspective about life. Taking into
account that human beings are considered gregarious animals it is crucial to learn how to relate to
others. Improving non-verbal communication, solidarity, cooperation and other basic social skills
are crucial in order to be able to function within a group of people. Some scientists support the
theory that in adolescent ages the brain creates a sophisticated net of neuronal connections linked
with rewards and positive social interactions. Social rejection during youth period could end up in
a general perception of danger towards others and block, peer social learnings.
Dance as an educational tool to improve overall wellbeing
Dance can be worked individually in order to discover a range of self-perception and creativity, as
well as in group in order to enhance fellowship and positive coexistence towards reaching a joint
objective. In spite of being a part of an educational process, participants in a dance project can
253
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Figure 1 Range of Healths impacting on overall Health according to NeuroEF Theory by
Irene Pellicer (2015)
discover the main features of a dance world, valuing the dancer dedication and the dose of effort
needed to achieve in a cooperative way (Bautista, 2016).
Improving body expression, self-perception, social capital and overall wellbeing and health as well
as reducing stress and mental health potential issues are some of the pursued objectives of
introducing dance (Sheppard & Broughton, 2020). Over the years, results have revealed a
significant increase in the socio-emotional skills of the pupils who participated in dance programs
in relation to self-management and relationship skills (Pereira & Marques-Pinto, 2017).
Quality Physical Education for lifelong participation and inclusion
Taking into account neuroscience and NeuroEF learnings, the overall purpose of the
implementation is to consolidate students’ lifelong participation strategies towards improving their
health and help them seeing Physical Activity as a crucial item to promote their wellbeing through
dance and Physical Education. Following Quality Physical Education (QPE) principles, a need for
enhancing participants’ interpersonal skills, social learning and provide specific encounters between
students has been secured during the summer camp experiences (Castillo, Campos & Sebastiani,
2018).
Specially related to this particular summer camp, Quality Physical Education (QPE) principles state
that it has to be a consideration in how girls’ approach and experience sport and physical activity
to make the experience relevant and enjoyable for them. Initiatives have to be taken to support and
encourage girls to engage in physical education and physical activity, overtaking barriers such as
body image and physical education/sport image (McLennan & Thompson, 2015). Besides, an
accompanying role from professionals in overseeing the big picture relationships between
254
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
sport/physical activity and gender, has to be monitored to avoid future rejection of girls in taking
part in sport and PA activities.
Social Transformation to introduce critical pedagogy
Social transformation pedagogy has a potential to mobilise empathy, social acceptance and
solidarity within participants. This educational approach helps in pushing participants’ imagination
towards situations and contexts outside of the usual setting, both in space-time and symbolic levels.
It helps in minimising the gap between educational curriculum and society challenges (MartosGarcia et al., 2021). Discussions followed by using social transformation pedagogy, helps in
mobilising participants’ attitudes, feelings and facilitates the production of critical reflections to
help in building a more openness oneself personality (Martos-Garcia et al., 2021).
Promoting autonomy patterns, increasing critical thinking and activating Social Transformation
attitude towards life are the accompanying, but yet, equally important objectives of the intervention
deployment. According to the three-level achievement process related to Social Transformation
(Identification, Familiarisation and Transformation), participants have been able to recognise an
issue topic within a social context, have been able to relate their own actions according to the topic
and plan actions for improving their relation towards the topic in real life (Castillo, 2020).
Figure 2 Theorical components of Creix amb Dansa Project and the implementing elements.
THE PROJECT GENERALITIES
Objectives
The whole project has been delivered in order to explore NeuroEF theory put into practice in a
non-academical setting and based on Leisure Education principles of having fun while improving
various skills without the need of following and strict curriculum. Therefore, the objectives respond
to this general idea of combining leisure with conscious learning and having dance as a central
theme.
255
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
-
General objectives:
• To enjoy themselves and others while improving overall wellbeing.
• To experiment several dance techniques and disciplines.
• To participate in a range of activities based on alternative education.
• To activate social transformation attitude and critical thinking.
• To improve autonomy patterns and the spirit of overcoming.
-
Objectives related to NeuroEF implementation:
• Physical Health: to improve physical fitness properties to enhance health and life
quality standards.
• Mental Health: to develop cognitive abilities, especially those related to memory and
coordination.
• Social Health: to reinforce coexistence principles and positive attitude towards the
group of participants and society.
• Emotional Health: to learn how to express, identify and communicate feelings and
emotions through dance and performing body.
• Inner Health: to value own personal capacities in order to improve self-esteem and
self-recognition.
Group of participants and setting
Since its creation, the project has reached over 40 families and their children. The participants are
aged 8 to 16 years old, with a notorious presence of females. Despite the fact that this was not the
original option, it has helped in treating more specific female concerning topics, working on girl
empowerment and use their voice and exercise leadership skills (Voelker, 2016). Worries about
self-image peer pressure, eating disorders and social media addictions derived from inadequate
usage, have been some of the common issues treated. Professionals in charge of the project have
worked towards treating these issues with respect and in accordance with parents and professionals’
guidelines.
The intervention has experienced three different locations over the years, but from 2018 onwards
it has been taking place in Mas Comademont, a rural accommodation located in Olot, the capital city
of one of Catalonia region counties. This final settlement has improved project opportunities in
various areas such as organising better outdoor activities, giving participants more autonomy (the
house is booked just for the project participants’) and improving meal options and opportunities
to work on a healthier diet as a part of the educational input.
256
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
Figures 3 & 4 Participants in two of the activities of 2022 edition.
Timetable and activities pattern
The Project has a duration of one week, starting on Sunday. The timetable is structured following
three daily time zones (morning, afternoon and night). In the morning pupils take part in dance
activities (contemporary dance, hip hop, jazz, African dance, acrobatics and body percussion) as
well as music (with percussion instruments). After having lunch and a midday break to facilitate
digestion, the afternoon activities start with a number of physical education and motor games and
creative workshops. At night, a number of social transformation games are deployed as well as film
projections and other specific activities to accompany the main objectives of the project.
Each activity is organised following the same pattern with a general introduction to the activity, a
main part where participants can interact with each other and with the topic and a final plenary
activity where the group is organised in a big circle and everyone have a chance to share their
opinions and feelings about the activity, as well as highlighting particular learnings gained from it.
Besides, throughout the whole campus, participants can deliver messages to other members of the
group by posting them into a named envelope hanging in one of the main rooms of the house.
Topics organisation
Topics are being organised following the general views on health achieving process of NeuroEF
impulse. The five dimensions of health are present during the whole week and sometimes they
cannot be split from one another. However, a particular health is chosen as the main one to be
considered in each of the activities. This action helps in keeping a balance among each health and
it is overseen during the whole process, making sure that all of them are present during activities
deployment. Therefore, all dimensions of health are put into practice in order to facilitate group
interaction with all of them.
257
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
In general terms, the physical health is worked during the dance activities, as well as during the
nutrition workshops, in meals and resting time. The guiding professors highlight the importance
of having proper rest and nutritive guidance as basic elements to improve physical health and
facilitating a better energetic supplementation for the body. Although not being the main one,
physical health it is also present during physical education and motor game activities. During this
interaction time among participants, social health gets especial attention and becomes the main
area of development, as well as in other social encounters such as thematic escape rooms and social
transformation night games.
Inner Health is worked in a more relax and calm atmosphere with activities related to yoga, postural
breathing and using particular mindfulness routines. By using creative and sensorial workshops to
accompany mental health, we incorporate a number of arts and crafts activities, music therapy
dynamics and other initiatives that provide time to create the final show scenery, outfits and the
script. On the emotional side, various tools are used in order to follow up the health. Emotional
thermometer, calming areas, resolution strategies to overcome conflicts, as well as particular
activities to identify emotional status are used throughout the campus.
All the activities have a joint objective of working the dimensions of health in order to prepare
participants for a final dance and multidisciplinary show that englobes all the learnings of the week.
During the show, spectators, mainly parents and family members of the participants, are invited to
dive into the world of health and other topics treated within the week (human rights, environmental
protection, refugees’ situation, etc.). The show has about an hour of duration and it is a clear
example on how important is to work a wider concept of human health and all its dimensions in
order to get the most out of each participant.
Figure 5 Topics organisation activities in relation to the final show
258
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
THE PROJECT DELIVERY
Methodological tools and strategies
Despite the fact that the campus is organised under a ludic and dynamic methodology through the
use of alternative education parameters, there is a deployment of a battery of methodological
approaches in order to uplift participants experience during the activities. Most of these tools are
taken from mainstream and special education system delivery patterns adapted to a lesser strict and
curricular environment, but with the same level of professionalism and dedication. The main
methodological tools used throughout the project are: project-based learning, guided discovery,
peer-feedback, problem-solving and gamification.
The main methodological process is planned as a project-based learning structure where
participants had to work together playing their particular role in the group in order to reach the
objectives and work towards the final show creation. This highlights the importance of a guided
discovery pattern strategy, commonly used throughout dance lessons due to the visual and
practical assets of the subject. Professionals propose the task and different levels of difficulty and
participants have the responsibility to decide which level match their own skill in order to choose
the appropriate routine (Chatzipanteli et al., 2015). By using this methodology participants realise
their own potential in performing dance and other activities, while having a realistic guidance by
the teacher.
Encouraging peer-feedback derives into a sense of solidarity towards the rest of the group and
compromise effective teaching strategies commonly used for affective learning (Teraoka et al.,
2020). This methodology is used both in particular couple dynamics, where one of the members
guides the other one and in a wider cooperative group initiative. Solidarity born as a result of
applying previous methodologies induce the group to create their own problem-solving strategies
out of a particular difficult situation that may arouse in order to achieve what was planned. This
process is accompanied by emotional strategies taken from the emotional health implementation
such as relaxation techniques and positive self-talks, where participants can reflect on the sources
of stress and negative thoughts (Teraoka et al., 2020) out of any social situation.
The implementation of particular methodologies helps in improving outcomes and enhancing
participants and professionals’ encounters throughout the project, as well as increasing the leisure
background. This is the case of applying gamification where participants are prompted to work
cooperatively and supporting each other during particular activities. By applying this methodology,
a number of game elements are taken into account in order to use them in an educative framework
and in non-game contexts (Deterding et al., 2011). The social and collective intentionality of the
games helps participants in experiencing relevant social issues such as migration, human rights,
health habits, etc., as part of a planned social transformation proposal.
259
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Attention to diversity of participants
Attention to diversity starts when professionals in charge of an activity understand that every one
of the project participants has their own personal feelings and biorhythms. Only by accepting and
respecting this premise, we can generate a thoughtful set of activities that guarantees the correct
functioning of the project and the generation of personal learnings. Within the project, this
acknowledgement is put into practice by reinforcing parallel SEL (Social and Emotional Learning)
activities based on emotional health activities in order to facilitate a personal approach to improve
self-knowledge and personal discovery.
Personal discovery can be especially seen during reflection times at the end of each day where
participants can rely upon their own daily experiences to express their feelings, likes and dislikes.
Reflection times as well as resolutions and other emotional strategies can be delivered as a big
group conversation, in small groups or individually, by taking advantages of calming areas and the
personal diaries provided. The usage of emotional tools such as emotional thermometers and the
named envelopes to write down messages can enhance personal learnings within the group of
participants.
Potential learnings
Participants can experiment a set of direct, personal and indirect learnings. Direct learnings are
mostly linked with dance disciplines, as participants had the opportunity to rehearse in order to
perform in a final show that give them a sense of achievement. Personal learnings are assessed by
each participant with the usage of personal diaries and named envelopes and as a group in
democratic discussions. These learnings are mostly related to helped students improve basic social
and personal skills for life as well as interacting with social transformation topics. Direct learnings
are gained by generating new ways of expressing and communicating with the body freed of stress
issues, while personal learnings are enhanced by having a better understanding of opinions and
accepting different ways of participation
At the background, and without even noticing, students had the opportunity to daily interact with
health in all forms and shapes, understanding its impact in their own lives. Therefore, the project
learnings in all areas, not only help in producing a final dance multidisciplinary show, but in
understanding a wider concept of health and open up their minds to critically analyse a complex
society. Although provided in a leisure education setting, all these learnings help participants to
gain lifelong healthier skills that can be put in practice in several situations in real life experiences.
260
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
Figure 6 Relationship of different participants‘ learnings at the end of the campus
THE PROJECT OUTCOMES
Participants’ benefits based on testimonials
Alongside the named envelope activity, where participants can give messages to each other’s, a
testimonials box is presented. At the end of the campus, testimonials are recorded into three
categories: negative outcomes, positive outcomes and improvements to apply. Most of them are
largely deposited in the positive outcomes as participants see in “Creix amb Dansa” a way to
overcome years of repetitive and non-meaningful leisure activities. Following testimonials,
participants appreciate the idea of being treated as equals and having the chance to develop
autonomy patterns throughout the campus. Managing own learning, fully interact and cooperate
with others are other benefits express by participants.
Different types of participants value the improvement of self-esteem, the generation of new
relationships and the promotion of inclusion throughout the campus activities. The wider
treatment of health, induces a sense of self-responsibility and future changes in their own lives.
Although over the years we had few male participants, the will to empower female participants
does not attempt male benefits, yet give them a wider sense of social empathy towards others.
Resizing personal and social expectations are other outcomes experimented by males to confront
today’s heteropatriarchal society.
Strengths, Limitations, and Future improvements
Although COVID-19 affected the normal deployment of the campus in 2020 and 2021, as it
happened with many sports school and leisure education organisations in Catalonia (Castillo,
261
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Figure 7 Participants‘ benefits drawn from testimonials.
Pesarrodona & Usón, 2021), the will of parents and participants was to carry on with the activity
with the implementation of pandemic measures. Wanting to be provided with the activities in
difficult circumstances is a clear example of families’ loyalty towards the project, as well as the
yearly petition by participants for extending the campus days and parents request for the
organisation of similar adult initiatives alongside the children and youth ones.
If we look at limitations, the main one is not being able to compete against big companies that can
have a big number of participants with the same price, although not paying sufficient attention to
the quality of the project. Following this issue, not having enough marketing power to reach a
broader public with social media and television advertising it is always handicapping. Limited ways
to reduce the cost of organising a quality product to reach families with lesser income is another
of the limitations to take into account in order to work towards an equitable society.
As per future improvements for the project, it is planned to start a specific promotion to reach
more schools and secondary education placements in order to provide a bigger range of participants
and guarantee the engagement of more males within the group of participants. Strengthen the
project by planning more weeks of activity and increasing the number of participants, without the
need of sacrificing the quality of the project or professionals’ wages, will give the opportunity to
offer grants to socially handicapped families and enhance social interactions and outcomes within
the group.
262
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
References
Bautista, J. F. (2016). La Dansa a l’escola, el mestratge de Joan Serra. Barcelona: Associació de Mestre
Rosa Sensat
Castillo, A., Campos, J., Sebastiani, E. (2018). " Leadership for All ": sports leadership and Content
and Language Integrated Learning based education intervention to enhance secondary
education pupils' competencies through Quality Physical Education. In Popovic, Antala,
Bjelica & Gardasevic (Eds.) Physical Education in Secondary School. Researches, Best practices and
Situation. (pp. 259-270) Faculty of Sport and Physical Education of University of Montenegro
& Fédération Internationale d’Éducation Physique. Montenegro
Castillo, A. (2020) “Make a Move! Don’t Wait for Others to Do it for You” A Quality Physical
Education Program for Social Transformation to Improve Physical Education Training
Education System Among Catalan Universities. In Brobrík, Antala & Pêlucha (Eds.) Physical
Education in Universities. Researches, best practices and Situation. (pp. 247- 256) Slovak Scientific
Society for Physical Education and Sport & Fédération Internationale d’Éducation Physique.
Bratislava
Castillo, A., Pesarrodona, N., Usón, M. (2021). " COVID-19, forced inactivity and inequality in
sport" Remapping school sport in Catalonia: A regional European perspective. In Knjaz,
Novak & Antala (Eds.) Physical activity and health aspects of COVID-19 pandemic (pp.11-24)
Faculty of Kinesiology (University of Zagreb) & Fédération Internationale d’Éducation
Physique et Sportive. Croatia
Chatzipanteli, A., Digelidis, N., & Papaioannou, A. G. (2015). Self-regulation, motivation and
teaching styles in physical education classes: An intervention study. Journal of Teaching in
Physical Education, 34(2), 333-344. https://doi.org/10.1123/JTPE.2013-0024
Deterding, S., Dixon, D., Khaled, R., & Nacke, L. (2011). From game design elements to
gamefulness: defining “gamification”. Proceedings of the 15th international academic MindTrek
conference: Envisioning future media environments, 9-15.
McLennan, N. & Thompson, J. (2015). Quality Physical Education, Guidelines for Policy- Makers. United
Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization. Paris, France.
Martos-Garcia, D., Fuentes-Miguel, J., Atienza-Gago, M., Felis-Anaya, M. (2021). Educación Física
como herramienta de transformación social, pretextos críticos (Soca-rel). Barcelona: INDE
Morgado, I. (2014). Aprender, recordar, Olvidar. Barcelona: Ariel
Pellicer, I. (2015). NeuroEF, la revolución de la Educación Física desde la Neurociencia. Barcelona: INDE
Pereira, N. S., & Marques-Pinto, A. (2017). Including educational dance in an after-school socioemotional learning program significantly improves pupils’ self-management and relationship
skills? A quasi experimental study. The Arts in Psychotherapy, 53, (36-43).
Ratey, J. (2008). Spark: The revolutionary new science of exercise and the brain. New York: Little, Brown
and Co.
Sheppard, A., Broughton, M.C. (2020) Promoting wellbeing and health through active participation
in music and dance: a systematic review. International Journal of Qualitative Studies on Health and
Well-being, 15 (1). https://doi.org/10.1080/17482631.2020.1732526
Sousa, D. A. (2014). Neurociencia educativa. Mente, cerebro y educación. Madrid: Narcea
263
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Teraoka, E., Ferreira, H. J., Kirk, D., & Bardid, F. (2020). Affective learning in physical education:
A systematic review. Journal of Teaching in Physical Education, 40(3), 460-473.
Valero-Valenzuela, A., García, D. G., Camerino, O., & Manzano, D. (2020). Hibridación del
modelo pedagógico de responsabilidad personal y social y la gamificación en educación
física. Apunts. Educación física y deportes, 3(141), 63-74. https://doi.org/10.5672/apunts.20140983.es.(2020/3).141.08
Voelker, K. D. (2016). Promoting Leadership development of girls through Physical Education
and Sport. Journal of Physical Education, Recreation & Dance, 87 (3), 9-15.
264
Best Practices
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Creating a Global Index Measuring Countries’ Levels of Fitness:
The “World’s Fittest Countries Ranking”
Nadim Nassif - Kaissar Keyrouz
Notre Dame University, Louaize, Lebanon
e-mail: nnassif@ndu.edu.lb
Abstract
Several indicators are used worldwide to measure the levels of fitness of countries’ populations. Some
are based on quantitative measurements such as the obesity rate and the “ALPHA Health-Related
Fitness Test Battery for Children and Adolescents”. Others use qualitative reports such as the
International Physical Activity Questionnaire (IPAQ) and the Global Physical Activity Questionnaire
(GPAQ). The last two mentioned indicators are employed by the World Health Organization (WHO)
to evaluate the level of physical activity in every country. In this chapter, we will further explain each
of these methods, identify their limitations and suggest a new index that will measure the level of
fitness in every country, which will be named the “World’s Fittest Countries Ranking” (WFCR). Our
proposed indicator will partly be based on the World Ranking of Countries in Elite Sport (WRCES),
a research-based ranking that measures the performances of all the countries having National Olympic
Committees (NOCs) in all the sports recognized by the Global Association of International Sports
Federations (GAISF), in addition to other sports that are not yet recognized but have a significant
popularity and universality. Although this index targets elite sport results, its features allow to give an
accurate evaluation of the level of physical activity in each country. The main purpose of the WFCR
is to give to all the governments around the world an accurate idea on the fitness status of their
populations, so they can undertake adequate policies to improve them.
Key words: Index, World, Fitness, Countries, Ranking
265
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Traditional methods used to measure fitness and their limitations
The Obesity Rate
The obesity rate (OR) is defined by the percentage of a country’s population that is considered to be
obese. Obesity is characterized by a variable called the Body Mass Index (BMI), which is defined as
the body mass divided by the square of the body height, and is expressed in units of kg/m2, resulting
from mass in kilograms and height in meters. According to the WHO (2022), commonly accepted
BMI ranges are underweight (under 18.5 kg/m2), normal weight (18.5 to 25 kg/m2), overweight (25
to 30 kg/m2), and obese (over 30 kg/m2).
The OR is considered to be a relevant indicator to measure the level of physical inactivity in a country.
A high percentage of obese people among the population shows that there is a high level of inactivity
(Rippe and Hess, 1998). However, there are two major factors that limit the pertinence of the OR in
evaluating the average fitness of a country:
1. 1 - Although it gives a rate of the potential inactive people within a country, it does not give any
indicator on the level of fitness of those who are active.
2. 2 - In some countries, a low OR can largely be due to a high level of undernourishment. The
latter is actually calculated by indicators such as the Hunger Map (HM), established by the United
Nations World Food Programme (WFP, 2020). Undernourishment is defined “as the condition
in which an individual’s habitual food consumption is insufficient to provide the amount of
dietary energy required to maintain a normal, active, healthy life. The indicator is reported as the
prevalence of undernourishment (PoU), which is an estimate of the percentage of individuals in
the total population that are in a condition of undernourishment. To reduce the influence of
possible estimation errors in some of the underlying parameters, national estimates are reported
as a three-year moving average”. There are six categories of PoU: Less than 2.5%; Less than 5%;
Between 5 and 14.9%; Between 15 and 24.9%; Between 25 and 34.95; More than 35%. We have
looked at the PoU of the world’s 20 least obese countries in 2020 and found out that 18 of them
(90%) have nourishment issues. So, due to the fact that the populations of many non-obese
countries are undernourished, the OR cannot systematically be an accurate measurement of the
level of physical activity.
“ALPHA Health-Related Fitness Test Battery for Children and Adolescents”
Established by the European Union (EU) in collaboration with the University of Granada (Spain), the
University of Cadiz (Spain), Karolinska Institute (Sweden) and the UKK Institute (Finland), the
ALPHA test measures cardiorespiratory fitness (through a 20m shuttle run test), musculoskeletal
fitness (through handgrip strength and standing long jump), body composition (through BMI, Waist
circumference, triceps and subscapular skinfold thickness) and motor fitness (through 4x10m shuttle
run) (Ruiz and al., 2011). Although this test proposes a relevant assessment of a very broad range of
266
Best Practices
_____________________________________________________________________________________
physical qualities (aerobic capacity, strength, endurance, speed, agility, coordination, flexibility…), in
addition to body composition, the time needed to do it on a group of 20 individuals is around 2 hours
and 30 minutes. It is therefore very difficult to apply it on a whole population.
In addition, although physical tests can be very pertinent, their accuracy can be very limited for athletes
who engage in sport competitions. Indeed, Montgomery & al. have shown how “live play is
substantially more demanding” than training in “both physical and psychological attributes” in
basketball (Montgomery and al., 2010). Broad & al. have also demonstrated how sweat rates are
greatest in competition than in training in basketball, netball and football (Broad and al., 1996).
The IPAQ and GPAQ
The IPAQ assesses the types of intensity of physical activity and sitting time that people do as part of
their daily lives (Craig and al., 2017). It targets youth of 15 years of age and older. It is characterized
by open-ended questions surrounding individuals’ last 7-day recall of physical activity. The persons
taking the questionnaires will be asked about the activities that they do at work, as part of their house
and yard chores, to get from a place to another and in their spare time for recreation, exercise or sport.
The GPAQ uses the same concept as the IPAQ. It was developed by WHO and its objective is to
collect information on physical activity participation in three domains (Armstrong and Bull, 2006):
Activity at work; Travel to and from places; Recreational activities.
For Guthold & al. (2018), the IPAQ and GPAQ have numerous limitations, such as:
• Data are not available for every country and year.
• Availability varies across countries and regions. For example, Latin America, the Caribbean, highincome Western countries, Oceania, and sub-Saharan Africa had a very low proportion of
countries with data.
• Nationally representative data for physical activity using scientific measurements, like
accelerometers, are only available for high-income countries.
For Stefan Hey (2021), PhD in biomedical engineering, research consultant for the company Movisens
(Movisens, 2021), which produces sensors that “capture high resolution Electrocardiogram,
electrodermal activity, physical activity data to record and analyze psycho-physiological parameters in
everyday life”, the correlation between self-report questionnaires on physical activity and actual
physical activity is 0.41. This shows the lack of reliability of measurements such as IPAQ and GPAQ.
The inaccuracies identified in the OR, ALPHA Test, IPAQ and GPAQ have led us to propose a new
index, which we will name “World’s Fittest Countries Ranking” (WFCR). We will further explain this
indicator in the second part of this paper.
267
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Creating a new index to measure a country’s level of fitness: The WFCR
One of the variables that will be used to establish the WFCR is the WRCES. Although the WRCES
concerns only countries’ results in elite sports, its characteristics will contribute to give a pertinent
measurement of the level of fitness in every country. We will start by giving an overview of the
WRCES and then see how it can be used to create the WFCR.
The WRCES
Nassif has created the WRCES because he considered that the Olympic Medal Table (OMT),
traditionally used by scholars, media and politicians to compare results in elite sport, does not give an
accurate measurement of countries’ results in elite sport (2018). He found that the OMT methodology
has several limitations:
1. The superiority of a gold medal over any number of silver and of a sliver over any number of
bronzes will create false inference, where a country having only one exceptional athlete capable
of winning one gold medal ranked above another one endowed with several athletes who were
placed second and third.
2. The number of medals awarded per event does not take into account neither the level of
competition of the sport to which it belongs, nor the number of countries and athletes that it
involves. For example, a sport like sailing that has 10 events and that is played in 115 countries,
offers 10 gold medals, whereas a sport like basketball, that only has two events played in 215
countries, only offers two gold medals. Moreover, for the same event, as an individual sport,
sailing can offer medals to several athletes of a same country whereas, as a team sport, basketball,
can only offer one medal per country.
3. Although the Olympics is the largest multidisciplinary competition in the world, it is not the
pinnacle event of several mainstream sports such as boxing, football, tennis, golf and cycling.
4. The number of countries that win medals are limited. Indeed, only 94 countries won medals if
we combined the OMT of the last Olympics to date, Pyeongchang 2018 and Tokyo 2020
(Olympics, 2022). This fact will prevent a proper comparative analysis of countries’ success in
elite sport considering that almost 54% of the participants are absent. According to Henry & al.
(2020), the limited number of countries ranked is one of the main weaknesses of the OMT.
5. The OMT only considers the Olympic sports, which were 40 if we combined the 2018 and 2020
Olympics. Many sports recognized by GAISF (GAISF, 2022), which sanctions a total of 98
sports, are not included.
Those limitations led Nassif to create a methodology, that incorporates main features, which are:
1. A computation model that attributes to each country its share of points in at least one sport, and,
consequently, its ranking on the basis of the total number of points, which this country would
have garnered in all sports.
268
Best Practices
_____________________________________________________________________________________
2. The introduction of universality and popularity coefficients for each sport being considered. The
universality and popularity of each sport can grow and new sports can be added. All the yearly
methodology updates are found in the WRCES website (WRCES, 2022). Popularity indicates the
international media ratings for each sport. It shows to which extent a sport is covered;
consequently, how much this sport attracts private and public funding and raises competition’s
level by engaging the most talented athletes. Universality takes into account the number of all
countries participating in a given sport. The more countries participating, the more difficult it is
for them to win.
The WRCES was able to bring the following changes:
1. In the 2021 WRCES edition (last edition to date), 206 countries were ranked instead of the 94
that were only ranked by the combined 2018-2020 OMT.
2. An annual evaluation of countries’ performances in more than 100 sports (115 in 2021), including
the Para-sports (which were grouped into one sport) instead of one done once every 4 years in
only 40 sports by the combined Winter and Summer OMT.
3. An accounting of countries’ performances in all the major international competitions like the
FIFA World Cup, Tennis Grand slams and the Rugby Union World Cup where success is not
recorded by the OMT.
4. A more accurate measurement of countries’ performances in sport, since it rewards countries that
succeed in highly popular and universal sports that do not offer a lot of medals, and scales
appropriately those that win several medals in minor sports that have a multitude of events.
In September 2018, the WRCES was presented to the Association of Sport Performance Centers
(ASPC)- first African Forum that took place in Durban, South Africa. The ASPC, which has among
its members the Loughborough University, United Kingdom (UK) Sport, INSEP (French Center for
Sport Excellence), FC Barcelona and the United States Olympic Committee (USOC), is an
international body with a mission to “provide opportunities that enhance training for high
performance sport (elite sport) worldwide” (ASPC, 2022). The ASPC is currently (2022) investigating
whether it will formally sanction this ranking. Three of the ASPC centers: the Kuortane Olympic
Training Center of Finland, Berlin Olympic Training Center of Germany, and the Centre d’Alt
Rendiment (CAR) Sant Cugat of Spain have already started a pilot project using the WRCES to
measure their contribution to the success of their countries in elite sport. In its 2021 ASPC General
Assembly, the newly elected president, Tapio Korjus, has declared that the ASPC will continue its
collaboration with the WRCES in the years to come (General Assembly of the ASPC, November 30,
2021).
By giving an accurate ranking of the 206 countries having NOCs, the objective was to open the door
for a holistic and precise comparative analysis of countries’ performances in elite sport as well. After
explaining the methodology of the WRCES, we will explain how this index can contribute to show
the level of physical activity, hence fitness, of each country.
269
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
_____________________________________________________________________________________
How can the WRCES contribute to the creation of an index that measures the fitness level of
the general population?
Unlike the OMT, which awards medals only for the top three competitors, the WRCES can actually
show the depth of participation in every country, considering that all the countries that take part in
international competitions will gather points, even if they achieve very modest results. Competing in
a sport at a world stage, even without succeeding, systematically shows that there is a formal and/or
official local participation from which those elite athletes are selected. Countries that are able to be
ranked in a large number of sports have systematically a higher local participation. So, to examine if
achieving success in elite sport reflects a higher sport participation, we have looked at the percentage
of the total number of sports in which the top 20, mid-table (countries which positions were between
93 and 112) and bottom 20 of the WRCES final ranking were ranked in for the 2014, 2015, 2016,
2017, 2018 and 2019 editions. We have found out that, the top 20 were on average ranked in 84% of
the sports, the mid-table in 26% and those who are in the bottom 20 in 6%. This undoubtedly shows
that succeeding at the international stage cannot be achieved without a large and diversified local sport
participation. Through the analysis of the Chinese model, Zheng & al. has advocated that the success
at the elite level cannot be reached without a large base of youth practicing sport (Zheng and al., 2019),
as we can see in Figure 1:
Full-time teams: Olympic Squad, national
and provincial teams
Sports schools: Provincial Sports Academies or
Reserve Teams
Extra-Curricular Sports Schools
Figure 1. Interpretation of the Chinese’s elite sport system defined by Zheng et al.
Nassif has also upheld the concept of the pyramid when he analyzed the success of France between
2002 and 2005 (Nassif, 2009). He found out that it is out of the 26 million people participating in
sport (43% of the population at that time) that the 9.7 million federation licensees (16% of the
population) emerged, and constituted the base of the 15586 elite athletes that made France succeed in
international sport competitions.
Zheng & al. (2019) and Nassif’s (2009) examples show that the more a country is developing an elite
sport system, the more youth will take part in sports. We also believe that the countries that will have
the highest performance are those that have the fittest youth. Indeed, for Serrano and al., sport
performance is characterized by four factors: physical, technical, tactical and psychological (2013).
Therefore, higher physical abilities among the youth will lead to a higher success at the elite level.
270
Best Practices
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Although the WRCES constitutes a pertinent variable to assess the fitness of a population, we believe
that it cannot be its only method of measurement for the following reasons:
1. It does not give an evaluation of all the people that do not engage in competitive sport whether
they are children, youth or adults. For this reason, the OR must not be dismissed as long as it is
considered with the PoU of every country.
2. Countries’ performances in elite sport are not only achieved with the fitness of the competitors.
There are other factors that need to be considered like wealth, population or scientific
advancement, which were the main subjects of the study of scholars aiming at identifying which
are the most determinant variables that lead to countries’ success in elite sport. To determine which
of these factors has the higher incidence, we have undertaken correlation calculi between the
WRCES results with the population, GDP and research output rankings for the years 2014, 2015,
2016, 2017, 2018 and 2019. The comparisons were done between the points won by each country
in the WRCES and the number of inhabitants for the population, the total amount of US dollars
(in millions) for the GDP, and the number of publications for the research output. We have found
that the correlation between the WRCES and the population ranges between 0.30 and 0.39, the
one of the WRCES and the GDP between 0.74 and 0.78 and the one of the WRCES and research
output between 0.78 and 0.82.
Therefore, among the three most studied factors, population has the weakest correlation. Media often
use the medal per capita ranking to identify the countries that are able to “punch above their weight”
(Businessinsider, 2016; US News, 2016; Time, 2016). Less populated countries usually top this ranking
and are consequently considered as the most efficient in terms of international sport results. This
statement seems to be very inaccurate whether we take the Olympic Medal Table or the WRCES:
▪ In terms of medal collection first, several scholars have advocated the low incidence of the
population on sport results (Andrew and Busse, 2004; Den Butter and Van Der Tak, 1995; De
Bosscher, 2008; Kuper and Sterken, 2001; Bian, 2004). And the simplest reason behind it that
they provide is that no matter how populated countries are, they can only send a limited, often
the same number of athletes in every event.
▪ By correlating the WRCES with the population ranking, we have been able to measure the impact
of population on sports results on a wider number of countries (206 by opposition to the 86
countries ranked in the Olympic Medal Table). We have even found that for the countries that
have more than 30 million inhabitants, the correlation is even less than 0.2, which is very weak.
Correlations that are above 0.35 are for countries that have below 6 million inhabitants.
Consequently, one can conclude that a number approximately close to 6 million inhabitants
appears to be a large enough size to compete with anyone. It is also possible to have a good
number of athletes with a smaller number. Indeed, as an example among many other similar ones,
Luxembourg, with around 600 000 inhabitants, outperformed Iraq (40 million inhabitants), Ivory
Coast (25 million inhabitants), Jordan (10 million inhabitants), Lebanon (6 million inhabitants)
and Kyrgyzstan (6 million inhabitants) for six consecutive years (WRCES, 2022).
271
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
_____________________________________________________________________________________
The two factors that have the highest impact are the GDP and the research output. Since funding is
needed for research, we believe that the countries that will be considered to have “punched above
their weights” are the non-wealthy ones who achieved good results in the WRCES. Those
underprivileged nations will have to count mainly on the human factor. This is why, if we are aiming
to measure the fitness level of every country, a parallel WRCES index must be considered. This
indicator will be entitled the WRCES Merit Ranking and will be calculated by doing the difference
between the GDP and the WRCES ranking of a country. The higher this difference is, the better the
WRCES Merit Ranking will be. We will give the examples of two countries in 2019, Saudi Arabia and
Egypt: Saudi Arabia GDP ranking – Saudi Arabia WRCES ranking = Saudi Arabia WRCES Merit
Ranking 18 - 55 = -37. Egypt GDP ranking – Egypt WRCES ranking = Egypt WRCES Merit Ranking
41 – 55 = -14. Egypt will therefore have a better WRCES Merit Ranking.
Considering the WRCES Merit Ranking does not mean that the WRCES will have to be dismissed.
In fact, countries topping both the WRCES and the GDP ranking like the USA will be unfairly
penalized if we were to consider only the WRCES Merit Ranking as it cannot do better than first, and
will therefore fall victim to its own success. In addition, we cannot also assume that a country like
Switzerland (20th in the GDP ranking) will have a better WRCES position than France if it has a similar
GDP (7th GDP in the world) or if France will be below Switzerland in the WRCES if it has a similar
GDP to Switzerland. As an example, in theory, if the French region of “Ile de France” was a country,
its GDP will put it just behind Switzerland in the GDP ranking (Parisjob, 2022). We don’t have solid
evidences that this French region will rank below Switzerland in the WRCES.
So, our proposed new index that will measure the level of fitness in every country (WFCR) will
consider countries results in elite sport (WRCES), countries result in elite sport considering their
wealth (WRCES Merit Ranking), the Obesity Rate (OR) and the Prevalence of Undernourishment
(PoU). This methodology will be explained in the last part of this proposal.
The methodology of the WFCR
As we explained above, four variables will be considered to get the WFCR: the WRCES, WRCES
Merit Ranking, OR and PoU. To level them, they will all have a maximum of 100 points.
For the WRCES, the country topping the ranking will have 100 points and all the other countries will
get a score below 100 according to the rule of three. As an example, in 2019, the USA came first with
1,627,293 points (WRCES, 2022). They will get 100 points. France, who placed second, with 979,438,
will have the following amount: (979438 * 100) / 1627293 = 60.2
For the WRCES Merit Ranking, we will first take both the country having the highest difference
between its GDP and WRCES ranking (A) and the one having the lowest difference (B). We will then
make the difference between both amounts, and A will get points that are equal to this difference
272
Best Practices
_____________________________________________________________________________________
while B will have 0 points. The points obtained by A will be scaled to 100 and all the other countries
will get points according to the rule of three.
As an example, if A has a difference of 50 between its GDP and WRCES and B a difference of -34,
A will first get: 50 - (-34) = 84 points. B will get 0. We will then scale the 84 points obtained by A to
100.
If a third country, C, has a difference of 60 points with B, it will get the following amount: (60*100)/84
= 71. For the OR, countries will have a value equal to 100 minus their OR. As an example, Vietnam
who has an OR of 2.1% will have the following score: 100-2.1 = 97.9. For the PoU, countries will also
have a value equal to 100 minus their PoU. As an example, France who has a PoU of 2.5% will have
the following score: 100 – 2.5 = 97.5.
In the following step, we will consider either the countries’ WRCES or their WRCES merit ranking
score. If a country has a higher WRCES than WRCES Merit Ranking score, we will consider their
WRCES score. Conversely, we will consider its WRCES Merit Ranking score if it is higher than its
WRCES one.
For example, if France has a score of 60.2 in the WRCES and 30 in the WRCES Merit Ranking, we
will take 60.2. If it has a score of 30 in the WRCES and 45 in the WRCES Merit Ranking, we will take
45. This was done to be fair to both the countries succeeding in the WRCES and those who are over
performing considering their low GDP.
We will then take the average score between the OR and PoU scores of each country. For example, if
France has a score of 78.4 in its OR and 97.5 in its PoU, it will have an average score of: (78.4+97.5)/2
= 88. This was done to avoid the false inference that a low OR is a systematic indicator of a high
physical activity.
The final formula to reach the WFCR score will be done by calculating the average of the
WRCES/WRCES Merit Ranking score and the OR/PoU average score:
WFCR score = (WRCES or WRCES Merit Ranking score) + (OR/PoU average score) / 2
As an example, if France has a WRCES score of 60.2 points, a WRCES Merit Ranking score of 30
and an average OR/PoU score of 88, it will have the following WFCR score: (60.2 + 88) / 2 = 74.1
On the other hand, if it has a WRCES score of 30, a WRCES Merit Ranking score of 45 and an average
OR/PoU score of 88, it will have the following WFCR score: (45 + 88) / 2 = 66.5
The final WFCR ranking will be done according to the WFCR scores of each country.
273
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Conclusion
Having an ideal ranking to measure the level of fitness in every country is a complex endeavor. Our
proposed methodology seeks to be the most accurate possible. For this purpose, we have taken into
consideration the development of sports among their population, the obesity rate and the prevalence
of undernourishment. We believe that by considering these variables, we will help governments
implement the proper policies to improve the fitness level of their populations. When they will have
feedback on their WFCR score, they will be able to know which areas they must focus on more:
Developing their sports, doing awareness campaigns to reduce obesity or investing to fight
undernourishment.
References
Armstrong, T., & Bull, F. (2006). Development of the world health organization global physical
activity questionnaire (GPAQ). Journal of Public Health, 14(2), 66-70.
Bernard, A. B., & Busse, M. R. (2004). Who wins the Olympic Games: Economic resources and medal
totals. Review of economics and statistics, 86(1), 413-417.
Bian, X. (2005). Predicting Olympic medal counts: The effects of economic development on Olympic
performance. The park place economist, 13(1), 37-44.
Broad, E. M., Burke, L. M., Cox, G. R., Heeley, P., & Riley, M. (1996). Body weight changes and
voluntary fluid intakes during training and competition sessions in team sports. International
Journal of Sport Nutrition and Exercise Metabolism, 6(3), 307-320.
Craig, C., Marshall, A., Sjostrom, M., Bauman, A., Lee, P., Macfarlane, D., ... & Stewart, S. (2017).
International Physical Activity Questionnaire-Short Form. J Am Coll Health, 65(7), 492-501.
De Bosscher, V. (2008). The global sporting arms race: An international comparative study on sports policy factors
leading to international sporting success. Meyer & Meyer Verlag. p.44
Den Butter, F. A., & Van Der Tak, C. M. (1995). Olympic medals as an indicator of social
welfare. Social Indicators Research, 35(1), 27-37.
Kuper, G. H., & Sterken, E. (2001). Olympic participation and performance since 1896. Available at
SSRN 274295.
Guthold, R., Stevens, G. A., Riley, L. M., & Bull, F. C. (2018). Worldwide trends in insufficient physical
activity from 2001 to 2016: a pooled analysis of 358 population-based surveys with 1· 9 million
participants. The lancet global health, 6(10), e1077-e1086.
Henry, I., Dowling, M., Ko, L. M., & Brown, P. (2020). Challenging the new orthodoxy: a critique of
SPLISS and variable-oriented approaches to comparing sporting nations. European sport
management quarterly, 20(4), 520-536.
Minutes of the General Assembly of the Association of Sport Performance Centers, November 30 th,
2021.
274
Best Practices
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Montgomery, P. G., Pyne, D. B., & Minahan, C. L. (2010). The physical and physiological demands
of basketball training and competition. International journal of sports physiology and performance, 5(1),
75-86.
Nassif, N. (2009). Sport policy in Lebanon, 1975 to 2004.
Nassif, N. (2018). World Ranking of Countries in Elite Sport. Rivista di Diritto ed Economia dello Sport 14, no.
2, 55-75.
Official
website
of
the
Association
of
Sport
Performance
Centers,
https://sportperformancecentres.org/node, retrieved in January 2022.
Official website of the company “Movisens”, https://www.movisens.com/en/company/, retrieved
in December 2021.
Official website of the Global Association of International Sports Federations,
https://gaisf.org/mission-and-vision/, retrieved in January 2022.
Official website of the International Olympic Committee, www.olympics.org, retrieved in December
2021.
Official website of the Newspapers Business Insider, http://www.businessinsider.com/2016-rioolympics-medals-per-capita-2016-8, retrieved in January 2022.
Official website of the Newspapers Time, http://time.com/4452128/olympics-medals-per-capitarankings/, retrieved in January 2022.
Official website of the Newspapers US News, https://www.usnews.com/news/bestcountries/articles/2016-08-23/countries-with-the-most-olympic-gold-medals-per-capita,
retrieved in January 2022.
Official website of the portal “Paris Job”, https://www.parisjob.com/actualites/lile-de-france-restele-principal-moteur-de-leconomie-francaise.html#, retrieved in January 2022.
Official
website
of
the
United
Nations
World
Food
Programme,
https://www.wfp.org/publications/hunger-map-2020, retrieved in December 2021.
Official
website
of
the
World
Health
Organization,
https://www.who.int/data/gho/data/themes/topics/topic-details/GHO/ncd-risk-factors,
retrieved in January 2022
Official
website
of
the
World
Ranking
of
Countries
in
Elite
Sport,
https://www.worldsportranking.info/, retrieved in January 2022.
Personal discussion with Stephan Hey, PhD in biomedical engineering, research consultant for the
company Movisens on Monday February 15th, 2021.
Rippe, J. M., & Hess, S. (1998). The role of physical activity in the prevention and management of
obesity. Journal of the American Dietetic Association, 98(10), S31-S38.
Ruiz, J. R., Castro-Piñero, J., España-Romero, V., Artero, E. G., Ortega, F. B., Cuenca, M. M., ... &
Castillo, M. J. (2011). Field-based fitness assessment in young people: the ALPHA health-related
fitness test battery for children and adolescents. British journal of sports medicine, 45(6), 518-524.
Serrano, J., Shahidian, S., Sampaio, J., & Leite, N. (2013). The importance of sports performance
factors and training contents from the perspective of futsal coaches. Journal of human kinetics, 38,
151.
275
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
_____________________________________________________________________________________
World Health Organization (2014). Global status report on noncommunicable diseases 2014. No.
WHO/NMH/NVI/15.1. World Health Organization.
Zheng, J., Lau, P. W. C., Chen, S., Dickson, G., De Bosscher, V., & Peng, Q. (2019).
Interorganisational conflict between national and provincial sport organisations within China’s
elite sport system: Perspectives from national organisations. Sport management review, 22(5), 667681.
276
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
Coaches Help Czech and Slovak Teachers in Primary Schools
Jan Macháček1 - Branislav Antala2 - Diana Kosová3 - Martin Dovičák4
Trenéři ve škole, z.s., Czech Republic
Faculty of Physical Education and Sports of Comenius University in Bratislava, Slovakia
3
Tréneri v škole, Slovakia
1
2
4Faculty
of Mathematics, Physics and Informatics of Comenius University in Bratislava, Slovakia
e-mail: jan.machacek@treneriveskole.cz
Abstract
In Slovakia and the Czech Republic, sports coaches attend physical education classes every day to
help primary school teachers. Through working in tandem with the teachers, they inspire them
and give children in grades 1-4 (age 6-10) a safe environment for joyful physical activities. Children
experience a variety of activities throughout the year as the individual sports alternate regularly.
The Government of the Slovak Republic, various universities, the Czech National Sports Agency,
and a number of municipalities in the Czech Republic support the programme.
Key words: Physical education, Sports coaches, Primary school teachers, Attitude and joy of
movement
277
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Many studies confirm that the percentage of overweight and obese children rose by a significant
margin in both countries over the last decade. Children spend less time on physical activities,
spontaneous physical activities almost disappeared from the afternoon activities. It results in health
problems, and therefore a financial burden for the state.
Both governments are starting to be aware of this, addressing the problem by developing an
infrastructure, increasing investments to sports federations and clubs. However, it seems that the
environment of primary schools and kindergartens isn't taken seriously. Typically, in Czech and
Slovak primary schools, the children have two physical education (PE) classes (2 × 45 minutes) a
week, conducted by primary teachers (for grades 1-5, age 6-12) who aren’t trained to a standard
that they are able to meet the increased needs of today’s children.
Although some schools are equipped with modern equipment and multiple indoor arenas, they are
still in a minority. It is not uncommon for schools with more than 500 students to have a single
sports hall, where the size is no bigger than that of a volleyball court. Lessons are normally held
indoors for six months of the school year. School classes typically consist of 25 students, although
there are exceptions with classes with more than 30 students.
Judo lessons at school (Image: Trenéři ve škole, z.s.)
278
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
It is challenging for a specialist PE teacher to conduct a safe and varied PE lesson with 30 children
in a small hall, therefore it is even more challenging for non-specialists. Most of the general
primary teachers (for grades 1-5, age 6-12) have only a basic PE education from their
pedagogical faculty so it proves difficult to deliver varied, fun, engaging and educational
lessons every week on their own. In other demanding subjects, like for instance in foreign
languages, they are often helped by specialists.
There is a large percentage of female teachers in primary schools, therefore they may not be as
comfortable teaching certain sports and activities as their male counterparts. Observations suggest
that 50 percent of female teachers do not change for a PE class.
Sports clubs and sport federations are the preferred target of state investments into programmes
of physical activity interventions for the broad population. In the Czech Republic, funding for
sport has increased significantly since 2015. The positive outcome is that many sports clubs have
improved their facilities by replacing grass with artificial surfaces, such surfaces can serve the
athletes all-year round. Many clubs pay their coaches, many of whom started out as an involved
parent. Only a small percentage of these clubs can afford to contract full-time employees.
After the students come home from school and change their school bags for the sports kit, training
usually takes place in the late afternoon. Similarly, the coaches work nine-to-five jobs and attend
training as a voluntary activity. Their education is provided by the federations and varies sport by
sport. While some sports federations follow strict international protocols for youth coaches’
education, including hundreds of on-field hours of coaching and mentoring, and lessons in
children’s’ pedagogy, physiology, psychology, sports training theory, other sports bodies apply
much more relaxed approach to the expense of quality.
Unlike in other countries, Czech and Slovak sports clubs are financially motivated to engage
children in organised competitions in their respective sports from an early age. It leads to an
ever-increasing demand on the level of performance needed to participate in these competitions,
and therefore it puts more pressure on coaches to specialise their athletes at an early age. On the
other hand, judging by the government finances, general physical preparation programmes
are in the minority. Many of the above-mentioned competitions for primary school children are
regional or national, meaning that they require travel of more than an hour to reach. That’s why
children, coaches, and their families spend weekends travelling to these competitions.
The late evening training times in sports clubs rob children of time they should be spending with
their parents. Only a portion of the lessons are held in the early afternoon hours as many of the
coaches cannot be released from their jobs or because the parents cannot drive children from
school to training grounds. Some of these early afternoon sports activities in schools are run by
coaches, who often use them as a recruitment activity instead of striving for general physical
development of the children.
279
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Programme focuses on the positive emotions of children (Image: Trenéři ve škole, z.s.)
Seven universities in Czechia and Slovakia educate PE teachers who get teaching qualifications for
secondary and tertiary schools only (students of age 12-24). According to our estimate, only a
handful of specialised primary school PE teachers are educated through individualised study
programmes every year.
It has been proven that physical activities have an influence on cognitive functions. Physically
active children have better attention, memory, and creativity during the learning process. These
facts are nothing new in both countries. They are often pointed to in the press and in the media,
in fact the need for comprehensive physical development is taught at the sports faculties of the
aforementioned universities.
It is therefore surprising that while children’s physical activity has declined, we have seen an
increase in the teaching of their mother tongue, foreign languages, and IT but the number of PE
classes remains the same. As mentioned above, there is a growing disparity between amounts of
general, varied physical activities and specialised training in sports clubs. Experts have long warned
of the dangers of early specialisation and they seem to be confirmed by shrinking numbers of
engaged adults compared with children.
During an excursion to the INSEP Olympic centre in Paris in 2018, several Czech coaches met
and created a programme that would bring sports coaches to schools. They included Antonín
Barák, a PE teacher and youth football coach, Michal Prokeš, a visionary coach and Jan Macháček,
an inventive mind and former rugby player.
280
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
The “Coaches at School” programme takes a good example from abroad, where children play
sports mainly in the school environment and try a lot of sports under the age of 15. During the
2019 pilot programme, coaches from seven sports were assigned to teach PE lessons in four state
schools in the district of Prague 6. Although the trial period lasted only three months, the response
was so strong that it was requested by twelve school principals in Prague 6 from the new school
year.
Although news of the programme’s success spread rapidly and new municipalities quickly became
interested, the founders emphasise a slower approach and a focus on the quality of the coach and
education. Especially in the beginning, the programme relied on the dedication of club coaches
from Prague 6, who dedicated hundreds of hours to teaching, administration, persuading finance
backers, observations, and methodology.
At the beginning of 2020, the programme started outside of Prague, in the 30,000-strong town of
Příbram at seven schools. A national symposium took place in March 2020, where the programme
was presented to the public. It was noted by former Slovak elite tennis player Karol Kučera, now
a member of the Slovak Parliament and ambassador for sports for the government. After
assembling a team of experts, he brought them to Prague to learn about the programme. Currently,
the main programme leaders in Slovakia are psychologist Tomáš Gurský, Ice Hockey mentor
Diana Kosová, Karate coach, scientist Miroslav Sližik and mathematician and coach Martin
Dovičák.
The main goals of the programme are to give young school children the joy of movement, to
involve sports coaches in the morning times and to inspire primary school teachers.Side effects
are the creation of relationships between sports clubs and schools. Local clubs are starting to work
together and not just compete for sports grants. Individual coaches of various sports make friends
and develop their range of exercises outside their specialisation.
A focused programme like this already receives the support of many public figures and institutions.
In Slovakia, the programme started in March 2021, its activities are operated by the government.
As of June 2022, there are 110 schools in Slovakia that run the programme. There have already
been 8 courses organised by the Comenius University in Bratislava, Matej Bel Universityin Banská
Bystrica, and Technical University of Košice. There are small differences in the programmes of both
countries. Slovak coaches are selected by an individual selection procedure directly, in Czechia they
are recommended by local sports clubs.
In order to support the varied programme, the Slovak government provided the involved coaches
with modern sports equipment - ropes, foam balls, eye straps, colored parachutes and hoops,
bluetooth music speakers etc.
281
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
New coaches ready to be deployed in March 2022. (Image: Trenéři ve škole, z.s.)
In the Czech Republic, the main finance backers are municipalities, which are the founders of
schools; full government support has not yet been negotiated. However, good indicators of the
interest of other public institutions are the support from the City of Prague (which is not the
founder of primary schools) and from the National Sports Agency, which provided CZK 1.5
million (€ 60,600) last year for pilot testing in 30 schools in four different cities. Česká spořitelna
bank has been significantly helping with sponsorship donations for the third year in a row.
282
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
Dancing class led by a professional coach and teacher (Image: Trenéři ve škole, z.s.)
At the end of June 2022, the programme was operating in 17 areas in the Czech Republic, where
111 schools and 483 classes were involved. The faculties that educate future teachers are gradually
joining the programme. In the spring of 2021, Dr. Martin Dovičák with Dr. Iveta Cidhová from
Comenius University in Bratislava conducted a study focusing on children's attitudes towards
physical education and showed that they improved significantly after the coaches’ interventions.
The main principles of the programme are simple. Sports coaches attend lessons once a week in
each of the first, second and third grades (children aged 6-10 years) of the involved primary
schools, where they work in tandem with the teacher. They teach together with the goal of joint
physical and mental development of the children.
The coaches effectively organise the lessons so that the children do not stand in line for a long
time before it is their turn. Whenever possible, they use games where everyone is engaged without
being eliminated. It is important to involve those children who are less physically fit.
Psychomotor exercises and games are used, which aim at the emotional experience and perception
of one's own body. Coaches pay attention to the sensitive windows of development and focus
mainly on developing coordination, speed and strength appropriate to their age. Coaches develop
creativity through an "extra playground", where pupils play and oversee the rules themselves. All
involved coaches have a strict ban on recruiting pupils to their clubs, because the main goal is to
help the children and not get them for their sport. It is important that the child decides for himself,
later on, what sport he or she wants to pursue.
283
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Pupils' attitudes to the subject of PE before and after the coaches’ interventions. 177 interviewed.
Data and chart by Martin Dovičák and Iveta Cihová CU Bratislava
A prerequisite for the involvement of coaches is a coaching licence from their sports association
and a proven experience in working with children. Courses for the involved coaches are 4 days
long (40 hours) in Slovakia and 3 days (30 hours) in Czechia.
The courses are experiential, so participants go through a lot of physical activities during them, up
to two thirds of the time in the sports hall. The coaches mainly learn the difference between the
environment of a sports club, where children are sports-ready, and a school where some kids are
inexperienced. Participating coaches learn to apply the ten principles and present them in practice,
where other colleagues represent schoolchildren and the teacher. Every coach will receive a 200page manual that describes the methodology developed for this programme.
284
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
Coaches act as school children during the courses (Image: Tréneri v škole)
As soon as the coach passes the course, he obtains a licence for two years. Then he has to renew
it with a one-day course. In the Czech Republic, evaluations take place where lecturers visit schools
where coaches lead lessons with a real class and a teacher.
Coaches and their sports regularly alternate in Czech schools in monthly cycles, in Slovakia after
two months. The coaches attend one of the two PE classes per week, the other is led by the teacher
herself.
The coaches have their own distinctive jerseys so that the children can recognize them immediately
and form an association. A colourful chequered shirt also helps them not to be afraid if a different
coach comes in a month. In Czechia, teachers also wear the jerseys to connect even more with the
coach. As the image above demonstrates, children wear bibs with numbers, in the colours of each
neighbouring state, names of personalities or geographic information. These are used in games
and exercises.
Especially thanks to the Slovak colleagues, interdisciplinary relationships are developing, where
coaches link physical education with other subjects through imaginary environments involving
fairy tales, farms, Olympics, anthill, construction sites etc.
285
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Antonín Barák, one of the founders of the programme, wearing a “trademark” chequered
shirt. Children wear colourful bibs with numbers, flags and neighbouring countries.
(Image: Trenéři ve škole, z.s.)
In Slovakia, “cooking books” are now being prepared for teachers to teach PE through stories
using interdisciplinary relationships. This type of storytelling is something the programme wants
to build on in the next step (table 1).
Conclusion
The programme where sports coaches help primary teachers in physical education classes proved
successful in both Czech Republic and Slovakia. The coaches work in tandem with the teachers,
who confirm that they get inspiration from them. The programme gives children in grades 1-4 (age
6-11) a safe environment with joyful physical activities. Children experience a variety of activities
throughout the year as the individual sports alternate regularly. The Government of the Slovak
Republic, various universities, the Czech National Sports Agency, and a number of municipalities
in the Czech Republic support the programme. State authorities, schools, municipalities, academics
and sports officials in both countries indicate serious interest in the scheme and promised
continuing support. Further research aimed at the process of integrating the coaches into the
school environment and its effectiveness is planned.
286
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
Table 1 Facts about the program
Czechia
Slovakia
Started
2019
2021
Financing
Municipalities, Prague Magistrate,
National Sports Agency (NSA), Slovak government
private (Česká Spořitelna bank)
Average annual
€1 000
cost for a class
1330 €
Municipalities
involved
17
38
České Budějovice, Prague 2, Prague
6, Prague 8, Prague 10, Prague 11,
Prague 13, Prague 15, Prague 16,
Prague 17, Kosoř, Veselí nad Lužnicí,
Havlíčkův Brod, Liberec, Kladno,
Karlovy Vary, Klatovy, Písek,
Příbram.
Bratislava, Trnava, Pezinok, Nové
Zámky, Trenčín, Považská Bystrica,
Banská Bystrica, Žiar nad Hronom,
Žilina, Čadca, Kysucké Nové Mesto,
Košice, Prešov, Poprad, Stará
Ľubovňa and others
Schools
111
110
Classes
483
550
Courses held
12
8
Coaches
148
91
Sports involved
aerobics, American football, athletics, basketball, beach volleyball, dancing,
fencing, floorball, football, golf, gymnastics, handball, hip-hop, ice hockey,
yoga, judo, karate, lacrosse, parcours, rugby, softball, table tennis, taekwondo,
Thai boxing, volleyball, water polo, wrestling
Sources
BARANOVSKÁ, A. 2014. Pripravenosť dieťaťa na školu – spôsoby zisťovania a možnosti
rozvíjania. Metodicko-pedagogické centrum.
BARÁK, GURSKÝ, MACHÁČEK, SLIŽIK 2020 Program „Tréneri v škole“ Metodická príručka,
Úrad vlády SR Bratislava, ISBN: 978-80-557-1924-5
287
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
BLAHUTKOVÁ, M. 1996. Význam zařazení psychomotoriky do hodin tělesné výchovy na 1.
stupni základní školy a její vliv na rozvoj osobnosti dítěte mladšího školního věku. Brno: PF
MU.
DE CROOCK, DE BOSSCHER, VAN BOTTENBURG: The inspirational function of role
models for sport participation and development
DOVIČÁK, KOSOVÁ et al: Ukážkové hodiny – hravé prostredia, 2021, PDF online
KAPLAN, 2020 Pohybová neúspěšnost u žáků mladšího věku.
LARA-BERCIAL, S. et al 2017. European Sport Coaching Framework, CoachLearn & Human
Kinetics.
MUTTER, PAWLOWSKI: Role Models in Sports - Can success in professional sports increase
the demand for amateur sport participation?
SEGUI, YUBA, ALCARAZ, DE BOSSCHER: Sport pyramid metaphor: Trickle down and up
effect in Spain
ŠIMONEK, J. 2013. Rozvoj kinesteticko-diferenciačných schopností v programoch školskej
telesnej a športovej výchovy. Nitra: KTVŠ PF UKF.
THOMPSON, 2008 Positive Sports Parenting: How Second-Goal Parents Raise Winners in Life
Through Sports
VÁGNEROVÁ, 1997, Psychologie školního dítěte
VALEY, CHASE, 2016. Best Practice for Youth Sport. Human Kinetics.
“Tréneri v škole” - Slovak programme references
Website:www.trenerivskole.sk,
email:trenerivskole@gmail.com,
splnomocnenec_ms@vlada.gov.sk
Facebook:https://www.facebook.com/trenerivskole/
Youtube:https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC3O-2guY89MO5Tw-Mi8rF_g
Instagram https://www.instagram.com/trenerivskole/
“Trenéři ve škole” - Czech Republic programme references
Website:www.treneriveskole.cz
email: info@treneriveskole.cz
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/treneriveskole
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCGUTwEnFNiBQRKWUchaVEsg
288
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
Instructional Effectiveness in Physical Education: Factors for
Attaining Motor Skill Equity
Ulana Lysniak1 - Eve Bernstein2
1
Bronx Community College, City University of New York, USA
2
Queens College, City University of New York, USA
e-mail: ulana.lysniak@bcc.cuny.edu
Abstract
Having the appropriate motor skills lays a foundation for many movement possibilities throughout
an individual’s life. Physical education class may be the first time that students experience physical
activity. Therefore, allowing as many effective instructional possibilities in physical education
becomes increasingly important. If students experience success in physical activity, this may create
future movement possibilities. Repeated failure during movement possibilities, however, may have
long lasting consequences, as students may not want to continue activities that are unsuccessful.
Motor skill equity, a term developed by Lysniak (2020), explores the attainment of motor skills
despite a student’s skill level. This chapter will explore the important factors in teaching, so that
students can attain successful movement opportunities. The factors are: a) time and practice, b)
level of difficulty and skill progression, and c) class structure, including clarity, accountability, and
feedback.
Key words: Physical education, Instruction, Motor skill equity, Skills
289
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
The physical education class experienced by students relies on the environment that is created by
teachers. Creating environments in physical education that are individualized to meet the needs
of all the students, are developed by effective physical education teachers (Lysniak, Gibbone, &
Silverman, 2019). These environments support the ability and opportunity to participate and
succeed in physical activity, described as motor skill equity (Lysniak, 2020). Having motor skill
equity enables participation in physical activities. Allowing students, to practice at their own skill
level and develop competency, develops motor skill equity. Although motor skill equity was
proposed for low skilled students, it can apply to all skill levels. To further this term, several factors
to augment motor skill equity on all skill levels will be explored.
Students in physical education classes have differing skill levels that may range from the high skilled
to the low skilled student. Effective teachers find ways to help individual students maximize their
abilities throughout the full range of student experiences. Activities can be modified in ways that
will increase each student’s chances of successful achievement and learning. Students, who are
successful and are learning skills, enjoy physical education and are more likely to stay physically
active as adults (McKenzie, 2003).
When students continually experience failure in performing activities in physical education, often
they attribute their failure to their lack of ability and come to believe that nothing they do can
change future outcomes in physical education (Behzadnia, Adachi, Deci, & Mohammadzadeh,
2018). Teachers’ instructional decisions are crucial so that students can experience success. When
students are unable to participate in activities, they avoid learning new tasks, announce failure in
advance, act out their frustration in the form of anger, and accept failure while at the same time
practicing the skill (Bartholomew et al., 2018). It is then up to the teacher to be an effective and
influential educator and find what works best for those students. Effective teaching practices can
be diluted by socialization in their in-service placement (Richards, Housner, & Templin, 2018), as
the role of the teacher is influenced by one’s approach to teaching physical education and socialized
into that role. The traditional sport practices, in which physical education is grounded, may be
preserved by socialization. The role of socialization and how it might influence effective
instruction has been critically examined (Richards, 2015), and, therefore, it is important that
teachers are proactive in their effective teaching practices.
This chapter will examine factors that affect instructional effectiveness that may promote motor
skill equity: (a) the use of time and students’ practice, (b) the difficulty level and skill progression,
and (c) the class structure, which includes clarity, accountability, and feedback. The following
sections will explore these factors as they relate to instructional effectiveness.
Time and Practice
Time management skills have been linked with student satisfaction in physical education (Cronin,
Allen, Mulvenna, & Russell, 2018). Good time management leads to optimal efficiency in use of
290
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
class time, use of positive motivational management techniques, and the ability to cope with and
handle any unexpected classroom disruptions. An effective teacher uses classroom time effectively
and structures practice that is relevant, focused, and paced (Siedentop, 2000). Redefining time,
through a students’ experiential perspective of learning, can be critical to setting up an environment
where students can learn productively (Casey, Dyson, & Campbell, 2009).
Carroll (1989) proposed a framework that students needed time to practice and to successfully
participate in a task to engage in learning. Students need time to learn, and each student needs a
different amount of time. The quality of learning is based on the quality of instruction; the amount
of learning is the actual time devoted to learning divided by the total amount of time needed.
Silverman (2005) states that the more time spent practicing a skill, the more learning will take place.
The inequality of practice opportunities has been highlighted, and social justice through movement
has been discussed (Walton-Fisette, Richards, Centeio, Pennington, & Hopper, 2019). These
opportunities would allow for all students to achieve motor skill equity, and this foundation of
skill attained in physical education class could be used throughout the students’ lives.
The single most valuable commodity in teaching and learning is time (Silverman, Tyson, &
Morford, 1988). Students ought to be engaged with the subject matter during that period. To
learn, the student needs sufficient time to practice successfully (Engel, Broderick, van Doorn,
Hardy, & Parmenter, 2018). This however, might not be the case. A good deal of student time,
in early studies, was spent waiting for an opportunity to practice the actual skill being taught
(Metzler, 1982; Piéron, 1983; Placek, Silverman, Shute, Dodds, & Rife, 1982). Powell, Woodfield,
Nevill, Powell, & Myers (2019) found that students perceived that teacher spent much of the time
in class on non-practice related factors, such as stopping the class to give instruction, giving
instruction for long periods of time, and students waiting on line for a practice trial. Teachers,
however, might not perceive the use of time as wasted, as they think they are clarifying instruction
and keeping order.
Yet, it is not only the time spent practicing, but it is also necessary to practice appropriately.
Appropriate practice of motor skill is strongly related to student achievement and learning
(Silverman & Mercier, 2015). However, as appropriate practice trials are limited, students do not
have enough time to correct inappropriate practice (Lonsdale et al., 2013). Successful trials can
lead to good technique being used and repeated, whereas with unsuccessful attempts, mistakes are
being made and are not being corrected.
Practice at an appropriate level produces related gains in skill, and inappropriate practice is
negatively related to success (Brian & Tauton, 2018). Practice does have a greater effect on low
skilled students, whose skill improves more from practice appropriate to their skill level. Having
effective intervention, where students are practicing skill and experiencing success, could allow
students to increase their foundation of skill and lay a foundation for future physical activities
(Lorås, 2020). Students practicing at a level that is too difficult for them could get frustrated or
overwhelmed and, therefore, will not learn (Silverman, 2005). This can be seen in physical
education classes, when in one class period, students go from dribbling around cones to full291
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
fledged game play. This is not enough time to practice and learn the skill of dribbling, nor to
dribble within the complexity of game play.
A teacher’s behavior with respect to the physical education class environment is vital. Teachers
are the ones who make decisions as to the amount of practice opportunities, the level of the motor
skill, the skill level of the student, and the instructional strategy they will use with the students.
Effective teachers recognize the diversity among individuals and strive to meet their individual
needs and motor skill equity (Lysniak et al., 2019; Lysniak, 2020).
Level of Difficulty and Skill Progression
In every class, the teacher is faced with students of varying skill levels (Martin, 2003) and potential
for achievement. Motor skills that are performed in physical education range in levels of difficulty
from simple to complex. Curricula can be designed, so students develop the motor skills in a
progressive method and are, therefore, efficient and successful in physical education (Hebert,
Landin, & Solmon, 2000). Students master each skill level before progressing to the next level
(Rink, 2020), otherwise success, and learning, will not be achieved. Inexperienced teachers might
not use task presentations effectively (Kwak & Kwon, 2022). When these teachers begin to present
tasks effectively, often it is a result of their improving their use of skill progressions (Iserbyt et al,
2022).
Excellent teachers adapt instruction to their students (Lysniak et al., 2019), because students learn
best at an appropriate level of difficulty. The level of difficulty and the amount of practice trials
the student completes are more important than the length of practice time (Stodden et al., 2008).
When practice progressions are inappropriate for students, there is a possibility that regression can
occur in their performance (García-Hermoso et al., 2020). It can be inferred that the difficulty
level of the skills being taught has an effect on students. High and low skilled students have
different experiences in physical education as they strive for motor skill equity. Various instruction
is necessary for different student skill levels and task difficulty; one type of instructional strategy
or teaching style will not work best for all the motor skill levels found in a physical education class
(Silverman, 2005). To meet the students’ needs, a teacher must change the level of difficulty of
the task to make it simpler or more complex for them (Rink, 2020). When teachers establish a
sequence of tasks that propels students to a goal and then build new practice tasks based on their
previous performance, students will most likely successfully complete the tasks (Kolovelonis,
Goudas, & Dermitzaki, 2011).
If teachers teach at too high a skill level for low skilled students, for example, moving them to
games before they can actually perform the activity, the low skilled students defer to the higher
skilled students (Silverman, 2005), because they are not enjoying the class and are not able to
perform the skill (Rikard & Banville, 2006). When the tasks are arranged for the high skilled
students, the environment is not a positive one for the low skilled students (Ennis, 2000).
According to Walling & Martinek (1995), low skilled students do not often find success in physical
education, but rather humiliation, isolation, and alienation.
292
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
If students find the situation in the gymnasium boring, if it has no personal relevance, they
withdraw (Bernstein, 2020). When they withdraw, after constantly experiencing failure, their
perception of their ability changes, and they do not believe they have any power to alter their
outcomes (White et al., 2021). Conversely, high skilled students possess a strong sense of control
over their circumstances and ability to execute skills (Walling & Martinek, 1995). Unfortunately,
low skilled students feel a lack of affinity with physical education. They come to think that
achieving in physical education is beyond their capabilities, and they withdraw mentally,
emotionally, or physically. They feel as though they do not have control over their enjoyment
(Subramaniam & Silverman, 2002).
Skill progressions are critical to the proper teaching of movement skills. Progressions in physical
activities move students from less difficult, less complex tasks to more difficult, more complex
tasks, and eventually to the accomplishment of the motor skill, a movement from motor skill
inequity to motor skill equity. A teacher’s first goal is to ascertain the level of skill and
understanding of the students. This information will allow the teacher to develop content by
planning progressions that lead to terminal goals (Siedentop, 2000). Instructional tasks relate to
the achievement of final goals, and within physical education there are several options for
categorizing these tasks. Rink’s (2020) model would direct students’ concentration upon
performing various skills, which could then be expanded to each student’s need to acquire a
specific skill. It would be the teacher’s task to categorize the instruction in such a way as to
facilitate skill development and reach the envisioned goal.
There are four tasks to Rink’s model (2020) that deal with changing the complexity of a task.
Initially, Rink’s model begins with the informing task, as the teacher provides information to the
students about the new motor skill, specifically explaining skill requirements. Students then get to
practice the motor skill. Refinement tasks are given when the teacher is concerned with improving
the quality of the performances by the students. This is accomplished by focusing the student on
a particular movement skill, so that they can concentrate on improving one aspect of their
performance. From observing the students, the teacher can modify subsequent tasks to meet the
students’ needs. Extending tasks are a way to establish progression. These progressions can move
from less complex to more complex, or the task can be practiced in a different way (no complexity
added), or the complexity of a task will be reduced. Refinement or extension can help to make
the tasks more appropriate for students of different skill levels. Application tasks provide students
with opportunities to move from how to do the movement to game or scrimmage situations.
As with Rink’s model (2020), Graham, Holt/Hale, & Parker’s (2019) generic levels of skill
proficiency (GLSP) categorize instructional tasks to function as a rubric of a student’s ability in
regards to different skill proficiency. The GLSP consists of four stages, pre-control (for
beginners), control (for advanced beginners), utilization (for intermediate students), and
proficiency (for advanced students), which coincide with Rink’s stages (informing task, refinement
tasks, extending tasks, and application tasks) by accommodating the complexity level of the task
to match the skill level of the student. These two models are similar in that they guide the students
293
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
to eventually move automatically as they focus on other elements of complexity. Both models
take steps to achieve motor skill equity.
A common mistake in physical education is to move students too quickly, before they have
sufficient practice, from practice to games (Bernstein, Phillips, & Silverman, 2011). Students may
be more successful at motor skills if task complexity is gradually increased, as students become
more competent at their tasks. It is a progression of steps that build upon each other in order to
reach the target set by the teacher. Thus, moving from simple to more complex tasks allow
students to attain a higher rate of success and greater enjoyment at the given activity (Silverman,
2005). The practical applications of level of difficulty and skill progression should be considered
while learning forearm passing in volleyball, for example, by having three levels of skill practice,
based on students’ individual needs. For the basic level, the students perform the forearm pass on
a stationary, held ball. Once the students are proficient at the skill, they move to the next level of
skill practice. The forearm pass is then practiced using a dropped ball. And, finally, the ball is
tossed by a partner, and the forearm pass is executed by passing the ball back in a high arc to the
tosser. As the students’ skills advance, the volleyball can be tossed to the left and to the right of
the students passing the balls to include variation.
Class Structure
Factors in effective teaching are important in student learning and achievement (Michael et al.,
2019; Wibowo & Dyson, 2021). Teachers’ decisions in the structure of the physical education
class often reveal a balance among goals that reflect the students’ needs, limitations, and
knowledge. A teacher’s perspective influences the importance of particular components and the
emphasis each will receive in the instructional plan (Bernstein, Herman, & Lysniak 2021). Class
structure and the way tasks are presented have a great effect on student learning. More specifically,
task structure provides a basis to understand what happens in a physical education environment
(Roure & Pasco, 2018). Factors important to student learning and achievement in physical
education have been identified. Much of the research in physical education has focused on three
factors that affect class structure – clarity, accountability, and feedback.
Clarity. Effective teachers are clear as they communicate the meaning and importance of what
is to be learned by the student (Chesebro, 2003). When information is presented to students, it
has to be clear in its objectives, contain specific and concrete procedures, have step-by-step
presentations, and be understood by the students (Simonton, Garn, & Solmon, 2017). Rink (2020)
suggested that teacher clarity in physical education is a teacher’s ability to present and organize
material in a logical progression, while concurrently monitoring the student’s understanding of the
given tasks. The teachers’ goal is to create a learning environment that enables students to think
and act in ways that helps them to maximize learning opportunities (Lysniak et al., 2019).
One of the primary roles of the teacher is to structure the content for the learner. Students must
understand the purpose of the task before it is performed. Students might fail to complete a task
as intended by a teacher when they are not clear about the expectations for participation (Heath
294
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
et al., 2012). Effective teachers communicate appropriately to the students by explaining the skill,
giving examples and demonstrations, and using verbal cues, which can enhance both affective and
psychomotor domains (Ciotto, 2018).
Teacher clarity was one of the first effective teacher variables identified by early research on
teaching (Kennedy, Cruickshank, Bush, & Meyers, 1978). Clarity, also, was one of the most
consistent variables identified as being related to teacher effectiveness. It was found to be related
to student achievement and learning. Research studying teacher clarity also focuses on the
evidence of lack of clarity in classroom settings. Constructs such as vagueness, redundancy,
discontinuity are common detractors from clarity (Kangalgil & Özgül, 2018). For example,
describing a skill without clear steps, or giving too many cues, often occurs in physical education
and can confuse students. Also, calling out, “Hey, you” to a student, rather than using their name,
is ineffective and unclear instruction as students may not know whom the teacher is referring to.
These are missed teaching opportunities.
Accountability. Accountability plays an important role in physical education. It refers to the way
the teacher ensures that students learn and complete tasks and achieve motor skill equity. Without
accountability there is no record that the teacher is providing for motor skill equity (Lysniak, 2020).
When students are held accountable, the result of motor skill learning is more likely to take place;
if the teacher does not hold the student accountable, there is a less likely chance that learning will
occur (Tolgfors, 2018).
When students are held accountable by teachers for motor skill performance, they tend to remain
engaged with the assigned task. The students’ system of accountability allows them to perceive
the teacher’s task instruction, monitoring, and rewards/consequences system, and then they adjust
their behavior accordingly (Welk, Corbin, & Dale, 2000). Thus, teacher monitoring is related to
student behavior. As accountability grows, the student develops a greater focus for the task. It is
effective teaching that creates an accountability system, which translates into good performance
(Rink & Hall, 2008). When there is no accountability, or when it is ineffective, task
accomplishment may be incomplete, or the task may not make sense to the student. Examples of
what teachers can use to hold students accountable could be task sheets or exit slips, as well as
skill tests and cognitive quizzes.
Feedback. Feedback is defined as the information teachers provide to learners regarding their
performance (Rink, 2020) and modifying the next action (Siedentop, 2000). Feedback may be a
factor connected with student learning and achievement. It has been related to learning and
achievement in various degrees (Pitt, Bearman, & Esterhazy, 2020; Wisniewski, Zierer & Hattie,
2020). Feedback may be critical and may have an important place in learning a motor skill
(Anderson, Magill, Mayo, & Steel, 2020).
Feedback messages also come in many different forms and can be categorized as either general,
supportive statements, but not containing task-relevant information (“way to go,” “good job”), or
as specific, containing information relevant to the task (“great pass, just the right height”). It can
295
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
be further classified as positive (“good move”), negative (“bad move”), or prescriptive (corrective
- “keep that position longer” or descriptive – “your position is incorrect”) (Potdevin et al., 2018).
Magill and Anderson (2021) and Rink (2020) have discussed that teachers should give feedback
that is specific, congruent, and corrective, so that on the subsequent trial students would be able
to perform movements more correctly. Teachers most often used this type of feedback for motor
skill improvement (Kyriakides, Tsangaridou, Charalambous, & Kyriakides, 2018). Meaningful
teacher feedback is important in learning motor skills, because it can improve students’
understanding, focus of performance, self-concept, and increase the rate of on-task behavior.
Feedback, especially specific feedback, helps the motor learner focus on the task as consistent
information is relayed about the learner’s practice trials and goals (Ma, 2021).
More recent studies have found that feedback is not as important for motor skill learning as was
once thought. Anderson et al. (2020) believed that the role of feedback in motor learning was a
lesser one, and the involvement of teacher feedback in motor learning was overstated. Teacher
feedback only has a small, if any, role, in skill learning (Curran & Standage, 2017). Magill and
Anderson (2021) posit that feedback may be necessary for learning some skills in some situations,
but perhaps not others. Lee (2021) has concluded that although many teachers do feel that
feedback is very important to student achievement, results from research do not support it as a
critical variable for learning.
Conclusion
In this chapter, the factors that teachers need to consider when striving for motor skill equity have
been outlined. Equity often is not considered until it is apparent that one does not have it. What
does it feel like not to be able to do something? It may not seem like much, but what if that
something is a life skill, such as physical movement? It may have profound consequences.
Perhaps, the physical education class that the child or adolescence took seemed irrelevant and not
important at the time. Yet, now, in the future, those very skills that they were meant to learn and
did not, do not allow them to participate in activities with friends, in the gym, or in sporting events,
because they feel uncomfortable doing the motor skills that were not taught correctly.
Physical education teachers can be instrumental in helping students at all skill levels to maximize
their abilities. Teaching progressions should be designed so that students may develop their skills
in a progressive manner. After specific skills have been attained, students can achieve motor skill
equity throughout their lives. The variables discussed here, time and practice, level of difficulty
and skill progression, and class structure (clarity of teaching episodes, accountability to focus on
the motor skill, and feedback related to achievement), rely on instructional effectiveness, so
students can participate, increase motor skills, and achieve success and motor skill equity.
296
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
References
Anderson, D. I., Magill, R. A., Mayo, A. M., & Steel, K. A. (2020). Enhancing motor skill
acquisition with augmented feedback. In N. J. Hodges & A. M. Williams (Eds.), Skill
acquisition in sport: Research, theory and practice (3rd ed., pp. 3-19). New York, NY: Routledge.
Bartholomew, K. J., Ntoumanis, N., Mouratidis, A., Katartzi, E., Thøgersen-Ntoumani, C., &
Vlachopoulos, S. (2018). Beware of your teaching style: A school-year long investigation of
controlling teaching and student motivational experiences. Learning and Instruction, 53, 50-63.
Behzadnia, B., Adachi, P. J., Deci, E. L., & Mohammadzadeh, H. (2018). Associations between
students' perceptions of physical education teachers' interpersonal styles and students'
wellness, knowledge, performance, and intentions to persist at physical activity: A selfdetermination theory approach. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 39, 10-19.
Bernstein, E. (2020). Students’ perceived experiences of competitive activities through electronic
platforms. Kinesiology Review, 10(1), 101-108.
Bernstein, E., Herman, A. M., & Lysniak, U. (2021). A longitudinal examination of preservice
teachers' beliefs toward implementation of competitive activities. Journal of Physical Education
and Sport, 21(5), 2712-2721.
Bernstein, E., Phillips, S. R., & Silverman, S. (2011). Attitudes and perceptions of middle school
students toward competitive activities in physical education. Journal of Teaching in Physical
Education, 30(1), 69-83.
Brian, A., & Taunton, S. (2018). Effectiveness of motor skill intervention varies based on
implementation strategy. Physical Education and Sport Pedagogy, 23(2), 222-233.
Carroll, J. B. (1989). The Carroll model: A 25-year retrospective and prospective view. Educational
Researcher, 18(1), 26-31.
Casey, A., Dyson, B., & Campbell, A. (2009). Action research in physical education: Focusing
beyond myself through cooperative learning. Educational Action Research, 17(3), 407-423.
Chesebro, J. L. (2003). Effects of teacher clarity and nonverbal immediacy on student learning,
receiver apprehension, and affect. Communication Education, 52(2), 135-147.
Ciotto, C. M., & Gagnon, A. G. (2018). Promoting social and emotional learning in physical
education. Journal of Physical Education, Recreation & Dance, 89(4), 27-33.
Cronin, L. D., Allen, J., Mulvenna, C., & Russell, P. (2018). An investigation of the relationships
between the teaching climate, students’ perceived life skills development and well-being
within physical education.Physical Education and Sport Pedagogy, 23(2), 181-196.
Curran, T., & Standage, M. (2017). Psychological needs and the quality of student engagement in
physical education: Teachers as key facilitators. Journal of Teaching in Physical Education, 36(3),
262-276.
Engel, A. C., Broderick, C. R., van Doorn, N., Hardy, L. L., & Parmenter, B. J. (2018). Exploring
the relationship between fundamental motor skill interventions and physical activity levels
in children: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Sports Medicine, 48(8), 1845-1857.
Ennis, C. (2000). Canaries in the coal mine: Responding to disengaged students using theme-based
curricula. Quest, 52, 119-131.
297
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
García-Hermoso, A., Alonso-Martínez, A. M., Ramírez-Vélez, R., Pérez-Sousa, M. Á., RamírezCampillo, R., &Izquierdo, M. (2020). Association of physical education with improvement
of health-related physical fitness outcomes and fundamental motor skills among youths: A
systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA Pediatrics, 174(6), e200223-e200223.
Graham, G. M., Holt/Hale, S. A., & Parker, M. A. (2019). Children moving: A reflective approach to
teaching physical education (10th ed.). Boston: McGraw Hill.
Heath, G. W., Parra, D. C., Sarmiento, O. L., Andersen, L. B., Owen, N., Goenka, S.,...&
Brownson, R. C. (2012). Evidence-based intervention in physical activity: lessons from
around the world. The Lancet, 380(9838), 272-281.
Hebert, E., Landin, D., & Solmon, M. (2000). The impact of task progressions on students’
practice quality and task related thoughts. Journal of Teaching in Physical Education, 19, 338-354.
Iserbyt, P., Coolkens, R., Loockx, J., Vanluyten, K., Martens, J., & Ward, P. (2020). Task
adaptations as a function of content knowledge: A functional analysis. Research Quarterly for
Exercise and Sport, 91(4), 539-550.
Kangalgil, M., & Özgül, F. (2018). Use of feedback in physical education and sports lessons for
student point of view. Universal Journal of Educational Research, 6(6), 1235-1242.
Kennedy, J. J., Cruickshank, D. R., Bush, A. J., & Meyers, B. (1978). Additional investigations into
the nature of teacher clarity. Journal of Educational Research, 72, 3-10.
Kolovelonis, A., Goudas, M., & Dermitzaki, I. (2011). The effect of different goals and selfrecording on self-regulation of learning a motor skill in a physical education setting. Learning
and Instruction, 21(3), 355-364.
Kwak, E., & Kwon, I. (2022). An analysis of situations and perspectives of secondary education
Korean
dance
teachers’
task
presentation
sustainable
teaching
effectiveness. Sustainability, 14(3), 1762-1772.
Kyriakides, E., Tsangaridou, N., Charalambous, C., & Kyriakides, L. (2018). Integrating generic
and content-specific teaching practices in exploring teaching quality in primary physical
education. European Physical Education Review, 24(4), 418-448.
Lee, I. (2019). Teacher written corrective feedback: Less is more. Language Teaching, 52(4), 524-536.
Lonsdale, C., Rosenkranz, R. R., Peralta, L. R., Bennie, A., Fahey, P., & Lubans, D. R. (2013). A
systematic review and meta-analysis of interventions designed to increase moderate-tovigorous physical activity in school physical education lessons. Preventive Medicine, 56(2), 152161.
Lorås, H. (2020). The effects of physical education on motor competence in children and
adolescents: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Sports, 8(6), 88-101.
Lysniak, U. (2020). Motor skill equity: Physical literacy and the rise of low skilled students.
International Journal of Physical Education, 57(1), 2-16.
Lysniak, U., Gibbone, A., & Silverman, S. (2019). Effective teaching strategies for low skilled
students. The Physical Educator, 76, 701-725.
Martin, L. T. (2003). Context of schools. In S. J. Silverman, & C. D. Ennis (Eds.), Student learning
in physical education: Applying research to enhance instruction (2nd ed., pp. 43-66). Champaign, IL:
Human Kinetics.
298
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
Ma, J., Lander, N., Eyre, E. L., Barnett, L. M., Essiet, I. A., & Duncan, M. J. (2021). It’s not just
what you do but the way you do it: A systematic review of process evaluation of
interventions to improve gross motor competence. Sports Medicine, 51(12), 2547-2569.
Magill, R., & Anderson, D. (2021). Motor learning and control (12th ed.). New York, NY: McGrawHill Publishing.
McKenzie, T. L. (2003). Physical activity, fitness, and health-related physical education. In S. J.
Silverman, & C. D.Ennis (Eds.), Student learning in physical education: Applying research to enhance
instruction (2nd ed., pp. 207-226). Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics.
Metzler, M. W. (1982). Adapting the academic learning time instructional model to physical
education teaching. Journal of Teaching in Physical Education, 1(1), 44-55.
Michael, R. D., Webster, C. A., Egan, C. A., Nilges, L., Brian, A., Johnson, R., & Carson, R. L.
(2019). Facilitators and barriers to movement integration in elementary classrooms: A
systematic review. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport, 90(2), 151-162.
Piéron, M. (1983). Teacher and pupil behavior and the interaction process in physical education
classes. In R. Telama, V. Varstala, J. Tiamen, L. Laakso, & T. Haajanen (Eds.), Research in
school physical education (pp. 193-202). Jyvaskyla, Finland: Foundation for the Promotion of
Physical Culture and Health.
Pitt, E., Bearman, M., & Esterhazy, R. (2020) The conundrum of low achievement and feedback
for learning. Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education, 45(2), 239-250.
Placek, J., Silverman, S., Shute, S., Dodds, P., & Rife, F. (1982). Active learning time in a traditional
elementary physical education setting: A descriptive analysis. Journal of Classroom Interaction,
17(2), 41-48.
Potdevin, F., Vors, O., Huchez, A., Lamour, M., Davids, K., & Schnitzler, C. (2018). How can
video feedback be used in physical education to support novice learning in gymnastics?
Effects on motor learning, self-assessment and motivation. Physical Education and Sport
Pedagogy, 23(6), 559-574.
Powell, E., Woodfield, L. A., Nevill, A. M., Powell, A. J., & Myers, T. D. (2019). ‘We have to wait
in a queue for our turn quite a bit’: Examining children’s physical activity during primary
physical education lessons. European Physical Education Review, 25(4), 929-948.
Richards, K. A. R. (2015). Role socialization theory: The sociopolitical realities of teaching physical
education. European Physical Education Review, 21(3), 379-393.
Richards, K. A. R., Housner, L. D., & Templin, T. J. (2018). Addressing physical education teacher
socialization through standards-based reform of physical education teacher
education. Quest, 70(3), 334-353.
Rikard, G. L., & Banville, D. (2006). High school student attitudes about physical education. Sport,
Education and Society, 11(4), 385-400.
Rink, J. (2020). Teaching physical education for learning (8th ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill.
Rink, J. E., & Hall, T. J. (2008). Research on effective teaching in elementary school physical
education. The Elementary School Journal, 108(3), 207-218.
Roure, C., & Pasco, D. (2018). The impact of learning task design on students’ situational interest
in physical education. Journal of Teaching in Physical Education, 37(1), 24-34.
Siedentop, D. (2000). Developing teaching skills in physical education (4th ed.). Mountain View, CA:
Mayfield.
299
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Silverman, S. (2005). Low skilled children in physical education: A model of factors that impact
their experiences and learning. In F. Carrerio da Costa, M. Cloes, & M.Gonalez (Eds.), The
art and science of teaching in physical education and sport (pp. 211-226). Leige, Belguim: University
of Leige Press.
Silverman, S., & Mercier, K. (2015). Teaching for physical literacy: Implications to instructional
design and PETE.Journal of Sport and Health Science, 4(2), 150-155.
Silverman, S., Tyson, L., & Morford, L. M. (1988). Relationships of organization, time, and student
achievement in physical education. Teaching and Teacher Education, 4, 247-257.
Simonton, K. L., Garn, A. C., & Solmon, M. A. (2017). Class-related emotions in secondary
physical education: A control-value theory approach. Journal of Teaching in Physical Education,
36(4), 409-418.
Stodden, D. F., Goodway, J. D., Langendorfer, S. J., Roberton, M. A., Rudisill, M. E., Garcia, C.,
& Garcia, L. E. (2008). A developmental perspective on the role of motor skill competence
in physical activity: An emergent relationship. Quest, 60(2), 290-306.
Subramaniam, P. R., & Silverman, S. (2002). Using complimentary data: An investigation of
student attitude in physical education. Journal of Sport Pedagogy, 8(1), 74-79.
Tolgfors, B. (2018). Different versions of assessment for learning in the subject of physical
education. Physical Education and Sport Pedagogy, 23(3), 311-327.
Walling, M. D., & Martinek, T. (1995). Learned helplessness: A case study of middle school
student. Journal of Teaching in Physical Education, 14, 454-466.
Walton-Fisette, J. L., Richards, K. A. R., Centeio, E. E., Pennington, T. R., & Hopper, T. (2019).
Exploring future research in physical education: Espousing a social justice
perspective. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport, 90(4), 440-451.
Welk, G. J., Corbin, C. B., & Dale, D. (2000). Measurement issues in the assessment of physical
activity in children. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport, 71(sup2), 59-73.
White, R. L., Bennie, A., Vasconcellos, D., Cinelli, R., Hilland, T., Owen, K. B., & Lonsdale, C.
(2021). Self-determination theory in physical education: A systematic review of qualitative
studies. Teaching and Teacher Education, 99, 103247. doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2020.103247
Wibowo, J., & Dyson, B. (2021). A contingency perspective on learning and instruction in physical
education. European Physical Education Review, 27(4), 727-742.
Wisniewski, B., Zierer, K., & Hattie, J. (2020). The power of feedback revisited: A meta-analysis
of educational feedback research. Frontiers in Psychology, 10, 3087. doi:
10.3389/fpsyg.2019.03087
300
Best Practices
________________________________________________________________________________
eL CaMiNo De piEFcitos: United for a Healthy and Sustainable
Physical Education
Carlos Chamorro Durán
CEIP Cristóbal Colón, Madrid, Spain
e-mail: chamorrodurancarlos@gmail.com
Abstract
eL CaMiNo De piEFcitos: united by a healthy and sustainable Physical Education project is an
annual and cooperative project in which you can get symbolic kilometers by doing actions related
to physical activity, healthy food, reading, resting and sustainability to virtually tour the beautiful
Spanish geography, both insular and peninsular, and the two Autonomous Cities of Ceuta and
Melilla. It was firstly implemented in the 2019-2020 school year, and a new edition is being
developed in the current 2021- 2022 school year, with a thematic based on The Olympics and with
SDG (Sustainable Development Goals) as cross axis to the entire project. In addition to this, during
the school year some campaigns are carried out related to ephemeris linked to the 5 Healt Axes of
the project and the values we want to convey as empathy, solidarity, equiality, respect, fellowship.
In the project are involved more than 200 schools with different features and educational levels
from all over Spain, 4 international educational centers (Cambodia, Luxembourg and two centers
in Colombia), in addition to a care center for the elderly in Malaga and more than 50000 students
and their families take part. The project counts also with a bank of more than 100 ambassadors
who are people related to sport (many of them Olympics and Paralympics) that through short
videos support and motivate students and their families to keep getting healthy kilometers.
Key words: Childhood obesity; Healthy lifestyle habits; SDG, Physical activity, Healthy food,
Reading, Resting, Sustainability.
301
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
________________________________________________________________________________________
The project eL CaMiNo De piEFcitos (figure 1) is an annual and cooperative project in which
through the practice of physical activity, healthy eating, reading and sustainable
development actions will allow us to obtain symbolic kilometers, taking us to travel through
each and every one of the provinces in which the Spanish geography is divided, including the two
archipelagos and autonomous cities, which complete the beauty of which our country is composed.
Figure 1 Project logo and QR code to the explanation in less than 2 minutes
of its development
1. Introduction and contextualization of the proposal
The project was born from the latest studies carried out by entities working on health, such as the
PASOS study whose objective is to evaluate physical activity, sedentary lifestyles, lifestyles and
obesity in Spanish children and adolescents aged 8 to 16 years by the Gasol Foundation and the
report on The State of the World's Children 2019: Food and Nutrition by UNICEF, or, more
recently, the ALADINO 2019 study (Food, Physical Activity, Childhood Development and
Obesity in Spain) of the Spanish Agency for Food Safety and Nutrition (AESAN), which indicate
the increase in childhood obesity. Faced with this situation we have devised this project a group of
380 teachers, reaching 48,872 students and their families in 200 educational centers of different
stages throughout Spain (Figure 2), which puts in value the personal actions of each of the students,
their families, teachers and own center, since from education, and especially, Physical Education,
we can develop actions that incorporate these physical-healthy routines in their lives, reducing these
bad data and returning the lost health. All these actions will be rewarded with the sum of "healthy
kilometres" for the centres and students who carry out different actions of a motor nature,
favouring recycling, reading or eating habits in search of a comprehensive education that influences
their personality as an active and reflective citizen (Márquez Vargas, J., 2017).
Figure 2 Images of several teachers participating in the project and
QR code to the virtual tour
302
Best Practices
________________________________________________________________________________
2. Narrative
The game is learning, since above all it is emotion and curiosity as González de la Fuente (2015)
or Mora Teruel (2022) say, therefore, taking the words of Pérez (2020), what better way to teach
while playing! starting point to choose gamification as an active methodology for the project. Based
on the structure of the Camino de Santiago, we decided to shape it so that the students could get
to know the Spanish geography in a fun way through "virtual" kilometers in a healthy way through
four axes: physical activity, healthy eating, sustainable development and reading. Each group of
walkers has a passport with all the schools they have to visit on their way (figure 3). When they
symbolically arrive at each one of them, they will be given a "provinciala" as a stamp, as proof of
their passage, they will also receive a video of the students of that centre explaining cultural
curiosities, gastronomy, legends,... related to the province, with the aim of having completed the
whole route in the month of June.
Figure 3 Images of the map and the passport created for the Project
To ensure that all the schools manage to complete the healthy passport, a solidarity bank has been
created with donations of kilometres. The whole project follows an active methodological line,
promoting the development of active and healthy schools and playgrounds, carrying out common
actions between centres such as the challenge of jumping against obesity on the World Day against
Obesity, the San Silvestre de piEFcitos, the celebration of the Day of Disability or the climate
summit with the initiative of Zero Waste Playgrounds. In addition, it has a marked interdisciplinary
character, with project-based work in schools (Figure 4).
Figure 4 Images of some common actions between centres
303
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
________________________________________________________________________________________
Although the project is born in the area of Physical Education, it is a project that seeks
interdisciplinarity, such as working on content such as measurements and distances in the area
of Mathematics, knowing the different names and toponymy in the area of Spanish Language
and Literature, understanding the distribution of the Spanish geography in the area of Social
Sciences, discovering the natural landscapes, climatology, flora, fauna... in the area of Natural
Sciences or, for example, in the area of Values with the exchange between students from
different places about their daily life to see the similarities and differences with respect to others,
creating a network of twinning that can be the beginning of a lasting friendship and quality.
The project is developed with the dedication of the teachers who make up this initiative, investing
our time and passion to achieve the goal of generating change.
It should also be noted that it is a project that promotes inclusion from different perspectives:
• Participation of schools from different educational stages and with different characteristics,
such as Special Education centres or Grouped Rural Centres.
• Adaptation of the materials created to students with specific educational support needs, for
example, through pictograms.
• Videos of disabled and Paralympic ambassadors.
• Celebration of Disability Day on December 3.
3. Mechanics, dynamics, scoring, ranking, strategies to generate curiosity
The project begins on October 1st and ends on June 5th, the day on which World Environment
Day is celebrated with the Recyclalympics, as the culmination of a year full of different actions
related to changing the lifestyle of our students and their families.
All actions to add up kilometres are checked by sending photographs to the email created by each
coordinator in their centre, where they receive this evidence as justification for adding up the
kilometres:
• Inside the centre: direct observation and anecdotal records.
• Outside the centre: sending photographs, videos,... by email to the coordinator of your centre.
Most of the actions carried out in schools based on the 4 axes will last over time and in the
following school years, such as: the use of recycling bins, ecological patrols for waste collection,
more healthy lunches in the cafeterias of schools, conducting the I San Silvestre de piEFcitos...
The possibilities can be flexible depending on the characteristics of the context of each of the
centres (Figure 5).
304
Best Practices
________________________________________________________________________________
Figure 5 Explanation of how to get kilometers on the axes that make up the project
In the same way, each group of walkers will achieve one of the 5 levels of health consecrated and
established according to the kilometers obtained. Attributing a bagde or badge that will identify them
as a participant in this educational adventure and care of their health (Figure 6), with a reward at
each level:
1. First level -> Tourist, with visit to 5 provinces. Choose a game during the class.
2. Second level -> Backpacker, 13 provinces. One day of free play.
3. Third level -> Mountain guide, 24 provinces. A bracelet or notebook of the project.
4. Fourth level -> Mountaineer, 37 provinces. Participate in the Recyclalympics.
5. Fifth level -> Sherpa, 52 provinces. A t-shirt of the project.
Figure 6 Infographic of health levels along with some of the rewards received
Finally, in an interdisciplinary way, different campaigns have been created to raise awareness about
caring for the environment, healthy eating to overcome childhood obesity, the inclusion of all
people who live together in society,... making them coincide with the celebration of their days in
the school calendar or events worldwide, as has happened with the World Day of Childhood
Obesity (November 12), the International Day of Persons with Disabilities (December 3) or the
World Day of Environmental Education (January 26), bringing to our schools different awareness
actions by the entire educational community.
305
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
________________________________________________________________________________________
Figure 7 Posters of different campaigns carried out to add up healthy kilometres
4. Results, evaluation and complementary aspects of the project
The most visible results are the increase of healthy lunches during recess time, as well as the
reduction of waste due to the incorporation of cloth bags or the use of tuppers that have replaced
the aluminum foil wrappers that we were used to take lunch to school from home.
We can not forget the existing motivation among students and families to reach new provinces,
discovering through the videos of each school, the curiosities and secrets that encompass the
immediate environment, knowing the details of each province to see differences and similarities
with the place where we live each.
In addition, we have the collaboration of several associations and groups with whom we work to
achieve common goals such as:
• Educational centres sector: 200 educational centres of different characteristics and stages
sharing experiences, carrying out common actions and celebrations, establishing agreements,
providing feedback every day and creating a large inter-centre network.
• University sector: with the INEF of Catalonia, producing posters and motivational videos,
in addition to the aforementioned universities of Oviedo and Murcia. On the other hand, we
have also collaborated with the University Alcalá de Henares, carrying out different statistical
studies and infographics on the data collected in the different educational centres. Finally, we
have carried out a Service Learning together with the Ramón Llull University of Barcelona,
in which for the International Day of Physical Activity and Health, celebrated on April 6th,
we proposed activities so that the prisoners of the prisons would add up kilometres that they
would then donate to the students of the rest of Spain.
• Sector associations-organizations with collaboration in different fields:
a. Teachers for Future Spain, through the campaign Recreos residuo cero.
b. Educo-NGO, through its Lunchroom Grants program, whose aim is to ensure that no student
goes without at least one healthy meal a day.
c. Aladina Foundation, carrying out different campaigns to raise funds in order to donate them
to families who are suffering from a case of childhood cancer.
306
Best Practices
________________________________________________________________________________
d.
LOGRA Association, through activities to raise awareness and bring disability and inclusive
sport closer to schools.
e. PGR NGO, to promote women's sport through rugby in different countries of the world.
• Sector ambassadors (figure 8): from the fields of sport, culture, health and cooking, who
created motivational videos for students to add kilometres to this adventure, such as Lydia
Valentín, Sandra Sánchez, Javier Fernández, Maverick Viñales, among others.
Figure 8 Image with several ambassadors
The evaluation of the project is being done on a daily basis and continues due to the receipt of
emails from students and their families to add kilometers, showing that they perform actions
within the four axes around which the project revolves. Rubrics have been generated in order to
know attitudinal aspects and the students motivational activities, without forgetting that each
educational centre produced a video and a Kahoot with questions related to the content of their
video.
5. Conclusions and final considerations
Note that the sum of kilometers for each group of walkers is done from the cooperative point of
view, moving away from the competition between groups, since what is pursued is that the
members of each team encourage each other to achieve activities that they approach all the points
of Spain and not see which group gets more kilometers. In addition, we have the resource of the
solidarity kilometer bank, in which the contributions that are donated by the rest of the Educational
Community for those teams that go few kilometers are accumulated.
If we had to summarize the innovative and original aspects of the project they would be:
• Participation of more than 200 centers and almost 50,000 students from all over Spain.
• Involvement and active participation of the entire educational community.
• Use of gamification to motivate, involve and attract the educational community and achieve
the objectives.
• Simulation of the Camino de Santiago with El camino de piEFcitos, united by a healthy and
sustainable education.
• Specific and personalized materials: healthy passport, province cards, badges, videos, maps,
infographics,...
307
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
________________________________________________________________________________________
• Team of ambassadors and ambassadors (world champions, Paralympians, prominent
personalities from the world of nutrition, sports psychology,...) who show their support for the
project and motivate the students to continue adding kilometers through videos or face-to-face
performances in the centers.
• Actions and common celebrations in the different educational centers that are part of the
project.
• Use and development of ICT and innovative educational applications such as video editing,
sending images, promotional trailers, ambassador videos...
• Transversal nature: promotion of solidarity (actions and solidarity races, solidarity bank of
kilometers, collaboration with NGOs,...), road safety education, environmental conservation,
disability awareness,...
• Knowledge and learning of cultural and significant aspects of the different provinces of Spain
in a playful, innovative and motivating way for students.
• Dissemination through social networks and media: radio, press, television,...
This made me think that we are not naïve. To achieve modifications at the level of values and civic
actions is not the task of a course. The scale of individual values is hidden in the ethical essence
of the person and there you only get there by filtering, drop by drop, but in a repeated and tireless
way, small doses of peace, respect, solidarity, altruism? That is why this project must be maintained
over time, prolonging its action for many years, allowing these values to consolidate, to become
as commonplace as a child's smile.
References
UNICEF (2019). State of the world's children report 2019: food and nutrition. Retrieved 1 October
2020:
https://www.unicef.org/lac/media/8441/file/PDF%20SOWC%202019%20ESP.pdf
PASOS Study (2019). Physical Activity, Sedentarism and Obesity in Spanish Youth. Gasol
Foundation. Retrieved October 1, 2020: https://www.gasolfoundation.org/es/estudiopasos/
ALADINO study (2019). Report on Food, Physical Activity, Child Development and Obesity in
Spain. Retrieved on January 6, 2021:
https://www.aesan.gob.es/AECOSAN/docs/documentos/nutricion/observatorio/Infor
me_Aladino_2019.pdf
Márquez Vargas, J. (2017). Educando ciudadanos activos dentro de las aulas dormidas. Extraído el
6 de enero de 2021: https://www.compartirpalabramaestra.org/actualidad/blog/educandociudadanos-activos-dentro-de-aulas-dormidas
González de la Fuente, A. (2015). Cómo la “gamificación” promueve la innovación y el cambio
cultural. Recuperado de http://www.aunclicdelastic.com/como-la-gamificacion-promuevela-innovacion-y-el-cambio-cultural/
Mora Teruel, F. (2022). Neuroeducador. Una nueva profesión. Madrid: Alianza Editorial.
Pérez López, I. J. (2020). De las 7 Bolas de Dragón a los 7 reinos de Poniente: viajando por la
ficción para transformar la realidad. Granada: Copideporte.
308
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
Innovation in Physical Activity to Health Life Styles through the
Mile´s Schools Program: A Mexican Experience
Antonio Eugenio Rivera-Cisneros1 - Néstor Rangel Jantes2 - Manuel
Guerrero-Zainos2 - Gabriela Murguía-Cánovas1 - Yesenia Lara-Mayorga1 Jorge Manuel Sánchez González2 - Juan Antonio Rivera-Ríos1 - Gloria
Vargas-Sánchez1 - Ricardo Félix-Inguanzo2 - Felipe Horacio GómezBallesteros4 - Marco Antonio Ojeda Macías4
Universidad del Fútbol y Deporte, Mexico
Vicepresidencia Norteamérica FIEP, Mexico
3
Benemérita Universidad Normal de Zacatecas, Mexico
4
Federación Mexicana de Medicina del Deporte, Mexico
e-mail: antonio.rivera.academico@gmail.com
1
2
Abstract
In 2000´s, the England community implemented a special program denominated “Mile´s Schools”
for elementary schools. The program consists in walk or run one mile, before the scholar sessions.
Mexico has a regrettable problem with the corporality of their population and occupies the first
places of obesity in the world. Our country, as the world, require a new method to battle the obesity
and inactivity, and it´s necessary the early intervention. The purpose of this study is to determine
the impact in scholar population of México the experience of the “Mile School Program”.
Participated 2,017 scholars from seven to eleven years old, (male 60%, female 40%), who was
studied in six different schools of the Municipality of León, México. This City is in the center of
the country, and its population is representative of the Mexico. All the socio-economic class were
represented in a proportional basis. According with the 6 month program, scholars and their
teachers, manifested their satisfaction and they considering, that the school is an ideal place to
promote healthy lifestyle for several reasons: Children spend a large part of the day at school; they
think that generate a great impact in the future; it is implemented in ideal environment to acquiring
knowledge and habits of healthy living; educating in a healthy lifestyle is part of the school
curriculum that establishes the contents to work in the classroom, and it was a better way to inspires
physical activity among students in a fun way. To evaluate the effectiveness of the program, it was
measuring the body mass index, which it was reduced from 26+2 to 21+1 (Kg/m2). The program
left satisfied parents and teachers. Main benefits observed were: Improves the physical, social and
emotional health and the well-being of the students; helps to improve performance, mood and
concentration; reduces states of anxiety and stress; it was a fun and social activity that promotes
fellow the adherence; it's not a race or a competition, but it was a way to have fun interacting with
class mates outdoors; allows them to create new friendships and develop existing ones; tt is not
discriminatory or exclusive, all students are invited to participate. All the benefits and advantages
that this program brings to the students, have a positive impact on their parents and teachers.
Key Words: Mile´s School, Scholar´s early intervention, Scholar Obesity
309
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
According to the World Health Organization, childhood obesity and overweight are one of the
most serious global public health problems of the 21st century (WHO, 2014). Mexico occupies the
first places de childhood obesity in the world. The life expectancy of this generation may be less
than that of their parents, a situation that would occur for the first time in history.
Inadequate nutrition and physical activity are a key factor in the development of childhood obesity.
A sedentary lifestyle has become a risk for children and young people, who spend more hours
sitting in front of the computer or smartphone than playing or doing extracurricular activities
outdoors.
The consequences of childhood overweight and obesity go far beyond aesthetics, and can lead to
medical, psychological and emotional complications in the short and medium term. Diabetes, is
already currently a serious public health problem in our country, published through the National
Survey of Health and Nutrition carried out by the Mexican Government (ENSANUT, 2018).
In 2000, the Commonwealth of England implemented a program called “Mille's Schools for
Elementary Schools”. The program consists of walking or running one mile, before the academic
sessions daily. Benefits recognized by the basic and secondary school included decreased
overweight and obesity. In the educational process, it was also notable that the learning process,
concentration in class sessions and better execution of school tasks had improved (Slawson, 2015;
Harding, 2015). The simplicity of the execution of physical activity through walking and its
replicability has attracted the attention of different countries and in Mexico, by the ministries of
education and health.
The purpose of this work was to determine the impact on the school population of a representative
central zone of Mexico through the application of activities related to the methodology of the “Mile
schools” developed in England.
Methods
Participants were to 2,017 elementary school students from seven to eleven years-old (60% males,
40% females), who belonged to six different schools in the Municipality of León, Mexico. This city
is in the center of the country, and its population is representative of the Mexico, due to its
geographical location, economy, level education and their industry. It is considered the 5th most
important city in the nation. In this study, all socio-economic classes were chosen, represented in
a proportional basis.
The procedures, benefits and contraindications of the study were explained to parents, students,
school officials and teachers. The principles of the Declaration of Helsinki were observed and the
Mexican regulations on human research, particularly with the age of the students participating in
310
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
the study and approved by the ethics committee of the University of Guanajuato, and Mexican
Federation of Sports Medicine.
The program consisted of walking or running a mile, daily, before each class. The scholars
participated five days a week, according to the schedule of national study program. In Mexico, the
academic system takes place five days a week, and its usual academic activity is usual for 6 hours a
day.
A medical history and anthropometric measurements of height (meters) and weight (kilograms)
were obtained, and the body mass index was calculated (weight (Kg)/height (m)2). The data were
recorded every week in students and teachers to know their program perception through a Likert
scale, with 10 items and graduated on a scale of 5 degrees (from disagree to totally agree). The
weight (Kg) and height (m2) were obtained, to evaluate the body mass index (weight (kg) / height
(m2)).
Parents opinion was obtained at the beginning and the end of the program through direct
interviews.
The perception data were analyzed by qualitative techniques in a matrix that contained a comment
vs. the evolution of the time of the program. t paired test and Kruskall-Wallys test to nonparametric variables was performed to analyze the changes before and after program. Distribution
of normality was obtained in all data. In all cases, the significance level was fixed at alfa of 95%.
The data was analyzed in SPSS (v. 20.0).
Results
According to the 6-month program, the students and their teachers expressed their approval and
consider the school an ideal place to promote a healthy lifestyle and to avoid risky behavior for
several reasons: Children spend much of the day in the school and require a time to do physical
activities and this fact has long term impact on the lives of students; the school environments are
an ideal space for acquire knowledge and healthy life habits; the program is a way to educate in a
healthy lifestyle which is part of the educational program in schoolchildren and is consistent with
the contents to work in the classroom; represents a complementary way of action to promote
physical activity among students in a fun way, not competitive; promote companionship among
schoolchildren with lower hereditary biological capacities, as well as different economic or cultural
conditions of the family. The distribution participants scholars’ participants studied is showed in
table 1.
Table 1Distribution of participants by the sex and socioeconomic income. (Absolut values)
Total
Low
Girls (#) (#)
Middle
(#)
High
(#)
Total
Low
Boys (#) (#)
Middle
(#)
High
(#)
483
145
48
724
217
73
290
311
434
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Before
the
program
After
the
program
Height (cm)
Boys = 110
Height (cm) Boys
= 123
Girls = 120
Girls = 142
Body Mass Index
(Kg/m2)
Body Mass index
(Kg/m2)
Boys = 24
Boys = 19
Girls = 22
Girls = 22
The figure 1 shows the changes in mean values in the height and
the body mass index during the program.
The participants increased their height by of 3.2 cm in the period of the study, attributed to their
natural growth and natural development according to the reference values of Mexican infants
(ENSANUT, 2018). There was no significant difference (p > 0.05) between boy and girls. Long
term studies in this population will make it possible to characterize the impact of this type of
program coupled with adequate nutrition. The body mass index of the participants changed
significatively, attributed to age-specific growth and development, and feeding could be a noncontrolled variable in this study, but must be considering in a future studies, to assess the impact
of the program on the corporality of scholars, the body mass index is a good indicator. This was
reduced from 26+2 to 21+1 (Kg/m2) (p<0.05).
Discussion
Walking a mile each day brings a lot of benefits to students, not only in school children, but also
to parents and teachers. In this study, we showed some of the main observations detected in the
program that were considered the most important and transcendent. Data were coincident
between schoolchildren, parents, school officials and teachers: Improvement in physical, social
and emotional health and well-being of students; helps to improve the academic performance,
mood and concentration; reduces anxiety and stress; it is a fun social activity that promotes
solidarity and camaraderie among schoolchildren; this activity is not competitive and represents a
way to have fun interacting with the classroom mates; allows them to create new friendships and
develop existing ones; it isn´t discriminatory and not exclusive to students who have a better
hereditary and/or socio-cultural and family conditions and abilities; all schoolchildren can
participate.
312
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
The program doesn’t require a physical space. It can be done around the school, or in sports areas
within the school. The 15 to 30 minutes used contribute to achieving the recommended daily
minimum of 60 minutes of physical activity of moderate to vigorous intensity in children, which is
good option knowledge, habits int pediatric knowledge, habits and attitudes for school health in
the pediatric (Hatch, 2021).
Walking a mile or multiples of in younger children facilitate the development of a wide variety of
physical activity, and socialization. The program also has a big impact in the adoption of health
habits to combat a sedentary lifestyle. In this work, schoolchildren have an inherent interest in the
playful participation of activities based on games that are reinforced by having fun and enjoying
living together with their classmates. The “Miles School” program addresses childhood obesity in
a fun, simple, and effective way. It is to encourage the whole class to walking a daily mile together
with their classmates. This methodology additionally helps teachers to improve student attention
and obtain better learning, as has been shown in various studies (Slawson, 2015). Walking one mile
(1,609 meters) can be done in a short time and does not substantially take away time for school
activity. The program favors the quality of learning, by having students with better levels of
attention in daily scholar activities (Morris, 2021).
We were able to identify ten basic principles about the benefits of this program: 1 FUN: Students
should know that it is not a competition, but an opportunity to have fun and enjoy a little outside
with their classmates; 2 THE CLIMATE was not a barrier in our experience, and the sessions can
be recovered; 3. THE GROUND to exercise can be developed in the same school yard or in a
nearby park. Just calculate how many laps are needed to complete a mile: 4 THE CLOTHING, is
not a factor that affects the implementation of the program, since they need special clothing or
warmth before the activity; 5 IT'S SAFE as it takes place within or near school facilities, children
are not at risk; 6 IT IS SIMPLE, since it does not require complex instructions; 7 IT'S FREE,
students should be free to complete the mile at their own pace (especially at the beginning) and no
additional investment is required; 8 IS FLEXIBLE, you can take the routine to walk the mile always
at the same time or choose a different time each day either before the start of the school day,
between classes; during recess, among other periods; 9 IT'S FAST, it doesn't take a lot of time; 10
ALL WIN, schoolchildren, parents, officials and teachers (Morris 2021).
Conclusions
Although measures to increase physical activity should be encouraged, the initiatives should ensure
that the activity is fun, attractive to all, varied and improve the formulation and implementation of
new methodologies and innovation to be applied in physical education through the development
of skills, coordination and confidence. When additional time is available, structured play is a
complementary activity that will favor greater synergy in the activities of this important topic. More
studies are needs to evaluate the impact of this kind of this complementary scholar activities.
313
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Bibliografía
WHO (2014): Acabar con la obesidad Infantil. Estados Unidos. WHO
ENSANUT (2018). Encuesta Nacional de Salud y Nutrición en México. México. Secretaría de
Salud..
Harding E (2015). The primary School that makes every pupil rune a mile a day in drive to cut
childhood obesity. Available on line: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article3252793/Primary-school-makes-pupil-run-mile-day-drive-cutchildhood-obesity.html.
Department of Health DoH (2011). Start Active, Stay Active: a report on physical activity from the
four home countries' Chief Medical Officers (Report). London: Department of Health.
Available online: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/start-active-stay-active-areport-on-physical-activity-from-the-four-homecountries-chief-medical-officers.
Department for Education (DoH) (2013). Evidence on physical education and sport in schools
(Report).
London:
Department
of
Health,
UK.
Available
on
line.
https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/226506
/Evidence_on_physical_educatio n_and_sport_in_schools-summary.pdf
Hatch, L.M., Williams, R.A., Dring, K.J. et al (2021). Activity patterns of primary school children
during participation in The Daily Mile. Sci Rep 11, 7462. Available on line
https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-86631-2.
Morris JL, Daly-Ssmith A, Archbold VSJ, et al (2019): The Daily Mile™ initiative: Exploring
physical activity and the acute effects on executive function and academic performance in
primary school children. Psychology of Sports and Exercise. Available on line
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.psychsport.2019.101583.
Slawson (2015) Miles ahead: school that fired starting gun on running revolution. Scotland. The
Guardian. Available on line: http://www.theguardian.com/education/2015/sep/28/dailymile-school-st-ninians-stirling-scotland
314
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
An International Review of the Contributions of School-based
Physical Activity, Physical Education, and School Sport to the
Promotion of Health-enhancing Physical Activity
Richard Bailey1 - Manolis Adamakis2 - Jana Vašíčková3 - Petr Vlček3 Andreu Raya Demidoff4 - Uwe Pühse5 - Sandra Heck2 - Claude Scheuer2
1
University of Nottingham Malaysia, Malaysia
2
University of Luxembourg, Luxembourg
3
European Physical Education Association, Luxembourg
4
Deporte para la Educacion y la Salud, Spain
5
University of Basel, Switzerland
e-mail: claude.scheuer@uni.lu
Abstract
This chapter presents a summary of findings of a series of reviews of the scientific literature on
the current evidence of the contributions of different school-based settings on the promotion of
health-enhancing physical activity. The objectives of this review are: to review evidence from the
last ten years of the contributions of school-based physical activity, physical education, and school
sport on the promotion of health-enhancing physical activity; and to consider the role of certain
transversal factors in supporting the promotion of health-enhancing physical activity. The settings
embrace: Physical Activity (Active Breaks; Active Learning; Active Recess; Active Transport;
Active Homework); Physical Education (Curriculum Physical Education Lessons; Teacher
Education/Workforce); and School Sport. Findings highlight the strong evidence for a positive
association of Active Breaks, Active Learning, Active Transport, Physical Education, and School
Sport with the promotion of school-based health-enhancing physical activity. These findings are
critically discussed in relation to the implemented educational policies.
Key words: Active schools, Physical activity, Physical education, School sport, Literature review
315
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
Schools are expected to fulfil many different roles and functions, but most would probably agree
that two ambitions are central: the development of students’ well-being, and the knowledge, skills,
attitudes, and values that are likely to encourage a happy and successful life (Kristjánsson, 2019).
Curriculum content has developed to support the constitutive elements of these ambitions, and
among them, physical education (PE), sport, and other forms of physical activity (PA) have been
recruited to play a role. Traditionally, however, these activities have held relatively low prestige,
often justified as a break from the real business of schooling, namely academic work (McNamee
& Bailey, 2009). This situation changed significantly in recent years as falling levels of PA have led
international agencies, such as WHO and UNESCO, as well as national governments and agencies,
to sound calls of alarm about rising incidents of non-communicable diseases, like Type 2 diabetes,
coronary heart diseases, and obesity.
Although regular PA is near-universally acknowledged to be an important part of children’s and
young people’s healthy functioning and well-being, there is compelling and alarming evidence that
large numbers of youth are inactive to the extent that they are compromising their well-being, both
now and in later life (Kohl, Craig, Lambert, et al, 2012). The trend toward sedentary lifestyles
across almost every developed country, and increasingly across the developing world is a source
of considerable concern (Hallal, Andersen, Bull, et al, 2012). The causes of this trend are complex,
but there is little doubt that an important factor is the compound effects of industrial, automotive
and information technology innovations, which have resulted in radical changes to how people
carry out their daily tasks. Modern societies tend to be WEIRD (Henrich, Heine, & Norenzayan,
2010): Western; Educated; Industrialised; Rich; Democratic. WEIRD societies have become
organised in ways that are incompatible with human’s evolved biology, and they are paying the
price. The effects of some of these developments, such as computers and trains, have a direct
impact on PA levels, whilst others, such as televisions, computers and electronic entertainment
have indirect and more ambiguous effects (Bailey, 2018). The emergence and ready availability of
new technologies has exaggerated these changes on physical labour and human energy expenditure.
The consequences of living in WEIRD societies can be considerable, including reduction to the
quality and length of lives, as well as considerable economic and health costs.
There have been other factors influencing the changing state and status of PA in schools. In some
countries, for example, the lure of sporting success has motivated increased investment. In others,
sporting activities have been promoted as vehicles for developing stronger social connectedness
(Hellison, 2011). However, there seems little doubt that the main international concern that has
driven discussions on children’s and young people’s PA promotion related to the health and
economic consequences of an “inactivity pandemic” (Kohl et al., 2012).
In this context, schools hold a unique role. Public health strategies require access to the largest
possible population, and schools are the only societal institutions in which a very large proportion
of youth can be reached. In addition, schools have an established role in communicating vital
316
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
messages, whilst connecting with an extended network of parents, families, and communities.
Schools also deal with people at an early stage, when their behaviours and values are still being
shaped (Aston, 2018). Compulsory schooling coincides with a window of opportunity for affecting
the knowledge, skills, attitudes, and values associated with PA. It makes sense, therefore, that their
remit to support students’ well-being will be expected to respond to the increasing alarm about
physical inactivity.
European engagement with coordinated, school-based health promotion can be traced to the
1980s, when the WHO, European Commission, and Council of Europe developed the concept of
the health-promoting school, based on the principles and strategies of the Ottawa Charter for
Health Promotion (WHO, 1986). Central to this initiative was the notion that schools serve as
effective settings to promote health and well-being of all people in the communities associated
with school life (Viig & Wold, 2005). This collaboration led to the establishment of the European
Network of Health Promoting Schools, partnership that continues to this day.
While specialist agencies have called on schools to create cultures of health where youth have
opportunities to engage in and learn about healthy lifestyles, implementing this culture in practice
has often proved a challenge for various reasons (Centeio, Barcelona, Kaszeta, & McCaughtry,
2018). Subsequent research suggests that whole-school, multi-component interventions are most
effective when key stakeholders are empowered to make the interventions sustainable (Langford,
et al, 2015). Many of the models of healthy schools build on the groundwork laid down by the
WHO’s Health Promoting School framework (2020), and its aim of “a whole-school approach,
and focuses on reorienting school systems toward health promotion through embedding health
and well-being in the curriculum, creating healthy social and physical environments and engaging
with parents and the wider community” (Bartelink, et al, 2019, p. 2). The US ‘Whole School, Whole
Community, Whole Child’ (WSCC) model is, perhaps, the most widely disseminated approach,
highlighting the dynamic relationship between intrapersonal, interpersonal, and community levels.
It highlights the importance of evidence-based school policies and practices, and explicitly
identifies 10 components of an effective school-based health-promotion strategy (including PE’s
response to the increasing alarm about inactivity and PA, Nutrition environment and services,
Social and emotional school climate, and Community involvement) (ASCD & CDC, 2014). These
components reiterate findings from other studies demonstrating the importance of the inclusion
of specific activities and practices that can act as focal points for leveraging the promotion of
healthy and active lifestyles in schools (Storey et al., 2016).
Healthy and Active Schools
There have been numerous models promoting healthy schools as hubs of health promotion, in
general, and PA, in particular (Daly-Smith et al., 2020; Webster & Nesbitt, 2017). Many of these
models build on the groundwork laid down by the WHO’s Health Promoting School framework
(2020), and its aim of “a whole-school approach, and focuses on reorienting school systems toward
health promotion through embedding health and well-being in the curriculum, creating healthy
317
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
social and physical environments and engaging with parents and the wider community” (Bartelink
et al., 2019, p. 2). The common theme of these developments is a claim that health promotion can
and should be delivered through a school-wide approach, in which different elements are
integrated into a synergistic whole. The model presented below highlights the multiple
opportunities for PA at or connected with school and thus the interconnectedness of an effective
Active School (Figure 1).
Figure 1 A model of PA opportunities at school (Scheuer & Bailey, 2021, p. 174)
School-related PA is generally fragmented and varies greatly between systems. PE has typically
been relied upon to provide PA and curricular instruction for students (Kohl & Cook, 2013).
However, doubts have been raised about whether PE alone is capable of providing enough PA to
fulfil guidelines (Scheuer, 2019). Even curricula that prioritise PE’s role in the promotion of PA
include a host of educational outcomes related to psychological, intellectual, and development, and
at least some of this curriculum content is likely to be well-suited to students seeking to maintain
moderate-to-vigorous PA (MVPA) levels. A problem with equating PE and PA is that, even if
teachers manage to create lessons in which all students are active during every lesson, total PA
accrued would not come close to reaching the hour-a-day target because daily PE is extremely rare.
Most educational systems allocate 90-120 minutes a week at primary and secondary levels, and
research shows that in less than half of PE lessons students reach MVPA. More importantly, there
is a major difference between promoting students’ PA and laying the foundations for lifelong PA.
By most accounts, lifelong PA is likely to occur when an individual acquires and practices a broad
range of knowledge, skills, attitudes, and values (Kohl & Murray, 2012), so (s)he is motivated to
make informed decisions about the multitude of PA opportunities available at each stage of the
life-course.
Probably the most important of these competences from the perspective of lifelong PA is the
development of mature motor skills (De Meester et al., 2018). These skills seem to be a necessary
condition of sustained PA, since they supply the competences to engage in PA in the first place.
318
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
Basic movement skills are precursors to more specialized and specialist skills that are prerequisite
for participation in the culture of human movement that connects with many aspects of daily life
(Herrmann et al., 2015). This is mainly the case as students’ progress from spontaneous PA play
to activities that dependent on rules, roles, and specialised skills (Donnelly, Mueller, & Gallahue,
2016).
Merely making students more active is a relatively simple matter. Schools could, for example, begin
each day with synchronised callisthenics, as some Asian schools do, or replace traditional desks
with standing desks (Daly-Smith et al., 2020), fit each desk with an exercise standing bicycle, so
students cycle during classroom lessons (Fedewa, Abel, & Erwin, 2017). Alternatively, schools
could initiate a Daily Mile, which was first introduced in Scotland, and is spreading across Europe.
The basic idea is that each day, during class time, pupils run or walk outside for 15 min (~1 mile)
at a self-selected pace (Chesham et al., 2018). Each of these strategies is likely to increase students’
daily PA levels, and perhaps they deserve consideration for that reason alone. However, the extent
to which they will act as a motivator of PA outside of school time, and act as the bases for sustained
PA in later life is unclear. It may be the case that substantially increasing levels of activity through
compulsory activities that do not cognitively engage individuals’ (as would happen during skill
learning and problem-solving tasks) risks some sort of compensation whereby voluntary PA during
free time is reduced (Ridgers, et al., 2018). An old proverb seems apposite here: Give someone a
fish, and they are fed for one day; teach that person to fish, and they are fed for the rest of their
life!
The concept of the Active School, therefore, is a radical departure from traditional approaches to
PA promotion. It seeks to reconcile the evident potential of the school as a unique setting for the
promotion of PA, with the barriers presented by conventional approaches.
In this approach, all of a school’s resources operate in a coordinated and dynamic manner to
provide access, encouragement, and programmes that enable all students to engage in vigorous PA
(VPA) or MVPA at least 60 minutes every day. A whole-of-school approach encompasses all
segments of the school day, including travel to and from school, school-sponsored before- and
after-school activities, recess and lunchtime breaks, PE, and classroom instructional time. Beyond
the resources devoted to quality PE for all students, other school resources, such as classroom
teachers, administrators, and aspects of the physical environment, are oriented toward PA. Extracurricular sport and other PA are made available to all who wish to participate, active transport is
used by substantial numbers of children to move from home to school and back again, recess and
other types of breaks offer additional opportunities for PA, and lesson plans integrate PA as an
experiential approach to teaching. Importantly, they are framed within contextual or socioecological perspectives that acknowledge the need for the engagement of all school stakeholders
(such as students, teachers, parents and the wider community) (Storey, et al, 2016). The support
of parents seems to be particularly important (Rivard, Deslandes & Collet, 2010).
319
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
A whole-school approach encompasses all people involved in the day-to-day functioning of the
school, including students, teachers, and parents. It creates an atmosphere in which PA is
appreciated and encouraged by all these groups. School buildings, outdoor grounds and
playgrounds, indoor and outdoor equipment, and streets and pathways leading to the school from
the surrounding neighbourhood encourage and enable all persons to be more physically active.
Moreover, the school is part of a larger system encompassing community partnerships.
The reviews reported here used a methodological framework based on rapid reviews, which follow
most of the protocols of the standard approaches, such as systematic reviewing, but with greater
flexibility and speed. The chapter is prefaced by discussions of the contemporary importance of
PA for children, young people and society. It also considers the relevance of schools as a setting
for the promotion of PA.
The objectives of this rapid literature review are the following: To review evidence from the last
ten years of the contributions of school-based PA, PE, and school sport on the promotion of PA;
To consider the role of certain transversal factors in supporting the promotion of health-enhancing
PA. The selected settings are PA (Active Breaks, Active Learning, Active Recess, Active Transport,
Active Homework), PE (Curriculum PE lessons, Teacher Education / Workforce) and School
sport. The transversal categories are: Inclusion and Diversity; Continuous Professional
Development; Facilities, Equipment and Resources; Community Partnerships; School Events,
Project Weeks, Camps. The meanings of these terms are explained as they arise in the text.
Methods
The following sections present a series of reviews of the scientific literature in support of the
objective of this study: “To review evidence from the last ten years of the contributions of schoolbased PA, PE, and school sport to the promotion of health-enhancing PA”. Evidence for these
reviews was gathered using a methodology called rapid reviewing, which is “a streamlined
approach to synthesizing evidence in a timely manner” (Khangura, Konnyu, Cushman, Grimshaw,
& Moher, 2012, p. 1). It follows many of the strategies used by more established approaches,
adapted for a faster and more variegated response. Systematic reviewing, generally accepted as the
‘gold standard’ of methods of summarising and analysing research findings (Munn, Stern,
Aromataris, Lockwood, & Jordan, 2018), requires a considerable amount of time and investment
in human resourcing, and narrowly focuses on a specific question, whereas rapid reviewing allows
quicker results and a more diverse coverage of subject-matter. For these reasons, the faster, more
flexible approach is often used by policymakers, decision makers, stakeholders and other
knowledge users. By adopting a rapid reviewing methodology, it was expected to realise some of
the virtues of systematic reviewing, without becoming overcome by its inherent restrictions.
Searches were undertaken through a range of specialist academic databases (PsycARTICLES,
PsycINFO, SPORTdiscus, CINAHL Complete), Google Scholar, as well as the academic social
320
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
networking sites (i.e., ResearchGate and Academia.edu). The following criteria were used to keep
searches focused:
• Published from 1st January 2010 to 30th May 2020;
• Study conducted in either primary or secondary schools;
• Study investigated PA outcomes either as the sole or substantial focus;
• Empirical study, systematic review, or conceptual discussion.
Initial searches were carried out in English, followed by German, French, Spanish and Czech
searches. A set of broad MeSH terms (Medical Subject Headings)1 was used to capture the most
current studies and reviews (e.g., “recess” AND “physical activity” AND “children”). Data on
each context of interest were extracted, and the findings were validated with reference to other
gathered data and published reviews. The reviews were limited by focusing on school-setting and
school-aged children and young people. Three main contexts and seven activity-settings in schools
are discussed in the following text:
• PA settings at school: Active Breaks; Active Homework; Active Learning; Active Recess;
and Active Transport.
• PE as a Setting: Curriculum PE Lessons; and Teacher Education & Workforce.
• Sport as a setting: School Sport.
The general approach followed an earlier set of PA reviews by Public Health England (Chalkley,
Milton, & Foster, 2015). As such, it involved a purposive search, integration and translation of
relevant literature related to contexts for Active Schools. Both reviews of literature and empirical
studies are included in this analysis. Once the different reviews had been completed, members of
the research team independently evaluated the weight of evidence related to the findings of each
activity setting. Discrepancies were discussed, and a consensus was agreed for each area. A simple
coding system was used to indicate the weight of evidence, presented in Table 1.
Table 1 Weight of evidence
Weight
evidence
Weak
Moderate
Strong
1
of Description
Outcomes where there was not enough evidence to make any statements
regarding potential associations with school-based PA.
Outcomes that did not have a strong evidence base; either because the evidence
came from a small number of studies, the studies were of poor quality, or the
evidence was equivocal (i.e., studies showed mixed/contradictory results).
Outcomes that reflected a body of research with strong or at least sufficient
evidence for a positive association with school-based PA.
https://www.nlm.nih.gov/mesh/meshhome.html
321
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Summary of findings
Active Breaks are relatively brief bouts of PA, usually led by a teacher during classroom lessons.
Evidence shows Active Breaks increase students’ PA levels, as well as contributing to healthier
weight status, improved behaviour, enhanced cognition and greater enjoyment. The number and
quality of studies in this area suggest that the evidence in favour of Active Breaks is STRONG.
Active Homework, in which students carry out PA-related practices after school, is a potentially
useful way of increasing PA. The small number of identified studies report positive outcomes from
Active Homework for both girls and boys, although effects tended to be relatively small across the
school week. Due to the small number of studies and limited methodologies used, the evidence
for Active Homework is rated as WEAK.
Active Learning refers to the strategy of integrating PA into classroom lessons, across the school
curriculum. The findings reported here demonstrate that Active Learning is a cost-effective,
enjoyable, motivating strategy to increase students’ daily PA at school without undermining other
educational goals. On the contrary, the available evidence suggests Active Learning often enhances
other educational outcomes. Assuming proactive leadership, teacher support, and teacher efficacy,
the case for Active Learning is STRONG.
Active Recess, promoting PA during the non-curricular time allocated by schools between lessons,
promises to add a significant amount of activity to all European schools. Effective Active Recess
strategies have been found to provide up to 40% of students recommended daily PA, with greater
benefits going to younger children and boys. There is a growing high-quality scientific literature
on Active Recess, although this research is of variable quality. There has been no European-level
evaluation of the concept. The evidence for Active Recess is rated as MODERATE.
Active Transport to and from school, such as walking or cycling, has been proposed as an
important source of daily PA. Research demonstrates that walking and cycling to and from school
are associated with increased MVPA, and Active Transport interventions are effective. Due to the
quality and number of the scientific papers informing this domain, Active Transport is judged to
be STRONG.
PE has a unique position in school-based PA promotion as the only protected, regular, supervised
setting for PA during the school day. Students are more active during PE lessons than in any other
context, but generally fail to reach a target of 50% of lessons at MVPA. Due to the relatively large
number of reviews and empirical studies in this area, publication quality, and consistency if
findings, PE is rated STRONG.
PE Teacher Education and Workforce training are vital elements in the implementation of effective
practice, and this may be especially the case when innovations are introduced. However, no directly
relevant reviews or empirical studies were identified to inform discussion of this topic, and the
only indirectly related article reported limited impact of professional training in health-enhancing
322
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
PA promotion. In light of the poor evidence base, Teacher Education and Workforce is rated
WEAK.
School Sport, especially after school, has been a popular setting of PA, despite cautious support
from policy-makers. The studies reviewed in this section suggest that sporting activities, both
competitive and non-competitive, can increase both MVPA and VPA, especially if played multiple
times during the week. However, attention needs to be paid to the needs of girls and
overweight/obese students, who are heightened risk of exclusion. There have been numerous
studies of the relationship between school sport, including some of high quality, and their findings
are relatively consistent, leading to the rating of STRONG.
Conclusion
By way of summary, a model is suggested that captures the evidence and issues discussed in this
review, and the relationships between them. The skeleton of the model is based on the framework
presented by the Healthy and Physically Active Schools (HEPAS) partnership, as well as published
research (e.g., Daly-Smith et al., 2020). While the different elements represent an excellent account
of the key aspects of activity-promoting schools, the list is not final. Details can be added or
removed as more evidence emerges, or a more clear or logical structure is proposed. This model
is merely suggested as a useful starting point for discussion.
There are four key parts of the model, with some parts containing constituent elements:
1. Policy Drivers: External influencers; and Internal Influencers.
2. Active School Settings: Active breaks; Active learning; Active recess; Active transport; Active
homework; Curriculum PE lessons; Teacher education / Workforce; and School sport.
3. Transversal Categories: Inclusion and diversity; Continuous professional development;
Facilities, equipment and resources; Community partnerships; School events, project weeks,
and camps.
4. School Context.
Each of these parts and elements can be discussed separately, but the real significance is as part of
a synergistic whole. This means that the relationships between the different parts and elements
might be as important as the parts and elements themselves. Since it was not a part of the remit of
the reviews, the relationships between the parts of the Active School concept have not been
discussed in detail. However, this would be a worthwhile activity as there is evidence that changing
practices are much more likely when there is a whole-school approach. And this requires shared
values and priorities, underpinned by on-going communication. And shared commitments can
become worthless unless they are promoted by relevantly trained teachers and other staff, take
place in appropriate facilities and spaces, and are ensured sufficient time in and out of the timetable.
Research into educational policy supports the idea that the whole of an effective initiative or
concept is greater than the sum of its parts (e.g., Jie, 2016). Studies of policy development have
shown that policy-makers, local government officials, school leaders, and teachers, are all affected
323
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
by the context within which they live and work. Context is shaped by political change or ideology,
by history and culture, and the process of policy-making—how issues get on to policy agendas,
and how they fare once there—is affected by stakeholders, their influence, values and expectations.
And, of course, the content of initiatives reflects some or all of these dimensions. Therefore, while
the suggested model might be useful for helping us to systematically think about all the different
factors that might affect Active Schools, it is a map that shows the broad themes until further
detail is added.
‘Policy drivers’ are the aims, targets or statements that are considered to be desirable by the various
stakeholders for schools. Many of these drivers are external to the school, but their expectations
shape the day-to-day activities of teachers and students. For example, all European countries have
some sort of national framework for education, and this sets statutory requirements for all schools.
Some countries have a national curriculum that articulates detailed schemes of work, and because
they are legally binding, they carry great weight among school administrators and leaders. Some
external influences carry no legal power, but the wide-scale acceptance of the guidance means that
they have a “soft law”. An example of this is the guidance of the WHO, and its recommendation
that every child and young person be physically active for at least one hour a day. School leaders
and teachers have to struggle to meet this wide range of expectations and usually end up prioritising
some over others. So, some school curricular areas are generally considered to have a higher status
than others, and unfortunately, PE has traditionally been a low-status subject even when it is
technically equal to other subjects. This privileging of some subject areas over others reflects a
range of forces, both external and internal to the school, such as history, tradition and culture,
assessment regimes, national and local politics, and personal interests and backgrounds. There is
no doubt that influences from within the school play a significant role in shaping and managing
the different expectations presented to them. Principles/headteachers are particularly influential
in forming the values and goals of the school, and are the primary factors in determining what
takes place within the school, how, and why.
References
ASCD (Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development) & CDC (Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention) (2014). Whole School, Whole Community, Whole Child. Retrieved online
from: http://www.ascd.org/ASCD/pdf/siteASCD/publications/wholechild/ wscc-acollaborative-approach.pdf
Aston, R. (2018). Physical health and well-being in children and youth. OECD Education Working
Papers. Paris: OECD Publishing.
Bailey, R. P. (2018). Physical Education 2030. Paris, FR: OECD Publishing.
Bartelink, N., Van Assema, P., Jansen, M., Savelberg, H., Moore, G. F., Hawkins, J., & Kremers,
S. (2019). Process evaluation of the healthy primary school of the future. BMC Public Health,
19(1), 698.
324
Best Practices
__________________________________________________________________________________
Centeio, E. E., Barcelona, J., Kaszeta, K., & McCaughtry, N. (2018). Building healthy communities.
Journal of Youth Development, 13(3), 176-190.
Chalkley, A., Milton, K. & Foster, C. (2015). Change4Life Evidence Review. London: Public Health
England.
Chesham, R. A., Booth, J. N., Sweeney, E. L., Ryde, G. C., Gorely, T., Brooks, N. E., & Moran,
C. N. (2018). The Daily Mile makes primary school children more active, less sedentary and
improves their fitness and body composition. BMC Medicine, 16(1), 1-13.
Daly-Smith, A.J., Quarmby, T., Archbold, V. S., Corrigan, N., Wilson, D., Resaland, G. K., ... &
Chalkley, A. (2020). Using a multi-stakeholder experience-based design process to codevelop the Creating Active Schools Framework. International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition
and Physical Activity, 17(1), 13.
De Meester, A., Stodden, D., Goodway, J., True, L., Brian, A., Ferkel, R., & Haerens, L. (2018).
Identifying a motor proficiency barrier for meeting physical activity guidelines in children.
Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport, 21(1), 58-62.
Donnelly, F. C., Mueller, S. S., & Gallahue, D. L. (2016). Developmental physical education for all children.
Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics.
Fedewa, A. L., Abel, M., & Erwin, H. E. (2017). The effects of using stationary bicycle desks in
classrooms on adolescents’ physical activity. Journal of Occupational Therapy, Schools, & Early
Intervention, 10(1), 78-89.
Hallal, P. C., Andersen, L. B., Bull, F. C., Guthold, R., Haskell, W., Ekelund, U., & Lancet Physical
Activity Series Working Group (2012). Global physical activity levels. The Lancet, 380(9838),
247-257.
Hellison, D. R. (2011). Teaching personal and social responsibility through physical activity. Champaign, IL:
Human Kinetics.
Henrich, J., Heine, S. J., & Norenzayan, A. (2010). The weirdest people in the world? Behavioral and
Brain Sciences, 33(2-3), 61-135.
Herrmann, C., Bund, A., Gerlach, E., Kurz, D., Lindemann, U., Rethorst, S., … & Pühse, U.
(2015). A review of the assessment of basic motor qualifications and competencies in school.
International Journal of Physical Education, 52(3), 2-13.
Jie, N. D. (2016). Towards a Framework of Education Policy Analysis. Singapore: Head Foundation.
Khangura, S., Konnyu, K., Cushman, R., Grimshaw, J., & Moher, D. (2012). Evidence summaries.
Systematic Reviews, 1, 1.
Kohl, H. W., & Cook, H. D. (Eds.) (2013). Educating the student body. Washington, DC: National
Academies Press.
Kohl, H. W., Craig, C. L., Lambert, E. V., Inoue, S., Alkandari, J. R., Leetongin, G., ... & Lancet
Physical Activity Series Working Group. (2012). The pandemic of physical inactivity. The
Lancet, 380(9838), 294-305.
Kohl, H. W., & Murray, T. (2012). Foundations of Physical Activity and Public Health. Champaign, IL:
Human Kinetics.
Kristjánsson, K. (2019). Flourishing as the aim of education. London: Routledge.
325
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Langford, R., Bonell, C., Jones, H., Pouliou, T., Murphy, S., Waters, E. … Campbell, R. (2015).
The World Health Organization’s Health Promoting Schools framework. BMC Public Health
15, 130.
McNamee, M. & Bailey, R. P. (2009). Physical Education. In R. P. Bailey, R. Barrow, D. Carr, &
C. McCarthy (Eds.), SAGE Handbook of the Philosophy of Education (pp. 467-480). London:
Sage.
Munn, Z., Stern, C., Aromataris, E., Lockwood, C., & Jordan, Z. (2018). What kind of systematic
review should I conduct? BMC Medical Research Methodology, 18, 5.
Ridgers, N. D., Barnett, L. M., Lubans, D. R., Timperio, A., Cerin, E., & Salmon, J. (2018).
Potential moderators of day-to-day variability in children’s physical activity patterns. Journal
of Sports Sciences, 36(6), 637-644.
Rivard, M. C., Deslandes, R., & Collet, M. (2010). L’approche école en santé au primaire. Revue des
Sciences de l’Education, 36(3), 761-785.
Scheuer, C. (2019). The challenge of HEPA for physical education in Europe. In C. Scheuer & D.
Dreiskämper (Eds.), Schola Ludens Europaea (pp. 139-150). Maidenhead: Meyer & Meyer
Sport.
Scheuer, C., & Bailey, R. P. (2021). The Active School Concept. In R. Bailey, J. Agans, J. Côté &
P. Tomporowski (Eds.), Sport and Physical Activity during the First Ten Years (pp. 173-187).
London, UK: Routledge.
Storey, K. E., Montemurro, G., Flynn, J., Schwartz, M., Wright, E., Osler, J., ... & Roberts, E.
(2016). Essential conditions for the implementation of comprehensive school health to
achieve changes in school culture and improvements in health behaviours of students. BMC
Public Health, 16(1), 1133.
Viig, N. G., & Wold, B. (2005). Facilitating teachers' participation in school-based health
promotion. Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research, 49(1), 83-109.
Webster, C. A., & Nesbitt, D. (2017). Expanded roles of physical education teachers within a
CSPAP and implications for PETE. Journal of Physical Education, Recreation & Dance, 88(3), 2228.
WHO (World Health Organization) (1986). The Ottawa Charter for Health Promotion. Ottawa: WHO
Regional Office.
WHO (World Health Organization) (2020). Healthy Promoting School. Retrieved online from
https://www.who.int/school_youth_health/gshi/hps/en/
326
Best Practices
___________________________________________________________________________
The Use of Speed Agility Training Aids for Developing Physical
Fitness
Candrawati Ibrahim1,2 - Garry Kuan1 - Chin Ngien Siong3 - Ismail Dikoh2 Nurlyn Syifaa’ Jacklyna Aban4 - Muhd. Dzulfikrie Hipni5 –
Ratna Kertinie Hipni6 - Malisa Haziqah Mohammad Haffizie7
1
2
School of Health Sciences, Universiti Sains Malaysia, Kubang Kerian, Kelantan, Malaysia
Institute of Teacher Education Tun Abdul Razak Campus, Kota Samarahan, Sarawak, Malaysia
3
Institute of Teacher Education Batu Lintang Campus, Kuching, Sarawak, Malaysia
4
SK (A) Ibnu Khaldun, Kota Samarahan, Sarawak, Malaysia
5
Malaysia LNG (Liquefied Natural Gas), Petronas LNG Complex, Bintulu, Sarawak
Universiti Malaysia Sarawak, Kota Samarahan, Sarawak, Malaysia
7
SMK Petra Jaya, Kuching, Sarawak, Malaysia
e-mail: candrawati@student.usm.my
Abstract
Sports organizations or schools should constantly update and generate new innovative ideas in
order to develop physical fitness among students and athletes. In other words, innovation impacts
and helps to the improvement of physical fitness. To date, innovations related to physical fitness
have received little scientific attention. As this study will demonstrate, innovations in physical
fitness are important for increasing speed and agility and consequently improving sports
performance among students and athletes. In addition, by using the latest innovation will also
motivate them to continue to practice actively in sports. Physical fitness leads to better athletic
performance, and consistent training is usually sufficient to improve physical fitness. To succeed
in sports, athletes need to excel in physical fitness as well as speed and agility on the court or field.
Players need quickness and agility to react and get the badminton or ball. The purpose of this study
is to develop a physical fitness innovation tool set known as "Speed Agility Training Aids"
(SATAS) that builds on the development of Revolution 4.0 by adding more variations and
innovations to training to build maximum physical fitness. As a result, sports science must pay
special attention on SATAS, which is an innovative tool that can help for enhancing physical
fitness performance.
Key words: Physical fitness, Innovation, Speed, Agility, Techniques
327
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
Physical fitness is one of the most crucial conditions for good health. Physical fitness is defined
as a person's capacity to meet the ordinary and unusual needs of daily living without becoming
weary, while yet having energy left over for leisure and recreational activities. This fitness refers
to your body's ability to collaborate properly in order for you to be healthy and do daily tasks.
Being efficient includes carrying out daily tasks with the least amount of effort possible. Physical
fitness can also benefit patients who already have cardiovascular disease (Warburton, 2006). It also
promotes health and well-being, helps to avoid a variety of health problems, reduces the risk of
certain diseases such as high blood pressure, diabetes, cancer, and others, and improves general
quality of life (Owen et al., 2010; Lavie et al., 2019; Jiménez-Pavón et al., 2019). Total and
cardiovascular mortality have been linked to physical fitness (Blair et al., 1996; Meyers et al., 2002),
and even small gains in fitness may result in lower mortality (Erikssen et al., 1998).
Physical fitness also lowers the likelihood of stress, tension, and depression while also helping you
feel better. We can't see somebody being healthy if they aren't physically fit. As a consequence,
physical fitness but the whole of must be valued. The common perception of physical fitness is
the absence of illness. Chronic diseases are major causes of death in the modern era. A lack of
physical activity is the root cause of the majority of chronic diseases (Terjung et al., 2018). The
lack of any obvious sickness, such as depression or anxiety, is characterised as an individual's
physical fitness. Physical activity, according to Schuch (2018), has the ability to protect against
depression.
Sports require a high level of physical fitness.The first step for a great athlete who wants to
accomplish fantastic performances and reach the summit of world sports fitness is to develop a
solid foundation in physical fitness. Physical fitness is an important aspect that influences
movement level progress (Schuch, 2018). Physical fitness is divided into various component
categories that change on a regular basis. Athletes can be trained in these areas of physical fitness
to improve specific skills or performance in sports. Building on specific components can lead to
potential fitness, mental health, and lifestyle goals.
Physical fitness can be classified into two categories namely health-related fitness and skills-related
fitness. The health-related components are cardiovascular fitness, muscular strength, muscular
endurance, body composition and flexibility. While agility, speed, power, balance, coordination,
and reaction time are the six components of skill-related fitness. These skill-related components
are movements that an individual must perform in ability to successfully demonstrate a variety of
motor skills and movement patterns. Sports necessarily require a high level of physical fitness.
Athletes or students who really are physically fit cannot only increase their speed and agility, but
also reduce the effects of incidents and deaths caused by movement (B. Xu, 2015).
328
Best Practices
___________________________________________________________________________
Speed and Agility
The training focuses on agility elements while also improving physical fitness components based
on motor behaviour such as speed, power, reaction time, coordination, and balance (Kraemer et
al., 2001; Mackenzie, 2000). Speed is an important fitness component in many sports. Speed is
defined as the capacity to move fast. Speed is defined as the distance travelled in the smallest
amount of time. Athletes who concentrate on their foot speed can sprint rapidly, whereas athletes
who concentrate on their hand speed can throw or strike the ball quickly. Speed training is a set
of progressive exercises and teaching aimed at improving fundamental motor abilities and
increasing an athlete's ability to operate at faster speeds and with greater precision (Azmi et al.,
2018).
Speed is divided into two, namely general and specific speed. General speed is the ability to
perform any movement (motor reaction) with speed, usually over a short distance of 5–10 meters,
while specific speed is the ability to perform certain movements at a specified time. Athletes with
the ability to outpace their opponents have an advantage. A speedier athlete, for example, may be
able to get to the ball faster than a rival or even outrun a pursuer. If a player has good speed, the
athlete will move across the court quickly and be able to control the court well (Chen, 2014).
Agility is defined as the capacity to quickly alter body position, stop and start movements, and
control and direct whole-body movement. Verstegen et al. (2001) define agility as a physical talent
in which players can slow down, reverse direction, or accelerate in response to a task-relevant cue
such as an opponent or a teammate's pass. Agility, according to Sheppard et al. (2006), is a quick
whole-body movement with a change in velocity or direction in response to a stimulus. Agility
necessitates a high level of movement speed in order to confuse or escape the opponent. It is the
foundation of motor behaviour that emphasizes high performance in sports.
Agility is one of the most significant components that should be developed and frequently
employed in team sports athletes' strength and conditioning programmes (Paul et al., 2016; Wisloff
et al., 2004). Agility, according to Frederick (2014), is a valuable talent in a variety of field sports.
Consider sports that necessitate agility. In team sports such as football, basketball, hockey,
volleyball, and rugby, players must react swiftly to their colleagues' and the ball's movement
patterns. According to Krolo et al. (2020) stated that reactive agility and change of direction speed
are important determinants of success in football. Training factors have a significant impact on a
person's dexterity. Because each sport necessitates a different level of agility, training for agility
formation can be tailored to the specifics of the game or activity. Every coach must be
knowledgeable about proper training techniques for assisting athletes in improving their agility and
motivating athletes (Nazarudin, Waridi, & Saad, 2017). Epley (2004), also stated that any coach
needs an effective training approach to help players improve their agility and motivation. The
training emphasizes agility while also improving physical fitness components based on motor
behavior.
329
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Speed Agility Training Aids Set (SATAS)
The application of scientific knowledge study findings in the process of training players may bring
more ease. The advancement of technology, particularly in sport, is an unavoidable component
of improving an athlete's achievement performance in the twenty-first century (Jian-she, 2018).
Technology advancements have also offered specialised groups with the opportunity to simply
provide solutions to ensure that young athletes' performance continues to improve in order to
make Malaysia famous all over the world. The introduction of innovative physical fitness training
tools acknowledges the use of creative ways for sports skill training in order to increase
performance and discovered that physical fitness and sports training can be completed more
swiftly and efficiently. Sport governing organisations, universities, research institutes, and
enterprises, according to Marinho et al. (2018), should be encouraged and coordinated to spend
more effort to studies, development strategies, and policies for technological innovations that
benefit both students and athletes.
The main issue with developing this innovation is a lack of up-to-date tools and methods for
training athletes in Malaysia. The majority of them continue to use traditional methods to train
young athletes at the school. Most physical education teachers or coaches only employ traditional
training methods. Coaches of badminton players, for example, only show the directions to players
with badminton rackets and without additional tools. The player will move in the direction
indicated by the coach, but the player will not be heading in the proper area or in the direction
desired by the coach due to the lack of a tracking device. Furthermore, there are no training aids
that make it easier for coaches to monitor or record player performance.
The Fourth Industrial Revolution (4IR) is a term used to describe the blurring of the physical,
digital, and biological worlds. It is the result of advancements in artificial intelligence (AI), robotics,
the Internet of Things (IoT), 3D printing, genetic engineering, quantum computing, and other
technologies. The skills of the Fourth Industrial Revolution (4IR) were applied to the Speed Agility
Training Aids Set (SATAS) (Figure 1). The researcher expressed innovative thinking, original
ideas, problem-solving skills, ideation, analysis, critical analysis, and interpersonal skills. These are
some of the most critical 4IR-driven areas of expertise required to be successful in the evolving
sport industry work environment.
Figure 1 Speed Agility Training Aids Set (SATAS)
330
Best Practices
___________________________________________________________________________
The innovation of the Speed Agility Training Aids Set (Figure 1) makes it possible athletes to train
on their own without the guidance of a teacher or coach in the training grounds due to it being
portable and simple to use. Those who also can enhance their own speed and agility using the
laptops and sensors built into the boards. Athletes will be able to accelerate by touching the sound
sensor on the board. When the sensor detects a sound, it sends a number count to a computer
for recording via the UNO output. Besides that, the use of SATAS can increase athletes'
motivation to train harder. It can calculate the number of targets that an athlete can complete in
a given period of time (Timer). Teachers and coaches can monitor the performance of their
athletes by observing the results on the laptop. Teachers' and coaches' effectiveness and savings
in time could be enhanced, and athletes can keep a record of one ‘s record keeping in the laptop
for reference in the future.
This innovation, which uses high-quality sensors to detect sound, can improve an athlete's ability
to change direction and run quickly toward the right target in a set period of time. SATAS
Iimplementation procedures are shown in Figure 2. In the front of touch board 1 (Figure 3), the
athlete takes a ready position. The game begins with a buzzer (Figure 4) and a timer (which also
will countdown timer) (Figure 5). The athlete run to the touch board 2 direction (Figure 6). The
presence of both the player is detected by 2 ultrasonic sensors. Sprint from one touch board to
the other and back. That is 1 repetition. Sensors (Figure 7) placed just on board that detect player
movement would then indicate an entry into the Arduino UNO R3 Advance Beginner Learning
Sensor Starter Kit V5 (Figure 8) . An adding functional to The UNO board (Figure 9) board is
provided by a sensor can detect the player's touch on the board. The exit signal from the UNO
board (Figure 8) will be sent to Display 1 to add a value of COUNT (Figure 9) depending on how
often the sensor detects the player's touch on the board. After the timer runs out (Figure 5) and
the Buzzer sounds (Figure 4), the final Count value will be displayed (Figure 5).
Figure 2 SATAS Flow Chart
331
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Figure 3 Touch board 1
Figure 4 Buzzer
Figure 5 Laptop
332
Best Practices
___________________________________________________________________________
Figure 6: Touch board 2
Figure 7 Ultrasonic Sensor
Figure 8 Arduino UNO R3
333
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Figure 9 Numeric Display
Discussion
Sports innovation is a new topic for researchers that combines sport and different types of
experiences and practises. Technological innovations, tools, and equipment, as well as innovative
methods and coaching, consumer products and services, digital content and venues, are all
examples of sport innovations. Sport innovation research is still constrained by social, institutional,
and organisational constraints. These perspectives on the innovative phenomena should be
addressed in the future of research on sports innovations. While emerging innovations, sport
equipment, and product lines are important and contribute to the advancement of modern sport,
research on topics such as sport innovation issues and challenges, social innovations in sport, and
efficient management and leadership of sport innovation will be required.
This Speed Agility Training Aids Set (SATAS) is based on the characteristics of badminton and is
specifically designed to see how well a player's body can navigate in a sideways, forward, and
backward motion. Athletes or students, who use the SATAS can improve their physical fitness.
Their physical fitness was shown to be significantly improved by using this special innovation
training aids set. Furthermore, the SATAS adds variety, excitement, and pleasure to the coaching
and learning process, and it exhilarates the knowledge of sports concepts. It is also relevant to all
sports.
Conclusion
Speed is determined not only by how fast an individual can run (or cycle, swim, etc.) but also by
their own velocity (how quickly they can accelerate from a static position), maximum possible
speed of movement, and speed maintenance (minimizing deceleration). Speed necessitates good
strength and power, but excess body weight and air resistance can also stymie performance.
SATAS is designed to make training more engaging and manageable in the absence of a coach.
SATAS is also expected to increase players' interest in and motivation to practise speed and agility.
SATAS has revolutionised existing traditional speed and agility training tools, in line with the
modern 4.0 industrial revolution.
334
Best Practices
___________________________________________________________________________
Bibliography
Azmi, K; Kusnanik, N W (2018). Effect of Exercise Program Speed, Agility, and Quickness (SAQ) in
Improving Speed, Agility, and Acceleration. Journal of Physics: Conference Series, 947(), 012043–.
doi:10.1088/1742-6596/947/1/012043.
Blair SN, Kampert JB, Kohl III HW, Barlow CE, Macera CA, Paffenbarger RS, et al. Influences
of cardiorespiratory fitness and other precursors oncardiovascular disease and all-cause
mortality in men and women. JAMA 1996; 276:205–210.
Chen, C. (2014). Footwork Teaching of College Badminton Elective Course: Liuzhou Railway
Vocational Technical College, Liuzhao, China
Epley, B. (2004). Anaerobic, speed and agility training. The path to athletic power, the model conditioning
programme for championship performance. Human Kinetics. pp. 265 - 296.
Erikssen G, Liesto ̈ l K, Bjo ̈ rnholt J, Thaulow E, Sandvik L, Erikssen J.Changes in physical fitness
and changes in mortality. Lancet 1998;352:759–762.
Frederick M. F. A. (2014). Badminton: Specific Movement Agility Testing System (Malaysia:
Movement, Health & Exercise)
Jian-she, L. (2018). Progresses of the Badminton equipment relate to exercise: Some training
aspects. Journal of Sports Medicine and Therapy, (November), 001–
009. doi:10.29328/journal.jsmt.1001020.
Jiménez-Pavón, D., Carbonell-Baeza, A., and Lavie, C. J. (2020). Physical exercise as therapy to
fight against the mental and physical consequences of COVID-19 quarantine: special focus
in older people. ProgCardiovasc. Dis. 24, 386–388. doi: 10.1016/j.pcad.2020.03.009.
Kraemer, W. J., & Gomez, A. L. (2001). Effect of resistance training on women’s strength, power
and occupational performances. Journal of Medicine Science Sports Exercise, 33, 1011-1025.
Krolo, A., Gilic, B., Foretic, N., Pojskic, H., Hammami, R., Spasic, M., Uljevic, O., Versic, S.,
Sekulic, D. (2020). Agility testing in youth football (soccer) players: Evaluating reliability,
validity, and correlates of newly developed testing protocols. Int J Environ Res Public Health.
17(1), 294. doi: 10.3390/ijerph17010294.
Lavie, C. J., Ozemek, C., Carbone, S., Katzmarzyk, P. T., and Blair, S. N. (2019). Sedentary
Behavior, Exercise, and Cardiovascular Health. Circ. Res. 124, 799–815. doi:
10.1161/CIRCRESAHA.118.312669.
Mackenzie, B., (2000). Lateral change of direction test. Retrieved from
http://www.brianmac.co.uk/latchang.htm.
Marinho, Daniel Almeida; Neiva, Henrique Pereira (2018). The Use of Technology in Sport - Emerging
Challenges || Innovative Technology for High Performance and Mass Participation Sport.,
10.5772/intechopen.73269(Chapter 2), –. doi:10.5772/intechopen.79415.
Meyers J, Prakash M, Froelicher V, Do D, Partington S, Atwood JE. Exercise capacity and
mortality among men referred for exercise testing. N Engl J Med 2002; 346:793–801.
Nazarudin, M. N., Waridi, N., & Saad, I. (2017). Kesan latihan ketangkasan reaktif ke atas
peningkatan komponen kecergasan berasaskan lakuan motor dalam kalangan pemain
Ragbi (Novis). International Journal of Education, Psychology and Counseling, 2(4), 56-70.
335
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Owen, N., Sparling, P. B., Healy, G. N., Dunstan, D. W., and Matthews, C. E. (2010). Sedentary
behavior: emerging evidence for a new health risk. Mayo Clin. Proc. 85, 1138–1141. doi:
10.4065/mcp.2010.0444.
Paul, DJ, Gabbett, TJ, and Nassis, GP. Agility in team Sports:Testing, training and factors
affecting performance. Sports Med 46:421–442, 2016.
Schuch, Felipe B.; Vancampfort, Davy; Firth, Joseph; Rosenbaum, Simon; Ward, Phillip B.; Silva,
Edson S.; Hallgren, Mats; Ponce De Leon, Antonio; Dunn, Andrea L.; Deslandes, Andrea
C.; Fleck, Marcelo P.; Carvalho, Andre F.; Stubbs, Brendon (2018). Physical Activity and
Incident Depression: A Meta-Analysis of Prospective Cohort Studies. American Journal of Psychiatry, (),
appi.ajp.2018.1–. doi:10.1176/appi.ajp.2018.17111194.
Sheppard, J. M., Young, W. B., Doyle, T. L., Sheppard, T.A., & Newton, R. U. (2006). An
evaluation of a new testof reactive agility and its relationship to sprint speed andchange of
direction speed. Journal of Science and Medicinein Sport, 9, 342–349.
Terjung, Ronald (2011). Comprehensive Physiology || Lack of Exercise Is a Major Cause of Chronic
Diseases. , (), –. doi:10.1002/cphy.c110025.
Verstegen, M., & Marsello, B.; Agility and coordination. In B. Foran (Ed.), High performance
sports conditioning. Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics: 139-165, 2001.
Warburton, D. E.R. (2006). Health benefits of physical activity: the evidence. Canadian Medical Association
Journal, 174(6), 801–809. doi:10.1503/cmaj.05135.1.
Wisloff, U, Castagna, C, Helgerud, J, Jones, R, and Hoff, J. Strong correlation of maximal squat
strength with sprint performance and vertical jump height in elite soccer players. Br J Sports
Med 38: 285–288, 2004.
Xu, B. (2015). How to improve the athletes' physical fitness," Proc. 2nd Int. Conf. Civil, Mater.
Environ. Sci., vol. 11, no. Cmes, pp. 282–285. doi: 10.2991/cmes-15.2015.78.
336
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Situation
337
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
338
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Exploring the Efficacy of an International Immersion Program
towards Building Cultural Competence for Health and Physical
Education Teachers: Australia and Samoa
Matthew Winslade1 - Lana McCarthy1 - Suzie Schuster2
1
Charles sturt University, Australia
National University of Samoa. Samoa
e-mail:
2
Abstract
This situation-based chapter will explore the notion of international immersion programs within
Health and Physical Education Teacher Education (H)PETE) aimed at addressing multiple
international stake holder driven outcomes. Focusing firstly on an Australian regional based
university, this chapter will examine the contributing factors behind the adoption of an immersion
program (known as the Samoa Sports Outreach Program, SSOP) as a way to develop increased
levels of cultural competency, unpacking the perceived benefits of utilising such an approach. The
chapter will also consider what is required for sustainable continuation of such immersion
programs in the future including the exploration of the need to develop authentic partnerships not
only benefit the Australian participants but also provide meaning and benefits for the host nation.
To help understand the impact of a program such as the SSOP the chapter will draw on the work
of Health and Physical Education (HPE) academics from Samoa, to provide an increased
understanding of the regional issues impacting the population of the Island nation justifying the
choice of Samoa to base such an immersion program. The chapter will then look to the future to
present some potential HPE theoretical models and a specific target population group based on
the presented situational analysis (increased female participation) that could be adopted to support
future programs cognisant of the needs of both the Australian and Samoan stakeholders.
Key words: Cultural competence, Physical education, Partnerships International immersion,
Teacher training
339
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
There has been an identified need for graduating teachers in Australia to demonstrate a range of
professional competencies including an increased focus on cultural understanding and inclusion.
This need has impacts on such discipline Key Learning Areas (KLA) as Physical Education (PE),
which is referred to as Health and Physical Education (HPE) at an Australian national level. Whilst
there is no one-agreed way to integrate this need into the training curriculum of pre-service HPE
teachers, immersion programs have been identified as one possible way to address the issue. This
chapter will unpack why the notion of cultural competence is important in the Australian context
and also how this has been integrated into the graduate teaching standards that Australian preservice teachers are expected to demonstrate as they exit their teacher training. It will also provide
an explanation to align the need for cultural competence in teachers within the discipline area of
Health and Physical Education (HPE) and explore how an international cultural immersion
program has been shown to be effective in helping to develop that competency. Importantly, the
chapter will also unpack the need for authentic partnerships to be established that have the capacity
to support both the development of cultural competency of Australian HPE students participating
in the program and provide benefit for schools and academic staff in the host country. Finally, the
chapter will explore why Samoa is an appropriate site as a setting for such an immersion program.
Questions guiding this chapter include:
1.
2.
3.
4.
Why is the development of Cultural Competence important in countries such as Australia –
particularly for Health and Physical Educators?
How might international experiences help to support development of Cultural Competence
in Health and Physical Educators?
How can universities better partner with host countries to develop mutually beneficial
outcomes through international partnership programs?
Can such partnerships strategically align with significant world and regional issues (such as
obesity and diabetes, female participation) that may be present in the host country leading
to more meaningful and sustainable impact on physical activity?
The need for cultural competence in Teacher Education (Graduate standards)
In countries such as Australia there has been an increased focus for graduate teachers to not only
have knowledge of but be able to demonstrate their understanding of the impact of culture and
cultural identity on the educational outcomes of their students (AITSL, 2012). As such, cultural
competence has become an integral component of exit requirements for all Pre-Service teachers
(PSTs) as represented in the graduate professional standards. For Australian Health and Physical
Education (HPE) teacher education students, there is a balance throughout their training of PE
with a clear focus on increasing student participation and Health education inclusive of the impacts
of cultural influences on the participation of young people in physical activity. It is therefore
important for universities to consider ways to bring these elements together that not only increases
340
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
student understanding, but provides genuine opportunities to demonstrate that understanding and
international immersion programs have been shown as one way to provide that opportunity to
Australian students (Maakrun, 2020; Roose, 2001)
Culture and links to Health and Physical Education
Exploring syllabus documentation aligned with the curriculum area of HPE in Australia, with
reference to a New South Wales (NSW) perspective where the CSU university campus is located,
provides significant support and context as to why a dedicated cultural competence platform is
important to embed within teacher training courses. The term ‘Culture’ is referred to over 120
times in the NSW 7-10 HPE syllabus and as such, carries a significant weighting in the document
and consequently in the development, of effective HPE teachers. However, there are limited
opportunities for students to authentically engage in situations to support building of this capacity
across the structure of many HPE pre-service teacher training programs, whereas immersion
programs provide that opportunity (Winslade, 2016). Exit requirements for all Australian teacher
education students are aligned with Graduate Level Teacher Professional Standards (AITSL, 2019)
and since 2011 the notion of cultural competency has been woven into those standards. The
proposed program aligned to this study presents an authentic opportunity for students to
demonstrate their understanding through practice (Perso, 2012) and is designed to challenge
students to explore their values and belief systems in order to effectively plan and deliver learning
experiences that meet the needs of others.
The value of international immersion as a way to build Cultural Competence.
Cultural immersion supported through platforms such as international programs, has been
identified as one way to engage preservice teachers with the process of building cultural
competence (Lee, 2011, Suttichujit, 2009; Ryan, 2010; Walters et al., 2009). Whilst it is not without
its challenges and criticism (Karaman & Tochron, 2010), the notion of cultural immersion has
been shown to be an effective way to engage pre-service teachers into a reflective program
designed to challenge their existing values/beliefs and increase their frame of cultural reference.
Webber (2005), proffers that the impact of an immersion is the opportunity to learn through
experience in order to work effectively with other cultural groups and to reconstruct an individual’s
understanding of the notion of culture. Further, Hart and Moore (2005) argue that through
immersion the opportunity exists to challenge student’s established understandings about culture
and identity and in doing so, enhance more inclusive alternatives into their practice. This is
underpinned by the notion of viewing the profession from a different lens or perspective to what
they would experience in a placement situated in an environment more reflective of the dominant
cultural norms experienced in the student teacher’s everyday life (Smolcic & Katunich, 2017). An
immersion experience requires the student to step outside of their own cultural norms and values
and requires the student to experience conditions such as ‘culture shock’ and engage in critical
reflection in order to design and develop learning experiences reflective of the needs of the
community and the students they are working with (Jones & Bond, 2019). In Australia, it has been
341
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
suggested that teaching as a profession tends to draw from limited cultural diversity and as such is
often at risk of reinforcing dominant cultural stereotypes aligned with perceived middleclass
cultural capital (Koh et al., 2020). This is further reinforced in specific discipline areas such as HPE
where according to Spittle et al., (2012), argue there is a stereotypical image of the dominant
representation of physical educators as fit, masculine, male, Caucasian, physically aggressive, and
that this stereotyping has helped traditionally shaped both the dominant culture in regard to
teacher training and student/teacher demographic profile. However, Spittle et al., (2012) also
proffer that there has been considerable thought in regard to the self-perception of physical
educators and a growing social consciousness which is challenging those stereotypical perceptions
in the discipline. Therefore, the addition of immersion programs such as the SSOP provide a
perfect opportunity for pre-service PE teachers to step outside of their own established values and
beliefs systems supported through scaffolded reflection, to realign their self-perception of the role
and nature of a Physical Educator.
Universities Australia (2011) apply an appropriate theoretical lens on the concept of cultural
competence emphasis a focus on the knowledge, skills, values, and attributes of the professional
reinforcing that competencies can be considered a measurable capability demonstrated through
performance and behaviours displayed in the work setting. Further, Universities Australia
(referring back to the seminal definition of cultural competence by Cross et al., (1989) argue that
in relation to a professional context there are a number of what they refer to as key elements
(aligned with knowledge, skills, and values as a way to quantify understanding) that impact on the
perceived effectiveness of increasing cultural competence and understanding, these include:
• Knowledge of other cultures
• Individuals’ personal qualities such as openness, flexibility, tolerance of ambiguity and sense
of humour
• Behavioural skills - communication competencies, culturally appropriate role behaviours and
ability to relate to the others
• Self-awareness - particularly with respect to their own values and beliefs
• Technical skills - including the ability to complete a task in a new cultural setting (Universities
Australia, 2011, P.43)
It is also important to consider for many Australian students, particularly in regional locations
(such as where CSU is located), that equity can be a concern and as such programs such as the
NCP provide solutions that can allow increased access to participate in international programs.
Further, it has been shown that an international program with a specific focus (such as sport) not
only acts as a catalyst for engagement, but also provide the opportunity to situate pre-service
teaching students as a cultural minority, a significant first for the majority (Winslade, 2015). This
can be seen in the case of CSU where prior to the sport focused SSOP program not one HPE
student had previously enrolled in any form of student mobility program, however since inception
each SSOP program has run at full capacity.
342
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
In order to mitigate criticisms that have been levelled at international programs (such as Edu
tourism) it is important that programs integrate appropriate training (and valid assessment) for
both students and supervising staff. Ensuring that both theory and the realities of authentic workbased requirements are structured into the program, avoiding what Webber (2005) describes as
merely dropping students of in a foreign country and expecting them to learn through osmosis.
To understand the need for programs to build cultural competency in physical educators it is
helpful to understand the context from which the educators are coming from. Regional University
( RU) CSU is an Australian multi-campus, regionally located university catering predominantly for
domestic students in the teacher education field. While there is a significant portion of rural
students enrolled, there are less than four per cent of students identifying as being either
Indigenous or from non-English speaking backgrounds which offers limited diversity. This lessthan-ideal diverse student population has led to limited interaction with multicultural students and
programmes, especially in the HPE discipline. This demographic profile supports the need
identified in the graduate standards (cultural competence) to exposure of situations that challenge
their individual values and belief systems, in order to increase their understanding of cultural
contexts and work effectively with students from diverse cultural backgrounds (Winslade, 2015).
In recognition of the need for Australian students to develop a wider frame of cultural reference,
RU has aligned with international (referred to as student mobility) programs to immerse students
into programs based designed to build cultural awareness with the development of cultural
competency for HPE teacher education students has been seen as a key outcome.
RU has delivered four HPE focused immersion programs to the nation of Samoa, located in the
South Pacific. These programs have hosted between 12-20 students per cohort for a three-week
immersion program delivering a range of health focused programs in various iterations, from
dedicated individual school programs through to multiple sport-based clinics. The programs have
proved beneficial for the participants involved and the knowledge and skills developed have helped
to shape the growth of the Australian based students with numerous measured outcomes being
reported on.
The Samoa Sports Outreach Program (SSOP)
One of the key drivers behind the creation of the SSOP was the provision of an authentic
opportunity to engage pre-service teachers in a cultural immersion program that would firstly
capture their interest, to sign on and then immerse them in a trans-cultural setting that was both
challenging and rewarding. The program was underpinned by the notion of participants
experiencing what it was like to live and work in another culture as a way to examine their own
beliefs and value systems.
Findings from previous iterations of the CSU SSOP designed to help support teacher education
students, particularly Health and Physical education, have shown that as a method the use of
immersive international programs have had positive impact. Drawing on Winslade (2016) it can
343
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
be seen that previous iterations of the program have had a range of impacts on pre-service teachers
including noted changes in their perception of culture resulting from being involved in the
immersion experience. Across the programs it was noted that participants expressed an increased
awareness of both culture and diversity along with the need to be cognisant of the impact that this
awareness has on their professional practice and ability to operate effectively as a teacher. Through
the use of semi structured interviews of SSOP participants and thematically coded through the
lens of pre-service HPE teachers’ knowledge, values and skills participants expressed an increased
understanding cultural competence & the awareness of other people and cultures, both personal
and professional growth, as well as clear links to motivation for further study and consolidation of
their identity in regards to employment in the teaching profession. Of interest to this chapter, is
that participants indicated that an important component of the program was that the structure and
process supported them to increase their awareness of both the needs and learning styles of the
students they were working with requiring them to adjust their teaching strategies accordingly if
they were to be effective (Winslade, 2015). As the SSOP was the first of its kind for the education
faculty it was modelled on previous nursing programs, and it is important to note that the findings
form the research underpinning with the early iterations the program aligned with the work of
Harrison & Malone (2004) and Lee (2011) who disseminated similar results from pre-service
nursing international immersion programs. Both studies found that despite the perceived barriers
that can be associated with international immersion programs such as language constraints and
participant engagement, that students overall responded positively to the experience and that
following the program there were notable improvements to their professional practice with
particular impact in the area of effective communication strategies.
Looking to the future
It must be noted that whilst each SSOP iteration has been underpinned by a partnered school
approach, there is scope to build new and larger partnerships with Samoan researchers to explore
the potential beneficial for the host nation. This will provide the opportunity to design and deliver
a cultural immersion program that will not only benefit the development of cultural competence
of Australian pre-service teachers but also strategically target the physical education and physical
activity of students and the wider community in Samoa.
Why is Samoa an appropriate setting for a targeted Physical education focused immersion
program? How can such a program be beneficial towards the health and physical
education needs of the host country?
The existing relationship between RU and Samoa developed was established in 2012. The program
was aligned initially with the Pacific in Union (PiU) initiative in recognition of the fact that it was
built on a sport platform (Rugby Union) with a focused intervention approach supported by both
the Australian (ARU) and Samoa (SRU) Rugby Unions (ARU, 2013). A key driver of the first
program was the notion of utilising sport as a catalyst to engage Samoan school students into
health focused lessons across a range of schools and community settings. Additionally, the focus
344
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
on sport was also a key driver for the recruitment of university-based students to join the program
and commit to a month abroad to engage with and deliver the health-based program. In
partnership with both the ARU and SRU, the program was established to help address curriculum
challenges (as identified by Schuster, Tufue and Rasmussen, 2021), in recognition of emerging
health concerns on the island, with a series of health focused curriculum material developed and
delivered over a month-long period. When viewed through an equity lens, it becomes apparent
that programs such as the SSOP have traditionally privileged male participants both from the
Australian perspective and subsequently form host student participation perspective.
Subsequently, there has been an identified need to adopt a more inclusive approach from
Australian student recruitment, including through the choice of more gender inclusive supporting
sports based. This will assist immersion programs such as the SSOP to help meet perceived needs
such as in this case the identified need for increased participation of girls in sport and physical
activity. Which addresses Schuster and Schoeffel’s (2019, p. 119-121) finding that most sport and
physical activity programmes in Samoa align with male participation due to cultural protocols
impeding sports access equity. As will be shown later, this move towards the increased
participation of females aligns with a growing international movement (for example see
sportanddev.org as an appropriate platform) to promote the physical activity habits of girls in
recognition of the role this can play in promoting gender equality. As such, the alignment to a host
country such as Samoa with both its young population and increasing negative health trends
associated with females in terms of body weight and associated conditions such as diabetes could
provide a setting where an international immersion program such as the SSOP could support those
in country to develop sustainable and impactful partnerships. This approach will assist in the
Government's agenda to increase female participation through outreach programmes, sports and
the HPE curriculum (Schuster and Schoeffel, 2019, p 122), whilst still addressing the need to
develop the cultural competency of Australian pre-service teacher participants.
Is Samoa still an appropriate setting for a health and physical education focused
intervention?
Identifying the needs of the host nation
Pulling together the needs of two separate national partners is a complex issue, particularly in
relation to the needs of the hist nation, in this case Samoa. Exploring both the work of Samoabased academics and unpacking current available trend data, provides an opportunity to investigate
the complex connections that currently exist in relation to population health, wellbeing and the
associated challenges underpinning education and curriculum design. When considering current
health statistics and trends (see below), as a Pacific regional location (and regional neighbour of
Australia, an important consideration of the NCP), Samoa can be considered an appropriate and
potentially effective setting for future iterations of any physical activity/health focused
intervention programs of the SSOP. However, in moving forward and following the
recommendations of key stakeholders such as Schuster (NUS), the underpinning narrative of any
potential future program must be cognisant of the need to consider the establishment of genuine
345
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
and sustainable research partnerships as part of that process with Samoan institutions. This
partnership would directly address the findings from Schuster, 2019, confirming that the NUS
HPE Bachelor programme needs preservice training in HPE curriculum and delivery.
Health related trend data reveals that Samoa has a population just in excess of 190,000 and that
during the time frame from 1978 to 2013 there was a significant noted increase in concerning
health trends, including diabetes and obesity across all demographic’s population groups across of
the country. For males this figure rose from 1.2% to 19.6%, whilst for women this figure was 2.2%
to 19.5 %, further across this same period, it was noted that obesity levels also rose dramatically,
for males from 27.7% to 53.1% and of importance to this future partnership project (that will be
established in this chapter) from 44.4% to 76.7% in women. In 2020, it was noted that this health
trend has continued with obesity levels estimated at approximately 59% in men and rising to 81%
in women (Lin et al., 2017). This trend data provides a clear red flag of the need for partnerships
(in this case educational) and interventions that may provide some form of assistance in an
authentic and sustainable manner. Further, Schuster et al, (2021) identify that in relation to the
overall population of Samoa, that demographically under 30-year-old represents approximately
80% of the population highlighting a significantly large youth sub population. This further
provides evidence that aligned with increasing obesity and diabetes, that a health initiative aimed
at education and participation for young people is an appropriate focus for the SSOP to have
increased impact for the host nation. Further, media sources within the pacific identify that the
region has some has some of the highest rates of domestic violence in the world with a recent
United Nations (UN) 2021 report showed that in some regions of the pacific this number can be
as high as 70% - 100%. Unfortunately, there are also well documented media reported cases that
have also linked sport (and sporting personality’s) negatively in the region with domestic violence.
As such, any program that is designed to educate, include, and empower the female population
through sport provides a potential opportunity to assist to mitigate and bring awareness to such
issues.
Significantly, whilst there are numerous links to websites, awareness campaigns and media /news
stories, it is apparent that there is still the need for supporting evidence-based approaches to the
situation and programs that align to a research agenda that can advocate a strength-based
approach, driven through a genuine partnership model. Studies on health-based partnerships
report the importance of collecting data, including baseline data to allow for measurable objectives
and outcomes to be both set and evaluated (Estacio et al., 2017)
Schuster et al., (2021) identify a number of links to curriculum and educational opportunities
aligned with the current Samoan educational context that could provide a catalyst for thought in
regard to any future program. Use of Sport Organizations and National Federations has been
found to one effective pathway to engage and deliver parts of the HPE curriculum both in skill
and in health outcomes (Schuster, 2020). This is critical in order to have tangible links to the work
being currently undertaken in regard to curriculum implementation and reform in Samoa. Schuster
et al., (2021) articulate a range of challenges that exist in Samoa impacting on the acceptance and
346
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
potential impact that could be achieved with acknowledgement of (Health) Physical Education
curriculum, which can be considered relatively new in the Samoan educational landscape and is
still in a somewhat infancy mode, particularly in regards to what Schuster refers to as firm roots of
teaching styles that are underpinned by inclusive, generalist, holistic and significantly participatory
pedagogy. Although in its infancy, Schuster, 2020, confirms that local partnerships with National
Federations have benefited pre-service HPE teacher trainees and that "teacher trainees will need
to be exposed to various methods to increase their confidence in delivering effective HPE lessons".
By throwing the net wider and building transnational partnerships, preservice teacher trainees as
well as novice HPE teachers in Samoa will provide the critical relationships, experiences and
networks needed.
Of importance to the reimagining of immersion programs such as the SSOP, is that there have
been a number of recently released global initiatives aligned with UN Sustainable Development
aspirations, including those designed to provide increased levels of support in order for impacted
communities and target populations groups to recover, rebound and reimagine post COVID-19
(UNICEF). These programs provide a catalyst to create authentic links to schools and educational
programs under a partnered approach. With this in mind, the proposed program proffered by CSU
incorporates a three-to-four-week targeted (H)PE program utilising a range of Australian thirdyear HPE teacher education and exercise science students (prior to entering their final year of
study) to work closely with schools and teachers to develop a series of opportunities to promote
physical activity opportunities for female students and community members. The benefits can be
considered twofold, firstly for CSU (as previously indicated) and as a support mechanism for
Samoan stakeholders as a way to provide an additional voice to support those educators and
programs currently in situ. The UN (United Nations Office on Sport and Development for Peace,
UNOSDP) has advocated for a focus on empowering young people in such spaces as physical
activity and mental health through the notion of partnering, while UNICEF identify that a key
consideration for the future is finding tangible ways to strengthen mental health services for
children, adolescents, parents, and frontline workers. Further, UNICEF identify those adolescents
in particular girls, those with disabilities, and LGBTIQ are especially vulnerable to mental health
stressors and that there is a genuine need to explore opportunities that privilege these populations
through such platforms as exercise, sport, and education. Building on this, sport has been
identified as an important enabler of sustainable development by the UN and through its global
reach and appeal, is a tool that should be embraced as a platform to engage young people
(UNOSDP).
The big picture - Why are a partnered approach?
Aligning programs such as the SSOP with a broader international agenda
There is a growing field of literature supporting the field of health-based partnerships. Schriger et
al., 2021 argues that despite the growth in such partnerships there is still a lingering focus on the
benefits for the organisation involved, as opposed to acting as a catalyst for greater societal good,
347
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
with an aim to improve health outcomes and reduce health inequalities. At a community level,
Estacio et al., 2017 proffer that there are a number of key elements that are required if a
community-based health promotion initiative is to be effective and navigate potential tensions and
challenges that arise. They argue that such partnerships have the opportunity to support both
successful implementation and importantly maintenance of any community-based work.
Partnerships also help to ensure the adoption of a more holistic approach to any initiative ensuring
that there is increased clarity and consideration of social, economic, cultural, and environmental
determinants that may need to be addressed with consideration of the setting. Further, Estacio et
al., (2017) elaborate those partnerships are most successful when there is a clear goal for the
partnership to achieve and that partners are cognisant of that vision and of each other’s
perspective.
It is also important to note that there are a range of risks and threats to the sustainability of
partnerships aligned to such aspects as funding, staff, and policy changes, in addition to other
issues such as potential political influence. Estacio et al., (2017) highlight the need to ensure that
there is a high level of organisational commitment to any partnership, and that a shared vision
captured into documentation and policy can help to mitigate such risks.
For programs such as the SSOP to be sustainable they need to partner with a range of relevant
stakeholders to help reach intended goals and outcomes. For example the SSOP partners with
such agencies as New South Wales Netball, the Australian Royal Lifesaving Society, various
Samoan Sports Association, the Samoan Ministry for Education, Sports and Culture (MESC) and
mor recently the National University of Samoa (NUS), Faculty of Education in order to co-create
and design the project and research agenda To provide a further level of support and as a way to
help mitigate possible policy and political risk the SSOP also partners with the Government
agencies such as the NSW Office of Sport along with the MESC.
Importantly, moving forward the SSOP program aligns with a number of international objectives
including the World Health Organisation’s (WHO) focus on Gender Equality, particularly in
regions of the world such as the Indo-Pacific. This is in recognition of high rates of domestic
violence, obesity and diabetes that as indicated is estimated to affect 1 in 3 adults (Bollars,
Sorensen, de Vries & Meertens, 2019). A key facet underpinning the program is the alignment
with UN Sustainable Development Goals, reflected in the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable
Development, Sport for Development and Peace which advocates that through sport and physical
activity, women and girls can be empowered and benefit from the positive impact that sport has
on health and psychosocial conditions (Lemke, 2016). The program will specifically align with
Goals 3,4, and 5: (Goal 3: Ensure healthy lives and promote well-being for all at all ages); (Goal 4:
Ensure inclusive and quality education for all and promote lifelong learning); (Goal 5: Achieve
gender equality and empower all women and girls); with additional alignment to Goal 17 which is
underpinned by the strengthening of partnerships including, encouraging, and promoting effective
public, private and civil partnerships, building on the experience and resourcing strategies of those
partnerships (United Nations, Department of economic and Social Affairs.) The final element to
348
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
consider with the proposed SSOP is the alignment with an appropriate environment to put the
initiative in place to support the notion of individual development, and for this given the nature
of the SSOP schools are an obvious setting. Schools are recognised environments that can support
positive behaviour changes. Culturally, in Samoa, schools are a natural environment to implement
policy (on sport and PA participation) affect behavior change but must garner village and
community support (Schuster and Schoeffel, 2018, p 122). Balderson and Sharpe (2005) identify
that through schools not only provide access to students but also access to teachers and parents
who may play a vital role in the advocacy and identification and remediation of undesirable
behaviours and the promotion of positive social interaction. Samoa has 141 primary schools and
40 plus secondary schools, in addition to a university that supports teacher education preparation,
and it is through this network that SSOP can assist in adding value and assistance in addressing
the noted challenges to acceptance and legitimacy of HPE design and development in the
curriculum as identified by Schuster et al., 2021). There are noted beneficial links between PE
programs underpinned by a social interactive paradigm and both academic performance and
perceived levels of competence and confidence, particularly for girls (D’Anna, Forte & Paloma,
2019; Bracco, Lodewyk & Morrison, 2019).
There has been increasing investment into improving girls’ participation and engagement with PE
aligned to awareness of the need for integration of social and environmental considerations.
Literature suggests that there has been an international decline in physical activity participation of
girls particularly in adolescence and that interventions aimed at improving the participation rates
could help to remove perceived barriers to success (Goodyear & Casey, 2015). Contextually,
Schuster and Schoeffel (2018) identify that despite a range of policies in place that specific focus
on the participation of girls in sport in Samoa there are there is a notable absence of female
participation in all levels of recreation and competitive sport in the country, particularly when
compared to their male counterparts as a result of perceived barriers aligned to culture class and
location. Further, McCarthy et al., (2021) proffer that successfully engaging women in higher levels
of sport including within international teams should align with an understanding of the impacts of
creating the appropriate culture that includes notions of care and respect.
Exploring potential frameworks to support the needs of both Australian pre-service
teachers and increased physical activity of Samoan students.
Further, the adoption of appropriate learning platforms and strategies is crucial to the success of
any engagement driven initiative. Contextualizing these learning platforms for the Samoan learner
and sport environment will be addressed for effective intervention. Examples: modesty, clothing,
resources, venues, cultural protocols of female and male based activities, time, space and relational
issues. As such, there are two approaches that could potentially underpin a program such as the
SSOP in the future to become a targeted PE intervention aimed at increasing female participation,
cognisant of social and environmental design. These are the Sport Education model (SEM) and
the Teaching Games for Understanding (TGfU) Model. Both approaches are grounded in social
constructs and have proven demonstrated impact across a range of social domains (Smith et al.,
349
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
2021). SEM has a strong alignment with the development of social skills and competence fostered
through a collaborative learning (Goodyear, 2016) PE setting providing motivation links to
engagement with physical activity outside of the classroom (Hastie & Mesquite, 2016; Siedentop,
Hastie & van der Mars, 2004). Dyson and Casey (2016) proffer that with increased confidence and
perceived competence individuals are more likely to participate in recreational physical activity
more. In a similar way the TGfU Model provides a student-based approach that builds both
physical and social skills through a cooperative learning design (Kirk & MacPhail, 2022). TGfU is
underpinned by notions of group success demonstrated through tactics and skill execution with
skills learnt being able to be transferred to other social and sporting contexts. Importantly for this
project as a platform TGfU develops a strong sense of social interaction and cohesion meaning
that whilst individuals are participating, they are also part of an increasing larger collective helping
to establish a critical mass required for an ongoing and sustainable engagement environment.
Research by Chepyator-Thomson and Ennis (1997) and Siedentop and Tannehill, (2000) suggest
that gender bias is nearly always present in physical education classes. Within PE classes, it is
claimed that girls frequently devalue their contribution and suffer from stereotypical expectations
regarding their performance. Characteristically, this results in girls not overly exerting themselves
or being noticeably energetic. Although circumstantial, PE teachers tend to frequently make
comments referring to how girls do not always participate as fully as boys do. Slade (2006)
conducted a research project teaching novices field hockey using a TGfU instructional method.
The results indicated that in stage 1 of the project, 86% of the female students were sure that they
would not enjoy playing hockey. By the final stage, post the TGFU instruction, 100% of the female
participants stated they either probably or definitely did enjoy playing hockey. These responses
were an important indicator that the TGFU method of instruction can be used as motivation for
females to likely persevere in continuing with hockey and to a larger extent, continued participation
in physical activity. However, it needs to be noted that models such as TGfU are yet to be fully
researched in regard to the level of relevance, cultural appropriateness, and sustainable teaching
practice in Samoa for sports and PE and as such we advocate that through such programs as the
SSOP a research agenda be integrated in order to address this gap in the current field of literature.
Conclusion
As shown in this chapter, international immersion programs have been shown to be an effective
way to assist Australian pre-service HPE teachers to actively engage with the development cultural
competence. However, it has also been shown that any international program is cognisant of the
potential needs and context of the host country and as such university sponsored immersion
programs need to be underpinned by authentic partnerships that provide real impact for all
stakeholders. In addition, the chapter has also discussed how underpinning Health and Physical
theoretical frameworks such as TGfU which are present in many Australian programs may prove
to be an effective vehicle to support such partnership approaches in the future. Whilst there are
multiple perspectives at play here (Australian needs, Samoan needs, theoretical framework), the
aim of this chapter has been to bring these various elements and needs together in order to develop
350
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
a more sustainable health and physical education focused international immersion initiative aimed
at imparting effective support to both educators and students.
References
Australian Institute for Teaching and School Leadership (AITSL) (2011). Accreditation of Initial
Teacher Education Programs in Australia: Standards and Procedures: Ministerial Council for
Education, Early Childhood Development, and Youth Affairs (MCEECTYA).
Australian Rugby Union (ARU), 2013 retrieved from
http://www.rugby.com.au/News/PacificinUnion.aspx
Balderson, D., & Sharpe, T. (2005). The effects of personal accountability and personal
responsibility instruction on select off-task and positive social behaviors. Journal of
Teaching in Physical Education, 24(1), 66-87.
Bollars, C., Sørensen, K., de Vries, N. et al. Exploring health literacy in relation to
noncommunicable diseases in Samoa: a qualitative study. BMC Public Health 19, 1151 (2019).
https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-019-7474-x
Bracco, E., Lodewyk, K., & Morrison, H. (2019) A case study of disengaged adolescent girls’
experiences with teaching games for understanding in physical education, Curriculum
Studies
in
Health
and
Physical
Education, 10:3, 207225, DOI: 10.1080/25742981.2019.1632724
Chepyator-Thomson, J., & Ennis, C (1997). Reproduction and resistance to the culture of
femminity and masculinity in secondary school physical education. Research Quarterly for
Exercise and Sport, 68, 89-99
Cross, T., Bazron, B., Dennis, K., & Isaacs, M. (1989). Toward a culturally competent system of care.
Washington, DC: Georgetown University Child Development Center
D’Anna, C., Forte, P., & Paloma, F. (2019). Physical education status in European school’s
curriculum, extension of educational offer and planning. Journal of Human Sport and
Exercise. 14, 805-817
Dyson, B., and A. Casey. 2016. Cooperative Learning in Physical Education and Physical Activity:
A Practical Introduction. London: Routledge.
Estacio, E. V., Oliver, M., Downing, B., Kurth, J., & Protheroe, J. (2017). Effective Partnership in
Community-Based Health Promotion: Lessons from the Health Literacy
Partnership. International journal of environmental research and public health, 14(12), 1550.
https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph14121550
Goodyear, V. A. 2016. “Sustained Professional Development on Cooperative Learning: Impact
on Six Teachers’ Practices and Students’ Learning.” Research Quarterly for Exercise and
Sport. doi.org/10.1080/02701367.2016. 1263381.
Goodyear, V. A., and A. Casey. 2015. “Innovation with Change: Developing a Community of
Practice to Help Teachers Move Beyond the ‘Honeymoon’ of Pedagogical Renovation.”
Physical
Education
and
Sport
Pedagogy
20
(2):
186–
203.
doi:10.1080/17408989.2013.817012.
351
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Harrison, L., & Malone, K. (2004). A study abroad experiences in Guatemala: learning first-hand
about health, education, and social welfare in a low-resource country. Perso, T. (2012).
'Cultural competence' and National Professional Standards for Teachers. Centre for Strategic
Education, East Melbourne, Vic
Hastie, P. A., and I. Mesquite. 2016. “Sport-based Physical Education.” In Routledge Handbook
of Physical Education Pedagogies, edited by C. D. Ennis, 68–84. London: Routledge
Jones, M., & Bond, M. (2019) Personal adjustment, language acquisition and culture learning in
short-term cultural immersion. International Research and Review, Journal of Phi Beta Delta Honor
Society for International Scholars. (9) 1.
Karaman, A., & Tochon, F. (2010) Worldviews, criticism, and the peer circle: A study of the
experiences of a student teacher in an overseas school. Foreign Language Annals, 43, 683604
Kirk, D., and A. MacPhail. 2002. “Teaching Games for Understanding and Situated Learning:
Rethinking the BunkerThorpe Model.” Journal of Teaching in Physical Education 21 (2):
177–192
Koh, A., Maxwell, C., Engel, L., & Yemini, M. (2020) Critiquing dominant cultures of schooling
as a sustained critical enterprise in sociology of education, International Studies in Sociology
of Education, 29:3, 199-203, DOI: 10.1080/09620214.2020.1794343
Lee, J. (2011). International field experience – What do student teachers learn? Australian Journal
of Teacher Education, 36(10).
Lemke, W. (2016). The Role of Sport in achieving the Sustainable Development Goals. Retrieved
from
https://www.un.org/en/chronicle/article/role-sport-achieving-sustainabledevelopment-goals
Lin S, Naseri T, Linhart C, et al. Trends in diabetes and obesity in Samoa over 35 years, 1978–
2013. Diabet Med. 2017;34(5):654–661. doi: 10.1111/dme.13197.
Maakrun, J. (2020). The confluence of short-term immersion and intercultural competence:
Positive impacts for Australian preservice teachers (Doctor of Philosophy (College of
Education)).
University
of
Notre
Dame
Australia.
Retrieved
from
https://researchonline.nd.edu.au/theses/301
Major, J., Munday, J., & Winslade, M. (2019). Leading an International Teaching Experience:
Teacher Educators and Intercultural Competence. In F Dervin and R Moloney (Eds).
Intercultural Competences and Teacher Education. Routledge.
McCarthy, L., Martin, A., Slade, D., & Watson, G. (2021). Of women, by women, for women:
How coaches and captains created a caring and winning culture in the New Zealand netball
team. The International Journal of Sport and Society, 12(2), 153-165.
Ryan, S. (2010). Let's Get Them Out of the Country! Reflecting On the Value of International
Immersion Experiences for MPA Students. Journal of Public Affairs Education. 16(2) 307-312
Schriger, S., Binagwaho, A., Keetile M. (2021). Hierarchy of qualities in global health partnerships:
a path towards equity and sustainability. BMJ Global Health 2021; 6: e007132.
352
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Schuster, S., & Schoeffel, P., (2018) Girls and sports in Samoa. Culture, policy and practice in
urban and rural communities. In G. Molnar., S Amin., & Kanemasu, Y (Eds). Women, Sport
and Exercise in the Asia-Pacific: Domination, Resistance, Accommodation (1st Ed.).
Routledge: London.
Schuster, S. (2019). The novice Health and Physical Education Teacher in Samoan secondary
schools: Needs assessment of the preparedness, challenges and constraints. Pacific-Asian
Education Journal, 31. p. 73-87
Schuster, S., Tufue, R., Rasmussen, D., (2021). Physical education and inclusive education in
Samoa. Challenges from policy to practice. In B. Gheorghe, B. Antala, C. Carty, J. Aleokol
Mabiémé, I. Amar, & A. Kaplánová (Eds), Physical Education and sport for Children and
youth with Special needs: Researches Best Practices Situation. 1st Ed. Slovak Scientific
Society for Physical Education and Sport and FIEP.
Siedentop, D., Hastie, P., and H. van der Mars. 2004. Complete Guide to Sport Education. Leeds:
Human Kinetics
Siedentop, D., & Tannehill, D. (2000). Developing teaching skills in physical education. Ca.
Mayfield Pub. Company
Slade, D. (2006). Game Learning Experiences in Physical Education with a TGfU Application.
In Asia Pacific Conference on Teaching Sport and Physical Education for Understanding.
Smith, W., Philpot, R., Gerdin, G., Schenker, K., Linnér, S., Larsson, L., et al. (2021). School HPE:
its mandate, responsibility, and role in educating for social cohesion. Sport Educ. Soc. 26,
500–513.
Smolcic, E., & Katunich 2017 Teachers crossing borders: A review of the research into cultural
immersion field experience for teachers. Teaching and Teacher Education (62). 47-59
Spittle, M., Petering, F., Kremer, P., & Spittle, S. (2011) "Stereotypes and self-perceptions of
physical education pre-service teachers," Australian Journal of Teacher Education: (37)1, 2.
http://ro.ecu.edu.au/ajte/vol37/iss1/2
Stevens, J., Murray, D. M., Catellier, D. J., Hannan, P. J., Lytle, L. A., Elder, J. P., Young, D. R.,
Simons-Morton, D. G., & Webber, L. S. (2005). Design of the Trial of Activity in Adolescent
Girls (TAAG). Contemporary clinical trials, 26(2), 223–233.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cct.2004.12.011
Suttichujit, V. (2009). Becoming culturally competent: Adapting education to contemporary social
norms. Journal of Alternative Perspectives in the Social Sciences, 1(2), 490-497
United Nations (UN). Department of Economic and Social Affairs Sustainable Development
Goals retrieved from https://sdgs.un.org/#goal_section
United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF). Recover, Rebound, Reimagine: Building a better
future for every child in East Asia and the Pacific, post COVID-19. Retrieved from
https://www.unicef.org/pacificislands/media/1831/file/UNICEF%20Report:%20Recov
er,%20Rebound,%20Reimagine%20.pdf
Universities Australia. (2011). National Best Practice Framework for Indigenous Cultural
Competency in Australian Universities. Retrieved from
https://www.universitiesaustralia.edu.au/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/National-BestPractice-Framework-for-Indigenous-Cultural-Competency-in-Australian-Universities.pdf
353
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Webber, R. (2005). Integrating work-based and academic learning international and cross-cultural
settings. Journal of Education and Work, 18 (4), 473-487.
Winslade, M. (2015). Culture, motivation, and sport: Developing cultural competence of health
and physical education pre-service teachers. In M. Henning, C. Krageloh & G. Wong-Toi
(Eds). Student motivation and quality of life in higher education. New York: Routledge
Winslade, M. (2016). Can an international field experience assist Health and Physical Education
pre-service teachers to develop cultural competency? Cogent Education. Taylor and Francis.
354
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
The Professional Identity of the Physical Education Teacher
Hector Manuel Icaza Campa
Colimense College of PE Professionals, Recreation, Sport and Related Sciences, A.C. Colima, Mexico
email: icazacampa@hotmail.com
Abstract
The intention of this work was to resolve a concern that we were able to identify in the observation
of the practice of the Physical Education teachers, their comments and the conversations held
with various colleagues regarding how new teachers are graduating from the training schools and
that apparently - due to some deficiencies within the curriculum - and the application of the current
physical education program in basic education, they have not formed a strong identity as physical
education professionals; And, if you add to this that within schools they are not recognized or
valued professionally. On the contrary, they are considered as technicians or simple "entertainers"
of children and who do not contribute anything to the training of students, then, this aggravates
the social perception and that they themselves have of their profession. Likewise, the social
perception is that Physical Education is the kind of "Sports" where only children are played and
entertained; In addition, there is a tendency in several countries to reduce the number of PE classes
per week, while other groups have tried to delete or eliminate it or at least change its name to
concepts such as physical activity sciences, motor skills, corporeity, motor praxiology, sports
sciences and many others that it would be idle to mention here. Therefore, documentary research
was carried out that would allow us to have a broad vision of the conception that colleagues have
of this issue of professional identity, as well as the problems that they could identify, as well as the
conclusions they reached, to enrich our work and make our own contributions.
Key words: Professional identity, Physical education
355
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
The intention of this article is to rescue some conceptual elements and our own educational
practice that allow us to reaffirm our identity as professionals of Physical Education, since lately
this has been questioned due to various influences and interests of different groups to discredit
and even disappear it from the field of formal education.
Development
From a time to date, it has been mentioned by some people that Physical how can Physical
Education loose its professional identity and this has led us to review how much of this is true and
the reason of this is because it has happened or if it has really done so.
Based on the above, we ask ourselves the following question:
What is, or how has the Professional identity of the Physical Education teacher been constructed?
From the previous question is that we started our reflection and, at the time of writing this article,
we found that many other colleagues have asked themselves the same or a similar question; such
is the case of Navarrete (2008), write four questions about this and research and trying to find the
problem and that´s why we reproduced here, trying to adapt it to our professional field:
What are the traits that have been constituting the identity of the physical educator?
What identity of physical educator are we talking about?
What is the identity of the physical educator?
How has this identity come to be represented, how is it expressed today?
In terms of Noble (2020), "Some of the most frequent discussions today tend to problematize the place of physical
education (PE) in the current educational scenario, while others focus on the professional demands that society
demands for graduates in this training." To which this problem is added or extended to the professional
role or function of the physical educator himself, which implies the question of which is -professional
identity- and what is the function of the physical education teacher? a matter that touches the main theme of
this work and that will be addressed throughout it, seeking to answer all these doubts and thus
provide a little clarity about it.
We will begin with this work starting from defining what is meant by Identity and professional
identity.
The word Identity comes from the Latin identĭtas, -ātis. Which means "the same, the same" or equal
to my fellow man, in this case, to those of my profession and to the acts I perform within it.
Therefore, it is understood that identity is the set of characteristics, traits, or conceptions of an individual or
a community that allow us to distinguish ourselves from the rest or in relation to others.
356
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
According to Perez, J. and Gardey, A. (2009), Identity is also the awareness that a person has
regarding himself and that makes him someone different from others. Although many of the traits
that form the identity are hereditary or innate, the environment exerts a great influence on the
conformation of the specificity of each subject.
From the perspective of personal and subjective identity, on the level of the individual, the idea of
identity is associated with "something of my own that distinguishes me from others."
In this sense, it is affirmed that identity is formed, shaped and enriched.
Therefore, we consider that identity refers to the ability to recognize myself and to differentiate or distinguish myself
from others, since I am unique and thanks to that, I want distance myself from others; however, we need others to
be able to recognize ourselves.
Personal identity is individual, dynamic and covers different dimensions of the person and allows
on the one hand individualization or differentiation from other people and on the other hand
offers the possibility of belonging to a group or collective.
For García (2013), the teaching identity is understood not as "something with which one is born", but rather, that
it is acquired and shaped throughout life, through relationships with parents, friends, students, siblings, teachers,
institutions, etc. That is, it is something that we build in the passage of time and the actions we do
during it in a certain space.
This same author points out the following: identity is not a fixed attribute in a person, but it is a process
that is built, from the interpretation we make about ourselves and from the recognition that others make of us and
our work as teachers, in a certain context.
Therefore, we as teachers, define or project ourselves, from the various roles we perform in
educational spaces. On the other hand, García (2013) points out that biography plays a crucial role
in understanding how we build our identity and our practice in the classroom and for which he
cites Crow (2004), who suggests that the origins of our teaching identity are found in the teaching models we
had as students in our previous educational experiences, in childhood memories about learning, educational activities,
and family models
In this way, García (2013) concludes by saying that without a doubt, looking at our past and reflecting on
our experience as school and / or university students, is an effective way to begin to understand ourselves and be
aware of how we make part of our teaching identity and be ourselves, aware and protagonists of this process that is
formulated and reformulated throughout life.
On the other hand, González-Calvo, G., Hortigüela-Alcalá, D. and Barba-Martín, R (2018),
consider body stereotypes as a point to be taken into account in the construction of the
professional identity of the physical educator, given the image they show to other teachers and
357
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
their own students, as well as in what corresponds to their own body image, as they are perceived,
so these authors conclude that body stereotypes have a certain influence on the construction of one's own bodily
and professional identity.
It is González-Calvo himself (2013) who in the summary of his doctoral thesis on the "Evolution of
the professional identity of a novice teacher of physical education, expresses the following:
Among the most relevant conclusions of the research, the following stand out:
(1) In the field of education, the worlds of the personal and the professional cannot be separated from each other.
2) Professional identity is strongly imbued with internal factors (the way of being and doing in the profession, selfconcept and self-esteem, mainly) and external factors (the prestige of the profession, professional recognition
and interactions with students, families and peers).
3) What we have experienced as a student is a central element in the process of constructing the professional identity
of teachers.
4) Systematically questioning one's own teaching is a way to improve teaching, to maintain interest in the profession
and to open oneself to the path of new ideas.
The foregoing comes to reaffirm what is related to the fact that a professional identity is the result
of a process of construction derived from both subjective aspects such as the perception that the
physical educator has of himself and the opinion that his fellow teachers, the students and the
community where he works have about him; while from the objective point of view, this is
reinforced through studies relating to the definition of professional identity.
According to Navarrete (2008), "the subject constructs his identity from the assumption of different positions,
roles or identity poles: a person throughout his life history can be a pedagogue, father of a family, atheist, politician,
footballer, etc. and, in this sense, identity is constantly reconstructed by the acquisition of new positions and by the
resignifications that each subject makes of them. ". And the latter is one of the aspects that we wish to
emphasize, in the sense that professional identity is something unfinished, product of professional
practice, of the experience of the teacher in front of the group; but also, of their initial and
permanent formation, because that allows us to "rebuild" ourselves every day according to what
we are experiencing and learning in that practice.
In this way Navarrete (2008) offers a definition of professional identity, which is exposed with the
intention of adapting it to the field of physical education, which in the end, is very similar to what
the author establishes:
"Professional identity is the way in which the subject appropriates a professional-institutional project, corresponding
to a disciplinary field, and what that project and that field imply as a space and means of constitution-training. In
the case of this work, the professional identity of the pedagogue depends on the type of relationship and experiences
of the pedagogue with the institution in which he is trained, the discipline and working life in a specific time and
context"
358
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
In this case, Navarrete (2008) states that the formation of the professional identity is the result of
a project that she calls professional-institutional and that would correspond, in one hand, to the
initial training process of the professional. At another one, to his performance in the exercise of
his work / professional activity, highlighting that during this process certain features or
characteristics were identified that were delineating or profiling that professional identity.
Being on the one hand, those related to the historical evolution of the training school itself and on
the other, the features of professional practice directly in the workplace itself and within which it
is possible to include what some authors call as an entry profile or vocational traits.
This is a very important issue, particularly in the case of physical education, where on many
occasions the aspirants to enter the training schools manifest their idea that they want to teach or
learn sports, which is one of the most common mistakes or situations derived from the general
ignorance of what Physical Education is and that definitively affects this entire identity process.
In accordance with what is established by Pulido, S. Bores, N. and Moreno, A. (2009) and quoting
Barbier (1996), who emphasizes identity in two ways, one built by another, that is, the constructions
or representations that others make of a subject, and two, the constructions that an actor makes
about himself, therefore built by itself. On the other hand, it alludes to the characteristics attributed
to a person or group of people who seek to be related.
The philosopher Mead makes a reflection that allows us to understand identity as a process of
interaction, where the subject is built from free recognition and in the search for it that is established
with others (by right or by social estimation). For Mead (1990) the "I" is the organized set of
attitudes of others that is constitutive of the self. The "I" is the individual's response or reaction
to the attitudes of others.
As proposed by Benilde Vázquez, (cited by Pulido (2009), the basis of identity is self-concept ..."the
concept of sports identity is determined by the relationship that a person has with sport. Brock &
Kleiber (1994) and Wiechman & Williams (1997) propose the following definition: "Sports identity
is the degree to which people identify with the role of athlete”.
The construction of the sports identity is a reference for the understanding of the conditions that
lead to the formative choice in the area of Physical Education... The sports identity is the result of
very similar socialization/subjectivation processes, which are prior to the occurrence of
performing and the choice of Physical Education and Sports studies. In other words, the
trajectories and life stories of these people in contexts in which the link with physical activity
prevails, end up crystallizing in these predispositions.
As can be seen, what Pulido et al. quote. (2009), makes direct reference to the sports identity, but
that can well be extrapolated to the issue of identity in general and the professional identity of the
physical educator in very similar terms and that is why we quote it here.
359
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
It is interesting to highlight the fact that, according to the various research reviewed and made by
us, it has been possible to verify that the concept or idea of professional identity -as already
mentioned-, is in a constant transformation, which is dynamic as initial training and professional
practice have been evolving or transforming over time, what enriches it and also sometimes as it
was said at the beginning, this can affect that same appropriation or identification with the
profession itself.
In that same order of ideas, we find that professional identity is a set of ideas, values and beliefs
about physical education, based on the experience lived as teachers of that specialty, which is a
fundamental element in that construction. This is how Saucedo (2021) points out from a study
with students who will be PE teachers in a brief future: By recognizing a set of activities that delimit the
work of the physical educator, students build their professional identity by evaluating what they should and should
not do as professionals. And he goes on to say that identity attributes certain practices, rituals, dynamics,
behavior and behaviors that define a teacher, that is, that express a teaching professional while allowing him to be
considered part of a social group that shares the same characteristics. This identity is built in the professional practice
as well as in the school practices of preparation for teaching.
On this same topic, Benger (1998, quoted by Saucedo, 2021), states the following:
The conceptualization of professional identity undertaken in the text of Batista Graça and Queirós
(2014) is recovered for our purpose. Professional identity, notes Batista (2014), includes:
1. Legitimate participation in the professio;.
2. An occupation in the role of the professional with the ability to control their practices, a
language, as well as tools and resources associated with that role;
3. Ideas, values and beliefs that lead teachers to continue in the profession;
4. Result of experiences that influence your career decisions;
5. Representation of oneself as a professional who projects both for oneself and for others.
Based on the above, we define that the identity of the EF is composed of multiple elements such
as traditions, customs, acts, values and beliefs characteristic of the EF. Likewise, the identity of the
EF is one that gives us an identity feeling at the individual or collective level based on belonging
to a group or profession. The identity of the EF is a set of thoughts and feelings that allow us to
identify with our profession. The construction of the identity of PE is based on basic psychological
processes and social factors.
The professional identity allows on the one hand the individualization or differentiation from the
rest of people of other professions and on the other, it offers the possibility of developing a sense
of belonging to a group or collective.
To paraphrase Coreth (1991), professional identity comes from ourselves as professionals who
daily experience our teaching practices and this is how we can understand our professional identity
360
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
when exercising it daily, from our concrete situation; which arises from the concrete "precompression"
that is an indispensable condition to identify our professional identity. This "precompression"
refers to the fact that we start from a first notion product of our experience and from which we
can reflect and conceptualize our teaching work. To do this, it is approached -from the
methodological point of view- from the study or analysis of a phenomenon (in this case, the
teaching of physical education understood as our teaching task), so that from this, we are able to
experience and understand our professional practice and in this way, it is how we can understand
and understand ourselves as professionals of physical education and thus transcend ourselves and
be in possibility of define or explain what the professional identity of the physical educator is.
For his part, González-Calvo (2013), concludes:
Therefore, when the educator imparts his teaching he is expressing his way of understanding the world and education.
This process of construction of the teaching identity is complex and heterogeneous, precisely because it is configured
around personal, professional and institutional experiences. In this way, personal and professional life complement
and influence each other, ... the experiences that are forged in the day to day of the classrooms (the playground for
the Physical Education teacher), as a student first and as a teacher later, the behaviors of themselves and their
classmates, the reality of the classrooms and the centers, are shaping their own identity ... to the extent that the
educator goes (re)knowing himself, understanding the meaning of what he does and how he does it, remembering what
he has lived and how he has lived it, defining his educational ideals based on his past and present experiences,
outlining the type of relationships he wants to establish with the rest of the educational community, of how he sees
others and what he expects of them in relation to oneself, teaching connects with what the educator is, feels and wants.
In relation to the elements of teaching identity provided by the current school, Zayago, Z., Chacón,
M. and Rojas, M. (2008), point out that the teaching identity can be seen that the criterion of the majority of
students agrees that this institution has ceased to be a place where identity values are fully unified... Therefore,
identity is an individual device that is transformed on the basis of personal experiences, product of interactions between
subjects; taking as some of the strategies for its achievement the fact of affirmation and search, through which their
sense of commitment to the career and their willingness to constitute themselves as professionals fully identified with
teaching is ratified. (during the initial formation process) . Another strategy can be inferred as approval and
projection, since the ideas expressed indicate that students feel driven by a logic of promotion and social mobility.
Conclusions
Among the findings or conclusions that have been found throughout this study, it is possible to
point out or identify a series of traits that characterize the professional identity of the physical
educator, among which the following stand out:
•
In the vast majority, at present, physical education teachers graduate from normal schools
and / or university careers, that is, they have a well-defined professional training, however,
as there is a diversity of related careers, this sometimes confronts them with a situation of
361
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
•
•
•
•
•
loss of identity by not knowing if they are physical education teachers, recreologists, sports
coaches, graduates in physical activity or physical culture, physical instructors, etc., which
pays for the loss of professional identity
Hybrid vocational training, in the sense of the changes in the curricula of the training schools
and the various approaches that the profession has had throughout its history, which has
changed on several occasions the orientation of the profession itself towards objectives such
as hygienic, military, sports, pedagogical, etc.
Multifunctional professional, where at first his exclusive function was teaching, to which he
currently expands or diversifies his field of work, ceasing to be exclusively the school his
field of work, to develop another series of functions of an administrative type, oriented to
health, sport and even to the rehabilitation or activity of promotion in work centers or in
sports-recreational centers, in attention to vulnerable groups or addictions, social
reintegration and many others such as promoters of physical activity for leisure time,
recruiters of sports talents, entertainers of parties or in activities of summer courses and
many others.
Trainer of trainers in the training institutions themselves
Researchers, for the production of new knowledge, or to rethink their own educational
practice
Train for other activities outside their primary function that was teaching in schools, thus
having other areas of intervention such as sports journalism or other functions, such as those
of leaders or administrators, specialists in educational policies in their professional area,
historians or ideologues of their profession.
However, the best way to find our professional identity is in practice itself, when we realize
what we are doing and achieving with our students, seeing their joy, the development of
their skills and that they are able to do things that they did not do before and that these
sensations and observations we share with our colleagues and make us feel good, satisfied
to know that we are contributing to the formation of our students and the aggrandizement
of our profession as a result of our work, obtaining satisfaction, a sense of belonging and
pride in what has been achieved.
In this way, Dubar, 2002, p. 256, cited by González-Calvo (2013), concludes that identity, whether
personal or professional, "is never just acquired, always in search of itself and always exposed to changes and
questions"
This is how our professional identity and that of Physical Education itself is formed.
362
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
References
Coreth, E. (1991), What is Man?, Schematic of a Philosophical Anthropology, Edit. Herder, Barcelona
García-Huidobro, R. (2013), How do we build our identity as teachers? Retrieved from:
https://www.grupoeducar.cl/noticia/como-construimos-nuestra-identidad-comodocentes/
Julián Pérez Porto and Ana Gardey. Published: 2009. Updated: 2021.Definition. of: Definition of
identity. Retrieved from: https://definicion.de/identidad/
Meaning
of
identity. February
16,
2022.
Retrieved
from:
https://www.significados.com/identidad/
González-Calvo, G., Hortigüela-Alcalá, D. and Barba-Martín, R (2018), Body image and its influence
on the development of the professional identity of future Physical Education teachers. Retrieved February
16, 2022:
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/325323913_Imagen_corporal_y_su_influencia
_en_el_desarrollo_de_la_identidad_profesional_de_los_futuros_docentes_de_Educacion_
Fisica
González-Calvo, G. (2013), Evolution of the professional identity of a novice teacher of physical education:
analysis from the reflection of his personal experiences and his own practice, Doctoral thesis, Spain.,
retrieved from: Apunts. Physical Education and Sports. 2015, No. 119. 1.er quarter (JanuaryMarch), Doctoral theses. ISSN-1577-4015
Navarrete, Z. (2008), Construction of a professional identity. The pedagogues of the National
Autonomous University of Mexico and the Universidad Veracruzana, Revista Mexicana de
Investigación Educativa, Mexico.
Noble, J. (2020), Physical Education: Traditions in Training and Professional Identity. Profession,
Semi-Profession or Trade?, InterCambios Magazine. Dilemmas and transitions of Higher
Education, DOI - HTTP://DOI.ORG/10.29156/INTER.7.1.2, Volume 7, number 1. in
Instituto Superior de Educación Física, Universidad de la República, Uruguay
Pulido, S. Bores, N. and Moreno, A. (2009), Investigando la identidad deportiva de los estudiantes de
Educación Física, el proceso de construcción y la influencia en los programas de formación inicial,
Universidad, curriculum y Educación Física, Universidad de Antioquía, Funámbulos
Editores, Medellín.
Saucedo (2021), Professional Identity of the Physical Education Student in Mexico Global Network of
Physical Education and Sport. Physical Education, research, pedagogical experiences and
projects, Revista N° 1, Spain
Zayago, Z., Chacón, M. and Rojas, M. (2008), Construcción de la identidad profesional docente en estudiantes
universitarios, DUCERE • I n v e s t i g a c i ó n a r b i t r a d a • ISSN: 1316 - 4910 • Año 12,
Nº 2 • Julio - Agosto - Septiembre, 2008 • 551 - 561. University of Los Andes. Nucleus
"Pedro Rincón Gutiérrez" San Cristóbal, edo. Táchira. Venezuela
363
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
364
Situation
_________________________________________________________________________________
Motor Education in Primary Schools in Italy, the Role of the
Teacher of Motor Science is State Law
Francesco Perrotta
UNITUSCIA University, Viterbo, Italy
E-mail: francescoperrotta@msn.com
Abstract
This study proposes the importance of teachers with a degree in motor science in primary school
movement as a fundamental tool for the development of the whole person, and as a facilitating
tool for the acquisition of motor and socio-relational skills. The data in our owner highlighted
many problems on the hours of physical education in the school and the absence of adequate
sports facilities and equipment in Italy.The Italian Chamber of Deputies definitively approved the
Budget Law which, for 2022, "With the law of the Italian State, more than 900 million are destined
for schools and with over 17 billion with the National Recovery and Resilience Plan which allow
The immediate resolution of physical education in primary school will be entrusted to the teacher
with a degree in motor science from the school year 2022/2023 we start with the fifth classes, in
2023/2024 with the fourth classes a real revolution for the Italian school .
Key words: Physical Education, Italian Primary School, Critical Pedagogy, Teacher Training,
Motor Education, Italian Primary School, Critical Pedagogy, Teacher Training
365
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
_________________________________________________________________________________
The Chamber of Deputies definitively approved the Budget Law which, for 2022, "With the law
of the Italian State, more than 900 million are destined for schools and with over 17 billion with
the National Recovery and Resilience Plan which allow immediate resolution of the health
emergency and the enhancement of school staff. The law finally after 40 years considers the
importance of physical education in primary school and will be entrusted to the teacher with a
degree in motor science from the school year 2022/2023 we start with the fifth classes, in
2023/2024 with the fourth classes a real and its own revolution for the Italian school. The primary
school program is based on learning skills and basic motor patterns, orientation to sport and the
dissemination of healthy lifestyles and proper nutrition. to further increase the active time of
children by spreading the culture of movement and psychophysical well-being. Ensuring the
presence of an exercise science teacher in the primary school staff can educate the little ones to
regular physical practice and can represent a safe investment for the relaunch of the country, to
run together towards the future and overcome the current pandemic crisis together. ". In order
to achieve the objectives of the National Recovery and Resilience Plan and to promote in young
people, starting from primary school, the adoption of behaviors and lifestyles functional to
harmonious growth, health, psycho-physical well-being and full development of the person,
recognizing motor education as an expression of a personal right and cognitive learning tool,
pending an overall revision of the teaching of motor education in primary school.
Physical education in schools is one of the most effective tools not only to improve the physical
fitness and health of pupils, but also helps them to carry out physical activity while understanding
its importance and positive repercussions for life taking into account of the European Treaty of
Lisbon of 2009 provided the legal basis for the development of sport and its promotion at
European level. The set of motor activities that each individual develops in an individual or
organized form generically referred to as "sport" is unanimously considered, after family and
school, the most important training agency through which young people can be guaranteed a
balanced development in a highly socializing context and oriented towards the permanent
acquisition of healthy lifestyles and in general bringing benefits that can be found throughout the
life span and also taking into account the recommendations that have long been disclosed by the
scientific community on the subject (crf to the European Union White Paper on Sport and the
WHO Toronto Charter) At the international level it is now recognized that overweight and
obesity are a risk factor for the onset of chronic degenerative diseases and a priority challenge for
public health. In particular, obesity and overweight in childhood have direct implications on the
health of the child and represent a risk factor for the development of serious diseases in
adulthood. To understand the dimension of the phenomenon in Italian children and the
associated behaviors, starting from 2007, the Ministry of Health has promoted the development
and implementation over time of the surveillance system called OKkio alla SALUTE, coordinated
by the National Epidemiology Center, Health Surveillance and Promotion of the Istituto
Superiore di Sanità and conducted in collaboration with the Regions and the Ministry of
Education, University and Research. Surveillance is the basis of the Italian strategies in the field
of prevention and health promotion, such as the Government Program "Gaining health" and the
National Prevention Plan and, internationally, it adheres to the project "Childhood Obesity
Surveillance Initiative (COSI) of the Region European Union of the World Health Organization.
366
Situation
_________________________________________________________________________________
The data from OKkio to HEALTH, which has a two-year periodicity of data collection, describe
the geographical variability and evolution over time of the weight status, eating habits, physical
exercise habits of children in the third primary class and school activities promoting healthy
nutrition and physical education. The frequency of overweight and obesity in children observed
at national level, in the survey, albeit slightly lower than in previous collections, confirms worrying
levels of excess weight: 22.2% of children are overweight and 10.6% obese, with higher
percentages in the central and southern regions. The widespread diffusion among children of
incorrect eating habits that can promote weight gain, especially if concomitant, is also confirmed;
in fact, 9% of children skip breakfast and 31% eat an inadequate breakfast (ie unbalanced in terms
of carbohydrates and proteins); 65% have an abundant mid-morning snack, while 22% of parents
declare that their children do not consume fruit and / or vegetables every day and 44% habitually
consume sugary and / or carbonated drinks. Even the values of physical inactivity and sedentary
behaviors, although showing an improvement compared to the past, remain high: 18% of children
practice sports for no more than an hour a week, 17% did not do physical activity on the day
prior to the survey, 44% have a TV in their room, 36% watch TV and / or play video games for
more than 2 hours a day and only one in 4 children walk or cycle to school, Positive changes are
also found in the significant decrease in children defined as "physically inactive" which go from
21.9% in 2008 to 14.7% in 2010 and drop to 12.0% in the last survey. Also with regard to adequate
eating habits, there was an improvement that went from 11.2% in 2008 to 27.7% in the last survey.
The data are also favorable for the decrease in children defined as "sedentary" (who spend more
than two hours in front of the screen a day) who go from 37.8% in 2008 to 33.0%. It is from the
need to provide both children, families and schools with elements of clarity and homogeneity of
action that the proposal for a development project for the promotion of school sports culture is
born, with specific reference to physical education in primary school. , which falls within the right
and duty to study and health and, as such, responds to educational, sporting, preventive, cultural
and social purposes. All school sport represents an essential source of experience for children, is
capable of building a permanent "lifestyle", promotes greater social and intercultural integration
and, through learning and the development of common rules, contributes to training of an ethics
of citizenship. Through physical and sports education it is possible to achieve very high
educational objectives, acquire essential skills for the training and growth of young people, such
as self-control, a sense of solidarity, the ability to collaborate for a common purpose, the
enhancement of the role of everyone and respect for the role of each. Access to the teaching of
physical education in primary school is achieved following the passing of specific qualifying
competition procedures. The physical education teacher engaged in primary school is equated, in
terms of legal and economic status, with teachers of the same level of education. The staffing of
physical education teachers is determined on the basis of at least two hours of teaching per week
for each class of primary schools in addition to the timetable referred to in art. 4 of the decree of
the President of the Republic March 20, 2009, n. 89 only for classes that do not adopt the fulltime model. Without prejudice to the responsibility of both teachers, for classes that adopt full
time, during the two hours per week of physical education, co-presence is possible ". "In order
to achieve the objectives of the National Recovery and Resilience Plan and to promote in young
people, starting from primary school, the adoption of behaviors and lifestyles functional to
367
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
_________________________________________________________________________________
harmonious growth, health, psycho-physical well-being and full development of the person,
recognizing motor education as an expression of a personal right and cognitive learning tool,
pending an overall revision of motor education teaching in primary school, curricular teaching of
motor education is introduced in school primary in the fourth and fifth classes by teachers with
suitable qualifications and the related competition class "Motor and sports sciences in primary
school" to root physical education in primary school as a natural and fundamental element for
subjects in developmental age, establishing for it some parameters through which the correct
development of the body is favored, motor coordination is encouraged and the habit of constant
physical activity is established as a fundamental premise for disease prevention, discomfort and
self-perception. Also pay attention to the relational - social area, in particular and Accept anyone
as a playmate; also Strengthen the sense of solidarity, cooperation and sharing; Develop the ability
to positively interact with the "surrounding world", Collaborate with others in the construction
of games and paths; Respect individual diversity; Spreading a culture of peace and respect among
people, including foreigners; Raise awareness of the positive dimension of the conflict; Accept
the first simple rules and the results of a game; Increase the sense of responsibility through the
understanding of social rules; Develop different forms of verbal and non-verbal communication.
Pay attention to the emotional area, Know yourself; Recognize and accept one's limitations and
weaknesses; Recognize, express, control their feelings and impulsiveness Develop autonomy and
education in the responsibility of their actions; Increase self-confidence, also calling for
autonomy, self-evaluation, self-control; Develop a sense of empathy. Develop motor skills,
Develop and enhance their motor skills, sense-perceptive skills; basic motor patterns (postural
and dynamic); general dynamic coordination; Progressively orient towards sporting practice in
compliance with a subjective psychophysical maturation process. Recognize one's body as a
mediator of achievements; Recognize movement as a source of sensory-motor pleasure; To intuit
and plan an effective motor strategy during the activities. Implement and support adult training
actions
In action, improve communication through the following training contents The training action
at primary school level focuses on the different areas considered to be inherent to the relational
area, the emotional area, the development of motor skills. support materials for teachers
interested in traveling with their section or class, itineraries of knowledge and in-depth study on
the topic. Training hours are planned at regional or provincial level for all professional figures in
order to learn together to combine the activities carried out in the school world with the technical
specificities of motor science in order to create a "common language" of shared planning
intervention .
Families The aim is also to involve families and to promote their participation, by providing a
series of thematic meetings, of an "interactive" nature in relation to emerging needs, with the help
of experts necessary to work so that parents too can increase their social and educational skills
In using the methodology, it must be pointed out that Physical Education fits into the areas of
intervention of general education, alongside the emotional, intellectual and social ones. If we
consider the personality as an integrated whole, neglecting only one aspect of it damages the
general development of the individual. This is why there can be no education if space and
368
Situation
_________________________________________________________________________________
importance are not given to physical-motor education. not practicing it means not knowing the
dynamics of the personality, the areas, its dimensions, its aspects, how they interact and influence
each other.
However, it is not intended to affirm that the motor approach is suitable for tackling any
development problem thanks to the simple mediation of the body, but rather to highlight the
importance of motor skills in the development of the child's behavior and abilities. In carrying
out the planned activities, particular attention is paid to the communicative - relational dimension,
both on the child - adult level and on the child and child level.
Each work situation takes place in a serene and fun atmosphere which, in addition to favoring
the "pleasure of." doing ", urges the" pleasure of doing together with others "thus stimulating
cooperation and support and making sure that differences can be integrated and valued. In
primary school, physical education is normally practiced above all to support the psychophysical
development of the child. Particular emphasis is given to the acquisition of the body scheme: the
body can in fact be experienced as a sort of border between the internal world and the external
world and, if these borders are damaged, the discomfort can also manifest itself through somatic
symptoms. Through motor education you have the opportunity to establish a more direct
relationship with your body; it is therefore possible to learn to perceive the sensations stimulated
in it by movement. This helps the child to feel and therefore helps him to get an idea of himself
tto in the first years of primary school then, physical education represents the opportunity to be
able to get rid of the energy accumulated in the hours of study.
At primary school the ability to emotionally evaluate events begins to be acquired. While
remaining in a phase of self-centeredness, the child begins to discover the world around him and
understands that he must relate to other people, acquiring the rules of group life. The activities
that are carried out during the workshops proposed for the pupils, even with the necessary
differences due to the peculiarities of the age being treated, take into account some fundamental
indicators: the alternation of activities the progression of the proposals consistency with the
guiding thread alternation of the activities is important to allow the child to experience himself
completely at 360 ° alternating games of movement and not, games of skill, coordination and
sports with expressive games. But the alternation concerns not only the playful aspect, also motorsports activities and games will be identified in preparation for the development of the listed
areas: socio-relational, emotional and motor; the relationship with reference adults outside the
family, the comparison with the on the other hand, having to relate to reference adults who are
not parents, gives the child the opportunity to be able to experiment outside the family. Through
play and physical education, the child explores the world around him and learns through rules to
share the spaces around him and himself with others. Through physical education, almost always
practiced in a group, it is possible to re-establish contact with the environment and with other
people, providing the child with the way to express himself and overcome communication
difficulties. Physical education, centered on the dimension of the body, favors the encounter of
the other through physical contact, mutual perception, the paths of communication and
relationships. Through the experience of experiencing movement together with others, the child
369
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
_________________________________________________________________________________
realizes that there is a dimension of himself that can be in tune with them, experiencing an infinity
of emotions that are linked to this. Sport for children is a space for growth, where you learn to
be together with others, but also, and above all, together with yourself. The sensory-motor
pleasure therefore, in addition to facilitating the desire to communicate and enter into relationship
with companions and the pleasure of being together, also gives the possibility of self-discovery
and personal resources. So that physical education, games and recreational activities aimed at the
inclusion of everyone, no one excluded, become a moment of conquering personal autonomy
and gratification that can contribute to improving self-esteem. As mentioned so far, it must
therefore be strengthened that physical education is a highly effective educational tool, especially
if it does not neglect its playful aspect. Sports education for children should not be considered as
that of adults, separating it from its dimension of play and spontaneity, but we must always
remember the pleasure and joy that children feel in moving, running, jumping.
Children need to move to play. For children, play represents an instinctive approach to the world;
through this they learn to confront themselves, with their potential and with their limits. Through
play - which is always confrontation with the other - children have a chance ssibility of: expressing
oneself, communicating, entering into conflict, experiencing frustration, facing fears, competing,
cooperating ... Furthermore, play is a great means of socialization and civil coexistence, it is
characterized by a unifying spirit, beyond all ethnic differences , cultural and religious. Children
of different cultural backgrounds can therefore enter into dialogue through play, get to know each
other and establish relationships. It is by playing that even the most complex concepts reach the
hearts and minds of children. Through the sharing of rules and the concentration of efforts, the
community is realized. When you start playing with someone, the serene acceptance of this is
implied. For the improvement of psychophysical well-being, self-esteem has been identified in
the developmental age as one of the factors most capable of defining the success of a person's
growth path. A good level of self-esteem corresponds to better outcomes in terms of well-being
and quality of life in developmental age. in the way of cases of bullying unfortunately spreading
like wildfire, see the groups of baby gangs "youth gangs today a phenomenon of organized petty
crime, widespread in urban contexts where minors have deviant behavior towards other people"
consequently becomes a "protective factor" with respect to the possibility of later becoming a
"victim": Children who evaluate themselves negatively for their abilities, consequently, are targets
of bullies. Conversely, low self-esteem is one of the factors often implicated in the genesis of
some childhood disorders such as attention deficit, cognitive and learning deficits, phobias, etc.
and adolescence such as drug abuse, antisocial behaviors, etc .: developing a healthy concept of
self at an early age certainly provides the child with fundamental tools to deal with the various
difficulties in his growth stages as in cooperative motor games.
Many researches attest that it is not always true that performance increases when trying to outdo
someone. On the contrary, the highly competitive environment generates stress and reduces the
right quality of life; but, if the competition one against the other is replaced by collaboration, safer
and more continuous results are obtained. In the competitive spirit, the motivation rests more on
the consequences of the action (winning over the opponent) than on the task to be faced. When
it is based on cooperation, the task is faced collectively: in team sports the result depends on
370
Situation
_________________________________________________________________________________
common efforts, the success of one belongs to all. The social value that team games can allow
individuals to contribute to everyone's work, thus bringing their own personal benefit. The desire
for adventure and exploration and the development of personal creativity and imagination as well
as the need for contacts and collaboration and sociality, the need for movement. It is undeniable
that among the motivations that push to practice sports education there is also self-affirmation
which takes the form of: - overcoming obstacles, distinguishing oneself from others, emerging,
fulfilling oneself, achieving success or the main motivations of competition . But you need to
know how to manage the competitive spirit, knowing that in no game you play your life, selfesteem but that every opportunity to confront an opponent is a chance to work on yourself,
discovering your own possibilities and limits, you can to say that there are two competitive styles:
task-centered (focus on your performance to hit a goal) and victory-centered. Adopting a
competitive style rather than another depends on personal tendencies, but also affects the
development of the personality itself. It has been verified that having the ability to know how to
concentrate on the task to be performed, in daily life, in study, in sport, leads to better face the
anxiety of a possible failure, to overcome the disappointment of a failure, to recharge quickly to
pursue the action, to realistically evaluate their process. When, on the other hand, one only
pursues victory, the more easily one falls prey to profound disappointment, making excuses
outside of one's responsibility. An unsatisfactory performance, in the long run, creates a sense of
desire esteem in one's abilities and undermines one's sense of self-efficacy.
Participating in physical and sports activities means sharing group experiences with other people,
promoting the inclusion of students with various forms of diversity and enhancing the value of
cooperation and teamwork. In fact, play and sport are mediators and facilitators of relationships
and "encounters". Sports education promotes the value of respecting agreed and shared rules and
the ethical values that are the basis of civil coexistence. Physical education teachers are committed
to transmitting and making children live the principles of a sporting culture that brings respect
for oneself and for the opponent, loyalty, a sense of belonging and responsibility, control of
aggression, denial of any form of violence. The motor experience must be characterized as a
"positive experience" (knowing how to be), highlighting the pupil's ability to do, making him
constantly the protagonist and progressively aware of the motor skills gradually acquired. This is
why the school should play an important role in a positive sense, helping the child to have a good
confidence, which involves his appreciation and appreciation of personal positive qualities.
Security is strengthened and built in a relational context that offers the opportunity to express
oneself and one's abilities.
Enhancement helps the child to have confidence in himself by allowing him to overcome
obstacles, failures, frustrations both in the victim and in the alleged bully without fear and
aggression. It is not possible to achieve results through abstract and generalized messages and
rules, nor through a path that acts mainly on the cognitive level; a path of affective and cognitive
development must be hypothesized with the aim of achieving, involving the values and
motivations of children and adolescents, a deep and substantial consensus to the proposed
message, that is, that the pupil decides to make it his own. In recent years, a disorder characterized
clinically by inattention, impulsivity and hyperactivity (ADHD) has aroused increasing interest in
371
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
_________________________________________________________________________________
the psychological and pedagogical field, which has presented an increase in incidence in the infant
population and has led to an ever greater increase in research. Hyperactive children are not lacking
in goodwill, but constant inattention creates learning difficulties for them, although these do not
depend on an intellectual deficit. One of the ways to be able to intervene on hyperkinetic children
is to allow them to do physical activity, even better in the open air, so as to stimulate them to
introject both respect for the rules and the freedom to move. The progressive transformation of
Italy into a country of strong immigration brings to general attention and, in particular to the
world of education, the need to redefine contexts and methods of intervention in compliance
with the plurality of citizenships and cultures to be combined for a course of social growth. There
is talk of the totality of diversities. Plurality offers the possibility of educating, of enriching
knowledge, of filling gaps and filling them, without becoming rigid in pre-established identities.
As regards the topic of motor activity, master's graduates class LM-67 Sciences and techniques
of preventive and adaptive motor activities "or in class LM-68" Sciences and techniques of sport
or in the class LM-68 can participate in the competition for professorship in elementary schools.
competition class LM-47 Organization and management of services for sport and motor activities
or qualifications equivalent to the aforementioned master's degrees pursuant to the decree of the
Minister of Education, University and Research July 9, 2009, published in the Official Journal
Official 7 October 2009, n. 233, who have also obtained 24 CFU / CFA, acquired in curricular,
additional or extra curricular form in anthropo-psycho-pedagogical disciplines and in teaching
methodologies and technologies. In the event that the competition rankings are not yet approved
in time for the recruitment of teachers in the role of the school year 2022/2023, the Ministry of
Education may also assign substitutes to subjects placed in the provincial rankings for substitutes
for referred to in article 4, paragraph 6-bis, of law no. 124 in the classes of competition A048 Motor and sports sciences n he secondary education institutes of II degree and A049 - Motor and
sports sciences in the secondary school of I degree.
The work is structured in possible cases, the number of working classes per year of the course
was obtained by scrolling forward in the following years of the course the classes active in the
school year. 2020/21; where, due to the lack of a real number of reference classes, it was not
possible to calculate the number of classes as in the previous point, it is assumed that the number
of classes per year of course remains unchanged compared to that recorded for the corresponding
year of course in the academic year An additional staff of physical education teachers has been
estimated for the normal-time classes and for the full-time classes according to the two hours per
week, as per the table below. In detail, it appears that: for the academic year 2022/23, 1,647 (=
1,408 for ordinary classes + 239 for multi-classes) will be needed more staff for primary school,
for normal time. For full-time classes 917 units will be needed (= 834 for ordinary classes + 83
for multi-classes). Total places 2,564 and for the academic year 2023/24, it will take 2,881 (=
2,642 for ordinary classes + 239 for multi-classes) additional staff for primary school, for normal
time. For full-time classes, 1,836 units will be needed (= 1,753 for ordinary classes + 83 for multiclasses). Total places 4,717.
372
Situation
_________________________________________________________________________________
Conclusions
In conclusion, this research aimed to raise awareness of the importance of expert teachers
graduated in motor science in primary school, considering Motor Education an indispensable tool
for psychophysical development in the developmental age.
With the art. 329 of the economic maneuver of the budget law aims to enhance the skills related
to motor and sports activity in primary school and to promote in young people the adoption of
behaviors and lifestyles functional to harmonious growth, health, psycho well-being -physical and
to the full development of the person, consolidating the initiatives to promote physical activity
aimed at primary school children.Scientific research confirms that regular physical activity in
primary school is very important for the psycho-physical development of the child and in order
to prevent pathologies. Within the contexts in which he lives, the educational role of movement
must emerge, the awareness that motor practice can positively influence the acquisition of healthy
and active lifestyles. A sore point that today we spend little time learning about our body in
motion and the changes that motor activity entails on it, which is essential for the process of
consciously acquiring health and well-being behaviors. School activity should program regular
physical activity, the action of the main physiological functions aimed at movement, leading the
child to develop all areas: affective, social, cognitive and motor; through which he will have the
skills to be able to make the right choice, the healthiest one. This growth will take place in a
gradual, natural, balanced way, as children are taught to eat, they can be shown how to feel good,
how to feel healthy, playing and having fun. The practical exercises, proposed as much as possible
in a playful form, are then accompanied by continuous reflections on the benefits of motor
activity in the daily life of each individual. This focus must aim at transforming the lifestyle tending
to a sedentary lifestyle into one surrounded by healthy habits, and which includes movement
activities several times a day. in this way, children will have the opportunity to choose their own
lifestyle, from which in the future they will orient themselves to gain experiences for their own
well-being and good health as adults and the elderly
References
Indire. (2013). Eurydice in breve. Educazione fisica e sport a scuola in Europa. Disponibile
in: http://www.indire.it/lucabas/lkmw_file/eurydice/Highlights_IT.pdf [1 marzo 2016]
Isidori, E. (2009). La pedagogia dello sport. Roma: Carocc.
Krueger, R.A. (1988). Focus group: a practical guide for applied research. London: Sage.
Legambiente. (2014). Ecosistema scuola. XV Rapporto sulla qualità dell’edilizia scolastica,
delle strutture e dei servizi. Disponibile in: http://www.legambiente.it/sites/default/files/docs/ecosistema_scuola_-_xv_rapporto_def1311.pdf [1 marzo 2015].
LEGGE 30 dicembre 2021, n. 234 Bilancio di previsione dello Stato per l'anno finanziario
2022 e bilancio pluriennale per il triennio 2022-2024. (21G00256) (GU Serie Generale
n.310 del 31-12-2021 - Suppl. Ordinario n. 49)
Marmocchi, P., Dall’Aglio, C., & Tannini, M. (2004). Educare le life skills. Trento: Edizioni
Erickson..
373
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
_________________________________________________________________________________
Maulini, C. (2014). Progettare il benessere attraverso lo sport. Milano: Franco Angeli.
Ministero dell’Istruzione, dell’Università e della Ricerca (2012). Indicazioni nazionali per il
curriculo per la scuola dell’infanzia e del primo ciclo di istruzione. Disponibile in:
http://www.indicazioninazionali.it/documenti_Indicazioni_nazionali/Indicazioni_
An-nali_Definitivo.pdf [1 marzo 2016].
Mortari, L. (2007). Cultura della ricerca e pedagogia. Roma: Carocci.
Organizzazione Mondiale della Sanità (2003). Skills for health. HDD/EDC (document 9). Ginevra: Organizzazione Mondiale della Sanità.
Pattoia M., Spaccapanico Proietti S,. Habluetzel Esposito E,. (2021) Movimento e apprendimento
scolastico. Prospettive metodologiche e sistemiche per la didattica interdisciplinare in
educazione motoria, Edizioni Aracne (Genzano di Roma)
Mariani AM, Peluso Cassese F. (2020) Movement and health, Edizioni Universitarie Romane
OMS, (2004) Global strategy on diet, physical activity and health.
OMS, (2009) Gli interventi sulla dieta e sull’attività fisica: ciò che funziona: relazione di sintesi.
Ginevra.
OMS, (2010). Global Recommendations on Physical Activity for Health.
OMS, (2012). Young and physically active: a blueprint for making physicalactivity appealing to
youth
Perrotta F,.(2006) Le scienze dell'educazione motoria e dello sport in età evolutiva. Crescere e
muoversi anche nelle diverse competenze Edizioni Goliardiche
Perrotta F. (2011) Didattiche e metodologie delle attività motori,Edizioni Goliardiche
Perrotta F.,(2011) Pianeta scienze motorie: il corpo, il movimento, l'azione motoria. Edizione
Simone Ellissi
Piaget J., (1970). “La psicologia del bambino”, Piccola Biblioteca Einaudi, Torino. Polito M.
(2000). Attivare le risorse del gruppo classe. Edizioni Erickson.
Play England, (2011). A world without play: a literature review. Rampa, A., & Salvetti
Tommassetti, C. (1987). L’educazione psicomotoria dai 5 ai 10 anni. Juvenila – Edizioni
scolastiche Walk Over.
374
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Issues of Outdoor Physical Education in Bibliographic Databases
Agnieszka Pasek 1 - Barbara Griffin 2 - Marcin Pasek 3
1
2
Rumia District School Complex no. 1, Poland
Metro Nashville Public Schools, Nashville, Tennessee, United States
3
Gdansk University of Physical Education and Sport, Poland
e-mail: marcin.pasek@awf.gda.pl
Abstract
The issue of physical education lessons carried out in an open natural space barely penetrates the
consciousness of all its participants, which is determined by nowadays growing sedentary
tendencies. Grounded on assumptions, this type of classes can be implemented based on
traditionally acquired knowledge, although the importance of electronic sources of support in the
sense of scientific information databases increased significantly. The aim of this study, which took
the form of a Literature query available on the Internet, was to analyze the availability of materials
on outdoor physical education lessons. The results of this review are unequivocally positive
regarding the advisability of this form of youth activities. At the same time, the relatively small
number of sources referring directly to physical education in the form of extracurricular activities
indicates the need to promote it both in articles’ publication as well as in school practice.
Key words: Outdoor physical education, Electronic databases of scientific information
375
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
The outdoor physical education lessons in the form of health training are not new in many
countries and are a response to the traditional, in-school model of physical education (Brusseau et
al., 2015; Fjørtoft, 2001). Students are expected to spend long hours in enclosed spaces, with
increased temperature, low humidity, artificial lighting, excessive dustiness and often increased
noise levels, where the condition of the air in enclosed spaces and their thermal conditions are
particularly limiting factors (Mendell, 2005). Therefore, the inspiration to avoid these restrictions
is contact with open space, even during short breaks between classes (Tran et al., 2013).
Significant values of nature visited by physically active children are the colors of nature, trees, water
areas, meadows and varied terrain, creating opportunities for climbing, which in its entirety is of
greater value than the traditional playgrounds that are offered to them (Titman, 1994). Children
exercising outdoors feel better than those exercising in the classroom (Thomson Coon et al., 2011)
and are more likely to exercise in coeducational groups (Baranovski et al., 1993). Unfortunately, in
recent decades, the outdoors physical development opportunities of children and adolescents have
been gradually reduced, which hinders their proper psychomotor development (Esbensen, 1990).
The health of the human body is increasingly being carried out outside of its ecological
conditioning, in the absence of awareness that nature is the inorganic human body and that the
human body is part of the organic order of nature (Pawłucki 1994).
The organization of school physical education still faces numerous difficulties. The main concerns
are regarding social conditions related to pupils and organizational conditions related to school
facilities. The current model of sedentary lifestyle in families proves that their physical activity in
open space or even frequent outdoor activities are very limited. In addition, during their stay at
school, children take physical education classes in corridors or in small rooms that are intended
for only corrective gymnastics. It is not uncommon for a student to enter the gym for the first
time only after completing the pre-school or early grades of elementary school. Then, students
take these classes in numerous groups, sometimes even together with upper or lower classmates.
The escape from this reality, according to still too many teachers, is possible only in short-term
periods of the beginning and end of the school year (Pasek et al., 2020). On the one hand, these
factors are not conducive to the formation of positive attitudes towards culture of being physically
active, including attitudes towards the physical education classes (Lisicki, 1990). On the other hand,
considering this phenomenon, the same factors should signal the need for development of an
innovative formula for contact between the pupil and nature in the course of their physical activity.
The achievement of the technological age creates, compared to the reality of the last century, many
additional opportunities to exchange information on the methodology of outdoor physical activity
on all levels of primary and secondary education. To a large extent, this is facilitated by electronic
scientific databases, which can be a source of inspiration not only for teachers and students, but
also for administrative staff influencing the formulation of guidelines for the education cycle. Until
recently, the lack of this type of support was the reason for only intuitive searches for better
techniques for organizing physical education classes in open space.
376
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
The scientific literature in the world is growing so quickly that even researchers representing very
narrow specialities are not able to orient themselves in everything that has been published on a
given topic. In 1970, 799 new journals defined as scientific began to appear, in 1990 2227 such
periodicals arrived, and already in 2010 – 38901 (Drabek, 2014). This exponential increase in the
number of scientific publications has meant that sources that facilitate the search for literature on
a given topic are becoming more and more important, but also play the role of a sieve, by collecting
only valuable scientific publications. This means that the seeker of information can quickly and
efficiently find the data he or she needs. Such a role is played by bibliographic databases in modern
science. The very idea of preparing metainformation on published scientific papers is not new, and
the history of creating bibliographic lists dates to the eighteenth century. However, the
development of informational technology has made it possible to transfer these lists into a virtual
space and, thanks to new functionalities, has given them a new meaning and new possibilities. Of
course, not every database is suitable as a source for all possible research. Additionnaly, how the
information collected in the databases can be used is determined by the selection of sources and
the detail of the description. The selection of sources is very important, especially in the context
of thematic databases, as well as international interdisciplinary databases. International
interdisciplinary databases (e.g., Scopus database or Web of Science Core Collection) primarily
care about indexing high-quality publications and this depends on the publishers’ decisions,
focusing on calculating special indicators for evaluating journals (e.g., Impact factor, CiteScore)
and appointing expert teams that thoroughly consider the scientific level of the journal. These
indicators are based on citations, because the creators of the databases assume that good quality
works are often cited (referred to in the annex literature). Considering the growing importance of
bibliographic databases in recent years – far beyond their original function, i.e., information
retrieval – one can notice a much greater interest in these important sources of scientific
information in the scientific community. The increase in the popularity of search engines has
certainly contributed to this, because many authors and publishers have understood that it is worth
appearing in a database in which search results are visible in the first places, e.g., in Google Scholar
(Drabek, 2014). The well-known and widely searched scientific databases, in addition to the above,
include for example Biological Abstracts, CEEOL – Central and Eastern Europe Online Library,
CEJSH – The Central European Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities, DOAJ Directory of
Open Access Journals, EMBASE published by Elseviewer or JSTOR . They are only a part of the
available sources, and it is worth emphasizing the fact that many other databases are only domestic
in nature, and therefore their descriptions are edited in the languages of individual countries.
The aim of the research was to confront the content related to the issue of outdoor physical
education, located in six selected databases of scientific journals: ERIC, Mendeley, Ebsco,
PubMed, ResearchGate and Scientific Research. Due to the limited volume of work in editorial
requirements, only the first fifty records were analyzed in each of the databases.
Research methodology
In six scientific databases updated as of February 20, 2022, 27 publications were found under the
slogan outdoor physical education, including 23 articles in scientific journals and 4 monographs. The
377
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
method of research used was to query (from the Latin Quaero - I'm looking for) literature, i.e., to
collect available information on a given topic. Usually, it involves the analysis of reports, books,
articles, websites and other publications, i.e., the so-called existing data on issues of interest to the
reader. Nowadays, it is increasingly replacing the traditional library query. Thanks to Internet-based
search engines, we obtain the most complete knowledge about the problem or theory, in which
we are interested. The result of such action is a report with a bibliography, containing a summary
of information relevant to the course of our research. There are at least two types of queries,
depending on the topic of the work and the level of its specificity. Therefore, we can talk about
more general queries, in which the key term is not sharply specified, and about detailed queries,
i.e., created for one key password, which was used in this study.
Results
The first of the publish databases analyzed was ERIC (Educational Resource Information Center).
This database contains about one and a half million records and links to hundreds of thousands
of full-text documents dating back to 1966. The thematic scope includes the issues of education,
pedagogy, and psychology. In this scientific space, the social belief in contact with nature
mobilizing for physical activity has been confirmed. The transition from traditional classroom
teaching to an outdoor learning environment reduces students' time spent sitting and increases
light to moderate physical activity during the school day. Thus, outdoor learning can be an effective
complement to traditional teaching that promotes children's physical activity (Romar et al., 2019).
Looking for a publication in this database under the phrase outdoor physical education, a report on the
holistic development of the student under the influence of physically active contact with nature
was discovered. Analyzing the effects of an educational program carried out in the open air,
accelerated physical development, but also educational and emotional development was proven
(Finn, Yan and McInnis, 2018). Similar conclusions were reached by the authors of an educational
project that was used in a group of young people from a low-income environment (Peacock et al.,
2021). An additional advantage of such lessons is their low cost, which does not require constant
readiness of the school infrastructure, as well as the possibility of moving away from specialized
equipment in these conditions. Therefore, it is not surprising that physical education classes
utilizng the values of the natural environment is a didactic method commonly used by teachers
(Gruno & Gibbons, 2020). However, in relation to the part of the teaching staff that avoids
ecological initiatives in physical education, it is worth emphasizing the need for permanent
professional development. The recently presented results of research with the participation of
teachers from English primary schools show that their professional competences were reduced in
2017 compared to 1995 (Prince, 2019). For this reason, enriching the workshop is useful,
considering the deepening phenomenon of hypokinesis on a global scale, which also does not
bypass children and adolescents (Hall et al., 2020).
Another source of information on outdoor physical education is the Mendeley database. Founded
in 2007, it is a free, closed-ended software for managing, organizing, and sharing scientific
publications, as well as getting acquainted with scientific statistics and online cooperation. Bearing
in mind the previously mentioned gradual reduction of teachers' knowledge, resources useful in
378
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
the effective implementation of the assumptions of physical activity in nature, systematic education
of teaching staff in this area is recommended. Combining the review of literature with practice, a
draft outdoor plan for the organization of games and games with personal support of nature
educators has been developed (Hatten, 2018 ). The desirability of using similar practices is dictated
by the observation of decreasing interest in using natural areas for the needs of physical education.
While in the Study of British Columbia in the 70s of the last century, the outdoor education was
systematically implemented in 55% of schools (Klassen, 1971). Nowadays, in times of increasingly
limited natural space near schools, it would be difficult to approach this result. However, then as
now, the concept of corridors of learning remains valid, which includes the use by teachers and
students of every available part of the outdoor areas (Klassen, 1971). The benefits of outdoor
physical activity do not relate only to the space of its implementation. Time is also important in
this case, and specifically the length of training units. According to the latest reports, 15 minutes
of time actively spent outdoors during the day can guarantee measurable benefits for the
psychophysical well-being of a young person. Hence the proposal for necessary adjustments in
school curricula to take account of this aspect, addressed to both the teaching staff and school
adopters and policy makers (Robillard, 2021). Concepts of this type have so far been implemented
only in the conditions of pedagogical experiments (Szark & Pasek, 2017). Their results prove the
short-term benefits of field exercises (green exercises) for the physical and emotional sphere, and
in the long term – about the possibility of shaping permanently positive attitudes towards physical
culture (Szark & Pasek, 2017). According to some, there is still too little convincing evidence that
strategies to increase the time spent outside school buildings increase the activity and physical
fitness of young people (Schaefer et al., 2014). However, this probability is high, especially
considering information about the health benefits of being in open spaces after class. The positive
effects of students enjoying nature outside school apply to both the volume of physical activity
and cardiopulmonary capacity (Schaefer et al., 2014).
Relatively few publications devoted to outdor physical education were found in the Ebsco
database. In fact, it is a database platform where articles from magazines from many countries are
recorded. Currently, there is access to several domain databases of data in the field of biology,
economics and economy, humanities, social sciences, medicine or health care. These databases
record articles from several thousand titles of foreign magazines. Many of them have full-text
access. In this database we find information that physical education is sometimes presented as a
subject with unique characteristics that can contribute to the achievement of the Sustainable
Development Goals, with the teacher playing a key role in this matter. Although a detailed analysis
of the awareness of physical education teachers in the field of sustainable development has not yet
been carried out, preliminary analyses show that this awareness is reaching a satisfactory level,
which applies particularly to women (Baena Morales et al., 2021). However, there are doubts
whether the awareness associated with good intentions is a sufficient argument for the need to
implement outdoor education programs. As the Singaporean example indicates, young people
prepared to take on work assignments as teachers imagine that the goal of outdoor education
should be to provide students with a sense of discipline and mitigate the negative health effects
associated with urban and prosperous lifestyles. Meanwhile, local researchers are wondering how
this vision of future teachers can make a convincing contribution to holistic learning outcomes
379
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
(Atencio et al., 2015). Undoubtedly, the idea arises here that the visionary plans of educators must
always be supported by logically constructed curricula. Another type of doubt, resulting from
different interpretations of the tasks that should be presented to school physical education, we are
dealing with an interesting, albeit controversial thesis about the gentle transition of students from
total dedication to computer games through games using outdoor values, known as exergames, to
full integration with the natural environment. This strategy is worth considering during COVID19, when students in many countries are pursuing school subjects online, which also applies to
physical education. However, the question arises whether participating in this form of lesson will
not prove to be counter-effective in relation to the goals set for outdoor physical activity (Öhman,
Öhman and Sandell, 2016).
The PubMed database is also covered by this review. It is a database that includes articles in the
field of medicine and biological sciences. It was founded in 1996 by the National Center for
Biotechnology Information (NCBI), part of the National Library of Medicine, part of the National
Institutes of Health. PubMed provides free access to articles in the MEDLINE database and to
some articles from journals not belonging to it. PubMed, which mainly publishes abstracts of
articles, also provides links to the website of the publisher of the journal in which the article
appeared, where in some cases its full version is available. The thematic specificity of this database
determines the low interest in matters of school physical activity. Nevertheless, the importance of
outdoor play as a way to ensure age-appropriate range of mobility has been recognised in this
space, making it a priority in childcare programming (Bruijns, Johnson and Tucker, 2020).
However, the problem may be the fact that the lack of availability of outdoor school infrastructure
for students and other people during extracurricular time is dictated by security reasons.
Nevertheless, this benefit does not seem to offset the losses associated with the lack of school
advertising and the lack of physical activity of students in extracurricular time (Evenson &
McGinn, 2004), as well as the missed opportunity to effectively shape pro-environmental attitudes
(Fang, Ng and Chang, 2017).
A very popular source of scientific information has been ResearchGate, founded in 2008, an
international, free social networking site, aimed at scientists of all disciplines. The ResearchGate
database contains over tens of millions of passwords. Each user creates a private profile where
they can publish their own scientific articles, lectures, and papers. ResearchGate also has many
features specific to social networking sites, such as the ability to exchange messages on the web,
keep in touch with other users on online forums, create a blog and participate in virtual discussion
groups. The exchange of insights within this database concerns the already analyzed thread of
stimulating movement habits through contact with the external environment of the school (Durna
& Svobodová, 2020), integrating physical activity and outdoor learning (Finn, Yan and McInnis,
2018), as well as such activities in the ecopedagogy trend as making the right choices and, as a
result, developing self-esteem (Gray, 2018). The scope of this issue is so wide that it is proposed
to organize it as part of a guide defining the methodological details of outdoor physical education
lessons (Konukman et al., 2013; Nguyen, 2015). The analysis of new methods of increasing the
effectiveness of physical education lessons is of great importance. The repeatedly mentioned in
the literature reason for this is the lack of progress of students' skills, both physiologically and
380
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
mentally. Therefore, the need for pedagogical interventions at all levels of education is indicated.
The purpose of the research aimed at better understanding of this problem was to assess the impact
of selected individual and environmental conditions such as gender, place of exercise or place of
residence on the efficiency and physical fitness of schoolchildren. The International Physical
Fitness Test and the Cooper Test were used to test fitness and regeneration. An efficiency index
and a regeneration success rate were also determined. Lessons organized in the open field had a
positive impact on the speed, jumping, and endurance of children. They also improved the rate of
effectiveness of regeneration and an increase in oxygen uptake was observed (Pasek et al., 2016).
Contact with nature seems to be an advisable form of human activity, especially in relation to
children who are not yet teenagers, for whom it can take the form of adventure education positively
evaluated by teachers (Timken & McNamee, 2012).
The last of the analyzed publication databases was Scientific Research Publishing, one of the largest
publishers of open-access journals. Currently, it publishes over 200 publicly reviewed online
journals from various academic disciplines. In this database, several problematic issues were found.
One of them refers to the negligence observed in the preparation of outdoor programs and the
training of competent educational staff in the outdoor settings. Meanwhile, the intervention of
qualified outdoor educators allows children to have far-reaching independence in accordance with
a flexible curriculum, during the implementation of which students experience positive emotions
(flow) accompanying overcoming adversity, and thus conducive to self-development (Endo,
Aoyagi and Oka, 2017). In result, it promotes their return to nature, which is extremely important
due to their audiovisual addictions (Klein, Türk and Roth, 2018). This is a much more difficult
task than in the pre-technological era. While today's child, driven by the natural need for
movement, can engage in active forms of contact with the natural environment, in a short time
after the end of outdoor activity the child regains the status of a member of the community
connected to the network. Ultimately, this should force us to implement more regularly outdoor
education strategies into current curricula (Wood, Bruce and Baxter, 2012). The trend of using
open spaces is beneficial not only for students, but also for teachers, especially young people with
professional experience, for whom educational contact with nature can be a useful experience,
bridging the gap between formal education and irregular further education (Salmi, Kaasinen and
Suomela, 2016).
Summary
Over the past decades, various solutions have been developed and proposed to introduce
innovations to school physical education. Modernity was seen in the change in the structure of the
program, in the reconstruction of the course of the lesson, in the use of forms and methods, in
the development of school infrastructure, in the intellectualization of the physical education
process, and finally, in the implementation of classes in the natural environment. Numerous
analyzed scientific reports prove the desire to look for a new, better quality of school physical
education, which is often perceived as too ineffective. The information contained in electronic
resources can be helpful in equipping teachers with the richest possible directional knowledge, but
also in developing the ability to communicate with students. Too often, the lack of a noticeable
381
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
commitment to systematically supplementing one's own competences leads to professional
stagnation. Although the information gathered in this publication seems to convince about the key
educational role of outdoor physical education lessons, in the opinion of students, teachers and
parents, conducting physical education classes outdoors is usually a necessary evil. For this reason,
lessons have been giving up full-scale physical activities carried out in open space for a long time,
except for exceptionally favorable weather conditions or in a situation where the lack of
appropriate infrastructure inside school buildings forces it. A teacher characterized by a creative
approach to his own work should use all available didactic methods, including those in the virtual
space, to modify the ways of conducting physical activities, revealing recreational, health and
ecological competences. Unfortunately, supporting the development of outdoor physical
education lessons by most teachers seems to be a less important task than indoor physical
education. The low position of these competences may result from the fact that combining
thinking about physical education focusing on outdoor education has an unsustainable tradition in
many regions of the world. This was partly reflected in the relatively small amount of information
found in scientific databases that would be devoted to outdoor physical education.
The presented results of the research lead to the conclusion about the current need to expand the
information database on the outdoor environment stimulating educational impacts at all stages of
education. As a result, lessons organized in this mode should be a more effective promotion of a
healthy lifestyle, supporting the consolidation of appropriate attitudes towards physical culture,
and thus - facilitating the functioning of a person in subsequent stages of his life.
References
Atencio, M., Tan, Y., Ho, S. & Ching, C. (2015). The strawberry generation… they are too
pampered: Pre-service physical education teachers’ perspectives on outdoor education in
Singapore. In European Physical Education Review, 21 (1), 31-50.
Baena-Morales, S., Ferriz-Valero, A., Campillo-Sánchez, J. & González-Víllora, S. (2021).
Sustainability Awareness of In-Service Physical Education Teachers. In Education Sciences,
11, 798.
Baranowski, T., Thompson, W.O., DuRant, R.H., Baranowski, J. & Puhl, J. (1993). Observations
on Physical Activity in Physical Locations: Age, Gender, Ethnicity, and Month Effects. In
Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport, 64 (2), 127-133.
Bruijns, B., Johnson, A. & Tucker P. (2020). Content development for a physical activity and
sedentary behaviour e-learning module for early childhood education students: a Delphi
study. In BMC Public Health, 23, 20 (1), 1600.
Brusseau, T.A., Burns, R.D. & Fu, Y. (2015). Contextual factors related to physical activity during
daily middle school physical education. In Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport, 22.
pii:S1440-2440 (15) 00201-7.
Drabek, E. (2014). Indeksowanie czasopism w referencyjnych bazach danych. Poradnik dla
wydawców czasopism. Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznań, Poland.
Durna, R. & Svobodová, H. (2020). Strengthening Pupils’ Physical Activity through Outdoor
Education. In Studia Sportiva, 2, 24-36.
382
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Endo, H., Aoyagi, K. & Oka, K. (2017). Outdoor Educators’ Influence on the Self-Growth
Process of Participants: A Case Study of Educators at the Buddy Kids Adventure Challenge
Program. In Advances in Physical Education, 7, 332-342.
Esbensen, S.B. (1990). Play Environments for Young Children: Design Perspectives, In: Wortham,
S.C. and J.L. Frost, eds. Playgrounds for Young Children: National Survey and Perspectives.
Reston, VA: American Alliance for Health, Physical Education, Recreation and Dance.
Evenson, K. & McGinn, A. (2004). Availability of school physical activity facilities to the public
in four U.S. communities. In American Journal of Health Promotion, 18 (3), 243-250.
Fang, W., Ng, E. & Chang, M. (2017). Physical Outdoor Activity versus Indoor Activity: Their
Influence on Environmental Behaviors. In International Journal of Environmental Research
& Public Health, 17, 14 (7), 797.
Finn, K., Yan, Z. & McInnis, K. (2018). Promoting Physical Activity and Science Learning in an
Outdoor Education Program. In Journal of Physical Education, Recreation & Dance, 89, 1,
35-39.
Fjørtoft, I. (2001). The Natural Environment as a Playground for Children: The Impact of
Outdoor Play Activities in Pre-Primary School Children. In Early Childhood Education
Journal, 29 (2), 111-120.
Gray, T. (2018). Outdoor learning: not new, just newly important. In Curriculum Perspectives, 38,
145-149.
Gruno, J. & Gibbons, S. (2020). Incorporating Nature-Based Physical Activity in Physical and
Health Education. In Journal of Physical Education, Recreation & Dance, 91 (3), 26-34.
Hall, N., Bradford, B., da Costa, J. & Robinson, D. (2020). Physical Education Teachers'
Embracement of Alternative Environment Activities. In Journal of Teaching in Physical
Education, 39 (4), 508-517.
Hatten, C. (2018). Using pedagogical documentation to build early childhood educator capacity to
support children’s outdoor play experiences. The University of British Columbia.
Klassen, H. (1971). Outdoor Education. A Procedure for Site Analysis and Selection. University
of British Columbia.
Klein, D., Türk, S. & Roth, R. (2018). Outdoor Psychomotor Activities: Bringing Children to
Nature. In Advances in Physical Education, 8, 246-252.
Konukman, F., Moore, E., Johnson, C. & Thornton, M. (2013). Planning Effective Outdoor
Lessons for Physical Education. In Journal of Physical Education, Recreation & Dance, 84
(5), 11-13.
Mendell, M. & Heath, G. (2005). Do indoor pollutants and thermal conditions in schools influence
students’ performance? A critical review of the literature. In Indoor Air, 15 (1), 27-52.
Nguyen, N. (2015). Incorporating Outdoor Education into the Physical Education Curriculum. In
Strategies: A Journal for Physical and Sport Educators, 28 (1), 34-40.
Öhman, J., Öhman, M. & Sandell, K. (2016). Outdoor recreation in exergames: a new step in the
detachment from nature? In Journal of Adventure Education and Outdoor Learning, 16, 4,
285-302.
Pasek, M., Michałowska–Sawczyn, M., Zuzda, J., Sakłak, W. & Latosiewicz, R. (2016). The impact
of outdoor physical education classes, gender and place of residence on physical capacity
and fitness of primary school children. In Medical and Biological Sciences, 30 (3), 73-80.
383
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Pasek, M., Szark-Eckardt, M., Wilk, B., Zuzda, J., Żukowska, H., Opanowska, M. et al. (2020).
Physical Fitness as Part of the Health and Well-Being of Students Participating in Physical
Education Lessons Indoors and Outdoors. In International Journal of Environmental
Research & Public Health, 17, 309.
Pawłucki, A. (1994). Zdrowotny i ekologiczny wymiar wychowania fizycznego. In Rozważania o
wychowaniu, AWF Gdańsk, 139-154.
Peacock, J., Bowling, A., Finn, K. & McInnis, K. (2021). Use of Outdoor Education to Increase
Physical Activity and Science Learning among Low-Income Children from Urban Schools.
In American Journal of Health Education, 52 (2), 92-100.
Prince, H. (2019). Changes in Outdoor Learning in Primary Schools in England, 1995 and 2017:
Lessons for Good Practice. In Journal of Adventure Education and Outdoor Learning, 19
(4), 329-342.
Robillard, A. (2021). Fresh Air: Exploring Perceptions of High School Student and Teacher
Participation in Daily Outdoor Walking Breaks for Health and Wellbeing. University of
British Columbia.
Romar, J., Enqvist, I., Kulmala, J., Kallio, J. & Tammelin, T. (2019). Physical Activity and Sedentary
Behaviour during Outdoor Learning and Traditional Indoor School Days among Finnish
Primary School Students. In Journal of Adventure Education and Outdoor Learning, 19 (1),
28-42.
Salmi, H., Kaasinen, A. & Suomela, L. (2016). Teacher Professional Development in Outdoor and
Open Learning Environments: A Research Based Model. In Creative Education, 7, 13921403.
Schaefer, L., Plotnikoff, R.C., Majumdar, S.R., Mollard, R., Woo, M., Sadman, R. et al. (2014).
Outdoor time is associated with physical activity, sedentary time, and cardiorespiratory
fitness in youth. In The Journal of Pediatrics, 165 (3), 516-521.
Szark-Eckardt, M. & Pasek, M. (2017). Attitudes to various areas of physical culture in view of
indoor and outdoor physical education lessons. In Journal of Education, Health and Sport,
7 (2), 276-285.
Thompson Coon, J., Boddy, K., Stein, K., Whear, R., Barton, J. & Depledge, M.H. (2011). Does
participating in physical activity in outdoor natural environments have a greater effect on
physical and mental wellbeing than physical activity indoors? A systematic review. In
Environmental Science & Technology, 45 (5), 1761-1772.
Timken, G. & McNamee, J. (2012). New Perspectives for Teaching Physical Education: Preservice
Teachers’ Reflections on Outdoor and Adventure Education. In Journal of Teaching in
Physical Education, 31, 21-38.
Titman, W. (1994). Special Places, Special People: The Hidden Curriculum of School Grounds.
UK: World Wide Fund for Nature/ Learning through Landscapes.
Tran, I., Clark, B.R. & Racette, S.B. (2013). Physical Activity During Recess Outdoors and Indoors
Among Urban Public-School Students, St. Louis, Missouri, 2010–2011. In Preventing
Chronic Disease, 10, 130-135.
Wood, F., Bruce, F. & Baxter, S. (2012). Children’s Participation in the Design of Physical
Activities Conducted in the Outdoors. In Advances in Physical Education, 2, 153-162.
384
Situation
________________________________________________________________________________
Students with Special Educational Needs Care within Physical
Education Classes while Covid-19 Lockdown in the North of
Mexico
Mayra Judith Jurado Neri1 - Ramón Alfonso González Rivas1 - Oscar
Nuñez Enriquez1,2,3 - Javier Bernabé González Bustos1 - Ma. de los
Ángeles Bibiano Mejía1 - Felipe Valenzuela Jurado1
1
Autonomous University of Chihuahua, Mexico
Chihuahua State Delegate FIEPS Mexico, Mexico
3
National Scientific Committee Deputy FIEPS Mexico, Mexico
e-mail: onuneze@uach.mx
2
Abstract
Physical education has faced many challenges over the years. Among these challenges are the
fact that including students with special needs has been a struggle that some teachers have faced.
This is also the case of Mexican physical education classes; however, this issue faces a higher
challenge due worldwide pandemic lockdown caused by COVID-19. Since teachers had to
understand from a different perspective how to reach and connect with their students through
another pedagogical approach, in this case a virtual environment. This was an exploratory study,
what this means is that it begins with an interpretative paradigm, in which qualitative analysis
techniques were applied with the purpose to identify an existing reality. It also had a
phenomenological design, which is congruent when it tries to go in-depth in a specific event
coming from the experience of participants. Through a Technical Pedagogical Advisor, we
wanted to explore the challenges physical education teachers faced during the lockdown and the
prospective return to face-to-face classes. Among the findings of this study for the purposes of
space we presented two scenarios: 1) Care to Students with SEN while the Covid-19 lockdown;
and 2) Prospective PE classes including students with SEN, after the lockdown, as a way to
explain the challenges confronted by PE teachers. As such, it can be said that teachers need to
explore different pedagogical strategies and learn new pedagogical skills as a way to include all
of their students, at the same time higher education institutions to provide a link between
education authorities and teachers in order to create professional development courses to
update knowledge within teachers.
Key words: Physical education, Special educational needs, Educational approaches, Mexican
teachers.
385
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
Education is considered a fundamental human right that is inescapable and universal to all
populations nationwide, this includes children and youth that show an educative special need
(ESN). On one hand, physical education environments are one of the places where the care and
attention to children and youth with ESN is placed with empathy and inclusively. It is important
to mention that currently there are a series of modifications and changes to the nomenclature
used when we are referring to children and youth with disabilities among schools, an example
is the term SEN, which is going to change to learning barriers. However, for the Public
Education Department (SEP) which is the department that runs Mexican education, the
terminology ESN is still valid (SEP, 2017). As such, the objective of this study was to identify
the different ways that children with ESN will be included in physical education classes to the
new normality among schools of northern Mexico.
Physical activity through dance, recreation, exercise and physical education (PE) contribute to
the development of a more integral and complete individual, stimulating the acquisition of new
and healthy habits, favoring the development of the body in its different forms (mind, body and
spirit) including social and psychological aspects. Therefore, it is recommended to practice at
least 1 hour of physical activity daily (WHO, 2021).
Physical education has as an objective to favor the development and implementation of physical
activity in the educational sector, using pedagogical strategies with a sports-based approach or
a student-centered approach. These aspects most of the times are a response to the social or
political contexts involved in each country. Although it is important to mention that despite the
fact that is a response to a social or political issue, it is the government responsibility to facilitate
and open access to all individuals including children and youth with SEN (FIEP 2000, 2004).
On the other hand, school is the ideal space to promote the acquisition of healthy habits through
physical activity, healthy eating, sleeping habits (Brazendale et al., 2017). Although, once the
pandemic for Covid-19 hit society, teachers and students were affected in different ways,
including their academic performance due the lockdown. It can be estimated that around 40
million of children and youth around the world could not attend their school due the pandemic
lockdown, thus, switched to a synchronous and asynchronous learning environments, which
stopped or slowed down their physical activity practices on a daily basis, which is a health risk
factor (Wang, Zhang, Zhao, Zhang y Jiang, 2020). In Mexico, since March 23rd of 2020, schools
shut down indefinitely, having virtual classes (SEP, 2020). Besides this issue it is important to
say that in Mexico at least there are 580 289 children and youth around the ages of 5-17 years
old with a type of disability or disorder (INEGI, 2020).
Meanwhile, due to the lockdown, PE classes faced different issues that prevented students with
SEN to learn what should be expected to their grade and age (Baena-Morales et al., 2020;
González-Rivas et al., 2021). This pandemic has represented a challenge to inclusion in
education (Parra, Regalado y Poma, 2020) and the return to regular classes contributes to a
386
Situation
________________________________________________________________________________
bigger challenge, because of the mental, social and motor decrements some students suffered,
product of more forced sedentary lifestyle (Chen et al., 2020). The Mexican government has
ratified their intention to suggest a voluntary and scaffold back to classes, following all safety
protocols established by the Health Department (SEP, 2021). There is a controversy among
parents, teachers and students, mostly about teachers' feelings of being prepared and ready to
teach a class with the minimum safety requirements among their students and the adequate
modifications to attend to the diversity and disabilities within the class. A goal is to promote a
better approach to attend to physical, mental and emotional health issues within the PE classes
(Chen et al., 2020). As such, teachers should be prepared for a new and more complex reality,
to reflect in the content and curriculum planned for the classes in order to offer their students
new and better ways of working (Gil-Espinosa, 2020).
The pedagogical strategies used in PE classes include that student used the same equipment,
sweat and have physical contact of some sort, which in some ways are opposite to the safety
preventions protocols due to the Covid-19 lockdown (COLEF, 2020), however, there are some
established protocols specific to each subject that does not consider how to attend students
with disabilities and/or SEN. At the same time, the lack of resources, equipment, facilities,
curriculum and school organization in the northern part of Mexico face can become a specific
issue for this context, thus, teachers must act in a different manner considering specific safety
protocols context sensitive and, in some ways, to be a step ahead of what can happen with or
without these protocols (González-Rivas et al., 2021).
As such, this research seeks to contribute, from the perspective of the administrative leadership
that includes pedagogical technical adviser, the possible modifications for a PE intervention that
holds students with disabilities and/or SEN faced in the return to face-to-face classes. To
identify and propose different actions that could contribute not only to organization,
curriculum, methodologies, approaches, but to comprehend and practice in a different way the
purpose of PE.
Methodology
This was an exploratory study, what this means is that it begins with an interpretative paradigm,
in which qualitative analysis techniques were applied with the purpose to identify an existing
reality (Maldonado, 2018). It had a phenomenological design, which is congruent when it tries
to go in-depth in a specific event coming from the experience of participants (Hernández,
Fernández, y Baptista, 2014). Also, it was a case study method, and according to Yin (1994), this
is a feasible option when a study phenomenon was found in an organic and natural way, without
any type of context manipulation.
Participants
It is important to mention that for this study it was only considered one ATP participation, due
the fact s/he holds a holistic view of teachers’ performance and the reality PE faces within the
school district s/he supervises. In this way we seek that this participant could fulfill the following
387
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
________________________________________________________________________________
criteria: 1) more than five years of experience within the educational system; 2) at least three
years as ATP; 3) to hold a graduate degree; 4) being a ATP while the Covid-19 lockdown; 5) to
have at least 10 PE teachers within his/her school district; and 6) being willing to participate in
this study.
In this case study was about a Technical Educational Advisor (ATP) from the state of
Chihuahua, Mexico (Border with the U.S.) female, 38 years old, holding a bachelor's degree in
Physical education and a graduate degree in physical education and administration. Also has 10
years within the education system, with 5 years as ATP. It is important to mention that she is
responsible for 15 PE teachers within her school district.
Instruments
A semi structured questionnaire was designed in order to inquire about the PE classes that
included students with SEN while the covid-19 lockdown. It is important to mention that this
questionnaire was validated by experts in education research. We present the following
proposed questions:
While COVID-19 lockdown
What pedagogy strategies have been implemented by the PE teachers in order to include
students with SEN in their classes?
What type barriers had teachers in your supervision found in order to teach students with SEN
in their classes?
Within the new normality
From your perspective, would you consider that schools are prepared to begin/initiate face-toface classes in August 2021?
From your perspective, how would you consider the inclusion of students with SEN in the PE
classes within this new normality?
In order to collect the data, we chose a semi structured interview, which is defined as a small
chat between two or more individuals with the goal to obtain specific information, the proposed
questions provide a starting point, however, it is flexible because the interviewer can ask
additional questions in order to obtain more information, also because, if the interviewee has
an unclear reference that would like to clarify (Díaz-Bravo, Torruco-García, MartínezHernández y Varela-Ruiz, 2013).
For the data analysis we used the qualitative software, Atlas.Ti in its version 7.5, this tool has
been useful in diverse education research projects (San Martín, 2014). It is important to mention
388
Situation
________________________________________________________________________________
that offers a friendly interface and easy to handle to coding process and categorize, however,
the analysis and interpretation of the findings are based on the researcher experience (Silva &
Carneiro, 2018)
Procedure
First of all, this project was presented and approved by the education department of Chihuahua.
Once the questionnaire was designed it was validated by 3 education experts (holding a doctoral
degree and working in PE) who made recommendations to improve it, which these
recommendations were attended to, in order to complete a final version of the questionnaire.
The research group defined the criteria that should be included in the case study, inquiring with
the education authorities an open invitation to ATP was made, but only seven responded to the
invitation. Out the seven it was chosen one in order to do this case study. One reason was
because of he is the seniority at work and hold a graduate degree. Once the participant agreed
and signed the informed consent, his anonymity was guaranteed.
In May 2021, the semi structured interview was conducted through the ZOOM software, it was
a total of 35 minutes long, this was recorded and transcribed verbatim, once the translation was
completed, this was uploaded to the Atlas.TI for its analysis.
Data analysis
The data analysis was done with an emergent design, according to Glasses (1992) this proposes
a series of steps for an open coding process, using a constant comparison a possible idea or
theme emerges that researcher’s base and use as the different categories.
Findings
Care to Students with SEN while the Covid-19 lockdown
According to the ATP, while the Covid-19 lockdown PE teachers face many problems in order
to teach effectively their classes: a) communication problems, since this depended from the
intervention of parents and/or classroom teachers; b) from some PE teachers lack of ability to
use technology, as well from parents; c) lack or null access to internet; d) grammar typos in
writing planning sent to parents via email or text message (e.g. WhatsApp); e) the need to adapt
the activity with specific equipment and space at home for students.
“The first barrier that PE teacher faced was that some of them, not all are feeling there are not
the same person anymore, since they are learning new abilities to be incorporated into their
teaching, the mail barrier was to adapt to the use of technology even though they have not used
it to reach students, in this school district there are teachers with over 15 years without using
389
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
________________________________________________________________________________
regularly a computer especially for this type of usage, before Covid they used it to plan in
Microsoft Word, other than that their ability was null, but once the COVID reached our region
and the lockdown started, distance education and trying to reach their students with or without
SEN was very complicated for them”
As it was mentioned teachers were challenged in their pedagogical intervention, placing teachers
into a very unique situation. In this way, during the lockdown, the modifications to the PE
virtual classes were null that included students with SEN, although it is important to mention
that this lack of modifications for some teachers has been a problem even before the COVID
lockdown.
“A first issue was to include the pedagogy into the virtual environment, because we need to
teach teachers how to use these types of virtual environments… they wanted to keep doing the
same as they did before the lockdown, I see this as an important aspect, because they modify a
version and considered that adapting or modifying they classes for students with SEN was
complicated; this was true because only 2 teachers reached me personally and asked me directly
how could they modify their activities to include students with SEN, for instance students with
autism”
Prospective PE classes including students with SEN, after the lockdown
According to the ATP, the near return to face-to-face classes was going to be a challenge in
itself, because education authorities and PE teachers should be prepared to used equipment and
other resources that stopped using due the lockdown. In this way, it can be envisioned that a
professional development course is needed and required to build a new pedagogical perspective;
on the other hand, to include students with SEN. However, this is an issue because of the lack
of proactivity coming from the education authorities in order to update these types of new
procedures and pedagogies needed, especially to senior teachers in every school district.
“I do see it as an important aspect to update through professional development courses to
teachers, unfortunately, there is a big issue among senior teachers, because some of them refuse
to do so…
On other hand, it can be mentioned that including students with SEN is very important, as
important as to consider and adapt facilities, and equipment as a way to be inclusive, in order
to guarantee that all students have access to a quality education. Lastly, it is fundamental to have
clarity in safety and health protocols that should be implemented with the PE classes.
“With this new normality some aspects should be considered, we are talking about certain
protocols, protocols that consider the safety and health to access some parts of schools, also to
support teachers and parents as a way to prevent issues in face-to-face classes especially in PE
classes.”
390
Situation
________________________________________________________________________________
Discussion
The findings of this study indicate that, while the Covid lockdown PE classes were affected in
their pedagogy and approaches used directly. These findings are consistent with those found by
Baena-Morales et al., 2020 and Mercier, Centeio, Garn, Erwin, Marttinen & Foley, 2021. This
implies that teachers could not find and were not prepared to use different pedagogical strategies
other than the traditional ones, but also that it took them months to adapt themselves to this
new reality teaching virtual classes.
Specifically, within the Mexican context, these findings are related to the ones presented by
González-Rivas et al. (2021), identifying that in this country the lack or null access to internet
especially in rural areas, was a mayor issue for teacher, students and parents as a way to
implement a pedagogical approach. In this way, it is important to visualize that despite the
lockdown once we return to face-to-face classes the virtual environment will continue to be a
pedagogical strategy that teachers should keep implementing within their classes, however, the
education authorities should contemplate that not all students have access to these resources.
The findings of this study show that the care to students with SEN through the virtual
environment was almost null. These findings are consistent with those by Castillo-Retamal,
Torres-Medina, Herrera-Muñoz & Faúndez-Casanova (2021). This allows us to visualize that
the return of face-to face classes, especially to students with SEN, could present higher rates of
sedentarism and obesity, as is indicated by López, Martínez, Meza and Teixeira (2022). In this
way, before the return to face-to-face classes, teachers should work in a specific way that allow
students with different needs to prevent their learning and physical lag, giving more attention
to these needs. As such, there is an activities proposal that involves students with SEN by
Guamán and Navarro, 2021.
Lastly, it is important to mention that the practical and easier practices of this study are directed
to the education authorities in Mexico. PE teachers require a constant professional development
course in order to understand the modifications and changes to provide effective classes to
students with SEN, also to a more effective way of planning that involves these aspects too.
Conclusion
Physical education classes are right that all children and youth have, teacher should develop the
specific skills in order to include all students within their pedagogical approach. In this way, it
is recommended that higher education institutions propose adapted physical education courses
and pedagogical approaches as a way to create a more inclusive approach to all teachers and
students. On the other hand, in-service teachers should be responsible to guarantee their
students to be included and being willing to create different strategies to modify and adapt their
resources and curriculum. At the same time, to create a link between higher education
institutions and educational authorities a constant professional development courses as a way
to update these strategies.
391
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
________________________________________________________________________________
Futures lines of research
This was an exploratory study due to the findings, because we cannot generalize that this shows
the reality of all PE teachers; but it allows to visualize possible future lines of research: a) inquire
about the return to face-to-face classes and professional development courses in adapted
physical education; b) analyze teachers pedagogical skill needed for students with SEN; and c)
to begin action research projects in order to find different solutions to the issues found in this
study.
References
Baena-Morales, S., López-Morales, J., & García-Taibo, O. (2020). La intervención docente en
educación física durante el periodo de cuarentena por COVID-19. Retos, 39, 388-395.
doi:10.47197/retos. v0i39.80089
Brazendale, K., Beets, M. W., Weaver, R. G., Pate, R. R., Turner-McGrievy, G. M., Kaczynski,
A. T., ... & von Hippel, P. T. (2017). Understanding differences between summer vs.
school obesogenic behaviors of children: the structured days hypothesis. International
Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity, 14(1), 1-14.doi: 10.1186/s12966-0170555-2
Castillo-Retamal, F., Torres-Medina, A., Herrera-Muñoz, M., & Faúndez-Casanova, C. (2021).
Percepciones sobre el abordaje de las Necesidades Educativas Especiales en la Práctica
Profesional Virtual de Educación Física. Retos, 42, 774-784.
COLEF, C. (2020). Recomendaciones docentes para una educación física escolar segura y
responsable ante la «nueva normalidad». Minimización de riesgos de contagio de la
COVID-19 en las clases de EF para el curso 2020-2021. Revista Española de Educación Física
y Deportes, (429), 81-93
Chen, P., Mao, L., Nassis, G. P., Harmer, P., Ainsworth, B. E., & Li, F. (2020). Returning
Chinese school-aged children and adolescents to physical activity in the wake of COVID19: Actions and precautions. Journal of Sport and Health Science, 9(4), 322-324. Doi:
10.1016/j.jshs.2020.04.003
Díaz-Bravo, L., Torruco-García, U., Martínez-Hernández, M., & Varela-Ruiz, M. (2013). La
entrevista, recurso flexible y dinámico. Investigación en Educación Médica, 2(7), 162-167.
doi: 10.1016/S2007-5057(13)72706-6
FIEPS World Manifest 2000. (2004). Lúdica Pedagógica. 1(9). doi: 10.17227/ludica.num9-7630
Gil-Espinosa, F. J. (2020). La covid-19: una carrera de fondo para avanzar en educación física.
Journal of Physical Education and Human Movement, 2(2), 1-5. doi:
10.24310/JPEHMjpehmjpehm.v2i29849
Glasser, B., (1992). Emergence v Forcing Basics of Grounded Theory Analysis. Sociology Press
González-Rivas, R. A., Gastélum-Cuadras, G., Velducea, W. V., González, J. B., & Dominguez,
S. D. (2021). Análisis de la experiencia docente en clases de Educación Física durante el
confinamiento
por
COVID-19
en
México.
Retos,
42,
1-11.
doi:
10.47197/retos.v42i0.86242
392
Situation
________________________________________________________________________________
Guamán, P.V.H., & Navarro, W. H. B. (2021). Propuesta metodológica adaptada a estudiantes
con discapacidad visual en Educación Física. Revista Arbitrada Interdisciplinaria Koinonía,
6(2), 346-363.
López, J.A.H., Martínez, P.Y.O., Meza, E. I. A., & Teixeira, A.M. (2022). Actividad física
evaluada en la clase de educación física en estudiantes de secundaria con discapacidad y
sin discapacidad antes y durante la pandemia por COVID-19. Retos: nuevas tendencias en
educación física, deporte y recreación, (43), 447-451.
Hernández, R., Fernández, C., & Baptista, P. (2014). Metodología de la investigación (6ta. ed.).
México: McGraw-Hill.
Instituto Nacional de Estadística y Geografía. (2020). Estadísticas a propósito del día del niño.
Recuperado el 7 de julio del 2021 de
https://www.inegi.org.mx/contenidos/saladeprensa/aproposito/2020/EAP_Nino.pdf
Maldonado, J., E. (2018). Metodología de la investigación social paradigmas: cuantitativo,
sociocrítico, cualitativo, complementario. Colombia: Ediciones de la U.
Mercier, K., Centeio, E., Garn, A., Erwin, H., Marttinen, R., & Foley, J. (2021). Physical
education teachers’ experiences with remote instruction during the initial phase of the
COVID-19 pandemic. Journal of Teaching in Physical Education, 40(2), 337-342.
World Health Organization (2021). Salud mental del adolescente. Recuperado el 20 de junio de 2021
de https://www.who.int/es/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/adolescent-mental-health
Parra, C. N. E., Regalado, G. A. M., & Poma, C. J. R. (2020). Los desafíos de la inclusión en
tiempos de COVID-19. Revista Scientific, 5(17), 221-239.
doi: 10.29394/Scientific.issn.2542-2987.2020.5.17.11.221-239
San Martín, D. (2014). Teoría fundamentada y Atlas.ti: recursos metodológicos para la
investigación educativa. Revista Electrónica de Investigación Educativa, 16(1), 104-122.
SEP. (2020). Boletín No. 118 No se paralizó el Sistema Educativo ante la pandemia de COVID-19;
regresará a clases fortalecido: Esteban Moctezuma Barragán. Recuperado el 10 de marzo de 2022
de https: https://www.gob.mx/sep/articulos/boletin-no-118-no-se-paralizo-el-sistemaeducativo-ante-la-pandemia-de-covid-19-regresara-a-clases-fortalecido-estebanmoctezuma
barragan?idiom=es#:~:text=El%20Secretario%20de%20Educaci%C3%B3n%20P%C3
%BAblica,de%20la%20educaci%C3%B3n%20en%20M%C3%A9xico
SEP. (2021). Boletín SEP no. 105 regreso voluntario a clases presenciales a partir del 7 de junio: Educación.
Recuperado el 5 de septiembre de 2021 de https://www.gob.mx/sep/articulos/boletinsep-no-105-regreso-voluntario-a-clases-presenciales-a-partir-del-7-de-junioeducacion?idiom=es
Silva, L. A., & Carneiro, M. (2018). O software Atlas. ti como recurso para a análise de conteúdo:
analisando a robótica no Ensino de Ciências em teses brasileiras. Ciência & Educação
(Bauru), 24(3), 715-728. https://doi.org/10.1590/1516-731320180030011
Yin, R. (1994). Case study research: design and methods (2da ed.). EU: SAGE.
393
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
________________________________________________________________________________
394
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
The Health Benefits of Physical Activity in People with
Alzheimer's Disease - A Short Review
Italo Sannicandro1 - Rosa Anna Rosa2 - Giusi Antonia Toto1
1
Department of Humanities, Literature, Cultural Heritage, Education Sciences, University of Foggia, Italy
2
Faculty of Medicine and Surgery, University of Foggia, Italy
e-mail: italo.sannicandro@unifg.it
Abstract
The guide lines published by WHO (2019) sustain the effective role of physical exercise and a
healthy lifestyle in preventing/lowering the risk of dementia and cognitive decline in the
population, and in opposing the state of fragility in people affected by Alzheimer’s disease (AD).
The inverse relationship between a physically active lifestyle and cognitive decline is widely
documented in the literature (Sofi et al., 2011, Zhao et al., 2018); physical activity is essential for
maintaining good blood circulation in the brain, which favours neurogenesis and synaptogenesis
that in turn protect against AD and other forms of dementia. The objective of this review is to
summarise the results of studies demonstrating the effectiveness and protective and/or
compensatory role of multicomponent interventions on cognitive decline in people affected by
different forms of dementia (Bacciu, Bossa, Assenza, Foti, 2017).
Key words: Physical activity, Exercise training, Older adults, Dementia, Alzheimer’s disease, Mild
cognitive impairment, Cognitive function, executive function.
395
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
________________________________________________________________________________
Physical activity and a healthy lifestyle as a strategy for preventing dementia
Alzheimer’s disease (AD), one of the most common forms of dementia, falls into the category of
primary degenerative dementia. The problem of dementia cannot be dissociated from that of aging,
and in particular from cerebral aging in relation to the degenerative forms of dementia (Gale, Acar,
& Daffner, 2018). The risk factors correlated with AD are subdivided into modifiable and nonmodifiable risk factors (Costa, Sinforani, 2020). The modifiable ones are lifestyle linked, and include
diet, obesity, cigarette smoking, excessive alcohol consumption, vitamin deficiency, diabetes,
hypercholesterolemia, hypertension, dyslipidemia, a history of cerebral trauma, cardiovascular
pathologies, vasculopathies and low levels of physical activity or other recreational activities that
engage the subject physically, mentally or socially. Different studies have demonstrated physical
inactivity to be one of the most common preventable risk factors associated with the development
of AD, and that higher levels of physical activity are associated with a reduced risk of AD (Meng,
Lin, & Tzeng, 2020). Considering that non modifiable risk factors, by definition, cannot be altered,
it is fundamental to promote the reduction of modifiable risk factors through the adoption of an
active and healthy lifestyle. At present, alongside pharmacological research, a fertile area of research
focusses on the effects of multicomponent interventions, based on cognitive rehabilitation, motor
stimulation and physical activity, in terms of the health and the quality of life of people affected by
AD (Costa, Barban, 2017). As regards the interventions based on physical activity, the guidelines
published by WHO (2019) support the role of physical activity and a healthy lifestyle as important
strategies for the prevention of dementia and the risk of cognitive decline in the general population.
A number of studies have demonstrated that physical exercise, carried out as an integral part of
programmes for the prevention and care of AD, improves cognitive-behavioural functions,
enhances somatosensorial stimulation, improves performance in daily life tasks, and opposes the
fragility that brings about a dramatic and disproportionate change in the state of health of older
adults with or without AD; a state of fragility means that elderly individuals pass from a condition
of independence to dependence, from mobility to immobility, from postural stability to falls (Clegg,
Young, Iliffe, Rikkert, & Rockwood, 2013). These changes, which also occur in people affected by
various forms of dementia, expose people to an increased risk of falls – one of the most common
causes of disability and death in the elderly population (Bacciu, Bossa, Assenza & Foti, 2017).
Therefore, in order to contrast situations of dependency, intervention programmes aimed at
maintaining or strengthening daily life motor capacities are required (Sannicandro, 2013).
Over recent years, a great deal of research effort has gone into studies looking at ways of slowing
down the processes of cerebral aging by reinforcing the protective factors linked to lifestyle that
may decelerate or block the mechanisms of neurodegeneration in AD. Of these, the approach
which has received the greatest amount of attention is the increase in physical activity, which has
been shown to have the most significant effect, both in terms of slowing down the progression of
cognitive degeneration in subjects in the early stages of dementia and even more so in reducing the
prevalence of dementia in the elderly population (Erickson et al., 2018).
396
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Multicomponent adapted physical activity interventions: a brief review of the literature
The review was conducted according to the PRISMA guidelines (Liberati et al., 2009), using the
Web of Science (WOS), PubMed (Medline) and Scopus databases, and considering articles
published from 2010 to 2021. The searches were carried out using the following key words in
isolation or combination: exercise, physical activity, exercise training, older adults, dementia,
Alzheimer’s disease, mild cognitive impairment, cognitive function, executive function.
The inclusion criteria were:
• articles with interventions based on physical activities/exercise, and for which an analytical
description of the type, duration, frequency and intensity of the activities used was provided
in the study protocol, the aim of which was to assess the effects of the intervention on
cognitive decline in healthy elderly subjects or those affected by different forms of dementia;
• the presence of clinically relevant information related to the impact of modifying lifestyle
factors on the prevention of the various forms of dementia.
• Following the initial section of articles based on the aforementioned inclusion criteria,
replicates retrieved from different databases were identified and eliminated; articles were then
excluded that addressed the problem from exclusively the physiological point of view, as well
as literature review articles, case reports, and studies written in languages other than English
(Faieta et al., 2021).
In the study by Gregory, Parker & Thompson (2012), the results revealed that elderly people
performing any form of physical exercise demonstrated better cognitive function compared with
those who did not partake in any physical exercise and did not develop dementia. Physical exercise
was shown to be efficient not only as a factor able to prevent normal cerebral aging but also as a
valid non-pharmacological approach to protecting against Alzheimer’s disease. Ngandu et al. (2015)
clearly demonstrated that cognitive stimulation techniques and a hypolipidic diet associated with
regular physical exercise were able to reduce the progression of dementia over time. Zhang and
Zhang (2016) discovered that irisin is secreted by muscles in response to physical activity. This
finding is relevant as the hormone is present in minimal qualities in the hippocampus of subjects
with AD, and has been shown to have a protective effect on synapses and memory, even in the
presence of beta-amyloid plaques. Of consequence, the increase in the levels of irisin in the brain
obtained during physical activity may counterpose the processes leading to cognitive decline, as a
“barrier” that counteracts against processes already activated. Liu-Ambrose et al. (2010) described
the effects of 52 weeks of resistance training to combat cognitive decline in healthy elderly
individuals and found that a weight training programme was able to improve selective attention as
well as muscle function. The authors suggested that resistance training should be considered a valid
adjunct therapy to be recommended alongside pharmacological therapy.
Erickson et al. (2011) analysed the effects of a one-year exercise protocol based on aerobic walking
vs stretching on hippocampal perfusion and serum levels of brain-derived neurotrophic factor
(BDNF). The results show that aerobic exercise selectively increases the volume of the anterior
hippocampus, but they did not demonstrate bigger variations in the serum levels of BDNF with
397
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
________________________________________________________________________________
respect to the stretching only group. The one-year aerobic training protocol resulted in a 2%
increase in hippocampal volume and compensated for ageing-related degeneration. These results
clearly indicate that aerobic exercise is neuroprotective and that starting an exercise routine later
on in life can be effective at improving cognitive function and increasing cerebral volume.
Anderson-Hanley et al., (2012) examined the improvements in executive function following virtual
reality cycling exercises (“cybercycle”) compared with traditional exercises. They analysed the
improvements brought about according to the type of exercise programme as well as rises in
BDNF. The experimental group carried out cybercycle activities for three months, while the
control group performed pedalling-only exercises on a traditional static bike. At the end of the
activities, the authors found significant differences between the experimental and the control
group, with a reduction in the risk of the clinical progression of mild cognitive impairment (MCI)
and potentiated neuroplasticity in the cybercycle group resulting from/associated with the greater
interaction between BDNF values and activity type and duration. The results suggest that for an
equal intensity of effort, the experimental group performed better in tests of cognitive function
compared with the group performing traditional exercises, indicating that simultaneous cognitive
and physical exercise has a greater potential to prevent cognitive decline.
Hagovska & Nagyova (2016) compared the efficacy of cognitive and physical training on cognitive
function and its effects upon activities of daily living (ADL). Their sample, composed of older
adults with mild cognitive decline, was divided into an experimental group and a control group.
Both groups carried out physical training aimed at improving muscle strength in the lower limbs
and balance; in addition, the experimental group also performed a cognitive training programme
“CogniPlus”. The study showed that cognitive training combined with physical training had a
greater effect on the majority of cognitive functions and ADL compared with physical training
only.
The objective of the study by Müller et al. (2017) was to evaluate whether a dance training
programme increased neuroplasticity with respect to conventional fitness activities and whether
continuing the training programme for extended periods of time brought about any additional
advantages. For 18 months a group of healthy elderly people, randomly assigned to the dance or
conventional fitness group, carried out the programmed activities. The subjects in the dance group
participated in a programme in which they were constantly required to learn new sequences of
movements. The participants in the fitness group completed a conventional resistance and strength
training programme. After six months, the authors detected a significant increase in the volume of
grey matter in the left precentral gyrus in the dance group which did not occur in the fitness group.
This neuroplastic effect could have been mediated by the increase in the plasma levels of BDNF
observed in the dance group. Furthermore, an increase in volume was observed in the
parahippocampal region after 18 months of dance training. The results suggest that long-term
participation in a dance programme that requires constant cognitive and motor learning is better
able to induce neuroplasticity in the brains of elderly subjects. Therefore, dance should be
considered an appropriate activity for opposing age-related reductions in grey matter.
398
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Yu et al. (2018) evaluated the efficacy and the synergic effects of a “combined cycling and speed
of processing training intervention” on cognition in older adults with amnestic mild cognitive
impairment. At the end of the study, the authors showed that combined aerobic exercise and
cognitive training can have a synergic effect on cognition, reinforcing various neural functions in a
complementary manner.
Song & Yu (2019) investigated the effects of a moderate-intensity aerobic exercise programme on
cognitive function and quality of life correlated with health in a group of elderly Chinese subjects
with mild cognitive degeneration. The experimental group performed an aerobic exercise
programme of moderate intensity for 16 weeks, while the control group underwent a health
education programme (as attention-placebo control). The authors reported improvements in the
experimental group in cognitive function (memory, executive function, attention, language, visualspatial abilities) and quality of life with respect to the control group.
Casas-Herrero, et al. (2019) examined whether a multicomponent exercise programme called
VIVIFRAIL, previously shown to reverse functional decline associated with acute hospitalization
in very old patients, produced the same beneficial effects on the functional and cognitive state in
pre-frail/frail patients with MCI or dementia. The patients assigned to the control group received
normal outpatient care, including physical rehabilitation as necessary. The experimental group
participated in a training programme consisting of resistance, cardiovascular, balance and flexibility
exercises (VIVIFRAIL). At the end of the study, the authors revealed that the VIVIFRAIL
programme designed for frail elderly patients with cognitive deficit was more effective at reducing
functional and cognitive degeneration compared with conventional treatments.
The objective of the study by Raichlen et al. (2020) was to evaluate the effects of combined
cognitive and aerobic exercise training on dual-task walking performance in healthy older adults.
The participants were randomly assigned to one of four parallel interventions: 1) cognitive training
(COG), 2) aerobic exercise (EX), 3) combined aerobic exercise and cognitive training (EXCOG),
and 4) video-watching control (CON). All the interventions involved three days of training a week
for a total of 12 weeks.
The authors reported a significant improvement in the cognitive performance in the EXCOG
group after 6 and 12 weeks of training. The participants of the EX group showed a significant
improvement in cognitive performance only after 12 weeks of training.
The participants in the COG group also showed a significant improvement after 12 weeks of the
intervention, but an effect size less than half that of EXCOG (0.43). The CON group did not show
any significant changes in cognitive performance at any of the time points. The results of this study
suggest that a 12-week intervention that combines multiple cognitive tasks with aerobic exercise in
healthy older people can improve their cognitive performance. On the basis of these results, the
authors recommend the employment of activities that require the use of dual tasks (cognitive and
motor) as part of the therapeutic pathway in patients with various forms of dementia.
399
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
________________________________________________________________________________
Yu, Salisbury & Mathiason (2021) examined the inter-individual differences in aerobic capacity and
cognitive responses after an intervention involving 6 months of aerobic exercises in older adults
with mild and/or moderate AD. The seniors in the experimental group carried out 3 lessons a week
for 6 months; each session included a 5-minute warm-up and cool-down before and after moderate
to vigorous cycling and stretching exercises. The duration of the lessons was gradually increased
from 30 to 60 minutes. The control group carried out stretching exercises only. The authors show
that the experimental group recorded bigger changes with respect to the control group at the end
of the 6-month intervention; inter-individual differences were recorded in both the fitness and
cognitive components. According to the authors, true inter-individual differences in aerobic
capacity and in the cognitive responses to aerobic exercise exist in older adults with mild-tomoderate dementia due to AD, but that a better understanding of these differences requires further
research.
Conclusions
Over recent years research activities directed at analysing and describing the combined effects of
cognitive and physical exercise on the prevention and treatment of the various forms of dementia
has grown greatly. This review presented just some of the articles reporting the most advanced
research in the field of adapted physical activity, awareness of which will be important for the
construction of inter-disciplinary approaches that aim to reduce excess disabilities resulting from
cognitive alterations and to support and oppose deficits in executive function, memory, spatialtemporal disorientation, perceptions and language, all of which may become compromised in
dementia.
Some research studies demonstrate that the combination of cognitive and physical exercises can
be more efficacious than single interventions. Exergaming is a typical example that combines
physical exercise with interactive virtual reality, thereby supplying cognitive stimulation while taking
part in physical activity such as, for example, exercises carried out on a stationary bike equipped
with virtual reality tours (Meng, Yang, Ji, Xuewen, Ran, 2018). Physical and cognitive activities
performed simultaneously have a greater potential to improve global cognition (working memory,
episodic memory and executive function) and enhance frontal cognitive functions, walking gait and
neuroplasticity; while aerobic or resistance training, although unable to improve episodic memory,
by improving cardiorespiratory fitness they sustain cerebral function, attenuate age-related changes
to the myelinated axons in the corpus callosum and support white matter integrity (Meng, Yang,
Ji, Xuewen, Ran, 2018).
Higher levels of aerobic fitness reduce hippocampal decay, increase hippocampal volume and, by
consequence, result in better spatial memory performance (Meng, Yang, Ji, Xuewen, Ran, 2018).
A particular current day problem with the potentially significant implications is represented by
cognitive decline, and forecasts for the medium and long term indicate that the number of people
with dementia will continue to grow, in particular in very old people and in industrialized countries
(WHO, 2012). These numbers have pushed researchers into investigating the causes underlying the
onset of the different types of dementia and to study strategies useful for preventing their onset or
400
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
to oppose their damaging effects on health. In addition to advances made in early diagnosis,
pharmacological treatments and the development of new research techniques, the area presently
enjoying increased research attention is that of lifestyle changes; increasing physical activity as a
“non-pharmacological therapy” is of particular interest due to its ability to slow down the
progression of cognitive impairments in subjects with early symptoms of dementia, and because of
its capacity to reduce the incidence rate of dementia in the elderly population (Erickson, et al.,
2018).
References
Anderson-Hanley, C., Arciero, P. J., Brickman, A. M., Nimon, J. P., Okuma, N., Westen, S. C.,
Merz, M. E., Pence, B. D., Woods, J. A., Kramer, A. F., & Zimmerman, E. A. (2012).
Exergaming and older adult cognition: a cluster randomized clinical trial. American journal of
preventive medicine, 42(2), 109–119. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.amepre.2011.10.016
Bacciu, S., Bossa, M., Assenza,, C., Foti, C., (2017). Il progetto individuale riabilitativo nella persona
con demenza, pagg.412-421 In Sancesario, G., Caltagirone,C. (2017). Malattia di Alzheimer e
altre demenze. Diagnosi e terapia integrata. Società Editrice Universo, Roma.
Casas-Herrero, A., Anton-Rodrigo, I., Zambom-Ferraresi, F., Sáez de Asteasu, M. L., MartinezVelilla, N., Elexpuru-Estomba, J., Marin-Epelde, I., Ramon-Espinoza, F., PetidierTorregrosa, R., Sanchez-Sanchez, J. L., Ibañez, B., & Izquierdo, M. (2019). Effect of a
multicomponent exercise programme (VIVIFRAIL) on functional capacity in frail
community elders with cognitive decline: study protocol for a randomized multicentre
control trial. Trials, 20(1), 362.https://doi.org/10.1186/ s13063-019-3426-0.
Clegg, A., Young, J., Iliffe, S., Rikkert, M. O., & Rockwood, K. (2013). Frailty in elderly
people. Lancet (London, England), 381(9868), 752–762. https://doi.org/ 10.1016/S01406736(12)62167-9
Costa, A., Barban, F. (2017). La riabilitazione cognitiva nel paziente con demenza neurovegetativa,
pagg.453-462 In Sancesario, G., Caltagirone,C. (2017). Malattia di Alzheimer e altre demenze.
Diagnosi e terapia integrata. Società Editrice Universo, Roma.
Costa, A., Sinforani D., (2020). Le demenze. Manuale di diagnosi e trattamento, NEMS
Erickson, K. I., Voss, M. W., Prakash, R. S., Basak, C., Szabo, A., Chaddock, L., Kim, J. S., Heo,
S., Alves, H., White, S. M., Wojcicki, T. R., Mailey, E., Vieira, V. J., Martin, S. A., Pence, B.
D., Woods, J. A., McAuley, E., & Kramer, A. F. (2011). Exercise training increases size of
hippocampus and improves memory. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United
States of America, 108(7), 3017–3022. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1015950108.
Erickson, K. I., Hillman, C., Stillman, C. M., Ballard, R. M., Bloodgood, B., Conroy, D. E., et al.
(2018) Physical acrivity guidelines advisory committee* (2019). Physical Activity, Cognition,
and Brain Outcomes: A Review of the 2018 Physical Activity Guidelines. Medicine and science
in sports and exercise, 51(6), 1242–1251. https://doi.org/10.1249/MSS.0000000000001936
401
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
________________________________________________________________________________
Faieta, J. M., Devos, H., Vaduvathiriyan, P., York, M. K., Erickson, K. I., Hirsch, M. A., Downer,
B. G., van Wegen, E. E. H., Wong, D. C., Philippou, E., Negm, A., Ahmadnezhad, P.,
Krishnan, S., Kahya, M., Sood, P., & Heyn, P. C. (2021). Exercise interventions for older
adults with Alzheimer's disease: a systematic review and meta-analysis protocol. Systematic
Reviews, 10(1), [6]. https:// doi.org/10.1186/s13643-020-01555-8.
Gale, S. A., Acar, D., & Daffner, K. R. (2018). Dementia. The American journal of medicine, 131(10),
1161–1169
Gregory, S. M., Parker, B., & Thompson, P. D. (2012). Physical activity, cognitive function, and
brain health: what is the role of exercise training in the prevention of dementia? Brain sciences,
2(4), 684–708. https://doi.org/10.3390/brainsci2040684
Hagovska, M., & Nagyova, I. (2016). The transfer of skills from cognitive and physical training to
activities of daily living: a randomised controlled study. European journal of ageing, 14(2), 133–
142. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10433-016-0395-y
Liberati, A., Altman, D. G., Tetzlaff, J., Mulrow, C., Gøtzsche, P. C., Ioannidis, J. P., Clarke, M.,
Devereaux, P. J., Kleijnen, J., & Moher, D. (2009). The PRISMA statement for reporting
systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate healthcare interventions:
explanation and elaboration. BMJ (Clinical research ed.), 339, b2700.
https://doi.org/10.1136/ bmj.b2700.
Liu-Ambrose, T., Nagamatsu, L., Graf, P., Beattie, BL., Ashe, MC., Handy, TC. (2010). Resistance
Training and Executive Functions: A 12-Month Randomised Controlled Trial. Archives of
internal medicine. 170 (2), 170-178.
Meng, Q., Lin, M. S., & Tzeng, I. S. (2020). Relationship Between Exercise and Alzheimer's
Disease: A Narrative Literature Review. Frontiers in neuroscience, 14, 131.
https://doi.org/10.3389/fnins.2020.00131
Müller, P., Rehfeld, K., Schmicker, M., Hökelmann, A., Dordevic, M., Lessmann, V., Brigadski, T.,
Kaufmann, J., & Müller, N. G. (2017). Evolution of Neuroplasticity in Response to Physical
Activity in Old Age: The Case for Dancing. Frontiers in aging neuroscience, 9, 56. https: //doi.
org/ 10.3389/ fnagi.2017.00056.
Ngandu, T., Lehtisalo, J., Solomon, A., Levälahti, E., Ahtiluoto, S., Antikainen, R., Bäckman, L.,
Hänninen, T., Jula, A., Laatikainen, T., Lindström, J., Mangialasche, F., Paajanen, T., Pajala,
S., Peltonen, M., Rauramaa, R., Stigsdotter-Neely, A., Strandberg, T., Tuomilehto, J.,
Soininen, H., Kivipelto, M. (2015). A 2-year multidomain intervention of diet, exercise,
cognitive training, and vascular risk monitoring versus control to prevent cognitive decline
in at-risk elderly people (FINGER): a randomised controlled trial. Lancet (London, England),
385(9984), 2255–2263. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(15)60461-5.
Raichlen, D.A., Bharadwaj, P.K., Nguyen, L.A. Franchetti, M.K, Zigman, E. K. Solorio A.R
& Alexander G. E.. (2020). Effects of simultaneous cognitive and aerobic exercise training
on dual-task walking performance in healthy older adults: results from a pilot randomized
controlled trial. BMC Geriatrics 20, 83.
Song, D., & Yu, D. (2019). Effects of a moderate-intensity aerobic exercise programme on the
cognitive function and quality of life of community-dwelling elderly people with mild
cognitive impairment: A randomised controlled trial. International journal of nursing studies, 93,
97–105. https:/ /doi.org/ 10.1016/ j.ijnurstu. 2019.02.019.
402
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Sannicandro, I. (2013). Le attività motorie per i senior. Caratteristiche del senior. Evidenze scientifiche. Aspetti
metodologici. Correre, Milano
Zhang, Jing and Zhang, Weizhen (2016). Can irisin be a linker between physical activity and brain
function?" Biomolecular Concepts, 7, (4), 253-258. https://doi.org/10.1515/bmc-2016-0012
World Health Organization, (2019). Risk reduction of cognitive decline and dementia: WHO guidelines.
Geneva: World Health Organization; 2019. Licence: CC BY-NC-SA 3.0 IGO.
World Health Organization. (2012). Dementia: a public health priority. World Health Organization.
Geneva, https://apps. who.int/iris/handle/10665/75263.
Yu F, Lin FV, Salisbury DL, Shah KN, Chow L, Vock D, Nelson NW, Porsteinsson AP, Jack C
Jr. (2018). Efficacy and mechanisms of combined aerobic exercise and cognitive training in
mild cognitive impairment: study protocol of the ACT trial. Trials. Dec 22;19(1):700. doi:
10.1186/s13063-018-3054-0. PMID: 30577848; PMCID: PMC6303946.
Yu, F., Salisbury, D., & Mathiason, M. A. (2021). Inter-individual differences in the responses to
aerobic exercise in Alzheimer's disease: Findings from the FIT-AD trial. Journal of sport and
health science, 10(1), 65–72. https: //doi. org/10.1016/ j.jshs.2020.05.0
403
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
________________________________________________________________________________
404
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Physical Literacy as a Health Option for Children: Overweight and
Obesity a Rising Problem
Liliana Aracely Enríquez del Castillo1 - Oscar Núñez Enríquez 1,2 –
Luis Alberto Flores Olivares1
1
Autonomous University of Chihuahua, Chihuahua, Mexico
International Federation of Physical and Sport Education, Mexico
e-mail: onuneze@uach.mx
2
Abstract
Currently, Mexico presents high rates of childhood overweight and obesity; and several risk factors
that affect the development of non-communicable diseases have been observed from early ages.
Furthermore, a lack of physical activity is a global issue that is especially prevalent in Mexican
children. One of the primary aid initiatives is to adopt physical literacy, which aids in the
improvement of motor skills such as conditional physical abilities and coordination abilities in
schoolchildren, as well as the rise of physical activity levels and health indicators. A healthy lifestyle
from early age permits an impact on the adult age, especially since children who present obesity or
sedentary behavior are more likely to stay with obesity and develop other comorbidities in their
adult life. One of the main reasons for taking awareness over a healthy lifestyle in the childhood
period is through physical education classes. The physical education pedagogical approach
represents an ideal space for physical literacy application in order to help minimize issues such as
public health that includes overweight and obesity; however, there are issues to consider for proper
implementation. This chapter examines the fundamental aspects of physical literacy as well as
recommendations for incorporating it into physical education, highlighting benefits and possible
strategies for achieving optimal outcomes.
Key words: Physical education, Physical literacy, Overweight, Obesity, Pedagogical approach
405
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Physical Literacy as a health option in schools: against overweight and obesity
The concept of health should not be seen only as a conceptual term, but rather as a right for all
individuals, in which, this concept can be seen from a political perspective, and as an indicator of
the country's development. That is why governments and public policies must take different
actions that benefit their community, which have an impact on preventive strategies that allow
raising the quality of life of their population. It is important to take into account the main health
problems of the Mexican population, since, during the report presented by the National Institute
of Public Health, it mentions that more than 35% of all deaths in Mexico are attributed to
preventable diseases, such as heart diseases and diabetes (ENSANUT, 2018).
Overweight and obesity in Mexico are a problem that can be presented from early childhood, so
there are currently two conditions that begin to overtake within society, which are fatness and
sedentary lifestyle, where both complement each other to develop a disease and potentiate other
ones with high mortality rates, where children can become more vulnerable due to the social,
economic, health, and other factors.
The most recent data from the National Survey of Health and Nutrition, 2018 (ENSANUT)
indicate that 22.2% of the population age 0 to 4 is identified being at risk of being heavy, while the
prevalence of overweight and obesity in the population from 5 to 11 years of age has 35.6% with
an increase as the years go by related to this prevalence. Obesity among children and adolescents
has become one of the most serious public health problems of the 21st century. The global
prevalence of childhood weight problems has increased rapidly over the past 3 decades (Di Cesare,
Sorić, Bovet, Miranda, Bhutta, Stevens, & Bentham, 2019). On the other hand, overweight, obesity
and abdominal obesity in early stages are risk factors for the future that are associated with an
increase in chronic diseases such as type 2 diabetes mellitus, arterial hypertension, dyslipidemia,
cardiovascular diseases, breast cancer, osteoarthritis, and even depression (Muñoz & Arango, 2017;
Chacín, Carrillo, Rodríguez, Salazar, Rojas, Añez & Bermudez, 2019), an alarming situation for the
school stage.
An aid to this great problem would be the increase in hours of physical activity in schools, where
actions are carried out to develop physical literacy, a term used that, based on the facts, could help
combat this problem, since from physical literacy it is possible to develop conditional physical
abilities and coordination abilities of schoolchildren in order to achieve children to be more active
and a better health, eradicating the problems of sedentary lifestyle and obesity. Some prevention
alternatives could be the promotion of comprehensive educational activities as well as knowledge
of eating plans and physical activity, which society may adopt through teaching in schools.
The new paradigm lies in understanding that the advantage of preventing a disease or its
complications is greater than that obtained by treating it, even care is timely and appropriate.
Prevention is always better than treatment and the benefit of education by and for health will have
to show, in the medium and long term, important benefits and impacts on the population. In short,
406
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
the challenges to be met are multiple, however, they are identifiable and there are low-cost, highimpact solutions (Córdova-Villalobos, 2009).
Physical activity as a way to develop physical capacities in physical education
Through physical literacy within the physical education classes, it is possible to develop
coordinative capacities, which are determined by the ability to capture and process information by
the analyzers involved in the movement. Therefore, they fundamentally depend on the central
nervous system such as coordination, coupling, orientation, balance, change, rhythm, laterality, and
relaxation. In fact, conditional physical abilities are those that are limited by the efficiency of energy
metabolism, strength, endurance, speed, and flexibility. There are some other limiting factors of
the conditional capacities, which depend on the energy of the muscles and on the mechanisms that
regulate their supply, capacities that we will work on at the primary and secondary levels together
with the coordinative ones.
The main physical abilities, which can be developed through physical literacy, both coordinative
and conditional, are described below:
Strength: It is the motor capacity to overcome resistance through the opposition exerted by
muscular tension (Castañer and Camerino, 1993). It is the ability to apply an impulse. It is the
neuromuscular ability to overcome external and internal resistance (Bompa, 2002). Muscular
strength: the maximum amount of force that can be generated by a muscle or muscle group
(Howley and Powers, 2000).
When it comes to working on strength, during the stage of physical literacy, it must be done
globally and through motor skills, since girls and boys are in full growth, every time must be taken
into account the level of complexity of the contents being progressive and always adapted to the
possibilities and limitations of the students. Some activities to propose the development of
strength in classes would be: pushing, pulling, climbing, jumping, throwing, quadrupeds, etc. In all
of them, it is necessary to emphasize the importance of adopting a good body posture.
Power: they are dynamic exercises in which the most important muscles simultaneously manifest
relatively significant force and speed of contraction, that is, great power (Platonov and Bulatova,
2019). The ability of the neuromuscular system to develop a maximum increase in force after the
start of the contraction. It is the greatest development of force per unit of time (Samulski, Menzel,
and Prado, 2013).
Aerobic resistance: It is the ability to withstand the state of progressive fatigue that occurs in longterm work (Castañer and Camerino, 1993).
Endurance work should focus on developing aerobic endurance at low and medium intensities in
a global and playful way, or with high-intensity interval training (HIIT). For the evaluation of this,
407
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
there are different tests, such as the linear load functional cooper test, the Course Navette test
progressive functional test, and it is important to adapt to the characteristics of the students with
whom we work.
The benefits of resistance are: increased respiratory capacity, reduction of fatty tissue,
improvement of capillarization and vascularization of the muscle, helps prevent coronary diseases
in adulthood, and compensates for stress.
Speed: set of functional properties that allow motor actions to be executed in a minimum time.
Speed is the basic physical ability that allows us to make one or more movements in the shortest
possible time (Platonov and Bulatova, 2019).
The work must be carried out globally and always through skills and coordination aspects. Reaction
speed and gestural speed can be worked on from 7 or 8 years old. When it comes to travel speed,
we will focus on short distances. Some of the activities to be carried out to develop this ability
would be coordination games in the first cycles, relay races, jumps, chases, exits responding to
different stimuli.
Benefits of speed: increased attention and concentration, allows faster and more efficient
movements, and stimulates the functioning of the central nervous system.
Flexibility: Range of movement that the joints have with the greatest possible amplitude, facilitating
the mobility of the muscles in physical activity, the importance of performing flexibility exercises
has been established, which lies in the fact that they reduce the possibility of injuries, muscular
pains and possible inflammation associated with joint stress due to more rigorous activities
(Forteza Soler, Comellas and de Viñaspre, 2013). It is the ability to maximize the range of motion
in a given joint which is developed through stretching exercises at the end of each exercise session
(Naclerio et al., 2011).
It is a quality that, based on joint mobility, muscle extensibility and elasticity, allows the maximum
travel of the joints in different positions, allowing the subject to perform actions that require great
agility and dexterity (Castañer and Camerino, 1993). Flexibility must be worked on at all stages and
may be present at all phases of the session, although the warm-up and cool-down phases are the
ones that favor dynamic methods in the first levels and from the second third of primary and
secondary use static methods. We can work on flexibility in a playful way through circuits by
stations, using both mobility exercises and stretching.
Benefits of working on flexibility: it will help improve coordination, prevent different injuries of
the musculoskeletal system, help care for postural hygiene and increase the performance of other
physical capacities: strength-speed-resistance.
408
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Coordination: is the ability to combine various complex movement patterns into a single distinctive
movement, this skill is learned and improved by performing gymnastic exercises such as pull-ups,
rope climbing, push-ups, sit-ups, handstands, pirouettes, among others (Samulski, Menzel and
Prado, 2013).
Trying to fit this idea and fully respect the educational model that is present, the benefits of
working with force are: improving muscle tone, greater performance to perform the tasks of daily
life, or preventing some postural diseases.
Within the area of physical education, we must look for the motor enrichment and the harmonic
development of the student, through the previous work of the physical condition, which is
determined as we have seen, by the development of the different basic conditional capacities. We
must ensure that this development is fundamentally based on health, which is possible to achieve
from the correct teaching of physical literacy. Figure 2 shows aspects related to physical literacy,
which must be considered and viewed holistically (own elaboration).
Figure 1 Physical literacy with a holistic approach
The expectations and reality of [physical] education
Physical education has overcome many issues along the years, one reason is because these issues
established the discourse that had been portrayed as a way to respond to a society. According to
Kirk (2010) physical education has portrayed these issues in different ways because it is the first
409
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
encounter that students from all ages have. One reason is because physical education offers a more
fun and interactive form to teach an ideology or social aspects. At the same time physical education
has become an answer to prevent different issues for the same reason. An example can be depicted
through the rising health problem that overweight and obesity has become, because a physical
education class can be a first step to understand in a thorough manner the variables students with
these diseases face on a daily basis. As such, to provide a [pedagogical] approach that would help
students to engage in physical activity and acquire healthy habits for a lifetime.
A physical education class can provide a safe space where students and teachers can interact
without an expectation of what should or can be accomplished. According to Oliver and
Oesterreich (2013), considering and listening to students' voices is a way to establish a series of
steps that would help to build the appropriate curriculum and environment that a class will require,
thus creating an opportunity for students to solve this health issue. However, it is important to say
that, even though the benefits of creating an appropriate space and environment within the
physical education class are known, the reality that teachers/facilitators and students face on a daily
basis says otherwise. An example of this can be depicted through what Siedentop and van der Mars
(2012) identify as the problems, issues and the future of physical education. Through a series of
problems and issues they describe what would be the possible future of physical education if these
different paths are followed: 1) The time available for physical education; 2) Class size; 3)
Exemption/Waivers; 4) Physical activity as punishment; 5) Facilities; 6) Skill equity; 7) Liability; 8)
Gender equity; and 9) Good and Bag competition.
There is now a strong body of research that support the benefits of the practice of daily physical
activity (Center for Disease Control and Prevention, 2013; Trost & Van der Mars, 2009), however
the time available for physical education within school is decreasing due to several social and
political reasons (e.g. budget cuts, district policies). Similarly, these reasons create a direct link to
provide class opportunities for students thus, a simple solution from an administrative perspective
is to create large-sized classes. In this way, “all students” will get the daily physical education class.
However, with large-sized classes the lack of facilities and equipment becomes a problem, which
creates an issue for teacher/facilitators and students to interact. This is consistent with Kirk (2010)
mentioning that the future of physical education can be depicted through three possible scenarios:
a) more of the same; b) radical reform; and c) extinction. By radical reform Kirk mentions that
higher education institutions should be directly linked to the public education system. What this
means is that in different ways, theory-practice-research should be connected to provide a more
comprehensive and complete way to tackle the possible issues faced on a daily basis. Because if
more of the same is still reproduced, extinction would be most likely to occur. As such, it is
important to say that teachers/facilitators should be prepared in different ways to address the
issues.
A possible way that teachers could be prepared to handle different and difficult situations can be
provided through professional development courses. According to Armour and Yelling (2004)
through professional development teachers can create a safe and critical environment that would
410
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
allow them to increase and encourage their interest and educational standards, thus, build a diverse
and holistic way of teaching. It is important to say that through professional development the
proposed link of theory-practice-research can be accomplished, therefore, building a feasible way
to understand and develop different solutions to an established issue, such as overweight and
obesity in children and youth. However, this option is yet to be extensively explored in different
contexts, one of them is the Mexican context. One characteristic of the Mexican context is that its
premise is built on a hierarchy expectation also known as top-down approach. What this means is
that all instructions, solutions and possibilities come from the top and individuals at the bottom
are ‘expected’ to follow the leadership of individuals in power. This phenomenon also happens in
physical education classes, where teachers are the sole providers of the instruction, environment
and curriculum created for the class, and students are expected to follow without questioning the
teacher's instructions. Thus, it is important to create different ways to challenge the expected and
become comfortable with the unexpected in order to help and provide a different solution to rising
issues known in society.
As such it can be said that physical education classes are a great solution to help overcoming the
different identified issues portrayed along the society. Although, it is important to understand indepth the importance of creating a safe and knowledgeable environment where individuals can
comprehend its impact and how this may or may not affect their lives. At the same time, teachers
should have a support system where they can feel comfortable enough to continue learning and
link theory-practice-research as a way to help students to engage in physical activity for a lifetime.
Despite the fact that the reality of physical education can be shown in a different way and the
‘expected’ future says otherwise, however, through understanding and comprehending the reality
of physical education a possible solution can be brought up to help students and teachers to create
a new reality that reflects a ‘better’ future.
Conclusions
Throughout this chapter our intention was to provide a glimpse into the reality that physical
education and health face worldwide and Mexico is not the exception. Understanding these issues
from the social and health perspective can provide a thorough scenery on how individuals deal
from different fronts the possible solutions that our ever-changing society faces. Through physical
activity literacy teachers and physical activity facilitators will be able to adequate their knowledge
for life, at the same time, understanding the different physical capacities and how this work, can
fulfill a deeper understanding of how to face different challenges, among them, overweight and
obesity, to acquire healthy habits from an early age throughout lifespan. Especially we wanted to
provide an opportunity for undergraduate and graduate students to learn in-depth the possibilities
that they can offer in order to create a change in our society in order to generate strategies such as
public health and educational policies. Because facilitators can create through different scenarios
such as physical education classes as the first place on how knowledge is spread and creating a link
between theory-practice and research, because in this way, students could overcome the different
issues each one faces on a daily basis. As such, we can conclude that through physical literacy as
411
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
the first scenario where students engage in a physical activity service, this can become an essential
aspect in their life but more importantly that physical activity facilitators should create an
appropriate knowledge link to overcome issues such as overweight and obesity for present and
future generations.
References
Armour, K.M., & Yelling, M. (2004). Professional edevelopmentí and Professional eLearningí:
Bridging the gap for experienced physical education teachers. European Physical Education
Review, 10(1), 71-93.
Bompa, T. O. (2002). Periodização: teoria e metodologia do treinamento. Brasil: Phorte.
Castañer, M. y Camerino, O. (1993). La Educación Física en la enseñanza primaria. Barcelona: INDE
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). (2013). Vital signs: avoidable deaths from
heart disease, stroke, and hypertensive disease-United States, 2001-2010. MMWR Morb
Mortal Wkly Rep, 62(35), 721-727.
Chacín, M., Carrillo, S., Rodríguez, J. E., Salazar, J., Rojas, J., Añez, R., ... & Bermúdez, V. (2019).
Obesidad Infantil: Un problema de pequeños que se está volviendo grande.
Córdova-Villalobos, J. Á. (2009). Sobrepeso y obesidad, problemas de salud pública en México.
Cirugía y cirujanos, 77(6), 421-422.
Di Cesare, M., Sorić, M., Bovet, P., Miranda, J. J., Bhutta, Z., Stevens, G. A., ... & Bentham, J.
(2019). The epidemiological burden of obesity in childhood: a worldwide epidemic requiring
urgent action. BMC medicine, 17(1), 1-20.
Encuesta Nacional de Salud y Nutrición (2018). Presentación de resultados. Recuperado de:
https://ensanut.insp.mx/encuestas/ensanut2018/informes.php
Forteza, K., Comellas, J., & de Viñaspre, P. L. (2013). El entrenador personal. Editorial HISPANO
EUROPEA.
Howley, E.T., y Powers, S.K. (2000). Fisiologia do exercício: teoria e aplicação ao condicionamento e ao
desempenho. Brasil: Manole.
Kirk, D. (2010). Physical education futures. Routledge.
Muñoz Muñoz, F. L., & Arango Álzate, C. (2017). Obesidad infantil: un nuevo enfoque para su
estudio. Revista Salud Uninorte, 33(3), 492-503.
Naclerio, F., Rodríguez-Romo, G., Barriopedro-Moro, M. I., Jiménez, A., Alvar, B. A., & Triplett,
N. T. (2011). Control of resistance training intensity by the OMNI perceived exertion scale.
The Journal of Strength & Conditioning Research, 25(7), 1879-1888.
Oliver, K. L., & Oesterreich, H. A. (2013). Student-centred inquiry as curriculum as a model for
field-based teacher education. Journal of Curriculum Studies, 45(3), 394-417.
Platonov, V. N., y Bulatova, M. M., (2019). La preparación física. España: Paidotribo
Samulski, D. M., Menzel, H. J., & Prado, L. S. (Eds.). (2013). Treinamento esportivo. Brasil: Manole.
Siedentop, D., & van der Mars, H. (2012). Introduction to physical education, fitness, and sport (8th ed.).
St. Louis, MO: McGraw-Hill.
Trost, S., & van der Mars, H. (2009). Why we should not cut PE. Educational Leadership, 67(4), 6065.
412
Situation
_________________________________________________________________________________
The Development and Evolution of School Sports Policies since
China's Reform and Opening up
Qianyi Wang - Lin Li - Xin Liu
Beijing Sport University, Beijing, China
e-mail: blackmaggie@qq.com
Abstract
Based on the perspective of "three types" policy tools, this paper combs the history and
analyzes the content of 20 issued school sports policies since China's reform and opening up.
The research results show that, since the reform, China’s school sports policies have
experienced four periods: restoration and reconstruction, exploration and improvement,
deepening development and top-level design. With the development of society, the policies
have been continuously improved, the use of policy tools, and the blueprint of multiple
subjects participating in school sports have been gradually revealed, and the development
elements of school sports has been constantly balanced. China's school sports policies have
been continuously improved in the development process, but there are still some problems,
such as the unbalanced use of policy tools, the single subject of behavior, the unbalanced
development of factors and so on. Therefore, the formulation of school sports policies in the
new era should adjust the proportion of policy tools and optimize the internal structure;
Promotion of the joint governance of "family, school and society"; Leading the social force to
develop physical education; Balancing all factors of school sport development.
Key words: School sport policies; Policy tool; Text analysis; Reform and opening-up
413
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
In 1978, the Communist Party of China held the Third Plenary Session of the Eleventh Central
Committee, which was determined to pay main attention to the economic construction, which
marked that China's social development was moving to a new historical era. Under this
circumstance, school sport has been developing.[1]. Over the past 40 years, the Chinese
government has paid more and more attention to youth sports work, and the formulation and
promulgation of school sports policies have become more and more perfect, giving full play to
its leading role in school sports practice. Looking back on history, it remains to be discussed in
depth what historical evolution has been experienced, what historical experience has been
formed, and how to move forward in reflection in the future. Based on the perspective of
policy tools, this paper explores the development process of school sports policies, constructs a
three-dimensional analysis framework through the classification method of "three types" policy
tools, and makes a quantitative research on the text of school sports policy since the reform and
opening up, hoping to explore the phased development characteristics and trend of China's
school sports policies through data statistical analysis, and to discuss with peers, and provide
reference and reference for the formulation of school sports policies in the future.
Construction of 3-dimensional analysis framework
This study selects the school sports policies text issued by the state since the reform and
opening up as the research object. Through the official website databases of the CPC Central
Committee, the State Council, the Ministry of education, the State Administration of sports
and other official websites, as well as CNKI, relevant legal website databases and school sports
policy books, this paper collects the Chinese school sports policy texts since the reform and
opening up, follows the principles of authority, openness, uniqueness, comprehensiveness and
integrity, and finally determines20 policy texts as the research object .
This paper mainly adopts the content analysis method, and encodes and counts the policy text
through NVivo qualitative analysis software. It also discusses about the historical development
of school sport, using charts of data to show the developmental features and trends of school
PE policies deeply and intuitively.
Selection of 3-D analysis framework
414
Situation
_________________________________________________________________________________
Figure 1 3D frame diagram
Dimension X: policy tool dimension
Rothwell and Ziegfeld’s "three types" policy tools have been applied to the research of sports
policies by many researchers in recent years, and have repeatedly proved that they have strong
explanatory power on Sports Policy. The classification standard is divided into supply-oriented,
environment-oriented and demand-oriented policy tools according to the different levels of the
impact of school sports policies on school sports work and development. Each dimension is
divided into two levels of indicators, and the specific composition is shown in Figure 2. Based
on this, this paper constructs an X-dimension composed of supply-based type,
environment-based type and demand-based type policy tools.
Among the three types, the supply-based type policy tool is an impetus to school sport
development, and it was guaranteed by the government by providing talents, technology,
information, funds and other elements directly in order to promote the development of school
sport. The environment-based type policy tool is represented by the indirect effect on school
sport, showing that the government promotes the environmental development through this
kind of type policy tool, to provide a favorable policy environment. The demand-based type
one plays a role in stimulating the development of school sport, during which process the
government takes steps to expand the market demand for school sports development, and then
expands the platform for school sport development.
415
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
Figure 2 Classification of policy instrument dimensions [2]
Dimension Y: the dimension of relevant actors
Over the years, China's school sports have been committed to promoting the physical health of
teenagers, bearing the expectations of the state and the people for the growth of teenagers.
However, the practice of the years has indicated that relying solely on government behavior
cannot promote the sustainable development of school sports, and the cognition and attitude
of parents and society towards youth sports also seriously restrict the practical effect of school
sports. Only with the concerted efforts of multiple subjects can school physical education
obtain developing vitality. By sorting out the school sports policy text, it is found that the
frequency of "family", "community", "society" and other subjects appearing in the text content
have been increasing since 2006. Policy makers realize that school sports, for the purpose of
enhancing students' physical health, not only needs the attention of the government and the
school itself, but also needs the support of other forces such as society and family, so as to
form a multi-subject governance system of school sports in the new era. Therefore, after
statistically refining the content of the policy text, this study takes "government", "school",
"society", "community", "family" and "individual" as the main force to achieve the goal of
school sports, so as to construct the dimension-Y index.
Dimension Z: the dimension of school sport development
The analysis of each element of school sport can construct a dynamic process of its
development more clearly. There are different emphases on the measures taken for the
development elements, indicating different levels of attentions paid by Chinese government in
different certain periods of time. On the basis of the original school sports elements, after
studying the main contents of 20 school sports policies for many times and making statistics on
the title contents, 11 elements such as physical education teaching, cultural atmosphere
416
Situation
_________________________________________________________________________________
construction, after-school sports training, after-school sports competition, logistics guarantee,
overall planning of social resources, sports evaluation, system guarantee, construction of
teaching staff, scientific research and organization and management leadership are determined,
so as to construct the dimension Z.
Coding process
In this study, 20 Chinese school sports policy texts were coded and classified, so that
researchers can quantify the text content and obtain the required research results through the
data. The specific coding process is coded according to "policy text order- chapter series - unit
sentence", and each sentence is a code.
Reliability and validity test
In order to ensure the accuracy of the coding unit, the reliability and validity of the coding
results will be tested. In terms of validity, since the research objects are the policy texts
published by the government's official website, and their authority has been guaranteed, the
validity test of coding units is not involved. In the reliability test part, this study will ensure the
reliability of the coding by double coding, and take the consistency reliability test for the coding
results.
This paper adopts Holsti coefficient formula and Scott index in equivalence analysis to calculate
the coding results, and discusses whether the coding results have good consistency. The results
show that the Holsti coefficient and Scott index are 0.9865 and 0.9797 respectively, which
ensure that the coded data has good reliability and can be used for subsequent research.
Historical evolution
Through the in-depth analysis of school sport policies in different historical times,a clearer
historical context of the policy-development could be seen. This study takes influential
documents and events that have effects on school PE policies as criteria to divide the historical
periods.They are: The Regulations on School Sports Work in 1990,The Promulgation of "Central
Document No. 7" in 2007 and the convening of the National Education conference in
2018,dividing the school sports policy into four historical stages. Based on what has been
analyzed above, this study uses the method of statistics and analyzes the data in the aspect of
policy tools.
417
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
Table 1 Statistics of X-Y-Z 3D
data
418
Situation
_________________________________________________________________________________
Recovery and reconstruction stage
During the time of the late 1970s to the early 1980s, the tasks of school sport policy making
and its implementation were urgent in order to restore the work and reorder of school physical
education. The policy makers used the supply-based policy tool to evaluate PE classes, cultural
atmosphere, teachers, rear services, sport evaluation and other indicators. And they also used
the tool in developing organizations, aiming at schools. In October 1979, The Interim Stipulation
of Physical Education in primary and secondary schools (Trial draft) and The Interim Stipulation of Physical
Education in Colleges and universities (Trial draft) were promulgated one after another, which
determined the guiding ideology of "enhancing students' physique “. However, in the early
1980s, the demand for professional talents in all walks of life was particularly urgent. The
university entrance examination paid more attention to academic selection, which led to the
phenomenon of "emphasizing intelligence over physical education". The status of school
physical education in school education was difficult to be effectively guaranteed. The use of
supply-oriented type and demand-oriented type policy tools in school sports policies was
seriously unbalanced. The relevant elements of school physical education were kept unbalanced.
2.2 The stage of exploring and improving
In the 1990s, the reform and opening up had good effects, and China’s development entered a
steady developing stage. The Chinese government paid more attention to education, and
successively promulgated a series of documents and policies of school sport, especially The
Regulations on School Sport Work (1990), which promoted the institutionalization of this field.
Therefore, the proportion of environmental policy tools increased, and the institutional
guarantee index increased significantly while the Government behavior in the policy is also
increasing. In 1999, the CPC Central Committee and the State Council proclaimed the decision
419
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
on deepening educational reform and completely promoting quality education, which
established the idea of "health first", which had important guiding significance for the
formulation of school sports policy. The continuous promotion of quality education reform
has improved the status of school sports in school education, and people's demand for sports
has also increased slightly at this time. In 2006, the Ministry of education, the State Sports
Administration and the Communist Youth League together suggested and launched "the sport
activity of hundreds of millions of students", which triggered enthusiasm of doing exercise
among middle and primary schools throughout China. That also greatly improved the
proportion of supply-based type and environment-based type policy tools in the construction
of school sports cultural atmosphere in the policy at that time. However, the use of
demand-based type policy tools at this stage is still insufficient. The subjects such as society,
families and students have not really participated in the school sports work. School sports
urgently need to build a multi-agent collaborative governance system.
Deepening development stage
In 2007, the CPC Central Committee and the State Council issued The Opinions on Strengthening
Youth Sports and Enhancing Youth Physique (hereinafter referred to as "Central Document No. 7"),
which is the first policy document from the national level specifically for school sports work.
The construction of school sports policy has made a substantive breakthrough, which is
reflected in the policy text, which is also a further increase in the proportion of demand-based
policy tools. Since then, the State Council has successively issued Some Opinions on Further
Strengthening School PE work(2012) and The Opinions on Strengthening School Physical Education to
promote the Development of Students' Physical and Mental Health (2016, hereinafter referred to as "No.
27 Document"), which further improved the dominant position of the government, strengthened
the subjectivity of families and communities, and gradually formed the concept of "home
school social education".
At this stage, in order to promote quality education and promote the development of
educational modernization, the central idea of the government's policy always focuses on
"health first", puts improving the physical health of teenagers in the first place, strives for the
coordinated development of various elements of school sports in addition to ensuring key tasks,
pays more attention to the use of demand-oriented policy tools to open the school sports
market, and increases the social demand for school sports. However, in the development of
some elements, such as scientific research and sports evaluation, there has never been a
breakthrough direction.
420
Situation
_________________________________________________________________________________
Top-level design stage
In 2018, the national education conference put forward the goal system of enjoying fun in
physical exercise, strengthening physique, improving personality and tempering will [3], and
established the concept of school sports development in the new era with "educating people"
as the core. The school sports policy also paid more attention to demand-based policy tools,
highlighting the care for the whole development of teenagers. In 2021, The Opinions on the
Integration of Physical Education and Education to Promote Teenagers’ Healthy Development and The
Opinions on Completely Strengthening and Promoting School Sport in the New Era were issued and
implemented. The two documents further focused on the status of school sport, focused on
educational values, and improved the supply of school PE resources, creating a practical model
of "learning practice competition integration", and building a multi-agent collaborative
governance system under the leadership of the government.
Main achievements
The use of policy tools tends to be balanced gradually
Since the reform and opening up, China's school sports policy has alternately occupied the main
content with supply-based type and environment-based type policy tools. The use of
demand-based type policy tools has always been insufficient. The low social demand for school
sports is the main factor leading to this problem. However, there are problems of obese
children, the improvement of myopia rate and the decline of some physical fitness. The
problems force the country to pay attention to the importance of school physical education. To
improve the status of school sport and the health levels of teenagers, the policies of school
sport policies in China have used the demand-based policy tools increasingly. Since the "Central
Document No. 7" was issued, policy documents such as The Outline of Constructing a Country of
Strong Sports and The Opinions on Completely Strengthening and Improving School Sport in the New Era
have also been issued. There are also documents concerning the entrance examination to
college in the subject of PE. And the proposal of the "Double Reduction" policy also improves
people's demand for school sports to a certain extent. At the national level, through the rational
use of policy tools, it is gradually promoting the status of PE subject which is significant for
teenagers’ all-round development, and which is also significant for a sustainable future
development of school sport.
421
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
Diversified change of principal parts
The release of school sport policies requires the participation of principal relevant parts. In
turn, it will have a direct impact on the implementation of policies. At the 2018 national
education conference, President Xi Jinping made an important speech on accelerating modern
education and building a strong educational country, and pointed out that schools, families, the
government and society should have the responsibility to run education satisfactory to the
people [4], and defined the important value concept of multi-body collaborative governance of
school sports. From the current development of school sports policy, China's school sports
governance system is moving towards the direction of multi subject coordination.
After the reform and opening up, the market economy has gradually replaced the planned
economy, and the society began to take responsibility in sports governance. From "government
driven" to "service-oriented government", the role of the government in sports governance has
gradually changed, which also provides an opportunity for social resources to enter school
sports. The idea of home-school cooperation was first put forward in The Interim Regulations for
Primary and Secondary Schools (Draft) in 1952 to the establishment and improvement of the
incentive mechanism for families, schools, governments and society. In 2020, in the policy of
The Opinions on Completely Strengthening and Promoting School Sport in the New Era in 2020 [5], there is
a need to build an incentive mechanism which perfects physical health concerned by “home,
school and society”, and under this social circumstance, China is forming a new governance
system of government-leading, society-participating and home-school-society nurturing in the
new era.
Policy-guidance for multiple factors’ cooperation and development
School sport development has the features of complexity and diversity, which determine the
comprehensiveness and depth of its policy making. From the perspective of the subject, school
sport includes physical education, extracurricular physical activities, extracurricular physical
training, competition and so on; However, as a policy maker, the work, like organizing and
managing, scientific research, faculty construction and social resources, has a vital impact as well.
With the continuous progress of society, China's school sports policy actively guides the
improvement of various elements of school sports, especially in promoting the individual
elements which were ignored at the beginning of the reform, such as system guarantee, cultural
atmosphere construction and overall planning of social resources. Under the environment of
multiple subjects participating in school physical education governance, the Chinese
government firmly grasped the advantages of multiple subjects and started with improving
422
Situation
_________________________________________________________________________________
social awareness. The idea of “health first” is rooted well in people’s heart, and the Chinese
government uses the integration of social resources to promote PE education, and thereafter
promotes the systematic establishment and perfection of faculty, regulations, scientific research,
management and so on. When looking back on more than 40 years, we could see the innovation
of school PE curriculum and sport activities; we could see the cultivation of sports talents
under the social circumstance of “integration of PE and education”; we could see the
increasing-number of PE teachers; we could see the cooperation of society, home and school;
we could see the perfection of the school sport organization and of new institutions; we could
also see the better evaluative criteria of school sport and improvement of scientific research
level. Chinese school sport is moving to the direction of comprehensive and cooperative
aspects.
Future outlook
Adjusting the proportion of policy instruments and optimizing the inner structure
In this study, there is an imbalance in the use of policy tools in China's school physical
education policy, and the internal structure of each policy tool needs to be optimized.
Specifically, the use of supply-based type and environment-based type policy tools is excessive,
and the use of demand-based type policy tools is insufficient. From the internal structure of
policy tools, the proportion of sports capital investment and the construction and use of
venues and facilities are the lowest, which lead to the problems that the financial support for
school sports is not in place and the school sports venues and facilities cannot meet the needs
of students. In addition, the supply of talent training, innovation support and public services
also needs to be improved. For environmental -based type policy tools, the use of regulatory
management and strategic measures is excessive, while the use of external incentives is
insufficient. Excessive laws and regulations and insufficient incentive measures are easy to lead
to the rebound of government compulsive behavior, and weaken the enthusiasm of school
leaders, physical education teachers, social organizations and other participants. What appears
inside the demand-oriented policy tools is the lack of foreign capital introduction. Therefore, in
the future, the formulation of China's school sports policies should expand the supply of
sports funds and venues, facilities and equipment, reduce the use frequency of supply-based
type policy tools, refine regulatory management measures and increase external incentive
measures. It should also reduce the proportion of environment-based type policy tools, so that
the use of policy tools tends to be balanced and its internal structure is continuously optimized.
In addition, we should further expand the demand market for school sports, and increase the
use of demand-based type policy tools in policies by strengthening the cultivation of students,
423
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
strengthening government procurement, promoting the cooperation between schools and
enterprise organizations, and increasing overseas exchanges of school sports.
Breaking the single subject model and promoting the joint governance of "family, school
and society"
In the "No. 27 document" issued by the general office of the State Council in 2016, it was
proposed that "primary and secondary schools should arrange family sports homework and
gradually form a mechanism for families, schools and communities to jointly guide students'
physical exercise" [6], "The education from home, school and society" has become a new
concept of school sports governance in the new era. However, the research results show that
the participation of society, community, family and students in school sports policy is low. In
the policies of different historical stages, only social behavior has increased slightly, and there
are no obvious changes in the other aspects. The government and schools still occupy the
leading position of school sports. It is not only people's insufficient understanding of school
physical education and students' excessive academic burden under the long-term thought of
"emphasizing intelligence and neglecting physical education", but also problems such as the lack
of guidance of family physical education.
In 2019, the outbreak of the global COVID-19, China's implementation of the policy of
"suspending classes and stopping learning" has gradually exposed the family education situation
to people's vision. How to ensure students to learn and exercise at home efficiently becomes a
great challenge for families and schools. In October 2021, The Family Education Promotion Law of
the People's Republic of China was officially issued. This law helps to indicate a path of
cooperation for home-education and school-education, and it also helps to promote the
development of social educational service [7]. The policy clearly points out that primary and
secondary schools should incorporate family education guidance into Teachers' training, which
means that China's future school sports policy should include guiding family education in the
work plan and shoulder the responsibility of guiding family physical education.
Policy-guidance and society-forces to help school sport development
Taking the government as the leading role was the core concept of Chinese sport governance in
the past. The top-down centralized management of the single government provided the most
effective way to develop. With the transformation of society, market economy and social
organizations have emerged one after another. The advent of multiple subjects promotes
China's sports governance to a new road of co-construction, co-governance and sharing in the
424
Situation
_________________________________________________________________________________
new era. However, the reality of Chinese school sports still does not get rid of the governance
mode of "government standard". The results show that the proportion of government as the
main body of policy behavior is far higher than that of society, and the phenomenon of single
subject participation still exists in the process of school sports governance. From the first
proposal of "service-oriented government" in the Sixth Plenary Session of the 16th CPC
Central Committee to the second mention of the construction of "service-oriented
government" in the 19th CPC Central Committee, the relationship between the Chinese
government and society is slowly changing [8]. In order to accelerate the realization of this goal,
in the future, China's school sports policy should actively guide the participation of social
behavior and give full play to the role of society and market. The specific measures include the
following three points: (1) to strengthen the government's procurement of sports services and
guide social resources to serve school sports. (2) to support social organizations, enterprises and
school sports to carry out cooperation and improve the level of school sports work. (3) to
strengthen the supervision of the sports market and improve the public sports service system.
4.4 Promoting the balance of factors and promoting the sustainable development of school
sport
The complex and diversified developing factors are the significant ones that have a great effect
on sustainable development of school sport. In the past, school sport paid more attention to
the input on fundamental resource and sport activities of both in school and after school. With
the deepening of school sport development, the focus of policies has been changing. However,
some problems have not been solved indeed. Among them, the most representative one is the
backwardness of scientific research. Under the background of “developing the country through
science and education”, the policy-makers should pay main attention to how to improving the
levels of school sport scientific research and take measures to promote the transformation of
scientific research achievement.
In addition, the use of policy tools by various development factors is also unreasonable and
unbalanced. Specifically, in terms of development system guarantee, overall planning of social
resources and organizational management, there are few supply-based type policy tools, so these
elements are lack of policy driving force. Physical education teaching, logistics support and
scientific research are insufficient in the use of environment-base type policy tools. Therefore,
the establishment of these three needs to be improved in the process of development. In
addition to the overall planning of social resources, there are deficiencies and deficiencies in the
use of demand-based type policy tools in other development factors. As a key link leading the
trend of school sports, the policy needs to have more comprehensive and clear instructions for
the development of school sports elements, grasp the historical period of society, and deepen
425
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
and promote the smooth implementation of school sports. In short, only the balanced
development of various elements of school sports can ensure the balance of the internal
structure of school sports and make the sustainable development of it.
References
[1] Ji, L. & Ma D.H. (2018). Review and Prospect of of School Physical Education
Development in China in the Past Forty Years of Reform and Opening-up.Sports
Research,v.1;No.5(05):1-11.
[2] Su, J. (2014). Introduction to public science and technology policy.Beijing: Science Press.
[3] Xi Jinping's important speech of the National Educational Conference.
[EB/OL]. (2018-09-11).http://edu.people.com.cn/n1/2018/0911/c1053-30286259.html.
[4] Xi jinping’s important speech of the National Educational Conference.
[EB/OL].(2018-09-10). http://www.gov.cn/xinwen/2018-09/10/content_5320835.htm.
[5] General Office of the CPC Central Committee and General Office of the State Council
issued the opinions about completely strengthening and improving school sport in the new era and The
opinions about completely strengthening and improving school aesthetic education in the new era.
[EB/OL]. (2020-10-15).
http://www.moe.gov.cn/jyb_xxgk/moe_1777/moe_1778/202010/t20201015_494794.ht
ml
[6] General Office of the State Council issued Opinions on strengthening school sport and
promoting the all-round development in students' physical and mental health [EB/OL].
(2006-05-06). http://www.gov.cn/zhengce/content/2016-05/06/content_5070778.htm
[7] Law of the promotion of family education in people's Republic of China [EB/OL].
(2021-10-23).
http://www.npc.gov.cn/npc/c30834/202110/8d266f0320b74e17b02cd43722eeb413.sht
ml
[8] Zhang, X.Q.&Luo,X.B. (2021). Research on the Governance of Youth Sports in China
from the Perspective of the “State Society” Relations. Journal of Beijing Sport University,44
(11):18-28.
426
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Importance of Physical Education in the Early Stages of the Life
Cycle, for a Healthy Life
Jose Francisco Mora Núñez1 - Manuel Guerrero Zainos2
1
Student at the University of the Atlantic / Bachelor's Degree Program in Physical Education, Recreation and
Sports the Barranquilla, Colombia
2
International Federation of Physical Education et Sportive. San Luis Potosi, Mexico
Email: jmora7024@gmail.com
Abstract
The following article aims to corroborate the scientific findings that give the importance of physical
activity in the early stages of the life cycle of human beings, and jointly disseminate worldwide the
need that exists in various educational institutions in the public sector in Latin America, with
respect to the harmonious and comprehensive development that all children should have in terms
of (PE), sport, recreation and physical activity, in the course of their academic training. Therefore,
a bibliographic study and field consultation is carried out, which manages to identify a series of
publications located in different archives, databases, repositories and on-line catalogs (libraries),
which support this research.
Key words: Physical education; Life cycle; Healthy life
427
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
Physical activity is a component that alludes to any body movement produced by voluntary
muscular action, with the aim of increasing energy expenditure; hence the importance of
performing physical activity and implementing healthy lifestyles in the early formative stages, lies
in taking advantage of these stages to achieve early learning and knowledge fixation, thanks to brain
and psychomotor development that occurs in the first years of life (Hernández-Rincón E.H.,2018).
For this reason, practicing some physical activity on a regular basis is crucial for the physical,
mental, psychological and social development of children and adolescents (UNICEF, 2019).
A brief explanation about this topic; the life cycle is an approach that allows understanding
vulnerabilities and opportunities to invest during early stages of human development; where it is
recognized that experiences accumulate throughout life, that interventions in one generation will
have an impact on the following ones, and that the greatest benefit of an age group may derive
from previous interventions in a previous age group (MinHealth). For this reason, it is necessary
to clarify that the life cycle comprises 7 stages of development, in which we find the prenatal stage,
early childhood from 0-5 years, childhood from 6-11 years, adolescence from 12-18 years, youth
from 14-26 years, adulthood from 27-59 years and older adults from 60 years and over (StuDuc
n.d.).
In this order of ideas, it can be deduced that physical activity in children and adolescents generates
immediate health benefits, and at the same time it is known that physical activity habits in infancy
and adolescence tend to be maintained into adulthood, so it is also expected that these benefits are
also present in the long term (Sánchez López, M.., Rodríguez Perea, M., Solera Martínez, M.,
Jiménez Rodero, C., Notario Pacheco, B., & Domínguez Contreras, M. L., 2005), Rodríguez Perea,
M., Solera Martínez, M., Jiménez Rodero, C., Notario Pacheco, B., & Domínguez Contreras, M.
L., 2005). Similarly, it is essential to note that, in recent decades, numerous studies have shown
that the regular practice of physical activity is essential in order to improve our health, understood,
as defined by the World Health Organization (WHO) in 1948, as the complete state of physical,
mental and social well-being, and not only as the absence of conditions or diseases that have
prevailed in today's society (Frago, Calvo J. M., 2014).
Likewise, multiple works and systematic reviews, have evidenced a considerable growth of research
that highlight the health benefits of physical activity practice in children and adolescents (Córdova,
Villa, Sureda, Rodríguez, Sánchez 2012; Ho, Ahmed, D'Amico, 2018; Veloso 2005). Therefore, the
importance of introducing in these developmental stages, a dynamic life system where adequate,
periodic, scheduled and well-prescribed physical activity is carried out, as a basic tool to achieve
and preserve health; it will provide countless physiological, metabolic, anatomical, cognitive, social
and academic benefits in an unobjectionable way (García, Rodríguez, J., &Fonseca Hernández, C.
2012).
However, much of the world is becoming less active, and although abundant works have been
published in different countries analyzing the usual physical activity levels of this population sector,
428
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
the results show low levels of compliance with the general recommendations established at
international level (Van Stralen, M.M., Yildirim, M., Wulp, A., Te Velde, S.J., Verloigne, M.,
Doessegger, A., 2014; Verloigne, M., Van Lippevelde, W., Maes, L., Yildirin, M., Chinapaw, M.,
Manios, Y.,... De Bourdeaudhuij, I. 2012; World Health Organization WHO. 2018). The
recommended physical activity for girls/boys aged 5-17 years with a view to improve their
cardiorespiratory and muscular fitness, bone health, cardiovascular and metabolic health markers,
reduce symptoms of anxiety and depression, is to engage in at least 60 minutes of daily physical
activity of moderate to vigorous intensity, through PE, play, sport, walking and recreational activity
and physical education, in the context of family, school and community activities; however,
exceeding 60 minutes of physical activity will provide additional health benefits, and vigorousintensity activities, including those that strengthen muscles and bones, should be incorporated at
least three times per week (World Health Organization WHO. 2018).
Development
Global estimates indicate that 27.5% of adults and 81% of adolescents do not meet the 2010 WHO
physical activity recommendations, with little improvement observed in the last decade; there are
also notable inequalities: data show that in most countries girls and adult women are less active
than boys and adult men, with significant differences in physical activity levels between the highest
and lowest economic groups and between countries and regions (World Health Organization
WHO, 2020). In this sense, despite the fact that a sedentary life in these populations is very
common, few studies on intervention programs with physical activity have focused on the time
spent in school and during a pandemic of such dimension as the one we are living, paradoxically,
the effects of other pandemics such as obesity, diabetes, depression, anxiety, stress, among many
others, which are associated with an industrial lifestyle are exposed (Guerra, Y. d. 2021; Mora
López, D. J., García Pinillos, F., & Latorre Román, P. Á. 2017).
Indeed, these results, and so many other recent analyses, lead us to ask whether the Covid-19
pandemic has left negative repercussions on the health of the population and the lack of a general
physical culture; in addition to the scarce public resources within the health field, related to PE.
Along these lines, experts have been pointing out for years the need to include PE in general public
health plans, health plans and to increase the number of hours in educational plans. In view of the
above, in this last component it is essential to emphasize that it is the duty of all educational centers
to create favorable environments for those receiving education, where free time is used
productively, through support networks and the establishment of links and interactions in positive
environments that help to enhance their wellbeing and integral development (Rodríguez Torres,
Á. F.., Rodríguez Alvear, J. C., Guerrero Gallardo, H. I., Arias Moreno, E. R., Paredes Alvear, A.
E., & Chávez Vaca, V. A. 2020).
On the other hand, it is recognized that everyone has different skills and abilities that help us to
face the chores of life, which represents one of the educational objectives or goals of the 21st
century, to achieve not only significant learning, but also to be able to solve problems in any context
429
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
(Loprinzi, P.D., Cardinal, B.J., Loprinzi, K.L., & Lee, H. 2012). That is to say, in the area of physical
education these environments to which we refer can be created, since a motor-competent child is
much more likely to practice physical activity, thus benefiting from the positive effects associated
with it on his or her health (Merino Merino, B., Esteban, C., Pilar, & Justo Gil, S., 2016). In turn,
it has been scientifically proven that those children who do not have the necessary opportunities
to practice and acquire basic motor skills at the appropriate level, may be limited to participate in
physical activities or sports, as they do not have developed the necessary foundations to be active
(Merino Merino Merino, B., Esteban, C., Pilar, & Justo Gil, S., 2016).
Therefore, the content of PE as an activity that includes a broad set of body and motor activities
implemented in different institutional settings: education, sport, health, leisure, free time and others
that are expanded according to social dynamics, market or state demands (Rozengardt Rodolfo,
2006). In this line, we share below the features of the graduate profile obtained thanks to the PE
area (Secretaría de Educación Pública. Méx. 2017):
Table 1 Features of the Physical Education graduation profile:
Kindergarten, Primary and Secondary
Component
A. BODY AND HEALTH CARE
B. BODY AND HEALTH CARE
C. BODY AND HEALTH CARE
Expected learning
Identifies their own physical traits and qualities, and recognizes
those of others. Performs physical activity from motor play and
knows that it is good for health. (SEP Mx.20017)
Recognizes his or her body. Solves challenges through creative
use of body skills. Makes informed decisions about hygiene and
nutrition. Participates in situations of play and physical activity,
seeking healthy and peaceful coexistence. (SEP Mx. 2017)
Activates their body skills and adapts them to different situations
faced in school games and sports. Adopts a preventive approach
by identifying the advantages of taking care of their body, having
a balanced diet and practicing physical activity regularly. (SEP
México 2017)
Source: The authors.
Even so, in current circumstances, PE is called to solve global problems typical of demographic
advances and the cultural gaps of peoples; therefore, physical education teachers should develop
life skills in their students, which contribute to a more active and healthy society (Posso Pacheco,
2020; Valladares Fuente, 2022). In this regard, it is essential to know what is happening with school
PE and how it can be strengthened in this third millennium.
What is happening with school physical education (PE)?
Throughout the history of Latin America, PE has become for several decades one of the most
neglected subjects in the educational system, where it is thought that the efforts are minimal or
430
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
even nonexistent to pass this subject or because of the simplicity of its contents, Consequently, PE
has historically had a halo of "simple" or also called "Mary" around it, which has never been
completely removed and, in many cases, we are still the "gym teachers" (Education 3. 0 Physical
Education: the eternal 'Maria'?, 2020). However, despite the Covid-19 experience, physical
education has renewed its essence in the school context, a clear example was the call made by
(UNESCO, 2021) to governments to invest in quality PE, in order to obtain significant results at a
low cost and high impact, to support the post-pandemic recovery towards the "new normal".
Therefore, quality PE has become a hot topic nowadays, but it is still difficult to establish a single
definition of what to do to achieve good impact in pedagogical acts. In relation to this, although it
is undeniable that the presence of PE in the curriculum offers an unbeatable opportunity to
promote healthy habits that will last in the adult beings of the future, the main function of PE
should not focus only on the health aspect, since we should not forget that we are talking about
education, and therefore, its main strengths revolve around a broader concept (Del Val Martín, P.,
Sebastiani Obrador, E., & Blázquez Sánchez, D. 2021).
Hence, the global study regarding the situation of PE in schools carried out by (UNESCO, 2013)
is captured as a model for Latin America, which showed that the time allocated to physical
education varies substantially by country, with up to 183 minutes per week in Cuba and only about
60 minutes per week in Mexico. This means that the overall agreement of Latin American countries
lags behind Europe and the time allocated to PE in Latin American countries is comparable to
some Asian and African developing countries; however, European countries show a consistent
time allocation to PE among all the countries represented, as can be seen in Table two (2) (Ho, W.,
Ahmed, M. D., D'Amico, R. L. d., Ramos, A., Ferreira, E. L., Ferreira, M. B. R., . . . Wong, B.
(2018).
Another relevant study to consider in this literature review is that of (Mora Núñez, 2021), who
emphasizes in his research on the current state of PE in official educational institutions, and jointly
alludes to the role played by public policies in the construction of quality PE. For the purposes of
this study, 17 teachers from different Latin American countries participated, and the result was an
eminent concern when it was demonstrated that within the basic requirements for the development
of this subject, there is no support from specialized PE teachers at the preschool and elementary
school levels. In view of this reality, the authors determined as a priority to retake the preliminary
study in order to know in more detail how the subject of PE is structured at the preschool, primary
and secondary levels, in accordance with the educational regulations that govern each of these
countries in the American continent. Therefore, an eight-question questionnaire is used to analyze
the current state of PE in Latin America.
431
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Table 2 Allocation of PE curriculum time in regions (mean minutes per week).
Latin
America
Brasil
Min
week
110
per
Min
Europe
week
Luxembourg 142
Chile
135
Andorra
165
Colombia
Cuba
Mexico
120
183
60*
Poland
England
France
156
120
220
Venezuela
90
Germany
135
per
Min
week
105
Asia
China
Kazakhstan
Hong
Kong
India
Japan
South
Korea
per
Min
week
225
115
Africa
Ethiopia
South
Africa
90
60
125
Gabon
Guinea
Lesotho
150
100
110
120
Libya
125
per
58
Source: UNESCO-NWCPEA: World-wide Survey of School PE (2013). * Guerrero, M (2019)
On the other hand, it should be noted that the sample selected for this study was one hundred and
ten (110) teachers who work in the field of PE, as National Delegates and/or collaborators of
FIEPS; which represents a significant percentage of the population group intervened in twenty (20)
countries. The following are the results found in the countries that opened their doors to this great
study:
Table 3 Basic Structure of Physical Education in the School Context
1. Pupils of school age
Presch. Primary Second.
Years Years
Years
4 Average students in
2. PE the Official curículum. 3 official physical edu- 3.1 Who is resp onsible
for the PE. in his country ? physical education class
cation curriculum
Presch. Primary. Second.
Gove
rnment
Others
Presch. Primary Second
Yes No Yes No Yes No
Yes
No
1
México
2 Guatemala
3
Honduras
4 El Salvador
5 Costa Rica
6
Panamá
7
Nicaragua
8
Argentina
9
Brasil
10
Bolivia
11
Chile
12
Colombia
13
Ecuador
14
Paraguay
15
Perú
16
Uruguay
17
Venezuela
18
Cuba
19 Dominicana
4
4
4
4
4
4
6
4
4
4
3
4
4
5
3
3
4
0
4
15
15
17
17
16
17
18
18
17
17
17
17
17
17
16
17
16
15
16
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
0
0
1
0
1
1
0
1
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
1
1
0
1
0
0
1
0
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
20
35
40
30
20
20
20
20
20
35
45
35
30
20
20
20
15
15
20
26
40
50
40
25
25
20
26
40
40
45
40
35
40
30
25
35
30
35
26
40
50
40
25
30
50
26
40
40
45
40
35
40
30
25
35
30
35
20 Puerto Rico
5a6
11 a 18
1
0
1
0
1
0
1
0
1
0
20
30
30
13
7
19
1
20
0
20
0
20
0
500
677
712
1
0.4
1
0.1
1.0
0
1
0
1
0
47.6
64.5
67.8
COUNTRY
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
6
6
5
5
5
5
7
6
7
5
5
5
5
6
5
5
6
6
6
7
7
6
6
6
6
7
7
8
6
6
6
6
7
6
6
6
6
7
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
12
12
12
12
12
11
13
12
13
12
12
11
11
12
11
11
11
12
12
6 a 10
Sum
Average
Standard dev.
12
13
12
12
12
12
14
12
14
12
12
12
12
12
12
12
11
12
12
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
0
0
0 .2
0 .2
0 .0
0
0 .0
0 .0
0
8.7
8.0
7.8
Minim um
0
0
0
0
1
0
1
0
1
0
15
20
25
Máximum
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
0
1
0
45
50
50
65 35
95
5
100
0
100
0
100
0
Percent
0
ITE MS
1.What is the school age in years of the students at the different levels of education? Preschool Primary Secondary.
2. Is Physical Education (P.E.) Official in Plans and Programs in Preschool, Primary and Secondary?
3. Is there a Specific National Curriculum for PE, at its different educational levels? 3.1 Who is responsible for the E.F . in his country?
4. What average number of students attend the P.E. session?
5. Monitoring by the P.E. Program Implementation Authority is done on a; monthly, quarterly, semi-annual, > six-monthly, > six-monthly basis
6. What is the frequency of the P.E. per week? preschool Primary secondary.
7. What is the total number of minutes per week received by P.E. students? Preschool, Primary and Secondary.
8. Staff that teaches P.E. Classroom teacher, Specialist teacher, other profile.
Source: The authors
432
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Note: In Table three (3), we can observe that in item number one (1), it tends to vary in the average
ages that students have according to the educational level they perform. In item two (2) we find
that only thirteen (13) countries have physical education plans and programs at all educational
levels, while in seven (7) countries there is some inconsistency in the preschool and primary grades.
In relation to items three (3) and three point one (3.1), it should be noted that all the countries
participating in this study (20) have a specific physical education curriculum at the different
educational levels established by the national government. Finally, in item number four (4), it is
detailed that the average number of students attending physical education classes is from fifteen
(15) to fifty (50) students, depending on the country.
Table 4 Current status of School Physical Education (PE) in Latin America
Sum
Average
1
0.05
Standard dev. 0.223606798
Other profile
1
0
0
0
1
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
Specialist
0
1
1
1
0
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
0
1
1
1
0
Specialist
50
60 120
30
80
70
30
40
80
45
90
90
120 120 120
30
45
45
90
90
90
90 100 120
30 150 100
90
90
90
90
90
90
30 120 120
90
90 135
30
40
80
30 180 180
80
80
80
20
90
90
40 135 90
30
90
90
75 250 250
Classroom teacher
2
2
2
2
3
1
2
2
2
1
1
2
3
1
2
2
1
2
2
5
Specialist
1
2
1
2
3
1
2
2
3
1
1
2
2
1
2
2
1
3
2
5
8. Personnel who teach PE:
Specialist, another profile
Preescolar Primaria Secundaria
Classroom teacher
1
1
1
2
3
1
2
2
1
1
1
1
2
1
1
2
1
2
1
2.5
Secodary
0
0
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
Primary
Preschool
2
Secondary
6
Primary
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Preschool
1
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
1
1
7. Physical
education minutes
per week
> 6 months
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
6. Frequency of
P.E. class per
week
Biannual
1
México
2 Guatemala
Honduras
3
4 El Salvador
5 Costa Rica
Panamá
6
Nicaragua
7
Argentina
8
9
Brasil
Bolivia
10
Chile
11
12
Colombia
Ecuador
13
Paraguay
14
15
Perú
Uruguay
16
Venezuela
17
Cuba
18
19 Dominicana
20 Puerto Rico
Monthly
PA Í S
Quarterly
5. Temporality
Supervision of the
PE Program
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
11
30
39
40
1120
2030 2130
14
6
3
17
20
0
0.3 0.1
0.6
1.5
2
2
56.0
101.5
107
0.7
0.3
0.2
0.9
1
0
0.5 0.3
0.5
0.6
1
0.9
30.7
49.6
44
0.5
0.47
0.4
0.4
0
0
1
3
5
5
120
250
250
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
20
40
45
Máximum
1
1
1
Minimum
0
0
0
0
Percent
5
30
10
55
0
0
0
0
1
0
70
30
15
85
100
0
Note 1: Cuba Provides physical education at the pre-university, higher technical and university levels, with two sessions per
week with a total of 90 minutes.
Note 2: Puerto Rico Upper Secondary Education 14 to 18 years old, applies 2.5 average sessions of 50 minutes each.
ÍTE MS
5. Supervision of the Application of PE Programs, is its timing?: Monthly, quarterly, six months, > six months.
6. What is the frequency of the E.F. per week? : Preschool Primary Secondary.
7. What is the total number of minutes per week received by PE students? : Preschool, Primary and Secondary.
8. Personnel who teach the E.F. Classroom teacher, Specialist teacher, Other profile.
Source: The authors.
433
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Note: Table four (4) shows that in item five (5), the governments of eleven (11) Latin American
countries supervise physical education programs over a period of time of more than six (6) months,
two (2) governments every six months, six (6) every three months and only one (1) government on
a monthly basis. In relation to items six (6) and seven (7), we found that the frequency per week of
physical education sessions in the school environment varies according to the regulations of each
country. However, it could be identified that five (5) countries maintain the same frequency per
minute in all educational levels, seven (7) increase the sessions in the last two levels, three (3) dose
the amount of time with respect to the grade, four (4) maintain an unstable time (increase/decrease)
and only one (1) country maintains the time established in the first formative levels, to later increase
it in secondary school. Finally, in item number eight (8), it is evident that fourteen (14) countries
use the figure of the classroom teacher to teach the subject of physical education at the preschool
level, and six (6) have specialists; at the primary level, seventeen (17) countries have specialist
teachers in these grades and three (3) still have classroom teachers; while, at the secondary level,
the total number of countries participating in this study (20), develop PE sessions with a specialist
teacher of the specific subject.
Now, despite the fact that these transcendental studies are taken as a reference for the PE sector,
there are two particular cases that need to be addressed in this article; the first one emphasizes the
problem that has been occurring in Chile in relation to the stipulations of the National Education
Council, regarding the modification of the school curriculum, in which it is established through
agreement No 57/2019, that the subject of physical education and health (EFYS), will be optional
for the III and IV medium courses from the application of the two thousand twenty curriculum
(PUCV, 2019). Consequently, the decision to eliminate the obligatory nature of this subject for
third- and fourth-year students (13 to 18 years old) continues to cause discrepancies (Senado, 2019),
since according to the Colegio Médico De Chile A.G. (2019) it has generated rejection by a dozen
groups of health, education and sports professionals (Perez Tapia, 2021). (2019) has analyzed the
rejection of a dozen groups of health, education and sports professionals (Perez Tapia, 2021).
In the meantime, it is worth mentioning that, throughout this exhaustive analysis, we were able to
identify that in Brazil a series of anomalies have been increasing in
the Secretariat of Education of the State of Rio Grande do Sul, which
deteriorate the essence and/or purpose of the subject of physical
education. In fact, we had the opportunity to know, study and detail
an open letter made by different entities or organizations in the
sector, including the Rio Grande do Sul delegation of FIEPS, who
besides being one of the standard bearers in being a leader in this
initiative to raise awareness about the importance of this discipline
in society, also allowed us to access the document where the current
situation of physical education in the school context is exposed in
detail.
Figure 1 Image obtained from the Facebook profile of FIEPS-RS Delegate Everton Deiques
434
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Given that:
With this government action, in the first years (from 1st to 5th grade) the number of hours of
Physical Education will be reduced to only 1 hour and 40 minutes per week. Worse, in the later
years (6th to 9th), the workload seems to respond to an announced countdown that would start
with 2 periods per week for the 6th year, and would be reduced to a single period in the 7th, 8th ,
9th and first year of high school. Sacrificing the end of PE in the 2nd and 3rd years of high school,
there would be no more conventional PE classes, something unprecedented in Brazil, in its 171
years of history in the educational sector. And what is aggravating is that this Ordinance 350/2021
is already beginning to show signs of a domino effect in municipal networks, as some municipalities
are already trying to adopt this reduction of periods for their elementary schools (Fédération
Internationale d' Education Physique Et Sportive FIEPS.D. Rio Grande DS (2022).
Source:https://www.facebook.com/photo/?fbid=4265731333528422&set=a.362131163888478
Similarly, it is appropriate to clarify that, according to the latest report presented by the Brazilian
Institute of Geography and Statistics (IBGE), the volume of physical education classes in official
elementary schools is provided by two classes per week lasting 45-50 minutes. This time is only 8%
of the time that schoolchildren remain in school during the week and where they dedicate more
time to moderate and vigorous physical activity (MVPA), on days that include PE classes than on
days without them; therefore, it is a challenge for public educational policies to guarantee access to
knowledge and a minimum infrastructure for learning for all schoolchildren (Gonzalez RH, F.-G.
M. 2021).
For this reason, based on the above, we conclude in this section that it is essential to consider the
educational progress of countries as a component of the process of improving the living conditions
of societies, i.e., their development. In this context, education policies must be harmonized with
the social, political, economic and cultural reality of countries, and must be gradual, coherent and
consistent. Therefore, policies must change as the country's educational development progresses,
so that these changes pose substantial challenges for decision-makers, since they must work to
manage the improvement of the educational system (Pérez Tapia, C. A. 2021).
Conclusions
Having completed the literature review of this study, we conclude that physical exercise, properly
prescribed, advised and controlled by health professionals, represents multiple benefits for
physical, mental, social and public health, and has a significant impact on the prevention of diseases
in the different stages and special conditions of life (Márquez Arabia, J. J. 2020).
Therefore, we infer that those responsible for designing health policies in each nation, are in the
obligation to consider these significant benefits in the evolutionary development of children and
adolescents, when promoting physical activity and healthy eating programs in school environments
(Sánchez Ruiz-Cabello FJ, Campos Martínez AM, de la Vega de Carranza M, Cortés Rico O,
Esparza Olcina MJ, Galbe Sánchez-Ventura J, et al., 2019).
435
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Another fact to consider, in terms of health and education, is to ask the politicians in charge to
make school PE a compulsory discipline for all (for example, boys and girls, and young people with
disabilities) and to promote and achieve equal provision in terms of quantity, quality and content
(United Nations Educational Scientific and Cultural Organization UNESCO, 2021). Likewise, it is
achieved to guarantee through the area of PE, recreation and sport, the fulfillment of the 2030
Sustainable Development Goals, taking as a priority items 3, 4, 5 and 16, so that good health, quality
education, gender equality, peace and justice are promoted from the school context (BaenaMorales, S., Merma-Molina, G., & Gavilán-Martín, D., 2021; United Nations ECLAC, 2018; United
Nations Educational Scientific Cultural Organization UNESCO, 2021).
Finally, it is recommended to all the people who have the possibility to read this research, that if
they wish to present this proposal before any governmental entity, they will have to understand the
current political landscape in order to effectively influence the processes and contents of the
policies and equally to know which positions, responsibilities, commitments, committees and
members are important for the development of policies related to physical activity, PE, school
sport and health. All of this will help build consensus among the various stakeholders, and likewise
allow you to leverage the public and political momentum needed for policy change, with the goal
of getting the leaders of the day to implement each of the stated requests (United Nations
Educational Scientific Cultural Organization UNESCO., 2021).
Reflection
"Let us build in the framework of physical education, public policies of an inclusive nature, aimed at solving problems
that benefit the Latin American community in its different formative stages, from the official educational institutions".
José Francisco Mora Núñez,2022
References
Baena-Morales, S., Merma-Molina, G., & Gavilán-Martín, D. (2021). What do Physical Education
teachers know about the Sustainable Development Goals? A qualitative-exploratory study.
Retos(42), 460. Recuperado el 14 de Febrero de 2022
Cordova, A., Villa, G., Sureda, A., Rodriguez-Marroyo, J.A., & Sánchez-Collado, M.P. (2012).
Physical activity and cardiovascular risk factors in Spanish children aged 11-13 Years. Revista
Española de Cardiología, 65(7), 620 - 626. doi:10.1016/j.recesp.2012.01.026
del Val Martín, P., Sebastiani Obrador, E., & Blázquez Sánchez, D. (2021). ¿Qué es y cómo se mide
la calidad en Educación Física? Una revisión de literatura. Sportis. Scientific Journal of School
Sport,
Physical
Education
and
Psychomotricity,
7(2),
300-301.
doi:https://doi.org/10.17979/sportis.2021.7.2.7181
Educación 3.0. (10 de Junio de 2020). Educación Física: ¿la eterna ‘María’? Recuperado el 2 de Febrero
de
2022,
de
Líder
Informativo
en
Innovación
Educativa:
https://www.educaciontrespuntocero.com/opinion/educacion-fisica-la-eterna-maria/
436
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Fédération Internationale D´ Education Physique Et Sportive FIEPS. (2022). Delegación Do Rio
Grande Do Sul. Recuperado el 31 de Enero de 2022, de Carta Aberta em Defesa da Educação
Física no Rio Grande do Sul: um alerta à sociedade gaúcha sobre a Portaria 350:
https://www.instagram.com/p/CZamTkRO4yp/
Fondo de las Naciones Unidas para la Infancia UNICEF. (2019). La Actividad Física en niños, niñas
y adolescentes. Prácticas necesarias para la vida. República de Panamá: UNICEF. Recuperado el 5
de Febrero de 2022
Frago Calvo, J. M. (2014). Niveles de actividad física en escolares de educación primaria: Actividad física
habitual, clases de educación física y recreos. Zaragoza, España: Universidad de Zaragoza.
Recuperado el 6 de Febrero de 2022
García Rodríguez, J., & Fonseca Hernández, C. (2012). La Actividad Física en los y las jóvenes
mexicanos y mexicanas: Un análisis comparativo entre las universidades públicas y privadas.
MHSalud: Revista en Ciencias del Movimiento Humano y Salud, 9(2), 4. Recuperado el 10 de
Febrero de 2022
Gonzalez RH, F.-G. M. (2021). Characterization of the physical education environment and
practice in public schools. Revista Brasileira de Atividade Física & Saúde, 26, 6.
doi:https://doi.org/10.12820/rbafs.26e0187
Guerra, Y. d. (2021). Relationship Between Physical Inactivity and Covid-19. Acción Motriz(28), 10.
Recuperado el 12 de Febrero de 2022
Guerrero, M. (2019). La Sesión de Educación Física con posibilidad de alcanzar los estándares internacionales
de movimiento recomendados por NASPE y OMS. México: Casa FIEPS San Luis Potosí.
Recuperado el 25 de Marzo de 2022
Hernández-Rincón E.H., A.-V. S.-L.-P.-C.-H.-B. (2018). Physical activity from primary care
oriented to the community for preschool children in a Colombian municipality. Revista
Cubana de Pediatría, 90(2), 202. Recuperado el 4 de Febrero de 2022
Ho, W., Ahmed, M. D., D'Amico, R. L. d., Ramos, A., Ferreira, E. L., Ferreira, M. B. R., . . . Wong,
B. (2018). Measuring the perception of quality physical education in Latin American
professionals.
Revista
Brasileira
de
Ciências
do
Esporte,
40(4),
363.
doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rbce.2018.05.006
Loprinzi, P.D., Cardinal, B.J., Loprinzi, K.L., & Lee, H. (2012). Benefits and environmental
determinants of physical activity in children and adolescents. Obesity Facts, 5(4), 597-610.
doi:10.1159/000342684
Márquez Arabia, J. J. (2020). Physical inactivity, exercise and pandemic COVID-19. VIREF Revista
de Educación Física, 9(2), 47. Recuperado el 14 de Febrero de 2022
Martínez-Aguilera, G. (2022). Multiple intelligences in physical education class; a formative
experience
in
primary
school
students.
Retos(44),
775.
doi:https://doi.org/10.47197/retos.v44i0.89393
Merino Merino, B., Esteban, C., Pilar, & Justo Gil, S. (2016). Actividad Física y Salud de 3 a 6 años:
Guía para docentes de Educación Infantil. Madrid, España: Ministerio de Sanidad, Servicios
Sociales e Igualdad . Recuperado el 12 de Febrero de 2022
437
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Ministerio de Salud, República de Colombia. (s.f.). Protección Social. Recuperado el 9 de Febrero de
2022,
de
Ciclo
de
Vida:
https://www.minsalud.gov.co/proteccionsocial/Paginas/cicloVida.aspx#:~:text=La%20si
guiente%20clasificaci%C3%B3n%20es%20un,(60%20a%C3%B1os%20y%20m%C3%A1s
).
Mora López, D. J., García Pinillos, F., & Latorre Román, P. Á. (2017). Actividad Física, Condición
Física, y Salud en niños preescolares. Estudio de revisión narrativa. EmásF, Revista Digital de
Educación Física(45), 110. Recuperado el 12 de Febrero de 2022
Mora Núñez, J. F., & Campo Peña, A. E. (2021). Políticas Públicas Hacia la Construcción de una
Educación Física de Calidad. FIEPS Bulletin On-line, 91(1), 468-469. doi:10.16887/91.a1.62
Naciones Unidas CEPAL. (2018). La Agenda 2030 y los Objetivos de Desarrollo Sostenible: Una
oportunidad para América Latina y el Caribe. Santiago: Copyright ©. Recuperado el 14 de Febrero
de 2022
Perez Tapia, C. A. (2021). Educación Física Electiva: El caso de Chile ¿Está en crisis su legitimidad
en el curriculum escolar? Arquivos em Movimento, 17(1), 10. Recuperado el 30 de Enero de
2022
Pita-Torres, B. (2020). Políticas públicas y gestión educativa, entre la formulación y la
implementación de las políticas educativas. Civilizar: Ciencias Sociales Y Humanas, 20(39), 140.
doi:https://doi.org/10.22518/jour.ccsh/2020.2a09
Pontificia Universidad Católica de Valparaíso PUCV. (28 de Mayo de 2019). Comunicado Escuela De
Educación
Física.
Recuperado
el
30
de
Enero
de
2022,
de
https://www.pucv.cl/uuaa/filed/noticias/comunicado-escuela-de-educacion-fisica
Posso Pacheco, R. J., Barba Miranda, L. C., Marcillo Ñacato, J. C., Acuña Zapata, M. C., &
Hernández Hernández, F. R. (2020). Enfoques Curriculares como Contribución para la
Autonomía de la Actividad Física. EmásF(63), 132 - 135. Recuperado el 13 de Febrero de
2022
Rodríguez Torres, Á. F., Rodríguez Alvear, J. C., Guerrero Gallardo, H. I., Arias Moreno, E. R.,
Paredes Alvear, A. E., & Chávez Vaca, V. A. (2020). Physical activity benefits for children
and adolescents in the school. Revista Cubana de Medicina General Integral, 36(2), 7. Recuperado
el 12 de Febrero de 2022
Rozengardt Rodolfo. (2006). Acerca de los contenidos de la Educación Física escolar.
EFDeportes(100), 1. Recuperado el 13 de Febrero de 2022
Sánchez López, M., Rodríguez Perea, M., Solera Martínez, M., Jiménez Rodero, C., Notario
Pacheco, B., & Domínguez Contreras, M. L. (2005). Actividad física y calidad de vida
relacionada con la salud en escolares. Revista Clínica de Medicina de Familia, 1(2), 66. Recuperado
el 6 de Febrero de 2022
Sánchez Ruiz-Cabello FJ, Campos Martínez AM, de la Vega de Carranza M, Cortés Rico O,
Esparza Olcina MJ, Galbe Sánchez-Ventura J, et al. (2019). Promoción de la actividad física
en la infancia y la adolescencia (parte 1). Rev Pediatr Aten Primaria(21), 282. Recuperado el 14
de Febrero de 2022
Secretaría de Educación Pública. (2017). Aprendizajes Clave para la Educación Integral: Educación Física,
Educación Básica. Ciudad de México: SEP. Recuperado el 13 de Febrero de 2022
438
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Stodden, D. F., Goodway, J. D., Langendorfer, S. J., Roberton, M. A., Rudisill, M. E., Garcia, C.,
& Garcia, L. E. (2008). A Developmental Perspective on the Role of Motor Skill
Competence in Physical Activity: An Emergent Relationship. Quest, 60(2), 290–306.
doi:https://doi.org/10.1080/00336297.2008.10483582
StuDocu. (s.f.). Ciclo vital humano. Recuperado el 9 de Febrero de 2022, de Fundación Universitaria
Autónoma de las Américas: https://www.studocu.com/co/document/fundacionuniversitaria-autonoma-de-las-americas/farmacologia/ciclo-vital-apuntes-1/7594859
United Nations Educational Scientific Cultural Organization UNESCO. (2013). UNESCONWCPEA: World-wide Survey of School Physical Education - Final Report 2013. Paris: UNESCO.
Recuperado el 3 de Febrero de 2022
United Nations Educational Scientific Cultural Organization UNESCO. (2021). How to influence the
development of quality physical education policy: a policy advocacy toolkit for youth. París, Francia:
UNESCO. Recuperado el 14 de Febrero de 2022
United Nations Educational Scientific Cultural Organization UNESCO. (2 de Febrero de 2021).
La UNESCO hace un llamamiento a la inversión en educación física de calidad para apoyar la recuperación
postCOVID-19.
Recuperado
el
2
de
Febrero
de
2022,
de
https://es.unesco.org/news/unesco-hace-llamamiento-inversion-educacion-fisica-calidadapoyar-recuperacion-post-covid-19
United Nations Educational Scientific Cultural Organization UNESCO. (2021). Making the case for
inclusive quality physical education policy development: a policy brief. París, Francia: UNESCO.
Recuperado el 14 de Febrero de 2022
United Nations Educational Scientific Cultural Organization UNESCO. (2021). Quality Physical
Education Policy Project: analysis of process, content and impact. Paris, France: UNESCO.
Recuperado el 14 de Febrero de 2022
Valladares Fuente, F. E., & Posso Pacheco, R. J. (2022). Metodología para Fortalecer la dimensión
Salud en la clase de Educación Física: Una perspectiva desde Ecuador. FIEPS Bulletin, 91(1),
334. doi:10.16887/92.a1.32
Van Stralen, M.M., Yildirim, M., Wulp, A., Te Velde, S.J., Verloigne, M., Doessegger, A., …. (2014).
Measured sedentary time and physical activity during the school day of European 10- to 12year-old children: The ENERGY project. Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport, 17(2), 201206. doi:10.1016/j.jsams.2013.04.019
Veloso, S. M. (2005). Determinantes da actividade física dos adolescentes : estudo de uma população escolar do
concelho de Oeiras. Recuperado el 10 de Febrero de 2022, de Dissertação de mestrado em
Psicologia desportiva.: http://hdl.handle.net/1822/4800
Verloigne, M., Van Lippevelde, W., Maes, L., Yildirin, M., Chinapaw, M., Manios, Y.,… De
Bourdeaudhuij, I. (2012). Levels of physical activity and sedentary time among 10- to 12year-old boys and girls across 5 European countries using accelerometers: an observational
study within the ENERGY-project. International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical
Activity, 9(34). doi:10.1186/1479-5868-9-34
World Health Organization WHO. (2018). Global Action Plan on Physical Activity 2018-2030.
Recuperado el 11 de Febrero de 2022, de More Active People for a Healthier World:
https://apps.who.int/iris/handle/10665/272722
439
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
World Health Organization WHO. (2019). WHO guidelines on physical activity, sedentary behaviour and
sleep for children under 5 years of age. Washington, D.C.: Organización Panamericana de la Salud.
Recuperado el 11 de Febrero de 2022
World Health Organization WHO. (2020). WHO guidelines on physical activity and sedentary behaviour:
at a glance. Ginebra: World Health Organization. Recuperado el 11 de Febrero de 2022
440
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Physical Activity at School of Children in Poland during the First
Three Years of Primary Education
Aleksandra Lodzińska1 - Magdalena Lelonek2
‘Motor’ Students’ Study Group, Jan Kochanowski University of Kielce, Poland
2
Collegium Medicum, Jan Kochanowski University of Kielce, Poland
e-mail: magdalena.lelonek@ujk.edu.pl
1
Abstract
Physical activity is a key component of a child’s correct development and functioning. Early
school children undergo a period of intense physical, motor, mental and social development.
Because physical activity allows them to fully satisfy the resulting needs, it is important to
guarantee its appropriate dose at this age. Schools, where children spend a major part of their
time, are among the institutions responsible for fulfilling this guarantee. This study analyses the
importance of physical activity in early school children. The authors took into account the
current recommendations for physical activity of children and observed the course of physical
education lessons and breaks at school.
Key words: Physical activity, Physical education, School, Primary education
441
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
Physical activity (PA) is a natural human need at all stages of life. It is considered one of the most
important components of a healthy lifestyle, especially in early school age due to its role in
stimulating and supporting correct growth and development, shaping motor abilities and coping
with stress (Payne & Isaacs, 2016). Children show a natural need for exercise, which is why they
willingly and enthusiastically engage in all forms of PA. A characteristic feature of early school
age that should be taken into account in relation to children’s everyday activity is a high aptitude
for learning new motor skills, especially during sensitive periods (Unierzyski et al., 2019).
Consequently, it is crucial to appropriately incorporate PA into children’s everyday schedule. In
this respect, particular attention is paid to the role of educational institutions, such as schools, in
which children spend most of their day once they begin their education, i.e., from the age of 7
years. Because schools organise physical exercises, they affect the children’s future outlook on PA
for their entire lives (Tremblay et al.; 2016, Erwin et al.; 2012, Ramstetter et al., 2010).
Importance of PA in the development of primary school children
Physical activity can be understood as any bodily movement produced by skeletal muscles that
require energy expenditure (Ward DS, 2007). It is considered one of the basic human biological
needs. Physical activity during early school age is one of the most important factors stimulating
correct development, including control over one’s body and motor coordination. Physical activity
is also very important in children undergoing a growth spurt, which takes place over the first few
years of primary school, and may amount to up to about 7 cm of height gained per year. Physical
activity strengthens the skeletal system, which may alleviate growing pains (Ormańczuk, 2020).
Nałęcz, Mazur and Fijałkowska (2021) propose five primary functions of PA that play a major
role in childhood: stimulatory, adaptive, compensatory, corrective and prophylactic. The first
function, stimulatory, is responsible for supporting correct growth and development. Regular PA
stimulates the body to work with higher intensity. The increased amounts of necessary substances
and oxygen transported into blood by the cardiovascular system reinforces the musculoskeletal
and respiratory systems. As a result, physical exercise improves lung capacity. The nervous system
is also involved: due to the accelerated development of brain centres responsible for movement,
it gains a range of own motor experiences, as well as gradually improves muscle memory and
focus (Ormańczuk, 2020).
The adaptive function of PA shapes motor abilities and determines adaptability to different
conditions in life. Through PA, children are able to strengthen their bodies, i.e. increase their
tolerance to various external factors, such as heat or cold, and resistance to social factors, such as
stress.
The compensatory function of PA is primarily related to counteracting insufficient PA in
children. Physical activity can restore the balance between beneficial and harmful factors in a
young body, thus ensuring correct development. In turn, the corrective function applies to
442
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
children with various disorders, including bad posture, overweight or obesity (Carson et al., 2013;
Hills et al., 2011; Janssen & Leblank, 2010). Finally, the prophylactic function involves preventing
health problems and fostering healthy habits. All five functions should be incorporated into
physical education.
Physical activity of early school children is also particularly important due to the stage of motor
development at this age, which is optimal for the development of most motor abilities. Without a
doubt, early school age still involves an increased need for PA, but at the same time, children’s’
movements become purposeful, harmonious and more efficient. Learning new motor tasks with
a complex structure comes easily to children. Furthermore, the precision of movement also
increases, with almost all motor abilities and foundational movement skills reaching a relatively
high level by the end of the early school period. All of the aforementioned manifestations of
motor development in early school children also determine the occurrence of the second apex in
motor development (Tomik et al., 2018). The second apex lends itself to building speed and
agility and maintaining appropriate flexibility. Conversely, intense strength-based exercise should
be applied with due care (Osiński, 2011). A sensitive period involving an increased aptitude for
learning motor tasks and rapid development of motor abilities is also one of the best times to
learn various sports forms (Payne & Isaacs, 2016). Furthermore, children enter a stage of social
development, during which they enjoy cooperating with others, and by the end of the period,
they even identify with their group of peers. Characteristically, they also want to compare their
capabilities and abilities with others (Garbowski & Górna-Łukasik, 2012), which encourages
them to take on such forms of PA as games or team sports.
Failing to meet the minimal PA needs in children may lead to severe consequences; one of the
most important among these is an increase in overweight and obesity, especially noticeable during
the early school age. The Supreme Audit Office (Najwyższa Izba Kontroli, NIK) in Poland has
issued a warning (NIK, 2013) that Polish children show the most rapid increase in overweight
and obesity in Europe while also showing a consistent decrease in PA. The authors of the report
also point out that Polish children engage in PA less than their peers from other European
countries. The positive energy balance in children and youth may result not only from
increasingly sedentary activities, but also from commuting predominantly by car or various means
of public transport and a regular intake of excessive, calorie-rich meals (Nałęczkowska, Mazur &
Fijałkowska, 2021). Physical inactivity may lead to the increased share of children with
overweight and obesity among the population, a high prevalence of bad posture, as well as a
considerable decrease in the physical fitness of Polish children, which has been observed over the
last 30 years (Sakłak, Szark-Eckardt & Pasek, 2021).
Recommendations for PA in early school children
The WHO (2020) recommends a minimal dose for children and youth aged 5–17 years of 60
minutes per day of moderate to intense PA, which should primarily involve aerobic exercise.
Children and youth should also perform intense aerobic exercise three times per week, as well as
443
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
activities that strengthen the muscles and bones. Furthermore, the WHO recommends reducing
sitting and screen time.
Recommendations for PA in early school children have also been developed in Poland. The
Ministry of Sport and Tourism, in cooperation with experts, published a research-and-analysis
report entitled Krajowe Rekomendacje Prozdrowotnej Aktywności Fizycznej (National Recommendations
for Healthy Physical Activity). The report diagnosed PA in Polish society between 2015–2017,
and the collected data were used to develop recommendations concerning minimal PA for
various age groups, from children and youth, through adults, to elders. The recommendations for
early school children (6/7–11 years old) match those developed by the WHO and amount to at
least 60 minutes of organised or spontaneous daily PA, which should involve aerobic exercise.
Early school children should also perform high-intensity activity three times per week, which also
matches the WHO recommendations. As the authors of the report state, ‘this physical activity
should include physical games and play, sports activities, commuting, recreational activities, as
well as physical education lessons or other organised forms of physical activity performed with
family, at school or with the local community (Tomik i inni, 2018). A report published by the
Institute of Mother and Child entitled Aktualna ocena poziomu aktywności fizycznej dzieci i młodzieży w
wieku 3-19 lat w Polsce (Current Assessment of the Level of Physical Activity in Children and
Youth Aged 3–19 Years in Poland) also provides recommendations for PA in early school
children. Among these are limiting screen time to two hours daily, promoting traditional forms of
physical recreation during free time as an alternative to screen time, increasing the accessibility of
gymnasiums and sports equipment at school and encouraging children to commute actively to or
from school, i.e. by walking or cycling, in cases where commuting would take no longer than 30
minutes. The report also stated that about 20% of early school children did not meet the
recommended minimum of PA, most of whom were girls (Fijałkowska, 2018). According to the
results obtained during an assessment conducted as part of the Global Matrix 3.0 project 80% of
Polish children do not meet the criterion of minimal daily PA (Aubert et al., 2018).
All of the above recommendations, both global and Polish, aim to promote taking up PA to
ensure optimal functioning and minimise the risk of health problems, especially because the level
of PA decreases with age (Ostręga, 2017).
Physical education in early school education of children
Subject literature defines physical education as deliberate action aimed at shaping healthy and
prosocial attitudes, supporting physical and health development and building a habit of
performing PA and maintaining physical endurance, motor fitness and correct body posture
(Osiński, 2011). Physical education is a mandatory subject in primary education across the EU.
Furthermore, the value of physical education is highlighted by the fact that in the curricula in all
European countries, it is taught throughout the entire period of mandatory education (Sakłak,
Szark-Eckardt & Pasek, 2021). In Poland, in accordance with the Regulation of the Minister of
National Education on the framework daily schedule in public education, the minimum weekly
volume of physical education in early childhood education is three hours (Dz.U. 2012 poz.204).
444
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
As per the core curriculum, the primary aim of physical education is building a habit of
performing PA. Lessons should focus on developing each student’s interests and attitudes and
supporting the building of a positive self-image as a participant of broadly defined PA, including
recreational, sports and touristic activity. According to recommendations, physical education
lessons must be conducted in a gymnasium, in an appropriately equipped substitute room, on a
school playing field or in a natural environment. Furthermore, the core curriculum recommends
that students perform different roles over the course of the lessons, including the initiator and
organiser of physical exercises, games and play, player, referee and fan (Dz.U. 2017 poz. 356).
The core curriculum also lists areas to be covered during physical education lessons in grades 1–3
of primary school, including maintaining personal hygiene and health, motor fitness and various
forms of sports and recreation. The purpose of these topics is to help students achieve awareness
of the importance of systematicity and perseverance in exercising and various forms, such as
team sports, gymnastics or track-and-field (Dz.U. 2017 poz. 356).
Physical education lessons in
minutes per week
Physical education lessons in early school education are children’s first contact with systematic
organised PA. Lessons in grades 1–3 of primary school in Poland amount to a total of 96 hours
over a school year. This volume allows for certain optimism compared to other European
countries, as indicated in a comparison included in a study by Pośpiech (2006) of the average
weekly volume of obligatory physical education lessons in minutes across the subsequent stages
of education (Tab. 1).
200
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
Children aged 6-9
Children aged 10-12
Country
Figure 1 Mean weekly volume of mandatory physical education lessons in minutes
for early school and school children across selected countries in Europe
Source: authors’ own elaboration based on: Pośpiech, J. (2006). Jakość europejskiego wychowania
fizycznego w świetle badań [Quality of Physical Education in Europe in Light of Research]. Racibórz:
Wydawnictwo Państwowa Wyższa Szkoła Zawodowa.
However, it is debatable whether physical education lessons at school are actually or effectively
spent on PA. In a study by (Białek, Fila & Zielonka, 2015), 80% of assessed teachers declared
445
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
conducting three physical education lessons per week. Unfortunately, there were also teachers
who declared conducting only two (7%) or even one (7%) lesson per week. A study conducted by
Madejski (Madejski, 2013) showed that only 64% of primary school students had physical
education lessons in a gymnasium, and even then, only once per week, while about 10% did not
use a gymnasium at all. Another important factor for the evaluation of the quality of physical
education is how the lessons are conducted. According to a survey conducted by NIK (NIK,
2013), only 21% found the lessons to be interesting. Unfortunately, the remaining students (79%)
disagreed (NIK, 2013). The fact that such situations take place already at an early stage of
education may considerably reduce the importance of PA, leading to children developing a
negative attitude toward it.
An important part of school time are breaks, during which children may also perform PA, which
contributes to the recommended minimum of PA. Breaks can be defined as the time between
lessons during which children can engage in spontaneous or organised play at the premises of the
school (Andrzejczuk, 2017). In Poland, children have at least four breaks daily at school. It is
estimated that moderate PA performed by children during a break may even amount to 40% of
total break time and constitute a major contributor to the recommended minimum dose of PA
for this age group due to the accumulation of active minutes over the course of a day (Parish et
al.; 2013; Ridgers et al., 2012). Engaging in PA by children during breaks may bring numerous
health benefits, especially those related to maintaining an appropriate body composition and
correct functioning of the circulatory system (Carson et al.; 2013; Kwon et al., 2011). Breaks are
also important due to the developmental opportunities they offer to children, along with an
opportunity for rest, relaxation and improved chances for good performance at school (Ickes et
al., 2013, Parrish et al., 2013).
Summary
Physical activity is a key element for the correct development of children. Some of the benefits of
regular PA indicated in subject literature are improved physical fitness, endurance and immunity,
strengthened bones, increased muscle strength and endurance, reduced excessive body mass,
decreased blood pressure in youth with moderate hypertension, reduced concentration of
cholesterol and/or triglycerides, as well as increased readiness for learning, better mental wellbeing and improved social relationship (Nałęczkowska, Mazur & Fijałkowska, 2021) s.
Early school age is also especially important due to the opportunities offered by this stage of
development, particularly by the second apex of motor development, which is a very beneficial
factor for the shaping of children’s lifelong attitude toward PA and building selected motor
abilities. Early school age is also an appropriate period to encourage children to take on various
sports disciplines considering the ease with which they learn new motor skills.
A key element here is a consistent improvement in the quality of education and encouraging
children to fully participate in physical culture from the youngest age. This depends to a
considerable extent on awareness of PA needs and the importance of PA in ontogenesis. To this
446
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
effect, an active attitude on the part of teachers in early school education along with school-led
initiatives, such as organising after-school sports classes, can have a beneficial influence.
Furthermore, it is important to support the development of various motor abilities from the
earliest age by implementing educational programmes to promote everyday PA (UNESCO,
2021).
References
Andrzejczuk, J. (2017). Przerwy międzylekcyjne: sposoby ich wykorzystania z pedagogicznego
oraz psychologicznego punktu widzenia. In Е.Е. Марченко (Ed.), Психология сегодня: взгляд
современного студента: cборник материалов XII международной студенческой научнопрактической конференции по психологии. Брест, 28 апреля 2017 года. Брест 2017.
Aubert, S., Barnes, J. D., Abdeta, C., Abi Nader, P., Adeniyi, A. F., Aguilar-Farias, N., &
Tremblay, M. S. (2018). Global Matrix 3.0 Physical Activity Report Card Grades for
Children and Youth: Results and Analysis From 49 Countries. Journal of Physical Activity and
Health, 15(S2), S251–S273.
Białek, A., Fila, J., & Zielonka, P. (2015). Wychowanie fizyczne w opiniach dyrektorów i nauczycieli.
Organizacja kształcenia, podstawa programowa i ocenianie uczniów w szkołach podstawowych.
Warszawa: Instytut Badań Edukacyjnych.
Carson V., Ridgers N.D., Howard B.J. (2013). Light-intensity physical activity and
cardiometabolic biomarkers in US adolescents. PLoS One 2013;8:e71417.
doi:10.1371/journal.pone 0071417 e71417.
Engel, J. Okresy sensytywne w rozwoju dziecka. Miastodzieci.pl. Retrieved March 13, 2022, from
https://miastodzieci.pl/czytelnia/okresy-sensytywne-w-rozwoju-dziecka/
Erwin H.E., Abel M., Beighle i in. (2012). The contribution of recess to children’s school-day
physical activity. Journal of Physical Activity & Health, 9(3), 442–448.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21934153.
Fijałkowska, A. (2018). Aktualna ocena poziomu aktywności fizycznej dzieci i młodzieży wieku 3-19 lat w
Polsce. Warszawa: Instytut Matki i Dziecka.
Garbowski, W. & Górna-Łukasik, K. (2012). Szkolne wychowanie fizyczne. Katowice: Wydawnictwo
Akademii Wychowania Fizycznego.
Hills A.P., Andersen L.B., Byrne N.M. (2011). Physical activity and obesity in children. Br. J.
Sports Med; 45, 866–870.
Janssen I., Leblanc A.G. (2010). Systematic review of the health benefits of physical activity and
fitness in school-aged children and youth. Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act 10;7:40.
doi:10.1186/1479-5868-7-40.
Kwon S., Janz K.F., Burns T.L., Levy S.M. (2011). Association between light-intensity physical
activity and adiposity in childhood. Pediatr Exerc Sci 2011;23: 218–29.
Madejski, E. (2013). Wybrane uwarunkowania osobnicze, rodzinne i szkolne aktywności ruchowej. Kraków:
Wyd. AWF.
Nałęcz, H., Mazur, J., & Fijałkowska, A. (2021). Aktywność fiyczna dzieci i młodzieży. In W.
Drygas, M. Gajewska, & T. Zdrojewski (Eds.), Niedostateczny poziom aktywności fizycznej w
Polsce. Warszawa: Narodowy Instytut Zdrowia Publicznego.
447
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
NIK (2013). Raport. Wchowanie fizyczne i sport w szkołach publicznych i niepublicznych. Retrieved March
12, 2022, from https://www.nik.gov.pl/plik/id,5651,vp,7325.pdf
Ormańczuk, I. (2020). Znaczenie aktywności ruchowej w rozwoju dziecka w wieku szkolnym.
Zdrowie i rozwój (13).
Osiński, W. (2011). Teoria wychowania fizycznego. Poznań: Akademia Wychowania Fizycznego.
Ostręga, W. (2017). Aktywność fizyczna jako kluczowy element zdrowego stylu życia. Warszawa: Instytut
Matki i Dziecka.
Parrish, A., Okely, A. D., Stanley, R. M., Ridgers, N.D. (2013). The effect of school recess
interventions on physical activity: a systematic review. Sports Med.;43(4):287–299.
Payne, G. V. & Isaacs, L. D., (2016) Human motor development, Holcomb Hathaway: United States
of America.
Polish Journal of Laws 2012, Item 204. Rozporządzenie Ministra Edukacji Narodowej z dnia 7 lutego
2012 r. w sprawie ramowych planów nauczania w szkołach publicznych. Retrieved March 12, 2022,
from https://isap.sejm.gov.pl/isap.nsf/DocDetails.xsp?id=wdu201200002
Polish Journal of Laws 2017, Item 356. Rozporządzenie Ministra Edukacji Narodowej z dnia 14 lutego
2017 r. w sprawie podstawy programowej wychowania przedszkolnego oraz podstawy programowej
kształcenia ogólnego dla szkoły podstawowej, w tym dla uczniów z niepełnosprawności intelektualną w
stopniu umiarkowanym lub znacznym, kształcenia ogólnego dla branżowej szkoły I stopnia, kształcenia
ogólnego dla szkoły specjalnej przysposabiającej do pracy oraz kształcenia ogólnego dla szkoły policealnej.
Retrieved March 12, 2002, from
https://isap.sejm.gov.pl/isap.nsf/DocDetails.xsp?id=WDU20170000356
Pośpiech, J. (2006). Jakość europejskiego wychowania fizycznego w świetle badań. Racibórz : Wydawnictwo
Państwowa Wyższa Szkoła Zawodowa
Ramstetter C.L., Murray R., Garner A.S. (2010). The crucial role of recess in schools. J Sch
Health.;80(11):517–526.
Ridgers, N. D., Salmon, J., Parrish, A. M, Stanley, R.M., Okely, A.D. (2012). Physical activity
during school recess: a systematic review. Am J Prev Med. 2012;43(3):320–328.
Sakłak, W., Szark-Eckardt, M., & Pasek, M. (2021). Nauczyciel wychowania fizycznego jako
wsparcie w realizacji programów zdrowotnych. In W. Drygas, M. Gajewska, & T.
Zdrojewski (Eds.), Niedostateczny poziom aktywności fizycznej w Polsce. Warszawa: Narodowy
Instytut Zdrowia Publicznego.
Tomik, R., Dębska, M., Gołaś, A., Nawrocka, A., Polechoński, J., & Rozpara, M. (2018). Krajowe
Rekomendacje Prozdrowotnej Aktywności Fizycznej. Katowice: Ministerstwo Sportu i Turystyki.
UNESCO (2021). Promoting Quality Physical Education Policy. Retrieved March 20, 2022, from
https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000376151
Unierzyski, P., Lelonek, M., Multan, J., Walter, K., Wałęsa, K. & Andrzejewski, W. (2019). Tennis
10: manual of tennis teaching for children under 10: guide for instructors and coaches. Polish Tennis
Association.
Ward, D.S. (2007). Physical activity interventions in children and adolescents. Champaign, IL.: Human
Kinetics Publ.
WHO (2020). Physical activity. Key facts. Retrieved March 12, 2022, from
https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/physical-activity
448
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Percentiles of Physical Qualities in Men and Women of Primary
Schools, in San Luis Potosí Mexico
Manuel Guerrero Zainos1 - Antonio Eugenio Rivera Cisneros2 - Ricardo
Félix Inguanzo3 - Juan Sandoval Barajas4
1
FIEPS North America, Mexico
Universidad del Futbol y Ciencias del Deporte, Mexico
3
Benemérita Escuela Normal "Manuel Ávila Camacho", Mexico
4
Departamento de Educación Física SEGE; San Luis Potosí, México
e-mail: mzainos@fiepmexico.org
2
Abstract
Different studies show an alarming deterioration of poor physical condition in children and
adolescents caused by sedentarism, mainly in industrialized societies (Ortega, Castillo, Moreno
2005). Also, the United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF)notes that Mexico ranks first in the
world in childhood obesity and second in adults (Senate of Mexico, 2017). These obesity crises are
also manifest in Spain, the Netherlands, Belgium, Denmark, Australia, and Japan, cited by Aguilar,
Pradilla, and Mosquera (2011). Purpose: To determine the percentiles of physical qualities of men
and women of Primary Education, ages 9 to 11, in San Luis Potosí, Mexico. Methodology: There was
a participation of 6,333 students. Six Tests of Physical Qualities related to health and sports activity
were selected, following the protocols recommended by AAHPERD (1970) American College of
Sports Medicine (2014). The hypothesis of this study was: Percentiles located with students from the
state of San Luis Potosí (SLP) are lower than in other studies. Results: Percentiles 5 to 99 were
obtained; for the internal and external analysis of the Physical Qualities, the percentile (p) 50 in
men and women was considered. In the Flexibility Test, women are more flexible than men. In the
tests related to cardiorespiratory resistance, strength/muscle endurance, and speed, men present
better results than women. These percentiles were compared with other studies carried out; in Latin
America is, their values similar; with higher values were located in those of the United States of
America and other countries of Europe. Conclusion: these percentiles obtained are a reference of the
Physical Qualities in SSLP from 9 to 11 years, considered a diagnostic tool for the safe prescription
of exercise in physical education and school sports sessions.
Key words: Percentiles, Physical qualities, Physical education
449
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
Several studies show an alarming deterioration in the poor physical condition of children and
adolescents caused by sedentarism, mainly in industrialized societies (Ortega, Castillo, Moreno
2005). The World Health Organization (WHO 2002) and the Pan-American Organization (PAHO
2002) express the need for the timely diagnosis and implementation of physical activity programs
that are reflect in the improvement of cardiorespiratory and muscular capacity as their nutritional
status, with positive effects on their physical, social and psychological environment for a healthy
life.
For Secchi, García, (2012) cited by Vidarte, Vélez, Arango, Parra (2022):
Physical condition is related to health, defined as the ability that a person has to perform
activities of daily life with vigor and refers to those components of physical condition that
are related to health: aerobic ability; muscle-skeletal capacity; motor capacity; and body
composition. (Secchi, G. 2012:163).
Other studies on physical condition carried out by Pila (2012) in Mexico, Cuba and Venezuela
mention the contribution of the Physical Quality as the set of components the individual must
possess. The AAPHERD in 1958 marks the starting point with different Tests to evaluate the PQ;
Canada has also made different contributions to evaluate the Physical Qualities.
In Mexico, there are few works on physical qualities in primary school students; some correspond
to Hermenegildo Pila (1997), supported by the National Commission of Physical Culture and Sport
(CONADE). Another document is the Manual of Measurement in Physical Education, published
by the National Council for the Development of Physical Education and Sport in Basic Education
(CONDEBA 2000). The most recently applied to the whole country, with the name of "Ponte al
Cien" (Measuring Physical Qualities), promoted by CONDEBA and CONADE (2013), the latter’s
final results are not known.
The preceding shows the importance of attending to physical condition in school children, with
the application of physical qualities tests, considered as a strategy to know their results and
implement activities that support the preservation of health.
The state of San Luis Potosi is geographically located in the center of the Mexican Republic. With
industrial development and great cultural wealth, the Department of Physical Education of the
(SEGE) San Luis Potosí, in coordination with the International Federation of Physical and Sports
Education (FIEPS), set the objective: Determine the percentiles of physical qualities in men and women of
primary education.
For this study, the Physical Qualities Tests related to Flexibility, Strength (abdominal), Explosive
force (jumps: horizontal and vertical), travel speed, and cardiorespiratory resistance was applied.
Authors of the American Alliance for Health, Physical Education, Recreation and Dance AAHPER
450
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
(1970), Bravo C. (2016), Fernandes J. (2003), Pila H. (1997), Blázquez D. (1996), Martínez (2008)
were consulted for the application protocols of the various Tests.
Methodology
The participating students were from primary schools of 9, 10, and 11 years of age, with a total of
6,333 participants (51% men and 49% women), with a collection of 15,833 samples. This study
was carried out with a collection of data from three school cycles, 2018 - 2020, from public and
private primary schools, which are located with an average to medium-low socioeconomic level
(90%) and high (10%), belonging to three regions of the state of San Luis Potosí.
For the current project, a Test Battery suggested by the AAHPERD mentioned by Fernandes
(2003) and EUROFIT was considered, applying the following Tests: Traditional Sit and Reach
(Wells & Dillon); Sit-up (Pollock & Wilmore) 60 seconds; Speed 30 meters; Vertical Jump (Sargent
& Lewis); Standing Long Jump (Johnson & Nelson); Shuttle Run / Course Navette (Léger &
Lambert).
The procedures for carrying out this project were carried out through the physical education
authorities, with information on the project to school directors and parents. To ensure the integrity
of the participating students, the ethical aspects of research expressed in the Declaration of Helsinki
(1964) were considered, in Mexico, the General Health Law on Health Research (Chamber of
Deputies DOF 02-02-2014). This research project was endorsed by the Ethics Committee
composed of the Department of Physical Education of the SEGE and the Technical Pedagogical
Committee of the FIEPS North America.
The methodology of each Test was explained to the participants; in its realization, they were
assisted, and a previous "heating" was applied for each Test to avoid injuries (Platonov 1991). The
results of each Test were manually recorded in a format delivered to the evaluators.
For the final analysis of the collected data, the statistical treatment (quantitative) was made through
several templates, Excel, Microsoft, and Software Statistical Package Social Sciences (SPSS v. 20.0);
in this way, the percentiles were determined and ranked from 5 to 99. Percentiles were passed to a
qualitative assessment of seven levels, with the following interpretations: Very low, Low, Medium-low,
Medium, Medium-high, Good, Excellent.
To operate successfully percentile actions obtained from (PQ) or Physical Capabilities, it is
necessary to have as a reference the Global Plan of Action on Physical Activity 2019 - 2030 of the
WHO: This calls on the government authorities to support the action of School Physical
Education, which is associated with adopting healthy lifestyles impacting the school population.
Results
After applying the Physical Qualities Tests to men and women, the teachers expressed their
approval to continue these results and to know the statistical data the present study yielded to
451
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
appreciate the reality of the Physical Qualities, students (9, 10, and 11 years old) from the state of
San Luis Potosí.
Tables 1, 2, and 3 show a descriptive analysis of the results obtained in men and women, with the
Percentiles from 5 to 99, with the name of each of the Physical Qualities and age. For the analysis
of results, the percentile (p). 50 was taken as the basis.
Sit and Reach test women 9 and 10 years old present a difference 3 cm greater than men; in 11 years
women present a difference in favor with 4 centimeters.
The argument for flexibility is significant in women because they are designed for a greater
amplitude of movement, especially in the pelvic region: wider hips with less muscle tone. Corbin
(1980) mentions that girls have more significant potential for flexibility due to their lower height
of the center of mass and shorter legs. Martin (1982), in his Sensitive Phase Model (SPM), explains
that from six (6) to ten (10) years of age, boys and girls have a high level of flexibility development;
from year 11 onwards, flexibility is placed at a basic level.
In sit-up tests, men have better results than women; in 9 years, there is a difference of 6 repetitions;
in 10 years, the difference is five repetitions; and in 11 years, a difference of 4. It is noted as eight
years of age. That women in the 11 years are improving their strength. Martin (1982), in his SPM,
mentions that the capacity of the force develops from
In the Speed Test, 30 m. men have better results than women. At the age of 9, there is a difference of
three (3) tenths of a second being favoring men. At the age of 10, there is a difference of four (4)
tenths of a second, favoring men. At the age of 11, there are a difference of two (2) tenths of a
second, lower in men than women. In this Displacement Speed Test, their results in men and
women do not exist significant differences in their times, which are very close, as seen in Tables
1,2, and 3. Rabadán (2010) mentions that the speed of displacement in puberty values is similar to
that of adults.
Vertical Jump Test, men scored better than women. In the nine years, it is observed that men are
with a (1) centimeter better than women; in the ten years, the difference is three (3) centimeters
favoring men; in the 11 years, men are with two (2) centimeters better than women. In the end, the
differences are very short between men and women. Meanwhile, Martin (1982) in his SPM,
mentions the capacity of explosive speed, which has a good development from 8 to 12.5 years.
Test Standing Long Jump, in the ages of 9 and 10 years, a difference of 10 centimeters was found to
favor men; in the 11 years, men present a greater displacement of 13 centimeters, compared to the
mark obtained by women.
In the Shuttle Run Test, men have a better route than women. For example, in the nine (9) and 10
years a difference of 0.5 periods or paliers of travel was obtained favoring men. In the 11 years, it
is observed that the improvement of men compared to women, was a difference a (1) period or
452
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
95
101
1.0
1.0
15
20
25
17
18
19
20
21
23
7"4/10
7"1/10
6"9/10
20
21
21
105
106
109
1.0
1.0
1.5
30
35
40
20
21
22
24
25
26
6"8/10
6"7/10
6"6/10
22
23
24
110
112
115
1.5
1.5
2.0
45
50
55
23
24
25
27
28
29
6"5/10
6"5/10
6"4/10
24
25
26
116
120
125
2.0
2.5
2.5
60
65
70
26
27
28
30
31
32
6"4/10
6"3/10
6"3/10
26
27
28
128
129
132
75
80
85
28
29
30
33
35
37
6"2/10
6"1/10
6"1/10
29
30
31
90
95
99
32
34
36
38
41
47
6"0/10
6"0/10
5"6/10
5
10
16
19
10
14
15
20
25
20
21
22
30
35
40
SHUTTLE RUN. Course
Navette Léger - Lamber)
1 minute.
17
18
STANDING LONG
JUMP.Johnson & Nelson.
Centimeters
8"1/10
7"6/10
Repetitions
Seconds
Centimeters
14
15
14
18
7"8/10
7"2/10
19
21
94
100
1.0
1.0
15
20
25
18
19
20
19
22
23
7"0/10
6"8/10
6"7/10
22
23
24
105
110
114
1.0
1.5
1.5
30
35
40
21
22
23
24
25
26
6"6/10
6"5/10
6"4/10
25
26
27
115
119
120
1.5
2.0
2.5
M
E
N
45
50
55
24
25
25
27
29
30
6"3/10
6"3/10
6"2/10
27
27
28
121
125
126
2.5
3.0
3.0
10
2.5
3.0
3.0
60
65
70
26
27
28
30
31
34
6"2/10
6"1/10
6"0/10
29
30
31
130
132
135
3.0
3.5
4.0
135
138
142
3.5
4.0
4.5
75
80
85
29
31
33
35
36
39
6"0/10
5"9/10
5"9/10
32
32
34
137
140
145
5.0
5.0
6.0
32
35
38
145
149
160
5.0
6.0
8.0
90
95
99
34
37
41
40
45
60
5"8/10
5"5/10
5"2/10
34
36
40
150
157
171
7.0
8.5
9.0
8"3/10
7"8/10
15
17
80
93
1.0
1.0
5
10
17
20
10
14
7"5/10
7"4/10
18
19
85
91
1.0
1.0
15
16
17
7"6/10
7"5/10
7"3/10
18
19
20
96
98
100
1.0
1.5
1.5
15
20
25
22
23
24
15
16
18
7"3/10
7"1/10
7"0/10
20
20
21
95
100
102
1.5
1.5
1.5
23
24
25
18
19
20
7"2/10
7"1/10
7"0/10
20
21
22
102
105
106
1.5
1.5
1.5
30
35
40
24
26
26
19
20
21
7"0/10
6"9/10
6"8/10
22
23
24
105
110
110
1.5
2.0
2.0
45
50
55
26
27
27
21
22
24
6"9/10
6"8/10
6"7/10
23
24
24
110
110
113
2.0
2.0
2.0
45
50
55
27
28
28
22
24
25
6"7/10
6"7/10
6"6/10
24
24
25
113
115
116
2.5
2.5
3.0
60
65
70
29
30
30
25
26
27
6"7/10
6"6/10
6"5/10
25
25
26
115
117
120
2.0
2.5
2.5
60
65
70
30
30
31
26
28
30
6"5/10
6"4/10
6"3/10
26
26
27
120
120
123
3.0
3.5
3.5
75
80
85
32
32
33
29
31
32
6"5/10
6"4/10
6"3/10
26
27
28
120
124
129
3.0
3.0
3.5
75
80
85
32
33
34
31
31
33
6"2/10
6"1/10
6"1/10
28
28
29
125
130
131
3.5
4.0
4.5
90
95
99
34
35
39
34
36
40
6"2/10
6"1/10
5"9/10
29
31
35
131
140
148
4.0
4.5
7.5
90
95
99
35
37
47
35
40
45
6"0/10
5"8/10
5"5/10
30
32
40
137
145
151
5.0
6.0
7.5
Centimeters Period / Palier
M
E
N
9
Y
E
A
R
S
W
O
M
E
N
9
Y
E
A
R
S
School population Primary
Source: Author
School population Primary
SPEED 30 METERS
Expressed in seconds.
VERTICAL JUMP
(Sargent & Lewis)
STANDING LONG
JUMP.Johnson & Nelson.
SHUTTLE RUN. Course
Navette Léger - Lamber)
1 minute.
5
10
Centimeters
14
16
Repetitions
13
17
Seconds
7"8/10
7"1/10
Centimeters
19
22
Centimeters
100
105
Period / Palier
1.0
1.5
15
20
25
20
20
21
21
23
25
7"0/10
6"7/10
6"6/10
23
24
25
110
113
120
2.0
2.0
2.5
30
35
40
21
23
24
26
28
29
6"5/10
6"4/10
6"3/10
26
27
27
125
126
127
2.5
3.0
3.0
45
50
55
24
25
26
30
31
32
6"2/10
6"2/10
6"1/10
28
29
30
130
131
134
3.5
4.0
4.0
60
65
70
27
27
28
33
35
38
6"0/10
5"9/10
5"9/10
30
31
32
135
138
139
4.5
5.0
6.0
75
80
85
29
32
34
39
40
42
5"8/10
5"7/10
5"6/10
33
34
36
140
145
150
6.5
7.0
8.0
90
95
99
34
35
43
43
48
57
5"5/10
44"0/10
4"9/10
37
39
44
155
162
175
8.5
9.0
9.5
5
10
18
19
11
15
8"1/10
7"5/10
19
20
90
97
1.0
1.0
15
20
25
22
24
25
16
20
21
7"4/10
7"2/10
7"1/10
22
22
23
100
103
106
1.5
1.5
1.5
30
35
40
25
27
28
22
24
25
6"8/10
6"7/10
6"6/10
24
24
25
110
110
113
2.0
2.0
2.0
45
50
55
28
29
30
26
27
29
6"5/10
6"4/10
6"4/10
26
27
28
115
118
120
2.5
3.0
3.0
60
65
70
32
32
33
30
30
32
6"3/10
6"2/10
6"2/10
29
29
30
120
124
125
3.0
3.5
4.0
75
80
85
34
35
35
33
35
37
6"1/10
6"0/10
6"0/10
31
32
33
128
130
134
4.5
5.0
5.5
90
95
99
36
38
44
39
43
56
5"9/10
5"8/10
5"4/10
34
35
41
139
148
155
6.5
8.0
9.0
SIT AND REACH (Wells
& Dillon). AAHPERD
traditional
SIT - UP (Pollock &
Wilmore). Repetitions
60 seconds.
Table 3. Percentile: Sit and Reach, Sit – Up, Speed 30 m, Vertical Jump, Standing Long Jump,
Shuttle Run in 11 year-old Men and Women.
PERC EN TI LE
Source: Author
PERC EN TI LE
Centimeters
5
10
PERC EN TI LE
VERTICAL JUMP
(Sargent & Lewis)
Seconds
18
19
SPEED 30 METERS
Expressed in seconds.
VERTICAL JUMP
(Sargent & Lewis)
Repetitions
8
14
SIT - UP (Pollock &
Wilmore). Repetitions
60 seconds.
SPEED 30 METERS
Expressed in seconds.
Centimeters
5
10
SIT AND REACH (Wells
& Dillon). AAHPERD
traditional
Table 2. Percentile: Sit and Reach, Sit – Up, Speed 30 m, Vertical Jump, Standing Long Jump,
Shuttle Run in 10 year-old Men and Women.
SHUTTLE RUN. Course
Navette Léger - Lamber)
1 minute.
STANDING LONG
JUMP.Johnson & Nelson.
SIT - UP (Pollock &
Wilmore). Repetitions
60 seconds.
SIT AND REACH (Wells
& Dillon). AAHPERD
traditional
Table 1. Percentile: Sit and Reach, Sit – Up, Speed 30 m, Vertical Jump, Standing Long Jump,
Shuttle Run in 9 year-old Men and Women.
Source: Author
School population Primary
453
M
E
N
11
Y
E
A
R
S
W
O
M
E
N
11
Y
E
A
R
S
Centimeters Period / Palier
Y
E
A
R
S
W
O
M
E
N
10
Y
E
A
R
S
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
complete palier; the latter result coincides with those explained, by Martín (1982) and Rabadán
(2010), in this capacity of cardiorespiratory resistance begins a stage of overcoming from 11 years
of age marked in the PMS.
In Table 4, a qualitative assessment is presented, with percentiles grouped to give the following
interpretation: p. 5 to 10 obtain the Very Low Level; p.15 to 25 as Low Level; p. 30 to 40 Low
Mean Level; p. 45 to 55 Medium Level, p. 60 to 70 High Mean Level; p. 75 to 85 Level Good; 90
to 99 Level Excellent.
In this table, all physical qualities evaluated are concentrated, having a quick visualization of the
location of all the percentiles achieved in this research.
Table 4. Percentile Levels of Physical Qualities in men and women from 9 to 11 years of age.
MEN
WO ME N
SIT AND REACH
AAHPERD Traditional
Values Centimeters
SIT - UP (Pollock
Wilmore) Repetitions
60 seconds
SPEED 30 Meters
Values in seconds
VERTICAL JUMP
Sargent & Lewis
Value centimeters
SATANDING LONG
JUMP. Values
centimeters
SHUTTLE RUN. COURSE
NAVETTE. Léger &
Lamber. 20 m. Period
1 minute.
Saurce: Author
School population Primary
Discussion and conclusion
The following findings emerged from the present study:
The stated objective was fulfilled Determine the percentiles of physical qualities in men and women from 9 to
11 years of age of Primary Education in San Luis Potosí. Have percentiles of their own obtained from a
battery of six Physical Qualities, which are related to the statement by (Gudes; 2007, Martínes &
López; 2008) in a sense. That four Tests can focus on physical evaluation related to health, and six
to eight are related to the evaluation of sports performance. In this sense, the battery of Physical
Qualities applied encompasses health with the Tests of flexibility, muscle endurance, and
cardiorespiratory capacity (Shuttle run); other Tests of muscle strength (jumps) and speed are added
to support sports performance.
454
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
The cut-off points were expressed in percentiles, similar to those presented by Blázquez (1996).
These percentiles are grouped to express a qualitative evaluation.
This study highlights that woman have more flexibility compared to men of all ages. The remaining
Tests show slight differences in their values, being higher than that of men than women.
The comparison of values obtained with other countries is essential to know and overcome the
weaknesses, this analysis was done with the age of 10 years and the (p) 50 in men and women, and
the following results were obtained: For the Flexibility test, the data found in (p) 50, of the students
of San Luis Potosí (SLP) in men are 25 and women 28 centimeters, data that are lower than those
found by (Salleg 2010 and Teleña 2000) Colombia and Miami USA, where the men obtained 26
and 30 cm.; the women with 31 and 33 cm.
In abdominal strength, the results of (p) 50, of the SLP students were, in men 29 and women 24
repetitions, these data are lower than those presented by (Teleña 2000. AAHPERD 1976) the USA
and Miami USA; where the men got 49 and 31 and the women 45 and 27 repetitions. We also
found minor results (Cossio, Arruda-Miguel 2009) in men with 27 and women with 23 repetitions
concerning those of SLP students.
In Speed 30 meters, in (p) 50 this study, a time of 6.3/10 seconds was reached for men and 6.7/10
seconds for women; these data are greater than those presented by (Morales, Pila;2014. Pila
H.;2004) in Venezuela and Cuba, where they obtained in men 5,9/10 and 6.1/10, in women 6.2/10
and 6.5/10 seconds.
The Vertical Jump maximum of (p) 50 was 27 centimeters for men and 24 for women; these data are
lower than those mentioned by (Teleña, P.; 2000) in the USA and Belgium, with 35 and 29
centimeters in men and 32 and 28 centimeters in women. We also obtained minor data cited by
(Morales, Pila; 2014) in Venezuela and Uruguay, in men between 26 and 20 cm. and women
between 20 and 18.6 cm, compared with those obtained by SLP students.
The Long Jump feet together for this Test at your (p) 50, were obtained results in SLP students in
125 cm men and 115cm women, which are lower than those found by (AAHPERD, National
Fitness Standards USA, Fernades 2003, Blázquez 1996). These express data in men of 152, 149,
144, 143 cm; women with 147, 142, 120, 133 cm., compared with students of San Luis Potosí.
For cardiorespiratory resistance, as was the Course Navette in its (p) 50, a distance was obtained in men
of 460 meters (3 periods or paliers) and women with 380 meters (equivalent to 2.5 periods). These
data are lower than those expressed by (Blázquez 1996 EUROFIT battery), where they developed
a distance in men 900m and women 720 meters. Other data were also found in Peru, which are
lower than this investigation.
455
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
The results showed that the population studied has a lower level of physical performance compared
to developed countries and similar results with those found in Latin America, proving the
hypothesis raised in this study.
These results establish that the assessment of physical qualities must be part of the diagnoses of
physical education programs and that it has a close relationship with health (Gutiérrez, 2007).
Considering these results in planning the physical education sessions, the teacher will have more
people active for a healthier world (Pan American Health Organization A. 2018 - 2030).
Conclusion
• With these percentiles of the Physical Qualities obtained, they are a reference in the students
of San Luis Potosí from 9 to 11 years, considered as a diagnostic tool for the safe prescription
of exercise in the sessions of physical education and school sport.
• With this research, it is observed that there is a prevalence of low levels of Physical Qualities,
and urgently requires the constant practice of physical exercise in the school population of
San Luis Potosí.
• A tool that helps strengthen public programs and policies to reduce obesity problems and
other risk factors, with good physical and sports education practices for a healthy life.
Recommendations
Consider new lines of research: Quality of life—update body composition study.
Appreciation
To all participating Physical Education students and teachers from the state of San Luis Potosí. To
the Department of Physical Education of the SEGE of San Luis Potosí for all the support in
carrying out this research.
References
AAHPERD (1970). Test de Aptitud Física Recomendados por AAHPERD. Buenos Aires: Ministerio de
Cultura y Educación.
Aguilar A., Pradilla A., Mosquera, Gracia A., Ortega, Leiva JH., Ramírez R.-Vélez (2011).
Percentiles de condición física de niños y adolescentes de Santiago de Cali, Colombia. En
Biomédica
Instituto
Nacional
de
Salud.
Vol.
31
Núm.2
(2011).
DOI: https://doi.org/10.7705/biomedica.v31i2.420
ALPHA-FIT TEST BATTERY NORMS FOR CHILDREN AND ADOLESCENTS FROM 5
TO 18 YEARS (2019) European Journal of Physical Education and Sport Science - Volume 5 │
Issue 4 │DOI:10.5281/zenodo.2546360
456
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
American College of Sport Medicine. Manual ACSM para la valoración y prescripción del ejercicio. 2ª
edición. Barcelona: Paidotribo
Arancha, Rodríguez, García (2015) Capacidad aeróbica y calidad de vida en escolares de 8 a 12
años. Rev. Clínica e Investigación en Arteriosclerosis. Volumen 27, Issue 5, September–October
2015, Pages 239-245. Recuperado de:
https://dialnet.unirioja.es/servlet/articulo?codigo=5210030
Aras, Ş.; GÜnayt, T.; Ozan, S. & Orcine, E. Risky behaviors among high school students in İzmir.
Anadolu Psikiyatr Dergisi. Anatolian Journal of Psychiatrists, 8(2): 2007, p. 186-196.
Bolaños & Casio (2009). Propuesta de valores normativos para la evaluación de la aptitud física en
niños de 6 a 12 años de Arequipa, Perú. Rev Med Hered v.20 n.4 Lima . Recuperado de:
http://www.scielo.org.pe/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S1018-130X2009000400006
Bouchard C, Shepard R (1993). Physical activity, fitness and health: the model and key concepts. Champaign:
Human Kinetics.
Cale, L. (2000). Physical activity promotion in secondary schools. European Physical Education Review,
vol. 6, n. 1, pp. 71-90. Recuperado de:
https://www.academia.edu/17248420/Physical_education_and_health_promotion_a_qual
itative_study_of_teachers_perceptions
Bravo C. (2005) Evaluación del Rendimiento Físico, (3ª edición). Colombia: Editorial Kinesis
Campos, Delgado, Caamaño (2016) Alterations in the physical performance of students: the Test
Cafra and Navette and association with obesity and cardiometabolic risk. Nutrición
Hospitalaria. Nutr. Hosp. vol.33 no.4 Madrid jul./ago. 2016.
https://dx.doi.org/10.20960/nh.374
Canadian HealthMeasures Survey (2019). Sit and Reach. Recuperado de:
https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Sit-and-reach-percentile-values-by-age-group-andsex_tbl2_336614461
Castro, Ortega, RTERO (2018). Midiendo la Fuerza Muscular en Jóvenes: Uso del Salto Horizontal
como un Índice General de la Aptitud Muscular. PubliCE. Recuperado de: https://gse.com/midiendo-la-fuerza-muscular-en-jovenes-uso-del-salto-horizontal-como-un-indicegeneral-de-la-aptitud-muscular-2393-sa-e5addff1babd3d
Cakir G, Ozidlek C, Kalkavan A, Isik U, Akoguz N, Ibrahim H. (2021) Relationship between
healthy lifestyle behaviours and quality of life: An analysis of high licensed athletes. African
Journal of Research in Sport, Physical Education and Recreation. 43 (2). Pp 13-27.
Recuperado de: https://www.ajol.info/index.php/sajrs/article/view/205755
Cossio-Bolaños, Marco Antonio; Arruda, Miguel 820199. Propuesta de valores normativos para la
evaluación de la aptitud física en niños de 6 a 12 años de Arequipa, Perú. Revista Médica
Herediana, vol. 20, núm. 4, octubre-diciembre, 2009, pp. 206-212 Universidad Peruana
Cayetano
Heredia
San
Martín
de
Porres,
Perú.
Recuperado
de:
https://www.redalyc.org/articulo.oa?id=338038896006
Corbin, C., Noble, I (1980). Flexibility: A major component of physical fitness. Journal of Physical
Education and Recreation, 51, (6), 23-24, 57-60. Alter, M. (2004). Los Estiramientos. Desarrollo
del Ejercicio. España: Paidotribo.
457
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Fernandes J. (2003). La Práctica de la Evaluación Física. Rio de Janeiro: Editorial Shape
Garrido, N. (2021). Correlación y comparación entre el nivel de actividad física y flexibilidad en
niños y niñas de 10 a 11 años de edad de un colegio de Concepción. Chile.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.29035/rcaf.22.1.2
Guedes DPD. Implicações associadas ao acompanhamento do desempenho motor de crianças e
adolescentes. Rev Bras Educ Fis Esp (Sao Paulo) 2007; 21: 37-60. Recuperado de:
https://www.revistas.usp.br/rbefe/article/view/16664
Guío, F. (2017). Modelos para la Medición de la Condición Física en estudiantes de Educación
Física Media desde la Perspectiva pedagógica de los Test. Revista Ímpetus. Universidad de los
Llanos Col. vol. 11 N° 2 | año 2017 ISSN: 2011-4680. Recuperado de:
https://revistas.unillanos.edu.co/index.php/impetus/article/view/436
Ley General de Salud en materia de Investigación para la Salud (Cámara de Diputados DOF 0202-2014). Recuperado de:
https://www.diputados.gob.mx/LeyesBiblio/regley/Reg_LGS_MIS.pdf
Léger, L., Mercier, Gadoury (1988). The multistage 20 metre shuttle run test for aerobic fitness.
Journal
of
Sports
Sciences
Vol.
6,
1988
- Issue
2. Recuperado
de
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/02640418808729800
López Pastor, V., Monjas Aguado, R., Gómez García, J., López Pastor, E., Martín Pinela, J.,
González Badiola, J., Barba Martín, J., Aguilar Baeza, R., González Pascual, M., Heras
Bernardino, C., Martín, M., Manrique Arribas, J., Subtil Marugán, P., Marugán García, L.
(2006). La evaluación en educación física. Revisión de modelos tradicionales y planteamiento
de una alternativa. La evaluación formativa y compartida. Revista Retos. Nuevas Tendencias
en Educación Física, Deporte y Recreación, (10), 31-41. Recuperado de:
https://recyt.fecyt.es/index.php/retos/article/view/66478
Manzano,J. (1991) La Preparación Física en Tenis. Sevilla: Wanceulan
Manzano J. (2004). Clarificación de Conceptos Realacionados con el Entrenamiento Deportivo.
Recuperado de:
file:///C:/Users/ASUS/Downloads/DialnetClarificacionDeConceptosRelacionadosConElEntrenami-1065698.pdf
Matthew J., Taylor, Daniel, Cohen, Christine Voss, & Gavin R. (2010). Vertical
jumping and leg power normative data for English schoolchildren aged 10–15
years.Journal of Sports Sciences,;28(8):
867–872.
Recuperado
de:
https://www.academia.edu/11439386/Vertical_jumping_and_leg_power_norm
ative_data_for_English_school_children_aged_10_15_year
Martínez E., López. (2008). Pruebas de Aptitud Física. Barcelona; Paidotribo
Sebastiani E. y González, C. (2000). Cualidades Físicas. Barcelona: INDE,
Morales, L., Pila, H. (2014). Normas para Evaluar talentos en condición física. Una experiencia en
escolares entre 7 y 17 años en el estado de Portuguesa, Venezuela. Segunda parte.
EFDeportes.com, Revista Digital. Buenos aire, Año 19, N° 195. Tomado de:
http//:www.efdeportes.com
458
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Organización Mundial de la Salud. (1968) Relaciones entre los programas de salud y el desarrollo
social y económico Ginebra: OMS. Recuperado de:
https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/95264/Official_record172_spa.pdf?se
quence=1&isAllowed=y
Organización Mundial de la Salud. Declaratoria sobre la salud ocupacional para todos. Ginebra
(1994). Recuperado de:
http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/58824/WHO_OCH_94.1_spa.pdf?seq
uence=1
Organización Mundial de la Saludos (2018). Plan de Acción Mundial sobre actividad física 20182030. Recuperado de: https://iris.paho.org/handle/10665.2/50904
Pila,H. (2004). Selección de talentos para el deporte, 27 años de experiencia en Cuba, metodología
para evaluar pruebas. EFDeportes.com, Revista Digital. Buenos aire, Año 10, N° 69, agosto de
2004. Tomado de: http//:www.efdeportes.com
Salleg M.(2010) Perfil de aptitud física de los escolares de 12 a 18 años del municipio de Montería,
Colombia. EF Deportes.com. Revista Digital. Buenos Aires, Año 15, N° 149. Recuperado de :
https://efdeportes.com/efd149/aptitud-fisica-de-los-escolares.htm.
Rabadán, I., Rodríguez (2010). Las capacidades físicas básicas dentro de la educación secundaria:
una aproximación conceptual a través de la revisión del temario para oposiciones. EFDeporte.
Revista
digital.
Buenos
Aires,
año
15
N°
147.
Recuperada
de:
https://efdeportes.com/efd147/las-capacidades-fisicas-basicas-dentro-de-secundaria.htm
Ros, García (2015). Valoración de la salud relacionada con la condición física en escolares de
educación primaria. Estudio piloto. EFDeportes. Com. Revista Digital. Buenos Aires, Año 19,
N°202. www.efdeportes.com
Platanov (1993). Planificación del entrenamiento deportivo. Barcelona. Paidotribo.
Reis, F. (2016). Estudios sobre la condición física saludable: una revisión bibliográfica hasta el año
2005. Revista
Fuentes,
(8),
299–321.
Recuperado
de
https://revistascientificas.us.es/index.php/fuentes/article/view/253
Secretaria de Salud México (2018). Sobrepeso y obesidad, factores de riesgos para desarrollar diabetes Reporte
oficial. Recuperado de: https://www.gob.mx/salud/es/articulos/sobrepeso-y-obesidadfactores-de-riesgos-para-desarrollardiabetes?idiom=es#:~:text=En%20M%C3%A9xico%20siete%20de%20cada,al%20sobrep
eso%20y%20la%20obesidad.
Teleña A.(2000). Evaluación Deportiva, los Test de laboratorio de campo. Madrid: Edi. Pila Teleña
Torres, J; Rivera y otros (1996): Fundamentos de la Educación Física. Consideraciones Didácticas. Granada
Esp.: Ed. Rosillo.
Tovar y La Rota (2019) Tesis: Comparación de los efectos de dos programas de entrenamiento
sobre la Fuerza Activa y Reactiva en un grupo de baloncesto y otro físicamente activo.
Universidad de Ciencias Aplicadas y Ambientales. Bogotá Colombia. Recuperado de:
https://repository.udca.edu.co/bitstream/handle/11158/2084/TRABAJO%20DE%20IN
VESTIGACION%20PDF.pdf?s equence=1&isAllowed=y
459
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Ugarkovic,D., Jiménez., Matavulj, D., Kukolj, M. & Jaric, S. (2002) Standard Anthropometric, Body
Composition, and Strength Variables as Predictors of Jumping Performance in Elite Junior
Athletes. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, pp. 4. Recuperado de
file:///C:/Users/ASUS/Downloads/DialnetAnalisisDeVariablesMedidasEnSaltoVerticalRelaciona-3830363.pdf
Vidarte J., Vélez C., Arango A., Parra J. (2022). Valores Percentiles de la Condición Física saludable
en escolares. Retos. Nuevas tendencias en Educación Física, Deporte y Recreación. 43, 162–170.
WHO (World Health Organization) (2015). Health topics-adolescent health. Hyperlink:
Recuperado de: https://www.who.int/health-topics/adolescent-health#tab=tab_1
460
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Effect of Exercises on Elderly to Prevent Fall: A Narrative Review
Wan Zhen Lee1,4 - Kueh Yee Cheng2 - Muhammad Hafiz Hanafi3 –
Garry Kuan4
1
School of Rehabilitation Science, Faculty of Health Sciences, Universiti Sultan Zainal Abidin (UniSZA),
Kampus Gong Badak, Terengganu, Malaysia
2
Unit of Biostatistics and Research Methodology, School of Medical Sciences,Universiti Sains Malaysia,
Kelantan, Malaysia
3
Department of Neuroscience, School of Medical Sciences,Universiti Sains Malaysia, Kelantan, Malaysia
4
Exercise and Sports Science Programme, School of Health Sciences, Universiti Sains Malaysia, Kubang
Kerian, Kelantan, Malaysia
e-mail: garry@usm.my
Abstract
Falls are the leading cause of illness and disability among the elderly. When the age of individual
increases, changes in physiology occur, including stress, mitochondrial dysfunction, distortion of
the provocative process, less hormone production, and a reduction in total energy utilised over a
period, all of which can lead to organ degeneration. These actions destroy neuron cells over time,
impair bone density, and lessen muscle mass and strength. Regular exercise is essential for healthy
ageing and offers many health benefits, including a reduced risk of illness and disability. A wellbalanced fitness programme for the elderly can help them avoid falls and improve their day-today performance, so improving their quality of life. It is proposed that an exercise programme
consists of a variety of forms to improve balance, postural control, cognition, muscle strength,
and overall quality of life. The therapists, who are experts in prescription exercise and physical
activity, promote exercise among the elderly in order to prevent falls. Promoting physical activity
and exercise is critical in the daily lives of the elderly. Thus, this study aims to conduct a narrative
review on the effect of exercise on fall prevention among the elderly.
Key word: Exercises, Prevent fall, Elderly, Physical activity
461
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
Falls are the leading cause of illness and disability among the elderly. Every year, over one-third
of people aged 65 and above fall, with a range of moderate to severe outcomes. Half of these
individuals suffer more than one fall and are more likely to fall again (Moylan et al., 2007). When
the age of an individual increase, changes in physiology occur, including stress, mitochondrial
dysfunction, distortion of the provocative process, fewer hormone production, and a reduction
in total energy utilized over a period, all of which can lead to organ degeneration. These actions
destroy neuron cells over time, impair bone density, and lessen muscle mass and strength (Sieber,
2017).
As a result, it reduces one's capacity to do everyday tasks, increasing the danger of falling and
lowering one's standard of life. According to Rubenstein (2006), falls are the leading cause of
senior health concerns, and the rate of falls rises with the increase in age. Falls occur because of
a variety of interconnected situations. Adverse drug effects and impaired balance are the two very
important primary indicators of a fall event in older persons (Gillespie et al., 2021). According to
Kojima (2015), older persons have difficulties maintaining their postural integrity while doing
daily tasks, which increases the likelihood of falling.
Additionally, older adults with mild cognitive impairment who live in the community fall twice as
frequently as their cognitively intact peers (Taylor et al., 2012; Manaf, 2020). In communitydwelling older people, mild cognitive impairment is a predictive risk factor for falls (Delbaere et
al., 2012; Doi et al., 2015). It is characterised as a stage of cognitive impairment that occurs
between normal ageing and dementia (Winblad et al., 2004). In older people with mild cognitive
impairment, decreased muscle strength, worse balance control, and reduced walking speed, along
with growing age and cognitive deterioration, increase the risk of falling (Deandrea et al., 2010;
Laughton et al., 2003). A strategy that combines physical exercise and cognitive training into a
single treatment plan may be the most effective way to address these risk factors all at once (Thom
& Clare, 2011; Eggenberger et al., 2015).
Postural control entailed synchronising multiple of a person's systems. The sensory system, which
includes the vestibular, visual, and somatosensory systems, is combined with the central nervous
system and the musculoskeletal system to infer the situation. The sensory system will reduce your
ability to sense illumination contrast, judge distance, and see spatial relations as you become older.
These appeared to be the typical deficits associated with falls in older people (Lord, 2006).
According to Ishiyama (2009), the changes in the vestibular system are part of ageing.
A decrease in the number of hair cells in the semi-circular canals demonstrates these changes.
Additionally, Lord and his colleagues (1996) discovered in 1996 that the risk of falling in older
adults is exacerbated by a diminished perception of movement and posture, as well as a loss of
lower limb strength and sensation (Lord et al., 1996). Rubenstein (2006) stated that inter-joint
synchronisation is impacted, affecting muscle action during daily tasks such as walking. As a result,
462
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
the elderly person's ability to avoid falling is compromised. Thus, the purpose of this study was
to summarise the benefits of improving muscular strength, stability, and risk of falling. The
investigation will aid in the development of exercise training programmes for older adults with
the goal of reducing falls and improving quality of life.
Role of exercise in preventing elders from fall
Overall muscular strength is known to wane as people become older. Falls become more likely
when lower limb strength deteriorates. Muscle strength (Nichols et al., 1993) and response time
(Lord & Castell, 1994) may both be improved by exercising on a regular basis. According to
Chodzko-Zajko and colleagues (2009), cardiovascular fitness exercise as well as resistance exercise
are generally supplied among older individuals and based on aerobic exercise training and strength
exercise adapted as separate measures, older adults can be utilised. Balance improvements, on the
other hand, may occur following long-term training strategies.
Marques and his colleagues (2017) investigated the relationship between knee muscular strength
and balancing changes in stable older persons after 8 months of increasing aerobic and resistance
training. The one-leg stance test and up and go test (UGT) and centre of pressure measurements
were used to assess leg strength and balance. Both treatments resulted in improved equilibrium
performance, according to the findings. Leg strength was found to have improved after resistance
exercise and aerobic activity. They discovered that both resistance and aerobic training increase
balance; however, resistance exercise was also beneficial in increasing leg strength. Additionally,
an increase in leg strength following resistance exercise has a significant impact on improvements
in static and dynamic balance (Marques et al., 2017; Rao et al., 2021). The greatest risk for falls in
older persons is decreased balance with age and loss of equilibrium (Beauchet et al., 2009). There
seems to be evidence to back up the effectiveness of exercise in helping healthy older persons
maintain their posture while completing daily activities. A well-known balancing training
programme for older individuals is designed to reduce the risk of falling and improve balance
function in everyday life.
Both static and dynamic balance, postural control is achieved by posturing the centre of mass
(Nagy et al., 2007). The balance exercise includes static or dynamic stability postures, which are
performed by older persons. These exercises benefited by reducing support base and visual
information, producing a shift in the person's centre of gravity. Using wobble boards, foam
surfaces, or perturbation platforms to change the standing surface. The body will try to recreate
the interruptions that cause people to fall out of their everyday routines (Rogge et al., 2018). Nagy
and his colleagues (2007) conducted an 8-week programme that included static and dynamic
balance exercises, as well as strength, flexibility, and aerobic exercises. The results showed that
older adults improved their postural control regulation with and without visual input, and that
the more challenging direction (i.e., mediolateral) increased their postural control regulation.
463
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________
In older persons, coordinated exercise with limited and low-speed training improves mental
functioning (Wong et al., 2001). It includes the stimulation of the cerebellum, which is responsible
for motor control and learning, and has been linked to alterations in higher cognitive functioning
(Manto et al., 2012). Wong and his colleagues (2001) also mentioned that Tai Chi exercises are
linked together with a continuous sequence of motion (cooperation) and the body is constantly
moving side to side, with the knees and hips in flexion (lower centre of gravity and balance).
Various components of the body spend most of their time acting as stabilisers and mover,
necessitating smooth motions that do not compromise balance and stability (Raj et al., 2020). The
effect of exercises effect of exercises on elderly to prevent fall is shown in Table 1.
Discussion
The discussion will focus on the effect of exercise to prevent fall among the elderly. Table 1
demonstrated numerous beneficial effects using exercises on the physical and functional activity
among the elderly. Exercise has a positive impact on balance and muscle strength; developments
in skills would enable elderly to be more independent in their daily activity. Falls in the elderly are
an indicator of frailty, immobility, and acute and chronic health deterioration. Falls, in effect,
reduce function by causing injury, activity limits, fear of falling, and mobility loss. The majority
of injuries in the elderly are caused by falls; fractures of the hip, forearm, humerus, and pelvis are
commonly caused by the combined effect of falls and osteoporosis. It is essential to understand
the benefits of exercise for promoting the fall prevention among elderly. It may affect various
aspects of their lives such as daily living activities and the ability to participate in exercise to
become more active and fit.
Twelve week of multicomponent exercise program on balance, strength, endurance, and flexibility
improve the dynamic balance among the elderly. In additional, fourteen week of conventional
resistance training (CRT) group and elastic resistance training (ERT) such as 3 multi-joint
exercises, upper limbs and lower exercise result approach of ERT may be used as an alternative
strategy to CRT to promote functional improvements in older people. Furthermore, 4-week
training of exercise such as 60-second sit-to-stand (STS), seated knee extensions of alternating
legs, standing knee bends of alternating legs, marching on the spot, and standing calf raises. At
the same time hold onto a chair for stability during standing exercise shown that improving leg
power, muscle size and sit-to-stand score compare with control group. Its indications that
maximum leg press force and power may also improve in function activity.
On the other hand, respiratory exercises, active and strengthening for the joints of upper and
lower extremities and spine, isometric exercises for strengthening the abdominal muscles and
weight-bearing exercises improve the balance and muscle strength among elderly. Exercises
should be practiced regularly because with advancing age the muscle tissue is decreased as well as
the strength of the muscles and physical abilities. Therefore, exercises maintain physical
condition, mobility and social life and hence contribute to a better quality of life.
464
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Table 1
Author
(year)
Lipardo
&
Tsang,
(2020)
•
•
•
Souza et
al.
(2019)
Participant
s
(N),
gender,
age
N = 92,
communit
y-dwelling
older
persons
with mild
cognitive
impairmen
t (aged 60–
83)
Intervention
Outcome
measuremen
t
The physical training group
and the combined physical
and cognitive training
group had the same
multicomponent exercise
program
on
balance,
strength, endurance, and
flexibility, with no less than
one-third focused on
balance training.
fall
incidence,
overall fall
risk, dynamic
balance,
walking
speed, and
lower limb
strength.
Divided in
4 groups
group
physical
training
group
combined
physical
and
cognitive
training
group
cognitive
training
group
waitlist
control
group
The cognitive training
group was involved in a set
of paper-based cognitive
exercises on executive
function,
memory,
attention, and orientation
training with an emphasis
on executive function.
N = 25,
older
women •
communit•
y dwelling
All participants performed
a full-body protocol
with 3 multi-joint exercises
being two exercisesfor
upper limbs (chest press
and row)
one for lower limbs(squat)
following a minimal dose
approach
Each exercise was
performed with two sets,
with 10 to 14 repetitions.
Sixty seconds of rest
intervals
were
used
between sets and exercises.
ES group will receive
exercises were 60-second
sit-to-stand (STS), seated
Divided in•
2 groups;
Conventio
nal
resistance
training
(CRT)
group and
Elastic
resistance
training
(ERT)
group
Perkin et
al.
(2019)
N = 20
older men
and
Length of
study and
Frequency
per week
(Duration)
12 weeks 3
times per
week (60
to
90minutes
)
Result
Functional
test, Chair to
stand
Arm curl ,8foot up-andgo, 6-minute
walk test,
Sit-andreach,
Back stretch
and
Blood
pressure
14 weeks,
twice per
week
(15 to 18
min)
The result shown that CRT group from
pre- to post-training in the 6-min walk were
significant increases. While the Arm Curl
test and 8-feet up-and-go the showed the
greatest magnitude of treatment effect in
both groups. The minimal dose approach
of ERT may be used as an alternative
strategy to CRT to promote functional
improvements in older women.
60 second
sit-to-stand
score, rating
4 weeks,
twice per
day
The result shown ES group improving leg
power, muscle size and sit-to-stand score
compare with control group. Its indications
Dynamic balance was improved with
combined physical and cognitive training
compare with another group.
Waitlist control group was
instructed to go on with
their usual daily routine,
habits, and physical activity
level, and would receive the
intervention,
combined
physical and cognitive
training, on a later date
after the completion of all
the other intervention
groups.
465
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________
women
communit
y-dwelling,
(65–80
years)
Divided 2
group:
exercise
snacking
interventio
n (ES), n =
10
Vitale et
al.
(2020)
Control
Group, n
= 10
N = 9
elderly
people,
(60–80
years)
Divided 2
group:
Interventi
on Group,
n=5
Control
Group, n
=4
Aartola
hti et al.
(2020)
N = 182
elderly age
80
(SD ± 3.9)
years]
Divided 2
group:
Male
Group, n
= 52
Female
Group, n
= 130
knee
extensions
of
alternating legs, standing
knee bends of alternating
legs, marching on the spot,
and standing calf raises. At
the same time hold onto a
chair for stability during
standing exercise.
Intervention group receive
warm-up included light
dynamic movements and
exercises for all the body
areas and joints (e.g.,
walking and skipping on
site),
including
upper/lower limbs (e.g.,
shoulder and elbow circles
or half squat) back (e.g.,
twists and side bending),
and neck (e.g., 3-axis
movements).
Each training session
started with a 15-min
balancing exercise as a
warm-up , static and
dynamic,
standing,
walking,
turning
and
reaching exercises where
challenge was adjusted by
changing the size or
stability of the base of
support with dual task and
eyes-closed situations.
progressive
resistance
training
for
60 min
included knee extension
and flexion, leg press, hip
adduction, abduction and
extension and abdominal
crunches.
perform 8–12 repetitions
and two to three sets of the
exercises
of perceived
exertion
velocity,
force,
and
power
variables of
leg pressing
anthropomet
ric
measuremen
t (calf and
thigh muscle
and
percentage
body
fat),
and
Diet
recorded.
Anthropome
tric
assessment,
Whole-body
dual energy
X-ray
absorptiome
try,
thigh
magnetic
resonance,
mini-Balance
Evaluation
Systems
Test, chair
stand test; b.
Handgrip
strength test
and
dynamomete
rs
Knee
extension
strength,
Knee flexion
strength,
Chair rises,
Walking
speed,
Timed
up
and go and
Berg Balance
Scale
466
that maximum leg press force and power
may also improve in function activity.
24 weeks,
4 time per
week (55
minutes)
The result shown that the intervention
group improved lower limb strength. They
concluded that during the lockdown
period, and these benefits in muscle
strength were likely associated with the
home-based resistance training program.
2
years,
once per
week (75
minutes)
The result shown that both women and
men improved their chair rise capacity.
Women’s knee extension and flexion
strength improved by walking speed while
men, no changes in muscle strength or
walking speed occurred during training or
follow-up. No changes in BBS and TUG
were observed at the end of the
intervention but decrease in BBS was
observed at post-intervention follow-up in
men.
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Marini et
al.
(2019)
N = 44,
osteoporo
sis elderly
women
(Age: from
60 to 75)
Divided 2
group:
experimen
tal group,
n = 22
Control
Group, n
= 18
Koevsk
a et al.
(2019)
•
•
•
Carral et
al.
(2019)
N = 92
postmeno
pausal
osteoporo
sis (Age:
from 60 to
75)
Divided 3
group:
patients
with
exercises
and
physical
modalities
group
Exercise
Group
Control
Group
N=
24
elderly
women
(Age: from
60 to 75)
Divided 2
group:
interventio
n group, n
= 11
Control
Group, n
= 13
Experimental
group
receive Warm-up: 15 min;
multi-articular exercises,
focus
on
joint
mobilization, balance and
postural control during
walking.
-Workout:
35
min;
resistance
bodyweight
exercises (isometric and
dynamic).
-Cool down: 10 min;
Stretching, Exercise in an
upright and supine static
position, holding a stretch
position for up to 30 s
under IG Supervised.
HealthRelated
Quality of
Life
ECOS-16
EuroQoL
(EQ-5D-3L)
Fear
of
Falling: FESI
questionnair
e, Lumbar
Back Pain:
VAS,
Physical
performance
: POMA, 6MWT and
Chair
Sitand-Reach.
24 weeks,
2 times per
week (60
minutes)
The result shown that experimental group
greater significant in Health-Related
Quality
of
Life
questionnaire, fear of falling questionnaire,
VAS, POMA, 6-MWT and Chair Sit-andReach compare with control group. They
conclude that feasibility, safety and the
positive effect of the proposed exercise
protocol on quality of life, fear of falling,
balance and functional exercise capacity
show that programs should be extended
also to patients with osteoporosis and a
history of vertebral fracture.
Patient’s with exercises and
physical modalities group
received
physical
modalities
(interferent
currents and magnetic
therapy) for 3 weeks
Quality of
life
was
determined
with
a
specific
questionnair
e Qualeffo41.
3 times per
week;
The results showed that significant
statistical difference in terms of pain,
physical activity, social life, the perception
of own health was shown between the
groups (p < 0.0001), only in term of mental
function were no significant (p < 0.3). They
conclude that Exercises should be practiced
regularly because with advancing age the
muscle tissue is decreased as well as the
strength of the muscles and physical
abilities. Therefore, exercises maintain
physical condition, mobility and social life
and hence contribute to a better quality of
life.
Barthel index
of daily living
activities, the
five times sitto-stand test
(FTSTS) and
timed up and
go
(TUG)
test
12 weeks,
twice per
week
The SG maintained the Barthel index
scores for activities of daily living and
improved in the FTSTS; the CG showed a
significant decrease on both tests. The
dynamic balance test showed significant
differences between groups for the
variables sit to stand, peak angular velocity,
anterior-posterior range, turning, stand to
sit, total time, and speed. They conclude
that the muscle strength intervention
programs may help promote healthy
lifestyles by maintaining autonomy,
improving function, and balance.
Exercise Group received
the respiratory exercises,
active and strengthening
for the joints of upper and
lower extremities and
spine, isometric exercises
for strengthening the
abdominal muscles and
exercises for balance. For
weight-bearing exercises,
the weight was determined
by the functional abilities
of the patients, 1 (one)
kilogram at the most.
Exercises were performed.
Each exercise was repeated
for 5 to 8 times.
Intervention
group
received
lower
limb
strengthening
exercise
such
as
Knee
flexion/extension,
Hip
flexion and abduction,
ankle Plantar flexion,
inversion and eversion.
Each of the exercise was 15
repetition for 3 set.
467
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________
Conclusion
Finally, falls are very prevalent among the elderly. The decreasing of total muscular strength is
connected to ageing. Falls become more likely when lower limb strength deteriorates. According
to the findings, a well-balanced fitness programme for the elderly can help them avoid falls and
improve their day-to-day performance, so improving their quality of life. To improve balance,
postural control, cognition, muscle strength, and quality of life, it is proposed that an exercise
programme consist of a combination of forms. To prevent the occurrence of falls, therapists or
instructors should establish an exercise programme for older adults in community or home-based
activities which includes mild-to-high difficult balance tasks that are completed at the right time
and frequency. The exercise programme protects their safety, and exercises like static and dynamic
exercise, as well as resistance exercise, help to lower the danger of falling. Fall prevention in the
elderly can be achieved by progressing to activities that require overall physical and cognitive
capabilities.
References
Aartolahti, E., Lönnroos, E., Hartikainen, S., & Häkkinen, A. (2020). Long-term strength and
balance training in prevention of decline in muscle strength and mobility in older adults.
Aging Clinical and Experimental Research, 32(1), 59-66.
Beauchet, O., Annweiler, C., Dubost, V., Allali, G., Kressig, R. W., Bridenbaugh, S., ... &
Herrmann, F. R. (2009). Stops walking when talking: a predictor of falls in older
adults? European Journal of Neurology, 16(7), 786-795.
Carral, J. M. C., Rodríguez, A. L., Cardalda, I. M., & Bezerra, J. P. A. G. (2019). Muscle strength
training program in nonagenarians–a randomized controlled trial. Revista da Associação
Médica Brasileira, 65, 851-856.
Chodzko-Zajko, W. J., Proctor, D. N., Singh, M. A. F., Minson, C. T., Nigg, C. R., Salem, G. J.,
& Skinner, J. S. (2009). Exercise and physical activity for older adults. Medicine & Science in
Sports & Exercise, 41(7), 1510-1530.
Deandrea, S., Lucenteforte, E., Bravi, F., Foschi, R., La Vecchia, C., & Negri, E. (2010). Risk
factors for falls in community-dwelling older people: a systematic review and metaanalysis. Epidemiology, 658-668.
Delbaere, K., Kochan, N. A., Close, J. C., Menant, J. C., Sturnieks, D. L., Brodaty, H., ... & Lord,
S. R. (2012). Mild cognitive impairment as a predictor of falls in community-dwelling older
people. The American Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry, 20(10), 845-853.
Doi, T., Shimada, H., Park, H., Makizako, H., Tsutsumimoto, K., Uemura, K., ... & Suzuki, T.
(2015). Cognitive function and falling among older adults with mild cognitive impairment
and slow gait. Geriatrics & Gerontology International, 15(8), 1073-1078.
De Bruin, E. D., Eggenberger, P., Theill, N., Holenstein, S., & Schumacher, V. (2015).
Multicomponent physical exercise with simultaneous cognitive training to enhance dualtask walking of older adults: A secondary analysis of a 6-month randomized controlled trial
with I-year follow-up. Clinical Interventions in Aging, 10, 1711-1732.
468
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Gillespie, L. D., Robertson, M. C., Gillespie, W. J., Sherrington, C., Gates, S., Clemson, L., &
Lamb, S. E. (2012). Interventions for preventing falls in older people living in the
community. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, (9).
Ishiyama, G. (2009, November). Imbalance and vertigo: the aging human vestibular periphery.
In Seminars in neurology, Vol. 29, No. 05, pp. 491-499. Thieme Medical Publishers.
Koevska, V., Nikolikj-Dimitrova, E., Mitrevska, B., Gjeracaroska-Savevska, C., Gocevska, M., &
Kalcovska, B. (2019). Effect of exercises on quality of life in patients with postmenopausal
osteoporosis–randomized trial. Open Access Macedonian Journal of Medical Sciences, 7(7), 1160.
Kojima, G. (2015). Frailty as a predictor of future falls among community-dwelling older people:
a systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of the American Medical Directors
Association, 16(12), 1027-1033.
Laughton, C. A., Slavin, M., Katdare, K., Nolan, L., Bean, J. F., Kerrigan, D. C., ... & Collins, J. J.
(2003). Aging, muscle activity, and balance control: physiologic changes associated with
balance impairment. Gait & Posture, 18(2), 101-108.
Lipardo, D. S., & Tsang, W. W. (2020). Effects of combined physical and cognitive training on
fall prevention and risk reduction in older persons with mild cognitive impairment: a
randomized controlled study. Clinical Rehabilitation, 34(6), 773-782.
Lord, S., & Castell, S. (1994). Effect of exercise on balance, strength and reaction time in older
people. Australian Journal of Physiotherapy, 40(2), 83-88.
Lord, S. R., Lloyd, D. G., & Keung Li, S. E. K. (1996). Sensori-motor function, gait patterns and
falls in community-dwelling women. Age and Ageing, 25(4), 292-299.
Lord, S. R. (2006). Visual risk factors for falls in older people. Age and Ageing, 35(suppl. 2), 42-45.
Manaf, M. R. B. A. (2020). Weight reducing interventions for overweight and obese
employees. European Journal of Molecular & Clinical Medicine, 7(11), 835-844.
Manto, M., Bower, J. M., Conforto, A. B., Delgado-García, J. M., Da Guarda, S. N. F., Gerwig,
M., ... & Timmann, D. (2012). Consensus paper: roles of the cerebellum in motor control—
the diversity of ideas on cerebellar involvement in movement. The Cerebellum, 11(2), 457487.
Marini, S., Leoni, E., Raggi, A., Sanna, T., Malavolta, N., Angela, B., ... & Dallolio, L. (2019).
Proposal of an adapted physical activity exercise protocol for women with osteoporosisrelated vertebral fractures: a pilot study to evaluate feasibility, safety, and
effectiveness. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 16(14), 2562.
Marques, E. A., Figueiredo, P., Harris, T. B., Wanderley, F. A., & Carvalho, J. (2017). Are
resistance and aerobic exercise training equally effective at improving knee muscle strength
and balance in older women? Archives of Gerontology and Geriatrics, 68, 106-112.
Moylan, K. C., & Binder, E. F. (2007). Falls in older adults: risk assessment, management and
prevention. The American Journal of Medicine, 120(6), 493-510.
Nagy, E., Feher-Kiss, A., Barnai, M., Domján-Preszner, A., Angyan, L., & Horvath, G. (2007).
Postural control in elderly subjects participating in balance training. European Journal of
Applied Physiology, 100(1), 97-104.
Nichols, J. F., Omizo, D. K., Peterson, K. K., & Nelson, K. P. (1993). Efficacy of heavy‐resistance
training for active women over sixty: muscular strength, body composition, and program
adherence. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 41(3), 205-210.
Perkin, O. J., McGuigan, P. M., Stokes, K. A. (2019). Exercise snacking to improve muscle
function in healthy older adults: A Pilot Study. Journal of Aging Research, 2019, 1–9.
469
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________
Raj, N. B., Lee, W. Z., Eswaramoorthi, V., Razali, H., Othman, N. Y. H., & Rao, U. S. (2020).
Exercise programmes for reducing the risk of falls in elderly: a review. Research Journal of
Pharmacy and Technology, 13(6), 2977-2984.
Rao, U. M., Siddharthan, S., Sowmya, R., Raj, N. B., Syazana, O., Ain, R. N., ... & Luqman, Z. M.
(2021). Study on excessive daytime sleepiness among undergraduate medical students:
Cross sectional survey to study the risk factors. Research Journal of Pharmacy and
Technology, 14(3), 1828-1833.
Rogge, A. K., Röder, B., Zech, A., & Hötting, K. (2018). Exercise-induced neuroplasticity:
Balance training increases cortical thickness in visual and vestibular cortical
regions. Neuroimage, 179, 471-479.
Rubenstein, L. Z. (2006). Falls in older people: epidemiology, risk factors and strategies for
prevention. Age and ageing, 35(suppl 2), 37-41.
Sieber, C. C. (2017). Frailty–from concept to clinical practice. Experimental Gerontology, 87, 160167.
Souza, D., Barbalho, M., Vieira, C. A., Martins, W. R., Cadore, E. L., & Gentil, P. (2019). Minimal
dose resistance training with elastic tubes promotes functional and cardiovascular benefits
to older women. Experimental Gerontology, 115, 132–138.
Taylor, M. E., Lord, S. R., Delbaere, K., Mikolaizak, A. S., & Close, J. C. (2012). Physiological fall
risk factors in cognitively impaired older people: a one-year prospective study. Dementia and
Geriatric Cognitive Disorders, 34(3-4), 181-189.
Thom, J. M., & Clare, L. (2011). Rationale for combined exercise and cognition-focused
interventions
to
improve
functional
independence
in
people
with
dementia. Gerontology, 57(3), 265-275.
Vitale, J. A., Bonato, M., Borghi, S., Messina, C., Albano, D., Corbetta, S., ... & Banfi, G. (2020).
Home-based resistance training for older subjects during the COVID-19 outbreak in Italy:
preliminary results of a six-months RCT. International Journal of Environmental Research and
Public Health, 17(24), 9533.
Winblad, B., Palmer, K., Kivipelto, M., Jelic, V., Fratiglioni, L., Wahlund, L. O., ... & Petersen, R.
C. (2004). Mild cognitive impairment–beyond controversies, towards a consensus: report
of the International Working Group on Mild Cognitive Impairment. Journal of Internal
Medicine, 256(3), 240-246.
Wong, A. M., Lin, Y. C., Chou, S. W., Tang, F. T., & Wong, P. Y. (2001). Coordination exercise
and postural stability in elderly people: effect of Tai Chi Chuan. Archives of Physical Medicine
and Rehabilitation, 82(5), 608-612.
470
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Criticality in New Zealand Physical Education: Disrupting the
Orthodoxy, Creating a New Imagery
Susannah Stevens - Ian Culpan
University of Canterbury, New Zealand
e-mail: Ian.culpan@canterbury.ac.nz
Abstract
Aotearoa New Zealand has a short, but rich history of diverse developments in physical education.
Government initiatives, perceived learner needs, agendas of community agencies, the shifting of
societal standards, political economies of health and sport, and individual teacher value beliefs
have all played part in shaping curriculum orientations. One curriculum orientation, however,
seems to have altered the course of health and physical education in the New Zealand curriculum.
It continues to have a significant effect on the physical education landscape through its ability to
entice thought and disruption to the ‘norms’ of health, physical activity, play and sport. This sociocritical curriculum value orientation is now more important than ever, as New Zealand enters
another round of curriculum discussions and ‘refreshes’. It has the possibility of creating a new
imagery for health and physical education. Health and Physical Education in the New Zealand Curriculum
has serious scope for evolution; but only if those in charge acknowledge and value the depths of
its past.
Key words: Socio-critical curriculum, Critical pedagogy, Health and Physical Education in New
Zealand Curriculum, New Imagery, Value orientations
471
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
This chapter sets out to briefly outline the historical foundations from which physical education
(PE) in Aotearoa, New Zealand (NZ) developed. From the time of indigenous settlement to the
colonisation of the British in the 1800s, NZ PE has been built predominantly on three dominant
curriculum value orientations. Arguably unique to NZ, the socio-critical curriculum value
orientation has been the most recent focus in NZ PE. Bought about by comprehensive economic
and social reforms in the 1990s, the health and PE curriculum has required a seismic shift in
thinking and practice. Fundamental to the change has been the introduction of a strong criticality,
which has challenged and disrupted orthodox practices. Seeking a new imagery, this chapter
highlights present developments and lays down the challenge to liberate present knowledge and
truths in the quest to address social justice and equity issues that are ubiquitous in orthodox
programmes.
Backgrounding Physical Education in Aotearoa New Zealand
Aotearoa NZ’s history is comparatively short but is enormously rich with diverse developments.
Originally settled by the Polynesians (indigenous people of the South Pacific) approximately 750
years ago, New Zealand Aotearoa (NZ), arguably, is the most recent country in the world to be
populated. This Indigenous population developed a distinctive and unique Māori culture that was
based on ancestral affiliations and very strong spiritual connections to the land (whenua). In the
early 1800s, Indigenous Māori participated in a rich array of physical cultural practices and games.
Many of which have now been problematically formalized in Health and Physical Education in the New
Zealand Curriculum (NZHPE) (MOE, 1999) and the more recent New Zealand Curriculum (NZC)
(Ministry of Education, 2007). For many years following European colonisation, predominately
British, in the 1800s, NZ lacked a formalised and specific PE curriculum that addressed the
learning needs of young New Zealanders. Heavily reliant on British documentation, NZ schools
offered physical training, formalised exercise for all, and military training for boys. As the colony
developed, NZ, like many other Western democracies, shifted in and out of various PE curriculum
value orientations (Jewitt, 1994). These shifts can be attributed to no formalised mandated NZ
curriculum. Indeed, it was not until 1987 that NZ had a formalised government mandated PE
curriculum that addressed the learning needs of its school population (5-15 yrs.). This 1987
curriculum document had a strong focus on the curriculum value orientation of motor skill
development for individual personal and social growth. Despite this focus, other curriculum value
orientations emerged because of specific government initiatives, perceived learner needs, the
agendas of community agencies, the shifting of societal standards, political economies of health
and sport and individual teacher value beliefs. Three curricula value orientations dominated the
PE landscape in NZ right up to and including the 1990s. A fourth curriculum value orientation
recently emerged at the turn of the century. The curriculum value orientations used over time are:
Motor skill development for personal and social growth.
This orientation assumed that a good education needed to address psycho-motor, cognitive, and
affective dimensions of learning for all round development. The content areas emphasised
technical proficiency in physical skills associated with large and small balls, aquatics, athletics,
gymnastics, dance, fitness, and outdoor activities including camping and games. Critics of this
472
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
approach suggested this traditional approach is based on unsubstantiated assumptions about
learning, skill development, active involvement, and adherence in active lifestyles – particularly in
the young (Trost, 2004).
Physical activity and fitness development for personal health
The belief that regular and vigorous physical activity made significant contributions to students’
physical health has long been an agenda of PE in NZ. Dating back to the 1940’s, this orientation
placed emphasis on rigorous physical fitness regimes designed to improve personal health, achieve
body control, and body discipline (lingering military influence) and to develop physical skills for
sporting performance (Culpan, 1996, 1997). The focus was overtly physical and often punishing
in nature, promoting the ‘no pain no gain’ mentality. Scholars agree that PE has a key role to play
in the public health agenda, particularly in the promotion of physical activity, but question the
punitive nature of such punishing programmes. Evans and Davies (2004) provided an insightful
perspective by stressing the importance of critically evaluating programmes of this nature and
promoted the notion that students need to be encouraged in how to become critical consumers of
health-orientated initiatives. They argued that PE lessons should be enjoyable and ensure that
students are knowledgeable about the way health has been constructed and shaped by corporate
and business interests. Evans and Davies argued that promoting physically taxing fitness
programmes for health in unproblematic ways endorsed ‘body perfection codes’ which personify
the body as:
• Imperfect (whether through circumstance of one’s social class, or poverty or self-neglect).
• Incomplete and to be re-engineered through physical therapy (circuit training, fitness
through sport, and a better diet).
• Endangered (by risk of modernity or lifestyle of overeating and inactivity and other noncommunicable disease.).
This PE curriculum value orientation conceptualises the body as something that needs remediating
results in an ‘ill health pedagogy’, which in turn ignores the multi-facet complexity of holistic health
and leaves the students feeling powerless and alienated from their bodies (Culpan, 2011).
Sport education
Sport has been a regular, important, and ubiquitous aspect of teaching in PE in NZ for some time.
Its presence is the result of the general pervasiveness of sport across the ‘Kiwi culture’1. It was not
until the 1980’s that ‘sportification’ and scientisation of PE became more formally dominant. This
was brought about by a raft of government initiatives (see Grant & Pope, 2000), the success of
NZ sports performance internationally, and the development of two sport-related teaching
models: Sport Education Model for PE (Siedentop, 1994), and Games for Understanding (Bunker
& Thorpe, (1982). The ‘sportification’ and scientisation of PE was consistent with many European
initiatives (see Naul, 2003) and initially the orientation was characterised by a ‘sport for all’
1
The national symbol of NZ is the kiwi bird.
473
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
philosophy, the spirit of competition, learning its culture, and the teaching of new types of sports
like golf, korfball, and martial arts. However, as the sport orientation morphed into a scientised
performative ideology, where young talent is identified, developed, and promoted at the expense
of the majority, and schools began using elite sport success as a marketing tool, resistance within
the academy emerged.
While each of the three orientations had their own internal educative coherence and provided PE
with a diverse ideology(ies), the fragmented legitimacy, resulted in a destructive divergence of PE
perspectives and practices across the country. There was no consensus or commitment to the
educative and social worth of PE, occasioning in a laissez faire market mentality where ‘anything
goes’ and ‘everyone gets a bargain’. Essentially, the educative experience of the students was simply a
crude manifestation of either consumer demand, or the interests of the teacher. Consequently, the
educative potential of PE became marginalised. These orientations co-existed in a feigned
harmony, and the edgings defining them blurred and became inter-changeable with relative ease.
This ‘no general consensus’, was not a unique problem for PE, indeed, a lack of general consensus
across the total school curriculum areas was commonplace. This no consensus culminated in
resolute neo-liberal political and economic government reforms in the last decade and a half of
the 20th century (Culpan, Cowan, Lindsay, and Stevens, 2018). The reforms saw the government
instigate a massive curriculum overhaul to align the schooling system to economic and market
driven agendas which had strong measures of accountability and control. Driven by this sociopolitical-economic agenda, the education sector experienced upheaval and changes focussed on
the demise of centralised regulations for schools, universities, education providers and other
government agencies. The dismantling of an arguable cumbersome bureaucracy across the whole
state sector saw education providers given the mandate to be self-directed, self-managed and
largely self-regulating, whilst required to follow government established guidelines e.g., national
curriculum statements (Culpan, Cowan, Lindsay, & Stevens, 2018). This strong neo-liberal market
orientation saw the emergence of education institutions (schools, universities, and nongovernment education providers) as self-maximising economic units requiring the adoption of
business models of operation, clear accountability lines, with budgeted profit outcomes.
This disruption to the whole education sector required a complete rewrite of the total school
curriculum and gave impetus for the development of the fourth curriculum value orientation for
both health and PE in NZ. Indeed, this moment became the first time NZ adopted NZHPE and
integrated Health and PE into a single curriculum document (Ministry of Education, 1999).
Socio-critical physical education.
A socio-critical value orientation for both health and PE necessitates a seismic shift and expansive
thinking in the practice of teaching these subjects. This orientation aims to better capture health
and PE as a more valued socially educative practice and to give more meaning for the students
and legitimacy for the teachers. The approach highlights the shortcomings of past orientations
particularly the problematics of rampant individualism, scientised and technocratic PE content
laced with cogent sportive and fitness regimes, and an overindulgent menu of traditional
474
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
patriarchal games. These shortcomings were made evident by a plethora of government reports
highlighting decreasing physical activity rates, increased obesity, poor decisions being made
around nutritional choices, alcohol and drug usage, and other social ills affecting young people’s
healthy lifestyle habits. The socio-critical orientation required a strong focus on a socio-ecological
perspective (Lawson, 1992). It emphasises the self, others, and society, where teachers use health
and PE contexts to allow students to experience, discover and make lifelong health and PE
choices related to themselves, their culture, and the society in which they live. Fundamental to
the successful implementation of this orientation is the teacher’s capacity and capability to provide
movement contexts where students can learn health and PE content, in, through and about
movement (Arnold, 1997). It encourages students to make meaningful connections and critically
apply these experiences to wider aspects of their lives. This approach endeavours to give more
coherence to PE and to promote more socially just, inclusive, and equitable practices through a
vision involving actively participating in, and critically examining, the movement culture to
achieve more holistic and valued lifestyle practices (Burrows, 2004).
This fourth curriculum value orientation has been made evident in the philosophical foundation
of the Health and Physical Education in the New Zealand Curriculum (NZHPE), (Ministry of Education,
1999) and its subsequently revised health and PE area of the New Zealand Curriculum (NZC)
Ministry of Education, (2007). The developers of the NZHPE, wanted to resist many of the
government neo-liberal reforms, and address the shortcomings of previous health and PE
practices. Consequently, they drew on four conceptual underpinnings to reinforce the adoption
of this socio-critical orientation: Hauora (an indigenous Māori term for holistic wellbeing), Health
Promotion, A socio-ecological perspective, and an integrated set of Attitudes and Values (see
Ministry of Education, 2004). These conceptual under-pinning’s (Ministry of Education, 1999)
provide the foundation for a holistic focus encompassing the social, cultural, scientific, political,
economic, ethical, and physical contexts of health and movement in people’s lives. This approach
in NZ promotes a clear move away from the historically dominant curriculum value orientations
where physical activity, sport skill mastery, physical fitness, and sportive curriculum content,
informed by issues of public health and notions of healthism dominated. Principally, this new
approach sought to develop essential life skills central to notions of humanism drawing on a critical
pedagogy (Culpan, Cowan, Lindsay & Stevens, 2018). Importantly, the concept of critical
pedagogy is aligned with, and supported by, constructivist perspectives of teaching and learning
(see Culpan & McBain 2012) that occur within multiple movement contexts. The critical pedagogy
within the NZHPE and NZC is both emancipatory and empowering. Emancipatory, in the sense
that critical pedagogy encourages students to accumulate knowledge, skills and power to develop
increased control over their personal and collective lives. Empowering, where critical pedagogy
supports individuals and groups to recognise and characterise hegemonic practices, and take social
action to promote change (Dardner, Baltodano, & Torres, 2003; Evans, 2014).
Critical pedagogy within the NZHPE and NZC, has required teachers to not only consider it as a
process of problem solving and questioning to promote higher order thinking skills, but more
importantly to examine and question the educational assumptions, inequality and hegemonic
practices occurring in a physical, social, political, and historical health and movement orientated
475
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
contexts (Burrows, 2004; Culpan & Bruce, 2007). In the employment of critical pedagogy
(McLaren, 2003) in health and PE contexts, teachers and students must assume and accept
potential difficulties. They need to be prepared to be responsible for destabilising and interrogating
‘truths’ about health and PE practices existing in schools and the wider community. This approach
can be disruptive to the general orthodoxy of the past. NZHPE and NZC requires teachers to
work with students to be the key agents in the development of, and transformation to more just
and equitable health and movement orientated environments. There is a need for them to become
critical intellectuals to advance the educative, social, and moral values of health and PE so to
maximise the learning opportunities that this curriculum area can provide. Essentially, the sociocritical curriculum value orientation drawing on critical pedagogy has provided NZ with a new
imagery for health and PE.
Physical Education today
The rich history of curriculum development and four value orientations have shaped current
practices, and NZHPE and NZC are now positioned for another round of curriculum
‘innovations’ and ‘refreshes’. This process, although in its infancy, will indefinitely see discussion
and debate on curriculum orientations. How this looks is yet to be decided, however the extensive
work done to dismantle ‘truths’, and address the shortcomings of past orientations will mean that
this process will certainly begin from a socio-critical position. This hints towards the successfulness
and permanency of a socio-critical value orientation for health and PE curriculum design.
Arguably, some key considerations when it comes to the development of NZHPE in the NZC
should be biculturalism, movement meaning and joy. Alongside addressing critique, these
considerations would further drive audacious disruptions to practice, and further the work
achieved by curriculum writers in 1999. To realise this, key movements in the political landscape
would be essential.
Physical Education New Zealand (PENZ) is the not-for-profit organisation that supports the
quality planning, teaching, and assessment of PE (Physical Education New Zealand, 2022a). They
hold a rich history of challenging the status quo, in the hopes of continued development and
understanding of PE and physical activity when it comes to the school setting (Culpan & Stothart,
2012). An example of this was in the late 1980’s, and through the 1990’s when PENZ developed
te ao kori (the world of movement) programmes to support PE teachers to better understand and
give indigenous meanings to the use of traditional Māori movement activities in their planning and
programme offerings. Given that the predominant discourse in the education sector was
Eurocentric, this was both a challenge, and an opportunity for the Ministry of Education. One
could argue these initial commitments to Māori as Treaty Partners2 in education, ultimately set the
tone and path for PENZ values moving forward. There is authenticity across policy and practice
that values mātauranga Māori (Māori wisdom/knowledge), te reo Māori (Māori language), te ao
‘Treaty partners’ is referring to the valuing and upholding of the formal document, Te Tiriti o Waitangi. Which is
considered the founding document of New Zealand and was signed in 1840 as a formal agreement between Māori chiefs and
representatives of the British Crown. The Treaty has legal principles and obligations pertaining to the rights and needs of
Māori. Historically, there have been many misinterpretations and breaches of these documents, and these are still being
recognised, addressed, and repaired.
2
476
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Māori (Māori customs and traditions), and te ao kori (the world of Māori movement). This is
notable in their current strategic plan that portrays an ongoing commitment to biculturalism, and
socio-critical change:
“Together as staff, members, volunteers, and physical educators, we are
working towards an Aotearoa (NZ) where quality physical education is
understood, valued and experienced. PENZ values and models Treaty-led
planning and decision making; and continues to be a staunch advocate of
bicultural curriculum, te reo Māori, te reo kori and te ao Māori. We confront and
challenge physical education practices that provision ableism, racism, sexism or
gender discrimination. We support professional learning, environments and
encounters that are positive, creative, inclusive, antiracist, and gender diverse.”
(Physical Education New Zealand, 2022b, p. 2)
The work of PENZ as a national subject organisation is the embodiment of Evans’ (2014)
assertion that groups must recognise, characterise hegemonic practices, and take social action to
promote change. This advocacy has become somewhat easier over time, as other governmental
and national bodies concerning physical activity and sport have seemingly accepted and celebrated
the disruption of ‘norms’. Sport New Zealand | Ihi Aotearoa (Sport NZ), the government
organisation tasked with leading the play, active recreation, and sport system in NZ (Sport New
Zealand, 2022b) have begun to shift more radically towards equity in policy and practice. For
example, there have been significant changes to Sport NZ’s strategy and operations that encourage
multiple worldviews and encompass broader definitions of play, recreation, and sport. The
campaign #itsmymove was brought about in 2022 to raise awareness to the challenges young women
face in sport and recreation as they age, that often lead to lower overall participation rates (Sport
New Zealand, 2022a). Additionally, the organisation has also identified three strategic priorities of
Te Aho, which are giving effect to Te Tiriti o Waitangi, increasing cultural capability and capacity,
and prioritising contribution to Māori wellbeing (Sport New Zealand, 2022c). In committing to
these actions, Sport NZ (as a Crown Entity) recognises that there is an accountability and
responsibility to uphold the principles of Partnership, Protection and Participation as stated in Te
Tiriti o Waitangi. Specifically, to uphold the rights and interests of Māori. It is not to say that Sport
NZ previously did not strive to be a good Treaty partners or use bicultural or Māori expertise.
Rather, to highlight the more recent overt strategic aims, campaigning, and promulgation of their
organisational shift towards equity.
These explicit stands against inequity in physical activity spaces seemingly affirm a socio-cultural
understanding of movement, and an authenticity towards social justice. A stand that acknowledges
the construction of these dynamic and educative spaces, and their ability to shape the experiences
that children have within them. However, although these examples of equity may seem to indicate
an adoption of criticality, as governmental education and health sectors begin to understand the
vital role they play in the shaping and use of knowledge, these acts of social justice do not naturally
constitute a socio-critical approach. Fundamentally, in a socio-critical curriculum, it comes down
to a willingness to relinquish control as knowledge experts, or providers, and avoiding the
‘mandating’ of knowledge. Simple acts of inclusion or change cannot replace the ongoing need for
477
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
disruption, progression of new knowledge’s and the willingness to allow for criticality. It could be
argued that there is still a very strong desire by government, and to some extent evidenced in NZC,
to control how physical activity is positioned concerning its contribution to ‘health’, and therefore
the usefulness of it in PE. In the case of Mātauranga Māori or gender equity, or any other identified
inequity for that matter, the end goal is not merely the labelling and awareness of, or ‘use’ of these
things to shape ‘health’ in policy and practice. Yet, this is ever-present. There is a notable absence
of critically informed social action in the form of ‘surrendering control’.
It is problematic and cumbersome to achieve (plan and implement) an authentic socio-critical value
orientation, when health and PE was previously unwaveringly influenced by a value orientation
predisposed to public health norms, shaping personal health, performance, body control, and body
discipline. Even the current curriculum document falls back into neoliberal mannerisms by design.
An example of this is the contradiction between the humanist philosophy of NZHPE in the NZC
and the assessed progressive learning outcomes across the year levels. Despite NZHPE valuing
movement meaning and Arnold’s ‘In, Through and About’ movement, there is still an emphasis
on the ‘seriousness’ of movement, health, and physical activity. This can be seen in the number of
learning outcomes that promote performative, athletic or behavioural elements in place of joyful
or meaningful ones, especially as the learners’ progress through the higher levels of schooling
(Stevens, 2017).
Outside of PE, despite the progress made, the health, physical activity, and sport sector still look
upon the subject with a desire for PE to be the solution to public health problems and other social
ills – hypothesising ‘physical activity time’ as a reason for its usefulness (Mizdrak, Shaw, Lynch, &
Richards, 2021). For instance, the overtly scientised and technocratic approaches to sport
propagates the body control ideology, elite sports performance, early talent identification, and the
hopes of a nation. These aim to provoke nationalism, enhance professionalism and the political
economy of sport. The current physical activity initiatives combating alleged ill health further
illustrates this scientised technocratic emphasis. Such initiatives create debate and confusions
within the profession and reduce the educative value, role, and potential of PE for lifelong wellbeing, to the explicit use of PE as a servant of public health policy. Another example of the
governmental desire to regulate and use physical activity, as a panacea to address social need, was
the introduction of the concept of Physical Literacy, and the desire of designing subsequent
assessment tools to track one’s physical literacy. Such a framework returns PE to the Motor skill
development for personal and social growth value orientation that has been found to be inadequate
for student’s contemporary learning needs. The action of adopting Physical Literacy, though
outwardly ‘progressive’, essentially saw an un-critical adoption of a Western framework for a
bicultural country, and risked the trialling and adoption of measurement tools that could reduce
the intent and scope of a socio-critical NZHPE. Such a move insinuates regression, distraction
and a weakening of a socio-critical orientation. Moreover, it perpetuates the colonisation of NZ
education (Stevens, Ovens, Hapeta, & Petrie, 2021). Pope (2014) suggests these reductionist and
neoliberal approximates to PE are the longest standing challenges to the subject area in NZ. We
argue these are contradictory to, and the antithesis of, a socio-critical approach to learning.
478
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Moving on
Despite the clear, authentic policy changes that seek equity and social justice through criticality,
there continues to be a need to ‘mandate’ knowledge rather than to liberate it. The tension between
public health policy, physical activity and sport practices, and a socio-critical curriculum is still rife.
The NZHPE in NZC has serious scope for evolution; however, those leading the charge need to
be astutely aware of the purpose of a socio-critical curriculum, and the potential for development
that preserves the document’s liberating and emancipatory intent. While it is most pleasing to see
the employment of a critical pedagogy, and the dismantling of truths thus far, it is important to
note that there has been a dilution of critical pedagogy internationally. According to McLaren
(2003) this “domestication” can be attributed to neo-liberal political ideologies, and the rise of
liberal humanism. The effects of these political economies remain a concern for PE as
understanding the range of truths that affect local and global decisions impact upon curriculum
innovation.
As in all curriculum design and orientation, there are risks of the unconscious implementation of
‘new truths’ to replace the old curriculum progressions. NZ must hold true to their socio-critical
value orientations throughout any curriculum ‘refresh’, not only to identify injustices and foster
equity, but more importantly – to not rest on any ‘truths’. This we argue is the new imagery that
needs fostering and impetus in NZ.
References
Arnold, P. (1997). Sport, ethics, and education. London: Cassell.
Bunker, D., & Thorpe, R. (1982). A model for teaching of games in secondary school. Bulletin of
Physical Education, 10, 9-16.
Burrows, L. (2004). Understanding and investigating cultural perspectives in physical education.
In J. Wright, D. MacDonald & L. Burrows (Eds.), Critical inquiry and problem solving in physical
education (pp. 105-119). London: Routledge.
Culpan, I. (2011). Olympism education within physical education: Contributing to legitimacy. In
S. Brown (Ed.), Issues and controversies in physical education (pp. 35-45). Auckland: Pearson.
Culpan, I. (1996/97). Physical education: Liberate it or confine it to the gymnasium? DELTA,
Vo148, no.2/Vol.49 no.1, pp. 203-220.
Culpan, I., & Bruce, J. (2007). New Zealand physical education and critical pedagogy: refocusing
the curriculum. International Journal of Sport and Health Science, 5, 1-11.
Culpan I, Cowan J., Fyall G., Lindsay H. & Stevens S. (2018). Secondary school physical education
in New Zealand; Bridging the theory practice nexus. In S. Popovic, B. Antala, D. Bjelica, &
J. Gardasevic, J. (Ed.), Physical Education in Secondary School: Researchers - Best Practice - Situation
(First ed.): 271-282. Bratislava, Slovakia: Faculty of Sport and Physical Education of
University of Montenegrpo, Montenegrin Sports Academy and Federation Internationale
D'Education Physique.
479
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Culpan, I., & McBain, S. (2012). Constructivist pedagogies for Olympism education. Asia-Pacific
Journal of Health, Sport, and Physical Education 3(2): 95–108.
Culpan, I., & Stothart, R. (2012). For the record: An encyclopaedia of historical aspects of New
Zealand physical education. Christchurch, New Zealand: University of Canterbury.
Dardner A, Baltodano M., & Torres R. (2003). The Critical Pedagogy Reader. New York: Routledge
Falmer.
Evans, J. (2014). Neo-liberalism and the future for a socio-educative physical education. Physical
Education and Sport Pedagogy 19(5): 545–558.
Evans, J. & Davies, B. (2004). The embodiment of consciousness: Berstein, health and schooling.
In J. Evans, B. Davies & J. Wright (Eds.). Body, knowledge, and control. London: Routledge.
(pp207-218).
Grant, B., & Pope, C. (2000). Retrospection and ruminations on sport and physical education.
Journal of Physical Education New Zealand. Vol. 33, (2). pp64-74.
Jewett, A. (1994). Curriculum theory and research in sport pedagogy. Sport Science Review. 3(1).
Lawson, H. (1992). Towards a socio-ecological conception of health. Quest, 44, 105-121.
McLaren, P. (2003). Critical pedagogy: A look at the major concepts. In A. Darder, M. Baltodano
& R. D. Torres (Eds.), The critical pedagogy reader (pp. 69-97). New York: Routledge Falmer.
Ministry of Education. (2007). The New Zealand Curriculum. Wellington, New Zealand: Learning
Media.
Ministry of Education. (2004). Making meaning, making a difference. Wellington, New Zealand:
Learning Media.
Ministry of Education (1999). Health and physical education in the New Zealand curriculum. Wellington,
N.Z: Learning Media.
Mizdrak, A., Shaw, C., Lynch, B., & Richards, J. (2021). The potential of school-based physical
education to increase physical activity in Aotearoa New Zealand children and young people:
a modelling study. The New Zealand Medical Journal (Online), 134(1531), 23.
Naul, R. (2003). Concepts of physical education in Europe. In K. Hardman (Ed.), Physical education:
Deconstruction and reconstruction - issues and directions (pp. 35-52). Schorndorf, Germany:
Hofmann.
Physical Education New Zealand. (2022a). Physical Education New Zealand | Te Ao Kori Aotearoa.
Retrieved from https://penz.org.nz/
Physical Education New Zealand. (2022b). Strategic plan 2021 - 2023. https://penz.org.nz:
Retrieved from https://penz.org.nz/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/Physical-EducationNew-Zealand-Strategic-Plan-2021-2023.pdf
Pope, C. (2014). The jagged edge and the changing shape of health and physical education in
Aotearoa New Zealand. Physical Education and Sport Pedagogy, 19(5), 500-511.
Siedentop, D. (1994) Sport education: Quality PE through positive sport experiences. Champaign, IL:
Human Kinetics.
Sport New Zealand. (2022a). #itsmymove. Retrieved from
https://sportnz.org.nz/itsmymove/overview/
Sport New Zealand. (2022b). Sport New Zealand | Ihi Aotearoa Retrieved from
https://sportnz.org.nz/
480
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Sport New Zealand. (2022c). Te Aho a Ihi Aotearoa. Retrieved from
https://sportnz.org.nz/resources/te-aho-a-ihi-aotearoa-maori-activation-plan-2021-2024/
Stevens, S. (2017). The joy of movement in physical education: The enfleshed body. University of Canterbury,
Christchurch). Retrieved from https://ir.canterbury.ac.nz/handle/10092/14910
Stevens, S., & Culpan. I. (2020). The ever-changing landscape: Physical education in New Zealand
universities, 433-442. In M. Bobrik, B. Antala & R. Pelucha (Eds.). Physical education in
universities: Researchers—Best Practices – Situation. Bratislava, Slovakia: Slovak Scientific Society
for Physical Education.
Stevens, S., Ovens, A., Hapeta, J. W., & Petrie, K. (2021). Tracking Physical Literacy in Aotearoa
New Zealand: concerns of narrowed curriculum and colonisation. Curriculum Studies in Health
and Physical Education, 12(2), 123–139. https://doi.org/10.1080/25742981.2021.1901598
Trost, S. (2004). School physical education in the post report era. Journal of Teaching in Physical
Education. V.23, 4. pp318-337.
.
481
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
482
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Physical Activity on Children and Youth – The Importance for a
Healthy Lifestyle
Liliana Ramos1,2 - Susana Franco1,2 - Carla Chicau Borrego1,2
Sport Sciences School of Rio Maior, Polytechnic Institute of Santarém, Portugal
2
Life Quality Research Center, Portugal
e-mail: sfranco@esdrm.ipsantarem.pt
1
Abstract
This chapter brings a reflection about physical activity (PA) in individuals and in society, namely
in children and youth. It starts with the importance and benefits of PA and Sport for children
and youth, followed by recommendations about PA for these populations. The current situation
of PA in children and youth around the world, and particularly in Portugal, and ways to measure
it, it is also presented. The chapter ends with the theme PA and Sport as promoters of a healthy
lifestyle, personal and social development, referring the ways to promoting them.
Key words: Sport; Personal and Social Development; Sustainability; Inclusion; Education;
Values.
483
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Importance and effects (benefits) of physical activities in children and youth
Physical activity (PA) can be defined as any movement produced by skeletal muscles that requires
energy expenditure and improves physical, mental, social health and well-being, helps prevent
disease and reduces the burden on health care systems (World Health Organization [WHO],
2020). It contributes to gender equity, social inclusion, increase longevity, employability and
education. Examples of PA can be walking to work, going to school by bicycle, domestic tasks or
doing some exercise or sports activities. These activities are contributors to multiple governments
and global agendas including COVID-19 recovery, improving socio-economic development,
reducing inequalities, addressing climate change, and contributing to the sustainable development
agenda (WHO, 2018; United Nations [UN], 2015). For children and adolescents, PA includes
games, playing, sports, transportation, recreation activities, physical education, or planned
exercise, in the context of family, school, and community (WHO, 2020).
On the other hand, sedentary behaviour can be defined as any waking behaviour in a sitting,
reclining, or lying posture with low energy expenditure (Tremblay et al., 2017). The majority of
adolescents do not meet current PA guidelines (Guthold, Stevens, Riley& Bull, 2020), putting
their current and future health at risk. So it is urgent to implement effective programs to increase
PA in children and youth. Such action will improve the health of this and future young
generations and supports achieving the 2030 Sustainable Development Goals (UN, 2015). A
higher amount of sedentary behaviour is associated with some poor health outcomes like
increased adiposity, poorer cardiometabolic health, fitness, behavioural conduct/pro-social
behaviour, and reduced sleep duration and is recommended that children and youth should limit
the amount of time spent being sedentary, particularly the amount of recreational screen time
(WHO, 2020). According to Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
(OECD, 2019) obesity report, “(…) children in particular are paying a high price for obesity. Children who
are overweight do less well at school, get lower marks, are more likely to miss school and are off school for longer
than children with a healthy weight. Children with obesity are 13% less likely to report good school performances
and, when they grow up, they are less likely to complete higher education. Children with obesity show lower life
satisfaction and are up to three times more likely to be bullied, which may contribute to lower school performance.”
(pp.14).
Several studies indicated that PA in children and youth has numerous health benefits (Physical
Activity Guidelines Advisory Committee [PAGAC], 2018; Poitras et al., 2016) in relation to
physical, psychological, social, and cognitive aspects, namely in:
• Body composition: Do PA resulted in a decrease in adiposity, and higher levels of activity
may be associated with healthy weight in children and adolescents (Poitras et al., 2016), but
overall, there is low certainty evidence that PA is associated with the control of a healthy
weight, and more studies were needed to confirm these associations;
• Cardiometabolic biomarkers: PA is positively associated with cardiometabolic health
outcomes, like for example improving blood pressure, lipid profile, glucose control and
insulin resistance (PAGAC, 2018; Pozuelo-Carrascosa et al., 2018);
484
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
•
•
•
•
Physical fitness: PA improved cardiorespiratory and musculoskeletal capacities in children
and adolescents (PAGAC, 2018; Poitras et al., 2016);
Bone health: Bone health in childhood and adolescence can help protect from osteoporosis
and related fractures later in life (WHO, 2020). PA is positively associated with bone mass,
higher bone mineral content or density and greater bone strength (PAGAC, 2018);
Cognitive and metacognition functions & academic achievement: PA benefits several
domains of cognition, like nonexecutive cognitive functions, core executive functions,
including working memory, selective attention-inhibition and cognitive flexibility and
metacognition functions, like cognitive life skills and executive functions (Álvarez-Bueno et
al., 2017). Some evidence also suggests that there are positive associations between PA and
academic achievement, but there are some aspects that remain to be explored, like the type,
amount, frequency, and timing and more research is necessary to determine devices and
long-term impact, as well as strategies to translate these findings to the school environment
(Donnelly et al., 2016);
Psychological and social factors: PA in children appears to be an inverse relation with
depression and anxiety (Bélair, Kohen, Kingsbury & Colman., 2018) and may be comparable
to psychological and pharmaceutical therapies in reducing symptoms. The self-esteem, social
interaction and fewer depressive symptoms were the most referred by the literature (Eime,
Young, Harvey, Charity & Payne., 2013).
Relations between PA and health indicators were more consistent and robust for higher versus
lower intensity, but all patterns of activity (sporadic, short time, continuous) provided benefit
(Poitras et al., 2016). Children and youth with some health problems have also benefit from PA.
In children with autism spectrum disorder there were some evidences about providing
entertaining and engaging training for whole-person development (Yu, Wong, Lo, So, & Chan,
2018) and in children with diabetes type 1 the regular practice of supervised regular moderate to
vigorous PA was associated with several health benefits (Aljawarneh, Wardell, Wood & Rozmus.,
2019).
Considering that in children and adolescents (aged 5-17 years) the adiposity (weight gain, weight
change, weight control, weight stability, weight status and weight maintenance), adverse events,
bone health, cardiometabolic health, cognitive outcomes, mental health, and physical fitness were
considered critical for health and pro-social behaviour and sleep were considered important
(WHO, 2020), the PA assume a very important and vital role for this population.
Recommendations for PA in children and youth
Over time, several organizations tried to establish guidelines for PA in children, based on
scientific evidence (Okely et al., 2022; PAGAC, 2018). The WHO is an international recognized
entity and has its guidelines translated into several languages, which facilitates its dissemination.
In this way, the most recent recommendations for PA in children aged 0 to 17 years are
presented below (WHO, 2019, 2020).
485
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Table 1 Recommendations for PA in children and youth (WHO, 2019, 2020)
Age
Less than 1 year
1-2 years
3-4 years
5-17 years
and children
with disability
(5-17) years
Recommendations
Be active several times a day in a variety of ways, particularly through
interactive floor-based play. In babies that doesn´t yet mobile, this
includes at least 30 minutes in prone position throughout the day.
Spend at least 180 minutes for day in a variety of types of PA, from
moderate to vigorous intensity.
Spend at least 180 minutes in a variety of activities, of which 60
minutes of moderate-to-vigorous PA.
An average of 60 minutes per day of moderate to vigorous intensity,
mostly aerobic, across the week.
Vigorous-intensity aerobic activities, as well as those that strengthen
muscle and bone, should be incorporated at least 3 days a week
Another good practice statement of WHO (2020) is that doing some PA is better than doing
none and will benefit their health. Children and adolescents, particularly sedentary, should start
doing small amounts of PA and gradually increase the frequency, intensity, and duration over
time. It is also important that the PA is safe and there are equitable opportunities and
encouragement to participate in enjoyable physical activities, offers variety and ensure it is
appropriate for their age and ability (WHO, 2020).
The current situation of PA in children around the world and in Portugal
Worldwide, 1 in 4 adults, and 3 in 4 youths (aged 11-17 years) do not currently meet the global
recommendations for PA of WHO, with some countries reaching about 70% of levels of physical
inactivity, justify most of all by the changing patterns of transportation and the increased use of
technology and urbanization, with the countries more developed economically obtaining lower
rates of physical inactivity (WHO, 2020). In Europe, the proportion of the Europeans that never
exercise or play sport continues to increase, with 46% of people above 15 years of age saying that
never exercise or play sport (TNS Opinion & Social, 2018).
In children and youths more studies, about the lack of PA, are still needed, since available results
are not consistent, in part due the variation in protocols and data management (Mota, Coelho-eSilva, Raimundo & Sardinha, 2016). The Active Health Kids Report Card, from Canada, is an
excellent instrument for presenting the data in a format that is operational by researchers, policy
makers, and practitioners (Tremblay et al., 2014). This report includes ten indicators of PA and
sedentary behaviour, namely: Overall PA, Organized Sport and PA, Active Play, Active
Transportation, Sedentary Behaviours, Family and Peers, School, Community and the
Environment, Government and Physical Fitness. In 2018, 30 countries applied this protocol,
with a classification range of the indicators from F (success in less than 20% of children and
young) to A (success in more than 80% of children and young). In Portugal, in 2018, Active
486
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Health Kids Report Card (Mota, Santos, Coelho-e-Silva, Raimundo & Sardinha., 2018) the overall
average was C+ (table 2), which means that approximately half of the Portuguese children and
adolescents achieve the quality indicators. Nevertheless, concerning overall PA levels, only 34%
of boys and 17% of girls, aged 11-15 years, were sufficiently active. Only 36% of 10 to 11 years
old children, and 4% of 16 to 17 years old adolescents meet PA guidelines, and 49% of children
and adolescents aged 12-18 years regularly participated in physical activities outside of school,
14% engaged at least once per week. That means that in this matter Portugal is succeeding with
less than half of children and adolescents in card grades.
Table 2 Results from Active Health Kids Report Card in Portugal (Mota et al., 2018)
Indicator
Overall, PA
Organized
Sport
Participation
Active Play
Active Transportation
Sedentary Behaviours
Family and Peers
School
Community
and
Environment
Government
Fitness
Grade
D
B*
CC
C
A
B
B
C
*For this indicator no grade was assigned in Portugal because there is little literature related to active play and leisure activities
among Portuguese school-aged children.
Comparing 30 countries (Aubert et al., 2018) the majority (18 of the 30) have an average of C in
all indicators (considering C-, C and C+), like Portugal results, and 3 of the countries, namely
Denmark, Japan and Slovenia have an average of B and the other 9 countries have an average of
D. The main conclusion of this report is that is very concerning the situation regarding PA in
children and youth, being expected that, unless a major change to a more active lifestyle happens
quickly, an extreme rate of non-communicable diseases can be anticipated when this generation
of children reaches adulthood (Aubert et al., 2018). Considering that the COVID-19 pandemic
decreased even more the levels of PA, have we a new pandemic within the pandemic? (Wilke et
al., 2021).
Healthy lifestyle promotion and physical education
In addition to the importance of PA to improve various health indicators, there are other equally
important aspects to improve quality of life, well-being as well as being healthy. For example, the
487
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
recommendations for children under 5 years old of the WHO (2019) include, beyond PA, some
suggestions about sedentary screen time (0 minutes for 1 year age and under; no more than 60
minutes for children with 2, 3 and 4 years old) and about good quality sleep (14-17 hours for 0-3
months of age; 12-16 hours for 4-11 months of age; 11-14 hours for children with 1-2 years; 1013 hours for children with 3-4 years). There is another study that concluded that a healthy
lifestyle promotion in child involves PA, nutritional patterns, sleep and mental health and
wellness, suggesting a PERMA model (positive emotions, engagement, relationships, meaning,
and accomplishment), that is a useful construct to approach improving PA, eating, and sleep to
improved physical and mental wellness in youth (Hosker, Elkins & Potter, 2019). There are also
some programs that promote a healthy lifestyle in schools. School is a very important place for
the interventions, because children spend a long time in that place and it is easy to organize data
and implement a multidisciplinary team. The program SI! (Salud Integral-Comprehensive Health)
existed for a decade, in United States of America, Spain and Colombia, and has the goals for preschoolers understand and apply a good diet, PA, manage de emotions and understand how works
the body and heart, with some step guides for this purpose, like organize health celebrations,
promote active school break periods, encourage body awareness, involve school canteen in
school activities and encourage children to come to school on foot or by bicycle, for example
(Santos-Beneit et al., 2022).
The 1990’s brought the idea of “WITH kids and not FOR kids”, seeing children and youth as
individuals to be nourished, having an emphasis on nurturing the potential of youth more than
addressing their supposed deficits, and on addressing and helping to shape the roles of
developmental contexts, especially that of the community and youth themselves as agents of their
own development (Hellison & Martinek, 2006). This marked the beginning of the concept of
“Positive Youth Development” (PYD), reflecting the desired outcomes for youth that encompass
society’s hopes and aspirations for a nation of healthy, happy, and productive individuals (Roth,
Brooks-Gunn, Murray, & Foster, 1998). Sport, within the framework of PYD, is an asset‐
building approach to youth development research and practice that emphasizes enhancing
strengths and developing potential in all youth (Lerner, 2017). The framework is child/youthcentered and aims to provide the opportunity for children/youth to learn and promote
empowerment, autonomy, and opportunities to experience challenges and, above all, play sport
and PA, never forgetting the playful component within an appropriate technical framework
(training environment) and with an adequate educational back up (personal, and social
development, and presence of supportive interactions). The sport context is one of the most
popular organized activities for youth, across several countries. In the PA realm, Hellison’s (2003)
“Teaching Personal and Social Responsibility” (TPSR) model was influential in initiating these
PYD ideas. This model provided a framework for empowering youth to be responsible for their
actions and learning, and to transfer these behaviors outside of the gym (Hellison, 2003). The
TPSR literature also discusses the importance of creating programs strengthened by personal
characteristics, interpersonal relationships, cultural differences and practices (Li, Wright,
Rukavina, & Pickering, 2008; Wright & Burton, 2008). The creation of a positive environment
can also influence program goals, for instance, how opportunities and activities that are provided
488
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
can facilitate or inhibit student commitment and engagement (Hellison & Martinek, 2006), and
moral development (Shields & Bredemeier, 2007).
Sports programs highlight the belief that sports participation has a positive impact on youth
development because it does the following: a) Creates motor and sport-specific skills that are
convertible into physical capital; b) Improves health, fitness, and an overall sense of physical wellbeing; c) Increases self-confidence, self-esteem, and positive body image; and d) Builds character
in the form of discipline, teamwork, and responsibility (Carreres-Ponsoda, Escartí, JimenezOlmedo & Cortell-Tormo, 2021; Fraser-Thomas, Côté, & Deakin, 2005; Goudas, 2010; Holt &
Jones, 2008). However, as Coakley (2011) claimed “By itself, the act of sport participation among young
people leads to no regularly identifiable development outcomes” (p. 309). The PYD approach does not
assume sports participation, by itself, leads to positive developmental outcomes, rather, it
emphasizes the idea that sport can enhance personal growth and produce positive developmental
outcomes when it is structured and delivered in the most appropriate ways (Coakley, 2011; Gould
& Carson, 2008; Holt & Jones, 2008). Various models exist to classify PYD outcomes, but one of
the most widely recognized outcome models is the “Five C’s” of youth development (Lerner et
al., 2005). The “Five C’s” model delineates PYD outcomes across five domains: competence,
confidence, connections, character, and caring. When all five C’s are present, a sixth C
(contribution) may occur, which enables youth to give back to their community.
Table 3 The “5+1 C’s” of Positive Youth Development Adaptation from Holt and Neely (2011)
“C”
Competence
Definition
Positive view of one’s actions in specific areas, including social,
academic, cognitive, health, and vocational. Social competence refers to
interpersonal skills (e.g. conflict resolution). Cognitive competence refers
to cognitive abilities (e.g. decision making). Academic competence refers
to school performance as shown, in part, by school grades, attendance,
and test scores. Health competence involves using nutrition, exercise,
and rest to keep oneself fit. Vocational competence involves work habits
and explorations of career choices. Effective entrepreneurial skills may
be one instance of vocational competence.
Confidence
An internal sense of overall positive self-worth and self-efficacy.
Connection
Positive bonds with people and institutions that are reflected in
exchanges between the individual and his or her peers, family, school,
and community, in which both parties contribute to the relationship.
Character
Respect for societal and cultural norms, possession of standards for
correct behaviors, a sense of right and wrong, and integrity.
Caring/Compassi A sense of sympathy and empathy for others.
on
Contribution
Enables youth to give back to their community and society.
489
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Since sports participation provides a focus for social activity, an opportunity to make friends,
develop networks and reduces social isolation, it seems well placed to support the development
of social capital. As Weiss and Wiese-Bjornstal (2009) summarize, a series of connected
dimensions of social inclusion (figure 1) can be a useful framework for considering sport’s
potential contribution to social inclusion/exclusion. First, the functional dimension of social
inclusion relates to the enhancement of knowledge, skills and understanding. Second, social
inclusion can be defined in relational terms, such as a sense of social acceptance. Sport might play
a positive role here, by offering young people a sense of belonging - to a team, a club or a
community. However, the fact that to engage in most sports in developed countries costs money
(e.g. for special clothing and equipment, club membership, entrance fees for events, insurance,
and travel), it may not be equally open for all individuals. Third, there is a spatial dimension, as
social inclusion relates to proximity and the closing of social and economic distances. Certainly,
there are frequent claims that sport brings individuals from a variety of social and economic
backgrounds together in a shared interest in activities that are seen to be inherently valuable
(Bailey, Hillman, Arent, & Petitpas, 2013). Finally, social inclusion assumes a change in the locus
of power. In this respect, sport contributes to social inclusion to the extent that it increases an
individual´s sense of control over their lives, as well as the “community capital” by extending
social networks, increasing community cohesion and civic pride. The establishment of social
networks is a key feature of socially inclusive practices. This is especially important, within the
context of sport for at-risk youth and in low-income neighbourhoods, for whom social and
organized settings can be sources of anxiety or disaffection (Escartí, Gutiérrez, Pascual, & Llopis,
2010).
PYD occurs when young people experience opportunities to develop competencies through
interactions with important others in family, peers, school, and community settings - “Be active,
healthy, and happy!”. From the European and world guidelines (e.g. Eurobarometer on sport and
physical activity [TNS Opinion & Social, 2018]; White paper on sport [European Commission,
2007]; WHO European Regional Obesity Report [World Health Organization, 2022]; Lisbon
Treaty - Article 165 [European Union, 2008]) and the report from OECD (2019), it is clear that
regular PA/sport leads to important physical, social, psychological, and academic competencies
and healthy outcomes among children and adolescents.
PA/sport through positive youth development approach specifies the essential goals, contexts,
and activities that optimize the achievement of these competencies and healthy outcomes. A
caring and mastery-oriented climate, supportive relationships with adults and peers, and
opportunities to learn social, emotional, and behavioral life skills—these are the elements for
promoting positive youth development and a healthy lifestyle through PA/sport.
490
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Provide Physical Activity Access & Opportunity for All Youth
Capacities
Policies
Supports
Stakeholders
Play spaces
Cultural
Financial tangible
Coordinated efforts for
Program
sensitivity
Marketing/dissemination all agents
interventions
Physical ability of good practices
Strong partnerships
Inclusion
Youth as active agents
Create Optimal Context for Physical Activity Engagement
Safety
Climates
Content
Methods
Relationships
WellAutonomy
Intentional
Experiential
Nurtured &
maintained
supportive
programming
learning
sustained
spaces
Mastery-oriented Life
skills Effective
Caring, role
Supervision,
“5+1 C’s” of activities
pedagogy
models
first aids
Positive
Youth
Development
Motor
Movement
literacy
PA skills
Achieve Developmental Health Outcomes for Participants
Physiological
Psychological & Social
Academic
Physical fitness
PA identity
Cognitive
Physical wellness
Positive leadership
functioning
Health-enhancing PA
Connection with others Energy & effort
Decrease time spent in affect
sedentary activities
Social inclusion and equal
access to sport for all
Social networks
Figure 1 Connected dimensions of social inclusion
(Adaptation from Weiss and Wiese-Bjornstal, 2009)
Conclusion
Physical activity (PA) and sports play an important role in health, well-being, physical, personal
and social development, education and values of the individuals, and in inclusion, socioeconomic and sustainable development of populations, namely in young generations.
In general, PA is low in populations, particularly in children and youth, being recommended for
all ages, since birth, with necessary adaptations to the individuals’ characteristics and preferences.
Besides the increase of PA, is it also important the decrease of sedentary behaviours, and the
potentiation of healthy nutrition, sleep and a positive mind-set? Several PA indicators can be used
491
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
to know the PA level of children, namely: Overall PA, Organized Sport and PA, Active Play,
Active Transportation, Sedentary Behaviours, Family and Peers, School, Community and the
Environment, Government and Physical Fitness. Parents at home, teachers in school and sports
professionals in different sports contexts, have an important role in the education and promotion
of a healthy lifestyle, for them and for new generations, particularly using PA.
References
Aljawarneh, Y.M., Wardell, D.W., Wood, G.L., & Rozmus, C.L. (2019). A Systematic Review of
Physical Activity and Exercise on Physiological and Biochemical Outcomes in Children and
Adolescents With Type 1 Diabetes. Journal of Nursing Scholarship, 51, 337-345.
https://doi.org/10.1111/jnu.12472
Álvarez-Bueno, C., Pesce, C., Cavero-Redondo, I., Sánchez-López, M., Martínez-Hortelano, J. A.,
& Martínez-Vizcaíno, V. (2017). The Effect of Physical Activity Interventions on
Children's Cognition and Metacognition: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Journal of
the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 56(9), 729–738.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jaac.2017.06.012
Aubert, S. Barnes, J. D., Nicolas, Aguilar-Farias., Cardon, G., Chang, C.K., Nyström, C.,
Demetriou, Y., Edwards, L., Emeljanovas, E., Gába, A., Huang, W., Izzeldin, A.E.
Ibrahim, J. J., Katzmarzyk, P., Korcz, A., Y Kim, Y. S., Lee, E., Löf, M., Loney, T.,
Morrison, S., Mota, J., … Tremblay, M. (2018). Report Card Grades on the Phsyical
Activity of Children and Youth Comparing 30 very high human development index
countries.
Journal
of
Physical
Activity
and
Health,
15(2),
s298-s314.
http://doi.org/10.1123/jpah.2018-0431
Bailey, R., Hillman, C., Arent, S., & Petitpas, A. (2013). Physical Activity: An Underestimated
Investment in Human Capital? Journal of Physical Activity and Health, 10(3), 289-308.
https://doi.org/10.1123/jpah.10.3.289
Bélair, M. A., Kohen, D. E., Kingsbury, M., & Colman, I. (2018). Relationship between leisure
time physical activity, sedentary behaviour and symptoms of depression and anxiety:
evidence from a population-based sample of Canadian adolescents. BMJ Open, 8(10),
e021119. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2017-021119
Carreres-Ponsoda, F., Escartí, A., Jimenez-Olmedo, J. M., & Cortell-Tormo, J. M. (2021). Effects
of a Teaching Personal and Social Responsibility Model Intervention in Competitive Youth
Sport
[Original
Research].
Frontiers
in
Psychology,
12,
Art624018.
https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2021.624018
Coakley, J. (2011). Youth Sports: What Counts as “Positive Development?”. Journal of Sport &
Social Issues, 35(3), 306-324.http://doi.org/10.1177/0193723511417311
Donnelly, J. E., Hillman, C. H., Castelli, D., Etnier, J. L., Lee, S., Tomporowski, P., Lambourne,
K., & Szabo-Reed, A. N. (2016). Physical Activity, Fitness, Cognitive Function, and
Academic Achievement in Children: A Systematic Review. Medicine and Science in Sports and
Exercise, 48(6), 1197–1222. https://doi.org/10.1249/MSS.0000000000000901
492
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Eime, R. M., Young, J. A., Harvey, J. T., Charity, M. J., & Payne, W. R. (2013). A Systematic
Review of the Psychological and Social Benefits of Participation in Sport for Children and
Adolescents: Informing Development of a Conceptual Model of Health Through Sport.
The International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity, 10, 98(2013).
https://doi.org/10.1186/1479-5868-10-98
Escartí, A., Gutiérrez, M., Pascual, C., e Llopis, R. (2010). Implementation of the Personal and
Social Responsibility Model to Improve Self-Efficacy during Physical Education Classes for
Primary School Children. International Journal of Psychology and Psychological Therapy, 10(3), 387402.
European Commission (2007). White Paper on Sport. Luxembourg: European Communities.
European Union (2008). Consolidated Version of the Treaty on European Union and the Treaty
on the Functioning of the European Union. Official Journal of the European Union, 2008/C
115/01.
Fraser-Thomas, J. L., Côté, J., & Deakin, J. (2005). Youth Sport Programs: An Avenue to Foster
Positive Youth Development. Physical Education and Sport Pedagogy, 10(1), 19-40.
https://doi.org/10.1080/1740898042000334890
Goudas, M. (2010). A Review of Life Skills Teaching in Sport and Physical Education. Hellenic
Journal of Psychology, 10, 241-258.
Gould, D., & Carson, S. (2008). Life Skills Development Through Sport: Current Status and
Future Directions. International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 1(1), 58-78.
https://doi.org/10.1080/17509840701834573
Guthold, R., Stevens, G. A., Riley, L. M., & Bull, F. C. (2020). Global Trends in Insufficient
Physical Activity among Adolescents: A Pooled Analysis of 298 Population-based Surveys
with 1.6 Million Participants. The Lancet. Child & Adolescent Health, 4(1), 23–35.
https://doi.org/10.1016/S2352-4642(19)30323-2
Hellison, D. (2003). Teaching Responsibility Through Physical Activity (2nd Ed.). Champaign, IL:
Human Kinetics.
Hellison, D., & Martinek, T. (2006). Social and Individual Responsibility Programs. Handbook of
Physical Education. In D. M. D. Kirk, & M. O'Sullivan (Eds.), Handbook of physical education,
(pp. 610-627). London: SAGE Publications Ltd.
Holt, N. L., & Neely, K. C. (2011). Positive Youth Development Through Sport: A Review.
Revista Iberoamericana de Psicología del Ejercicio y el Deporte, 6(2), 299-316.
Holt, N., & Jones, M. I. (2008). Future Directions for Positive Youth Development and Sport
Research. In N. L. Holt (Ed.), Positive Youth Development Through Sport (pp. 122-132).
London: Routledge.
Hosker, D. K., Elkins, R. M., & Potter, M. P. (2019). Promoting Mental Health and Wellness in
Youth Through Physical Activity, Nutrition, and Sleep. Child and Adolescent Psychiatric Clinics
of North America, 28(2), 171–193. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chc.2018.11.010
Lerner, R. M. (2017). Commentary: Studying and Testing the Positive Youth Development
Model: A Tale of Two Approaches. Child Development, 88(4), 1183–
1185. https://doi.org/10.1111/cdev.12875
493
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Lerner, R. M., Lerner, J. V., Almerigi, J., Theokas, C., Phelps, E., Gestsdóttir, S., . . . von Eye, A.
(2005). Positive Youth Development, Participation in Community Youth Development
Programs, and Community Contributions of Fifth Grade Adolescents: Findings from the
First Wave of the 4-H Study of Positive Youth Development. Journal of Early Adolescence,
25(1), 17-71. https://doi.org/10.1177/0272431604272461
Li, W., Wright, P. M., Rukavina, P. B., & Pickering, M. (2008). Measuring Students' Perceptions
of Personal and Social Responsibility and the Relationship to Intrinsic Motivation in Urban
Physical Education. Journal of Teaching in Physical Education and Sport Pedagogy, 27(2), 167-178.
https://doi.org/10.1123/jtpe.27.2.167
Mota, J., Coelho-e-Silva, M. J., Raimundo, A. M., & Sardinha, L. B. (2016). Results from
Portugal´s 2016 Report Card on Physical Activity for Children and Youth. Journal of Physical
Activity and Health, 13(s2), S3242-S3246. https://doi.org/10.1123/jpah.2016-0293
Mota, J., Santos, R., Coelho-e-Silva, M. J., Raimundo, A. M., & Sardinha, L. B. (2018). Results
from Portugal´s 2018 Report Card on Physical Activity for Children and Youth. Journal of
Physical Activity and Health, 15(s2), S398-S399. https://doi.org/10.1123/jpah.2018-0541
Okely, A.D., Ghersi, D., Loughran, S.P., Cliff, D.P, Shilton, T., Jones, R.A, … Tremblay, M. S.
(2022). A Collaborative Approach to Adopting/Adapting Guidelines. Australian 24-hour
Movement Guidelines for Children (5–12 years) and Young People (13–17 years): An
Integration of Physical Activity, Sedentary Behaviour, and Sleep. International Journal of
Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity, 19(2), 1-21. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12966-02101236-2
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (2019). The Heavy Burden of Obesity:
The Economics of Prevention. OECD Health Policy Studies. Paris: OECD Publishing.
Physical Activity Guidelines Advisory Committee (2018). Physical Activity Guidelines Advisory
Committee Scientific Report. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human
Services.
Poitras, V. J., Gray, C. E., Borghese, M. M., Carson, V., Chaput, J. P., Janssen, I., Katzmarzyk, P.
T., Pate, R. R., Connor Gorber, S., Kho, M. E., Sampson, M., & Tremblay, M. S. (2016).
Systematic Review of the Relationships Between Objectively Measured Physical Activity
and Health Indicators in School-aged Children and Youth. Applied Physiology, Nutrition, and
Metabolism, 41, S197–S239. https://doi.org/10.1139/apnm-2015-0663
Pozuelo-Carrascosa, D. P., Cavero-Redondo, I., Herráiz-Adillo, Á., Díez-Fernández, A., SánchezLópez, M., & Martínez-Vizcaíno, V. (2018). School-Based Exercise Programs and
Cardiometabolic Risk Factors: A Meta-analysis. Pediatrics, 142(5), e20181033.
https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2018-1033
Roth, J., Brooks-Gunn, J., Murray, L., & Foster, W. (1998). Promoting healthy adolescents:
Synthesis of youth development program evaluations. Journal of Research on Adolescence, 8(4),
423–459. https://doi.org/10.1207/s15327795jra0804_2
Santos-Beneit, G., Fernández-Jiménez, R., Cos-Gandoy, A., Rodríguez, C., Carral, V., Bodega, P.,
… & Fuster, V. (2022). Lessons Learned From 10 Years of Preschool Intervention for
Health Promotion: JACC State-of-the-Art Review. Journal of the American College of Cardiology,
79(3), 283–298. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jacc.2021.10.046
494
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Shields, D. L., e Bredemeier, B. L. (2007). Advances in Sport Morality Research. In G.
Tenenbaum & R. C. Eklund (Eds.), Handbook of Sport Psychology (3rd Ed.; pp. 662-684).
Hoboken, New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
TNS Opinion & Social (2018). Special Eurobarometer 472 / Wave EB88.4 "Sport and Physical
Activity". Brussels: TNS Opinion & Social.
Tremblay, M. S., Gray, C. E., Akinroye, K., Harrington, D. M., Katzmarzyk, P. T., Lambert, E.
V., … Tomkinson, G. (2014). Physical Activity of Children: A Global Matrix of Grades
Comparing 15 countries. Journal of Physical Activity and Health, 11(S1), S113–S125.
https://doi.org/10.1123/jpah.2014-0177
Tremblay, M. S., Aubert, S., Barnes, J. D., Saunders, T. J., Carson, V., Latimer-Cheung, A. E., …
SBRN Terminology Consensus Project Participants (2017). Sedentary Behavior Research
Network (SBRN) - Terminology Consensus Project Process and Outcome. The International
Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and physical activity, 14(1), 75. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12966017-0525-8
United Nations (2015). Transforming our World: The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable
Development. Resolution Adopted by General Assembly. United Nations.
Weiss, M. R., & Wiese-Bjornstal, D. M. (2009). Promoting Positive Youth Development Through
Physical Activity. Research Digest, President’s Council on Physical Fitness and Sports, 10(3), 1-8.
Wilke, J., Mohr, L., Tenforde, A. S., Edouard, P., Fossati, C., González-Gross, M., … Hollander,
K. (2021). A Pandemic within the Pandemic? Physical Activity Levels Substantially
Decreased in Countries Affected by COVID-19. International Journal of Environmental Research
and Public Health, 18(5), 2235. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph18052235
World Health Organization (2018). Global Action Plan on Physical Activity 2018–2030: More Active
People for a Healthier World. Geneva: World Health Organization.
World Health Organization (2019). Guidelines on Physical Activity, Sedentary Behaviour, and Sleep for
Children Under 5 Years of Age. Geneva: World Health Organization.
World Health Organization (2020). WHO Guidelines on Physical Activity and Sedentary Behaviour.
Geneva: World Health Organization.
World Health Organization (2022). WHO European Regional Obesity Report 2022.
Copenhagen: WHO Regional Office for Europe.
Wright, P. M., e Burton, S. (2008). Implementation and Outcomes of a Responsibility-based
Physical Activity Program Integrated into an Intact High School Physical Education Class.
Journal
of
Teaching
in
Physical
Education,
27(2),
138-154.
https://doi.org/10.1123/jtpe.27.2.138
Yu, C., Wong, S., Lo, F., So, R., & Chan, D. (2018). Study Protocol: A Randomized Controlled
Trial Study on the Effect of a Game-based Exercise Training Program on Promoting
Physical Fitness and Mental Health in Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder. BMC
Psychiatry, 18, 56(2018). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12888-018-1635-9
495
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
496
Situation
________________________________________________________________________________
Obstacle Course Race in Physical Education Lessons: A Way to
Contrast the Covid-19 Restrictions
Viviana Zito - Nicola Lovecchio
Capdi & LSM, Italy
e-mail: viviana.zito73@gmail.com
Abstract
In 2020 a wide range of attempts to develop PE lessons were done during the second way block
of Covid-19 restrictions: guidelines for students on how to do PE at home, tips on how
encourage students to do PA in the garden of their home, on the stairs of their building, outside
in the park or even in the street. Web-based interactive learning platforms with several new
educational materials (photos/videos, ppts, on-line PE format lessons...) for PE teachers were
created by Capdi and LSM, the National Association of PE teachers in Italy, to help teachers
who were faced the new challenge of organizing their teaching totally on line, or in presence (in
the gym but with no contact between people or people and sport tools) or hybrid (at the same
time with half class on line and half class in presence). Everybody, and especially young people,
tend to be more active when they are outdoors rather than when they are inside (Nicol, 2014).
The Outdoor Obstacle Course during PE lessons raised awareness to the possibility to use,
beside all school facilities for PE like the gyms, all the spaces, in and out of the school, as places
useful to move. Outdoor Obstacle Course lessons are safe and accessible to keep students active
during PE classes, after school sport clubs, active breaks, recess, active lessons and other events
that can be integrated into the school schedule. Using creativity and imaginations PE teachers
could transform both indoor and outdoor spaces potentially as active spaces during the long
school days. The Outdoor Obstacle Course triggers to involve the largest number of students of
all ages, increase participations to the PE lessons in a holistic way, develop motor ability, motor
coordination, psychomotor skills, cognitive skills and allow students to continue PA as a lifelong
habit reducing the risk of possible health issue in their future (Dern, 2018).
Key words: Outdoor education, Physical education, Physical inactivity
497
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
________________________________________________________________________________
Background
Since the World Health Organization (WHO) declared the Covid-19 Pandemic, there were
serious emergency measures such as two world-wide lockdowns, self-isolation or quarantines,
travel restrictions and closures of school, sport clubs, gyms, swimming pool and parks.
Everybody experienced the isolation and the impossibility to go out and work out. Physical
Activity (PA) was rarely admitted and only people who need physical rehabilitation were
admitted to gyms and clinical structures. The period between March 2020 and September 2021
was characterized by the lack of free play for children and the absence of structured motor
learning lessons delivered by PE teachers (Physical Education).
This circumstance aggravated the physical development of children/adolescent and improved
the cases of mental difficulties with a plethora of unhealthy and un-social sequelae. This
extraordinary situation pushed Capdi & LSM (Italian Confederation of Associations of Physical
Education and Sport Science teacher) to support PE teacher category who has reorganised their
teaching routine into online, in dual or rarely in presence. Thus, it become important share new
and original strategies to lead lessons and disseminate as much as possible new materials for an
extraordinary condition.
Obstacle Course Race (OCR) PE lessons: a way to restart moving in outdoor setting
At the begin of the 2020-21 scholastic year a new challenge meets the PE teacher: the practice
according to Covid-19 sanitary restrictions. In particular; PE lesson indoor wearing masks,
compulsory social distance, no team sport, no touching the same sport materials, disinfecting
tools, on-line and dual form of PE lessons. PE teachers all over the world were forced to
explore new and original way to engage the students avoiding the spread of the disease. Thus,
become essential, during Covid-19 restrictions, re-organize the contents of the PE curriculum
giving priority to outdoor sport, the basic motor skills development and highlight the cultural
importance of investing in PA as a primary illness prevention (Davis 2010).
An obstacle training path was an attractive idea to re-start from robust basic motor abilities
developing them in outdoor context (Bortolotti, 2019). Indeed, this kind of PA has more than
8.5 million participants and become popular in this past decade. The main purpose, beside
improving the fitness level, was to carry PE in presence with classmates, both in outdoor gym
context keeping the social distance but through a stimulating PA. This reinforced the spirit of
belonging and get back the cohesion of each group class lost in the previous pandemic months.
In particular, the specific objective was the construction of a path to promote sports practice
(Mullins, 2012) according to:
• promote a path of psycho-physical well-being to be used in all free moments of school life
• become an instrument of attraction for students who are not involved in the other most
famous sport
498
Situation
________________________________________________________________________________
•
•
•
•
•
offer the possibility to perform PA outdoor
use a challenge as a moment of self-verification and not as an opponent's comparison
help spread the educational values of PE and PA
develop in students the self-awareness to know their abilities and appreciate personal
improvements
enhance the school environment using every tool and space
Methods
By ensuring that methodological choices were profitable and functional to the contents
(Rawdon, 2016), in September 2021, a total of 10 classes with an average number of 25-30 each
student from 15- 18 years old were involved in an OCR intensive learning unit by a qualified PE
teacher and also, OCR athlete. The learning unit were developed in a total of 10 hours during
one month in the beginning of the school year. It was chosen a school in the south Italy with an
indoor gym and a outdoor space (with a basketball court inside) located just in front of the
beach and surrounded by 1km promenade. Students were involved in this project in occasion of
the European Week of Sport in the last week of September 2021.
The obstacle path training was organized considering (Dexheimer, Schroeder, Sawyer, Pettitt,
Aguinaldo, & Torrence, 2019):
• initial tests to evaluate the athlete's starting conditions
• resistance training
• strength training with natural load or with the help of tools
• training to overcome obstacles, through appropriate techniques and simulations
• functional training to improve functional strength, mobility, agility and balance
• training about the modulation of the race over short or long distances
• nutrition suggestion
• mental training suggestion
Depending on the aim of each lesson and the fitness level of the students a teacher- centred
method together with a method of demonstration were the best at the beginning of the learning
unit in order to let the teacher focus the attention of possible dangers of each obstacle and to
give clear instructions about the basic obstacles and the organization of an OCR lesson.
Once students knew the basic knowledge of safety instructions to practice OCR and scaffolding
exercises were developed, it was possible to let them to know new obstacles and experiment
how to pass throughout adopting the cooperative learning method. In this phase, the division in
small groups allowed students to build relationships, making connections and re-establish the
sociality lost during the Covid 19 Pandemic. In the end of the school year, it was also useful and
very exciting for the students to flip the classroom and let them to build their own obstacles
path for their mates. It was very interesting to see how nice and creative were the results.
499
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
________________________________________________________________________________
Students with some difficulties were often supported by pairs in a very natural way like often
happen in team building activities. This happened very easily because in some specific lessons all
obstacles were structured in a way that students reach the result only with the help of
companions.
As regards the final evaluation of the OCR lesson, the PE teacher took into account:
• Commitment and active participation in all the teaching activities proposed according to
the students’ abilities
• Specific technical skills acquired taking into account the starting level
• Attention capacity
• Ability to make constructive and appropriate interventions and proper suggestions
• Willing to help and support classmates
• Awareness about not to be dangerous for themselves and for others
By ensuring a full compliance of the students it was taken into account the starting physical
fitness level, the need to make them main leader of the learning process and the guarantee to
ensure, even students with disabilities, the opportunity to fully participate and enjoy the indoor
or outdoor activities (Macey, & Brown, 2014).
In particular, the main motor abilities developed in the OCR paths generally include running,
climbing (fig. 1), crawling (fig. 3), walking through, balancing (fig. 9), carrying (fig. 5), jumping
(fig. 4) and jumping down. This discipline has always to include a cross country or on mud path
interspersed with natural and artificial obstacles. The running courses have to be different,
various and unpredictable such as the distance between obstacles.
Another special feature of the OCR training are suspended obstacles in which the translocation
of the body from one point to another is carried out using mainly the grip of the hands or the
support of the feet on the same tools like rings or rope (fig. 2). Those kinds of obstacles are
generally called “Monkeys” (fig. 6 and fig. 7). This type of exercises strengthens the muscle
groups of the upper body which, together with running, it makes this sport one of the most
complete. The performance in this kind of PA is clearly situational because the athlete has to
adapt to new settings every time.
In class groups where this type of lesson has been carried out longer during the school year, it is
also possible to introduce the system of "burpees" when an obstacle is not overcome correctly.
A burpee is a powerful full body exercise divided in two phases: the push up and the jump.
Starting from a standing position the body has to do a push up in a plank position on the floor
followed by a vertical jump in the air with the hands over the head. Then the body has to return
back to the standing position (fig. 8). The number of burpees can vary from competition to
competition but above all, in the school context, the number must adapt to the age and physical
condition of the pupils.
500
Situation
________________________________________________________________________________
Figure 1 Climbing
Figure 2 Tyrolean Rope
Figure 3 Wire crawl
Figure 4 Wheel mat
Figure 5 Bucket carry
Figure 6 Monkey bar 1
501
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
________________________________________________________________________________
Figure 7 Monkey bar 2
Figure 8 Burpees
Figure 9 Balance beam
From a metabolic point of view, the burpees during OCR trainings are very useful to improve
the physical fitness levels of children and this system can also help to involve pupils in the class
who cannot take part in physical training with control and support roles.
Anyway, the rational and wise distribution of the obstacles in the track made by the PE teacher
generally help students to recover with short breaks between two obstacles, or eventually, from
the burpees.
During the experience of OCR training in schools, managing correctly energies by the students
during the track was thought through analysing the modulation of intensity of famous athletes
during their competitions and through simple practical tests during mini competitions in
schools.
Obstacle Course PE lesson at school
If well planned, an OCR path could be realized in a simple or in a more complex way in schools
using tools (chairs, hurdles, benches, poles, wall bars, etc.) and natural/artificial obstacles in and
outdoor (hedges, small hills, brooks or stairs, low walls, stair railings, etc.).
During PE lessons it is realizable the creation of obstacle courses associated with running laps
around the gym also organized as a race (Bellar, Hatchett, Judge, Breaux, & Marcus, 2015). If
the gym is large and there are lot of equipment, it is possible to prepare two similar routes to
avoid queues or two different routines for different levels of abilities.
These types of trainings, especially at school, are attractive even if they are not carried out in the
form of competition and, if done outdoor, they raise pupils' awareness of the local environment
heritage, increase their autonomy and self-esteem (Baghurst, Prewitt, & Tapps, 2019).
Conclusions
Due to the alarming data about the decrease of PA between students of all ages it is important
to look for new incentives outdoor. Nowadays the OCR project carried out by the Italian school
502
Situation
________________________________________________________________________________
showed that the motivation to be physically active was very strong during this unconventional
OCR course and the joy of over pass an obstacle activated every student at the most.
Becoming familiar with OCR techniques, the OCR course has also strengthened the courage in
facing more or less demanding obstacles and helped students to overcome everyone’s fears
developing personality as a whole.
Together with “standard” sport such volleyball, basketball, football, track and field, etc, OCR
has the ability to boost the health and well-being of students in a fun way, especially if it is
taught outdoor, re-evaluating the contact with the nature (Waite, 2011).
OCR training contributes to discover, learn, adapt and relearn motor skills to various tracks
proposed each time and lead to a new way of shaping the knowledge and engaging at the same
way children, youth and adults in the perception of the own body.
In the future, a more structured OCR program with contents organized in a taxonomic order
and a methodological planning divided for the different grades of school would be desirable, as
none of this already exists.
Moreover, an accurate and official description of tested obstacles would avoid improvisations by
PE teachers or instructors that could be sometimes dangerous for the pupils' safety. In the same
way, a specific preparation with OCR teacher training courses should be organized to share the
techniques of overcoming obstacles, the specific athletic preparation for develop running and
grip strengthens and to ensure the respect for safety measures. Those considerations would also
be appropriate for sports club’s instructors which often collaborate with schools during
extracurricular activities.
Finally, further active researches are envisaged with the used of pilot schools and illustrative
examples of good practices.
References
Baghurst T, Prewitt SL, Tapps T. (2019). Physiological demands of extreme obstacle course
racing: a case study. Int J Environ Res Public Health.;16(16):2879; doi:
10.3390/ijerph16162879.
Bellar D, Hatchett A, Judge LW, Breaux ME, Marcus L. (2015). The relationship of aerobic
capacity, anaerobic peak power and experience to performance in CrossFit exercise.
Biology of Sport. 32(4):315–320; doi: 10.5604/ 20831862.1174771.
Bortolotti, A. (2019). Outdoor Education. Storia, ambiti, metodi. Guerini e Associati.
Davis, J (2010) Young Children and the Environment: Early Education for Sustainability.
Cambridge University Press.
503
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
________________________________________________________________________________
Dern N. (2018). Why are obstacle-course races so popular? The Atlantic. Available from:
https://www. theatlantic.com/health/archive/2018/07/why-are-obstacle-course-racesso-popular/565130/.
Dexheimer JD, Schroeder ET, Sawyer BJ, Pettitt RW, Aguinaldo AL, Torrence WA. (2019).
Physiological performance measures as indicators of CrossFit® performance. Sports.
7(4):93; doi: 10.3390/sports7040093.
Macey, J., Brown, M, (2014). Coming Back to Life. New Society Publishers.
Mullins N. (2012). Obstacle course challenges: history, popularity, performance demands,
effective training, and course design. J Exercise Physiology Online.;15(2):100– 128.
Nicol, R. (2014) Entering the Fray: The role of outdoor education in providing nature-based
experiences that matter, Educational Philosophy and Theory, 46:5, 449-461,
DOI: 10.1111/j.1469-5812.2011.00840.x
Rawdon CL. (2016). Performance variables of obstacle course racing and recommendations for
programming in novice and intermediate competitors. Strength Cond J.; 38(5):1–17;
doi: 10.1519/SSC.0000000000000253.
Waite, S (2011) Children Learning Outside the Classroom: From Birth to Eleven. Sage.
504
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Physical Education and Physical Activities Attitude in the
Preservice Physical Education Teacher in Primary School for
Healthy Active Living Research
Stefania Cazzoli1 - Federico Abate Daga2
1
School of Exercise and Sport Sciences, and Department of Philosophy and Education Science, University of
Turin, Italy
2
Department of Clinical and Biological Sciences, University of Turin, Italy
e-mail: stefania.cazzoli@unito.it
Abstract
Background: The role of physical activity in enhancing health is well recognized. However,
physical activity rates are declining in more industrialized countries. To fight against this
phenomenon, institutions and organizations institute physical activity promotion projects in
primary schools to sensibilize children with physical activity. Thus, this study aimed to describe the
physical activity profile of a community of primary teaching students. Methods: Physical activity
was assessed using the official Italian short form of IPAQ, intended for digital use. Participation
was voluntary, and students could fill out the questionnaire simply by clicking on a specific link
received by email. Results: The final sample size was 168 primary teaching students, male and
female, with gender imbalance (86% female and 14% male). Analyzing the years of practice, 30%
of the participants did not practice any sport or activities. On the opposite, 21% started practising
from one to three years ago, 18% from four to seven years ago, 7% from seven to ten years ago
and 24% declared to have started more than ten years ago. In addition, data showed a percentage
of 13% of inactive subjects (MET<600), 54% of moderate active (MET 600-3000), and 33% of
active people (MET>3000). Finally, the more experienced showed a higher MET consumption
(p<0.001). Conclusions. Primary teaching students tend to be gender imbalanced and moderately
active. Future studies should investigate if this behaviour will positively reflect children's attitudes.
Key words: Physical education in primary school; Physical activity attitude; Healthy active living
505
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
The Benefits of an active lifestyle are nowadays well recognized by the World Health Organization
(WHO) (World Health Organization, 2010). The WHO promotes reaching a 150 min/week goal
of moderate-to-vigorous intensity physical activity such as walking, running, cycling, or swimming
to prevent cardiovascular diseases and comorbidities, improve immune system functions and
reduce the risk of infections.(Tofas et al., 2020; Jones & Davison, 2019; Warburton & Bredin,
2017). Not only adults but also children are recommended to move regularly. The Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention recommend 60 minutes or more of moderate-to-vigorous intensity
physical activity each day for children(Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2019). Children
practising regular physical activity have many benefits from school advantages to better healthrelated quality of life (Bermejo-Cantarero et al., 2017; Szabo-Reed et al., 2017).
However, in the major industrialized countries, physical activity rates seem to decline instead of
increase(Brownson, Boehmer, & Luke, 2005). A significant study on the population of leading
European countries revealed that sedentary behaviour increased by 8% in the last two decades
(López-Valenciano et al., 2020). This trend is alarming when considering the dangerous
consequences on the health of physical inactivity. To fight against this phenomenon, institutions
and organizations institute physical activity promotion projects in primary schools to sensibilize
children with the practice of physical activity (Smedegaard, Christiansen, Lund-Cramer, Bredahl,
& Skovgaard, 2016). Nevertheless, the efficacy of interventions is usually related to the intensity of
project actors' beliefs. Thus, teachers' verbal and nonverbal behaviours related to physical
education may affect children's approach to physical activity(Brey & Pauker, 2019).
The easiest way to understand if a teacher is positively or negatively oriented to physical activities
consists in investigating their lifestyle and rate of physical activity. An excellent tool to analyze the
physical activity rate in a large population is the International Physical Activity Questionnaire
(IPAQ). It was developed by various researchers from different countries, with support from the
World Health Organization (WHO) and the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
(CDC). (Craig et al., 2003)(Lee, Macfarlane, Lam, & Stewart, 2011a) IPAQ's unique feature is that
it assesses all believed health-related physical activities that can take place in different settings. Thus,
it is an appropriate tool to evaluate the practice of physical activity. Therefore, the purpose of this
study was to describe the physical activity profile of a community of primary teaching students
using the short version of IPAQ(Lee, Macfarlane, Lam, & Stewart, 2011b) intended for digital use.
Research Question
Are our primary school future teachers physically active? A description of the physical activity rate
in primary school teaching students using the International Physical Activity Questionnaire
Materials and methods
506
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Study design and ethical considerations
This descriptive study reports data gathered between October 2021 and March 2022 using an online
survey. The online questionnaire was created using the Google online survey platform (Google
LLC; Mountain View, CA, USA). The link to the survey was sent to the participants via email.
According to the manufacturer's privacy policy (https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=it), all
answers were anonymous and confidential. This form was IP address case sensitive; therefore,
nobody could submit another questionnaire from the same IP address once completed. Participants
could abort or leave the questionnaire before the submission process. Participants had to submit
the form by clicking on the "submit" button, and a message with the sentence "The survey was
successfully submitted. Thank you for participating" would appear. Unsubmitted questionnaires were not
saved and not included in the database
Participants
Participants were recruited among fourth years students of the primary teacher education faculty
of the University of Turin. Inclusion criteria were as follow: a) be registered at the University of
Turin; b) attend the fourth year of primary teacher education; c) attend the course of physical
education methodology. Therefore, Erasmus students, students not attending the fourth year of
the primary teacher education faculty and the course of physical education methodology were
excluded from this survey.
Three hundred and thirty subjects filled out the questionnaire. However, 162 answers have been
rejected because participants did not meet the inclusion criteria. The remaining 168 answers were
considered acceptable for further analysis.
Outcome measures
The questionnaire included an introductory section with the background, the purpose of the study,
and the anonymity and confidentiality declarations. At the end of this section, participants were
asked to provide informed consent to participate in the survey. The questionnaire would not begin
if the participants did not provide informed consent.
In the first section, the following demographic information was collected: gender, date of birth,
body height, body weight, year of attendance, sport practised (if any), and years of practice (if any).
The second section of the survey included the Italian version of the International Physical Activity
Questionnaire - Short Form (IPAQ-SF) (Minetto et al., 2018). The IPAQ-SF is a self-reported
assessment of the time spent at different physical activity intensities in four domains: (1) work, (2)
transport, (3) domestic and gardening, and (4) leisure time during the last seven days. This tool
categorizes the levels of physical activity as low, moderate, and vigorous (days/week, hours, and
minutes per day) and records daily sitting time. From these values, it is possible to calculate the
total amount and intensity of physical activities per week in terms of Metabolic Equivalent Tasks
(MET), according to the following formulae: low activity (walking) = (3.3 x walking minutes x
507
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
walking days); moderate activity = (4.0 x moderate activity minutes x moderate activity days);
vigorous exercise = (8.0 x vigorous activity minutes x vigorous activity days (www.ipaq.ki.se).
Outcomes were classified into three categories: inactive (< 600 MET-min/w), moderately active
(600-3000 MET-min/w) and active (> 3000 MET-min/w), according to the scoring system
provided by IPAQ (Craig et al., 2003).
Statistical Analysis
Data were exported from the online forms to a Microsoft Excel spreadsheet and checked for
outliers according to IPAQ guidelines (www.ipaq.ki.se). All data were analyzed using SPSS, version
19.0 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA). Questionnaires that did not meet the inclusion criteria were
not considered for further analysis.
Descriptive statistics ((mean and standard deviation (SD)) and count and percentage were used to
present demographic data and levels of physical activity (low, moderate or vigorous). In addition,
an unpaired T-Test was used to assess differences in MET consumption between groups
considering years of practice in sports or activities for fitness and health.
Results
Participants' anthropometric characteristics are represented in Table 1.
Mean age is 25±5 years, mean height 170±7,44 cm, mean weight 59,70±10,57 kg and mean BMI
21,2± 3,05 kg/m2. Spitting for gender, males showed a mean age of 26±8 years, mean height
177±6,87 cm, mean weight 71,23±9,37 kg and mean BMI 22,81±2,09 kg/m2. On the opposite,
females show a mean age of 24±6 years, mean height of 166±6,40 cm, mean weight of 57,76±9,45
kg and mean BMI of 20,96±3,10 kg/m2. Participants' gender analysis showed a significant
imbalance between females (86%) and males (14%) (Table 1).
Regarding physical activity, 30% of the participants declared not to practice any sport or activities
for fitness and wellness. However, the remaining 70% reported practising sports or activities for
fitness and health, and they started to participate in physical conditioning from one to three years
ago (21%), from four to seven years ago (18%), from seven to ten years ago (7 %). Finally, 24%
declared to have started more than ten years ago (Table 1).
IPAQ outcomes are shown in Figure 3. We detected a percentage of 13% of inactive subjects
(MET<600), 54% of moderate active (MET 600-3000), and 33% of active people (MET>3000)
(Figure 1). In addition, a significant difference in MET consumption was observed considering
years of practice in sports or activities for fitness and health (P<0.001; do not practice or practice
less than three years versus more than four years) (Figure 2).
508
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Table 1 Representation of sociodemographic variables. We collected gender, age, Body Mass Index
(BMI), practised sport (if any), and the related years of practice. Data are represented with Meand
± SD and per centage (%)
Total sample (n = 168)
Sex
Number
%
Age
Height (cm)
Weight (kg)
BMI (kg/m2)
Male
Female
24
144
14
86
26±8
24±6
177±6,87
166±6,40
71,23±9,37
57,76±9,45
22,81±2,09
20,96±3,10
Sport
Practice
Yes
No
Number
%
114
54
70%
30%
Years of
practice
0
1--3
4-7
7-10
10+
Number
%
51
36
30
11
40
30
21
18
7
24
Discussion
This study aimed to describe the rate of physical activity in a community of future primary school
teachers. IPAQ was massively used to obtain data on the rate of physical activity due to its versatility
in submission and ease in data acquisition (Al-Hazzaa, 2007; Pedro Curi Hallal, Victora, Wells, &
Lima, 2003; Saran, Owoc, & Bojar, 2018). For this reason, it was utilized to assess the rate of
physical activity in a large group of subjects. Firstly, this study shows that the population is pretty
young (age 25±5 years, height 170±7,44 cm, weight 59,70±10,57 kg and BMI 21,2± 3,05 kg/m 2),
and the gender prevalence is female (84%). This outcome agrees with the Organisation for
Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD). This organization affirmed that there had
been a feminization of the teaching profession in all industrialized countries (OECD, 2016). In
addition, several studies conducted on teachers' communities in different countries showed a
systematical prevalence of females than males in their sample (Boström et al., 2020; Kreuzfeld &
Seibt, 2022; Orejudo, Navarro, Vicente, & Cardoso, 2020). Therefore, this trend is also identified
in the primary teaching faculty where females are prevalent and might be a sort of influence due to
gender imbalance in the teaching profession.
Level of physical activity
Inactive
13%
Active
33%
Moderate
Active
54%
Inactive
Moderate Active
Active
Figure 1 Physical activity rate using IPAQ. 13% of the responders are inactive,
54% moderately active and 33% active.
509
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Figure 2 Representation of MET consumption among groups related to years of practice in
sport or activities for fitness and wellness. Responders with more experience consume
more MET a week than the less experienced (p<0,001; no experience or less than three
versus more than four years of practice).
Secondly, this study shows that just over half of the population reached by this survey declared to
be moderately active (54%). Thus, people were moderate-active for at least 30 minutes or more a
day, five days a week. Besides, the inactive population was 13%, while the active or very active part
was 33%. These outcomes are interesting because they show a partial inversion of the alarming
trend of a sedentary style in industrialized countries (Brownson et al., 2005). In addition, women
are generally less active than men since childhood (Telford, Telford, Olive, Cochrane, & Davey,
2016; Trost et al., 2002). This behaviour belongs to psychosocial and cultural variables(Edwards &
Sackett, 2016) that lead women to be less engaged in physical activity programs. This fact is
probably related to women being more engaged in the household than men (Cerrato & Cifre, 2018).
Therefore, having a prevalence of moderate active or active people in a gender-imbalanced
population is encouraging for a future inversion of this trend. However, this study was conducted
on students, and tendentially young people are more active than adults or the elderly (Hallal et al.,
2012). Therefore, future studies should investigate the rate of physical activity in professional
primary teachers' communities to understand better the role of activities for fitness and health in
these gender-imbalanced populations.
Furthermore, responders had to indicate how many years of experience they had in their training
program. Outcomes showed that 30% did not practise regular training programs. 21% had less
than three years of experience, 18% had from four to seven,7% from seven to ten years of
experience, and 24% had more than ten years. In addition, this study identified that the more
experienced (4 years of experience or more) spent more significant time in training and consumed
a higher amount of energy than the less experienced. Physical activity produces many benefic
510
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
effects on the body and mind and generates a wellness state that positively affects people's lifestyles
(Fox, 1999; Heijnen, Hommel, Kibele, & Colzato, 2016). Therefore, those who used to exercise
regularly internalize it and feel it as an essential need. Thus, they may be more inclined to share the
importance of practising regular exercise. If this attitude belongs to teachers, they will reflect on
their students (Trigueros, García-Tascón, Gallardo, Alías, & Aguilar-Parra, 2020).
Finally, the present study is subject to the following limitations. First, this report used the short
form of IPAQ submitted by email. Thus, as with any questionnaire, the respondents could have
suffered from multiple link sending or internet connection problems. Secondly, the sample in the
present study was recruited only among students belonging to the University of Turin. Thus, the
sample size was limited to this community. Therefore, a more significant sample may be necessary
to describe better this scenario.
Conclusion
The present study's findings underline that a moderately active lifestyle is more consistent in
primary teaching students. Also, responders with more than four years of experience in physical
activities for fitness and wellness spent more time in training and consumed more energy.
Therefore, an active lifestyle starts gaining consideration among primary teaching students.
However, future studies among primary teachers and primary teaching students are necessary to
investigate if this behaviour will positively reflect children's attitudes.
References
Al-Hazzaa, H. M. (2007). Health-enhancing physical activity among Saudi adults using the
International Physical Activity Questionnaire (IPAQ). Public Health Nutrition, 10(1), 59–64.
Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1017/S1368980007184299
Bermejo-Cantarero, A., Álvarez-Bueno, C., Martinez-Vizcaino, V., García-Hermoso, A., Isabel
Torres-Costoso, A., & Sánchez-López, M. (2017). Association between physical activity,
sedentary behavior, and fitness with health-related quality of life in healthy children and
adolescents: A protocol for a systematic review and meta-analysis. Medicine (United States).
Lippincott Williams and Wilkins. Retrieved from
https://doi.org/10.1097/MD.0000000000006407
Boström, M., Björklund, C., Bergström, G., Nybergh, L., Elinder, L. S., Stigmar, K., … Kwak, L.
(2020). Health and work environment among female and male swedish elementary school
teachers—A cross-sectional study. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public
Health, 17(1). Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph17010227
Brey, E., & Pauker, K. (2019). Teachers’ nonverbal behaviors influence children’s stereotypic
beliefs. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 188. Retrieved from
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jecp.2019.104671
511
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Brownson, R. C., Boehmer, T. K., & Luke, D. A. (2005). DECLINING RATES OF PHYSICAL
ACTIVITY IN THE UNITED STATES: What Are the Contributors? Annual Review of Public
Health, 26(1), 421–443. Retrieved from
https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.publhealth.26.021304.144437
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2019). FrameworkGraphicV9.
Cerrato, J., & Cifre, E. (2018). Gender inequality in household chores and work-family conflict.
Frontiers in Psychology, 9(AUG), 1–11. Retrieved from
https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2018.01330
Craig, C. L., Marshall, A. L., Sjöström, M., Bauman, A. E., Booth, M. L., Ainsworth, B. E., … Oja,
P. (2003). International physical activity questionnaire: 12-Country reliability and validity.
Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 35(8), 1381–1395. Retrieved from
https://doi.org/10.1249/01.MSS.0000078924.61453.FB
Edwards, E. S., & Sackett, S. C. (2016). Psychosocial Variables Related to Why Women are Less
Active than Men and Related Health Implications. Clinical Medicine Insights: Women’s Health,
9s1, CMWH.S34668. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.4137/cmwh.s34668
Fox, K. (1999). The influence of physical activity on mental well-being. Public Health Nutrition, 2(3a),
411–418. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1017/s1743921307004425
Hallal, Pedro C., Andersen, L. B., Bull, F. C., Guthold, R., Haskell, W., Ekelund, U., … Wells, J.
C. (2012). Global physical activity levels: Surveillance progress, pitfalls, and prospects. The
Lancet, 380(9838), 247–257. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(12)606461
Hallal, Pedro Curi, Victora, C. G., Wells, J. C. K., & Lima, R. C. (2003). Physical Inactivity:
Prevalence and Associated Variables in Brazilian Adults. Medicine and Science in Sports and
Exercise, 35(11), 1894–1900. Retrieved from
https://doi.org/10.1249/01.MSS.0000093615.33774.0E
Heijnen, S., Hommel, B., Kibele, A., & Colzato, L. S. (2016). Neuromodulation of aerobic exerciseA review. Frontiers in Psychology, 6(JAN), 1–6. Retrieved from
https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2015.01890
Kreuzfeld, S., & Seibt, R. (2022). Gender-Specific Aspects of Teachers Regarding Working
Behavior and Early Retirement. Frontiers in Psychology, 13. Retrieved from
https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2022.829333
Lee, P. H., Macfarlane, D. J., Lam, T. H., & Stewart, S. M. (2011a). Validity of the international
physical activity questionnaire short form (IPAQ-SF): A systematic review. International
Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity, 8, 1–11. Retrieved from
https://doi.org/10.1186/1479-5868-8-115
Lee, P. H., Macfarlane, D. J., Lam, T., & Stewart, S. M. (2011b). Validity of the international
physical activity questionnaire short form. International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical
Activity, 8(115), 1–11.
López-Valenciano, A., Mayo, X., Liguori, G., Copeland, R. J., Lamb, M., & Jimenez, A. (2020).
Changes in sedentary behaviour in European Union adults between 2002 and 2017. BMC
Public Health, 20(1). Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-020-09293-1
512
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Minetto, M. A., Motta, G., Gorji, N. E., Lucini, D., Biolo, G., Pigozzi, F., … Maffiuletti, N. A.
(2018). Reproducibility and validity of the Italian version of the International Physical
Activity Questionnaire in obese and diabetic patients. Journal of Endocrinological Investigation,
41(3), 343–349. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1007/s40618-017-0746-3
OECD. (2016). Education at a Glance 2016. OECD. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1787/eag2016-en
Orejudo, S., Navarro, J. J., Vicente, E., & Cardoso, M. J. (2020). Student misbehaviour and teacher
coercion. A comparative study of contextual factors in primary and secondary education
teachers. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 17(24), 1–19. Retrieved
from https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph17249429
Saran, T., Owoc, J., & Bojar, I. (2018). Use of the ipaq questionnaire in the form of a mobile
application in monitoring physical activity of patients with cardiovascular diseases. Annals of
Agricultural and Environmental Medicine, 25(3), 395–402. Retrieved from
https://doi.org/10.26444/aaem/75704
Smedegaard, S., Christiansen, L. B., Lund-Cramer, P., Bredahl, T., & Skovgaard, T. (2016).
Improving the well-being of children and youths: a randomized multicomponent, schoolbased, physical activity intervention. BMC Public Health, 16(1), 1–11. Retrieved from
https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-016-3794-2
Szabo-Reed, A. N., Hillman, C. H., Greene, J. L., Hansen, D. M., Gibson, C. A., Sullivan, D. K.,
… Washburn, R. A. (2017). Physical activity and academic achievement across the
curriculum: Results from a 3-year cluster-randomized trial. Preventive Medicine, 99, 140–145.
Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ypmed.2017.02.006
Telford, R. M., Telford, R. D., Olive, L. S., Cochrane, T., & Davey, R. (2016). Why are girls less
physically active than boys? Findings from the LOOK longitudinal study. PLoS ONE, 11(3),
1–11. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0150041
Tofas, T., Draganidis, D., Deli, C. K., Georgakouli, K., Fatouros, I. G., & Jamurtas, A. Z. (2020).
Exercise-induced regulation of redox status in cardiovascular diseases: The role of exercise
training and detraining. Antioxidants, 9(1), 1–41. Retrieved from
https://doi.org/10.3390/antiox9010013
Trigueros, R., García-Tascón, M., Gallardo, A. M., Alías, A., & Aguilar-Parra, J. M. (2020). The
influence of the teacher’s prosocial skills on the mindwandering, creative intelligence,
emotions, and academic performance of secondary students in the area of physical education
classes. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 17(4). Retrieved from
https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph17041437
Trost, S. G., Pate, R. R., Sallis, J. F., Freedson, P. S., Taylor, W. C., Dowda, M., & Sirard, J. (2002).
Age and gender differences in objectively measured physical activity in youth. Medicine and
Science in Sports and Exercise, 34(2), 350–355. Retrieved from
https://doi.org/10.1097/00005768-200202000-00025
Warburton, D. E. R., & Bredin, S. S. D. (2017). Health benefits of physical activity: A systematic
review of current systematic reviews. Current Opinion in Cardiology, 32(5), 541–556. Retrieved
from https://doi.org/10.1097/HCO.0000000000000437
World Health Organization. (2010). Global recommendations on physical activity for health. World
Health Organization, 58.
513
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
514
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
French Articles
515
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
516
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Influencée de l´angle cuisse-tronc sur la mobilité de la chaine
posturale
Djiby Guissé Diakhate - 2Mohamed Mansourou Lawani - 2Gratien Houeto 3
Djibril Seck
1
Université Gaston Berger, Saint-Louis, Sénégal
Unité de Recherche en Biomécanique et Performance INJEPS – UAC, Benin
3
Institut National Supérieur de l’Eduction Populaire et du Sport, Dakar, Sénégal
e-mail: djibril1.seck@ucad.edu.sn
1
2
Resumé
Cette étude a pour objectif d’analyser le rôle que joue l’angle articulaire cuisse-tronc dans la mobilité
du corps. Il a été démontré dans des études antérieures, que la réduction de la surface de contact
ischio-fémoral avec l’assise favorisait une performance dans des tâches exécutées en position assise,
Lino et Bouisset (1993) ; Goutal et al. (1994) ; Bouisset et al. (2002) ; Le Bozec et al. (2004). Deux
conditions d’assise (100-IFC et 30-IFC) et deux conditions d’angle cuisse-tronc (C-T) (45° ou 0°)
ont été étudiées. La diminution de la surface de contact ischio-fémorale de 100-IFC à 30-IFC
combinée à la modification de l’angle cuisse tronc favorise une performance plus élevée dans la
condition 30-IFC à 45° comparée aux autres conditions.
Mots clés : Mobilité articulaire, Surface de contact ischio-fémoral, Flexion du tronc, Performance
517
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
Il a été montré que la réduction de l’aire de contact ischio-fémoral avec l’assise favorisait la
performance. Les études antérieures de Lino et al. (1992), sur une tâche de pointage, Lino et
Bouisset (1993) ; Goutal et al. (1994) ; Bouisset et al. (2002) ; Le Bozec et al. (2004), de Diakhaté et
al. (2013) sur le Sit-to-Stand (StS) et celle plus récente de Diakhaté et al. (2014) sur une tâche de
poussée l’ont tous montré. L’augmentation de la mobilité du bassin est observée dans des tâches
exécutées aussi bien en position statique qu’en dynamique. L’augmentation de la mobilité du bassin
améliore la performance dans des tâches exécutées en position assise. Les auteurs ont lié ces
résultats à une modification de la mobilité du pelvis quand l’aire de contact ischio-fémoral avec
l’assise est réduite.
Cependant, aucune de ces études n’a mis en évidence l’interaction qu’il y a entre le tronc et les
cuisses, quand l’angle cuisses-tronc (C-T) est modifié, sur la mobilité du bassin et du rachis. C’est
ce que nous allons tenter de démontrer dans cette étude.La modification de l’angle C-T changeraitelle la mobilité du bassin et du rachis. En effet, plus cet angle est fermé, plus la mobilité de l’un et
de l’autre diminuent, même si la surface de contact ischio-fémoral a été réduite.
Même si la diminution de la surface de contact ischio-fémorale augmente la mobilité du corps. Estelle la seule à influencer la mobilité articulaire ?
Cette étude a pour objectif principal d’analyser le rôle que joue l’angle articulaire cuisse-tronc (CT) dans la mobilité du corps. En d’autres termes, de regarder comment la position articulaire de la
hanche influe sur la performance. La modification de l’angle C-T sur la mobilité du corps a donc
été étudiée. La démarche consistera à faire varier l’angle C-T au cours d’une tâche de sit-to-stand
avec des surfaces de contact ischio-fémorale de 100-IFC et de 30-IFC.
Materiel et méthode
Sujet
Pour cette étude, nous avons testé 8 sujets masculins ne souffrant d’aucune pathologie musculosquelettique et sensori-motrice. Tous les sujets étaient consentants et informés des objectifs de
l’étude. Cette étude a été menée conformément à la déclaration d’Helsinki.
Matériel
Pour ce travail, nous avons utilisé une plateforme de force rectangulaire de (120 x 60) cm et d’un
équipement en bois placé à côté de la plateforme qui nous permettait d’avoir un angle de 45 ° par
rapport à la verticale. C’est un dispositif qui permet de placer le siège de force sur la plateforme de
force, permettant ainsi de découpler les efforts verticaux au niveau du siège, des forces extérieures
agissant sur le corps qui sont mesurées par la plateforme de force. La hauteur du siège est ajustable
à la taille du sujet par un ajout de planche en bois. Cette adjonction est prise en compte dans
518
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
l’initialisation des capteurs avant chaque expérience. L’équipement en bois permettait au sujet
d’aligner son tronc par rapport à la planche pour avoir un angle de 45 ° entre son tronc et ses
cuisses. Le siège consiste en un carré en bois de 65 cm de côté solidaire d’un cadre métallique
supporté par 3 pieds. Un capteur de force à jauge de contrainte travaillant en traction /
compression, mesurant dans une gamme de 10 daN à 50 KN, est monté à chaque extrémité basse
des pieds. A l’extrémité de chaque pied, une pointe métallique assure la bonne adhérence du siège
sur le plateau afin qu’il n’y ait aucun mouvement relatif pendant l’exécution des séquences de levée,
même pour les vitesses très élevées. (Son emplacement sur la plateforme est variable en fonction
de la morphologie du sujet, et reste identique pour la même série d’essai, car systématiquement
vérifié.
Protocole
Les sujets étaient assis sur le siège capteur de force, en posture inclinée à 45° ou 0° (c'est-à-dire,
l’angle C-T fait soit 45°, soit 0°). Pour obtenir la posture à 45°, les sujets devaient aligner leurs
troncs sur une structure en bois placée à 45° par rapport à l’horizontal. Les bras sont collés au
corps et placés sur le dos du sujet pour éviter des oscillations pendant et à la fin du mouvement.
L’écartement des pieds est de 30 cm, et sont placés à 15 cm du bord de la plateforme de force à
l’aide de marquages, un au niveau du talon l’autre sur la plateforme de force.
Au signal de départ, le sujet devait se lever à la vitesse qu’on lui avait indiquée au départ. La durée
des acquisitions était de 5 secondes, avec une fréquence de 250 hz. L’enregistrement des données
commençait quelques secondes avant l’action de se lever et se terminait quelques secondes après le
lever du siège. Le nombre d’essai par condition est de 10, ce qui faisait au total 40 essais par sujet
pour les 4 conditions. L’ordre de passage dans les quatre conditions est fait de manière aléatoire,
pour éviter l’effet de rang. La position des talons est identique pour tous les sujets. Deux conditions
posturales sont considérées; assise sur toute la longueur fesses-cuisses (100-IFC) et assise sur 30 %
de cette longueur (30-IFC) Ces deux conditions d’appui présentent le même polygone de
sustentation, seule varie l’aire de contact avec l’assise (figure 1). Tous les sujets portaient le même
short au moment des deux expériences.
Résultats
Les résultats ont permis de mettre en évidence l’importance de la mobilité articulaire dans la
performance motrice. En effet, une modification de l’aire de contact ischio-fémoral couplée à une
variation de l’angle C-T entrainent une modification des variations de performance. Nous nous
intéresserons aux forces de réactions générées par la plateforme de force.
Détermination de la performance
Nous comparerons les caractéristiques cinématiques de la performance (vitesse et accélérations du
centre de gravité) suivant les axes antéropostérieur et vertical, ainsi que l’instant du décollement
des fesses.
519
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Siège
45 °
30-IFC
45 °
Siège
Siège
P lateforme
d e fo rc e
45 °
100-IFC
45 °
Siège
30-IFC
0°
P lateforme
d e fo rc e
100-IFC
0°
Figure 1 Conditions d’assise à 100-IFC 0 et 45°, et condition d’assise à 30-IFC 0 et 45°
30-IFC : 30 % de contact ischio-fémoral avec l’assise
100-IFC : 100 % de contact ischio-fémoral avec l’assise
0° : Angle formé par les cuisses et le tronc est de zéro degré
45° : Angle formé par les cuisses et le tronc est de quarante-cinq degrés
Les accélérations (Az et Ax), les vitesses (Vz et Vx), le long des axes verticaux et antéropostérieurs ;
la vitesse antéropostérieure au moment du décollement des fesses (Vxdf), la durée nécessaire pour
le décollement des fesses (DF) ainsi que le recul du centre des pressions (Xp) suivant l’axe
antéropostérieur ont été relevés (figures 2, 3, 4, 5).
520
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
T0
DF
8
Az (m/s2)
4
0
-4
-8
1,6
Vz (m/s)
1,2
0,8
0,4
0,0
Ax (m/s2)
2
1
0
-1
Vx (m/s)
0,3
0,2
0,1
0,0
0,4
Xp (m)
0,3
0,2
0,1
0,0
-0,1
-0,2
0,0
0,2
0,4
0,6
0,8
1,0
1,2
1,4
Temps (s)
Figure 2 Tracés biomécaniques du sit-to-stand à 0° et 100 % d’assise pour un sujet et pour un essai
Az, Vz, accélération et vitesses verticales du centre de gravité ; Ax, Vx, accélération et vitesse
antéropostérieure du centre de gravité ; Xp déplacement du centre des pressions, la ligne en
pointillée indique le début du mouvement et la ligne en tiret indique le décollement des fesses (DF).
8
T0
DF
Az (m/s2)
4
0
-4
-8
1,2
0,8
Vz (m/s)
0,4
0,0
3
2
2
Ax (m/s )
1
0
-1
-2
-3
0,8
0,6
0,4
Vx (m/s)
0,2
0,0
0,4
Xp (m)
0,2
0,0
-0,2
-0,2
0,0
0,2
0,4
0,6
0,8
1,0
1,2
1,4
Temps (s)
Figure 3 Tracés biomécaniques du sit-to-stand à 45 ° et 100 % d’assise pour un sujet et
pour un essai
Az, Vz, accélération et vitesses verticales du centre de gravité ; Ax, Vx, accélération et vitesse
antéropostérieure du centre de gravité ; Xp déplacement du centre des pressions, la ligne en
pointillée indique le début du mouvement et la ligne en tiret indique le décollement des fesses (DF).
521
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
DF
T0
8
2
Az (m/s )
4
0
-4
-8
1,6
1,2
Vz (m/s)
0,8
0,4
0,0
1
2
Ax (m/s )
2
0
-1
-2
0,4
0,3
Vx (m/s)
0,2
0,1
0,0
0,2
Xp (m)
0,1
0,0
-0,1
-0,2
0,0
0,2
0,4
0,6
0,8
1,0
1,2
1,4
Temps (s)
Figure 4 Tracés biomécaniques à 0 ° et 30 % d’assise pour un sujet et pour un essai
Az, Vz, accélération et vitesses verticales du centre de gravité ; Ax, Vx, accélération et vitesse
antéropostérieure du centre de gravité ; Xp déplacement du centre des pressions, la ligne en
pointillée indique le début du mouvement et la ligne en tiret indique le décollement des fesses (DF).
T0
DF
8
Az (m/s2)
4
0
-4
-8
1,6
1,2
0,8
Vz (m/s)
0,4
0,0
Ax (m/s2)
4
2
0
-2
0,6
0,4
Vx (m/s)
0,2
0,0
0,3
0,2
Xp (m)
0,1
0,0
-0,1
-0,2
0,0
0,2
0,4
0,6
0,8
1,0
1,2
1,4
Temps (s)
Figure 5 Tracés biomécaniques du sit-to-stand à 45 ° et 30 % d’assise pour un essai
Az, Vz, accélération et vitesses verticales du centre de gravité ; Ax, Vx, accélération et vitesse
antéropostérieure du centre de gravité ; Xp déplacement du centre des pressions, la ligne en
pointillée indique le début du mouvement et la ligne en tiret indique le décollement des fesses (DF).
522
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Ces figures montrent des variations des tracés biomécaniques, qui sont reproductibles d’un sujet à
un autre et d’un essai à l’autre. Les allures générales des courbes sont identiques avec des amplitudes
différentes selon les conditions des essais. Le début du mouvement symbolisé par la ligne en
pointillés commence par un recul du centre des pressions suivi au même instant d’une
augmentation de l’accélération antéropostérieure pour atteindre son pic avant de décliner pour
atteindre des valeurs négatives, avant de revenir sur la ligne de base. On note une cupule négative
suivant l’axe vertical au début du mouvement, mais elle est moins importante dans la condition
d’inclinaison du tronc à 45° et presque inexistante dans la condition 0°.
L’accélération antéropostérieure atteint son pic avant de redescendre à son minimum qui coïncide
avec le maximum de l’accélération verticale. Les pics des vitesses verticales et antéropostérieures
sont atteints au moment où les accélérations verticales et antéropostérieures changent de signe.
L’instant du décollement des fesses survient peu de temps après le pic de l’accélération verticale.
Tous ces paramètres reviennent à leurs valeurs initiales sauf pour la valeur du centre des pressions
du fait du changement de posture. Le sujet n’étant plus assis, mais debout.
Accélérations verticales et antéropostérieures du centre de gravité
Accélération verticale
L’accélération verticale maximale dans la condition 0° est de 5 m/s 2 à 100-IFC et 5,16 m/s2 à 30IFC (figures 2,3 et tableau 1), alors que dans la condition 45 °, elle vaut respectivement 5,31 m/s 2
et 5,71 m/s2 (figures 4, 5 et tableau 2). Dans la première condition, l’analyse de la variance montre
qu’il n’y a pas de différence significative (F(1,7) = 3,02 ; p > 0,5), tandis que dans la deuxième
condition, l’analyse de la variance montre une différence très significative (F(1,7) = 12,77 ; p <
0,01).
Accélération antéropostérieure
Suivant l’axe antéropostérieur, l’accélération vaut respectivement dans la condition 0° 2,32 m/s2 et
2,49 m/s2 respectivement à 100-IFC et 30-IFC (tableau 1). L’analyse de la variance montre une
différence non significative avec un effet courant (F(1,7) = 2,89 ; p > 0,5). Dans la condition 45 °,
l’accélération antéropostérieure est de 2,69 m/s2 à 100-IFC et de 3,29 m/s2 à 30-IFC (tableau 2).
Cette différence est hautement significative avec un effet courant (F(1,7) = 38,47 ; p < 0,001).
Vitesse verticale et antéropostérieure du centre de gravité
Vitesse verticale
La vitesse maximale atteinte lors du StS est l’un des critères de la performance. Elle est dans la
condition 0° de 1,03 m/s et 1,12 m/s respectivement à 100-IFC et 30-IFC pour un effet courant
(F(1,7) = 2,32 ; p > 0,5) (tableau 1) donc statistiquement pas significatif. Mais dans la condition 45
523
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
°, cette vitesse est égale à 1,08 m/s à 100-IFC et 1,24 m/s à 30-IFC (tableau 2) pour un effet courant
(F(1,7) = 7,42 ; p < 0,05). Le résultat montre une différence significative.
Vitesse antéropostérieure
Suivant l’axe antéropostérieure, la vitesse est de 0,44 m/s à 100-IFC et 0,32 m/s à 30-IFC dans la
condition 0°. L’ANOVA montre une différence pas significative avec un effet courant (F(1,7) =
1,29 ; p > 0,5) (tableau 1). Alors que dans la condition 45°, l’analyse de la variance montre une
différence significative avec un effet courant (F(1,7) = 9,06 ; p < 0,01) (tableau 2).
Déplacement du centre des pressions
Le déplacement du centre des pressions a été relevé suivant l’axe antéropostérieur. Le recul du
centre des pressions est de 9 cm à 100-IFC et 11 cm à 30-IFC dans la condition 0°. On note une
différence non significative d’après l’analyse de la variance (F(1,7) = 1,84 ; p > 0,5). Concernant la
condition 45 °, le recul du centre des pressions à 100-IFC est de 14 cm et à 30-IFC de 23 cm avec
une différence hautement significative (F(1,7) = 61,122 ; p < 0,001).
Durée nécessaire pour le décollement des fesses.
La durée nécessaire pour le décollement des fesses est beaucoup plus courte à 30-IFC qu’à 100IFC dans la condition 0°. Elle est respectivement de 340 ms et 430 ms, une différence hautement
significative, avec un effet courant (F(1,7) = 46,87 ; p < 0,001). Quant à la condition 45 °, cette
durée est de 500 ms et 370 ms respectivement pour 100-IFC et 30-IFC. On note une différence
statistique très significative comme dans la condition 0°. L’analyse de la variance donne ses résultats
(F(1,7) = 35,47 ; p = 0,001).
Tableau 1 Moyenne et écart-type des différents paramètres relevés dans le sit-to-stand (StS) à 0°
100-IFC 0°
30-IFC 0°
P
Azsts(m/s2)
5,00 (±2,27)
5,16 (±2,55)
Ns
Vzsts (m/s)
1,03 (±0,38)
1,12 (±0,28)
Ns
Axsts (m/s2)
2,32 (±0,73)
2,49 (±0,88)
Ns
Vxsts (m/s)
Vxdf (m/s)
Xpsts (m)
DF (ms)
0,44 (±0,34)
0,33 (±0,17)
-0,09 (±0,03)
430 (±70)
0,32 (±0,06)
0,30 (±0,06)
-0,11 (±0,02)
340 (±70)
Ns
Ns
Ns
**
Pic vertical (Azsts) de l’accélération du centre de gravité et de sa vitesse (Vzsts) ; pic antéropostérieur
de l’accélération du centre de gravité (Axsts) et de sa vitesse (Vxsts) ; Vxdf, vitesse antéropostérieure
au moment du décollement des fesses ; Xpsts, recul maximum du centre des pressions ; DF, durée
524
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
nécessaire pour le décollement des fesses ; ms : millisecondes. P : Probabilité ; ** P < 0,01 ; ns :
non significatif.
Tableau 2 Moyenne et écart-type des différents paramètres relevés dans le sit-to-stand (StS) à 45°
100-IFC 45°
30-IFC 45°
P
Azsts(m/s2)
5,31 (±2,46)
5,71 (±2,55)
**
Vzsts (m/s)
Axsts (m/s2)
Vxsts (m/s)
Vxdf (m/s)
Xpsts (m)
1,08 (±0,28)
2,69 (±0,72)
0,53 (±0,23)
0,38 (±0,11)
-0,14 (±0,02)
1,24 (±0,23)
3,29 (±0,82)
0,64 (±0,19)
0,45 (±0,11)
-0,23 (±0,07)
*
***
*
Ns
***
DF (ms)
500 (±70)
370 (±50)
***
Pic vertical (Azsts ) de l’accélération du centre de gravité et de sa vitesse (Vzsts) ; pic antéropostérieur
de l’accélération du centre de gravité (Axsts) et de sa vitesse (Vxsts) ; Vxdf, vitesse antéropostérieure
au moment du décollement des fesses ; Xpsts, recul maximum du centre des pressions, DF, durée
nécessaire pour le décollement des fesses ; ms : millisecondes ; P : Probabilité ; * : p < 0,05 ; ** P
< 0,01 ; *** : p < 0,001 ; ns : non significatif.
Discussion
Les résultats montrent que la modification de l’aire de contact ischio-fémoral associé à une
modification de l’angle articulaire entre le tronc et les cuisses a une influence sur la performance
dans la tâche de StS. En effet, dans la condition 0°, on ne note pas de différence significative pour
les différents paramètres relevés (tableau 1) (l’accélération verticale du centre de gravité, la vitesse
verticale du centre de gravité, l’accélération antéropostérieure du centre de gravité ainsi que sa
vitesse, la vitesse au moment du décollement des fesses, le recul maximum du centre des pressions)
sauf pour la durée du décollement des fesses. Cependant dans la condition 45 °, on note des
différences significatives à hautement significatives sauf pour la vitesse antéropostérieure au
moment du décollement des fesses.
Comme le sujet adopte la même posture entre les conditions 100-IFC et 30-IFC. Le fait qu’il n’y a
pas de différence significative dans la condition 0° contrairement à la condition 45° peut s’expliquer
par la modification de l’angle articulaire entre le tronc et les cuisses. En effet, les études de Lino et
al. (1992); Goutal et al. (1994); Bouisset et al. (2002) ; Le Bozec et al. (2004) et celle plus récente de
Diakhaté et al. (2013), ont démontré que la modification de la surface de contact ischio-fémoral sur
des tâches de poussée et de sit-to-stand favorisait la dynamique du corps et donc la performance
qui en découlait. Le fait de ne pas observer de différence significative dans la condition 0° entre
100-IFC et 30-IFC, nous pousse à croire que cette position limite la mobilité articulaire au niveau
du rachis et de l’articulation de la hanche. En effet, la position 0° limite la mobilité du rachis et
525
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
aussi celle de la hanche. Ici, le sujet ne profite presque pas de l’ouverture de l’angle entre les cuisses
et le tronc. Dans le sit-to-stand normal où le sujet est en posture assise redressée, Diakhaté et al.
(2013), le sujet déplace son tronc vers l’avant en adoptant un certain angle avant de se lever dans la
verticalité. On note aussi une différence significative des vitesses (antéropostérieure et verticale) et
des accélérations (antéropostérieure et verticale) entre les deux assises (100-IFC versus 30-IFC).
De même, dans la condition 45°, la performance est toujours plus importante à 30-IFC. La
diminution de l’appui ischio-fémoral ne change pas le polygone de sustentation, Diakhaté et al.
(2013). Mais la vitesse est plus importante à 30-IFC et la durée nécessaire pour se lever du siège est
diminuée.
En accord avec la littérature, Zattara et Bouisset (1988) ; Bouisset et al. (2002) ; Le Bozec et al.
(1997) et Le Bozec et al. (2001), les résultats de cette étude ont montré que le corps est le siège de
phénomènes dynamiques. La dynamique posturale observée serait favorisée par la mobilité lombopelvienne. En effet, d’après Vandervael (1956), la modification du bassin en fonction de l’assise
serait favorable à une augmentation de la dynamique posturale. A 0° le bassin ne peut utiliser sa
mobilité quelle que soit la condition d’assise, car le débattement possible en antéversion et en
rétroversion comme précédemment souligné est quasi impossible du fait de la posture adoptée.
Toujours en accord avec la littérature, un recul plus important du centre des pressions suivant l’axe
antéropostérieur a été noté dans les études de Le Bozec et al. (1997) et Lino et al. (1992) quand on
passe de 100-IFC à 30-IFC. Les résultats dans la condition 45° vont dans le même sens,
contrairement aux résultats dans la condition 0°. En effet à 45°, le recul qui était de 14 cm à 100IFC sera de 23 cm à 30-IFC. C’est une différence absolue de 9 cm qui peut s’expliquer par le fait
que les sujets sont penchés vers l’avant, ce qui peut contribuer à augmenter ce recul. Dans la
condition 0°, le recul du centre des pressions est de 9 cm à 100-IFC et 11 cm à 30-IFC, une
différence qui n’est pas statistiquement significative (tableau 1).
Ces études montrent que la variation de l’angle C-T réduit l’amplitude articulaire des articulations
de la colonne vertébrale ainsi que celle de la hanche. Cette réduction entraîne une performance
presque similaire, entre 30-IFC et 100-IFC, à 0°. Néanmoins une performance plus accrue est
observée à 30-IFC par rapport à 100-IFC dans la condition 45° et une performance aussi grande à
30-IFC dans la condition d’assise redressée, Diakhaté et al. (2014).
Conclusion
Cette recherche a confirmé les travaux de Bouisset et al. (2002), Le Bozec et Bouisset (2004) et
Diakhaté et al. (2014) sur l’importance de la mobilité articulaire dans la performance motrice.
En effet cette mobilité est favorisée d’une part par la réduction de la surface de contact ischiofémoral avec l’assise dans des tâches motrices exécutées en position assise, et d’autre part par l’angle
formé par les cuisses et le tronc toujours dans des tâches motrices effectuées en position assise. En
effet, la variation de la surface de contact ischio-fémorale combinée à la modification de l’angle
entre les cuisses et le tronc nous montrent que la réponse motrice dans des tâches exécutées en
position assise est augmentée avec une mobilité plus importante du corps.
526
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Ces résultats pourraient être utilisés pour la confection des sièges des voitures qui permettraient au
conducteur d’avoir une meilleure réactivité en cas d’urgence et aussi dans la confection de sièges
ajustables destinés aux personnes à mobilité réduite.
Bibliographie
Bouisset, S., Le Bozec, S., Ribreau, C. (2002). Postural dynamics in maximal isometric ramp efforts.
BiolCybern. 87: 211–219.
Diakhaté, D.G., Do, M-C., Le Bozec, S. (2013). Effects of seat–thigh contact on kinematics
performance in sit-to-stand and trunk flexion tasks. J Biomech.46: 879-882.
Diakhaté, D.G., Seck, D., Le Bozec, S. (2014). Influence des appuis plantaires dans la poussée
symétrique sur un siège ergométrique. Cahier Sciences de la Vie et de la Santé. Histoire &
Anthropologie. Numéro 30.
Goutal, L., Lino, F., Bouisset, S. (1994). Modalités de l’appui corporel et vitesse du mouvement de
pointage. Arch Int. Physiol. Bioch. Biophys 102: 5.c21.
Le Bozec, S., Goutal, L., Bouisset, S. (1997). Ajustements posturaux dynamiques associés au
développement de forces isométriques chez des sujets assis. C.R Académie des sciences.
Paris. 320: 715-720.
Le Bozec, S., Lesne, J., Bouisset, S. (2001). A sequence of postural muscle excitations precedes
and accompanies isometric ramp efforts performed while sitting in human subjects.
Neurosci. Lett. 303: 72-76.
Le Bozec, S., Bouisset, S. (2004). Does postural chain mobility influence muscular control in sitting
ramp pushes? Exp Brain Res. 158: 427–437.
Lino, F., Duchêne J.L., Bouisset, S. (1992). The effect of seat contact area on the velocity of a
pointing task. In. Biomechanics (Belloti P, Capozzo A. eds) Universita La Sapienza. Rome,
232p.
Lino, F., Bouisset, S. (1993). Is velocity of a pointing movement performed in a sitting posture
increased by upper body instability? Abstract.XIV th ISB Congress 802-803.
Lino, F. (1995). Analyse biomécanique des effets des modifications des conditions d’appui sur
l’organisation d’une tâche de pointage exécutée en posture assise. Thèse de Doctorat
d’université. Orsay, 211p.
Vandervael, F. (1956). Analyse des mouvement du corps humain. Paris: Maloine. Zattara, M., Bouisset, S.
(1988). Posturo-kinetic organisation during the early phase of voluntary upper limb
movement. J Neurol, Neurosurg, Psychiatry. 51: 956-965.
527
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
528
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Les activités physiques et sportives au Maroc: constats, contraintes
et voies d’amélioration
Abderrazak El Akari
Institut Royal de Formation des Cadres, Salé, Maroc
e-mail: aelakari@yahoo.fr
Introduction
Les mesures drastiques prises par les gouvernements, tout comme celui du Maroc, pour faire face
à la propagation de la pandémie du Covid 19, en décrétant l'arrêt de toutes les activités non
indispensables à la vie quotidienne, ont obligé les citoyens à se confiner dans leurs foyers. Cette
situation exceptionnelle a soulevé des questions relatives à la santé physique et mentale de
l’individu face à l’inactivité totale. L’objectif escompté, à travers cet article est de soulever des
questions relatives aux Activités Physiques et Sportives (APS) au Maroc, notamment le degré
d’intérêt du citoyen marocain à pratiquer les APS, ses motivations, les actions initiées par les
pouvoirs publics, l’existence ou non d’une culture sportive ancrée au niveau de la population
marocaine, et enfin les contraintes d’ordre socio-économique et culturelles qui peuvent entraver
le développement des APS au Maroc. Pour apporter des réponses à ces questions, l’étude a eu
recours à l’analyse de la documentation officielle, le benchmark avec des actions développées au
niveau international et les résultats des enquêtes de terrain réalisées au niveau du Maroc autour du
même sujet.
Mots clés Activités physiques et sportives, culture, enquête.
529
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
___________________________________________________________________________
I) Approche théorique relative à la pratique de l’APS
Il nous parait judicieux de présenter dans un premier lieu, une définition des concepts qui seront
utilisés tout au long de cet article. Dans un deuxième lieu, de mettre en exergue l’importance de la
pratique des APS, ses apports à tous les niveaux, notamment pour faire face au phénomène de
l’obésité.
1. Définition des concepts
Selon l’Organisation Mondiale de la Santé (OMS), l’activité physique est tout mouvement
corporel produit par les muscles squelettiques qui requiert une dépense d’énergie. L’APS inclut
des activités qui peuvent être pratiquées dans des contextes différents de la vie quotidienne –
l’activité physique au travail, pendant les déplacements, à la maison, l’activité physique de loisir.
« L’activité physique et sportive est caractérisée par un certain nombre de paramètres mesurables (fréquence, durée,
intensité, type de pratique), dont la combinaison permet de connaître le niveau d’activité physique d’une population
donnée. Généralement la mesure de l’activité physique s’effectue à l’aide de paramètres partagés au niveau
international. En effet, les professionnels de l’activité physique jugent le niveau de la pratique selon son contexte, sa
nature, son intensité, sa durée, sa fréquence. » 1
2. Importance des APS
Selon, l’Institut National de la Santé et de la Recherche Médicale (INSERM) 2, il est aujourd’hui
« scientifiquement avéré que la pratique régulière d’une activité physique, même d’intensité modérée, peut constituer
un élément de prévention ou de traitement de nombreuses maladies et améliorer le bien-être physique, mental et
social ». 3
La pratique d’une activité physique régulière permet, selon le même rapport, de réduire le risque
de la mortalité prématurée toutes causes confondues par rapport au fait d’être inactif notamment
la mortalité cardiovasculaire. Elle est en effet un élément important de la prévention et du
traitement des maladies cardiovasculaires. Aussi elle diminue le risque de développer certains
cancers : diminution moyenne de 40% à 50% du risque de développer un cancer du côlon chez les
sujets physiquement actifs, et probablement, de 30% à 40% pour le cancer du sein chez les
femmes; elle pourrait aussi réduire le risque du cancer de l’endomètre ;
De même, elle constitue un facteur d’équilibre en santé mentale et peut constituer un élément de
prévention et de prise en charge de la dépression et de l’anxiété. Elle améliore l’estime de soi, le
bien-être subjectif et peut contribuer à la prévention de pathologies liées au stress.
1
2
https://www.who.int/fr/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/physical-activity
Créé en 1964, l'Institut national de la santé et de la recherche médicale est un établissement public à caractère scientifique et
technologique, placé sous la double tutelle du ministère de la Santé et du en France (In : www.inserm.fr)
3
Inserm (2008).Activité physique Contexte et effets sur la santé. Expertise collective p-p 682-728
530
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Néanmoins, le rapport de l’INSERM souligne que ces bénéfices de l’activité physique régulière
sont tributaires du respect de précautions élémentaires, un suivi médical adapté et un encadrement
compétent. Dans ces conditions, les bénéfices d’une activité physique et d’une pratique sportive
régulière l’emportent très largement sur les risques qui leur sont associés.
A remarquer, que les récentes études et recherches scientifiques présentent des chiffres alarmants,
à savoir un déclin de l’activité physique chez les jeunes, tant aux pays développés que chez les pays
en voie de développement. De plus, la nouvelle génération souffre du problème d’obésité chez les
enfants.
3. Des statistiques inquiétantes
Les statistiques de l’OMS4 tirent la sonnette d’alarme concernant le phénomène de l’obésité:
• 58 millions de personnes meurent chaque année d’une maladie non transmissible (diabète,
l’obésité et le cancer...).
• Les maladies non transmissibles représentent approximativement 60% de tous les décès dans
le monde chaque année, et 66% des 35 millions de ces décès surviennent dans des pays en
voie de développement.
• L’obésité infantile est un problème croissant, avec près de 22 millions d’enfants de moins de
cinq ans et 155 millions (soit 10%) en âge scolaire (5-17 ans) en surcharge pondérale, dont
30-45 millions d’obèses.
3.1 Au niveau mondial
En 2020, la banque mondiale a publié un rapport intéressant intitulé « health and economic
consequences of an Imdepending global challenge «. Selon ce rapport, les maladies liées à la
surcharge pondérale figurent aujourd’hui parmi les trois premières causes de mortalité dans toutes
les régions du monde. L'obésité a presque triplé depuis 1975 et elle est désormais responsable de
quatre millions de décès dans le monde chaque année.
Figure 1 les répercussion sanitaires de l’obésité5
4
O.M.S (2003). Obésité : prévention et prise en charge de l’épidémie mondiale rapport d’une consultation de l’OMS,
Genève.
531
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
___________________________________________________________________________
La généralisation des produits ultra transformés et sucrés, le recul de l'activité physique et la
hausse des niveaux de vie, qui s’accompagne souvent d’une consommation plus importante
d'aliments nocifs pour la santé, sont autant de facteurs qui favorisent la progression des
problèmes de surcharge pondérale. En outre, les individus et la société devront non seulement
supporter ce coût sanitaire, mais aussi des coûts indirects dus à la baisse de la productivité du
travail, à l'absentéisme et aux retraites anticipées.
Figure 2 Facteurs affectant l'obésité : un cadre conceptuel6
Selon l’OMS, la promotion des APS et la lutte contre la sédentarité sont des objectifs majeurs de
santé publique, (2013). A cet effet, elle recommande de concevoir des politiques d’amplification
de l’activité physique qui visent à faire en sorte que :
• "La marche, le vélo et les autres modes de transport actif non motorisé soient accessibles et
sûrs pour tous ;
• Les politiques du travail et des lieux de travail favorisent les déplacements actifs et les
occasions d’être physiquement actif pendant la journée de travail ;
• Les garderies, les écoles et les établissements d’enseignement supérieur disposent
d’installations et d’espaces sûrs et accueillants où les élèves et les étudiants peuvent se
dépenser pendant leurs temps libres ;
• Les établissements scolaires (premier et second degré) dispensent des cours d’éducation
physique de qualité qui aident les enfants à adopter des comportements qui les
maintiendront physiquement actifs toute leur vie ;
• Les programmes communautaires et scolaires offrent à tous, quels que soient l’âge et les
aptitudes de chacun, la possibilité de faire du sport ;
5
6
Banque Mondiale (2020). « health and economic consequences of an Imdepending global challenge «. p 6.
Banque Mondiale (2020). «health and economic consequences… Op cit p 8.
532
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
•
Les installations sportives et récréatives offrent à chacun la possibilité de pratiquer une
variété de sports, de danses, d’exercices et de loisirs actifs." 7
3.2 Au Maroc
En 2011, le Haut-commissariat au Plan (HCP) a mené une enquête auprès de 2426 ménages.
Selon ses résultats, près du tiers de la population du Maroc (soit environ 10,3 millions de
personnes avec un adulte sur cinq) connaissent des problèmes de surpoids. Une question de santé
publique qui prend de l'ampleur depuis dix ans. Chez les enfants de moins de cinq ans,
l'insuffisance pondérale est ainsi passée de 9,3% en 2004 à 3,1% en 2011, ce qui met le royaume
en très bonne position par rapport à la moyenne mondiale (16%). Pour les adultes de plus de 20
ans, ils ne sont plus que 3,3% à être concernés contre 3,9% en 2001. Les femmes sont les plus
touchées (26,8%), en particulier en milieu urbain. Sur 10 ans, l'obésité grave et morbide a
augmenté de 7,3% par an en moyenne, s'alarme le HCP, relevant que l'inactivité ainsi que les
niveaux de vie et d'éducation influent sur ce phénomène. Ainsi, la prévention d’une prise de
poids excessive passe-t-elle par l’adoption d’une alimentation équilibrée et la pratique d’une
activité physique régulière.
II) pratique des APS au Maroc
Pour répondre à la question suivante : qui pratique le sport au Maroc ? Nous faisons souvent
recours à deux techniques ou outils d’investigation de terrain :
• Les statistiques officielles émanant principalement du Ministère chargé du sport,
• Les sondages d’opinion effectués par des institutions spécialisées.
A reconnaitre que nous ne disposons que de peu d’informations sur les APS : leurs pratiquants,
les facteurs qui influent sur leur développement, le nombre des encadrants, les différents métiers
du sport et les filières scientifiques consacrées au sport, les équipements sportifs et leurs
typologies, la participation directe et indirecte du sport dans l’économie nationale…etc. Ces
informations revêtent un caractère stratégique, pour toute organisation sportive lui permettant
d’assurer une veille stratégique sur son environnement interne et externe, de réduire son
incertitude sur ce dernier et d’élaborer des stratégies adaptées au contexte.
D’un point de vue méthodologique, nous allons présenter une revue contenant les statistiques
officielles émanant du ministère chargé du sport, ainsi que les différentes études de terrains
menées durant des périodes séparées , selon une répartition qui présente , dans un premier lieu les
constats relatifs à la réalité des APS au Maroc. Dans un deuxième lieu, les obstacles qui entravent
la promotion des APS. Enfin des propositions permettant le développement des APS au Maroc.
7
https://www.who.int/fr/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/physical-activity
533
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
___________________________________________________________________________
Tableau 1 Les études menées relatives aux APS au Maroc
Date
1993
2008
2015
2017
2021
Population concernée
Jeunes 14-34
Jeunes(
Casa,
Rabat,
Khouribga et Ait Ourir)
10
Recherche académique
de 12 villes du Maroc
Ministère chargé du Les licenciés des fédérations
sport
sportives
11
Recherche académique
Ville de Salé
Organisme
CNJA8
LMS Conseil9
Echantillon étudié
100 personnes
14 focus groups
165 acteurs territoriaux
L’ensemble
des
adhérents
165 personnes
1- Constats relatifs à la pratique des APS dans le sport civil au Maroc.
Il sera question de présenter un état des lieux présenté par différentes études.
1.1 Statistiques du Ministère chargé du sport
Selon les statistiques émanant du Ministère chargé du sport 12, le nombre des adhérents aux
Fédérations Sportives (au nombre de 55) ne dépassent guère 500.000 adhérents, toutes disciplines
sportives confondues et à travers toutes les régions du Royaume. Si nous prenons le cas du
Football, considéré comme discipline populaire, très répandue et compte tenu du fait que sa
pratique ne nécessite pas un équipement spécialisé et couteux, le nombre de l’ensemble de ses
adhérents avoisine 60.000 évoluant au sein de 903 clubs de football à travers le Royaume. Ce qui
veut dire qu’il existe un seul club de football pour 70.000 citoyens marocains.
Ces mêmes statistiques nous permettent de relever les remarques suivantes :
• Les disciplines sportives qui attirent le plus les jeunes sont les sports de combats et
notamment les arts martiaux : (Karaté, Full contact, Taekwondo…)
• Les chiffres très modestes, sont enregistrés par les sports nautiques à titre d’exemple, en
2021 le nombre d’adhérents à la Fédération Royale Marocaine d’aviron ne dépasse pas 350
adhérents (comportant sportifs, encadrants, arbitres et responsables) encadrés par seulement
13 clubs13, dont la moitié est concentré sur la ville de Rabat !
8
Conseil national de la jeunesse et de l'avenir (CNJA) organe consultatif et de propositions groupant l'ensemble
des acteurs économiques : Administration, patronat, syndicats, ONG, secteur privé, créé par Dahir ses missions
consistaient à mener des recherches, des études, des enquêtes, réflexions et proposer des avis et des incitations
des mesures pour assurer la promotion de l'emploi.
9
Cabinet privé de conseil et de formation.
10
El Akari.A (2015). «La gouvernance territoriale des politiques publiques sportives au Maroc ». Thèse de
Doctorat. Faculté Sciences de l’Éducation.
11
Azirar.B (2021). La pratique sportive au Maroc, cas la ville de Salé. Mémoire Master . IRFC
12
Ministère de la Jeunesse et des Sports « Bilan des actions réalisées en 2017 et plan d’action 2018 » , présenté à
la chambre des représentants décembre 2017.
13
Rapport de mission de la commission provisoire chargée de la gestion de la F.R.M du canoë Kayak 12 Mars
2011
534
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
•
La pratique sportive reste peu développée au Maroc, donnant ainsi l’impression que nous ne
disposons pas d’une culture sportive bien ancrée dans le comportement collectif des
marocains.
500000
350000
320000
250 000
200 000
49000 47 000 57 000 55 000
1959
1970
1983
1990
1998
Année
2000
2005
2010
2017
Nombre des licenciés
Graphique 1. Evolution des licenciés des fédérations sportives depuis 195914
Le graphe 1, nous montre que le nombre de licenciés est de 0,6% du total de la population
marocaine en 2010. Ceci nous interpelle profondément, du fait que la pyramide démographique
témoigne de la présence d’une large population de jeunes (33% de la population est âgée de 7 à
19 ans).
Avant de procéder à des déductions donnant lieu à des interprétations erronées, il est impératif de
souligner que les statistiques des adhérents du mouvement sportif et olympique au Maroc sont
loin de refléter la réalité de la pratique sportive au Maroc, à ne retenir que les exemples suivants :
Durant tous les jours de la semaine notamment le weekend, le nombre des personnes qui
fréquentent les espaces publics, les aires de jeux et les installations sportives ne cessent d’accroitre
touchant tous les âges et les sexes. Le sport, d’une manière générale, se pratique régulièrement
dans un cadre informel pour des raisons ayant rapport avec la santé, le bien-être, et surtout
comme moyen préventif et thérapeutique non médicamenteux des pathologies et aux maladies
chroniques non transmissibles (diabètes, cardiovasculaire, et certains types de cancers….).
Aussi, à notifier le développement progressif de pratique sportive non encadrée par aucune
structure fédérale, notamment les équipes de quartiers qui touchent la tranche d’âge de plus de 13
ans et qui organisent des championnats inter-quartiers. Selon des chiffres approximatifs le
nombre de pratiquants dépasse70.000 qui adhèrent à plus de 1400 clubs de football de quartiers
non affiliés aux instances de la F.R.M de football15.
De même, le chiffre de 500.000 concerne seulement les adhérents du sport civil et précisément de
l’action indirecte menée par les fédérations sportives. Ce chiffre ne comptabilise pas l’action
14
15
Source : Atlas Graphique « 50 ans de développement humain au Maroc» et statistiques du MJS.
Chiffres recueillies au niveau du Ministère de la jeunesse et des sports ( rapport d’activités 2012)
535
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
___________________________________________________________________________
directe menée par le Ministère chargé du sport par le biais de son réseau des services
déconcentrés à travers le Royaume. De même, il ne prend pas en considération les pratiquants du
sport au sein des établissements scolaires affiliés à la Fédération Royale Marocaine du Sport
Scolaire, ni ceux du sport militaire qui constitue une composante essentielle du système sportif
national.
1.2 Les sondages d’opinion
Le recours à la deuxième technique, à savoir les sondages d’opinion, pour identifier le nombre
des pratiquants du sport, nous offre une autre possibilité d’interpréter différemment la réalité de
la pratique du sport au Maroc. A reconnaître toutefois, que c’est une technique qui reste peu
développée au Maroc. Elle est intimement liée au domaine économique et utilisée dans la quête
d’une meilleure connaissance des besoins de la population pour offrir des prestations adéquates à
la demande. Concernant le domaine sportif, peu de sondages ont été effectués. Nous en avons
identifié seulement quatre.
1.2.1 Enquête en 1993
Réalisée par le CNJA sur un échantillon représentatif de jeunes marocains âgés entre 15 et 34 ans.
L’objectif e cette enquête consiste à disposer d’informations sur leurs nivéaux d’instruction, leurs
activités socioculturelles, et leurs relations avec leur famille. Le questionnaire comportait un item
relatif à la pratique sportive, à savoir: Quelles sont les activités ludiques pratiquées, de manière
régulière par les jeunes? Parmi les résultats de ce sondage:
• 15,7% des jeunes interviewés confirment pratiquer différentes activités physiques et
sportives.
• le sport reste très développé aux villes avec un pourcentage de 21,7% du fait qu’elles
disposent d’un nombre important d’infrastructures sportives. Quant au monde rural,
seulement 7,8% de sa population déclare pratiquer le sport.
• le fait de disposer d’un niveau d’instruction supérieur constitue un facteur encourageant à
pratiquer le sport. Plus de 31,8% de jeunes étudiants confirment réserver une partie de leur
temps de loisir au sport.
1.2.2 : Enquête en 2008
Elaborée par un bureau d’études au profit du Ministère chargé du sport. Cet outil d’investigation
a été utilisé en parallèle avec la tenue de neuf forums régionaux visant à diagnostiquer l’état du
sport au Maroc dont les résultats devaient être présentés lors des assisses nationales16. Parmi les
zones de fragilité identifiées par l’étude :
• Des terrains et clubs sportifs insuffisants et mal équipés
• Absence d’espaces publics aménagés pour développer le sport
16
Assisses Nationales du sport tenues les 24 et 25 Octobre 2008 à Skhirat
536
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
•
•
L’Éducation Physique est inexistante au primaire et très peu pratiquée dans les collèges et les
lycées
Des professeurs de sport pas suffisamment impliqués.
1.2.3 Enquête en 2014
Cette enquête fait partie d’une recherche doctorale relative à la gouvernance sportive territoriale.
Elle a été effectuée durant la période du 10 Novembre 2013 au 20 Janvier 2014 au niveau de 12
villes du royaume. Parmi les questions posées celle relative aux raisons de pratiquer les APS, est
aussi, la perception des acteurs locaux quant aux rôles dévolus au sport au sein du territoire. De
portée cognitive, cette question nous permet de déceler l’existence d’une conscience auprès des
personnes-questionnées, des différents apports du sport au sein de la société de manière générale.
Améliorer la Santé (140)
52%
Participer à Intégration des jeunes (140)
Réaliser l’épanouissement personnel (140)
Eduquer sur les valeurs de la société (138)
98%
21%
Assurer le Bien-être (138)
97%
10%
98%
7%
97%
5%
Améliorer l’image de la ville (136)
3%
Participer au développement de la ville (135)
2%
Total des citations
98%
95%
94%
1ere citation
Graphique 2 Appréciation des acteurs quant aux rôles dévolus au sport dans le territoire
Selon les résultats de l’enquête, 52% des personnes interrogées ont mentionné que le premier rôle
du sport consiste à améliorer la santé du citoyen. En deuxième position, le sport comme facteur de
cohésion sociale avec 21%. En troisième position nous trouvons l’apport du sport pour améliorer
l’image de la ville avec seulement 3% des réponses.
Si nous procédons à un regroupement par familles des sept réponses proposées, il en ressort trois
grands blocs, à savoir la santé, la cohésion sociale et la promotion de la ville. Les statistiques
confortent le choix de l’échantillon choisi à privilégier « La santé » comme étant le rôle primordial
dévolu au sport. De ce fait, améliorer la santé, peut être considéré comme le premier argument
avancé par le citoyen pour justifier la décision de pratiquer le sport. Si nous procédons à un
croisement des données propres aux différentes réponses mentionnées, avec la qualité des
personnes interrogées, nous aboutissons aux résultats suivants :
▪ « Améliorer la santé » est, souvent, mentionnée, comme premier « rôle » du sport, par le bloc
composé des acteurs suivants : MJS, MEN et le mouvement associatif.
537
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
___________________________________________________________________________
▪
« Assurer la cohésion sociale et améliorer l’image de la ville » constitue la première réponse
émanant du bloc composé de l’Autorité Locale, Collectivités Territoriales, INDH et le secteur
privé.
Tableau 2 Regroupement des réponses par affinités
1ere citation
Total citations
Santé :
Améliorer la Santé
Assurer le Bien-être
Réaliser l’épanouissement personnel
69%
99%
Cohésion sociale :
Participer à Intégration des jeunes
Eduquer sur les valeurs de la société
26%
99%
Image de la ville
Participer au développement de la ville
Améliorer l’image de la ville
5%
97%
Les trois rôles essentiels dévolus au sport reflètent, en réalité, les trois générations qui retracent
l’évolution de l’histoire des activités sportives. Au départ, le sport a été utilisé pour l’amélioration de
la santé de l’individu, très intéressé et soucieux de sa forme physique. Une forte conviction de
l’existence de lien entre pratiquer le sport régulièrement et avoir un effet bénéfique sur le rendement
et le comportement de l’individu au sein de sa communauté.Les différentes recherches et études
récentes sont unanimes à confirmer qu’une pratique régulière d’une activité physique, même
d’intensité modérée, peut constituer un élément de prévention ou de traitement de nombreuses
maladies et améliorer le bien-être physique, mental et social de l’individu 17.
En deuxième étape, et dans un contexte historique précis, la société fera appel au sport, en tant
qu’institution de socialisation permettant de remplir de nouveaux rôles notamment d’assurer le lien
social et la cohésion entre les différentes couches de la société. L’utilisation du sport à des fins
sociales trouve sa raison d’être dans les changements opérés au niveau des espaces urbains, devenus
des lieux propices à la violence, à la ségrégation et à la pauvreté, dans son acception la plus large. De
ce fait le sport est perçu comme un outil efficace permettant de véhiculer ses propres valeurs
prônant la solidarité, le fairplay et l’abnégation de soi…
La troisième fonction du sport, en tant que facteur participant à la promotion de la ville, concerne la
nouvelle approche du recours au sport et de son utilisation, qui coïncide avec un environnement
caractérisé par le retrait progressif de l’Etat et un intérêt grandissant accordé au territoire. Dans
17
Inserm (2008). Activité physique Contexte et effets sur la santé. Expertise collective p-p 682-728
538
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
cette logique une concurrence ardue se fait jour entre les villes cherchant à se positionner et à attirer
le maximum d’investissement, tant interne qu’externe. Le sport est perçu par les acteurs territoriaux
comme un facteur qui peut participer à structurer le territoire (Pociello 1999).
13
4,36%
2
0,67%
25
8,39%
28
9,40%
9
3,02%
4
1,34%
28,86%
37
12,42%
43
14,43%
17,11%
51
86
1.2.4 Enquête en 2021
Réalisée à la ville de Salé sur un échantillon de 165 citoyens. Les résultats de cette enqêute
montrent que l’APS est omniprésente chez la population de cet arrondissement dont 89% des
personnes questionnées pratiquent une APS au moins une fois par semaine et principalement
pour leur bien-être et le plaisir. Les sports collectifs, la marche et musculations sont les activités
physiques les plus pratiquées, et représentent 61%. Bien que les résultats démontrent un certain
niveau de conscience quant à l’importance de la pratique d’activité physique et sportive, ils
mettent aussi en évidence des contraintes, notamment le manque du temps et de la motivation
qui constituent un frein à la pratique sportive régulière.
Graphique 3 Lles APS pratiquées au niveau de la ville de Salé
L’étude s’est intéressée à identifier les raisons qui encouragent les jeunes à pratiquer du sport. Il
ressort que le facteur déterminant est la préservation de la santé, ce qui corrobore les résultats de
l’étude doctorale menée en 2014. Le citoyen marocain est devenu très attentif à son bien être
notamment préserver sa santé physique et mentale.
III) Limites du Système de promotion du Sport National
Nous allons présenter les facteurs, identifiés par ces études, qui peuvent expliquer l’état actuel de
la pratique sportive au sein de la population du Royaume, tout en mettant l’accent sur les points
suivants :
• Rareté d’informations fiables sur les APS au Maroc
• Intervention symbolique du Mouvement Sportif
• Apport modeste du Ministère de l’Education Nationale (chargé sport scolaire)
• Structure d’encadrement sportif peu connue
539
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
___________________________________________________________________________
autres
10%
conseillé par un médecin
2%
10%
pour le bien être
10%
4%
pour le plaisir
35%
29%
prendre de la masse
musculaire
réduire du poids
Rencontrer des amis
Graphique 4 Les raisons de la pratique d'APS à salé
•
•
Manque d’infrastructures sportives
Coût exorbitant des prestations sportives.
1-Rareté d’informations fiables sur le sport au Maroc
La connaissance exacte de la situation des APS et des tendances de la population est un atout
majeur dans le choix de politiques nationales du sport à même de contribuer à l'établissement
d’une santé cohérente à la hauteur des objectifs de développement de notre pays. Une vision
globale des problèmes de ces pratiques réelles et de leurs déterminants permet aux décideurs de
mettre au point et dans une action commune, des interventions appropriées et efficaces pour le
bien-être de la population et pour un développement harmonieux et durable du Maroc.
Le premier obstacle qui a entravé la réalisation de ce travail, réside dans le manque d’informations
crédibles concernant la réalité des APS au Maroc, notamment au niveau territorial. L’information
recherchée concerne l’ensemble des données et statistiques ayant un rapport direct ou indirect
avec le domaine du sport. Son utilité stratégique découle du fait qu’elle constitue la pierre
angulaire permettant de réduire l’incertitude sur l’environnement, comprendre le système existant
et ses acteurs, et surtout de prendre des décisions judicieuses.Nous évoquons, de nos jours, de
plus en plus le concept de la «Veille Stratégique », qui peut être définie comme étant « un système
d’aide à la décision qui observe et analyse l’environnement scientifique, technique, technologique
et les impacts économiques présents et futurs pour en déduire les menaces et les opportunités de
développement. Elle s’appuie essentiellement sur les informations ayant un caractère stratégique
ou décisions importantes lui associant le terme de veille stratégique18. »
18
Coudol. D&Gros S.(in : ttp://www.agentintelligent.com/veille/veille strategique.html#Définition, 03/12/2009)
540
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Les informations utiles pour effectuer le diagnostic territorial sont souvent à caractère quantitatif
(nombre d’adhérents et de pratiquants sportifs, les sites sportifs, les différents types d’installations
sportives et leurs situations juridiques, le mouvement sportif local…)
Ces informations peuvent revêtir, également, un aspect qualitatif (spécificités du pratiquant
sportif, caractéristiques des équipements sportifs, sociodémographique de la pratique sportive
entre les différentes régions du Maroc, le potentiel propre à chaque région et sa prédisposition à
investir dans une discipline sportive donnée…)
2- Intervention symbolique du Mouvement Sportif
Le système très compliqué mis en place par le mouvement sportif, constitue, en soi-même un
obstacle pour attirer l’attention des jeunes et assurer leur intégration dans le système fédéral. Le
mouvement sportif et olympique, reste enfermé, et n’essaye pas de développer des actions visant
à faire connaitre sa discipline auprès du grand public, et d’entamer aussi des initiatives pour
promouvoir et vulgariser la pratique du sport au profit de toutes les catégories d’âge à travers le
Royaume.Rare sont les Fédérations qui recourent aux techniques du Marketing pour mieux
communiquer autour de leurs services sportifs offerts, en organisant des portes ouvertes au profit
des parents, des caravanes, des journées d’informations à destination des journalistes en tant
qu’intermédiaires avec le grand public…
Un autre facteur qui peut expliquer cette situation, à identifier dans les statuts des fédérations
sportives, c’est l’existence d’une relation entre l’augmentation du nombre de licenciés et le
nombre de voies octroyées aux clubs leur permettant ainsi de disposer d’un pouvoir
proportionnel dans le processus de prise de décision. Le fait d’accepter de nouveaux clubs, peut
constituer une menace aux jeux électoraux, que seuls quelques clubs, détiennent ces ficèles. Ce
qui peut expliquer, dans une grande partie, les raisons du changement perpétuel des statuts de
certaines fédérations et les conditions draconiennes exigées pour accepter l’intégration d’un
nouveau club.
A remarquer aussi, que le sport en tant que phénomène social, évolue et s’adapte à son propre
contexte socio-économique et culturel, donnant lieu à l’émergence de nouvelles pratiques
sportives, qui intéressent les jeunes, à titre d’exemple Skate board, Kit surf, Foot salle, Beach
volley, VTT, Parapente….etc. Malgré l’engouement des jeunes pour ces sports «urbains », les
responsables fédéraux n’essayent pas d’anticiper le changement inéluctable et persistent à refuser
l’intégration de ces nouvelles pratiques.
3- Apport modeste du sport scolaire
Parmi les innovations importantes initiées par la loi 30-09 relative à l’Education Physique et aux
sports, le fait d’avoir insisté dans l’article deux sur le point suivant "L’enseignement de l’éducation
physique et sportive est obligatoirement dispensé au sein des établissements…".
541
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
___________________________________________________________________________
Cette obligation contenue dans la Constitution (article 26) et dans la loi découle des constats
alarmants mentionnés dans la Lettre Royale adressée aux participants aux assises nationales sur le
sport et dans la nouvelle stratégie sur le sport. Selon l’enquête LMS (2008), parmi les zones de
fragilité identifiées par l’étude, le fait que l’Éducation Physique est inexistante au primaire et très
peu pratiquée dans les collèges et les lycées. Il faut reconnaître, faute de ressources humaines, que
l’Éducation Physique ne se pratique que dans quelques écoles primaires, ce qui signifie, tout
simplement que nos enfants, à un âge précoce, ne bénéficient pas d’un encadrement qui leur
permet d’acquérir les éléments de base de la pratique sportive. Cette « déperdition sportive » ne
permet pas au mouvement sportif de disposer d’une masse de jeunes talentueux qui peuvent
constituer de futurs champions. Malgré les circulaires du département de tutelle, exhortant les
responsables des services extérieurs, l’Éducation Physique est presque absente dans le primaire, et
peu développée dans le deuxième cycle.
4- Structure d’encadrement sportif peu connue
Ce facteur est intimement lié aux actions menées par le Ministère chargé du sport, qui dispose
d’un réseau important d’installations sportives et d’un encadrement qualifié, permettant ainsi de
créer et d’offrir un service au grand public. A titre d’exemple, les écoles de sport destinées aux
enfants de moins de 12 ans, l’encadrement des équipes de quartiers …etc. Néanmoins, l’absence
d’une bonne communication autour de ces services, auprès du grand public, ne permet pas de
toucher un plus grand nombre de pratiquants. De même, leur impact reste très faible sur la
population concernée.
A signaler aussi l’absence de passerelle entre le sport de masse et le sport de compétition. Les
actions de promotion de sport de masse initiées par le ministère chargé du sport destinées
notamment aux enfants de moins de douze ans, ne peuvent en aucun cas atteindre les résultats
escomptés, faute d’une étroite coordination entre les acteurs intervenants dans le domaine sportif
pour attirer ces jeunes talents et leur assurer la formation et le suivi adéquat, conditions sine qua
non pour former de futurs champions.
5- Manque d’infrastructures sportives
Les infrastructures sportives constituent un levier essentiel pour concrétiser le droit à l’exercice
du sport et un outil de choix pour la promotion du sport et l’excellence sportive. Ils doivent
satisfaire les besoins les plus divers de la population. En revanche l’équipement sportif participe à
l’aménagement et au développement harmonieux et durable du territoire en jouant un rôle
économique non négligeable, tout en étant un vecteur d’intégration sociale et d’affirmation de
l’identité locale. L’enquête LMS (2008) a mentionnée parmi les insuffisances les terrains qui sont
insuffisants et mal équipés. Aussi, l’enquête de terrain auprès de 12 villes en 2015 a a-t-elle
identifié comme obstacle qui entrave la promotion du sport au niveau territorial, Manque
d’infrastructures ;
542
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Manque moyens financiers
27%
Manque d’infrastructure
24%
Encadrement qualifié
17%
Manque culture sportive
11%
Chevauchement des
compétences
10%
Absence de stratégie de dév
sport
Absence de gouvernance
6%
5%
Graphique 5 Les obstacles identifiés dans la promotion du sport
6- Coût exorbitant des prestations sportives
Deux autres facteurs de démotivation, ont été identifié par les enquêtes de terrain réalisées
respectivement en 2014 et 2021, à savoir le manque de temps et le budget nécessaire pour l’achat
des équipements indispensables à la pratique .
Graphique 6 Les obstacles à la pratique des APS
A constater, une nouvelle tendance chez les citoyens à s’orienter vers les salles de fitness et de
remise en forme, qui offrent des services s’accommodant avec leurs attentes. De même, force est
de constater la floraison et la multiplication de nouvelles offres de prestations sportives, à travers
le royaume. Néanmoins les prix affichés restent exorbitants et sont au-dessus duniveau de vie du
simple citoyen, confronté quotidiennement à des charges fixes.
543
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
___________________________________________________________________________
IV)
Voies susceptibles de promouvoir les APS au Maroc
Nous allons mettre l’accent sur trois facteurs, identifiés dans les études analysées et jugés
indispensables pour le développement des APS au Maroc, à savoir :
• Accroitre le réseau d’infrastructures sportives
• Développer le sport scolaire ;
• Développer la culture sportive ;
Une lecture attentive, sous un angle comparatif, des avis de la population-cible, concernant
notamment les obstacles identifiés et les actions phares susceptibles de promouvoir le sport au
niveau territorial, fait émerger deux blocs/groupes de propositions :
Le premier bloc, à qualifier de traditionnel, regroupe des facteurs indispensables pour une
pratique sportive, faisant référence aux moyens financiers, aux ressources humaines et à
l’infrastructure.
Certes, ces facteurs revêtent un aspect stratégique dans le système sportif, mais ils sont repris de
manière récurrente, dans toute la littérature ayant rapport avec le sport au Maroc, depuis
l’indépendance.
Malgré l’effort déployé par l’Etat pour injecter des sommes importantes, en focalisant l’intérêt sur
les trois facteurs précédemment cités, la situation du sport au Maroc, ne fait que s’empirer et
demeure en-deçà des attentes et aspirations de la population.
C’est dans cette optique, que l’enquête a donné lieu à une autre série de propositions, englobant
les éléments ayant rapport avec l’ancrage de la culture sportive ; la mise en place des principes de
la bonne gouvernance et la création d’une structure englobant tous les acteurs permettant ainsi
d’assurer la convergence des politiques sectorielles.
L’ensemble des propositions fait partie du registre propre à la gouvernance des organisations
sportives. Ce qui reflète une conscience plus aigüe, que le développement des APS nécessite de
revoir le mode de pensée et d’action en faisant appel à d’autres voies, qui ont donné pleine
satisfaction dans le milieu des entreprises privées.
Nous pouvons, également, déduire, qu’une partie de ces propositions comporte le souci de
rompre avec les pratiques d’antan qui ont démontré leurs limites (bénévolats, Amateurisme, …),
et incitant, par la même occasion de s’inscrire dans la pensée stratégique qui favorise, entre autres,
la planification stratégique, le diagnostic prospectif, et le recours à la démarche participative.
Dans le même ordre d’idées, il est à remarquer le galvaudage du concept de « Culture sportive »
qui a été maintes fois pointé du doigt par les responsables de la chose sportive comme étant le
facteur limitant la promotion du sport.
544
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Cette notion fait référence à l’absence chez les acteurs locaux, d’informations, de connaissance et
surtout une appropriation des valeurs propres à la pratique sportive, communément admises par
la communauté.
Ancrer la culture sportive passe, impérativement, par un travail de longue haleine d’information,
de communication, de sensibilisation et de formation à l’égard de tous les acteurs concernés
autour des apports bénéfiques du sport pour le développement durable du territoire. Les effets de
ces actions ne peuvent être appréciés que sur le long terme.
Conclusion
L’objectif escompté de cet article, à travers l’analyse des résultats des différentes enquêtes de
terrain menées depuis 1993 jusqu’à 2021, relatives à la pratique sportive au Maroc, est de
disposer de données concernant le degré d’intérêt du citoyen à pratiquer les APS, ses motivations,
les actions initiées par les pouvoirs publics, l’existence d’une culture sportive ancrée au niveau de
la population marocaine et enfin les contraintes d’ordre socio-économique et culturelles qui
peuvent entraver le développement des APS au Maroc.
Le premier constat de taille, c’est le manque de données qui peuvent orienter et éclairer la
décision publique. Ce qui nécessite que le haut-commissariat au plan, intègre dans son enquête
nationale un volet relatif aux APS.
De cela découle, l’importance de la maitrise de l’information relative aux A PS, étape jugées
indispensable pour mettre en place des politiques favorisant la pratique du sport, en tant que
droit inaliénable de tous les citoyens. L’intérêt doit être focalisé sur la mise en place
d’infrastructures de proximité avec une répartition géographique égale.
Aussi, les différentes recherches mentionnées ont-elle mis l’accent sur le rôle prépondérant des
APS face aux multiples maladies de nos sociétés, intimement liées aux changements progressifs
que connaissent les sociétés à tous les niveaux, culturels, urbains, vieillissement de la
population…etc.
Le fait d’accorder un effort conséquent à la pratique du sport ne peut pas être perçu comme un
gaspillage des deniers publics, mais plutôt, comme un investissement qui pourra avoir un impact
positif direct et indirect sur la communauté.
Bibliographie
Augustin j-p (2001). Sport, pouvoirs et territoire. Revue pouvoirs locaux n° 49 ii.
Azirar.B (2021). La pratique sportive au Maroc, cas la ville de Salé. Mémoire Master . IRFC
545
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
___________________________________________________________________________
Banque Mondiale (2020). « health and economic consequences of an Imdepending global
challenge «.
Bayeux, p. (2006). Le sport et les collectivites territoriales, que sais-je 3eme édition, puf
Ben mahmoud. I & marriessa .(2014) jeux d’influences et dans la gouvernance d’un événement
sportif : stratégie d’acteur, modalités d’organisation et enjeux contemporain. la revue
européenne de management du sport 41(1):23-34 · january 2014 with 82 reads
Boussaquet l, jacquot s&ravinet p.(2006). Dictionnaire des politiques publiques, 2eme Edition,
paris.
Chazaud.p. (2001). La place du sport dans les stratégies marketing locales revue pouvoirs locaux,
n° 49 ii
CNJA. (1993). Enquete nationale après Des jeunes. Activités socio-culturelles des jeunes Volume
3.
Coase. R. (1988). The firm, the market and the law” Chicago, the university of Chicago press,
pp.9-25.
Crozier, friedberg.e.(1977). L’acteur et le système : les contraintes de l'action collective » éditions
du seuil
Dossier documentaire sur « management territorial » 2005 carif-oref Guadeloupe.
El Akari.A (2015). «La gouvernance territoriale des politiques publiques sportives au Maroc ».
Thèse de Doctorat. Faculté Sciences de l’Éducation.
Gasparini, w., vieille marchiset, g. (2008). Le sport dans les quartiers : pratiques sociales et
politiques publiques. Paris cedex 14, France : presses universitaires de France. Doi:
10.3917/puf.gasp.2008.01.
Inserm. (2008). Activité physique contexte et effets sur la sante. Expertise collective p-p 682-728.
O.M.S (2003). Obésité : prévention et prise en charge de l’épidémie mondiale rapport d’une
consultation de l’OMS, Genève.
Sporsora. (2008"). Le livre blanc du marketing sportif à destination des collectivités ».
546
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Realités infrastructurelles, activités de loisir et perspectives
d´attraction au parc urbain Bangr-Weoogo de Ouagadougou
Gouriyamba Ouedraogo 1 - Augustin Pale 1 - Antoine Hounga 2
Université Joseph Ki Zebro, Ouagadougou, Burkina Faso
Institut National de la Jeunesse, de l’Education Physique et du Sport, Porto-Novo, Bénin
e-mail : gouryjeano82@gmail.com
1
2
Résumé
L’objectif de cet article est d’identifier les activités de loisir des usagers du Parc Urbain BangrWeoogo de Ouagadougou (PUBWO) et les contraintes de pratique qu’ils rencontrent. C’est
l’analyse constructiviste de Pagès (1993) qui a été utilisée pour mieux comprendre les opinions des
visiteurs, des gestionnaires du parc et des acteurs du développement des loisirs au niveau communal
et national. Pour collecter les données, une enquête par questionnaire a été réalisée auprès de 150
visiteurs et une autre par entretien auprès de 17 personnes ressources. De l’analyse et de la
discussion qui ont été faites à partir des résultats, il en ressort que les visiteurs du PUBWO, sont
en majorité des jeunes qui aiment plus pratiquer les activités physiques de loisir par des promenades,
des marches et des pratiques sportives dans le but d’atteindre leur bien-être. Mais, ces derniers sont
confrontés à d’énormes contraintes avec en tête la vétusté des infrastructures et matériels de loisirs.
Ainsi, en termes de stratégies d’attraction, il est donc souhaitable que l’Etat accompagne la
commune pour la réalisation d’un nouvel aménagement et que les autorités communales élaborent
une politique communale de loisirs axée sur la pratique des loisirs sportifs.
Mots-clés : Parc urbain Bangr-Weoogo - Activités Physiques de loisir - Stratégies d’attraction –
Ouagadougou - Burkina Faso.
547
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
Les loisirs sont des composantes de la vie des hommes, ils ont existé depuis les sociétés dites
traditionnelles où elles occupaient une place privilégiée dans les moments de détente, de
divertissement, d’épanouissement personnel, de créativité et de transcendance sensuelle (Hounga,
2013). Ils continuent de faire valoir positivement leur rôle dans les sociétés modernes. Pour
certaines institutions comme la Conférence des ministres de la Jeunesse Et des Sports ayant le
français en partage (CONFEJES), la pratique des loisirs est un droit pour chaque citoyen dans tout
Etat au regard des différents avantages qu’elle renferme (CONFEJES, 2006).
En Afrique, et précisément dans sa partie sub-saharienne, le secteur des loisirs est peu développé
(Kinda, 2014). Conscient de cette situation et connaissant le rôle combien important des loisirs
dans la vie quotidienne des Burkinabè, le gouvernement a créé en 2002 le Ministère des Sports et
des Loisirs (MSL) qui est chargé de la promotion des loisirs.
Il a aussi élaboré deux politiques nationales de loisirs, une première en 2009 et la seconde en 2017
et projetait la formulation de la troisième en 2022. Il ressort du diagnostic de ces politiques que les
principales difficultés qui freinent le développement et la promotion des loisirs au Burkina Faso
sont, le manque de compétence des acteurs en matière de gestion des loisirs et la mauvaise qualité
et répartition spatiale des infrastructures et équipements de base (PNL, 2009). L’élaboration de ces
deux documents politiques doit permettre de surmonter ces difficultés afin de contribuer au
rayonnement international du pays et à l’instauration d’un bien-être social.
L’atteinte de ces objectifs doit se concrétiser par la réalisation d’actions comme le « développement des
infrastructures et équipements de loisirs, la création et l’opérationnalisation des structures de gestion des infrastructures
de loisirs et par des actions d’appui aux collectivités territoriales dans le cadre de l'exercice des compétences transférées
« (PNSL, 2017, P38). Parlant de développement et de promotion des loisirs au niveau des
collectivités territoriales, en guise d’appui à ces circonscriptions, le décret n°2014-925/ PRES/PM/
MATD/ MCT/ MJFPE/ MSL/MEF/MFPTSS/ MICA du 10 Octobre 2014 portant modalités de
transfert de compétences et de ressources de l’Etat aux régions dans le domaine des sports et des
loisirs donne droit aux communes et régions de prendre en charge la gestion des infrastructures de
sports et de loisirs sous la supervision du Ministère de tutelle. La mise en œuvre de cette stratégie
a connu d’énormes difficultés et n’a pas permis de redresser le niveau de développement des loisirs
dans les communes.
La commune de Ouagadougou, plus grande commune urbaine du pays et possédant une population
motivée par la pratique des loisirs ne reste pas en marge de ce sous-développement en matière de
loisirs. En effet, les habitants de cette ville pratiquent divers types de loisirs sur les berges des
barrages, visitent des musées (musée national, le musée de la musique, le musée du Moogh-Naaba,
etc.), fréquentent des piscines, des boîtes de nuit, des aires de jeux, des stades, des plateaux
omnisports, des salles de sport. Ils vont au dans les salles de cinéma dont certaines sont de standing
international (Ciné Olympia) sans oublier les cyber-cafés, les places publiques, les centres aérés, les
centres d’activités socio-éducatives, les bibliothèques, les maisons des jeunes etc. Les Ouagavillois
548
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
aiment aussi fréquenter les espaces verts, les jardins publics, les parcs d’attraction. Parlant de parcs,
la ville de Ouagadougou possède un parc urbain, « le Parc Urbain Bangr-Weoogo de Ouagadougou
(PUBWO) » qui renferme des opportunités de par sa situation au centre-ville, sa proximité avec les
deux grandes routes nationales (RN3 et RN4) et l’immensité de son étendue soit 265 hectares
clôturés.
Dans l’optique de promouvoir la pratique des loisirs, les autorités locales avaient commencé à
aménager en 2001 des sites de loisirs (Association Internationale des Maires Francophones [AIMF],
2010) qui permettaient aux visiteurs de pratiquer quelques types de loisirs comme les loisirs sportifs,
les loisirs culturels, les loisirs socio-éducatifs. Les visiteurs fréquentaient donc ce parc pour
s’épanouir, pour maintenir et améliorer leur santé physique et mentale, donc, pour une cure de
santé (Marion, 2014). En somme ce parc participait à l’amélioration des conditions de vie de ses
usagers.
Dans ces dernières années, on constate que le parc est incapable d’enregistrer une bonne
fréquentation, en effet, le niveau de fréquentation connait une baisse sensible. En 2014 le taux de
fréquentation des visites par jour était estimé à 450, en 2015 il était estimé à 430 avant de chuter à
390 en 2017 (archive des statistiques du parc, 2017). Pourtant, Diallo (1998) avait montré que la
population de Ouagadougou avait exprimé son besoin de voir cette forêt hérissée en parc urbain
et avait donné son accord pour s’y rendre au moins une fois par semaine à condition que le prix
soit compris entre 100f et 250f et jusqu’en 2017 le ticket d’entrée au parc était de 100f par adulte
et de 50 francs pour les enfants. Quant à l’affluence des visiteurs, elle est fortement influencée par
les paramètres temps et lieu, pendant la saison des pluies, certaines activités de loisir ne sont pas
réalisables et le parc demeure presque vide. L’autre constat est l’intensification de manifestations
de mécontentement des usagers qui se traduisent souvent par des plaintes auprès des responsables
du parc. Ces derniers se plaignent car, ils n’arrivent plus à pratiquer convenablement leurs loisirs
pour s’épanouir.
Il est donc important de rechercher l’origine des plaintes de ces visiteurs. C’est là, tout le fondement
de cette recherche dont l’objectif général est de contribuer à l’amélioration des conditions de
pratique des activités de loisir des visiteurs du PUBWO. Il s’agit spécifiquement d’identifier
les loisirs prisés des visiteurs et les contraintes qu’ils rencontrent pour la pratique de ces activités
afin d’en formuler les perspectives.
Cadre d´étude
Ouagadougou: ville des grands évènements de loisirs de tout genre et d’infrastructures de
loisirs
La commune urbaine de Ouagadougou est située dans la province du Kadiogo au centre du Burkina
Faso. Elle couvre une superficie de 21.930 hectares et sa population majoritairement jeune était
estimée à 2.532.311 habitants en 2015 (INSD, 2006). C’est un centre urbain important où des
rencontres politiques, économiques et culturelles avec de nombreux évènements de grandes
549
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
envergures dont entre autres le Festival Panafricain du Cinéma et de la télévision de Ouagadougou
(FESPACO) et le Salon International de l’Artisanat de Ouagadougou (SIAO). Difficile d’oublier
les événements sportifs comme les championnats nationaux des disciplines sportives ou de loisirs,
les coupes et tournois organisés par des promoteurs privés ou des institutions. C’est une ville
caractérisée par un climat nord soudanien avec des températures maximales comprises entre 40-41
voire 43°C en Avril et Mai (Schéma Directeur d’Aménagement du Grand Ouaga [SDAGO], 1996)
favorables à la pratique des loisirs de plein air.
L’organisation administrative au sein de la mairie centrale donne une place importance aux loisirs
et au sport avec la création d’une Direction de la Promotion des Sports et des Loisirs (DPSL) et
d’une Direction des Aménagements Paysagers et de Gestion des Parcs (DAPGP) toutes rattachées
au Secrétariat Général. Ces directions œuvrent pour le développement du sport et des loisirs au
niveau communal. Elles sont appuyées par des commissions du conseil municipal telle la
commission « environnement et développement local » qui s’occupe de la gestion d’espaces verts
et de parcs communaux qui sont par excellence les lieux de pratiques de loisirs.
PUBWO: une propriété du Mogho Naaba devenue un bien communal
Le PUBWO est situé au cœur de la ville de Ouagadougou dans l’arrondissement n°5 entre la
Route Nationale n° 4 et la Route Nationale n° 3 « au côté Est de l’hôtel Silmandé sous la forme d’une aile
d’oiseau à l’aval du barrage n°3 de Ouagadougou » (Natura n° 3, 2008, P 8). Historiquement cette forêt
fut une propriété du Mogho Naaba avant d’être érigée en 1936 en forêt classée (Bondaz, 2011).
En 1995, débutera la construction de la clôture suivie de l’aménagement de l’intérieur en 1997. Le
05 janvier 2001, le parc fut baptisé "Parc Urbain Bangr-Weoogo" qui signifie littéralement en langue
mooré, « brousse du savoir » ou « la forêt de la connaissance » (Kaboré, 2004). Actuellement, il s'étend
sur une superficie de 265 ha, dont 240 ha clôturés et aménagés.
De 2001 à 2017, une direction autonome rattachée à la mairie, appuyée du Conseil Scientifique et
Technique (CST), s’occupaient de sa gestion. Depuis février 2018, cette direction est érigée en
Direction des Aménagements Paysagers et de Gestion des Parcs dont la mission est de planifier
toutes les activités visant à améliorer la physionomie de l’aménagement paysager de la ville de
Ouagadougou et d’assurer la gestion des parcs urbains. Elle comprend six services et dix-huit
sections dont « une section détente » qui s’intéresse plus aux activités sportives, culturelles et les
loisirs.
A la découverte de l’offre en activités de loisir du PUBWO
A l’intérieur du PUBWO se trouvent des espaces aménagés et des espaces naturels qui servent de
cadre de détente, d’épanouissement et d’acquisition du bien-être pour les visiteurs.
550
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Figure 1 Carte de la commune urbaine de Ouagadougou montrant la situation
géographique du PUBWO par rapport aux arrondissements et secteurs
On peut pratiquer des loisirs touristiques en se rendant au parc zoologique (72 ha) abritant une
faune abondante d’antilopes, de crocodiles, etc. ou au jardin botanique (8ha) constitué d’espèces
locales et exotiques sans oublier la ménagerie où sont logés des animaux et oiseaux de tout genre
(singes ; varans ; cailles ; poules d’eau ; pigeons). On y trouve aussi un musée à l’intérieur duquel
sont exposés des trophées en entier, en capes, des trophées d’oiseaux, des bocaux de poissons
formolés et autres objets d’arts.
Concernant les loisirs sociaux et éducatifs, on a « l’espace du bonheur » où des sorties détente sont
organisées et sont des moments festifs. Sur ces lieux des « dassandaaga » (journées
communautaires), des kermesses, des journées de retrouvailles sont organisées. La bibliothèque et
les ombrages des arbres servent de lieux de lecture pour visiteurs sans oublier les bars-restaurants
avec des paillotes qui constituent des lieux propices de rafraîchissement et d’échanges sociaux.
Les activités physiques de loisir et les loisirs de plein air qui semblent attirer plus l’attention de la
majorité des usagers du parc sont entre autres : la pratique du football, la pratique du volleyball, du
basketball sur le plateau omnisport. La marche et la promenade, les randonnées pédestres ou à vélo
551
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
(VTT) sont pratiquées sur les différentes pistes qui sillonnent tout le parc. Les visiteurs peuvent
aussi faire des balades, juste pour contempler la nature, ou peuvent se reposer sur des banquettes
qui sont disséminées à l’intérieur du parc.
Approche scientifique et théorique
Cette recherche a été appréhendée sous l’angle d’une double approche sociologique, la sociologie
des loisirs et celle des Activités Physiques et Sportives (APS). C’est pourquoi des documents de ces
disciplines ont été d’abord lus avant de choisir l’approche constructiviste du modèle d’analyse de
Pagès (1993). L’identification des activités de loisir prisées des usagers et des contraintes qu’ils
rencontrent ainsi que la recherche des solutions viables n’ont pu être possibles que de par la
triangulation du contenu des différentes opinions des groupes sociaux.
Dispositif méthodologique
Cette recherche synchronique et analytique est de type quantitatif et qualitatif à dominance
quantitative. Elle a eu pour populations d’étude 150 visiteurs du parc qui ont été accidentellement
choisis après vérification de certains critères (être âgé d’au moins 18 ans, avoir visité le parc au
moins trois fois). De même, 2 responsables des structures d’activités de loisir au PUBWO, 9
responsables et agents de la DAPGP, 2 membres du CST; 2 responsables et agents de la
DPSL/Mairie et de 2 responsables du MSL ont été retenus par choix raisonné car ces derniers sont
capables de donner des statistiques ou de fournir des renseignements relatifs aux visions de la
commune et celles de l’Etat en matière de loisirs. Les données collectées par questionnaire auprès
des visiteurs au sein du parc ont fait l’objet d’un traitement statistique avec le logiciel SPSS. 22.0 et
celles recueillies par entretien auprès des sujets interviewés ont tout simplement fait l’objet d’une
analyse thématique de contenu.
Interpretation, analyse, des résults et discussion
Des jeunes visiteurs plus friands d’activités physiques de loisir pour leur bien-être
Tableau 1 Ccaractéristiques des visiteurs selon l’âge, le sexe et la profession
Variables
Age
Sexe
Modalités
Effectif
Pourcentage
Modalités
Effectif
Pourcentage
[18-36ans [
114
76%
Elèves
13
8,66%
[36-60ans [
33
22%
60 ans et plus
3
2%
Etudiants
Agent Public de l’Etat
58
30
38,66%
20%
21,33%
150
100%
Agent du Privé
32
Total
Profession libérale
14
9,33%
Masculin
95
63, 33%
Féminin
Retraité
3
2%
55
36,66%
Total
150
100%
Total
150
100%
Variables
Profession
552
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Avant de nous intéresser aux activités de loisir pratiquées par les usagers du PUBWO, il est
important que nous jetions un regard sur quelques caractéristiques sociodémographiques et
socioprofessionnelles de ces derniers.
Se référant aux visiteurs ayant répondu aux questionnaires, il ressort que le PUBWO a une clientèle
plus représentée par sa couche juvénile (Tableau I) dominée par les étudiants. En effet, les visiteurs
du parc sont en majorité (76%) jeunes (18-35ans). Ces résultats sont similaires à ceux de Marchiset
et Gasparini (2010) qui ont montré que dans les quartiers populaires de la France, parmi la
population qui s’adonne à la pratique des loisirs sportifs, les jeunes sont les plus nombreux et que
les femmes demeurent en retrait dans l’accès aux loisirs. Cette forte représentativité des jeunes peut
s’expliquer par la jeunesse de la population de la ville de Ouagadougou. En effet, 80,2% de la
population de cette ville-capitale a moins de 35 ans parmi laquelle 33,2% ont un âge compris entre
15 et 35 ans (Plan National de Développement Economique et Social [PNDES], 2016).
Paradoxalement au résultat de la variable sexe, la même source PNDES (2016) indique que les
femmes représentent près de 52 % de la population burkinabé d’où une forte représentativité des
visiteuses du parc était attendue. En lien avec la variable profession, le nombre plus élevé
d’étudiants peut se justifier par le fait que le parc n’est pas distant de l’Université Ouaga I, par
conséquent les étudiants peuvent s’y rendre facilement. La période de l’enquête a coïncidé avec le
début des vacances des écoles professionnelles, période pendant laquelle, les étudiants de ces
établissements organisent des sorties détente au PUBWO.
En termes d’activités pratiquées par ces visiteurs, le tableau II ci-dessous montre que les usagers
du PUBWO aiment plus se promener, marcher en contemplant la nature et faire du sport. Ces
trois activités caractérisées toutes par l’exécution d’un effort physique représente 73, 4%. Si ce
résultat diffère de ceux de l’International Social Survey Program [ISSP] (2007), de Hounga, Tito et
Akoueté (2014) qui ont respectivement trouvé que les Français et les personnes retraitées de la ville
de Cotonou aiment plus « suivre la télévision », il faut noter qu’il est conforme à ceux de Hémon
(2014) et de Palé (2007) qui ont tous investigués dans des parcs urbains. Toute chose qui fait penser
que la zone d’étude est à l’origine de cette différence antérieurement mentionnée.
Les responsables de la DAPGP, de par leurs observations et connaissance du parc classent la
promenade au premier rang et les pratiques sportives au deuxième, des résultats qui soutiennent
davantage la forte pratique des activités physiques dans ce parc. Les écrits de Jackson (2022) ont
aussi montré que les activités physiques de loisir comme la randonnée, les promenades dans la
nature, le golf et le patinage sont quelques-unes des activités amusantes disponibles au réseau de
parcs de la vallée d’Oldman au Canada. On est donc emmener à se demander, pourquoi une ruée
des usagers du PUBWO sur la pratique des activités physiques de loisir ?
553
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Tableau 2 Activités de loisir les plus pratiquées par les visiteurs au PUBWO
Activités de loisir
Effect
if
Visite du zoo
1
Jeux de société
3
Musique
3
Lecture
15
Pique-nique
18
Sport
22
Marche pour contemplation du 27
paysage
Promenade dans les artères du 61
parc
Total
150
Pourcentage
0,7%
2%
2%
10%
12%
14,7%
18%
40,7%
100%
« Notre groupe vient ici tous les mercredis et samedis matin pour pratiquer les activités physiques et sportives, juste
pour se détendre et améliorer nos capacités physiques et mentales » nous a confié un responsable d’une
structure d’activités de loisir. Comme lui et les membres de son groupe, l’objectif poursuivi par la
majorité (85%) des visiteurs en se rendant au PUBWO est la recherche de l’amélioration de leur
bien-être. La complexité du sens de ce mot conduit à le considérer sous sa dimension holistique
c’est-à-dire « santé », donc sur ses plans social, psychologique et mental. Une compréhension qui
peut se rapprocher de celle de Bedet (2022) qui affirme que la pratique des activités physiques de
loisir dans les parcs urbains permet aux usagers d’appartenir à une communauté d’amis et libère
leurs endorphines, dont la dopamine qui est l’hormone naturelle du bonheur de l’être humain. Faire
du vélo ou de la course au parc, active la production d’endorphines des pratiquants et leur offre
une sensation de bien-être et de sérénité. Chaillet (2018) surenchérit dans la même lancée qu’une
promenade dans un espace vert peut évoquer des souvenirs agréables contribuant au bien-être du
promeneur.
Vétusté des infrastructures et matériels de loisirs, nœud de paralysie du bien-être des
visiteurs
La pratique d’une activité de loisir ne saurait être possible sans l’existence de d’infrastructure de
loisirs accessible, bien équipée et de bonne qualité. Les résultats de la figure 2 témoignent que près
de 70% des visiteurs, ont laissé entendre qu’ils n’arrivent pas à pratiquer convenablement leurs
loisirs prisés, ce qui signifie déjà qu’il existe des contraintes auxquelles ils font face. L’existence de
ces contraintes a aussi été signalé par les responsables de structures de loisirs en ces termes : « nous
travaillons vraiment dans de mauvaises conditions ».
554
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Arrivez-vous à pratiquer convenablement vos activités de loisir ?
31,5%
68,5%
Oui
Non
Figure 2 Secteur représentant la possibilité de pratique des activités de loisir
Pour mieux connaitre l’origine de ces mauvaises conditions, il a été établi un tableau
d’hiérarchisation de différentes contraintes. Un tableau qui a placé au premier rang, la mauvaise
qualité des infrastructures et des matériels de loisirs. Ce résultat ne se démarque pas de celui de GSI
et ACPL (2016), qui ont trouvé que dans les collectivités canadiennes, la détérioration des
infrastructures récréatives est la première cause qui empêche les citoyens de profiter des bienfaits
qui découlent des activités physiques et récréatives. Ils sont partiellement similaires à ceux Levesque
et al (2021) qui ont remarqué que même si le parc de Terrebonne au Québec connait une
défaillance d’éclairage, l’insuffisance de sécurisation des espaces et des installations, la désuétude
des composantes du parc et l’insuffisance des lieux de rafraîchissement sont les premiers éléments
critiques qui minent la pratique des loisirs des usagers.
Cet état de détérioration d’infrastructures et de matériels comme principale cause a été fortement
soutenu par les responsables des structures de loisirs. « Les vieilles pistes sont impraticables à cause de la
boue pendant l’hivernage ». « Ce parc a un vieux aménagement qui ne s’adapte plus aux réalités du moment, en
fait les gestionnaires n’ont pas songé à renouveler leur système d’aménagement » renchérit un autre. Les
responsables et agents de la DAPGP tout en reconnaissant cette désuétude pointent du doigt le
manque de moyens financiers pour l’entretien de ces infrastructures et matériels et pour faire face
aux inondations. « Les aménagements que vous voyez datent de 1995 ou 1996 ; beaucoup d’infrastructures sont
détériorées et ne sont pas renouvelées, c’est le cas des pistes, des banquettes, des plateaux de sport, etc. ». Le cas du
PUBWO peut s’inscrire dans un contexte africain, les résultats des auteurs africains placent
généralement la contrainte infrastructurelle (disponibilité, qualité, quantité) au premier lieu.
Alors que faire pour une pratique plus large des loisirs au PUBWO ?
Eu égard aux résultats obtenus et à leur analyse, et en considérant la discussion, il est important de
formuler des suggestions pour une meilleure pratique des activités de loisir et redresser le niveau
de fréquentation du PUBWO.
Penser à une réhabilitation de l’existant avant un réaménagement du parc sous
l’intervention de l’Etat
555
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Le niveau de dégradation des infrastructures et matériels à l’intérieur du parc est critique, les
responsables du parc ont toujours soulevé le manque de moyens financiers, il est souhaitable que
l’Etat burkinabè accompagne la mairie de Ouagadougou pour la réalisation d’un nouvel
aménagement. En attendant un tel réaménagement, il est urgent de réhabiliter quelques
infrastructures de loisirs sportifs en l’occurrence, les pistes, les plateaux et terrain des sports, les
banquettes de soupir.
Ce type de stratégie qui a été murie par la charte africaine de la jeunesse va permettre de redonner
un éclat au parc. Cette réhabilitation doit être suivie d’un apport de matériels et équipements
adéquats pour inciter plus les visiteurs à la fréquentation de ce parc.
Combler un vide juridique par l’élaboration d’une politique communale de loisirs
« Pour le moment nous n’avons de politique communale de loisirs, nous utilisons le programme du mandant du maire,
on se réfère souvent à la PNSL pour l’organisation de nos activités de loisir, cela ne nous facilite pas la tâche » a
laissé entendre le Directeur communal de la Promotion des Sports et des Loisirs. L’acquisition
d’un tel instrument juridique permet de défendre certaines prises de position dans des instances
décisionnelles.
Accorder plus d’attention aux activités physiques de loisir et veiller à leur pratique saine
Les résultats montrent clairement que les activités physiques de loisir sont les plus prisées des
visiteurs. Il serait plus commode de mettre plus d’accent sur ces types de loisirs en pensant à des
stratégiques innovatrices. Le bitumage de certaines pistes surtout les voies principales, la création
d’un parcours de santé, l’aménagement d’une piscine à l’intérieur du parc, l’insertion de balades
avec des chevaux, la mise à disposition des vélos (VTT) aux visiteurs peuvent faciliter plus la
pratique de ces loisirs sportifs.
Conclusion
La pratique des loisirs n’est jamais superflue, elle conduit toujours à un développement que celuici soit social, psychique ou mental. Les lieux de prédilection de pratique de ces loisirs pour certains
adeptes sont les espaces verts en l’occurrence les parcs. Pour des raisons et des motifs divers ces
derniers s’y rendent pour pratiquer une gamme d’activités. Les usagers du PUBWO, en majorité
des jeunes, eux sont friands des activités physiques de loisir comme les promenades, les marches
et les pratiques sportives qui représentent jusqu’à 73,4% des activités. La pratique de ces activités
leur apporte au-delà du divertissement un bien-être tant sur le plan social que sur le plan de la santé.
Dans ces dernières années, près de 70% des usagers de ce parc éprouvent de nombreuses difficultés
dans la pratique de leurs loisirs, toute chose qui les prive de leur bien-être tant adoré. Les résultats
de la hiérarchisation de ces difficultés a placé au haut du tableau l’état vétuste des infrastructures et
matériels de loisirs.
556
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Vu, l’importance de la place qu’occupent les loisirs dans la vie quotidienne des populations de
Ouagadougou, il urge que l’Etat vienne en aide à la commune pour une réhabilitation du parc avant
que les responsables municipaux ne pensent à une éventuelle élaboration d’une politique
communale des loisirs. Ce document doit accorder une part belle aux activités physiques de loisir
qui sont plus prisées dans les parcs comme le montre notre recherche. La persistance de l’insalubrité
du parc ces derniers temps nécessite d’être prise au sérieux par les responsables de la DAPGP qui
peuvent envisager faire la promotion de l’éco-loisirs, ce qui va permettre d’impliquer tous les
acteurs dans la recherche de la salubrité.
References
Association Internationale des Maires Francophones, AIMF. (2010).Transformation de la forêt
d’Ouagadougou en parc urbain et de loisirs (Bangr-Weoogo, la Forêt du savoir). Repéré à
https://www.aimf.asso.fr
Bédet, L. (2022). 5 effets de la nature sur la santé mentale. Programme milieux de vie en santé.
Repéré à https://milieuxdevieensante.org/nature-sante-mentale/.
Bondaz, J. (2011). « Parcs urbains et patrimoine naturel en Afrique de l’Ouest : De la période
coloniale au Cinquantenaire des indépendances ». Géographie et cultures, 79, pp 67-87.
https://doi.org/10.4000/gc.375
Chailet, M. (2018). Les espaces verts urbains à travers le prisme des usagers : approche sociospatiale application à trois cas rennais. Mémoire de master 2 mention aménagement et
urbanisme. Université Rennes 2. Repéré à https://dumas.ccsd.cnrs.fr/dumas02489973/document
Diallo, A. (1998). Valorisation d’un actif naturel à usage éducatif : la forêt du barrage de Ouagadougou.
Mémoire de DEA d’Economie Université de Ouagadougou.
Dumazedier, J. (1962). Vers une civilisation du loisir? Paris : Éditions du Seuil.
Hémon, C. (2014). Le parc urbain : appropriations et pratiques au cœur d’un paysage de « nature » le cas du
parc de l’Arrou à Blois, Loir-et-Cher. Mémoire de Master Recherche de Gouvernance territoriale.
Université François Rabelais, Tours. Repéré à https://serveur.msh-vdl.fr/wpcontent/uploads
Hounga, A ; Tito, M. A et Akoueté, D. (2014). Les loisirs des personnes retraitées de Cotonou au
Bénin. J. Rech. Sci. Univ. Lomé. pp 75-84.
Hounga, A. (2013). Tourisme dans un pays en développement ; l’exemple du Bénin en Afrique de l’Ouest. Thèse
de doctorat unique en Géographie Université Blaise Pascal Clermont-Ferrand.
Jackson, A. (2022). Les Plus Grands Parcs Urbains Au Canada. Repéré à
https://fr.ripleybelieves.com › largest-city-parks-in-cana.
Kaboré, A. J. (2004). Savoir local et gestion des ressources naturelles: l’expérience traditionnelle de gestion de la
forêt naturelle du Parc Urbain Bangr-Weoogo. Maitrise de Biologie Végétale. Université de
Ouagadougou.
Lévesque, J-F., Elliott, J-F., Couture, M-P., Renaud, V., Dejean, C-N., Frenette, G-P., ... Paquet,
M. (2021). Plan directeur des parcs, des équipements et des plateaux extérieurs 2022-2037 de
Terrebonne. Terrebonne une histoire de vie. Repéré à https://www.ville.terrebonne.qc.ca ›
557
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Marchiset, G.V et Gasparini, W. (2010). « Les loisirs sportifs dans les quartiers populaires :
modalités de pratique et rapport au corps ». STAPS n° 87, pp 93- 107. Repéré à
https://www.cairn.info/revue-staps
Marion, L. (2014). Valeur des espaces verts urbains à travers la perception des usagers : Une autre approche des
Services Ecosystémiques Culturels. Citeres. Cnrs. Projet SERVEUR. Université François Rabelais,
Tours. Repéré à https://serveur.msh-vdl.fr/wp-content/uploads
Natura Fondation, (2008). A la découverte du parc urbain Bangr-Weoogo. Edition Birdlife international.
Pagès, J.P. (1993). Démocratie délibérative et perspectives des risques. Rapport de recherche. Paris,
agoramétrie.
Palé, K. (2007). Estimation monétaire du bien -être procuré par un actif naturel à usage récréatif et éducatif : Cas
du Parc Urbain Bangr-Weoogo de Ouagadougou. Mémoire de DEA d’Economie. Université de
Ouagadougou
Politique Nationale des Loisirs. PNL (2009). Document cadre pour la période 2009-2013.
Politique Nationale des Sports et des Loisirs PNSL (2017). Document cadre pour la période 20162020.
558
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Détermination des normes de la valeur physique liée à la santé en
milieu scolaire en Algérie - 13 – 19 ans catégorie garçons
Nacer Abdelkader - Sebbane Mohammed - Belkadi Adel - Remaoun
Mohamed
Institut d’éducation physique et sportive, Université Abdelhamid Ibn-Badis, Mostaganem- Algérie
e- mail : mohamed.sebbane@univ-mosta.dz
Résume
Cette étude à pour objectif de déterminer la santé des élèves algériens à partir d'une série de tests
et mesures d'évaluation relatifs à la valeur physique et par conséquent de déterminer des normes
sur le plan des indices cardio-respiratoires, de la force musculaire et des paramètres biométriques.
Un échantillon de 1200 élèves de sexe masculin dont l'âge varie entre 13 et 19 ans à participer
volontairement à cette étude. L’analyse des résultats montre globalement, que la valeur physique
liée à la sante de notre échantillon se situe à un niveau moyen voir faible. En effet, l'indice
pondéral traduit un retard dans le développement de la valeur physique liée à la sante. Ceci
entraine des problèmes de santé à posteriori, notamment, la surcharge pondérale, la tension
artérielle et des séquelles au niveau de la colonne vertébrale.
Mots clés : Normes, Valeur physique, Santé, Milieu scolaire.
559
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
La sédentarité est un réel problème de santé publique au niveau mondiale (Briand, 2016a).
L’OMS (2020) affirme que le lieu idéal pour sensibiliser les jeunes sur un mode de vie actif et
leur enseigner les connaissances pour adopter des choix favorables à la santé est l’école, car c’est
le milieu dans lequel les jeunes passent une grande partie de leur temps, et qui est accessible
(Sauret, 2008). Plusieurs travaux réalisés sur la prévention et la protection des citoyens de
différents âges dans les pays développés ont confirmés ces résultats (Dumont & Fischer, 2015a;
Edouard et al., 2011). En effet, des résultats obtenus aux USA montrent clairement que la bonne
santé est intimement liée à l’activité physique (Gérard & Haffray, 2018a). Par ailleurs, une récente
étude relevant de l'organisme mondial de la sante (OMS) est arrivée à la conclusion que le
manque d'activité physique est la cause principale de la surcharge pondérale facteur de décès
(Erbüke&Todesco, 2021; Petitgenet, 2012; Tchicaya& Lorentz, 2009). Il s'agit dès lors, de
prendre à bras le corps ce problème. Tous les indicateurs et les témoignages en tout temps
relèvent qu'il faut accorder une importance primordiale à l'activité physique pour le bien être de
l'individu tant sur le plan physique que psychique (Gagnon, 2011; Perrin &Mino, 2019; Poirel,
2017a). Ils mettent l'accent sur les dangers de la sédentarité et son impact néfaste sur les
fonctions de l'organisme (Labie, 2006a; Tchicaya& Lorentz, 2009). Même si les bienfaits de
l'activité physique sont un fait reconnu depuis bien longtemps, l'homme est confronté
actuellement à beaucoup de maladies d'origine cardiaque (Poirel, 2017a), lediabète, l'arthrose,
l'obésité…, qui réduisent son autonomie (Laberge, 2007).
Il a été démontré que plus l'activité physique est pratiquée, plus le niveau d'aptitude de l'activité
cardio-respiratoire et l'amélioration des fonctions de l'organisme entrainent une amélioration du
potentielle santé (Adda & Ali, s. d.; Laroppe, 2010).
En accord avec (ARGUIN, s. d.; Coisne, 2007; Filiatrault, 2014; Riesco, 2009) , l'activité physique
demeure l’un des remèdes les plus pertinents pour favoriser le potentiel énergétique et réguler le
poids du corps.
En Algérie, le Ministère de la Santé en 2010, à avancé que la proportion des maladies liées au
manque de l'activité physique augmente d’une année à l'autre. Dans l'ensemble des Instituts et
laboratoires de recherche, les résultats convergent à leurs tour vers cette thèse (KAMBOUCHE,
DJEKAOUA, & BENLALDJ, 2017). Les pourcentages proposés par l'Organisation Mondiale de
la Santé situe le taux de sédentarité en ALGERIE à 56% pour les hommes et 53% pour les
femmes, d'où son impact sur la surcharge pondérale et l'obésité (Hammiche & Brahamia, 2012).
Ce fléau touche un enfant sur six (Filiatrault, 2014; Zerguine, 2002)
Méthodes et Moyens
Les chercheurs ont utilisés la méthode descriptive. L’échantillon de cette étude est de 1200 élèves
choisi volontairement parmi les garçons scolarisé au cycle moyen et secondaire dont la tranche
d’âge varie de 13 à 19 ans, il correspond à 69,72% de la population relevant des établissements
scolaires..
560
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Batterie de tests utilisés
Après avoir consulté l'ensemble des ouvrages traitant des concepts clés similaires à notre
recherche, nous avons appliqué une série de batterie de tests et mesures physiques (test de
COOPER) concernant la vo2max, le (Fitness gram) test le plus indiqué pour évaluer la valeur
physique liée à la santé. La batterie comprend les tests suivants:
• L'IMC (INDICE DE MASSE CORPORELLE)
• La course –marche (01 mile soit 1609,34m)
• Abdominaux (de la position couchée relever les jambes en pliant les genoux)
• De la position assise, relever le tronc vers l’avant
• Pompes
• Dynamométrie (force de la main)
Résultats
Tableau n° 1 Indice de masse corporelle
âge
13ans
14ans
15ans
16ans
17ans
18ans
19ans
moyenne
Poids
(kg)
43.11
47.02
57.86
61.43
62.05
64.21
64.73
57,20
Taille(m)
maigre
chétif
Surpoids
obèse
31.43%
0.00%
36.84%
31.25%
9.30%
24.56%
26.00%
Poids
normal
54.29%
50.00%
47.37%
52.08%
81.40%
49.12%
48.00%
1.51
1.55
1.65
1.70
1.74
1.74
1.74
1,66
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
3.51%
2.00%
8.57%
11.29%
2.63%
10.42%
9.30%
19.30%
20.00%
5.71%
8.06%
13.16%
6.25%
0.00%
3.51%
4.00%
0.79%
22.77%
54.61%
11.64%
5.81%
.
L'indice de poids du corps en relation avec la taille nous apporte une appréciation du taux de
graisse. L'échantillon étudié se caractérise par un poids au niveau de la moyenne (54,61%). Ce
pourcentage met également en relief la faiblesse des élèves sur le plan pondéral: 11,64% ont un
surpoids et 5,81% sont obèses. Nous savons que les proportions anormales du corps sur le plan
adipeux , la faiblesse de la masse musculaire ainsi que les proportions en eau réduites ont une
incidence fâcheuse sur l'activité physique et entraine des répercussions sur le plan cardiorespiratoire et donc sur toute activité physique même si cette activité à elle seule n'a pas tendance
à faire disparaitre toute présence de graisse au niveau du corps (graisse indispensable).
561
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________
Tableau n° 2 : Normes relative au test du mile
13ans
14 ans 15ans
16ans
17ans
18ans
Evaluation Normes
Normes – Unité de mesure : la minute
Excellent Moins
Moins
Moins
Moins
Moins
16.00-Moins
de
de
de
de
de
20.00
de04.89
06.87
06.58
05.72
04.42
04.22
Bon
12.00--08.25
-08.07
-07.32
-06.24
-05.99
-05.95
15.99
06.87
06.58
05.72
04.89
04.42
04.22
Moyen
08.00—
-09.64
-09.57
-08.93
-07.59
-07.58
-07.69
11.99
08.26
08.08
07.33
06.25
06.00
05.96
Faible
04.00—
-11.03
-11.07
-10.54
-08.95
-09.16
-09.43
07.79
09.65
09.58
08.94
07.60
07.59
07.70
00.00—
Très
11.0411.08- 10.5508.96- et 09.1709.4403.99
faible
et plus et plus et plus plus
et plus et plus
.
45.66% ont un niveau moyen, 27.54% ont un niveau faible
19ans
04.58
Moins
de
-05.93
04.58
-07.28
05.94
-08.64
07.29
08.65et plus
Les résultats ont montrés, un pourcentage de 45,66% dans le niveau moyen. Seuls, 27,54%%
présentent un niveau acceptable. ce résultat est un pourcentage relativement bas concernant cette
catégorie d'âge puisque, les études (CARPET,1985) précisent que cet âge est le moment le plus
propice du développement de l'endurance aérobie (amélioration du système cardio-respiratoire)
compte tenu du développement rapide du muscle cardiaque (développement des vaisseaux et
augmentation de l'activité sanguine. La capacité musculaire dépend de la force musculaire, de
l'endurance et de la souplesse musculaire (Dumont & Fischer, 2015b; Filiatrault, 2014; Poirel,
2017b).
Tableau n° 3: Pompes
Evaluation
16.00-20.00
12.00-15.99
08.00—
11.99
04.00—
07.79
00.00—
03.99
18ans
19ans
44-et
plus
16ans
17ans
Normes
40-et
48-et
plus
plus
49-et
plus
50-et
plus
25-18
43-30
39-27
47-34
48-35
49-35
19-10
17-11
29-15
26-14
33-19
34-21
34-21
09-01
10-03
14-01
13-01
18-04
20-07
20-06
Très
02 et
03et
06et
0.00
0.00
0.00
faible
moins
moins
moins
43,49% ont un niveau moyen, 33,19% ont un niveau faible
05et
moins
Normes
Excellent
Bon
Moyen
Faible
13ans
4ans1
15ans
29-et
plus
26-et
plus
28-19
562
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
En revanche, la partie abdominale a tendance à prendre du volume (embonpoint). Cette
proéminence à des répercussions fâcheuses sur le dos et entraine des séquelles avec
l'augmentation du poids d'où l'apparition de l'obésité et de nombreuses maladies qui coutent à
l'état des dépenses onéreuses (Briand, 2016b; Gérard &Haffray, 2018b; Jany-Catrice, 2016; Labie,
2006b).
Le test de pompes et le test de dynamométrie évaluant la force musculaire des membres
supérieurs (cette force joue un rôle majeur dans la vie de l'individu puisqu'elle est utilisée
quotidiennement (prise d’objets, poussées, tractions) . L'échantillon pour les pompes a obtenu les
résultats suivants: 43,49% (niveau moyen à faible) ; 33,19 %5(niveau faible)
Tableau n° 4: Plier le tronc vers l'avant , position assise
13ans
Evaluation
16.00-20.00
12.00-15.99
08.00—
11.99
04.00—
07.79
00.00—
03.99
Normes
Excellent
Bon
Moyen
Faible
Très
faible
4ans1
15ans
16ans
Normes
33.80et 35.88et 40.22et 39.12et
plus
plus
plus
plus
33.7935.8740.2139.1126.98
28.44
31.37
30.88
26.9728.4331.3630.8720.17
21.00
22.51
22.65
20.1620.9922.5022.6413.35
13.56
13.65
14.42
Moins
Moins
Moins
Moins
de
de
de
de
13.35
13.56
13.65
14.42
17ans
18ans
19ans
38.84et
plus
38.8332.06
32.0525.28
25.2718.50
Moins
de
18.50
41.27 et
plus
41.2631.71
31.7022.14
22.1312.58
Moins
de
12.58
39.89 et
plus
39.8831.46
31.4523.02
23.0114.58
Moins
de
14.58
42.97% ont un niveau moyen, 27,77% ont un bon niveau
Discussion
La promotion de l’activité physique et réduire les comportements sédentaires représente un enjeu
majeur de santé publique. Il est plus que nécessaire d’augmenter la pratique de l’activité physique
et de diminuer la sédentarité. En effet, afin d’améliorer les qualités physiques liées à la santé, qui
sont des facteurs majeurs de la santé de la personne et de la population, il devient nécessaire
d’une part, d’évaluer le niveau des qualités physiques des élèves scolarisés de 13 à 19 ans et
d’autres part, de comparer ce niveau avec les normes de l’organisation mondiales de la santé
(OMS). Cette évaluation des qualités physiques permet d’établir un bilan afin de proposer des
programmes d’activités physiques adaptées aux caractéristiques de la tranche d’âge étudiée. Les
résultats ont montrés un niveau juste moyen aux différents tests et mesures cités auparavant.
Cette identification du niveau de notre échantillon et sa comparaison avec les normes de l’OMS,
montre qu’il est impératif de mettre en place dans les différents paliers de la scolarité, un
563
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________
programme d’activité physique afin de réajuster ou de modifier les comportements pour prévenir
les maladies cardio-respiratoire ou l’obésité qui commence à prendre une ampleur effrayante au ni
Par ailleurs, la piste de la mise en place de programmes d’activité physique adaptée en milieu
scolaire selon le type de région du pays, visant à promouvoir la santé devra montrer des effets
bénéfiques sur la santé de manière particulière. Afin d’approfondir davantage cette thématique,
une prochaine revue de littérature viserait à évaluer l’impact de ces programmes sur les qualités
Physiques et par extension, sur la santé des enfants et adolescents par région (littoral ; hautsplateaux-Sahara). Ces interventions devront influencer la santé actuelle et future, particulièrement
en termes de prévention des MNT.
Conclusion
L'organisation Mondiale de la Santé a consacré de gros efforts à la prévention et à la santé de
l'homme contre les maladies telles que la surcharge pondérale, l'obésité, les maladies cardiovasculaires et les maladies liées à l'inactivité. De nombreuses recommandations sont évoquées par
les organismes internationaux pour lutter contre ces fléaux des temps modernes, différents
moyens de dépistage sont mentionnés. Un des moyens les plus significatifs reste l'activité
physique continue et quotidienne. Il ressort de notre étude que l'activité physique liée à la santé
reste très peu répandue, notamment en ce qui concerne l'adolescent. Il s'agit de tirer la sonnette
d'alarme si nous ne prenons pas les mesures nécessaires à cet effet. Nous recommandons :
• La prise en charge de l'activité physique liée à la santé dans les établissements scolaires en
augmentant le volume horaire afin de lutter contre l'obésité
• Le réaménagement des programmes d'éducation physique liés à la santé
• Le développement et la multiplication de l'activité physique adaptée à chaque âge
• Amélioration de l'activité cardiaque au début de l'adolescence
• Développement de la force musculaire pendant le milieu et la fin de l'adolescence
• Application de la batterie à titre individuel pour évaluer la santé de l'élève durant sa scolarité
et de proposer un programme en fonction de ses capacités et des différentes régions du pays.
Références
Adda, G., & Ali, B. (s. d.). L’IMPACT DE LA PRÉPARATION PHYSIQUE INTEGRÉE SUR
LE NIVEAU DE PERFORMANCE PHYSIQUE CHEZ LES JEUNES
FOOTBALLEURS (U-17).
ARGUIN, H. (s. d.). INTERVENTIONS NUTRITIONNELLES POUR LA PRÉVENTION
ET LE TRAITEMENT DE L’OBÉSITÉ.
Briand, M. (2016a). Des sensations au sujet éthique : La danse physico-mentale du νόος dans la
poésie «lyrique» archaïque. Methodos. Savoirs et textes, (16).
Briand, M. (2016b). Des sensations au sujet éthique : La danse physico-mentale du νόος dans la
poésie «lyrique» archaïque. Methodos. Savoirs et textes, (16).
564
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Caru, M. (2021). Étude des effets de l’activité physique en oncologie pédiatrique : Des paramètres
physiologiques aux paramètres psychologiques.
Chaput, J.-P. (2008). Obesite et modernite : L’emergence de nouveaux stimuli nous amene-t-elle
aredefinir la notion de sedentarite?
Coisne, T. (2007). Contribution à l’étude des effets de l’activité physique sur le fonctionnement
mitochondrial et la production de radicaux libres-Etude sur mitochondries musculaires et
hépatiques (PhD Thesis). Université Joseph-Fourier-Grenoble I.
Dumont, C., & Fischer, L. (2015a). Pratique d’une activité physique régulière après la période
post-partum : Principaux facteurs influents et implications pour la prise en charge
physiothérapeutique: travail de Bachelor (PhD Thesis). Haute école de santé Genève.
Dumont, C., & Fischer, L. (2015b). Pratique d’une activité physique régulière après la période
post-partum : Principaux facteurs influents et implications pour la prise en charge
physiothérapeutique: travail de Bachelor (PhD Thesis). Haute école de santé Genève.
Edouard, P., Morel, N., Serra, J.-M., Pruvost, J., Oullion, R., &Depiesse, F. (2011). Prévention
des lésions de l’appareil locomoteur liées à la pratique de l’athlétisme sur piste. Revue des
données épidémiologiques. Science & sports, 26(6), 307‑315.
Ehrenberg, A. (2008). La fatigue d’être soi : Dépression et société. Odile Jacob.
Erbüke, M., &Todesco, C. (2021). Observation du taux d’activité physique chez les étudiants en
physiothérapie à la Haute école de santé de Genève au cours du cursus scolaire 2020-2021 :
Une étude pilote : Travail de bachelor. Haute école de santé Genève.
Filiatrault, M.-L. (2014). Traitement diététique de l’obésité : Influence des comportements
alimentaires et des perturbations du sommeil sur la perte de poids et de graisse corporelle.
Gagnon, M. (2011). Évaluation du perfectionnisme prescrit par autrui chez des patients souffrant
de maladies cardiovasculaires du Saguenay-Lac-St-Jean et de ses relations avec l’activité
physique, les habitudes alimentaires et le bien-être psychologique. Library and Archives
Canada= Bibliothèque et Archives Canada, Ottawa.
Gérard, S., &Haffray, J.-B. (2018a). Prévention de l’obésité de l’enfant par l’activité physique :
Revue de littérature.
Gérard, S., &Haffray, J.-B. (2018b). Prévention de l’obésité de l’enfant par l’activité physique :
Revue de littérature.
Hammiche, A., &Brahamia, B. R. (2012). Essai d’évaluation des coûts de prise en charge du
diabète sucré en Algérie. Université Abderrahmane mira bejaia/aboudaou.
Jany-Catrice, F. (2016). La mesure du bien-être territorial. Revue de l’OFCE, (1), 63‑90.
Joye, F. (2011). Jeux dangereux et jeux d’évanouissement chez l’enfant et l’adolescent. Congrès
Société française de médecine d’urgence.
KAMBOUCHE, D., DJEKAOUA, D., & BENLALDJ, D. (2017). Prévalence de l’obésité et du
surpoids chez les travailleurs Des résidences universitaires de Kharouba Mostaganem en
2017.
Laberge, S. (2007). Promotion de l’activité physique et impact du niveau de pratique sur certains
facteurs favorisant l’apprentissage. Canada: Comité de gestion de taxe scolaire de l’île de
Montréal.
565
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________
Labie, D. (2006a). Les maladies chroniques, une urgence planétaire. médecine/sciences, 22(1),
68‑70.
Labie, D. (2006b). Les maladies chroniques, une urgence planétaire. médecine/sciences, 22(1),
68‑70.
Lagrange, F. (1912). La fatigue et le repos. F. Alcan.
Laroppe, J. (2010). Promotion de l’activité physique chez le sujet obèse : Évaluation de la
demande et des pratiques professionnelles en médecine générale. UHP-Université Henri
Poincaré.
Loriol, M. (1999). Le temps de la fatigue : La gestion sociale du mal-être au travail. FeniXX.
Perrin, C., &Mino, J.-C. (2019). Activité physique adaptée et enjeux normatifs dans les trajectoires
de maladie chronique aux points de rencontre des approches interactionnistes et de la
philosophie de Georges Canguilhem. Corps, (1), 103‑112.
Petitgenet, C. (2012). Recommandations d’une activité physique régulière en médecine générale :
Évaluation d’un action sur la mesure de l’activité physique par questionnaire. Université de
Lorraine.
Poirel, E. (2017a). Bienfaits psychologiques de l’activité physique pour la santé mentale optimale.
Santé mentale au Québec, 42(1), 147‑164.
Poirel, E. (2017b). Bienfaits psychologiques de l’activité physique pour la santé mentale optimale.
Santé mentale au Québec, 42(1), 147‑164.
Riesco, É. (2009). Effet de l’activité physique seule ou combinée à une diète sur le profil
cardiométabolique et la qualité de vie chez la femme.
Sauret, M.-J. (2008). 3. Psychanalyse et psychothérapie dans l’histoire et dans la contemporanéité
de la santé mentale. Humus-subjectivite et lien social, 37‑53.
Tchicaya, A., & Lorentz, N. (2009). Prévalence des maladies chroniques et facteurs de risque en
matière de santé.
Tessier, M.-P. (2017). Étude de l’activité cardiaque dans l’autisme adulte au repos à deux
moments de la journée : Hyperactivité sympathique matinale.
Zerguine, M. (2002). Caractéristiques de l’obésité massive en Lorraine : L’expérience du centre
médico-diététique de l’ALUMNAT. UHP-Université Henri Poincaré.
566
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Le boom du fitness au Sénégal : le développement de l’activité
physique pour tous à partir d’initiatives privées
Fall Ibrahima
Université Cheikh Anta Diop, Dakar, Sénégal
E-mail: ibrahifall@yahoo.fr
Résumé
Une prise de conscience des problèmes de santé liés à la sédentarité et l’inactivité physique semble
pousser beaucoup de sénégalais vers la pratique des activités de fitness. Ce phénomène qui se
traduit par la multiplication des salles de sport nous amène à chercher le profil et la motivation des
pratiquants, ainsi que la nature des activités et leurs cadres de pratique. Notre méthodologie s’est
basée d’une part, sur approche qualitative « à échelle multiple » épousant les contours d’une
démarche ethnographique qui s’appuie, pour l’essentiel, sur l’enquête par entretien, l’observation
participante, et d’autre part, sur une enquête par questionnaire administrée en ligne. Les résultats
montrent que même s’il est pratiqué en majorité dans les salles de sport, le fitness est également
fait en plein air dans différents espaces publics. Les jeunes âgés de 20 à 40 ans constituent l’essentiel
des pratiquants de fitness au Sénégal. Les motivations tournent autour des préoccupations de santé,
même si la recherche de la performance et le besoin de rencontre apparaissent dans les motifs
invoqués.
Mots clés: Fitness, Aerobic, Remise en forme, Activité physique et sportive
567
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
Une dépense énergétique insuffisante combinée à une alimentation trop riche constituent des
facteurs de risque pouvant entraîner une augmentation des cas de surcharge pondérale et les
maladies cardiovasculaires (OMS, 2017). Ces dernières sont responsables de 17 millions de décès
annuels dont 7,5 millions sont attribués à l’hypertension (OMS, 2006). A cela, s’ajoutent au moins
2,8 millions de décès annuels causés par l’excès pondéral ou l’obésité. Cette situation est une
préoccupation dans beaucoup de pays développés au point d’être l’objet de stratégies et de plans
dans leurs politiques de prévention en santé publique.
Le Sénégal, à l’instar des pays de l’Afrique subsaharienne, présente les mêmes facteurs de risque :
15,8% de la population présente un surpoids, 6,4% une obésité, 14% à la sédentarité ou une activité
physique insuffisante et 5,1% ont une alimentation riche en sel1. Or, la promotion des activités
physiques à visées sanitaires reste l’une des grandes oubliées des politiques publiques, car ne
figurant dans aucun programme ministériel et, de surcroît, les données sportives sont absentes des
statistiques nationales du Sénégal. Pourtant, un accroissement de la pratique des activités physiques
s’observe dans les villes, et même, dans des coins les plus reculés du pays. La préoccupation
grandissante pour la santé et le bien-être pousse les populations vers la pratique régulière d’une
activité physique ou sportive. Cette tendance bénéficie pleinement au secteur de la remise en forme
en général, du fitness en particulier, qui connait un boom spectaculaire depuis quelques années2.
Même s’il n’y a pas de statistiques officielles sur la pratique du fitness, l’augmentation fulgurante
des salles de remise en forme montre que ce phénomène est d’une vitalité sans précédente au
Sénégal. Si le pays ne comptait que deux salles de sport dans les années 1970 (Diatta, 2007),
aujourd’hui, rien qu’à Dakar, on dénombre plus d’une centaine de salles de remise en forme. Cette
étude exploratoire s’efforce d’apporter des éléments de réponses aux interrogations suivantes :
Quel est le profil et la motivation des pratiquants de fitness au Sénégal ? Quelles activités et dans
quel cadre les pratiquent-ils le fitness ?
L’objectif de cette contribution est d’étudier le phénomène du fitness au Sénégal, à travers ses
offres, ses acteurs, ses cadres de pratique.
Fitness : itinéraire d’un concept « importé »
Si aujourd’hui, on utilise souvent, par simplification, le concept de « Fitness », les pratiques
auxquelles il revoit ont connu plusieurs appellations au cours du temps : gymnastique d’entretien,
sport de maintien, (re)mise en forme ou aerobic. Le concept aerobic a été inventé par Kenneth
Cooper, un médecin lieutenant-colonel de l’US Army qui l’a introduit pour la première fois dans
son ouvrage intitulé « Aerobic » devenu un best-seller3. Il a conçu une série d’exercices visant à
améliorer la condition physique des soldats américains à travers l’entraînement du système cardio1Plan stratégique de lutte contre les maladies non transmissibles 2017-2020, Sénégal, Ministère de la Santé et de l’Action
Sociale du Sénégal, avril 2017
2 https://terrasenegal.com/societe/salles-de-fitness-sport-senegal/
3
Cooper K. Areobic, Mass Market Paperback, 1968.
568
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
vasculaire. L’engouement pour cette nouvelle pratique est tel que l’actrice américaine Jane Fonda
l’a adopté et rendu populaire à travers ses nombreuses vidéos diffusées à la télévision dans les
années 19704.
Cette « vague aerobic » (Bessy, 1987) débarque en Europe vers les années 1980 et devient un
phénomène dans les salles de sport. En France, ce sont Véronique et Davina qui, à travers leur
émission de télévision « Gym Tonic » sur l’Antenne 2, ont contribué à développer l’aerobic dans
les années 1980. Le terme aerobic est entré dans le Petit Robert en 1981. En 1986, Gin Miller
invente les cours popularisant encore un peu plus l’aérobic qui, au fur et à mesure de la
multiplication des variantes, se transforme en fitness. En effet, des cours collectifs voient le jour et
le terme aerobic disparait au profit du mot Fitness (mot anglais signifiant « forme physique » que
l’on utilise encore actuellement, un peu sous toutes les formes. L’aérobic est d’ailleurs devenue une
activité parmi d’autres dans le fitness5 qui désigne, selon Le Larousse (2009), « l’ensemble des activités
de (re)mise en forme comprenant de la musculation, du stretching et du cardio-training ». Il ne s'agit pas d'une
discipline précise mais d'un ensemble d’activités physiques permettant de maintenir, d’améliorer sa
condition physique et son hygiène de vie dans un souci de bien-être physique et ou psychologique.
D’ailleurs, Frugier et Choque (2008) estiment qu’il s’agit d’un concept et non d’une activité
physique elle-même.
En 1968, Leslie Roy Mills, ancien athlète néo-zélandais surnommé Les Mills, avait créé des cours
collectifs de remise en forme qui sont pratiqués aujourd’hui par plusieurs millions de personnes
dans le monde. Dans les années 2000, le Colombien Beto Perez crée la Zumba, le Japonais Izumi
Tabata met en place une méthode d’entrainement qui porte son nom « Tabata ». Aujourd’hui, les
formes de pratiques ont évolué et de nouveaux concepts ont redynamisé le secteur du fitness. Il
s’agit notamment de Boot camp, le HBX ou le HIIT qui sont un ensemble de méthodes
d’entrainement regroupant des exercices issus de la gymnastique, permettant d’obtenir un
entraînement complet et performant, tout en pratiquant une activité collective et ludique.
Grâce à une offre diversifiée, l’attrait pour le fitness a grimpé en flèche au point de compter600
millions de pratiquants à travers le monde en 2015, dont 150 millions dans de 200 000 clubs de
santé et de remise en forme6. Dominée par États-Unis, l'Allemagne et le Royaume-Uni, la taille
totale du marché de l'industrie mondiale des clubs de fitness est de plus de 87 milliards de dollars7.
Avec 2,46 milliards d’euros de chiffres d’affaires (en 2016), une croissance de 5% : le marché du
fitness français ne cesse de progresser, jusqu’à devenir le troisième en Europe (IHRSA)8. Selon Le
Bourgeois (2016), 15 millions de français font du fitness (soit 2 fois plus que le nombre de coureurs
à pied) dont 6 millions sont inscrits dans des salles (soit 3 fois plus que le nombre de licenciés en
football !).
https://www.lequipe.fr/Coaching/Fitness/Actualites/Les-origines-du-fitness/742530 - publié le 4 mai 2015 à 11h32
https://www.lequipe.fr/Coaching/Fitness/Actualites/Les-origines-du-fitness/742530
6 Dossier special Fitness, Direct Matin n° 1849 du 18/03/2016.
7 https://www.statista.com/topics/1141/health-and-fitness-clubs/
8
International Health, Racquet & Sportsclub Association
4
5
569
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Méthodologie
Dans le cadre de cette étude, une méthodologie mixte basée à la fois sur une approche qualitative
et une méthode quantitative a été utilisée. Ainsi, des observations ont été effectuées dans plusieurs
salles de sport mais également sur plusieurs sites où des activités de fitness sont menées (les
corniches, les places publiques, sur des terrains de basket, à la plage, au niveau des parcs naturels)
et lors des événements liés au développement et/ou à la promotion du fitness, particulièrement les
sessions de formation et les Fitness-show.
Nous avons mené également des entretiens semi-directifs individuels auprès de plusieurs acteurs :
8 moniteurs de fitness dont le président de l’Association sénégalaise des moniteurs de fitness, 6
gérants de salles de sport, 17 pratiquants de fitness. Tous les entretiens ont été effectués en face à
face à l’aide d’un guide d’entretien, préparé à l’avance et ajusté après quelques entretiens pilotes. Le
guide comprend des questions qui portent sur les types d’activités pratiquées dans les salles de
sport, le profil et les motivations des pratiquants, ainsi que leurs habitudes de consommation des
services liés au fitness. Les entrevues d’une durée de 30 à 90 minutes ont été enregistrées à l’aide
d’un dictaphone numérique pour assurer l’authenticité des propos rapportés. Les données
qualitatives ont été traitées selon une analyse de contenu thématique (Bardin, 1977).
Des données quantitatives sur les pratiquants ont été obtenues eu égard une enquête sous la forme
d’un questionnaire très simple cherchant à connaître, entre autres, le profil et les motivations des
pratiquants, les activités et cadres de pratique. Le questionnaire a été confectionné dans
l’application Google Forms avant d’être testé auprès d’une dizaine de pratiquants de fitness et
administré en ligne en début d’année 2022. Le lien a été partagé dans le groupe WhatsApp de
l’Association sénégalaise des moniteurs de fitness à qui on a invité à partager avec leurs clients.
Nous avons pu recueillir 557 réponses traitées automatiquement par l’application Google Forms
qui dresse les statistiques.
Le cadre de la pratique du fitness au Sénégal
En tant que pratique physique, le fitness s’effectue dans différents lieux et contexte au Sénégal. Le
tableau montre 1 que les salles de sport ne sont plus l’unique endroit où se pratiquent les activités
de fitness au Sénégal. Les lieux de pratiques se sont également diversifiés : à domicile, les espaces
publiques, les parcs naturels et autres sites en plein air reçoivent de plus en plus des adeptes du
fitness.
Les salles de fitness
Le premier cadre de pratique des activités de fitness au Sénégal est la salle de sport dont le nombre
a explosé dans les principales villes du Sénégal. En effet, 71.1 % des pratiquants interrogés affirment
qu’ils l’exercent dans les salles de fitness, même si, il faut le reconnaitre, plusieurs termes sont
utilisés pour désigner ces salles. Par le passé, elles étaient généralement (et le sont toujours)
570
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
désignées sous les termes de « salles de sport », de « salles de gymnastique », « salles de musculation
», « salles de remise en forme ». Toutes ces appellations semblent suivre l’évolution du concept de
fitness et désignent la même réalité, à savoir un lieu mettant à disposition du public des
équipements, un environnement et des prestations d’encadrement visant à l’amélioration de la
condition physique, de la détente et du bien-être de ses clients (SNEF, 2004).
Lieux de pratique
Plage
0,9 %
Parc naturel
2,6 %
Terrain de basketball
2,8 %
A domicile
4,7 %
Parcours sportif
4,7 %
Place publique
13,2 %
Salle de sport
71,1 %
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Source : enquête Fall I. 2022
Figure 1 Représentation des répondants en fonction des lieux de pratique du fitness
Une enquête réalisée par Djiba (1998) a montré qu’il existait 27 salles de remise en forme qui sont
l’œuvre de privés, celle de Fall (2009) a recensé plus de 58 centres de remise en forme dans le
département de Dakar. Aujourd’hui, rien que dans la région de Dakar, on compte plus de 171 salles
de sports (voir tableau 1), de dimensions variables. Elles sont localisées dans différentes structures.
•
•
•
•
•
Les casernes militaires : le complexe sportif de la gendarmerie de Colobane, la salle de sport du
camp Leclerc, la salle de fitness de la gendarmerie de Ouakam, la salle du camp Dial Diop…
Les entreprises privées et parapubliques : salle de sport de l’Agence nationale de la BCEAO, les salles
de sports de agences de la, Sonatel, la salle Samba Gueye de la Lonase.
Les Administrations publiques : salle de sport du Ministère de l’Intérieur
Les Universités et écoles de formation : salle de l’IAM, de l’Université Gaston Berger (UGB), de
l’Université Cheikh Anta Diop (UCAD), de l’Ecole Supérieure Polytechnique (ESP)….
Les structures sanitaires : salle de sport de l’Hôpital Général de Grand Yoff, la salle du Centre
National d’appareillage et d’orthopédie (CNAO).
La multiplication des salles de sport au sein des organisations professionnelles montre qu’au
Sénégal, une tendance en faveur de l’activité physique pour la santé sur le lieu de travail se
développe de plus en plus. Les directions de quelques grandes entreprises ont inscrit la pratique
571
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
des activités physiques et sportives au programme de leurs œuvres sociales. Ce modèle paternaliste
s’inscrit souvent dans une gestion globale et contrôlée des salariés de l’entreprise (Fall, Tine et
Gassama, 2021).
A côté de ces pratiques de fitness sur les lieux de travail, on retrouve une offre commerciale
d’initiative privée. Il s’agit notamment, des nombreuses salles privées qui font du fitness une activité
commerciale rentable. En se basant sur la typologie de Sandy (2002), les salles de fitness de la région
de Dakar peuvent être classées dans plusieurs catégories, selon les critères suivants : la superficie
du Centre, le nombre d’adhérents, le nombre d’encadrants et les produits et services proposés
(activités). A cela, il convient d’y ajouter l’existence ou non d’espaces de pratique différenciés, à
savoir : une salle de musculation, un espace cardio-training, une salle de cours collectifs pouvant
servir également de cours de danse. Ainsi, on aura : les grandes, les moyennes et les petites structure
et les très petites structures qui constituent une catégorie spéciale fréquentée.
•
•
•
•
Grandes structures : Superficie supérieure à 1000 m² ; 61 % de ces clubs ont plus de 1500
adhérents ; 12,6 salariés en moyenne ; plusieurs espaces de pratique (Salle de musculation Espace cardio-training - Cours collectifs - Cours de dance) ;
Structures intermédiaires ou structures Moyennes : Superficie comprise entre 500 et 1000 m²,
¾ ont plus de 500 adhérents ; 6,6 salariés ; une seule salle pour la musculation et les appareils
cardio-training, un espace de cours collectifs ;
Petites structures : Superficie inférieure à 500 m² ; Elles ont moins de 500 adhérents ; environ
1,7 encadrants ; une seule salle pour accueillir tous les pratiquants de musculation et de cours
collectifs ;
Très petites structures (c’est une catégorie spéciale de salles que l’on retrouve dans les
quartiers populaires et en banlieue au Sénégal) : superficie inférieure à 100 m² qui se résume
en une petite salle dans laquelle quelques appareils sommaires de musculation sont installées
pour les besoins des jeunes lutteurs et pratiquants de bodybuilding, sans la présence d’un
encadrant.
Tableau 1 Le nombre de salles de fitness dans la région de Dakar
Départements Nombre de Grandes
de Dakar
salles total Structures
Très
petites
structures
Dakar
46
2
11
14
19
Pikine
61
0
17
21
23
Guédiawaye
45
1
9
18
17
Rufisque
19
0
2
6
11
Total
171
3
39
59
70
Source : enquête Fall I. 2022 (recensement effectué avec l’aide des moniteurs de fitness)
572
Moyennes
structures
Petites
structures
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Chaque catégorie de salle propose des tarifs adaptés aux conditions économiques des pratiquants
qui la fréquentent. En effet, les grandes structures qui exigent un abonnement mensuel dépassant
60 euros sont fréquentées en général par des cadres supérieurs, tandis que les très petites structures
permettent à leurs abonnés (aux possibilités financières plus réduites) de payer moins de 7 euros
par mois et, très souvent, moins d’un euro la séance à ceux qui n’ont pas un revenu stable.
Si le fitness est associé la plupart du temps aux salles de sport, force est de constater qu’il investit
désormais de nouveaux territoires et prend parfois de nouvelles formes de pratique au Sénégal. En
effet, pratiquer le fitness est également devenu possible en-dehors des salles de sport classiques.
Les espaces de pratique en plein air
On n'est sans doute plus dans les temps où le fitness n'était pratiqué que dans les salles de sport
traditionnelles. Désormais les pratiquants se tournent vers des espaces en plein air, sur des terrains
vagues, des places publiques ou tout le long des corniches.
• Les parcours sportifs
La figure 1 montre que 4,7 % des personnes interrogés pratiquent le fitness au niveau des circuits
aménagés au niveau de différents parcours sportifs (notamment celui de la corniche ouest, des
HLM et de Diamalaye) et 2,6 % au niveau de parcs naturels comme celui de Hann. Le premier
parcours sportif de Dakar est celui de la corniche ouest de Dakar qui est né de l’initiative de deux
professeurs de l’INSEPS9 qui, bénéficiant de l’appui financier de la Mission Française et de la
commune de Dakar. Leur projet est concrétisé en avril 1986 avec l’autorisation de la Mairie de
Dakar (Keita, 1988). Aujourd’hui, on assiste à une multiplication des parcours sportifs dans la ville
de Dakar. Il s’agit par exemple des parcours sportifs des HLM, de Guédiawaye, des Parcelles
Assainies (Diamalaye), de la Foire (CICES), etc. A cela, il convient de souligner l’existence de
parcours sportifs créés dans les espaces naturels comme le Parc de Hann, le Technopole ou la forêt
classée de Mbao qui connaissent, depuis quelques années, une grande affluence.
• Les places publiques
A côté des salles de fitness et des parcours aménagés pour la pratique sportive, de nombreuses
places publiques servant de plateaux de cours collectifs de fitness sont envahis tous les soirs par
des centaines de personnes désireuses de s’adonner à des activités physiques en plein air. Ainsi,
13.2 % des enquêtés pratiquent le fitness au niveau de places publiques, 2.8 % sur des terrains de
basket-ball appartenant aux collectivités territoriales. C’est ainsi que la place de l’Obélisque, les
Allées Seydou Nourou Tall, le Rond-point des HLM Grand Yoff, sont autant de lieux de
regroupement de pratiquants sous la direction de moniteurs de fitness.
Alain Monsellier et Georges Grave, deux enseignants de l’INSEPS, ont eu l’idée de créer des espaces naturels opérationnels
permettant à la population dakaroise de s’adonner à une pratique plus rationnelle de leurs activités
9
573
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Les cours de fitness à domicile
Nombreux sont les sénégalais qui pratiquent le fitness à domicile, soit seuls en imitant le plus
souvent des vidéos sur YouTube, soit à l’aide d’un coach personnel (appelé « personal trainer »
dans le langage du secteur). Ce phénomène de cours à domicile s’est accentué avec le confinement
imposé par les mesures de restrictions prises pour lutter contre la propagation du coronavirus
responsable de la pandémie Covid-19. Ainsi, malgré la réouverture des salles de sport, certains
adaptes du fitness continuent de pratiquer leurs activés favorites à domicile (4.7 % des enquêtés
dans le cadre de notre étude).
Que ce soit dans les salles de sports ou en plein air, le profil et les motivations des pratiquants sont
divers.
Profils et motivations des pratiquants des fitness au Sénégal
Le fitness séduit de plus en plus de sénégalais, sans distinction de sexe, d’âge ou de catégorie
socioprofessionnelle, mais avec des motivations différentes.
Le profil des pratiquants de fitness au Sénégal
Les activités de fitness sont plus pratiquées par les hommes (59,7 %) que par les femmes (40,3 %).
Toutefois, il convient de souligner que la participation des femmes s’est accrue depuis une
quinzaine d’années, puisque le taux était de 30,84 % en 2007 (Diatta, 2007). Cette situation
s’explique par l’arrivée de nouvelles formes de pratiques beaucoup moins accès sur le
développement de la force, et plus orientées vers des formes dansées comme la zumba et le body
balance.
Plusieurs recherches ont montré que les salles de fitness sont fréquentées en majorité par des
célibataires (Diatta, 2007 ; Dièye, 2011 ; Sané, 2014).
Globalement, c’est chez les jeunes que s’observent les niveaux de pratique les plus importants. Plus
de la moitié des pratiquants (51,7 %) ont un âge compris entre 20 et 30 ans, tandis que 27,8 % sont
âgés de 31 à 40 ans. Les mêmes tendances ont été observées dans des études antérieures menées
au Sénégal.
Les moins de 20 ans et les plus de 60 ans se singularisent par un niveau plus faible de pratique.
Avec l’avancée en âge, on observe une diminution de l’activité de fitness qui deviennent de plus en
plus intense avec l’arrivée des cours de bady-attack et de body combat, au profit d’un niveau
d’activité physique modéré comme la marche. La grande majorité des pratiquants a un niveau
d’étude supérieur (78 %) et exerce des activités professionnelles en tant que cadres supérieurs (35,6
%). Le deuxième taux de pratique de fitness se retrouve au niveau des individus ayant atteint le
niveau d’étude moyen/secondaire et des employés (tableau 2).
574
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Tableau 2 Profil sociodémographique des pratiquants
Genre
Femme
Homme
Catégories d’âge
- de 20 ans
20-30 ans
31-40 ans
41-50 ans
51-60 ans
61-70 ans
+ de 70 ans
Niveaux d’étude
Non scolarisé
Elémentaire
Moyen/Secondaire
Supérieur
Occupations professionnelles
Cadres supérieurs
Employé
Profession libérale
Élèves et étudiants
Femme au foyer
Cadre moyen
Recherche d’emploi
Sportifs
Artisan
Source : enquête Fall I. 2022
%
40.3
59.7
%
0.7
51.7
27.8
15.9
2.6
0.7
0.7
%
0.7
1.3
20
78
%
35.6
23.5
12.7
11.4
0.7
7.7
4
2.3
2.1
La motivation à la pratique du fitness
La figure 2 présente les motifs de pratique évoqués par les personnes interrogées et indique la
variété des motivations qui poussent des sénégalais à pratiquer du fitness.
Les résultats montrent à l’évidence la place prépondérante qu’occupe l’amélioration de la santé et
du bien-être comme motif de la pratique le plus cité (73,5 %) chez des personnes interrogées.
L’amélioration de la condition physique se positionne à la deuxième place des motivations évoquées
par nos enquêtés (47,7 %).
575
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Motivations à la pratique du fitness
Faire des rencontres
9,3 %
Maigrir et/ou garder sa ligne
24,5 %
Développer sa performance sportive
25,2 %
Se divertir
27,8 %
Réduire son stress, se relaxer
33,8 %
Améliorer sa condition physique
47,7 %
Améliorer sa santé et son bien-être
73,5 %
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Source : enquête Fall I. 2022
Figure2 Motivations à la pratique du fitness au Sénégal
La dimension esthétique est présente dans les motifs de 24,5 % de pratiquants qui veulent « maigrir
et/ou garder la ligne ». En effet, si l’apparence occupe une place importante dans les sociétés
occidentales (Amadieu, 1990) où la silhouette plus ou moins fine ou empâtée est considérée comme
une facilitatrice d’intégration sociale (Vigarello, 2012), au Sénégal, beaucoup de femmes cherchent
également à ressembler à ce modèle ou « idéal » qui est en réalité une norme de corps « importée ».
Toutefois, une étude menée par Tine et Fall (2015) a pu montrer le dilemme de certaines
sénégalaises pratiquantes de fitness de vouloir à la fois maigrir sur certaines parties de leur corps
tout en gardant le reste inchangé. « Je fais du fitness parce qu’on m’a dit qu’il peut me permettre d’avoir un
ventre plat, je veux seulement maigrir du ventre mais pas les fesses » (une pratiquante).
Les scores élevés des items « améliorer sa santé et le bien-être » et « « réduire son stress, se relaxer
», ajoutés à celui relatif aux préoccupations esthétiques montrent l’importance, chez les sujets
interrogés, de la pratique du fitness pour la santé physique et mentale. Les mêmes tendances ont
été trouvées dans des études réalisées chez des pratiquants de fitness au Sénégal où, la recherche
du bien-être et de la santé domine dans les motivations des pratiquants de fitness (Diémé, 2006 ;
Sané, 2014).La dimension hédoniste qui se manifeste à travers la recherche du plaisir par le
divertissement (27,8 % de réponses) montre.
Même si l’amélioration de la performance sportive (25,2 % de réponses) apparaît aujourd’hui
relativement secondaire par rapport aux motivations relatives au plaisir ou à la préservation de la
santé, la compétition et le challenge est d’une grande importance pour les sportifs qui souhaitent
développer leurs qualités physiques à travers des programmes de musculation. L’entretien du corps
« athlétique » devient un objectif primordial chez les pratiquants de la banlieue composés dans leur
grande majorité de lutteurs en quêtes d’un corps hypertrophié comme chez les culturistes (Gillet &
576
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
White, 1992). « La grande majorité des salles de sport de la banlieue n’offre que des séances de musculation. Ce
sont des salles qui reçoivent beaucoup de jeunes qui pratiquent la lutte. Ils cherchent à développer leur musculature,
ils font de la gonflette » (un moniteur).
Par ailleurs, on note l’affirmation d’une forme de sociabilité chez certains pratiquants qui espèrent
« faire des rencontres » (9,3 % de réponses, loin derrière les autres motifs de pratique). En effet,
l’adhésion à un club de remise en forme favorise en outre les contacts sociaux, raison pour laquelle
les salles de fitness sont considérées comme de véritables lieux de rencontre10.
Les offres de prestations dans les salles de fitness
Le fitness est une activité commerciale, un moyen de générer des profits par la mise en place d’un
service qui vient satisfaire les besoins et attentes des clients.
Types de pratiques
Body pump
4%
Yoga, stretching
7,1 %
Cours de danse
8%
Cardiotraining
12,2 %
Low impact aerobic
18,3 %
Zumba
20 %
Musculation
34,7 %
Gym bâton
44 %
Step
46,7 %
Body attack, Body combat
58 %
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
Source : enquête Fall I. 2022
Figure3 Les activités de fitness pratiquées au Sénégal
Dresser un panorama de l’ensemble des activités de fitness pratiquées au Sénégal semble difficile.
Le fitness renvoie concrètement à des pratiques extrêmement diverses : de la course à pied aux
cours collectifs en aerobic, en passant par des pratiques douces (yoga, tai-chi, etc.) en groupe ou
bien des séances de Rando-fitness (marche en groupe qui se termine par un cours d’aerobic). Cette
situation est accentuée par la grande diversification des « concepts »11 qui rend délicate leur
observation et qui renvoie à de fortes évolutions des pratiques ces deux dernières décennies. En
fait, 58 % (figure 3) des enquêtés pratiquent le Body-combat et le Body-attack, des concepts créés
par LesMills adoptés par des millions de pratiquants à travers le monde12. Ces cours devraient être
10
https://senego.com/salles-de-sport-a-dakar-les-muscles-de-lamour_483151.html
Il faut entendre ici « Concept » comme étant une forme de pratique créé par les grandes industries du Fitness comme LES
MILLS, HBX, etc.
12
https://www.lesechos.fr/2002/06/les-mills-ou-le-fitness-clefs-en-main-694744
11
577
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
pratiquées uniquement dans les salles ayant acheté la licence et dispensées par des coachs en contrat
avec la société LesMilss. Toutefois, on remarque que la quasi-totalité des salles de Dakar les
affichent dans leurs programmes, en plus du body pump qui récoltent respectivement les scores de
8 % et 4 % dans notre étude. Si le body pump est apparu très peu dans les réponses c’est
certainement dû au fait que sa pratique nécessite du matériel (barres, haltères, step) et d’autre part
son intensité qui décourage les personnes en âge avancé.
Les cours de step viennent en deuxième place des activités les plus pratiquées (46,7 % de réponses)
par les personnes interrogées. Inventé par Gim Miller, ce cours nécessite un matériel particulier :
les « step », dont le prix n’est pas accessible par la quasi-totalité des Petites structures qui sont
obligées d’utiliser des « bancs » en bois commandés chez les menuisiers du coin.
Conclusion
En l’absence de politiques publiques sportives pour la santé, de nombreux sénégalais en général,
les citadins en particulier, s’adonnent à la pratique des activités de fitness qui, au cours des dernières
années, s’est considérablement accrue. Cette contribution s’est attachée à étudier le profil et la
motivation des pratiquants, les différents cadres de pratiques ainsi que les types d’activités qu’ils
exercent. Au Sénégal, le portrait type du pratiquant de fitness pourrait se décrire comme suit : un
homme âgé de 20 à 30 ans, avec un niveau d’étude supérieur, ayant un statut d’employé dans ses
occupations professionnels. Les principales motivations tournent essentiellement autour des
préoccupations de santé et de bien-être des pratiquants, même si par ailleurs, des motifs liés à la
performance sportive sont invoqués.
Les salles de sport restent le lieu privilégié de la pratique du fitness, ce qui explique, en partie, leur
floraison dans toutes les villes du Sénégal. Cependant, force est de constater qu’aujourd’hui les lieux
de pratiques du fitness se sont diversifiés. En effet, la fréquentation des nombreux espaces publics
et des parcs naturels par les adeptes du fitness est un phénomène social de grande envergure qui
traduit, dans une certaine mesure, une logique de démocratisation de l’accès à ces nouvelles formes
de pratiques, jusque-là rester la chasse gardée des entrepreneurs.
Par ailleurs, les formes de pratiques du fitness ont fortement évoluées et se sont diversifiées. Elles
vont des activités traditionnelles comme la musculation avec haltères et la gymnastique d’entretien,
aux nouvelles pratiques importées, à l’image des nombreux concepts tels le body-attack, le body
combat, la zumba et le tabata. Le fitness couvre aujourd’hui un large champ de pratiques
hétérogènes qui concourent au bien-être de l’individu, avec une demande qui semble évoluer
davantage vers des services annexes : massage, hammam, sauna, soins du corps.
Bibliographie
Amadieu, J.-F. (1990). Le poids des apparences. Beauté, amour et gloire. Paris : Odile Jacob, coll. « Poches
Odile Jacob », édition 2005.
578
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Badji, A. (2008). La pratique de la gymnastique d’entretien chez les personnes âgées de plus de 50
ans à Dakar, Mémoire de maitrise ès STAPS, INSEPS, Dakar.
Bardin, L. (1977). L'Analyse de contenu. Paris : Presses Universitaires de France.
Bessy, O. (1987). Les salles de gymnastique. Un marché du corps et de la forme. Esprit, n° 4, 7994.
Cooper K. (1968). Areobic, Mass Market Paperback.
Diatta, M. (2007), Profil et motivation a la pratique de la musculation en salle, Mémoire de maitrise ès
STAPS, INSEPS, Dakar.
Diémé, C. S. (2006). Composition corporelle et motivation des pratiquants a l’activité physique
d’entretien dans les salles de gymnastiques et au niveau du parcours sportif de la corniche
ouest de Dakar, Mémoire de maitrise ès STAPS, INSEPS, Dakar.
Dièye, I. (2011). Importance et influence de « l’ordonnance d’activité physique et sportive » dans le
traitement et la prise en charge du surpoids et de l’obésité à Dakar : cas des salles de fitness
et des « parcours sportifs », Mémoire de maitrise ès STAPS, INSEPS, Dakar.
Djiba, E. (1998). Contribution de la gymnastique de maintien à l’amélioration de la santé au Sénégal,
Mémoire de Maîtrise ès STAPS, INSEPS, Dakar.
Fall, I. (2009). Référentiel d’activités et de compétences des moniteurs de fitness au Sénégal. Mémoire
de DESS en Ingénierie et gestion de la formation, CESAG, Dakar.
Fall, I., Tine, C. T., & Gassama, M. (2021). La randonnée pédestre en milieu professionnelle :
l’instrumentalisation managériale d’une activité physique et sportive au Sénégal. Revue
Internationale Du Marketing Et Management Stratégique, 3(2). Consulté à l’adresse https://revuerimms.org/index.php/home/article/view/130.
Faye, B. (2007). Le profil de la condition physique de pratiquants de fitness : Etude comparative
entre hommes et femmes, Mémoire de maitrise ès STAPS, INSEPS, Dakar.
Gillet, J. & White, P. G. (1992). Male bodybuilding and the reassertion of hegemonic masculinity:
A critical feminist perspective. Play and Culture, 5, 358-369.
Goudiaby, S. (2010), Motivations et pratique du fitness en salle : le cas des femmes de la commune
de Dakar, Mémoire de maitrise ès STAPS, INSEPS, Dakar
Le Larousse. (2009), Le Petit Larousse illustré. Paris : Editions Larousse. p191.
Nolwenn, Le B., (2016). STEP : De l’école aux associations. EP&S Editions.
Sandy M. (2002), Structuration du secteur de la remise en forme, Rapport de stage, Université
Grenoble.
Sané, A. B. (2014). Etude de la qualité de service perçue par les pratiquants dans les salles de fitness
de Dakar, Mémoire de maitrise ès STAPS, INSEPS, Dakar.
SNEF. (2004). Centre de remise en forme ou de fitness, Syndicat National des Entreprises du Fitness,
Paris.
Tine, C. T. ; Fall, I. (2015). Les représentations du corps chez les femmes pratiquant le fitness à
Dakar, Le Journal de la recherche Scientifique de I'Université de Lomé, Série 8,17, pp, 285 à 293.
Vigarello, G. (2012). La silhouette du XVIIIe siècle à nos jours : naissance d’un défi. Paris : Seuil, coll. «
Albums »
579
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
580
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
La lutte de KÃGOR-YÕ du peuple "SAN" de Nayala au Burkina
Faso: une pratique saine des enfants a sauvegarder
Boukaré Ouedraogo - Augustin Pale - Sakré Pakode
Institut des Sciences, des Sports et du Développement Humain, Université Joseph KI-ZERBO, Burkina Faso
e-mail : ouedboukra@gmail.com
Résumé
Dans la province de Nayala au Burkina Faso, se pratique la lutte de kãgor-yõ, une activité ludomotrice
ancestrale du peuple "san" qui met en branle un corps à corps direct entre les enfants. Peuple de
lutteur, les "San" entreprennent leurs activités de lutte dès le bas âge et le kãgor-yõ constitue un des
premiers cadres initiatiques dans la trajectoire sociale de l’individu "san". A travers ce noble art, les
enfants "san" se frottent, s’affrontent, se forment, apprennent et intériorisent la culture "san" dans
le but de gravir les échelons de la socialisation. Pour saisir la part contributive du kãgor-yõ à
l’édification de l’être "san", un séjour a été effectué dans la province de Nayala où une observation
participante a été réalisée sur la pratique physique de tradition. De l’analyse des résultats, il ressort
que le kãgor-yõ est une activité physique qui offre un mode de vie saine aux enfants "san" tout en
favorisant leur intégration socioculturelle dans le milieu d’appartenance. Cependant, les résultats
exposent également que ce patrimoine ludique du peuple "san" est menacé de disparition par les
mutations physiques et socioculturelles du milieu "san". Ainsi, la recherche suggère une
redynamisation de la lutte de kãgor-yõ à travers sa codification en une discipline sportive suivie de
son intégration dans les programmes scolaires en vue d’assurer sa sauvegarde.
Mots clés : kãgor-yõ, "san", Nayala, lutte, pratique physique saine.
Keywords: kãgor-yõ, "san", Nayala, wrestling, healthy physical practice.
581
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
Le kãgor-yõ est une lutte de tradition pratiquée par les enfants en pays "san". Peuple du Nord-ouest
du Burkina Faso, les "san" ou les samo sont connus par cette pratique ancestrale transmisse de
génération en génération et qui fait la fierté du pays depuis la nuit des temps.
Incarnant l’ossature sociale et l’identité culturelle "san", cette lutte représente l’une des premières
étapes importantes à gravir par les enfants dans le processus de la socialisation de l’être "san". Elle
permet dès le bas âge la transmission des valeurs cardinales de la société "san" à l’image de la
solidarité, du fair-play, de l’intégration, du patriotisme, du vivre ensemble, etc.
En effet, bien que la lutte de kãgor-yõ soit une activité de combat, sa contribution à la promotion
d’un mode de vie saine chez les enfants ne réside pas dans la dimension martiale mais plutôt dans
la transmission de valeurs physiques et morales telles que l’endurance, la prudence, la patience,
l’aménité, la politesse, etc.
A
ce sujet, Dohin (2003, p. 23) souligne que l’idée principale des luttes traditionnelles est d’ailleurs
cette notion d’affrontement à mains nues, le combat fraternel où l’objectif n’est pas de mettre
l’adversaire à mort, mais au contraire, d’accepter l’opposition comme fondement de l’unité du
groupe, comme une garantie de sa bonne santé.
Cependant ce cadre d’éducation par excellence de l’enfant "san" est menacé de disparition par les
mutations physiques et socioculturelles que connait actuellement le milieu "san". En se penchant
sur le kãgor-yõ, notre objectif est d’analyse sa part contributive à la promotion d’un mode de vie
saine en milieu "san" ; une analyse qui pourra jeter les bases de sa sauvegarde au profit de la
génération future.
Cette recherche s’articule autour de trois points essentiels à savoir le cadre conceptuel et
méthodologie qui en constitue le premier, l’analyse des résultats le second et la discussion le
troisième.
Cadre théorique et méthodologie
Cadre théorique
La théorie est un moyen de donner un sens à des connaissances (Palé, Bassolé et Sawadogo, 2020,
p. 379). Elle part d’un intérêt pour certains phénomènes sociaux et de la reconnaissance de
problèmes qui demandent une explication. Le grand défi de la théorie est sa pertinence, à savoir sa
capacité de refléter la réalité. Dans l’analyse de la part contributive de la lutte de kãgor-yõ à la
promotion d’un mode de vie saine chez l’enfant, nous avons estimé que la théorie du jeu pourrait
appréhender cette réalité. Découlant essentiellement des champs psychologiques et sociologiques,
l’étendue des approches sur le jeu dans ces domaines de recherche montre un foisonnement
d’investigation de la part de plusieurs chercheurs. Mais notre choix théorique se porte sur celle du
582
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
"Jeux, sport et société" de Pierre Parlebas (1999). Cet auteur a analysé les fonctions physiques,
sociales et culturelles des jeux dans la formation de l’être et affirme dans la même lancée que Mauss
(1934), que les techniques du corps seraient particulières à chaque société. A de multiples cultures
différentes correspondent une multitude de jeux dissemblables: chaque jeu physique constitue une
ethno-motricité dont la société d’appartenance oriente et fait évoluer en fonction de ses besoins
spécifiques.
De cadre théorique, découle un modèle d’analyse axé sur la structure et la fonction du kãgor-yõ. Sa
branche structurelle expose les éléments cinétiques qui composent la pratique, les pas de danse, les
techniques de combat et de chutes conduisant à la victoire, le rapport techniques entre le lutteur et
de son corps et du corps de son adversaire, etc. En un mot, cette analyse tente de décomposer le
kãgor-yõ en unités indivisibles. Sa sphère fonctionnelle examine le contenu de jeu, sa fonction
physique, sociale, culturelle et environnementale qui concourt à l’édification de la vie saine des
enfants en milieu "San".
La démarche méthodologique
Pour saisir les différentes articulations de cette pratique endogène du peuple "san", nous avons
adopté une démarche anthropologique notamment, l’observation participante comme méthode et
technique de collecte des données. Ainsi, nous nous sommes introduit dans la province de Nayala,
le terroir du peuple "san" et le berceau de la de la lutte de kãgor-yõ.
Située à 190 kilomètres au Nord-ouest de Ouagadougou la capitale du Burkina Faso, la province
de Nayala se trouve dans la région de la Boucle du Mouhoun. Elle a pour chef-lieu Toma. Elle est
délimitée au Nord par la province du Sourou, au Sud par la province du Mouhoun, à l’Est par les
provinces du Sanguié et du Passoré et à l’Ouest par la province de la Kossi. Elle compte six
communes (Gassan, Gossina, Kougny, Yaba, Ye, Toma), 109 villages et couvre une superficie de
3923 km2 avec une population estimée à 223090 habitants dont 110639 hommes et 112451 femmes
(INSD, 2020, p. 36).
L’observation participante dans ce peuple de lutteur a consisté en une immersion au cœur et avec
la population étudiée afin d’observer l’objet de recherche de l’intérieur. Cette démarche in situ nous
a permis de prendre part aux différentes rencontres de lutte, d’interagir et de discuter autant que
possible avec les acteurs de son monde. Cela a été possible grâce à l’apprentissage de la langue
locale et des séjours d’une durée globale d’une année dans les communes et les villages abritant la
lutte de kãgor-yõ.
Les outils de recueils de données ont été le journal de bord ou le carnet de terrain. Nous l’avons
utilisé pour noter toute sorte d’informations utiles au cours du séjour. Outil professionnel de base
de l’anthropologue, le carnet est le lieu où s’opère la conversion de l’observation participante en
données ultérieurement traitables (Oliver de Sardan (1995). Ainsi, nous avons transformé les
interactions pertinentes en données dans le carnet le plus souvent aux moments de se coucher ou
immédiatement après le réveil.
583
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Nous avons également utilisé une grille d’observation systématique et compartimentée en plusieurs
rubriques pour identifier les différentes dimensions et composantes de la pratique. Le remplissage
de la grille d’observation s’est fait de façon discrète et l’exploitation des séquences de lutte que nous
avons filmées avec notre appareil IPhone a facilité la tâche.
Quant au traitement des données qui sont purement qualitatives, nous avons choisi l’analyse de
contenu de Bardin (1977) comme méthode de traitement. Ainsi, nous avons élaboré un format
d’analyse en fonction de nos objectifs de recherche. Les trois étapes de l’analyse de contenu à savoir
la retranscription, le codage des informations ou les tri-thématiques et le traitement proprement dit
ont donc été abordées.
Résultats
Qu’est-ce que la lutte de kãgor-yõ ?
Pratique lointaine, transmise de génération en génération, les origines de la lutte traditionnelle du
peuple "san" semble être méconnues de nos jours. Cette situation est commune à la plupart des
sociétés sans écriture qui grave, le plus souvent, leur histoire dans des sources orales généralement
détenues par les griots dont la disparition d’un des leurs peut faire perdre le fil des récits.
Mais la majorité des thèses avancées, admet que la pratique ancestrale aurait une origine externe
qui remonte depuis le Mandingue (actuel Mali) où les ancêtres des "San" ont émigré vers la première
moitié du XIIIe, pour s’installer dans le Yatenga en pays moose (Nyamba, 1992, P. 32). Malgré
cette origine lointaine et méconnue, la lutte traditionnelle s’est parfaitement adaptée aux conditions
socioculturelles des différentes époques traversées pour devenir une pratique sociale de référence
chez les "San".
En effet, on y dénombre plusieurs types de luttes traditionnelles qui rythment le quotidien des
"San" et qui remplissent des fonctions particulières dans leur société. Certaines sont sacrées c’està-dire réservées aux initiés et d’autres, profanes, sont ouvertes à tous (adulte, enfants, étrangers,
etc.). C’est dans cette dernière catégorie de lutte que se trouve la lutte de kãgor-yõ qui s’effectue
généralement en saison sèche et suivant l’accomplissement des besoins ludiques des enfants. Elle
se réalise aussi dans la journée que dans les nuits de clair de lunaire.
La lutte de kãgor-yõ est un combat de corps à corps direct et à mains nues qui opposent les enfants
dont l’âge est compris entre cinq (05) à douze (12) ans. Le but du combat est de terrasser l’adversaire
en se servant de son potentiel physique et technico-tactique.
Le mot kãgor-yõ attribué à cette pratique ancestrale tire son origine de la radicale "kã" qui veut dire
"son de mil" et du suffixe "yô" qui signifie "lutte" en langue locale. Le lieu de prédilection de cette
forme de lutte est l’espace où les femmes du village se retrouvent, le plus souvent, pour piler le mil.
Généralement, il se situe devant les concessions ou au centre du quartier ou du village.
584
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Chez les "San", les femmes pilent le mil à l’aide de gros mortiers faits à base de troncs d’arbres.
Elles enlèvent les grains et rejettent les débris et le son de mil qui s’entassent pour former une
couche épaisse au sol, rendant ainsi le cadre propice à la pratique de la lutte chez les enfants. En
effet, plus l’épaisseur de la couche du son au sol est grande, plus sa capacité d’amoindrir l’effet des
chutes est élevée. Cela permet de réduire au maximum les risques de blessures et d’attirer davantage
les enfants à la pratique de la lutte de kãgor-yõ.
L’organisation de la lutte kãgor-yõ repose sur la structuration spatiale du milieu "san". Dans cette
disposition spatiale, l’unité de base est la concession qui regroupe l’ensemble des maisons
appartenant à une même famille. Après cette unité de base suit le quartier qui constitue un
regroupement de plusieurs concessions et l’ensemble des quartiers forment le village.
Généralement le quartier porte le nom du lignage qui l’occupe. Ce qui fait du village "san" un
regroupement de plusieurs lignages ayant des liens avec d’autres villages proches ou éloignés.
Ainsi la lutte de kãgor-yõ s’organise d’abord entre les enfants d’une même concession, ensuite d’un
même quartier et enfin du même village entier. A l’étape du quartier, la lutte de kãgor-yõ prend déjà
l’allure d’une véritablement compétition en ce sens que ce sont des enfants d’une même concession
qui se sont affrontés pour déterminer les plus fort qui partent à la conquête du quartier (compétition
inter-concession ou au sein d’une même lignée) ou du village (compétition inter-quartier ou interlignagère). A l’image de la trajectoire sociale de l’individu "san", la trajectoire du lutteur traditionnel
"san" a également le quartier ou le lignage comme point de départ.
Le déroulement de la lutte de kãgor-yõ se débute par une exécution des pas de danse autour de
l’arène, entrecoupés par des sauts de lutte. Après cette démonstration de force, les adversaires se
désignent et les combats directs de corps à corps peuvent commencer. Chaque lutteur peut lutter
autant de fois qu’il souhaite.
Après ces multiples affrontements de la lutte de kãgor-yõ suivant l’ossature spatiale qui ont rythmé
l’atmosphère ludique des villages, viennent d’autres types de luttes auxquels font face les enfants
de la zone "san". Il s’agit des luttes de tõlèdouan-yõ ou la lutte des bergers, de pĩnti ou la petite arène
de bͻlͻgule ou la grande arène, etc. Le kãgor-yõ représente à ce titre le premier cadre d’initiation à la
lutte chez les "San".
Contribution de la lutte du kãgor-yõ à la promotion d’un mode de vie saine chez l’enfant
« san »
L’analyse de la lutte de kãgor-yõ laisse apparaître de multiples vertus qui concourent à la promotion
d’une vie saine chez les enfants en milieu "san". Cette promotion de la vie saine se lie dans ses
fonctions physiques, socioculturelles, de divertissement, etc.
D’abord, au plan de la distraction, la nature ludique de la lutte de kãgor-yõ offre un cadre de
divertissement sain aux enfants. Ne dit-on pas que l’enfant et le jeu sont intrinsèquement liés ?
Dans cette offre saine, vient en premier lieu le cadre d’exécution de la pratique qui, délimité par la
585
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
couche épaisse de son de mil, amoindrit les effets de la chute et réduit les risques de blessure. Ce
cadre sain pousse les enfants à s’adonner sans reserve à leur pratique ludique. En deuxième lieu, le
corps à corps direct de la lutte de kãgor-yõ permet aux enfants de se frotter, de se mesurer, de
prendre connaissance de soi et de l’autre. Cette exploration de soi et de l’autre favorise
développement de l’altérité, du schéma moteur, de la maîtrise de soi et de l’espace.
Ensuite, au plan social, la lutte de kãgor-yõ constitue toute une école dont le contenu pédagogique
est tiré du milieu d’appartenance. En effet, se dégagent dans cette offre éducatives, des séquences
d’apprentissage tels les sauts de lutte, les pas de danse, les techniques de combats et de chute, le
discours instrumental, etc. tous relevant du milieu socioculturel "san". Outre cette affinité éducative
au milieu d’appartenance qui facilite les transactions didactiques, la pédagogie utilisée dans la
transmission du savoir est active et centrée sur l’apprenant en ce sens que l’enseignant et l’apprenant
font corps dans la lutte de kãgor-yõ. Cela ne pouvait en être autrement dans la mesure où cette lutte
est une création exclusive des enfants qui, à force d’assister aux combats des adultes dans les
grandes arènes de lutte, ont fini par transposer cette pratique ludomotrice dans leur espace de jeu.
A ce titre, la lutte de kãgor-yõ, à l’image des joutes adultes favorise la transmission des valeurs
cardinales de la société "san" telles la fraternité, le fair-play, l’entraides, le patriotisme, etc. Ces
valeurs qui renforcent l’intégration, la cohésion sociale, les liens communautaires, la culture de la
paix sont transmisses lors des oppositions inter-concessions et inter-lignagères organisées par les
enfants.
A cette socialisation des enfants "san" par la pratique ancestrale, s’ajoute le registre culturel où la
lutte de kãgor-yõ constitue un des canaux d’expression identitaire dans lesquels les enfants
intériorisent et exposent la richesse culturelle de leurs peuples. Cette exposition s’observe dans
l’exécution des pas de danse, des sauts de lutte, la façon spécifique de lutter, etc.
Enfin au plan physique, la lutte de kãgor-yõ reflète un combat de corps à corps direct, opposant
deux individus dont le but est de terrasser l’autre, en se servant de son potentiel physique et
psychologique. En d’autres termes, c’est une mobilisation des énergies musculaires de part et
d’autre des deux combattants, produisant ainsi des forces importantes, des attaques et des contreattaques dont l’objectif est d’aboutir à la chute de l’adversaire. Dans ces charges successives de
forces opposées, plusieurs mouvements sont exécutés, notamment ceux des tirades, des esquives,
des fixations du corps, des feintes, des placements, des déplacements, des rotations, des sauts, des
sursauts, des fauchages, etc. La réalisation de ces mouvements nécessite le développement des
qualités physiques de force, d’endurance, de mobilité, de souplesse, de vitesse, de coordination, etc.
La lutte de kãgor-yõ contribue à ce titre à la formation physique intégrale des enfants. Cependant,
face aux mutations physiques et socioculturelles que vit le milieu "san", ce cadre ludomoteur de la
promotion de la vie saine des enfants est de nos jours menacé de disparition.
La pente raide de la lutte de kãgor-yõ
Le niveau de pratique de la lutte de kãgor-yõ est en régression dans la province de Nayala. L’ampleur
de cette régression varie d’un village à un autre et d’une commune à une autre. Elle est faible dans
586
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
les communes et les villages reculés et plus accentuée dans la commune urbaine de Toma. En effet,
certains villages de cette commune urbaine comme Goussi, Kion et Kolan situent la phase de déclin
de leur lutte de kãgor-yõ il y a une quarantaine d’année c’est-à-dire dans les années 1980. Tandis que
dans les villages des communes rurales de Yaba, de Gossina et de Yé, la régression de la lutte de
kãgor-yõ se situe vers les années 2000. La pratique de la lutte traditionnelle kãgor-yõ est donc en
décadence dans la province de Nayala. En effet, dans les localités enquêtées, elle souffre d’un
problème de mobilisation d’enfants lors des rencontres. Sa disparition est envisageable si aucune
action n’est entreprise. « La pente est vraiment raide ici à Toma et on a peur que cette lutte ne disparaisse »
Kawané, un ancien lutteur de 76 ans de Toma. Quel peuvent être alors les facteurs explicatifs de la
situation chancelante de la lutte kãgor-yõ dans la province de Nayala ?
Dans les localités explorées, la plupart des enquêtés reconnait que la pente raide de la lutte de kãgoryõ est lié aux à plusieurs facteurs dont le système éducatif formel, introduit dans la société "san"
par la colonisation peut être d’abord cité. L’école formelle dont la période d’apprentissage couvre
la majeure partie de l’année (neuf mois sur douze) écarte considérablement bon nombre d’enfants
de la lutte de kãgor-yõ. Au Burkina Faso, l’école est obligatoire pour tous les enfants de moins de 16
ans. Ce qui limite leur participation aux rencontres de luttes de kãgor-yõ. En effet, ceux-ci sont
contraints de déserter les rencontres au profit des cours à l’école ou de l’apprentissage des leçons
pendant les temps libres. En plus de cette désertion, les curricula du système scolaire inculquent
aux élèves une culture physique étrangère, à travers l’enseignement de disciplines sportives
importées (athlétisme, handball, football, etc.). Ce contenu d’enseignement, n’étant pas en
adéquation avec la culture du milieu, contribue au gommage des prérequis de la pratique ancestrale
inculqués dès le bas âge.
Ensuite, les mobiles de la décadence de la lutte de kãgor-yõ se situent dans les Activités Physique et
Sportives (APS) importées. En dehors de leur enseignement dans les écoles, les APS comme le
football et le karaté se pratiquent un peu partout dans la zone et accaparent de plus en plus le public
cible de la lutte de kãgor-yõ. Bien que leurs heures de pratique semblent se différer, l’attrait, de plus
en plus poussé des enfants pour ces sports modernes, se justifie par leur effet de mode. « La lutte
n’est plus à la page, c’est le football qui domine maintenant le monde » Sow, un enfant de 12 ans de la ville
de Toma.
Enfin, cette baisse de pratique de la lutte de kãgor-yõ se lit dans les mutations physiques de la zone.
Avec l’explosion démographique associée aux opérations de lotissement dans les Chefs-lieux de
commune, certaines localités comme Toma, Gossina, Yaba, etc. ont connu une urbanisation
accélérée sans tenir compte des lieux de pratique de la lutte de kãgor-yõ. A cette urbanisation
accélérée, se double d’un changement du mode alimentaire avec une surconsommation des denrées
importées (riz, spaghetti, pain, etc.) au détriment du mil local dont le son était utilisé pour amortir
les chutes lors des combats de lutte de kãgor-yõ. Cette disparition des lieux de prédilection de la
pratique a emporté avec elle la lutte de kãgor-yõ dans ces localités.
587
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Discussion
Transmise de génération en génération, la lutte de kãgor-yõ s’avère être une pratique ancestrale dont
le mode d’organisation (rencontres inter-concessions et inter-lignagères) est calqué sur la structure
de la société "san". Cette incarnation de l’architecture sociale de la lutte de kãgor-yõ confirme les
résultats des études sur les jeux traditionnels des chercheurs tels que Lavega (2016, p. 108) et
Parlebas (2016, p. 104). Ces auteurs ont concluent dans leur recherche que les jeux traditionnels
constituent des microsociétés. De par cette transposition, la lutte de kãgor-yõ assure le rôle
socialisant du contrat ludomoteur et s’avère être un laboratoire social dans lesquels les protagonistes
acquièrent un formidable bagage de compétences sociales. Ce rôle socialisant corrobore les travaux
de Piaget (1932) qui situe le contrat social du jeu au cœur du développement des conduites infantiles
(le développement de schéma moteur, de la latéralité, la maîtrise de soi et de l’espace). Il confirme
également les résultats de travaux de Zongo (2019, p. 181) et de Ouédraogo, Gouda et Palé (2022,
p. 77) sur les fonctions des jeux et des luttes traditionnelles en particulier au Burkina Faso. Ces
chercheurs conclurent que les jeux traditionnels participe à la promotion la vie saine en développant
la solidarité, la coopération, le vivre ensemble, etc. pour le bénéfice de la communauté.
A cette promotion de la vie saine, s’ajoute le reflet identitaire du peuple "san" porté par la lutte de
kãgor-yõ, à travers la posture du lutteur, les sauts de lutte, les pas de danse, etc. qui expose un attribut
commun à tous les jeux traditionnels dont plusieurs chercheurs ont déjà développé. Pour Vigne et
Dorvillé (2009, p. 1), les jeux traditionnels représentent des éléments fondamentaux de la
construction de l’identité culturelle, en ce sens qu’ils incarnent leur localité d’appartenance. Les
travaux de Parlebas (2016, p. 36), approuvent aussi cet attribut des jeux traditionnels, car étant en
phase avec les normes et les sensibilités de leur territoire, ils marquent les traits distinctifs et
reflètent par-là même l’identité de la communauté.
En somme, la promotion de la vie saine par la lutte de kãgor-yõ et son incarnation de l’architecture
sociale et de l’identité culturelle du peuple "san" relance les travaux de Mauss (1934) sur les
techniques du corps qui conclut que « toute motricité est une « ethno-motricité » et la logique
interne d’une activité est investie par les traditions ethniques et les usages sociaux symboliques, par
les représentations sociales et les croyances ». A ce titre, la lutte la lutte de kãgor-yõ est donc une
ethno-motricité qui reflète l’image de sa communauté, tout en enrichissant le patrimoine culturel
de l’humanité.
La situation chancelante de la lutte de kãgor-yõ en tant que pratique physique de tradition dont les
mobiles sont liés aux mutations physiques et socioculturelles des terroirs corrobore les travaux de
plusieurs auteurs. Au titre du système éducatif formel comme facteur exogène du changement,
Sanon (1982) note qu’il n’est plus une assertion hypothétique de dire que l’enfant burkinabè est
dépossédé de son jeu par l’institution scolaire et par la pression conjuguées des discours officiels
qui présentent la pratique sportive comme le modèle d’activité par excellence. Amouzou (2009, p.
27) soutient que l’école s’est plaquée brutalement sur une société qu’elle ignore et combat parfois.
Son seul but est d’instruire et non plus d’éduquer, ses finalités, ses programmes, son mode
d’évaluation, sa forme de socialisation sont un défi constant aux conventions du passé africain.
588
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Pour Ouédraogo (2018, p. 5), l’illustration parfaite de cette influence de l’école se situe le
programme d’enseignement de la matière dite Education Physique et Sportive (EPS) qui exclut
toutes formes de pratiques ludomotrices endogènes du Burkina Faso au profit des disciplines
sportives importées comme le football, le handball, la gymnastique au sol, l’athlétisme.
Sous l’angle des APS moderne, la baisse tendancielle de la pratique de la lutte de kãgor-yõ due à la
diffusion du sport moderne dans la zone confirme également les résultats de plusieurs chercheurs
dont Parlebas (2016). Cet auteur souligne que la monté en puissance du système sportif
institutionnalisé menace de disparition les jeux traditionnels. Processus en vogue dans les sociétés
actuelles, l’emprise du sport moderne fait perdre aux jeux traditionnels leur pureté originelle, leurs
caractéristiques en lien avec leur terroir.
Conclusion
La lutte de kãgor-yõ est une activité ludomotrice ancestrale du peuple "san" qui est transmise de
génération en génération. Elle est pratiquée par les enfants pendant la journée ou pendant dans les
nuits de clair lunaire. Sa mise en œuvre procure des vertus tel la formation physiques intégrale, le
fair-play, le patriotisme, l’intégration, le vivre ensemble, etc. L’ensemble de ces valeurs promues
par la pratique ancestrale concourt à la promotion d’un mode de vie saine des enfants en milieu
"san". Cependant, la lutte de kãgor-yõ est menacée de disparition par un ensemble de facteurs
endogènes, exogènes ou mixtes tels que l’urbanisation, le nouveau mode de vie, le système éducatif
formel et les APS modernes importées. Pour éviter le naufrage la lutte de kãgor-yõ afin de bénéficier
toujours de sa contribution à la promotion du mode de vie saine, sa redynamisation s’impose,
notamment à travers sa codification en une discipline sportive suivie de son intégration dans les
programmes scolaires et dans les activités socio-récréatives et sportives. La préservation de ces
espaces de déroulement lors des opérations de lotissement constitue également un atout pour sa
survie.
Références bibliographiques
Amouzou, E. (2009). L’impact de la culture occidentale sur les cultures africaines. Paris : L’Harmattan.
Bardin, L. (1977). Analyse de contenu. Puf. 302 p.
Dohin, (2003). La lutte éducative : un art de communication vecteur de la construction identitaire.
Empan, 3(51), 21-26
Institut National de la Statistique et de la Démographie. (2006). Recensement général de la démographique
et l’habitation (RGPH), www.INSD.bf
Lavega, P. (2016). Jeux d’enfants et jeux d’adultes. Dans P. Parlebas (dir.), Jeux traditionnels, sports
et patrimoine culturel (p.310). Paris : L’Harmattan.
Mauss, M. (1934). Les techniques du corps. In Sociologie et Anthropologie. Paris : PUF.
Nyamba, A. (1992). L’identité et le changement social des Sanan du Burkina Faso. [Thèse de doctorat non
publié]. Université de Bordeaux II. 2 tomes, 758 p.
Olivier de Sardan, J. P. (1995). La politique du terrain. Enquête, 1, 71-109
http://enquete.revues.org/263 ; DOI : 10.4000/ enquete.263
589
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Ouédraogo, B. (2018). Danse warba pour la sauvegarde du patrimoine et de l’identité du peuple moose de
Ganzourgou au Burkina Faso. (Mémoire de master non publié), Université d’Abomey Calavi,
INJEPS, Porto-Novo, Bénin.
Ouédraogo, B., Gouda, L. S., Palé, A. (2022). Des tèdiè au oudizon à Toma au Burkina Faso : la
réapproriation d’une valeur endogène en lutte. Regard d’Afrique, 1, 66-94 ISBN : 978-2493659-00-2
Palé, A., Bassolé, A. C. N., Sawadogo, A. (2020). L’épreuve du terrain exprience, postures et théories. Paris :
L’Harmattan.
Parlebas, P. (1999). Jeux, sports et sociétés. Paris : INSEP.
Parlebas, P. (2016). Le jeu fait-il partie de la culture ? Dans P. Parlebas (dir.), Jeux traditionnels,
sports et patrimoine culturel (p.310). Paris : L’Harmattan.
Piaget, J. (1932). Le jugement moral chez l’enfant. Paris : PUF
Sanon, A. (1982). Education physique en haute-Volta. Pour une pédagogie de l’enracinement culturel par les jeux
moteurs traditionnels. (Mémoire de master non publié), INSEP, Paris.
Vigne, M., & Dorvillé, C. (2009). Les jeux traditionnels du Nord, entre tradition ludique culturelle
et modernité sportive. Socio-logos, 4, 1-18.
Zongo, O. C. (2019). Les fonctions sociales et culturelles des activités physiques traditionnelles et des jeux : cas
des parties de chasse, de lutte et du sãane des moose du Boulkièmdé au Burkina Faso. (Thèse de doctorat
non publié) Université d’Abomey Calavi, INJEPS, Porto-Novo, Bénin
590
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Contribution de l’Education Physique et du Sport (EPS) à la
résilience communautaire par l’animation socio-éducative,
sanitaire, culturelle et économique (ASCE) face à l’épidémie de la
Covid-19 au Sénégal
Seck Djibril - Sèye Amadou - Ndongo Mohamed - Ndiouck Amadou Diompy Patrick - Diouf Thierno
Institut National Supérieur de l’Eduction Populaire et du Sport, Dakar, Sénégal
e-mail: djibril1.seck@ucad.edu.sn
Résumé
Arrivé au Sénégal en mars 2020, le coronavirus ou Covid-19 est devenu endémique en Afrique où
la population est majoritairement jeune, active, très mobile mais fragile sur le plan économique et
avec un taux de scolarisation encore faible. Face à l’ampleur du choc, la réaction s’est d’abord
traduite par des décisions et déclarations exprimées entre autres par les termes comme : « état de
guerre », «état d’urgence », « couvre-feu », «confinement », « distanciation sociale » et « geste barrières ». Aussi,
tous les acteurs de l’éducation physique et sportive (EPS) se sont mobilisés pour le rôle et la
contribution de l’EPS dans l’éducation à la santé et la résilience, par l’animation socio-éducative,
culturelle et économique en jeunesse et au sein des communautés contre cette situation d’épidémie
de Covid-19. Le plan de riposte du Sénégal a été cité en exemple au niveau mondial. L’Approche
didactique et technologique à visée de description, de lecture, de participation, de maîtrise, de
transformation des situations et des pratiques nous a permis de suivre les différentes étapes
parcourues et les épreuves subies par l’EPS lors de cette première année d’épidémie de Covid-19.
Les données recueillies proviennent des différentes rencontres autorisées en présentiel et à distance
sur les plateformes numériques (webinars), les échanges de courriers, les publications, les
informations recueillies et partagées par l’Observatoire de l’Animation Socio-Educative en Jeunesse
et Loisir en relation avec la radio universitaire et communautaire de l’université Cheikh Anta Diop
(UCAD FM). Aussi, nous présentons les étapes, les lieux, les enjeux, les obstacles rencontrés et les
actions menées par les différents acteurs pour une Education Physique et un Sport de qualité au
service des communautés afin de faire face par la résilience et l’innovation en contexte et en
situation de coronavirus Covid-19. Plusieurs actions ont été menées par les différents acteurs et
portant sur la gouvernance de l’EPS, la recherche, les enseignements, les formations et les services
à la communauté. Ainsi, l’EPS a pu réintégrer non sans difficulté les cours, les épreuves aux
examens et concours organisés au Sénégal et être reconnu à nouveau comme discipline scolaire à
591
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
part entière du système éducatif sénégalais. Elle a eu à prouver son statut de discipline à part entière
en affirmant sa transversalité et sa contribution notable à une nouvelle approche de la santé à
travers ses dimensions et ses déterminants majeurs. En conclusion, la situation d’épidémie de
Covid-19 a permis à l’éducation physique et au sport (EPS) d’éprouver et de confirmer sa place de
discipline scolaire à part entière du système éducatif sénégalais. Elle lui a permis de mobiliser tous
les acteurs, de revisiter l’ensemble de sa chaîne de valeurs portant sur la recherche, les
enseignements, les formations et les services à la communauté avant de réintégrer les cours,
examens et concours concernés aux niveaux scolaire et universitaire. L’EPS engagé pour un
système éducatif de qualité a ainsi contribué à la résilience communautaire face à la Covid-19 au
Sénégal et continue de participer pour le développement durable dans un environnement sain et
paisible.
Mots clés: Education physique, Sport, Epidémie Covid-19, Santé Communautaire, Résilience
592
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
Le coronavirus ou Covid-19 est arrivé au Sénégal le 02 mars 2020. L’Education et Sportive (EPS)
aura vécu à ce jour deux ans avec l’épidémie de la Covid-19 qui par la suite est passée pandémie, et
puis est devenue endémique en Afrique et dans le monde. S’en est suivi, un choc et un chaos
immenses et une réaction immédiate portant en premier sur la « contrainte par corps » suite aux
décisions et déclarations qui se sont exprimées entre autres par les termes suivants : « état de guerre »,
«état d’urgence », « couvre-feu », «confinement », « distanciation sociale » et « geste barrières ».
Au Sénégal et en Afrique, la population est majoritairement jeune, active, très mobile mais fragile
sur le plan économique et avec un taux de scolarisation encore faible. Comment cette situation et
ces décisions ont-elles été comprises, et acceptées par les différents acteurs de la société? Quelles
ont été les actions menées et les résultats obtenus en Education Physique et à tous les niveaux de
décision, d’intervention et pour tous les acteurs concernés? Quels ont été le rôle et la contribution
de l’EPS dans l’éducation à la santé et la résilience en situation d’épidémie de Covid-19, dans
l’animation socio-éducative, culturelle et économique en jeunesse et au sein des communautés? Le
plan de riposte du Sénégal est cité en exemple au niveau mondial.
D’abord soulignons, la décision de la fermeture immédiate des écoles et universités. S’en est suivi
ensuite la décision de la reprise des cours des classes d’examen de l’élémentaire, du moyen et du
secondaire après une grande mobilisation. De toutes les disciplines d’enseignement du système
éducatif, l’éducation physique et sportive (EPS) est la seule discipline qui a été exclue lors de la
reprise des cours, des examens et concours. Cette décision a créé une grande surprise et suscité
plusieurs réactions. Aussi, c’est tout la chaîne de valeurs portant sur les références sociales,
culturelles, politiques, économiques, symboliques, éducatives et environnementales qui a été
rudement éprouvé.
Cette présentation porte sur les décisions prises, les réactions, les activités menées et les résultats
obtenus à tous les niveaux lors de la Covid-19, par les acteurs investis dans des fonctions « praticiennes »
(enseignante ou formatrice), administratrice, innovatrice ou élaboratrice de ressources, d’expertise ou de recherche, qui
revendiquent et assument « l’exercice d’une responsabilité reconnue pour les contenus » de l’Education
Physique et du Sport. (Martinand 1986). Aussi, nous présentons les étapes, les lieux, les enjeux, les
obstacles rencontrés et les actions menées par les différents acteurs pour une Education Physique
et un Sport de qualité au service des communautés afin de faire face par la résilience et l’innovation
en contexte et en situation de coronavirus Covid-19.
L’ensemble des acteurs impliqués pour la qualité de l’Education Physique et du Sport (EPS) se sont
alors mobilisés autour de l’EPS. Aussi la riposte a porté sur les dimensions et les déterminants
majeurs de la Santé. C’est ainsi que l’état, les ministères de tutelle de l’EPS, les instituts nationaux
de formation des cadres en jeunesse et sports (INJS), les associations sportives, culturelles et
économiques (ASCE), se sont mobilisés afin de mener des activités et des actions importantes.
Plusieurs actions ont été menées par les différents acteurs et portant sur la gouvernance de l’EPS,
la recherche, les enseignements, les formations et les services à la communauté.
593
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Aussi, l’EPS a pu réintégrer non sans difficulté les cours, les épreuves aux examens et concours
organisés au Sénégal et être reconnu à nouveau comme discipline scolaire à part entière du système
éducatif sénégalais. Elle a eu à prouver son statut de discipline à part entière en affirmant sa
transversalité et sa contribution notable à une nouvelle approche de la santé à travers ses
dimensions et ses déterminants majeurs.
L’Approche didactique et technologique à visée de description, de lecture, de participation, de
maîtrise, de transformation des situations et des pratiques nous a permis de suivre les différentes
étapes parcourues et les épreuves subies par l’EPS lors de cette première année d’épidémie de
Covid-19.
Les données recueillies proviennent des différentes rencontres à distance et en présentiel sur les
plateformes numériques, (webinars), les échanges de courriers, les publications, les informations
recueillies et partagées par l’Observatoire de l’Animation Socio-Educative en Jeunesse et Loisir en
relation avec la radio universitaire et communautaire (UCAD FM ) de l’université Cheikh Anta
Diop de Dakar.
LES DECISIONS PRISES, LES ACTIONS MENEES ET LES RESULTATS OBTENUS
Les décisions prises
L’apparition de la pandémie du Covid-19 qui secoue le monde entier a incité les autorités à prendre
des mesures visant à limiter la transmission de la pandémie. Au Sénégal une série de mesures a été
mise en œuvre dans ce sens. Parmi les mesures celles qui concernent spécifiquement le secteur de
l’éducation, nous retenons la suspension des activités scolaires durant la période allant du 16 mars
au 01 juin 2020.
Le Ministère des Sports a pris la décision d’arrêt de toutes les activités sportives et report des Jeux
Olympiques de la jeunesse (JOJ) de 2022 à 2026. En effet, au tout début de la pandémie, le ministère
des sports a très tôt organisé une rencontre et convoqué une réunion avec tous les acteurs des 58
fédérations et structures sportives sous sa tutelle afin de partager les informations et de manière
collégiale s’engager pour une solidarité entière avec les acteurs du sport afin de faire face la Covid19. En effet, au Sénégal, la loi n°84-59 portant charte du sport stipule :
Article premier : la pratique sportive vise l’éducation, la formation, et l’amélioration de la santé physique et morale
des pratiquants. Elle participe également à l’amélioration de la qualité de la vie.
Article 2 : l’état et les collectivités publiques et privées créent les conditions préalables et les institutions qui garantissent
la pratique sportive amateur, pluridisciplinaire et démocratisée, principalement sous forme :
- d’éducation physique et sportive, facteur d’éducation, d’hygiène corporelle et de santé de la jeunesse ;
- de sport récréatif, facteur de détente, de loisir et d’animation de masse ;
- de sport de compétition, facteur de formation, d’émulation et d’épanouissement physique et moral des individus.
594
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Cette loi sur le sport, citée ci-dessus, a entrainé des exigences, qui ont elles-mêmes influencé la
naissance d’instituts universitaires afin d’apporter des réponses aux différentes interrogations
soulevées par les acteurs du monde sportif.
Au Sénégal, la prise en compte des STAPS dans les programmes universitaires de recherche et
d’enseignement s’est renforcée avec l’ouverture de la section STAPS de l’Unité de Formation et de
la Recherche (UFR) en Sciences de l’Éducation, de la Formation et du Sport (SEFS) à l’Université
Gaston Berger (UGB) et qui offre plusieurs formations. Trois décisions majeures ont été prises par
le Chef de l’Etat et les Ministères de l’Education, Ministère l’Emploi, de la Formation
Professionnelle et de l’Artisanat :
• la décision de l’arrêt des cours, examens et concours, puis décision de reprise à l’exclusion de
l’EPS et enfin réintégration de l’EPS ;
• la décision du Chef de l’Etat issue du Conseil des Ministres du 29 avril 2020. Concernant la
reprise des enseignements apprentissages à partir de 02 juin 2020 dans les structures scolaires
pour les classes d’examen ;
• enfin la décision du Chef de l’Etat de renvoyer la reprise des cours prévue pour le 01 juin
2020 à une date ultérieure.
Dans cette perspective de reprise et de poursuite de toutes les activités scolaires sauf les cours
d’Education Physique et Sportive ont été suspendus jusqu’à nouvel ordre. Dans un communiqué
conjoint, avec le Ministre de l’Emploi, de la Formation Professionnelle et de l’Artisanat, ils se sont
engagés à poursuivre les efforts en vue d’une prochaine reprise des cours. Ainsi, sauf l’EPS, les
activités scolaires pour les classes d’examen se sont déroulées jusqu’à l’organisation des examens
scolaires officiels : CFEE, BFEM et Baccalauréat. Dès lors, il apparait nécessaire de s’interroger
sur les modalités pratiques de reprise des enseignements-apprentissage et d’organisation des
différentes disciplines aux examens certificatifs.
LES ACTIONS MENEES ET LES RESULTATS OBTENUS
A/Les réactions et la mobilisation des « acteurs investis dans des fonctions, qui
revendiquent et assument l’exercice d’une responsabilité reconnue pour les contenus » de
l’Education Physique et du Sport.
Ce sont entre autres, les inspecteurs et enseignants d’EPS, les syndicats et associations de parents
d’élèves se sont mobilisés dans un cadre unitaire afin de faire face aux décisions et mener des
actions conjointes.Les acteurs ont commencé par le rappel des références juridiques qui fondent la
légalité et la légitimité de considérer l’EPS comme une discipline à part entière du système éducatif
sénégalais.
« L’éducation physique et sportive est une discipline obligatoire aux examens du CFEE, du BFEM et du
Baccalauréat. Seuls les candidats déclarés inaptes par un certificat médical délivré par l’Inspection Médicale des
Ecoles (IME) de la région à l’inscription ou en cours d’année scolaire en sont dispensés ». (Décret n° 95.947 du 18
595
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
octobre 1995; Décret n° 2014-570 du 06 mai 2014, Décret n° 2013-738 et Arrêté n°
0017/MEN/SG/DEXCO/os du 29 avril 2013).
Par une réflexion anticipative des acteurs de l’EPS en date en date du 02 juin 2020, il a été proposé
au Ministre de l’Education Nationale un protocole pour la reprise des enseignements
apprentissages en EPS prenant en compte les dispositions édictées par le Ministère de la santé et
de l’action sociale pour éviter la contamination.
Pour la reprise des cours et l’exclusion de l’EPS aux examens et concours, il a été proposé d’abord
par l’Autorité la prise en compte des seules notes de contrôles continus d’EPS aux examens.
Cependant, pour la reprise de l’EPS, il a été proposé par les autres acteurs, un argumentaire pour
la reprise des activités scolaires EPS et l’organisation des épreuves physiques. Les propositions et
contributions ont porté sur des dispositions techniques favorables à la reprise effective des
enseignements apprentissages en EPS et l’organisation des épreuves physiques du CFEE, du
BFEM et du Baccalauréat session 2020.
En ce qui concerne l’EPS, les évaluations sont essentiellement pratiques. Dans une perspective de
reprise des activités physiques et sportives, les questions centrales suivantes se posent:
1. Comment reprendre les enseignements – apprentissages en EPS le 02 juin 2020 ?
2. Comment planifier les épreuves physiques aux différents examens certificatifs ?
3. Quel dispositif mettre en œuvre pour évaluer les élèves aux épreuves physiques dans le respect
des mesures barrières individuelles et collectives?
A suivi la proposition par les acteurs de l’EPS que sont entre autre : les Inspecteurs de
l’Enseignement Moyen Secondaires (spécialités EPS), les formateurs, les coordonnateurs des
cellules d’établissements et cellules mixtes, d’un protocole de reprise portant sur les modalités
d’organisation de la session 2020 dans un contexte particulier au regard des mesures fixées par la
feuille de route et défavorables à l’EPS.
1. Reprise des enseignements – apprentissages en EPS
L’état des lieux a montré que la suspension des enseignements – apprentissages associée «au
confinement », a créé une rupture dans la pratique de activités physiques chez les apprenants. Cette
rupture a engendré une sédentarité et créé une déperdition des acquis au plan physique, moteur et
psychologique. En conséquence, la reprise des enseignements – apprentissages a mis l’accent sur :
a. la conduite de séquences pédagogiques pour quatre (04) heures de cours pour une « remise en
condition physique générale» du 02 au 15 juin 2020;
b. la conduite de séquences pédagogiques de six (06) heures de cours orientées sur les épreuves
choisies par les candidats aux différents examens du 16 juin au10 juillet 2020 ;
2. Planification des épreuves physiques
• CFEE : 26 juin 2020 sur initiative des IEF ;
• BEP ; BT, CAP : du 01 au 10 juillet 2020 ;
• Baccalauréat général et technique : 13 au 23 juillet 2020 ;
596
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
•
BFEM : 24 au 31 juillet 2020.
3. Dispositif technique et sanitaire pour l’organisation des épreuves physiques
Définition de l’épreuve. L’évaluation en éducation physique et sportive au BFEM et au baccalauréat
comprend deux (02) disciplines:
• une épreuve d’athlétisme notée sur vingt (20) et composée de concours et de courses ;
• une épreuve obligatoire de gymnastique notée sur vingt (20) ;
• la note du candidat est obtenue en faisant la demi-somme des notes obtenues dans ces deux
épreuves.
Au CFEE, les épreuves sont constituées de course, de lancer d’adresse et de saut. Les candidats
obtiennent des notes issues de l’organisation des épreuves physique à l’échelle nationale
conformément aux textes précités. La prise en compte des notes de contrôles continus constitue
une violation des textes en vigueur et porterait atteinte à la crédibilité des différents examens
nationaux.
Important : les différents examens certificatifs utilisent des activités physiques dites individuelles
qui sont : gymnastique, courses, sauts. De ce point de vue, toutes les mesures préconisées par les
autorités sanitaires sont plus que jamais respectables :
• distanciation physique : les épreuves physiques se déroulent dans un espace libre et aéré. La
distanciation physique est naturelle ;
• chaque candidat effectue son exercice seul et sans contact.
Propositions :
1. planification : le déroulement des épreuves physique prévoit le passage des élèves par petits
groupes de vingt-cinq (25) candidats, encadrés et gérés chacun par un évaluateur.
A ce propos, les épreuves pourront se dérouler le matin de 9 heures à 12 heures, l’après-midi de 16
heures à 18 heures.
2. les épreuves
• Les candidats vont choisir une épreuve de course et une épreuve de concours. La gymnastique
et obligatoire ;
• Toutefois il existe des épreuves à éliminer pour cette session : il s’agit du lancer de poids, du
grimper, des courses de demi-fond (600 m et 1000 m) ;
Motif : d’une part, les candidats utilisent et partagent les mêmes engins ; ce qui ne favorise pas le
respect des mesures barrières ; d’autre part, les courses de demi-fond (600 m et1000 m) sont sources
de fatigue. Dès la reprise, des cours, les candidats et les enseignants en seront informés ;
- Pour la gymnastique : un dispositif d’utilisation du gel hydro-alcoolique et le lavage systématique
des mains, avant et après le passage sera mis en place. Les candidats exécutent leur enchaînement
un à un, dans le respect de la distanciation ;
597
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Comme à l’accoutumée, les passages et les rotations des candidats à l’atelier de gymnastique se
déroulent sous la supervision de l’examinateur chargé de gérer et d’accompagner les candidats dans
le respect des mesures barrières. Chaque candidat à son espace dédié et matérialisé.
3. les centres : Les épreuves physiques se tiennent dans les établissements scolaires et stades qui
remplissent les conditions relatives aux infrastructures sportives fonctionnelles, au matériel
didactique suffisant, aux conditions d’hygiène et de sécurité confirmées
.
B/ Les réactions et la mobilisation des « acteurs investis dans des fonctions innovatrice ou
élaboratrice de ressources, d’expertise ou de recherche » (Martinand 1986).
Ce sont les structures d’enseignement et de formateurs de formateurs membres du réseau (RINJS,
(INSEPS, CNEPS, UGB). Dans les INJS, nos deux orientations majeurs de recherche portent
sur :1) l’orientation vers la production de connaissances fiables sur les processus d’enseignementapprentissage, (ayant une fonction objectivante et critique) et sur 2) l’orientation vers l’élucidation
des conditions et conséquences de décisions d’intervention (ayant une fonction prospective et
proactive).
Ces orientations ayant deux fonctions, objectivante et critique, prospective et proactive, nous
amènent à la confrontation avec les sciences humaines et sociales (ED ETHOS), les sciences
biologiques (SEV), mais aussi aux sciences de l’ingénierie, le génie pédagogique (sciences et
techniques de gestion, technologie de l’information pour l’éducation etc..) ou les sciences anthroposociales de l’éducation.
Au Sénégal, la prise en compte des STAPS dans les programmes universitaires de recherche et
d’enseignement a connu un bond en qualité porté par le CNEPS, l’INSEPS et renforcée par
l’ouverture de la section STAPS de l’Unité de Formation et de la Recherche (UFR) en Sciences de
l’Éducation, de la Formation et du Sport (SEFS) à l’Université Gaston Berger (UGB. Nous avons
organisé un panel à distance (webinar) le vendredi 18 décembre 2020 sur la plateforme de l’Université
Virtuelle du Sénégal (UVS) et portant sur le thème : « Education physique, sport et jeunesse en
situation d’épidémie de covid-19 : le jeu et les enjeux ».
En route vers les jeux olympiques de la jeunesse en 2022 au Sénégal nous avons été stoppés nette
par l’avènement de la COVID19. En Sport et Jeunesse, les conséquences sont alors énormes sur
tous les plans symbolique, économique, politique, culturel, éducatif, sanitaire et environnemental.
Le Sénégal a très tôt pris les bonnes dispositions édictées par le Président de la République en
fermant ses frontières, suivi par la Ministre des Sports qui a convoqué tous les acteurs du secteur
chargés de l’Animation Socio-Educative des Collectivités pour une large et franche concertation et
consultation en vue de valider la conduite à tenir face à la Covid-19 et s’y engager. Le champ des
Sciences et Techniques de l’Activité Physique en Jeunesse et Sport (STAPS-JL) est vaste, et, est
sous la tutelle de différents ministères mais s’unifie à travers les associations sportives culturelles et
économiques (ASCE) qui impliquent tout le peuple sénégalais et toutes les communautés dans sa
proximité et son intimité.
598
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Dès le début de la COVID19, nous avons mis en place un observatoire au Laboratoire en STAPSJL de l’INSEPS, animé une chronique qui diffusée par la radio UCAD-FM de notre Université,
Cheikh Anta Diop (UCAD) de Dakar afin de remplir nos missions universitaires à tous les niveaux
de la chaîne de valeurs que sont : la crédibilité scientifique par la recherche, la transmission par les
enseignements-formation et les services à la communauté. Il s’agit d’observer et d’analyser l’impact
sur la gouvernance, la santé l’environnement, l’économie, l’éducation et la paix ; ceci, pour tous les
acteurs et les segments de la population (des personnes à besoins spécifiques (handicapés et
personnes âgées aux athlètes) et pour toutes les formes de pratiques, du loisir au sport de haut
niveau. Un modèle global prenant en compte les trois grandes phases du stress a été utilisé pour
suivre la crise de la Covid-19, qui est passé d’épidémie à pandémie et qui actuellement est devenue
endémique. Il s’agit de : 1°) la phase d'alarme qui a lieu dès la perception par l’organisme d'une
contrainte à laquelle il n'est pas préparé pour y répondre et qui initie le processus de réaction non
spécifique au stimulus stressant ; 2°) la phase de résistance ou d'adaptation à l'agression qui
intervient dans le cas où l'organisme est soumis de manière prolongée au stimulus stressant.
L’organisme alors met en place ses propres mécanismes d’adaptation afin de faire face à l’agent
stresseur et 3°) la phase d'épuisement qui est amorcée lorsque l'organisme cesse de pouvoir
s'adapter aux stresseurs auxquels il est soumis. L’organisme répète la réaction d'alarme mais les
mécanismes d'adaptation s'effondrent.
La santé a été redéfinie en relation avec ses dimensions et ses déterminants majeurs. Un modèle
réactualisé distingue et prend en compte les différentes dimensions de la santé. En effet, la santé
est un processus faisant agir l’ensemble des ressources physiques, psychiques, sociales et
d’intégration à l’environnement matériel ou construit. Intégrant des aspects objectifs et la
perception subjective, la santé peut se concevoir au niveau de l’individu ou de la population. Ses
quatre (4) dimensions sont :a) la dimension physique ; b) dimension sociale et d’intégration à
l’environnement ; c) la santé de l’individu et d) la santé d’une population. Pour son
évaluation, notons la santé objective et la santé subjective. Retenons les cinq (5) déterminants
majeurs de la santé: 1°) Environnement physique ; 2°) Patrimoine biologique et développement
sain pendant l’enfance ; 3°) Mode de vie (activité physique), déterminé et prenant en compte
(Revenus, réseaux de relation, éducation, emploi, environnement social, culture, genre ; 4°) Services
de santé; 5°) Socioculturels, ensemble d’éléments qui exercent leur influence principalement sur le
mode de vie.
Un panel en ligne et à distance dont le thème est intitulé : «Sport et Jeunesse en Contexte et Situation de
Covid-19 : le jeu et les enjeux» est donc un cadre d’échange et une occasion de discussion sur l’état des
lieux de ce que nous avons fait, de ce que nous avons appris avec la Covid19 et enfin de ce qui est
à promouvoir.
Les communications ont mis l’accent sur les jeux et les enjeux de la COVID19 à travers des
approches et des postures multidisciplinaires, interdisciplinaire et transdisciplinaires comme l’est
d’ailleurs le champ des STAPS-JL. Ces communications sont issues des différentes équipes du
Laboratoire en STAPS-JL de l’INSEPS affilié aux les Ecoles Doctorales « Santé, Environnement
et Vie » (SEV) et « Etudes de l’homme en société » (ETHOS) de l’UCAD ont porté sur : a) Sport,
599
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
APS, EPS et gestion de la COVID 19 au Sénégal ; b) Sport et Conflit au Sénégal, entre Collision et Collusion
et c) Sport et Gestion de l´Émigration clandestine au Sénégal : une niche de création d´emplois.
Toutes ces activités ont été portées par nos autorités institutionnelles, de tutelle et nos partenaires
que sont : le Ministère de l »Enseignement Supérieur de la recherche et de l’Innovation (MESRI),
la Direction Générale de la Recherche et de l’Innovation (DGRI) ; l’Observatoire National des
Sciences, des Technologies et de l’Innovation pour la riposte contre la COVID19; les Ecoles
Doctorales « Santé, Environnement et Vie » (SEV) et « Etudes de l’homme en société » (ETHOS) ;
l’Université Virtuelle du Sénégal (UVS) ; la Conférence des Ministres de la Jeunesse et des Sports
(CONFEJES) de la Francophonie et la Fédération Internationale de l’Education Physique et
Sportive (FIEPS), pour leur appui constant et qui nous accompagnent dans la démarche qualité,
l’animation de nos établissements par la recherche, les enseignements, les formations pour l’emploi
et l’employabilité des jeunes et à travers notre réseau des instituts nationaux de jeunesse et de sport
(RINJS) et la RADIO UCAD FM, une radio communautaire où nous continuons d’animer depuis
le début en mars 2019, une chronique sur l’impact de l’épidémie de la Covid-19, à partir de
« l’Observatoire de l’Animation Socio-Educative des Collectivités » et portant sur la gouvernance,
l’environnement, l’économie, la santé, l’éducation et la paix.
En conclusion, la situation d’épidémie de Coronavirus a permis à l’éducation physique et au sport
(EPS) d’éprouver et de confirmer sa place de discipline scolaire à part entière du système éducatif
sénégalais. Elle lui a permis de mobiliser tous les acteurs, de revisiter l’ensemble de sa chaîne de
valeurs portant sur la recherche, les enseignements, les formations et les services la communauté
avant de réintégrer les cours, examens et concours concernés aux niveaux scolaire et universitaire.
L’EPS engagé pour un système éducatif de qualité a ainsi contribué à la résilience communautaire
face à la Covid-19 au Sénégal et continue de participer pour le développement durable dans un
environnement sain et paisible.
Bibliographie
Arrêté n° 0017/MEN/SG/DEXCO/os du 29 avril 2013 portant prise en compte de la note d’EPS
au CFEE. Repéré de http://www.jo.gouv.sn/spip.php?article9921.
Décret n° 2014-570 du 06 mai 2014 portant création et organisation du Brevet de Fin d’Etude
Moyenne (BFEM). Repéré de http://www.jo.gouv.sn/spip.php?article2525.
Décret n° 95.947 du 18 octobre 1995 portant organisation du baccalauréat modifié. Repéré de
https://mesr.gouv.sn/office-du-baccalaureat/ .
Décret n° 2013-738 du 7 juin 2013 portant création et organisation du certificat de fin d’études
élémentaires (CFEE) et fixant les conditions d’admission en classe de 6ème de
l’Enseignement moyen général
Repéré de http://www.jo.gouv.sn/spip.php?page=imprimer&id_article=9921
Décret n° 2014-570 du 06 mai 2014 portant création et organisation du Brevet de Fin d’Etude
Moyenne (BFEM). Repéré de http://www.jo.gouv.sn/spip.php?article2525.
Martinand, J. L. (1986). Connaître et transformer la matière. Des objectifs pour l’initiation aux sciences et
techniques, Berne, Peter Lang.
600
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Gestion de l’enseignement l’Education Physique et du Sport
Scolaire dans le contexte de la Covid-19 au Maroc
Abdesselam Mili
Ministère de l’Education Nationale, de la Formation Professionnelle, de l’Enseignement Supérieur et de la
Recherche scientifique, Département Education Nationale, Maroc
e-mail : abdesselam.mili@men.gov.ma
Résumé
La covid-19 est une maladie dangereuse pandémique qui a fait des morts et un nombre important
de contaminés dans le monde. Sur le site de l’OMS, au 28 Avril 2021, le nombre de cas contaminé
est de l’ordre de 148 329 348 dont 3 128 962 décès. Les mesures prises pour contre la propagation
de ce virus ont été gérées différemment d’un pays à un autre. L’enseignement en général et de
l’Education Physique et Sportive (EPS) en particulier, a été impacté par ces mesures. Le fait que
l’élève change ses habitudes quotidiennes (être confiné plusieurs mois chez lui, respecter les
dispositions de distanciation avec ses amis etc.…), il se trouve dans une situation de gestions de
ses conduites contraignantes. Il doit être actif pour protéger sa santé et son bien-être d’une part,
d’autre part il doit effectuer des activités physiques et sportives dans ces conditions draconiennes.
Une problématique à laquelle ont été confrontée les acteurs de l’EPS. Cette situation a été gérée
aussi différemment d’un pays à un autre. Cet article a pour objet de montrer comment a été organisé
l’enseignement de l’EPS et du sport scolaire au Maroc d’une part, d’autre part d’identifier les
scénarios possibles de l'apprentissage par le sport en intégrant les mesures sanitaires contre la
COVID-19.
Mots clés: Covid-19- la pandémie, L’enseignement, L’éducation physique et le sport (EPS), Le
sport scolair.
601
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Personne ne croyait avant qu’un jour un virus peut geler toutes les activités humaines notamment
la mobilité. Si on n’a pas vécu cette situation, on pourrait dire qu’il s’agit de la science-fiction. Et
pourtant, pendant une année, l’humanité a vécu des moments d’horreur, de stress et d’inquiétude.
Dans le monde, au « 13 avril 2021, plus de 1,7 million de personnes ont été infectées et près de 85
000 sont décédées » (OMS, 2021). Chaque pays a mis en place des dispositifs pour faire face à
l’ennemi la Covid 19 invisible en essayant d’équilibrer l’équation entre les mesures sanitaires et
l’activité économique. Le Maroc a annoncé l’état d’urgence sanitaire et le confinement le vendredi
20 mars 2020 à 18h, sachant que le premier cas a été enregistré positif le 2 Mars 2020. Les écoles
sont fermées et les élèves sont confinées chez eux avec leurs familles. Le gouvernement, sous la
coordination de sa majesté le Roi Mohamed VI, Roi du Maroc, a fait de la lutte contre la pandémie
de la Covid-19 une priorité stratégique de l’Etat en mobilisant tous les moyens pour faire face à
cette crise. Le ministère de l’Education Nationale a mis en place un dispositif d’enseignement en
ligne dès le 16 Mars 2020 à travers la plateforme électronique «TelmidTICE», via les chaines de
télévision publiques qui ont contribué à la diffusion des cours, ou à travers les classes virtuelles
créées par les enseignants pour communiquer avec leurs élèves. D’autres conduites humaines
commencent à s’installer pour faire face à la pandémie notamment comment concilier entre la
dynamique économique et la préservation de la santé. Un tiraillement est perçu entre ceux qui
croient à la vie comme auparavant et ceux qui sont effrayés par l’atteinte du virus. Les élèves ne
sont pas à l’abri non plus. Face à la pandémie faut-il rester inactif ou réagir pour créer un
environnement de l’EPS ? Tout porte à croire que le confinement est une mesure pour protéger la
santé de l’élève, mais au même temps il constitue un danger pour sa santé en restant inactif. D’où
la question principale : que faut-il proposer comme menu d’activités à l’élève en tenant compte des
mesures sanitaires recommandées par le gouvernement ? Les cours d’Education physique et le
sport, ainsi que les activités du sport scolaire ont été aussi programmées pour permettre aux élèves
d’entretenir leur bien-être physique et mental. Ces cours sont médiatisés en ligne via des plateformes ou diffusés par les chaines de télévision publiques nationales. Cet article a pour objet de
montrer comment a été organisé l’enseignement de l’EPS et du sport scolaire au Maroc d’une part,
d’autre part d’identifier les scénarios possibles de l'apprentissage par le sport en intégrant les
mesures sanitaires contre la COVID-19.
Les mesures entreprises par le Maroc face à la pandémie
La COVID-19 est « la maladie causée par un nouveau coronavirus, le SARS-CoV-2. L’OMS a
appris l’existence de ce nouveau virus le 31 décembre 2019 lorsqu’un foyer épidémique de cas de
« pneumonie virale » a été notifié à Wuhan, en République populaire de Chine » (OMS, COVID19 : ce qu'il faut savoir, 2020). Il fallait plusieurs mois pour son identification, et en cours toujours
des doutes de sa physiopathologie, de son évolution, de sa propagation et de traitement de la
maladie. Tout ce qu’on sait que cette une maladie infectieuse due à un virus mortel capable de se
propager très vite entre les humains par un simple contact ou par le toucher d’une surface
contaminée ou par respiration des gouttelettes de la toux d’une personne infectée. Le nombre de
personne déclaré positif dans le monde est de l’ordre de 148 329 348 dont 3 128 962 morts au 28
Avril 2021 selon l’OMS. Les USA est le pays plus touché par cette pandémie avec 31 835
314 confirmés et 567 971 décès. Le Maroc est le 42ème pays concerné par cette pandémie avec
602
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
9015 morts et 510 465 confinés. Selon une publication du gouvernement marocain (Conseil de
Gouvernement, 2021), la gestion de crise pandémique est gérée par une intelligence collective en
tenant compte de l’évolution du virus. Ce qui a induit la mise en place un certain nombre de
mesures.
Le confinement
Les mesures sont prises par le Maroc lorsque le premier cas est apparu le 02 Mars 2020 et les 19
cas détectés le 13 Mars 2021. C’est ainsi que le Maroc a procédé à la fermeture des frontières le 15
Mars 2021 et à l’arrêt des études dans tous les cycles d’enseignement. Le confinement total et les
mesures sanitaires imposés le vendredi 20 mars 2020 à 18h est une sorte d’état d’alerte sur tout le
territoire marocain. Il s’agit de limiter les déplacements et de rester chez soi comme mesure
nécessaire pour faire face à la propagation du Conavirus. Les déplacements ne sont autorisés que
pour faire des courses, soigner ou rejoindre le travail par un ordre de mission. Des barrages de
contrôles sont mis en place entre les villes et entre les quartiers. Ces mesures ont permis d’éviter
l’épidémie et l’apparition des cas en danger ou des décès comme c’est le cas dans plusieurs pays. Le
port du masque imposé le 14 Avril 2020 et les mesures de distanciation sont obligatoires et doivent
être respectées. De plus, d’autres actions ont été menées sous les directives de sa majesté le Roi
Mohammed VI, notamment la création du fonds spécial pour la gestion de la pandémie de la covid19 ayant pour but le renforcement du dispositif médical et la compensation des pertes socioéconomiques causées par cette pandémie. Ce fond a enregistré des recettes de l’ordre de 33.7
Milliards de dirhams (34 millions de dollars).
Déconfinement par un Assouplissement des mesures
Par obligation et ou par volonté politique, le gouvernement a pris la décision d’assouplir les
conditions de confinement. Les mesures d’allégement sont entrées en vigueur allant de 25 Mai au
20 juillet 2021. Elles concernent le port obligatoire des masques, la reprise des activités scolaires,
commerciales et touristiques sauf pour les régions ayant enregistré un taux élevé des cas atteints
par la pandémie. C’est faire face à la pandémie par un comportement conscientisé et citoyen. En
cas de non respect de ces mesures, des amandes sont infligées sur place, par les autorités locales.
Le couvre-feu par un protocole "renforcé"
Un ensemble de restrictions ont été mises pour limiter la mobilité et l’encombrement des
personnes. Les mesures deviennent draconiennes quand une ville ou région est déclarée en situation
épidémiologique (augmentation du nombre de la population infectée). Ces mesures concernent la
fermeture des restaurants, des cafés, des commerces et des grandes surfaces tous les jours à 20h.
Ces mesures ont été statuées dans le code pénal en cas de délit. Tout déplacement entre les villes
doit être justifié d’une autorisation délivrée par les autorités locales. Pour les déplacements à
l’étranger ou à l’embarquement, le voyageur est obligé de présenter aux autorités des frontières le
résultat du test RT-PCR effectué 72 heures avant de quitter le territoire.
603
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Les mesures prises au niveau de l’enseignement et l’éducation physique et sportive
Pour faire face à la pandémie, le ministère de l'Éducation nationale, de la formation professionnelle,
de l'enseignement supérieur et de la recherche scientifique (MEN) a annoncé, le 13 Mars 2020, la
fermeture de tous les établissements scolaires et universitaires, à partir du 16 Mars 2021. Ainsi, pour
assurer la continuité pédagogique, il a mis en place un dispositif d’un enseignement à distance. Pour
ce faire, la plateforme électronique «TelmidTICE» a été créée pour renforcer le dispositif de
l’enseignement à distance instauré auparavant. Cet enseignement est planifié pour couvrir tous les
établissements et tous les niveaux scolaires. Selon le Rapport du gouvernement (Conseil de
Gouvernement, 2021) « La plateforme offre ainsi 4500 contenus numériques pour une moyenne
d’utilisateurs de 600.000 par jour. Les chaines de télévision du pôle public ont pour leur part été
mises à contribution pour diffuser des cours filmés, ce qui a permis de couvrir tous les niveaux
depuis la première année du primaire, jusqu’à la deuxième année du baccalauréat, afin que les cours
puissent profiter à tous les élèves, particulièrement en milieu rural où 91 % de la population est
équipée de téléviseurs, et ne disposant pas toujours d’un accès à internet ». Afin de permettre à tous
les élèves de poursuivre les cours chaque jour, les séances sont soit diffusées sur quatre chaines de
la télévision nationale, soit assurées par les enseignants qui communiquent avec leurs élèves en
utilisant le système d’information intégré « Massar» 1 et la plateforme teams. Plus de 723.966 classes
virtuelles sont créées pour l’enseignement public et plus de 105.316 pour le privé. Pour permettre
l’accès à l’enseignement à distance, trois opérateurs téléphoniques ont offert leur service de
connexion internet gratuitement à tous les élèves sur tout le territoire national.
L’EPS a joué un rôle important malgré la pandémie et l’incompatibilité de l’enseignement à son
contexte comme peuvent prétendre certains enseignants. Sauf que les objectifs des séances vont
changer et ciblent directement à l’entretien du corps en tant que mode adapté au contexte
pandémique. Si l’élève est inactif sur le plan physique pendant le confinement, il pourra avoir une
prise de poids. Ce qui impactera sa santé et son bien-être. Pourtant, les élèves n’ont pas les mêmes
conditions de pratique chez eux. Donc, il a fallu orienter la réflexion aux objectifs recherchés par
l’EPS pour faire face à cette crise et proposer des activités d’apprentissage, d’entrainement et de
compétition adaptées au contexte de vie à la maison de tous les élèves. Tout se fera en ligne. Le
recours à la télévision nationale pour la programmation des cours d’aérobic, de yoga… et
l’utilisation de la plateforme du ministère (Massar) disposant d’un Data center, ont facilité la mise
en marche des cours d’EPS. Ce sont deux moyens officiels qui ont permis à tous les élèves d’accéder
à l’information et aux apprentissages. Sachant, que les enseignants ont eu recours à d’autres moyens
tels les applications mobiles.
Le projet "Massar" est un système de gestion d’information intégré crée par le ministère de l'Éducation nationale,
de la formation professionnelle, de l'enseignement supérieur et de la recherche scientifique (MEN) permettant la
gestion de scolarité des élèves individuelles sur le plan pédagogique et administratif. Il permet de fournir une base
de données de toutes les composantes du système éducatif.
1
604
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Pendant le confinement total : du 16 Mars 2020 jusqu’à la fin de l’année scolaire
a. Programmation des séances d’EPS en ligne pour l’entretien physique
Ces séances sont préparées en studio. Les enseignants d’EPS spécialistes en aérobic et des sports
de salle sont invités pour présenter des prestations physiques. Ces dernières sont filmées et montées
par des spécialistes en audio-visuel et diffusées sur les chaines nationales chaque jour à 11h 30mn.
Les étapes entreprises avant la diffusion sont comme suites :
• Désignation des enseignantes et des enseignants spécialistes en aérobic et en sport de salle.
• Préparation de la séance en groupe : sélectionner les exercices physiques adéquats et le
support musical d’accompagnement, prévoir le type d’enchainement.
• Coordination avec les équipes de tournage pour l’enregistrement des séquences vidéos.
Les cours sont enregistrés dans un espace ressemblant à celui où joue l’élève chez lui et ne dépassant
pas 9 m². Les séances sont diffusées, chaque jour de 11 h 30 à midi, sur une chaine de télévision
nationale.
b. Organisation exceptionnelles des compétitions sportives en ligne
Pour permettre aux élèves de vivre des moments de compétition, il a été question de proposer des
activités respectant le protocole de confinement. Ces activités proposées doivent répondent aux
critères suivants :
• La prestation de l’élève devra être réalisée dans un espace de la maison ou sur la terrasse.
• L’élève doit respecter les consignes de présentation (aspect technique, temps de la réalisation,
tenue sportive).
• La prestation, en format vidéo d’une minute au maximum, est postée sur la plate-forme du
ministère de l’éducation nationale.
Une correspondance ministérielle a été envoyée à tous les établissements scolaires et diffusée sur le
site du ministère. Le choix est porté sur quatre activités : le taekwondo (présentation d’un
enchaînement d’un poomsé), le karaté (présentation d’un enchaînement d’un kata), le jeu d’échecs
en ligne, les mouvements créatifs. Tous les élèves sont autorisés à y participer, quel que soit leur âge,
leur sexe y compris les enfants en situation d’handicap. Après inscription sur la plate-forme Massar
du ministère dédié à la compétition, l’élève choisit une activité dans le menu présenté et participe à
la compétition conformément aux règlements stipulés par les organisations. La session de cette année
a vu la participation de 1200 élèves dont 936 filles. Les 3 premiers de chaque catégorie ont reçu des
tablettes.
Les jeunes en taekwondo, des différentes catégories, ont participé au championnat du monde
organisé par l’ISF2 au Népal en août 2020. Le Maroc a eu la deuxième place après la chine.
2
International School Sport Federation
605
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Pendant le déconfinement avec couvre-feu : De l’entrée scolaire jusqu’à aujourd’hui
La rentrée scolaire a été maintenue. Elle a eu lieu le 7 septembre 2021. Les parents sont sollicités à
prendre une décision si leur enfant doit suivre les cours à distance ou en présentiel, suivant la note
ministérielle N°039/20. Chose qui a suscité des réactions à plusieurs niveaux y compris au
parlement. Mais la situation pandémique commence et le nombre des contaminés a augmenté d’une
manière exponentielle, et pour répondre aux attentes des parents qui ont opté pour le présentiel, le
scénario qui a été adopté par le gouvernement est le dispositif d’alternance en divisant la semaine
en deux périodes : une période sera réservée à l’enseignement en présentiel à l’école et une autre
sera réservée à l’enseignement en distanciel à la maison.
Le dispositif mis en place en présentiel catégorise la classe en deux groupes afin de permettre aux
élèves de retourner à leur classe d’une part, et d’autre part de respecter les dispositions de
distanciation imposées pour faire face à la pandémie. Chaque groupe bénéficie de façon alternée
(1 fois par semaine) des deux types d’enseignement au cours de la semaine. Les emplois du temps
des élèves sont organisés pour permettre cette alternance. D’autres procédés pédagogiques sont
mis en présentiel et en ligne pour la construction et renforcement des apprentissages, ainsi que
l’auto-formation et le suivi des réalisations des élèves. L’enseignement en ligne est assuré par les
enseignants via une plate-forme dédiée pour cela et reliée au système d’information scolaire Massar.
Ces mesures sont prises pour garantir l’équité des apprentissages et renforcer l’auto-formation des
élèves. Mais en cas d’apparition des cas contaminés, l’école est automatiquement fermée.
Le dispositif de l’enseignement de l’EPS en présentiel
En EPS, démarrer l’enseignement par l’incertitude et l’aléas est une chose qui a été prise en
considération au début de septembre 2020, des réunions sont programmées en ligne avec les
inspecteurs régionaux ont permis d’aboutir à des propositions et des recommandations. Ces
dernières s’inscrivent dans la même logique de l’enseignement général, la note ministérielle N°
058/20 vise, en effet, les objectifs de l’EPS en tant que matière d’enseignement obligatoire. Les
activités qui devraient être programmées dans le cadre du projet d’EPS se conforment au tableau1.
Les cours d’EPS en présentiel sont assuré en groupe restreint (la moitié de la classe), la note définit
les dispositions à prendre en considération pour éviter toute contamination au Covid-19
notamment aménagement des couloirs de passage, limitation des espaces, stérilisation du matériel
d’EPS, fermeture des vestiaires, lavage des mains, pas d’échange d’objets (bouteilles…). Le masque
n’est pas utilisé pendant l’exercice à condition de respecter la distanciation.
Le dispositif de l’enseignement de l’EPS et du sport scolaire à distance
L’enseignement à distance est programmé en tenant compte de la situation sociale des élèves et
l’environnement où ils apprennent. Ce qui a obligé le département d’éducation nationale de
diversifier les moyens de diffusion et de connexion pour chaque élève aura la possibilité de
poursuivre les cours en télé-enseignement ou sur la plate-forme du ministère.
606
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
Tableau 1
Activités
sportives
physiques
et Autoriser à pratiquer ou non Exemples de types d’activités
possibles à proposer
- La course de vitesse ;
- La course de durée
- Sauts ;
- Exercices et mouvements
Activités
physiques et
d’entretien du corps : Aérobicsportives et d’expression Oui
Danses… ;
sans engin
- Les activités de créativité
motrice
et
d’expression
individuelle ;
-…
- La gymnastique au sol ;
Activités
physiques et
- Les lancers ;
A condition de désinfecter
sportives et d’expression
- La manipulation du ballon ;
le matériel utilisé
avec engin
- La course de haies
-….
Activités
physiques et
sportives et d’expression Non
collective sans engin
Activités
physiques et
sportives et d’expression Non
collective avec engin
L’enregistrement des séquences vidéo et leur diffusion est orienté vers les régions où chaque
Académies Régionale de l’Education et de la Formation produit ses propres ressources numériques
et vidéothèques. Des difficultés sont enregistrées quant à l’utilisation de la technologie par les
élèves mais aussi par les enseignants. Ces derniers, habitués à l’enseignement en présentiel, se sont
trouvés désarmer des compétences pédagogiques de l’enseignement en ligne au niveau de la gestion
de la classe virtuelle, le suivi des productions des élèves, l’équité des apprentissages, …etc.
Le fait que la Covid-19 a continué de faire des dégâts en nombre de morts, et que les mesures de
protection sanitaire se sont renforcés, l’organisation des compétitions sportives a été maintenue
pour couvrir les sports préférés par les jeunes et qui se pratiquent individuellement. Le choix est
porté sur le taekwondo, le karaté, le break dance, le hip hop, le Skate-board et roller, le wushu, le
football freestyle et les échecs via la plateforme en ligne (www.adss.men.gov.ma.). La compétition
est étalée sur trois mois (du 1er février au 25 mai2021) allant de la période d’inscription jusqu’à la
qualification au niveau national. Tous les élèves des 3 cycle de l’enseignement sont concernés. Le
nombre d’élèves inscrits est de l’ordre de 17289 dont 6020 filles.
607
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Image 1 Plate-forme d’accès des élèves et des juges : www.adss.men.gov.ma
Image 2 Statistiques des inscriptions et de participation des élèves (en ligne) au 26 Avril 2021
Les pratiques de l’EPS dans un contexte pandémique
Dans le sport, il y a souvent la notion de l’interaction avec autrui, avec les objets et avec
l’environnement. En fonction des caractéristiques de chaque sport, le contact et le rapprochement
entre les sportifs en jeu ne sont pas tolérés dans ces conditions pandémiques. Le contact avec le
corps ou toute expiration peut entrainer la contamination surtout en sports collectifs tels qu’ils sont
organisés aujourd’hui. Faire jouer les élèves au Basket-ball présentera des risques d’infection les uns
des autres en cas d’atteinte d’un joueur du Covid. Pourtant, les sportifs ne prennent pas en
considération ce danger. On les voit dans les terrains des quartiers jouer des matchs comme si la
608
French Articles
__________________________________________________________________________________
situation était normale. Car, dans le sport, il y a une magie que seul le sportif peut la comprendre.
Les enseignants eux-mêmes sont habitués à créer de l’énergie, de l’activité, de la joie chez les jeunes.
Aujourd’hui, ils sont obligés de prendre en considération d’autres contraintes et des règles qui ne
font pas partie du jeu lui-même.
La question aujourd’hui, si la pandémie continue pour les années à venir : faut-il ignorer la maladie,
faire semblant que les choses sont normales. Autrement dit, c’est programmer des activités
physiques et sportives en présentiel pour les élèves en mettent à l’esprit que ces activités protègent
le corps des maladies et permettent la guérison. Cette attitude est ancrée dans l’esprit de certains
enseignants d’EPS et coachs. De plus, la compétition crée le spectacle et la valeur. Chacun trouve
en elle une satisfaction qu’elle soit morale, physique ou financière. A la question posée, on peut
répondre : la santé des pratiquants est primordiale ; est-il possible de proposer des jeux adaptés ou
transformés au contexte pandémique ? l’entreprise s’avère très difficile et il faut attendre des années
pour pouvoir la réaliser. Aujourd’hui, beaucoup d’initiatives apparaissent ici et là dans le but de
créer l’activité, mais on est loin des formes d’attraction atteintes par le sport. Tout est centré sur la
distanciation entre les joueurs, l’évitement de tout contact et le port du masque qui sont des
contraintes à prendre en considération pour la programmation d’une leçon d’EPS, d’un
entrainement sportif ou de l’organisation d’une compétition sportive. Par conséquent, les jeux
permettant le contact et le non-respect de distanciation sont à éviter. Ainsi, presque tous les jeux
sportifs seront délaissés et par conséquent :
•
•
•
•
•
Les enseignants d’EPS semblent désœuvrés par rapport à d’autres enseignants branchés en
ligne. Certains directeurs prévoient de les charger de missions administratives ;
Le confinement à l’école et le déconfinement hors de l’école : Un paradoxe où la pratique de
sport collectif dans les terrains de proximités des quartiers est permise par exemple, alors
qu’elle n’est autorisée à l’école ;
En cas de d’atteinte d’un cas par la covd-19, c’est toute l’école qui doit fermer ;
Certains enseignants ont refusé d’être vaccinés, chose qui a suscité la réaction des parents.
Ces derniers craignent que leurs enfants soient contaminés.
« Le retour à l’école dans le contexte de la pandémie du COVID-19 introduit un nouvel
ensemble de protocoles et de responsabilités. Assurer la protection des enfants et des
éducateurs est une priorité absolue. Les parents, les enfants et les enseignants doivent
s’assurer que les écoles sont des lieux sûrs et que les précautions nécessaires ont été prises
pour prévenir la propagation potentielle du COVID-19 en milieu scolaire » (UNICEF, 2020).
Le recours à l’enseignement ou à l’animation en ligne est une alternative utilisée, aujourd’hui, en
attendant la disparition complète de la maladie ou son atténuation dans les mois prochains. Covid
19, nous a appris à revoir nos conduites et à transformer la majorité de nos pratiques en des
interactions en ligne. Ce qui nous incite à instaurer d’autres dispositif d’enseignement et de
formation. Ça sera d’autres compétences professionnelles qui devront être maitrisées par les
enseignants.
609
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Conclusion
Les enseignants nourrissent l’espoir que bientôt la maladie disparaitra et les élèves regagneront les
terrains de sport comme auparavant. Aujourd’hui, ils sont inquiets et stressés à cause de l’inactivité
et de l’absence de l’animation et de la dynamique créées dans les séances d’EPS. Un enseignant
questionné à propos de la situation de l’enseignement à l’école, il a répondu : « je me sens dans le
désert ! ». Ils sont situés entre deux paradoxes : des élèves qui réclament la pratique des activités
physiques et sportives d’une part, d’autre part la préservation de la santé de leurs élèves en se
confiant aux dispositions sanitaires institutionnelles. Ils sont ainsi obligés de s’abstenir à l’envie de
leurs élèves. De plus, organiser des activités selon des règles strictes ne les confortent pas soit en
présentiel ou en ligne. Réduction d’un nombre important de sports notamment les sports collectifs,
dénaturation de la pratique de certaines activités physiques et sportives par l’introduction dans les
règles de jeu d’autres consignes. Bien que cette situation est pitoyable, les enseignants ont pris des
initiatives de création des jeux sportifs adaptés au contexte pandémique. Quant aux compétitions
sportives, elles sont organisées en ligne en se focalisant des prestations individuelles avec engin ou
sans engin. Ces prestations filmées sont postées sur la plate-forme du ministère dédiée à ces
compétitions. Ce qui limite les facteurs de risque pandémique chez les élèves et les motivent pour
se confronter à leurs pairs dans d’autres coin du pays. Covid-19 nous appris de se comporter
autrement, d’utiliser d’autres moyens technologiques et de créer l’environnement d’autres activités.
Si la pandémie persiste, de nouvelles activités physiques et sportives naîtront.
Bibliographie
Conseil de Gouvernement, M. (2021). Un an de gestion de la pandémie Covid-19. Rabat:
https://www.cg.gov.ma/ar.
OMS. (2020, 11 10). COVID-19 : ce qu'il faut savoir. Récupéré sur Organisation Modiale de la santé:
https://www.who.int/fr/news-room/q-a-detail/coronavirus-disease-covid-19
OMS. (2021). MISE À JOUR DE LA STRATÉGIE COVID-19. Consulté le 04 24, 2021, sur
https://www.who.int/docs/default-source/coronaviruse/strategy-updatefrench.pdf?sfvrsn=b1cfe48a_2
UNICEF. (2020). Prêt au retour :Dossier de formation à la préparation des enseignants. Amman 11821 Jordanie: UNICEF MENA REGIONAL OFFICE. Consulté le 04 24, 2021, sur
https://www.unicef.org/mena/media/9641/file/UNICEF_MENA_TTP_Francais_V1.pd
f%20.pdf
610
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Attitudes des élèves vis-à-vis du cours d’éducation physique et
sportive, perception des compétences durant la période de
propagation de la Covid-19 au Gabon
Doumbeneny Jean Derlish Désiré - Tsamba Nzedy Rosamour Gassien
Aymar - Boulamba Mounanga Sandra
Faculté des Lettres et des Sciences Humaines (FLSH), Université Omar Bongo, Gabon
e-mail : jeandesiredoumbeneny@yahoo.fr
Résumé
A partir d’une enquête par questionnaire menée auprès des élèves de 5ème et 3ème, faisant des cours
à d’éducation physique et sportive à l’école, nous avons voulu connaître dans un premier temps,
les attitudes des élèves face aux cours d’éducation physique et sportive (EPS) et dans une deuxième
phase, voire la perception qu’ils ont de leur compétence vis-à-vis de l’EPS. Afin de pouvoir mesurer
les attitudes des élèves à l’égard des cours d’éducation physique et sportive et la perception de
compétences, nous avons utilisé le questionnaire de Piéron, Ledent, Luts Pirottin et Delafosse
(1998) avec lequel il a été possible d’évaluer les opinions que les sujets ont des cours d’éducation
physique et sportive dans le contexte scolaire. Cet article propose de mieux comprendre les
attitudes à l’égard des cours d’EPS et la perception des compétences de quelques élèves gabonais
durant la période de la propagation de la Covid-19.
Mots clés: Attitudes, Éducation physique et sportive, Perception, Compétences, Covid-19.
611
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
Introduction
Aujourd’hui beaucoup de pays du monde et même le Gabon, se retrouvent confrontés à une crise
sanitaire liée au coronavirus encore appelé Covid-19. Pour éviter la propagation du virus, des
mesures ont été prises par le gouvernement gabonais. En situation d’urgence, la solution optée par
les établissements secondaire, a été de cessé momentanément les cours pratiques et procéder à
l’évaluation des élèves à l’unité d’enseignement d’éducation physique et sportive de façon théorique.
Après allègement des mesures aboutissant à une reprise des activités pratiques plusieurs questions
peuvent nous intriguer, telle que l’attitude des élèves vis-à-vis du cours d’éducation physique et
sportive. Le comportement de l’élève s’inscrivant dans une perspective dynamique et évolutive, il
se pourrait que la cessation du cours d’EPS du fait de la Covid-19, aurait contribuer à une attitude
négative des élèves à l’égard de ce cours et de même affecter leurs sentiment de compétences en
éducation physique et sportive. L’objectif de cette étude est d’une part, d’apporter un éclairage sur
les attitudes des élèves gabonais vis-à-vis du cours d’éducation physique et sportive en ce temps de
pandémie Covid-19. Et d’autre part, voir quelle perception ils ont de leurs compétences en
éducation physique et sportive en ce temps de pandémie Covid-19. Dans la première partie, il s’agit
de la présentation du problème de l’étude, tandis que la deuxième partie se concentre sur la
démarche méthodologique.
Problématique
Se référant à Faye (2003, p.16) pour les psychologues, le concept d’attitudes désigne la manière d'être
dans une situation. Il est fondamental en psychologie et tout spécialement en psychologie sociale.
C'est semble-t-il un concept flou, car il recouvre diverses significations. Il désigne l'orientation de
la pensée, les dispositions profondes de notre être (souvent inconscientes) qui guident notre
conduite. Le concept d’attitude désigne « une prise de position génératrice d’opinions et d’actions
sur un problème ou dans des circonstances », nous apprend Mucchielli (1979). Une attitude est
toujours orientée vers un objet. Moscovici (1976), souligne que « l’attitude exprime un
positionnement, une orientation par rapport à l’objet. L'attitude est donc porteuse de sens et
d'orientation et, est un état quasi permanent de la préparation à l'action, ne constituant pas un vécu,
mais un mode une disponibilité à sentir, à percevoir et à réagir d'une façon réfléchie et particulière
(Faye, op.cit). En ce sens, tenant compte de ces approches définitionnelles, nous pensons qu’il est
nécessaire d’apporter un éclairage aux attitudes des élèves vis-à-vis du cours d’éducation physique
et sportive durant la période de la propagation de la Covid-19. L’éducation physique et sportive (E.P.S),
se présente selon Vassadia (2005), comme une discipline d'enseignement qui propose, en favorisant
le développement et l'entretien organique et foncier, l'acquisition de connaissances et la
construction de savoirs permettant l'organisation et la gestion de la vie physique à tous les âges,
ainsi que l'accès au domaine de la culture que constituent les pratiques sportives. L'E.P.S, en tant
que discipline scolaire, fonde son enseignement sur des pratiques qui doivent être évaluées dans le
contexte de l'apprentissage. Dans ce cadre, la performance devient l'objet de l'évaluation. Par
ailleurs, Bandura (1977, 1986, 1994, cité par Bouchard, 1997, p.29) fut le premier auteur à
développer le concept de perception de la compétence sous l'appellation «self-efficacy appraisal ».
612
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Bouchard (1997), a mené une étude sur la perception de la compétence des élèves dans le contexte
de certaines activités d'enseignement et d'apprentissage bien précises des cours de sciences
physiques. Pour l’auteur, la perception de la cornp6tence est l'un des déterminants de la motivation.
la piètre perception de leurs compétences scientifiques suscite chez plusieurs jeunes1 des craintes
et du découragement même au secondaire. De plus il s’inscrit d’ailleurs dans l'esprit des travaux de
Maehr (1983), une carence de la perception de la compétence entraîne même de mauvaises
performances voire des échecs. La perception de la compétence exerce une influence significative
sur différentes facettes de l'autorégulation, telles le monitoring durant la période de travail et la
persévérance, autant que sur la performance (Bouffard-Bouchard, Parent et Larivée, 1991, cité par
Bouchard, op.cit, 1997, p.37). Ces auteurs constatent notamment que les élèves dont la
perception de la compétence est élevée exerce un contrôle plus actif sur leur période de
travail et persistent davantage sur la tâche que les élèves dont la perception de compétence
est faible. Les élèves qui sous-estiment leurs compétences sont moins attirés par les défis, ce qui
les expose à une autre diminution de leurs perceptions. À long terme, chez les enfants réellement
compétents, la sous-estimation de la compétence est plus néfaste que la surestimation (Bouchard,
op.cit, 1997, p.36). Se référant à ces résultats, il nous semble intéressant d’une part de connaitre les
attitudes des élèves vis-à-vis des cours d’éducation physique et sportive, pendant la période de
propagation de la covid-19, et d’autre part, de voir la perception que les élèves ont à l’égard du
cours d’éducation physique et sportive. Cette étude s’inscrit dans un domaine en ébullition : celui
de la perception de soi.
Nous nous intéressons à l'un des principaux déterminants de la motivation: la perception de la
compétence. Pour l’heure, au Gabon, aucune étude n’a porté sur les attitudes des élèves vis-à-vis
de l’EPS et la perception des compétences qu’ils peuvent avoir. La décision prise par le
gouvernement afin de limiter la propagation de la Covid-19, notamment celle de cesser les cours
pratique d’EPS au cours de l’année 2020, aurait certainement engendré des attitudes négatives des
élèves vis-à-vis des cours pratiques d’EPS et même avec avoir un effet négatif sur la perception
qu’ils ont de leurs compétences. L’originalité de ce travail réside dans le fait de s’intéresser d’une
part, aux attitudes des élèves à l’égard du cours d’éducation physique et sportive durant la période
de propagation de la Covid-19 au Gabon. Mais également du fait qu’elle cherche à voir la perception
que les élèves ont de leurs compétences vis à vis du cours d’EPS durant le période de propagation
de la covid-19. L'intérêt de cette recherche est qu’elle pourrait contribuer à motiver les élèves à
avoir une bonne attitude à l’égard du cours d’éducation physique et sportive (EPS). Mais de plus,
nous croyons qu'une meilleure compréhension des attitudes des élèves à l’égard du cours
1
En nous référant à l’Unicef (2020), la Covid-19 est :
« Une maladie provoquée par une nouvelle souche de coronavirus. D’abord appelée nouveau coronavirus 2019
ou nCoV-2019, la maladie a été rebaptisée maladie à coronavirus 2019 (COVID-19) – CO pour corona, VI pour
virus et D pour maladie en anglais. Le virus de la COVID-19 est un nouveau virus de la même famille que
d’autres virus tels que le syndrome respiratoire aigu sévère (SRAS) et certains types de rhumes courants ». En
effet, selon l’Unicef, le virus se transmet par contact direct avec les gouttelettes respiratoires produites par une
personne infectée (lorsqu’elle tousse ou éternue) et en touchant des surfaces contaminées par le virus ou en se
touchant le visage (par exemple, les yeux, le nez ou la bouche).
613
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
d’éducation physique et sportive, et de plus, pourrait nous aider à outiller davantage les enseignants
dans leur pratique.
Nous nous sommes posé la question de savoir, quelles sont les attitudes des élèves vis-à-vis du
cours d’éducation physique et sportive durant la pandémie de la Covid-191 ? De plus, quel est la
perception de compétence des élèves vis-à-vis du cours d’EPS?
Méthodologie
Cadre de l’étude et la description de la population d’étude
La présente étude s’est déroulée à Libreville auprès des élèves de 5ème et de 3ème du Collège
Monseigneur Béssieux faisant des cours d’Education Physique et Sportive, durant la période de
propagation de la Covid-19. Notre population cible était constituée exclusivement des élèves en
pleine pratique des cours d’EPS. Notre échantillon était composé de 96 sujets, dont 22 hommes
(38,60%) et 35 femmes (61,40%). Du fait du confinement, pour recueillir les données de cette
étude, nous nous sommes rendu auprès du directeur du collège, pour l’obtention d’une autorisation
nous permettant d’administrer un questionnaire aux élèves. Nous avons travaillé avec un
échantillon tout venant, en fonction de la disponibilité des sujets.
Questionnaire
Pour notre recherche nous n’avons pas eu besoin de construire d’instruments, nous avons tout
simplement adapté les outils existant dans la littérature relative à notre étude. L’instrument de
mesure privilégié dans le cadre de cette étude est le questionnaire d’enquête, composé de deux
échelles. Une mesurant les attitudes des élèves vis-à-vis du cours d’EPS et l’autre, la perception des compétences,
nous avons adapté à notre contexte le questionnaire de Piéron, Ledent, Luts Pirottin et Delafosse
(1998).
Traitement des données
Le dépouillement s’est fait en regroupant les réponses identiques par la méthode du pendu. Ainsi,
en se référant à l’étude de Faye (2003), les réponses sont d'abord groupées en fonction de l'âge et
du sexe, ensuite calculées en pourcentages par rapport aux totaux enregistrés au niveau de chaque
âge et par sexe.
Présentation des résultats et commentaires
Nous avons posé la question aux élèves du collège Monseigneur Béssieux afin de connaitre leur
sentiment à l’égard du cours d’éducation physique durant la période où sévie la pandémie de la
Covid-19 au Gabon. Il ressort du tableau 1, que la grande partie des élèves aiment (beaucoup ou
bien) leurs cours d’éducation physique et sportive. En effet, de 10 ans à 19 ans le constat est le
614
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
même, les élèves ont une attitude positive des cours d’éducation physique et sportive. La seule élève
de 10 ans de notre échantillon aime l’éducation physique et sportive, soit un pourcentage de 100%.
Tableau 1 Attitudes à l’égard des cours d’Education Physique : sentiment des élèves
au cours d’Education Physique (en pourcentage)
Age moyen
Effectif
10ans
11ans
G
0
2
F
1
7
12 ans
5
9
13 ans
14ans
6
8
6
19
15 ans
16 ans
17 ans
19 ans
2
6
3
1
10
10
1
0
J’aime
(beaucoup ou
bien)
G
F
0
100%
50%
42,85
%
50%
38,75
%
50%
50%
50%
44,73
%
50%
45%
50%
35%
50%
50%
100% 0
Je n’aime pas
(beaucoup
ou du tout)
G F
0 0
0 7,14%
0
11, 25%
0
0
0
5,26%
0
0
0
0
5%
15%
0
0
La majeure partie des sujets de 11 ans disent aimer leur cours d’éducation physique et sportive, soit
92,85% pour 50% de garçons et 42,85% de filles, tandis que seulement 7,14% des sujets de cet âge
disent ne pas aimer leur cours d’éducation physique et sportive. De même les élèves de 12 ans
également disent aimer les cours d’éducation physique et sportive, soit 98,75% pour 50% de garçons
et 38,75% de filles, tandis que 11,25% n'aiment pas leur cours. Le constat est le même pour les
élèves de 13 ans, ils aiment le cours d’EPS, soit 50% de garçons et 50% de filles. Les élèves de 14
ans aiment le cours d’EPS, soit 50% de garçons et 44,73% de filles, alors que seulement 5,26% des
sujets de cet âge disent ne pas aimer le cours d’EPS. Les élèves de 15 ans aiment leur cours d’EPS,
soit 50% de garçons et 45% de filles, contre seulement 5% qui disent ne pas aimer. Les élèves de 16
ans aiment leur cours d’EPS, soit 50% de garçons et 35% de filles, contre 15% qui disent ne pas aimer.
Les élèves de 17 ans aiment leur cours d’EPS, soit 50% de garçons et 50% de filles). Le seul élève
de 18 ans de notre échantillon aime le cours d’EPS, soit un pourcentage de 100%.
Par la suite, il a été question de connaitre le niveau d’importance du cours d’éducation physique et
sportive pour les élèves du collège Monseigneur Béssieux durant la période où sévie la pandémie
de la Covid-19 au Gabon. A travers le tableau 2, nous constatons que la grande partie des élèves
considèrent que le cours d’éducation physique et sportive est très important ou simplement
important. En effet, de 10 ans à 19 ans, l’observation est la même, les élèves considèrent leurs
615
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
cours d’éducation physique et sportive comme étant important ou très important. La seule élève
de 10 ans de notre échantillon accorde de l’importance en éducation physique et sportive, soit un
pourcentage de 100%.
Tableau 2 Attitudes à l’égard des cours d’éducation physique : importance accordée
à l’éducation physique (en pourcentage)
Age moyen
Effectif
10 ans
11ans
G
0
2
F
1
7
12 ans
5
9
13 ans
6
6
14ans
8
19
15 ans
16 ans
17 ans
19 ans
2
6
3
1
10
10
1
0
Très important Peu important
ou important
ou
pas
important du
tout
G
F
G
F
0
50%
0
0
50%
35,71
0
14,29
%
%
50%
44,44
0
5,56%
%
41,66
41,66
8,33% 8,33%
%
%
50%
42,10
0
7,89%
%
50%
40%
0
10%
50%
40%
0
10%
50%
50%
0
0
0
0
0
0
La majeure partie des sujets de 11 ans disent accorder de l’importance à leur cours d’éducation
physique et sportive, soit 85,71% pour 50% de garçons et 35,71% de filles, tandis que seulement
14,29% des sujets de cet âge disent ne pas aimer leur cours d’éducation physique et sportive. Les
élèves qui disent accorder beaucoup plus de l’importance à leurs cours d’éducation physique et
sportive sont ceux de 12 ans, soit 94,44% pour 50% de garçons et 44,44% de filles, tandis que
5,56% n'accordent aucune importance à ce cours. De même, Les élèves de 13 ans, accordent de
l’importance à leur cours d’EPS, soit 83,32% pour 41,66% de garçons et 41,66% de filles. Les élèves
de 14 ans accordent de l’importance à leurs cours d’EPS, soit 92,10% pour 50% de garçons et
42,10% de filles, alors que seulement 7,89% des sujets de cet âge disent ne pas accorder d’importance
au cours d’EPS. Les élèves de 15 ans accordent de l’importance à leur cours d’EPS, soit 90% pour 50%
de garçons et 40% de filles, contre seulement 10% qui disent ne pas accorder d’importance. Les élèves
de 16 ans accordent de l’importance à leur cours d’EPS, soit 90% pour 50% de garçons et 40% de
filles, contre 10% qui disent ne pas accorder d’importance. Les élèves de 17 ans également disent
accorder une certaine importance à leur cours d’EPS, soit 100% des sujets, pour 50% de garçons
616
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
et 50% de filles. Le seul élève de 18 ans de notre échantillon accorde de l’importance au cours
d’EPS, soit un pourcentage de 100%.
De plus, il a été question de connaitre l’utilité que les élèves du collège Monseigneur Béssieux
accordent à leur cours d’éducation physique en fonction de l’âge et le sexe durant la période où
sévie la Covid-19 au Gabon.
Tableau 3 Attitudes à l’égard des cours d’éducation physique : utilité de l’éducation physique
en fonction de l’âge et le sexe (en pourcentage)
Age moyen
Effectif
10 ans
G
0
F
1
11ans
12 ans
13 ans
2
5
6
7
9
6
A
se
développer
physiquement
, à être en
bonne santé
G
F
0
100
%
25%
50%
50%
50%
25%
50%
14ans
8
19
50%
15 ans
16 ans
17 ans
19 ans
2
6
3
1
10
10
1
0
25%
50%
50%
100%
39,4
7%
50%
50%
50%
0
A
A apprendre
s’amuser, à des
se détendre techniques
sportives
A apprendre
à
jouer
ensemble, à
se faire des
copains
G
F
0
0
G
0
F
0
G
0
F
0
0
0
16,
66
%
0
%
0
0
25%
0
8,33
%
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
5,26
%
%
%
0
0
0
2,63
%
0
%
0
0
0
2,63
%
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
25%
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
A travers le tableau 3, nous constatons que la grande partie des élèves considèrent que le cours
d’éducation physique et sportive sert beaucoup plus à se développer physiquement, à se muscler, à
être en bonne santé et à améliorer la condition physique. En effet, au vu des réponses, on pourrait
dire que les élèves aiment le cours d’éducation physique et sportive et y accordent de l’importance
parce qu’ils considèrent que leurs cours d’éducation physique et sportive contribue à se développer
physiquement, à se muscler, contribue à la bonne santé et contribue à améliorer la condition
physique. La seule élève de 10 ans dit aimer et accorder de l’importance au cours d’éducation
physique et sportive, parce qu’il contribue à se développer physiquement, à se muscler, à être en
bonne santé et à améliorer la condition physique, soit un pourcentage de 100%. De plus, 75% des
sujets de 11 ans disent accorder aimer et accorder de l’importance à leur cours d’éducation physique et
sportive, parce qu’il contribue à se développer physiquement, à se muscler, à être en bonne santé
et à améliorer la condition physique, tandis que seulement 25% des sujets de cet âge disent aimer
617
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
et accorder de l’importance à l’EPS parce qu’ils apprennent des techniques sportives et apprennent
à faire certains exercice convenablement. En ce qui concerne les élèves de 12 ans, 100% des élèves
disent aimer et accorder de l’importance à leur cours d’éducation physique et sportive, parce qu’il
contribue à se développer physiquement, à se muscler, à être en bonne santé et à améliorer la
condition physique, soit 50% de garçons et 50% de filles. Les élèves de 13 ans, disent accorder
aimer et accorder de l’importance à leur cours d’éducation physique et sportive, parce qu’il contribue à
se développer physiquement, à se muscler, à être en bonne santé et à améliorer la condition
physique, soit 75% pour 25% de garçons et 50% de filles, alors que seulement 8,33% de cet âge
disent aimer et accorder de l’importance à l’EPS parce qu’ils apprennent des techniques sportives
et apprennent à faire certains exercice convenablement. . Les élèves de 14 ans disent accorder aimer
et accorder de l’importance à leur cours d’éducation physique et sportive, parce qu’il contribue à se
développer physiquement, à se muscler, à être en bonne santé et à améliorer la condition physique,
soit 89,47%, pour 50% de garçons et 39,47% de filles, alors que 5,26% des sujets de cet âge disent
aimer et accorder d’importance au cours d’EPS parce qu’il sert pour s’amuser, à se détendre, d’autres
élèves de 14 ans, soit 2,63% de filles, aiment et accordent de l’importance parce qu’ils apprennent
des techniques sportives, apprennent à faire certains exercice convenablement et pour finir certains
élèves de 14 ans soit 2,63% de filles, aiment et accordent de l’importance à l’EPS, parce qu’ils
apprennent à jouer ensemble, à se faire des copains.
La grande partie des élèves de 15 ans disent aimer et accorder d’importance au cours d’EPS parce qu’il
sert à se développer physiquement, à se muscler, à être en bonne santé et à améliorer la condition
physique, soit 75% pour 25% de garçons et 50% de filles, contre seulement 25% qui disent aimer
et accorder de l’importance au cours d’EPS parce qu’ils apprennent des techniques sportives et
apprennent à faire certains exercice convenablement. Les élèves de 16 ans disent aimer et accorder
d’importance au cours d’EPS parce qu’il sert à se développer physiquement, à se muscler, à être en
bonne santé et à améliorer la condition physique, soit 100% pour 50% de garçons et 50% de filles.
Les élèves de 17 ans également disent aimer et accorder d’importance au cours d’EPS parce qu’il sert
à se développer physiquement, à se muscler, à être en bonne santé et à améliorer la condition
physique, soit 100% pour 50% de garçons et 50% de filles. Le seul élève de 18 ans de notre
échantillon dit aimer et accorder de l’importance au cours d’EPS, parce qu’il contribue à se
développer physiquement, à se muscler, contribue à la bonne santé et à améliorer la condition
physique soit un pourcentage de 100%.
Nous avons interrogé les élèves sur la perception qu’ils ont de leur compétence de manière générale
à l’égard de l’EPS, il ressort du tableau 4, que la grande partie des élèves se disent moyen ou faible
en éducation physique et sportive. La seule élève de 10 ans de notre échantillon se dit moyenne ou
faible en éducation physique et sportive, soit un pourcentage de 100%. Les élèves de 11 ans disent
être également moyen ou faible en éducation physique et sportive, soit 53,57% pour 25% de
garçons et 28,57% de filles, tandis que seulement 46,43% des sujets de cet âge disent être moyen
ou faible en éducation physique et sportive. Par contre, les élèves de 12 ans pour la majorité disent
être fort ou très fort en éducation physique et sportive, soit 74,44% pour 30% de garçons et 44,44%
de filles, tandis que 25,55%, disent être moyen ou faible, pour 20% de garçons et 5,55% de filles.
618
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
Les élèves de 13 ans, quant à eux disent être moyen ou faible en éducation physique et sportive,
soit 66,67% des sujets, pour 25% de garçons et 41,67% de filles, alors que 33,33% se disent fort
ou très fort en éducation physique et sportive, avec 25% de garçons et 8,33% de filles. Les élèves
de 14 ans disent être moyen ou faible en éducation physique et sportive, soit 67,11% des sujets,
pour 25% de garçons et 42,11% de filles, alors que seulement 32,89% des sujets de cet âge disent
être fort ou très fort en EPS, soit 25% de garçons et 7,89% de filles.
Tableau 4 Perception de compétences d’une manière générale
en éducation physique et sportive (en pourcentage)
Age moyen
Effectif
10 ans
G
0
F
1
Je suis très fort
(e)
Ou très fort (e)
G
F
0
0
11ans
2
7
25%
28,57
12 ans
5
9
30%
13 ans
6
6
44,44
%
8,33%
14ans
8
19
25%
7,89%
15 ans
16 ans
17 ans
19 ans
2
6
3
1
10
10
1
0
50%
25%
50%
100%
20%
20%
0
0
25%
Je
suis
moyen (ne)
ou faible
G
F
0
100
%
25% 21,4
3%
20% 5,55
%
25% 41,6
7%
25% 42,1
1%
0
30%
25% 30%
0
50%
0
0
Les élèves de 15 ans disent sont eux plutôt fort en éducation physique et sportive, soit 70% des
sujets, pour 50% de garçons et 20% de filles, contre seulement 30% de filles qui disent être moyennes
ou faibles. Les élèves de 16 ans pour la majorité se disent moyen ou faible en EPS, soit 55% des
sujets, pour 25% de garçons et 30% de filles, alors que 45% se disent être fort, avec 25% de garçons
et 20% de filles. Les élèves de 17 ans sont pour la moitié fort ou très fort en EPS, soit 50% des
sujets uniquement constitué de garçons, et 50% des sujets uniquement constitué de filles, sont
moyens ou faibles en d’EPS. Le seul élève de 18 ans de notre échantillon se dit fort en EPS, soit
un pourcentage de 100%.
Dans le même ordre d’idée au niveau de la perception des compétences, nous avons interrogé les
élèves sur l’activité proposée par le professeur le jour de la distribution de notre questionnaire. Il
619
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
ressort du tableau 5, que la seule élève de 10 ans de notre échantillon se dit moyenne ou faible en
éducation physique et sportive, soit un pourcentage de 100%. Les élèves de 11 ans, se disent pour
la majorité être également moyen ou faible en éducation physique et sportive, soit 53,57% pour
25% de garçons et 28,57% de filles, tandis que seulement 46,42% des sujets de cet âge se disent
fort ou très fort en EPS. Cependant, les élèves de 12 ans pour la majorité disent être fort ou très
fort en éducation physique et sportive, soit 57,77% pour 30% de garçons et 27,77% de filles, tandis
que 42,23%, disent être moyen ou faible, pour 20% de garçons et 22,23% de filles.
Tableau 5 Perception de compétences dans l’activité proposée par le professeur (en pourcentage)
Age moyen
Effectif
Je suis fort ou Je suis moyen
très fort (e)
(e) ou faible
10 ans
11ans
G
0
2
F
1
7
G
0
25%
12 ans
5
9
30%
13 ans
14ans
6
8
6
19
25%
37,5%
15 ans
16 ans
2
6
10
10
17 ans
19 ans
3
1
1
0
50%
33,33
%
50%
100%
F
0
21,42
%
27,77
%
25%
13,15
%
15%
20%
0
0
G
0
25%
20%
25%
12,5
%
0
16,6
6%
0
0
F
100%
28,57
%
22,23
%
25%
36,85
%
35%
30,11
%
50%
0
Les élèves de 13 ans, quant à eux disent pour la moitié être fort ou très fort en EPS, soit 50% des
sujets, pour 25% de garçons et 25% de filles, alors que 50% se disent moyen ou faible en EPS, avec
25% de garçons et 25% de filles. Les élèves de 14 ans disent être fort ou très fort en éducation
physique et sportive, soit 50,65% des sujets, pour 37,5% de garçons et 13,15% de filles, alors que
49,35% des sujets de cet âge disent être moyen ou faible en EPS, soit 12,5% de garçons et 36,85%
de filles. Les élèves de 15 ans disent sont eux plutôt fort ou très fort en EPS, soit 65% des sujets,
pour 50% de garçons et 15% de filles, contre seulement 35% de filles qui disent être moyennes ou
faibles. Les élèves de 16 ans pour la majorité se disent fort ou très fort en EPS, soit 53,33% des
sujets, pour 33,33% de garçons et 20% de filles, alors que 46,77% se disent être moyen ou faible,
avec 16,66% de garçons et 30,11% de filles. Les élèves de 17 ans sont pour la moitié fort ou très
fort en EPS, soit 50% des sujets uniquement constitué de garçons, et 50% des sujets uniquement
620
Situation
__________________________________________________________________________________
constitué de filles, sont moyens ou faibles en d’EPS. Le seul élève de 18 ans de notre échantillon
se dit fort en EPS, soit un pourcentage de 100%.
Nous avons demandé aux sujets de se comparé aux autres filles et aux autres garçons de leur âge.
Il ressort du tableau 6, que la majeure partie des élèves soumis à notre étude présente de bonnes
qualités physiques, soit 96,96% de garçons et 79,36% de filles. De plus, la majorité dit être gracieux
et élégant lors au cours d’EPS, soit 63,63% de garçons et 68,25% de filles. En outre, la grande partie
des sujets se dit être en forme soit 90,90% des garçons et 60,31% de filles. Au par delà de cela, le
plus grand nombre se dit fort(e), soit 93,93% de garçons et 60,31% de filles.
Tableau 6 Perception des compétences selon le sexe (en pourcentage)
Propositions
Garçons
Effectifs
Filles
G
qualités 33
F
63
Oui
96,96%
Non
3,03%
Oui
79,36%
Non
20,63%
33
33
33
33
33
33
63
63
63
63
63
63
63,63%
51,51%
90,90%
81,81%
93,93%
90,90%
36,36%
48,48%
9,09%
18,18%
6,06%
9,09%
68,25%
47,61%
60,31%
36,50%
60,31%
79,36%
31,74%
52,38%
39,68%
63,43%
29,68%
20,63%
J’ai de bonnes
physiques
Je suis gracieux (se) élégant (e)
Je suis souple
Je suis en forme
Je suis rapide
Je suis fort(e)
Je suis courageux (se)
En plus de cela, la plupart se dit courageux (se), soit 90,90% de garçons et 79,36% de filles.
Cependant, quand la grande partie des garçons se dit souple, soit 51,51%, la majorité des filles dit
ne pas l’être, soit 52,38%. Dans le même ordre d’idées quand la grande partie des garçons se dit
rapide, soit 81,81%, la majorité des filles dit ne pas l’être, soit 63,43%. D'une façon brève, la
majorité des pourcentages de réponses oui des garçons sont supérieurs à ceux des filles.
Conclusion
A l’issus de notre étude portant sur les attitudes des élèves vis-à-vis du cours d’éducation physique
et sportive et la perception de compétences durant la période de propagation de la covid-19, nous
sommes parvenue, d’abord au constat selon lequel les élèves de 5ème et de 3ème du collège
Monseigneur Béssieux ont une attitude favorable à l'égard du cours d'EPS. De plus, les élèves se
surestiment au niveau de leur compétences, mais beaucoup plus les garçons qui se disent être plus
compétents et avoir plus de bonnes qualités physiques contrairement aux filles. Les résultats ont
permis d’observer que la grande partie de ces élèves se disent plutôt fort en EPS. Cependant nous
sommes conscient des limites de cette recherche, d’abord, celle liée au nombre de sujets, nous
621
Physical Education and Physical Activities of Children, Youth and Adults and Healthy Active Living
__________________________________________________________________________________
aurons pu avoir un échantillon plus représentatif, ensuite, la limite liée au fait que nous n’avons pas
croisé les variables relatives à notre étude, en s’inscrivant dans une démarche descriptive.
Références
Bouchard, J. (1997). Étude de la perception de la compétence d'élèves du secondaire à l'égard d'activités des cours
de sciences physiques 416. Mémoire présenté à la Faculté d'éducation en vue de l'obtention du
grade de Maître en arts (M.A.), Université de Sherbrooke.
Faye, M. M. (2003). Attitudes, perceptions de compétences et du comportement des élèves sénégalais à l’égard des
cours d’éducation physique et sportive et du sport en club ou en dehors de l’école : cas du département de
Mbour. Mémoire de maitrise en sciences et techniques de l’activité physique et du sport,
Université Cheikh Anta Diop de Dakar.
Moscovici, S. (1976). La psychanalyse, son image et son public. 2e éd. Paris : PUF.
Mucchieli, R. (1979). Le questionnaire dans l’enquête psychosociale. Connaissance du problème et applications
pratiques. 6e éd. Paris : Les Éditions ESF.
Vassadia, D. (2005). L'attitude des élèves face à l’évaluation des apprentissages en EPS. Mémoire
en vue de l’obtention du certificat à l’inspectorat de la jeunesse et des sports.
Piéron, M., Ledent, M., Luts Pirottin, V. & Delafosse, C. (1998). Analyse de la prise en
considération des caractéristiques individuelles des élèves dans les décisions et
comportements d’enseignement expert de débutant, enseignement primaire et secondaire.
Rapport final soumis au comité d’accompagnement, Université de Liège.
Unicef, 2020, « Messages clés et actions pour la prévention et le contrôle de la COVID-19 dans les
écoles ». Disponible sur :
https://www.unicef.org/media/65846/file/Key%20Messages%20and%20Actions%20for
%20COVID-19%20Prevention%20and%20Control%20in%20Schools_French.pdf.
(Consulté le 20 janvier, 2020).
622